A variant of lambda repressor with an altered pattern of cooperative binding to DNA sites

Lambda CI Binding to Related Phage Operator Sequences Validates Alignment Algorithm and Highlights the Importance of Overlooked Bonds

Bacteriophage λ's CI repressor protein controls a genetic switch between the virus's lysogenic and lytic lifecycles, in part, by selectively binding to six different DNA sequences within the phage genome-collectively referred to as operator sites. However, the minimal level of information needed for CI to recognize and specifically bind these six unique-but-related sequences is unclear. In a previous study, we introduced an algorithm that extracts the minimal direct readout information needed for λ-CI to recognize and bind its six binding sites. We further revealed direct readout information shared among three evolutionarily related lambdoid phages: λ-phage, Enterobacteria phage VT2-Sakai, and Stx2 converting phage I, suggesting that the λ-CI protein could bind to the operator sites of these other phages. In this study, we show that λ-CI can indeed bind the other two phages' cognate binding sites as predicted using our algorithm, validating the hypotheses from that paper. We go on to demonstrate the importance of specific hydrogen bond donors and acceptors that are maintained despite changes to the nucleobase itself, and another that has an important role in recognition and binding. This in vitro validation of our algorithm supports its use as a tool to predict alternative binding sites for DNA-binding proteins.

Flexible linker modulates the binding affinity of the TP901-1 CI phage repressor to DNA

Temperate bacteriophages can switch between two life cycles following infection of a host bacterium: the lytic or lysogenic life cycle. The choice between these is controlled by a bistable genetic switch. We investigated the genetic switch of the lactococcal temperate bacteriophage, TP901-1, which is controlled by two regulatory proteins, the Clear 1 (CI) repressor and modulator of repression (MOR) antirepressor. CI consists of a DNA-binding N-terminal domain and a C-terminal domain responsible for oligomerization, connected by a flexible interdomain linker. Full-length CI is hexameric, whereas the truncated version CI with 58 C-terminal residues truncated (CIΔ58), missing the second C-terminal subdomain, is dimeric, but binds with the same affinity as full-length CI to the O_L operator site, responsible for lytic genes transcription repression. Three variants of CIΔ58 with shorter, longer, and PP substituted linkers were produced and confirmed by circular dichroism spectroscopy and nanodifferential scanning fluorimetry to be well folded. With small-angle X-ray scattering, we delineated the conformational space sampled by the variants and wild-type in solution and found that shortening and lengthening the linker decrease and increase this, respectively, as also substantiated by molecular dynamics and as intended. Isoelectric focusing electrophoresis confirmed that all variants are able to bind to the MOR antirepressor. However, using electrophoretic mobility shift assays, we showed that shortening and lengthening the linker lead to a 94 and 17 times decrease in affinity to O_L , respectively. Thus, an appropriate linker length appears to be crucial for appropriate DNA-binding and subsequent TP901-1 genetic switch function.

Structural and dynamics studies of a truncated variant of CI repressor from bacteriophage TP901-1

The CI repressor from the temperate bacteriophage TP901-1 consists of two folded domains, an N-terminal helix-turn-helix DNA-binding domain (NTD) and a C-terminal oligomerization domain (CTD), which we here suggest to be further divided into CTD1 and CTD2. Full-length CI is a hexameric protein, whereas a truncated version, CI∆58, forms dimers. We identify the dimerization region of CI∆58 as CTD1 and determine its secondary structure to be helical both within the context of CI∆58 and in isolation. To our knowledge this is the first time that a helical dimerization domain has been found in a phage repressor. We also precisely determine the length of the flexible linker connecting the NTD to the CTD. Using electrophoretic mobility shift assays and native mass spectrometry, we show that CI∆58 interacts with the OL operator site as one dimer bound to both half-sites, and with much higher affinity than the isolated NTD domain thus demonstrating cooperativity between the two DNA binding domains. Finally, using small angle X-ray scattering data and state-of-the-art ensemble selection techniques, we delineate the conformational space sampled by CI∆58 in solution, and we discuss the possible role that the dynamics play in CI-repressor function.

Refactoring the λ phage lytic/lysogenic decision with a synthetic regulator

In this work, we explore the refactoring of the circuitry of λ phage by engineering a new-to-nature regulator that responds to an ad hoc input signal that behaves orthogonal with respect to the host cell. We tailored a chimeric regulator, termed Qλ, between the CI protein of the λ phage and the BzdR repressor from Azoarcus sp. strain CIB that responds to benzoyl-CoA. When the Qλ was expressed in the appropriate Escherichia coli cells, it was able to reprogram the lytic/lysogenic λ phage decision according to the intracellular production of benzoyl-CoA. Our results are also an example of how generating new artificial regulators that respond to effectors of choice may be useful to control different cellular processes.

Enhancer-like long-range transcriptional activation by λ CI-mediated DNA looping

How distant enhancer elements regulate the assembly of a transcription complex at a promoter remains poorly understood. Here, we use long-range gene regulation by the bacteriophage λ CI protein as a powerful system to examine this process in vivo. A 2.3-kb DNA loop, formed by CI bridging its binding sites at OR and OL, is known already to enhance repression at the lysogenic promoter PRM, located at OR. Here, we show that CI looping also activates PRM by allowing the C-terminal domain of the α subunit of the RNA polymerase bound at PRM to contact a DNA site adjacent to the distal CI sites at OL. Our results establish OL as a multifaceted enhancer element, able to activate transcription from long distances independently of orientation and position. We develop a physicochemical model of our in vivo data and use it to show that the observed activation is consistent with a simple recruitment mechanism, where the α-C-terminal domain to DNA contact need only provide ∼2.7 kcal/mol of additional binding energy for RNA polymerase. Structural modeling of this complete enhancer-promoter complex reveals how the contact is achieved and regulated, and suggests that distal enhancer elements, once appropriately positioned at the promoter, can function in essentially the same way as proximal promoter elements.

Mechanism of origin activation by monomers of R6K-encoded pi protein

One recurring theme in plasmid duplication is the recognition of the origin of replication (ori) by specific Rep proteins that bind to DNA sequences called iterons. For plasmid R6K, this process involves a complex interplay between monomers and dimers of the Rep protein, pi, with seven tandem iterons of gamma ori. Remarkably, both pi monomers and pi dimers can bind to iterons, a new paradigm in replication control. Dimers, the predominant form in the cell, inhibit replication, while monomers facilitate open complex formation and activate the ori. Here, we investigate a mechanism by which pi monomers out-compete pi dimers for iteron binding, and in so doing activate the ori. With an in vivo plasmid incompatibility assay, we find that pi monomers bind cooperatively to two adjacent iterons. Cooperative binding is eliminated by insertion of a half-helical turn between two iterons but is diminished only slightly by insertion of a full helical turn between two iterons. These studies show also that pi bound to a consensus site promotes occupancy of an adjacent mutated site, another hallmark of cooperative interactions. pi monomer/iteron interactions were quantified using a monomer-biased pi variant in vitro with the same collection of two-iteron constructs. The cooperativity coefficients mirror the plasmid incompatibility results for each construct tested. pi dimer/iteron interactions were quantified with a dimer-biased mutant in vitro and it was found that pi dimers bind with negligible cooperativity to two tandem iterons.

Bicoid cooperative DNA binding is critical for embryonic patterning in Drosophila

Cooperative interactions by DNA-binding proteins have been implicated in cell-fate decisions in a variety of organisms. To date, however, there are few examples in which the importance of such interactions has been explicitly tested in vivo. Here, we tested the importance of cooperative DNA binding by the Bicoid protein in establishing a pattern along the anterior-posterior axis of the early Drosophila embryo. We found that bicoid mutants specifically defective in cooperative DNA binding fail to direct proper development of the head and thorax, leading to embryonic lethality. The mutants did not faithfully stimulate transcription of downstream target genes such as hunchback (hb), giant, and Krüppel. Quantitative analysis of gene expression in vivo indicated that bcd cooperativity mutants were unable to accurately direct the extent to which hb is expressed along the anterior-posterior axis and displayed a reduced ability to generate sharp on/off transitions for hb gene expression. These failures in precise transcriptional control demonstrate the importance of cooperative DNA binding for embryonic patterning in vivo.

DNA recognition sites activate MuA transposase to perform transposition of non-Mu DNA

Mu transposition occurs within a large protein-DNA complex called a transpososome. This stable complex includes four subunits of MuA transposase, each contacting a 22-base pair recognition site located near an end of the transposon DNA. These MuA recognition sites are critical for assembling the transpososome. Here we report that when concentrations of Mu DNA are limited, the MuA recognition sites permit assembly of transpososomes in which non-Mu DNA substitutes for some of the Mu sequences. These "hybrid" transpososomes are stable to competitor DNA, actively transpose the non-Mu DNA, and produce transposition products that had been previously observed but not explained. The strongest activator of non-Mu transposition is a DNA fragment containing two MuA recognition sites and no cleavage site, but a shorter fragment with just one recognition site is sufficient. Based on our results, we propose that MuA recognition sites drive assembly of functional transpososomes in two complementary ways. Multiple recognition sites help physically position MuA subunits in the transpososome plus each individual site allosterically activates transposase.

The operator-early promoter regions of Shiga-toxin bearing phage H-19B

Genes (stx) encoding Shiga toxins (Stx), major virulence factors in some pathogenic strains of Escherichia coli (STEC), are located in prophages of the lambda family. Agents that induce prophages lead to high levels of Stx, suggesting a role for the prophage in stx expression. Activation of the phage regulatory cascade has been shown to contribute to Stx production and release. Therefore, repressor-operator interactions that maintain prophage repression appear important in regulating expression of a major bacterial virulence factor. To determine if the operators of an stx-bearing phage have distinctive features, we characterized the operator regions of H-19B, a lambdoid phage carrying stx1 genes. H-19B mutants that grow in the presence of repressor (classically called virulent mutants) were selected and the mutations definitively identified the operators. The H-19B operators, as those in other lambdoid phages, comprise variations of an inverted repeat. Four repeats were identified in O(R) rather than the three found in each of the operators of other lambdoid phages. Primer extensions identified the transcription start sites of P(R) and P(RM), the two promoters in O(R) regulated by repressor.

Regulated endocytic routing modulates wingless signaling in Drosophila embryos

Embryos have evolved various strategies to confine the action of secreted signals. Using an HRP-Wingless fusion protein to track the fate of endocytosed Wingless, we show that degradation by targeting to lysosomes is one such strategy. Wingless protein is specifically degraded at the posterior of each stripe of wingless transcription, even under conditions of overexpression. If lysosomal degradation is compromised genetically or chemically, excess Wingless accumulates and ectopic signaling ensues. In the wild-type, Wingless degradation is slower at the anterior than at the posterior. This follows in part from the segmental activation of signaling by the epidermal growth factor receptor, which accelerates Wingless degradation at the posterior, thus leading to asymmetrical Wingless signaling along the anterior-posterior axis.

Isolation of mutations that disrupt cooperative DNA binding by the Drosophila bicoid protein

Cooperative DNA binding is thought to contribute to the ability of the Drosophila melanogaster protein, Bicoid, to stimulate transcription of target genes in precise sub-domains within the embryo. As a first step toward testing this idea, we devised a genetic screen to isolate mutations in Bicoid that specifically disrupt cooperative interactions, but do not disrupt DNA recognition or transcription activation. The screen was carried out in Saccharomyces cerevisiae and 12 cooperativity mutants were identified. The mutations map across most of the Bicoid protein, with some located within the DNA-binding domain (homeodomain). Four homeodomain mutants were characterized in yeast and shown to activate a single-site reporter gene to levels comparable to that of wild-type, indicating that DNA binding per se is not affected. However, these mutants failed to show cooperative coupling between high and low-affinity sites, and showed reduced activation of a reporter gene carrying a natural Drosophila enhancer. Homology modeling indicated that none of the four mutations is in residues that contact DNA. Instead, these residues are likely to interact with other DNA-bound Bicoid monomers or other parts of the Bicoid protein. In vitro, the isolated homeodomains did not show strong cooperativity defects, supporting the idea that other regions of Bicoid are also important for cooperativity. This study describes the first systematic screen to identify cooperativity mutations in a eukaryotic DNA-binding protein.

Hex is a transcriptional repressor that contributes to anterior identity and suppresses Spemann organiser function

One of the earliest markers of anterior asymmetry in vertebrate embryos is the transcription factor Hex. We find that Hex is a transcriptional repressor that can be converted to an activator by fusing full length Hex to two copies of the minimal transcriptional activation domain of VP16 together with the flexible hinge region of the (lambda) repressor (Hex-(lambda)VP2). Retention of the entire Hex open reading frame allows one to examine Hex function without disrupting potential protein-protein interactions. Expression of Hex-(lambda)VP2 in Xenopus inhibits expression of the anterior marker Cerberus and results in anterior truncations. Such embryos have multiple notochords and disorganised muscle tissue. These effects can occur in a cell non-autonomous manner, suggesting that one role of wild-type Hex is to specify anterior structures by suppressing signals that promote dorsal mesoderm formation. In support of this idea, over-expression of wild-type Hex causes cell non-autonomous dorso-anteriorization, as well as cell autonomous suppression of dorsal mesoderm. Suppression of dorsal mesoderm by Hex is accompanied by the down-regulation of Goosecoid and Chordin, while induction of dorsal mesoderm by Hex-(lambda)VP2 results in activation of these genes. Transient transfection experiments in ES cells suggest that Goosecoid is a direct target of Hex. Together, our results support a model in which Hex suppresses organiser activity and defines anterior identity.

Architecture of the Streptomyces lividans DnaA protein-replication origin complexes

The Streptomyces oriC region contains two clusters of 19 DnaA boxes separated by a spacer (134 bp). The Streptomyces DnaA protein consists, like all other DnaA proteins, of four domains: domain III and the carboxyterminal part (domain IV) are responsible for binding of ATP and DNA, respectively. Binding of the DnaA protein to the entire oriC region analysed by electron microscopy showed that the DnaA protein forms separate complexes at each of the clusters of DnaA boxes, but not at the spacer separating them. In vivo mutational analysis revealed that the number of DnaA boxes and the presence of the spacer linking both groups of DnaA boxes seem to be important for a functional Streptomyces origin. We suggest that the arrangement of DnaA boxes allows the DNA-bound DnaA protein to induce bending and looping of the oriC region. As it was shown by electrophoretic mobility shift assay and "one hybrid system", two domains, I and III, facilitate interactions between DnaA molecules. We postulate that domain I and domain III could be involved in cooperativity at distant and at closely spaced DnaA boxes, respectively. The long domain II extends the range over which N termini (domain I) of DNA-bound DnaA protein can form dimers. Thus, interactions between DnaA molecules may bring two clusters of DnaA boxes separated by the spacer into functional contact by loop formation. Removal of the spacer region or deletion of domains I and II resulted, respectively, in nucleoprotein complexes which are not fully developed, or huge nucleoprotein aggregates.

The function of auxiliary operators

Gene regulation by control of transcription has been analysed in great detail both in prokaryotes and in eukaryotes. The frequency of transcription may be decreased by repressors or increased by activators. A repressor may work by decreasing the concentration of RNA polymerase at a promoter capable of forming an open complex. An activator may work by increasing the concentration of RNA polymerase at a promoter capable of forming an open complex. For this purpose, a strategy is used over and over again. It is called increase in local concentration. How Escherichia coli uses this strategy efficiently is discussed.

The spacing between binding sites controls the mode of cooperative DNA-protein interactions: implications for evolution of regulatory circuitry

The CI repressors of lambdoid phages bind cooperatively to adjacent binding sites. Although these binding sites are found at complex operators containing three binding sites, cooperative binding occurs only between dimers bound at two of the sites, a mode of binding termed pairwise cooperativity. At the level of regulation, pairwise cooperativity allows the proper operation of the genetic switch. At the mechanistic level, it has been proposed to result from steric distortion of the complex, such that a protein dimer bound to a central site cannot contact both flanking dimers because it "leans" towards one of the two sites. We have tested this model using the CI repressor of phage HK022. Previous work suggested that reducing the spacing between adjacent operators might allow cooperative interaction among three dimers, a mode of cooperativity we term extended. Using a set of synthetic templates, we have shown that reducing the spacing allows extended cooperativity among three binding sites. Accordingly, the mode of cooperativity changes qualitatively in response to changes in the inter-site spacing. That is, the change in spacing has major functional consequences for the properties of the complex. We suggest that such changes can play important roles in the evolution of gene regulatory circuitry and of other processes involving nucleoprotein complexes.

The linker region of AraC protein

AraC protein, a transcriptional regulator of the L-arabinose operon in Escherichia coli, is dimeric. Each monomer consists of a domain for DNA binding plus transcription activation and a domain for dimerization plus arabinose binding. These are connected to one another by a linker region of at least 5 amino acids. Here we have addressed the question of whether any of the amino acids in the linker region play active, specific, and crucial structural roles or whether these amino acids merely serve as passive spacers between the functional domains. We found that all but one of the linker amino acids can be changed to other amino acids individually and in small groups without substantially affecting the ability of AraC protein to activate transcription when arabinose is present. When, however, the entire linker region is replaced with linker sequences from other proteins, the functioning of AraC is impaired.

Mutant LexA proteins with specific defects in autodigestion

In self-processing biochemical reactions, a protein or RNA molecule specifically modifies its own structure. Many such reactions are regulated in response to the needs of the cell by an interaction with another effector molecule. In the system we study here, specific cleavage of the Escherichia coli LexA repressor, LexA cleaves itself in vitro at a slow rate, but in vivo cleavage requires interaction with an activated form of RecA protein. RecA acts indirectly as a coprotease to stimulate LexA autodigestion. We describe here a new class of lexA mutants, lexA (Adg-; for autodigestion-defective) mutants, termed Adg- for brevity. Adg- mutants specifically interfered with the ability of LexA to autodigest but left intact its ability to undergo RecA-mediated cleavage. The data are consistent with a conformational model in which RecA favors a reactive conformation capable of undergoing cleavage. To our knowledge, this is the first example of a mutation in a regulated self-processing reaction that impairs the rate of self-processing without markedly affecting the stimulated reaction. Had wild-type lexA carried such a substitution, discovery of its self-processing would have been difficult; we suggest that, in other systems, a slow rate of self-processing has prevented recognition that a reaction is of this nature.