Molding a peptide into an RNA site by in vivo peptide evolution

Synthetic Peptides: Promising Modalities for the Targeting of Disease-Related Nucleic Acids

DNA and RNA play pivotal roles in life processes by storing and transferring genetic information, modulating gene expression, and contributing to essential cellular machinery such as ribosomes. Dysregulation and mutations in nucleic acid-related processes are implicated in numerous diseases. Despite the critical impact on health of nucleic acid mutations or dysregulation, therapeutic compounds addressing these biomolecules remain limited. Peptides have emerged as a promising class of molecules for biomedical research, offering potential solutions for challenging drug targets. This review focuses on the use of synthetic peptides to target disease-related nucleic acids. We discuss examples of peptides targeting double-stranded DNA, including the clinical candidate Omomyc, and compounds designed for regulatory G-quadruplexes. Further, we provide insights into both library-based screenings and the rational design of peptides to target regulatory human RNA scaffolds and viral RNAs, emphasizing the potential of peptides in addressing nucleic acid-related diseases.

Role of Mutations in Differential Recognition of Viral RNA Molecules by Peptides

The conserved noncoding RNA elements in viral genomes interact with proteins to regulate various events during viral replication. We report studies on the recognition mechanisms of two helical peptides, namely, a native (Rev) peptide and a lab-evolved (RSG1.2) peptide, by a highly conserved viral RNA element from the human immunodeficiency virus 1 genome. Specifically, we investigated the physical interactions between the viral RNA molecule and helical peptides by computing free energy changes on mutating key amino acid residues involved in recognition of an internal loop in the viral RNA molecule.

Role of salt-bridging interactions in recognition of viral RNA by arginine-rich peptides

Interactions between RNA molecules and proteins are critical to many cellular processes and are implicated in various diseases. The RNA-peptide complexes are good model systems to probe the recognition mechanism of RNA by proteins. In this work, we report studies on the binding-unbinding process of a helical peptide from a viral RNA element using nonequilibrium molecular dynamics simulations. We explored the existence of various dissociation pathways with distinct free-energy profiles that reveal metastable states and distinct barriers to peptide dissociation. We also report the free-energy differences for each of the four pathways to be 96.47 ± 12.63, 96.1 ± 10.95, 91.83 ± 9.81, and 92 ± 11.32 kcal/mol. Based on the free-energy analysis, we further propose the preferred pathway and the mechanism of peptide dissociation. The preferred pathway is characterized by the formation of sequential hydrogen-bonding and salt-bridging interactions between several key arginine amino acids and the viral RNA nucleotides. Specifically, we identified one arginine amino acid (R8) of the peptide to play a significant role in the recognition mechanism of the peptide by the viral RNA molecule.

Exploring the RNA-Recognition Mechanism Using Supervised Molecular Dynamics (SuMD) Simulations: Toward a Rational Design for Ribonucleic-Targeting Molecules?

Although proteins have represented the molecular target of choice in the development of new drug candidates, the pharmaceutical importance of ribonucleic acids has gradually been growing. The increasing availability of structural information has brought to light the existence of peculiar three-dimensional RNA arrangements, which can, contrary to initial expectations, be recognized and selectively modulated through small chemical entities or peptides. The application of classical computational methodologies, such as molecular docking, for the rational development of RNA-binding candidates is, however, complicated by the peculiarities characterizing these macromolecules, such as the marked conformational flexibility, the singular charges distribution, and the relevant role of solvent molecules. In this work, we have thus validated and extended the applicability domain of SuMD, an all-atoms molecular dynamics protocol that allows to accelerate the sampling of molecular recognition events on a nanosecond timescale, to ribonucleotide targets of pharmaceutical interest. In particular, we have proven the methodological ability by reproducing the binding mode of viral or prokaryotic ribonucleic complexes, as well as that of artificially engineered aptamers, with an impressive degree of accuracy.

Molecular recognition of HIV-1 RNAs with branched peptides

Targeting RNA offers the potential in many diseases of a therapeutic treatment. Due to its large surface area and ability to adopt different conformations, targeting RNA has proven challenging. Medium-sized branched peptides are of the size to competitively bind RNA while remaining cell permeable, stable in vivo, and non-toxic. Additionally, the ease in generating a large library followed by high-throughput screening provides a way to suggest a scaffold with high diversity that is capable of targeting the structure and sequence of RNA. The ability to select various types of amino acid modifications in the branched peptide allows for variable structures and interactions of the branched peptide but can result in too large a task if not approached properly. In this chapter, we discuss a strategy to selectively recognize RNAs of interest through high throughput screening of branched peptides, validation of hits and biophysical characterization, leading by example with our experience in targeting HIV-1 RNAs with branched peptides.

Identification of novel proteins binding the AU-rich element of α-prothymosin mRNA through the selection of open reading frames (RIDome)

We describe here a platform for high-throughput protein expression and interaction analysis aimed at identifying the RNA-interacting domainome. This approach combines the selection of a phage library displaying "filtered" open reading frames with next-generation DNA sequencing. The method was validated using an RNA bait corresponding to the AU-rich element of α-prothymosin, an RNA motif that promotes mRNA stability and translation through its interaction with the RNA-binding protein ELAVL1. With this strategy, we not only confirmed known RNA-binding proteins that specifically interact with the target RNA (such as ELAVL1/HuR and RBM38) but also identified proteins not previously known to be ARE-binding (R3HDM2 and RALY). We propose this technology as a novel approach for studying the RNA-binding proteome.

The new (dis)order in RNA regulation

RNA-binding proteins play a key role in the regulation of all aspects of RNA metabolism, from the synthesis of RNA to its decay. Protein-RNA interactions have been thought to be mostly mediated by canonical RNA-binding domains that form stable secondary and tertiary structures. However, a number of pioneering studies over the past decades, together with recent proteome-wide data, have challenged this view, revealing surprising roles for intrinsically disordered protein regions in RNA binding. Here, we discuss how disordered protein regions can mediate protein-RNA interactions, conceptually grouping these regions into RS-rich, RG-rich, and other basic sequences, that can mediate both specific and non-specific interactions with RNA. Disordered regions can also influence RNA metabolism through protein aggregation and hydrogel formation. Importantly, protein-RNA interactions mediated by disordered regions can influence nearly all aspects of co- and post-transcriptional RNA processes and, consequently, their disruption can cause disease. Despite growing interest in disordered protein regions and their roles in RNA biology, their mechanisms of binding, regulation, and physiological consequences remain poorly understood. In the coming years, the study of these unorthodox interactions will yield important insights into RNA regulation in cellular homeostasis and disease.

Coevolution Theory of the Genetic Code at Age Forty: Pathway to Translation and Synthetic Life

The origins of the components of genetic coding are examined in the present study. Genetic information arose from replicator induction by metabolite in accordance with the metabolic expansion law. Messenger RNA and transfer RNA stemmed from a template for binding the aminoacyl-RNA synthetase ribozymes employed to synthesize peptide prosthetic groups on RNAs in the Peptidated RNA World. Coevolution of the genetic code with amino acid biosynthesis generated tRNA paralogs that identify a last universal common ancestor (LUCA) of extant life close to Methanopyrus, which in turn points to archaeal tRNA introns as the most primitive introns and the anticodon usage of Methanopyrus as an ancient mode of wobble. The prediction of the coevolution theory of the genetic code that the code should be a mutable code has led to the isolation of optional and mandatory synthetic life forms with altered protein alphabets.

Diverse mutants of HIV RRE IIB recognize wild-type Rev ARM or Rev ARM R35G-N40V

The binding of human immunodeficiency virus Rev protein via its arginine-rich motif (ARM) to an internal loop in the Rev-response element region IIB (RRE IIB) is necessary for viral replication. Many variant RNAs and ARMs that bind Rev and RRE IIB have been found. Despite the essential role of Rev asparagine 40 in recognition, the Rev ARM double-mutant R35G-N40V functions well in a Rev-RRE IIB reporter assay, indicating R35G-N40V uses a distinct recognition strategy. To examine how RRE IIB may evolve specificity to wild-type Rev ARM and R35G-N40V, 10 RRE IIB libraries, each completely randomized in overlapping regions, were screened with wild-type Rev ARM and R35G-N40V using a reporter system based on bacteriophage λ N antitermination. Consistent with previous studies, a core element of RRE IIB did not vary, and substitutions occurred at conserved residues only in the presence of other substitutions. Notably, the groove-widening, non-canonical base-pair G48:G71 was mutable to U48:G71 without strong loss of binding to wild-type Rev ARM, suggesting U48:G71 performs the same role by adopting the nearly isosteric, reverse wobble base pair. Originating from RRE IIB, as few as one or two substitutions are sufficient to confer specificity to wild-type Rev or Rev R35G-N40. The diversity of RRE IIB mutants that maintain binding to wild-type Rev ARM and R35G-N40V supports neutral theories of evolution and illustrates paths by which viral RNA-protein interactions can evolve new specificities. Rev-RRE offers an excellent model with which to study the fine structure of how specificity evolves.

Randomized codon mutagenesis reveals that the HIV Rev arginine-rich motif is robust to substitutions and that double substitution of two critical residues alters specificity

The binding of the arginine-rich motif (ARM) of HIV Rev protein to its high-affinity site in stem IIB in the Rev response element (RRE) initiates assembly of a ribonucleoprotein complex that mediates the export of essential, incompletely spliced viral transcripts. Many biochemical, genetic, and structural studies of Rev-RRE IIB have been published, yet the roles of many peptide residues in Rev ARM are unconfirmed by mutagenesis. Rev aptamer I (RAI) is an optimized RRE IIB that binds Rev with higher affinity and for which mutational data are sparse. Randomized-codon libraries of Rev ARM were assayed for their ability to bind RRE IIB and RAI using a bacterial reporter system based on bacteriophage λ N-nut antitermination. Most Rev ARM residues tolerated substitutions without strong loss of binding to RRE IIB, and all except arginine 39 tolerated substitution without strong loss of binding to RAI. The pattern of critical Rev residues is not the same for RRE IIB and RAI, suggesting important differences between the interactions. The results support and aid the interpretation of existing structural models. Observed clinical variation is consistent with additional constraints on Rev mutation. By chance, we found double mutants of two highly critical residues, arginine 35 (to glycine) and asparagine 40 (to valine or lysine), that bind RRE IIB well, but not RAI. That an apparently distinct binding mode occurs with only two mutations highlights the ability of ARMs to evolve new recognition strategies and supports the application of neutral theories of evolution to protein-RNA recognition.

Specificity of RSG-1.2 peptide binding to RRE-IIB RNA element of HIV-1 over Rev peptide is mainly enthalpic in origin

Rev is an essential HIV-1 regulatory protein which binds to the Rev responsive element (RRE) present within the env gene of HIV-1 RNA genome. This binding facilitates the transport of the RNA to the cytoplasm, which in turn triggers the switch between viral latency and active viral replication. Essential components of this complex have been localized to a minimal arginine rich Rev peptide and stem IIB region of RRE. A synthetic peptide known as RSG-1.2 binds with high binding affinity and specificity to the RRE-IIB than the Rev peptide, however the thermodynamic basis of this specificity has not yet been addressed. The present study aims to probe the thermodynamic origin of this specificity of RSG-1.2 over Rev Peptide for RRE-IIB. The temperature dependent melting studies show that RSG-1.2 binding stabilizes the RRE structure significantly (ΔT_m = 4.3°C), in contrast to Rev binding. Interestingly the thermodynamic signatures of the binding have also been found to be different for both the peptides. At pH 7.5, RSG-1.2 binds RRE-IIB with a K_a = 16.2±0.6×10⁷ M⁻¹ where enthalpic change ΔH = −13.9±0.1 kcal/mol is the main driving force with limited unfavorable contribution from entropic change TΔS = −2.8±0.1 kcal/mol. A large part of ΔH may be due to specific stacking between U72 and Arg15. In contrast binding of Rev (K_a = 3.1±0.4×10⁷ M⁻¹) is driven mainly by entropy (ΔH = 0 kcal/mol and TΔS = 10.2±0.2 kcal/mol) which arises from major conformational changes in the RNA upon binding.

Evolution of synthetic polymers

A strategy for the enrichment of a DNA template that encodes a functionalized PNA oligomer is discussed. The method relies on iterated cycles of chemical translation (of the template into PNA), selection (for function), and amplification (of the survivors). Potential restrictions and future perspectives are considered.

Identification of antisense RNA stem-loops that inhibit RNA-protein interactions using a bacterial reporter system

Many well-characterized examples of antisense RNAs from prokaryotic systems involve hybridization of the looped regions of stem–loop RNAs, presumably due to the high thermodynamic stability of the resulting loop–loop and loop–linear interactions. In this study, the identification of RNA stem–loops that inhibit U1A protein binding to the hpII RNA through RNA–RNA interactions was attempted using a bacterial reporter system based on phage λ N-mediated antitermination. As a result, loop sequences possessing 7–8 base complementarity to the 5′ region of the boxA element important for functional antitermination complex formation, but not the U1 hpII loop, were identified. In vitro and in vivo mutational analysis strongly suggested that the selected loop sequences were binding to the boxA region, and that the structure of the antisense stem–loop was important for optimal inhibitory activity. Next, in an attempt to demonstrate the ability to inhibit the interaction between the U1A protein and the hpII RNA, the rational design of an RNA stem–loop that inhibits U1A-binding to a modified hpII was carried out. Moderate inhibitory activity was observed, showing that it is possible to design and select antisense RNA stem–loops that disrupt various types of RNA–protein interactions.

Amino acid requirement for the high affinity binding of a selected arginine-rich peptide with the HIV Rev-response element RNA

The arginine-rich motif is a class of short arginine-rich peptides that bind to specific RNA structures that has been found to be a versatile framework for the design and selection of RNA-binding peptides. We previously identified novel peptides that bind to the Rev-response element (RRE) RNA of the HIV from an arginine-rich polypeptide library (ARPL) consisting of a polyarginine (15 mer) randomized at the N-terminal 10 positions. The selected peptides bound more strongly to the RRE than the natural binding partner, Rev, and contained glutamine residues that were assumed to be important for recognition of the G-A base pair. In addition, the peptides were predicted to bind to the RRE in an alpha-helical conformation. In this study, in order to understand the mechanism of the interaction between the RRE and the putative alpha-helical glutamine-containing peptides, the amino acid requirements for high affinity binding were analyzed by a combinatorial approach using a bacterial system for detecting RNA-peptide interactions. A consensus peptide, the DLA peptide, was elucidated, which consists of a single glutamine residue within a polyarginine context with the glutamine residue flanked at specific positions by three nonarginine residues, two of which appear to be important for alpha-helix stabilization. In addition, the DLA peptide was found to bind extremely tightly to the RRE with an affinity 50-fold higher than that of the Rev peptide as determined by a gel shift assay. A working model for the interaction of the DLA peptide to the RRE is proposed, which should aid in the development of peptide-based drugs that inhibit HIV replication, as well as in our understanding of polypeptide-RNA interactions.

Tailoring the peptide-binding specificity of an RNA by combinations of specificity-altering mutations

In this study, the ability to tailor the peptide-binding specificity of an RNA was investigated. First, variants of the Rev-response element (RRE) RNA with different specificities toward the natural binding partner, Rev, and two RRE-binding aptamers, the RSG-1.2 and the Kl peptides, were identified. Next, hybrid RRE mutants with combinations of two sets of specificity-altering substitutions were tested for peptide-binding specificity. It was shown that in most cases the results of the combination of individual mutations were of an additive nature, therefore providing a way to manipulate the peptide-binding specificity of an RNA in a predictable manner.

Selection of peptides interfering with a ribosomal frameshift in the human immunodeficiency virus type 1

The human immunodeficiency virus of type 1 (HIV-1) uses a programmed -1 ribosomal frameshift to produce the precursor of its enzymes, and changes in frameshift efficiency reduce replicative fitness of the virus. We used a fluorescent two-reporter system to screen for peptides that reduce HIV-1 frameshift in bacteria, knowing that the frameshift can be reproduced in Escherichia coli. Expression of one reporter, the green fluorescent protein (GFP), requires the HIV-1 frameshift, whereas the second reporter, the red fluorescent protein (RFP), is used to assess normal translation. A peptide library biased for RNA binding was inserted into the sequence of the protein thioredoxin and expressed in reporter-containing bacteria, which were then screened by fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS). We identified peptide sequences that reduce frameshift efficiency by over 50% without altering normal translation. The identified sequences are also active against different frameshift stimulatory signals, suggesting that they bind a target important for frameshifting in general, probably the ribosome. Successful transfer of active sequences to a different scaffold in a eukaryotic test system demonstrates that the anti-frameshift activity of the peptides is neither due to scaffold-dependent conformation nor effects of the scaffold protein itself on frameshifting. The method we describe identifies peptides that will provide useful tools to further study the mechanism of frameshift and may permit the development of lead compounds of therapeutic interest.

Catalytic metallodrugs

Drug discovery remains a top priority in medical science. The phenomenon of drug resistance has heightened the need for both new classes of pharmaceutical, as well as novel modes of action. A new paradigm for drug activity is presented, which includes both recognition and subsequent irreversible inactivation of therapeutic targets. Application to both RNA and enzyme therapeutic targets has been demonstrated, while incorporation of both binding and catalytic centers provides a double-filter mechanism for improved target selectivity and lower dosing. In contrast to RNA targets that are subject to strand scission chemistry mediated by ribose H-atom abstraction, proteins appear to be inactivated through oxidative damage to amino acid side chains around the enzyme active site. Methods to monitor both intracellular delivery and activity against RNA targets have been developed based on plasmid expression of the green fluorescent protein (GFP). Herein, the activity of representative metallodrugs is described in the context of both in vitro and cellular assays, and the mechanism of action is discussed. Studies with scavengers of reactive oxygen species (ROS) confirmed hydrogen peroxide to be an obligatory diffusible intermediate, prior to formation of a Cu-bound hydroxyl radical species generated from Fenton-type chemistry.

Potent inhibition of HIV-1 replication by backbone cyclic peptides bearing the Rev arginine rich motif

Due to its essential role in the virus life cycle, the viral regulatory protein Rev constitutes an attractive target for the development of new antiviral molecules. In this work, a series of Backbone Cyclic Peptide (BCP) analogs that bear a conformationally constrained arginine rich motif (ARM) of Rev were tested for in vitro inhibition of HIV-1 replication. We observed a potent suppression of HIV-1 replication in chronically infected T lymphocytic cells treated with Rev-BCPs. We further investigated possible mechanisms of HIV-1 inhibition and showed that Rev-BCPs interfere slightly with the nuclear import process and are very efficient in blocking a mechanism that controls Pr55(gag) and gp160(env) synthesis. Interestingly, these protein precursors are known to be encoded by mRNAs that require Rev-binding for nuclear export. In situ hybridization using a Cy-3 conjugated HIV-1 gag oligonucleotide probe indicated that Rev-BCPs prevent the intracellular accumulation of unspliced viral RNA. As a model, the most promising analog, Rev-BCP 14, was studied by molecular modeling and dynamics in order to identify its binding site on the Rev Response Element (RRE). The annealing simulation suggests that upon binding on the RRE, Rev-BCP 14 widens the distorted major groove of the viral RNA. Numerous contacts between peptide and RNA were found within the complex and some were identified as key components for the interactions. Altogether, our data indicate that the use of conformationally constrained Rev-BCPs represents a promising strategy for the development of new peptide-based therapeutic agents against HIV-1.

PRMT6 diminishes HIV-1 Rev binding to and export of viral RNA

Background

The HIV-1 Rev protein mediates nuclear export of unspliced and partially spliced viral RNA through interaction with the Rev response element (RRE) by means of an arginine rich motif that is similar to the one found in Tat. Since Tat is known to be asymmetrically arginine dimethylated by protein arginine methyltransferase 6 (PRMT6) in its arginine rich motif, we investigated whether the Rev protein could act as a substrate for this enzyme.

Results

Here, we report the methylation of Rev due to a single arginine dimethylation in the N-terminal portion of its arginine rich motif and the association of Rev with PRMT6 in vivo. Further analysis demonstrated that the presence of increasing amounts of wild-type PRMT6, as well as a methylation-inactive mutant PRMT6, dramatically down-regulated Rev protein levels in concentration-dependent fashion, which was not dependent on the methyltransferase activity of PRMT6. Quantification of Rev mRNA revealed that attenuation of Rev protein levels was due to a posttranslational event, carried out by a not yet defined activity of PRMT6. However, no relevant protein attenuation was observed in subsequent chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) expression experiments that screened for RNA export and interaction with the RRE. Binding of the Rev arginine rich motif to the RRE was reduced in the presence of wild-type PRMT6, whereas mutant PRMT6 did not exert this negative effect. In addition, diminished interactions between viral RNA and mutant Rev proteins were observed, due to the introduction of single arginine to lysine substitutions in the Rev arginine rich motif. More importantly, wild-type PRMT6, but not mutant methyltransferase, significantly decreased Rev-mediated viral RNA export from the nucleus to the cytoplasm in a dose-dependent manner.

Conclusion

These findings indicate that PRMT6 severely impairs the function of HIV-1 Rev.

A peptide with alternating lysines can act as a highly specific Z-DNA binding domain

Many nucleic acid binding proteins use short peptide sequences to provide specificity in recognizing their targets, which may be either a specific sequence or a conformation. Peptides containing alternating lysine have been shown to bind to poly(dG–d5meC) in the Z conformation, and stabilize the higher energy form [H. Takeuchi, N. Hanamura, H. Hayasaka and I. Harada (1991) FEBS Lett., 279, 253–255 and H. Takeuchi, N. Hanamura and I. Harada (1994) J. Mol. Biol., 236, 610–617.]. Here we report the construction of a Z-DNA specific binding protein, with the peptide KGKGKGK as a functional domain and a leucine zipper as a dimerization domain. The resultant protein, KGZIP, induces the Z conformation in poly(dG–d5meC) and binds to Z-DNA stabilized by bromination with high affinity and specificity. The binding of KGZIP is sufficient to convert poly(dG–d5meC) from the B to the Z form, as shown by circular dichroism. The sequence KGKGKGK is found in many proteins, although no functional role has been established. KGZIP also has potential for engineering other Z-DNA specific proteins for future studies of Z-DNA in vitro and in vivo.

Engineering RNA sequence specificity of Pumilio repeats

Puf proteins bind RNA sequence specifically and regulate translation and stability of target mRNAs. A "code" for RNA recognition has been deduced from crystal structures of the Puf protein, human Pumilio1, where each of eight repeats binds an RNA base via a combination of three side chains at conserved positions. Here, we report the creation of seven soluble mutant proteins with predictably altered sequence specificity, including one that binds tightly to adenosine-uracil-rich element RNA. These data show that Pumilio1 can be used as a scaffold to engineer RNA-binding proteins with designed sequence specificity.

An efficient thermally induced RNA conformational switch as a framework for the functionalization of RNA nanostructures

RNA offers a variety of interactions and dynamic conformational switches not available with DNA that may be exploited for the construction of nanomolecular structures. Here, we show how the RNA loop-loop, or "kissing", interaction can be used to construct specific circular RNA arrangements that are capable of thermal isomerization to alternative structures. We also show how this thermally induced structural rearrangement can be used to unmask a functional RNA structure, in this case, a peptide-binding RNA structure, the Rev-response element (RRE) of HIV, thereby acting as a functional peptide-binding switch. The relative ease with which the RRE could be engineered into the RNA substrates suggested that a variety of functional RNA structures may be introduced. In addition, the structural rearrangement was extremely efficient, showing that the "kissing" complexes described in this study may provide a useful framework for the construction of functional RNA-based nanostructures, as well as aid in our understanding of the way RNA functions in biological systems.

Targeted Cleavage of HIV Rev Response Element RNA by Metallopeptide Complexes

Stoichiometric targeting and site-specific cleavage of HIV RRE RNA is demonstrated under physiologically relevant conditions by use of a metallopeptide that combines a specific RNA recognition sequence with a metal binding domain. Mass spectrometric analysis of cleavage products following treatment of target RNA with the metallopeptide, ascorbate, and dioxygen are consistent with C-1'H or C-4'H oxidative cleavage paths with an apparent second-order rate constant k2 approximately 700 M-1 min-1.

Evolvability of the mode of peptide binding by an RNA

The HIV Rev-response element (RRE) RNA binds strongly to two unrelated peptides, the HIV Rev peptide and an RRE-binding aptamer, the RSG-1.2 peptide, at a similar site, but using distinct sets of interactions. In this study, the nucleotide base requirements for the binding of the RRE to the Rev and RSG-1.2 peptides were determined by selection of Rev- and RSG-1.2-binding RRE variants using a bacterial reporter system. As a result, distinct differences in the bases necessary for binding the two peptides were found in the upper stem of the RRE. Strikingly, single nucleotide changes in this region were found to switch the peptide-binding specificity of the RRE from a bifunctional Rev- and RSG-1.2-binding mode to either a Rev-specific or a RSG-1.2- specific mode, demonstrating how an RNA can evolve alternative binding strategies in discrete steps without intermediate loss of function. This evolvability of the mode of peptide binding by an RNA presumably reflects the multidimensionality of conformational space that a given RNA has available for ligand recognition, which may have been utilized in the evolution of RNA-polypeptide complexes.

A quantitative description of the binding states and in vitro function of antitermination protein N of bacteriophage lambda

The N protein of bacteriophage lambda activates transcription of genes that lie downstream of termination sequences by suppressing transcription termination. N binds to specific (boxB) and non-specific sites on the transcript RNA and contacts RNA polymerase via cis-RNA looping, resulting in "antitermination" of transcription. To find the effect of N-boxB binding on antitermination, we quantitatively relate binding measurements made in isolation to in vitro antitermination activity. We measure binding of N to boxB RNA, non-specific single-stranded RNA, and non-specific double-stranded DNA fluorimetrically, and use an equilibrium model to describe quantitatively the binding of N to nucleic acids of Escherichia coli transcription elongation complexes. We then test the model by comparison with in vitro N antitermination activity measured in reactions containing these same elongation complexes. We find that binding of N protein to the nucleic acid components of transcription elongation complexes can quantitatively predict antitermination activity, suggesting that antitermination in vitro is determined by a nucleic acid binding equilibrium with one molecule of N protein per RNA transcript being sufficient for antitermination. Elongation complexes contain numerous overlapping non-specific RNA and DNA-binding sites for N; the large number of sites compensates for the low N binding affinity, so multiple N proteins are expected to bind to elongation complexes. The occupancy/activity of these proteins is described by a binomial distribution of proteins on transcripts containing multiple non-specific sites. The contribution of specific (boxB) binding to activity also depends on this distribution. Specificity is not measured accurately by measurements made in the presence and in the absence of boxB. We find that antitermination is inhibited by non-productive binding of N to non-specific sites on template DNA, and that NusA protein covers RNA sites on the transcript, limiting N access and activity. The activity and specificity of regulatory proteins that loop from high-affinity binding sites are likely modulated by multiple non-specific binding events; in vivo activity may also be regulated by the modulation of non-specific binding.

Morphing molecular specificities between Arm-peptide and NUT-RNA in the antitermination complexes of bacteriophages lambda and P22

Bacteriophage lambda's N-protein includes a 17-amino-acid segment, Arm, rich in arginine and having specific affinity for a 15-nucleotide RNA stem-loop called BOX-B. Parallel but different Arm/BOX-B sequences in lambda's cousin, phage P22, account for some of the type specificity that distinguishes lambda from P22: the N of each works only with its cognate BOX-B in vivo. We find that the specificity of N(lambda) can be shifted gradually to that of N(22) by substituting sets of particular amino acids from Arm(22) into Arm of N(lambda). The determinative amino acids are generally those shown by nuclear magnetic resonance to contact BOX-B RNA; gain or loss of these contact amino acids is reasonably expected to contribute to the affinity of each amino acid sequence. Intermediate sequences may show no function with either BOX-B, or weak function with both BOX-B(lambda) and BOX-B(22), the latter suggesting possible evolutionary paths for specificity shifts.

In vitro selection of ribozymes dependent on peptides for activity

A peptide-dependent ribozyme ligase (aptazyme ligase) has been selected from a random sequence population based on the small L1 ligase. The aptazyme ligase is activated > 18,000-fold by its cognate peptide effector, the HIV-1 Rev arginine-rich motif (ARM), and specifically recognizes the Rev ARM relative to other peptides containing arginine-rich motifs. Moreover, the aptazyme ligase can preferentially recognize the Rev ARM in the context of the full-length HIV-1 Rev protein. The only cross-reactivity exhibited by the aptazyme is toward the Tat ARM. Reselection of peptide- and protein-dependent aptazymes from a partially randomized population yielded aptazymes that could readily discriminate against the Tat ARM. These results have important implications for the development of aptazymes that can be used in arrays for the detection and quantitation of multiple cellular proteins (proteome arrays).

Sequence and structure space of RNA-binding peptides

Studies of RNA-binding peptides, and recent combinatorial library experiments in particular, have demonstrated that diverse peptide sequences and structures can be used to recognize specific RNA sites. The identification of large numbers of sequences capable of binding to a particular site has provided extensive phylogenetic information used to deduce basic principles of recognition. The high frequency at which RNA-binding peptides are found in large sequence libraries suggests plausible routes to evolve sequence-specific binders, facilitating the design of new binding molecules and perhaps reflecting characteristics of natural evolution.

Characterization of the caprine arthritis encephalitis virus (CAEV) rev N-terminal elements required for efficient interaction with the RRE

The Caprine Arthritis Encephalitis Virus (CAEV) genome encodes three structural (gag, pol, and env) and three accessory (rev, tat, and vif) genes. The Rev-C protein regulates Gag, Pol and Env expression by transporting their mRNAs to the cytoplasm. Rev trans-activation requires binding of Rev to an RNA structure called the Rev Response Element (RRE-C). Previous mutational analyses have shown that two domains of Rev are required for its function. The basic domain mediates RRE binding and multimer formation, and the nuclear export signal (NES) mediates trans-activation. Preliminary experiments demonstrate that Rev-C N-terminal deletion mutants bind the RRE less avidly than does wildtype Rev. As a result, it was hypothesized that an additional domain located in the N-terminal exon of Rev-C was required for optimal RRE binding. To test this hypothesis, Rev-C alanine scanning mutants were generated and in vitro RRE binding assays were performed. Alteration of Rev-C amino acids K13, E14, N15, V19, T20, M21 and R27 dramatically decreased affinity for RRE-C. These data demonstrate that Rev-C N-terminal amino acids are required for optimal RRE-C binding and suggest that a third functional domain exists within the N-terminus of Rev-C.

Selection of RRE RNA binding peptides using a kanamycin antitermination assay

The arginine-rich domains of several RNA-binding proteins have been shown to bind their cognate RNAs with high affinities and specificities as isolated peptides, adopting different conformations within different complexes. The sequence simplicity and structural diversity of the arginine-rich motif has made it a good framework for constructing combinatorial libraries and identifying novel RNA-binding peptides, including those targeted to the HIV Rev response element (RRE). Here we describe a modified transcription antitermination reporter assay engineered with kanamycin resistance that enables larger in vivo screens (approximately 10(9) sequences) than previously possible. We show that the assay detects only specific RNA-protein complexes, and that binders are enriched at least 300-fold per round of selection. We screened a large peptide library in which amino acids with charged, polar, and small side chains were randomly distributed within a polyarginine framework and identified a set of high affinity RRE-binding peptides. Most contain glutamine at one particular peptide position, and the best peptides display significantly higher antitermination activities than Rev or other previously described high-affinity RRE-binding peptides. The kanamycin antitermination (KAN) assay should be useful for screening relatively large libraries and thereby facilitate identification of novel RNA binders.

Selections for constituting new RNA-protein interactions in catalytic RNP

In vitro and in vivo selection techniques are developed to constitute new RNA-peptide interactions. The selection strategy is designed by employing a catalytic RNP consisting of a derivative of the Tetrahymena ribozyme and an artificial RNA-binding protein. An arginine-rich RNA-binding motif and its target RNA motif in the RNP are substituted with randomized sequences and used for the selection experiments. Previously unknown binding motifs are obtained and the newly established interactions have been indispensable for assembling a catalytically active RNP. The method employed in this study is useful for making customized self-splicing intron RNAs whose activity is regulated by protein cofactors.

1H-1H correlations across N-H...N hydrogen bonds in nucleic acids

In 2HJ(NN)-COSY experiments, which correlate protons with donor/acceptor nitrogens across Nd...HNa bonds, the receptor nitrogen needs to be assigned in order to unambiguously identify the hydrogen bond. For many situations this is a non-trivial task which is further complicated by poor dispersion of (Na,Nd) resonances. To address these problems, we present pulse sequences to obtain direct, internucleotide correlations between protons in uniformly 13C/15N labeled nucleic acids containing Nd...HNa hydrogen bonds. Specifically, the pulse sequence H2(N1N3)H3 correlates H2(A,omega1):H3(U,omega2) protons across Watson-CrickA-U and mismatched G.A base pairs, the sequences H5(N3N1)H1/H6(N3N1)H1 correlate H5(C,omega1)/H6(C,omega1):H1(G,omega2) protons across Watson-Crick G-C base pairs, and the H2(N2N7)H8 sequence correlates NH2(G,A,C;omega1):H8(G,A;omega2) protons across G.G, A.A, sheared G.A and other mismatch pairs. These 1H-1H connectivities circumvent the need for independent assignment of the donor/acceptor nitrogen and related degeneracy issues associated with poorly dispersed nitrogen resonances. The methodology is demonstrated on uniformly 13C/15N labeled samples of (a) an RNA regulatory element involving the HIV-1 TAR RNA fragment, (b) a multi-stranded DNA architecture involving a G.(C-A) triad-containing G-quadruplex and (c) a peptide-RNA complex involving an evolved peptide bound to the HIV-1 Rev response element (RRE) RNA fragment.

Design and development of a catalytic ribonucleoprotein

Ribonucleoproteins (RNPs) consisting of derivatives of a ribozyme and an RNA-binding protein were designed and constructed based upon high-resolution structures of the corresponding prototype molecules, the Tetrahymena group I self-splicing intron RNA and two proteins (bacteriophage lambdaN and HIV Rev proteins) containing RNA-binding motifs. The splicing reaction proceeds efficiently only when the designed RNA associates with the designed protein either in vivo or in vitro. In vivo mutagenic protein selection was effective for improving the capability of the protein. Kinetic analyses indicate that the protein promotes RNA folding to establish an active conformation. The fact that the conversion of a ribozyme to an RNP can be accomplished by simple molecular design supports the RNA world hypothesis and suggests that a natural active RNP might have evolved readily from a ribozyme.

Structural characterization of the complex of the Rev response element RNA with a selected peptide

INTRODUCTION

The RSG-1.2 peptide was selected for specific binding to the Rev response element RNA, as the natural Rev peptide does. The RSG-1.2 sequence has features incompatible with the helical structure of the bound Rev peptide, indicating that it must bind in a different conformation.

RESULTS

The binding of the RSG-1.2 peptide to the Rev response element RNA was characterized using multinuclear, multidimensional NMR. The RSG-1.2 peptide is shown to bind with the N-terminal segment of the peptide along the major groove in an extended conformation and turn preceding a C-terminal helical segment, which crosses the RNA groove in the region widened by the presence of purine-purine base pairs. These features make the details of the bound state rather different than that of the Rev peptide which targets the same RNA sequence binding as a single helix along the groove axis.

CONCLUSIONS

These studies further demonstrate the versatility of arginine-rich peptides in recognition of specific RNA elements and the lack of conserved structural features in the bound state.

Structure-based design of a dimeric RNA-peptide complex

The arginine-rich RNA-binding domain of bovine immunodeficiency virus (BIV) Tat adopts a beta-hairpin conformation upon binding to the major groove of BIV TAR. Based on its NMR structure, we modeled dimeric arrangements in which two adjacent TAR sites might be recognized with high affinity by a dimeric peptide. Some dimeric RNAs efficiently bound two unlinked BIV Tat peptides in vitro, but could not bind even one monomeric peptide in vivo, as monitored by transcriptional activation of human immunodeficiency virus long terminal repeat reporters. Results with additional reporters suggest that extending the RNA helix in the dimeric arrangements inhibits peptide binding by decreasing major groove accessibility. In contrast, a dimeric peptide efficiently bound an optimally arranged dimeric TAR in vivo, and bound with an affinity at least 10-fold higher than the monomeric peptide in vitro. Mutating specific nucleotides in each RNA 'half-site' or specific amino acids in each beta-hairpin of the dimeric peptide substantially decreased binding affinity, providing evidence for the modeled dimer-dimer interaction. These studies provide a starting point for identifying dimeric RNA-protein interactions with even higher binding affinities and specificities.

An RNA-binding chameleon

The arginine-rich RNA binding motif is found in a wide variety of proteins, including several viral regulatory proteins. Although related at the primary sequence level, arginine-rich domains from different proteins adopt different conformations depending on the RNA site recognized, and in some cases fold only in the context of RNA. Here we show that the RNA binding domain of the Jembrana disease virus (JDV) Tat protein is able to recognize two different TAR RNA sites, from human and bovine immunodeficiency viruses (HIV and BIV, respectively), adopting different conformations in the two RNA contexts and using different amino acids for recognition. In addition to the conformational differences, the JDV domain requires the cyclin T1 protein for high-affinity binding to HIV TAR, but not to BIV TAR. The "chameleon-like" behavior of the JDV Tat RNA binding domain reinforces the concept that RNA molecules can provide structural scaffolds for protein folding, and suggests mechanisms for evolving distinct RNA binding specificities from a single multifunctional domain.

Fitting peptides into the RNA world

The structures of several peptide-RNA complexes have been reported in the past year, underscoring the diverse nature of RNA structure and protein interactions. In general, specific peptide conformations are stabilized by the surrounding RNA framework; this is strikingly similar to how peptides are stabilized upon interaction with proteins.

The crystal structure of the Rev binding element of HIV-1 reveals novel base pairing and conformational variability

The crystal and molecular structure of an RNA duplex corresponding to the high affinity Rev protein binding element (RBE) has been determined at 2.1-A resolution. Four unique duplexes are present in the crystal, comprising two structural variants. In each duplex, the RNA double helix consists of an annealed 12-mer and 14-mer that form an asymmetric internal loop consisting of G-G and G-A noncanonical base pairs and a flipped-out uridine. The 12-mer strand has an A-form conformation, whereas the 14-mer strand is distorted to accommodate the bulges and noncanonical base pairing. In contrast to the NMR model of the unbound RBE, an asymmetric G-G pair with N2-N7 and N1-O6 hydrogen bonding, is formed in each helix. The G-A base pairing agrees with the NMR structure in one structural variant, but forms a novel water-mediated pair in the other. A backbone flip and reorientation of the G-G base pair is required to assume the RBE conformation present in the NMR model of the complex between the RBE and the Rev peptide.

Structure-based design of an RNA-binding zinc finger

A structure-based approach was used to design RNA-binding zinc fingers that recognize the HIV-1 Rev response element (RRE). An arginine-rich alpha-helix from HIV-1 Rev was engineered into the zinc finger framework, and the designed fingers were shown to bind specifically to the RRE with high affinity and in a zinc-dependent manner, and display cobalt absorption and CD spectra characteristic of properly folded fingers. The results indicate that a monomeric zinc finger can recognize a specific nucleic acid site and that the alpha-helix of a finger can be used to recognize the major groove of RNA as well as DNA. The RRE-binding zinc fingers demonstrate how structure-based approaches may be used in the design of potential RNA-binding therapeutics and provide a framework for selecting RNA-binding fingers with desired specifications.

Adaptive recognition in RNA complexes with peptides and protein modules

Recently, progress has been made towards the structural characterization of the novel folds of RNA-bound arginine-rich peptides and the architecture of their peptide-binding RNA pockets in viral and phage systems. These studies are based on an approach whereby the peptide and RNA components are minimalist modular domains that undergo adaptive structural transitions upon complex formation. Such complexes are characterized by recognition alignments in which the tertiary fold of the RNA generates binding pockets with the potential to envelop minimal elements of protein secondary structure. Strikingly, the peptides fold as isolated alpha-helical or beta-hairpin folds within their RNA major-groove targets, without the necessity of additional appendages for anchorage within the binding pocket. The RNA peptide-binding pocket architectures are sculptured through precisely positioned mismatches, triples and looped-out bases, which accommodate amino acid sidechains through hydrophobic, hydrogen bonding and ionic intermolecular contacts. By contrast, protein modules associated with the HIV-1 nucleocapsid and MS2 phage coat target their RNA binding sites through the insertion of specificity-determining RNA base residues within conserved hydrophobic pockets and crevices on the protein surface, with the bases anchored through hydrogen bonding interactions. These alternative strategies of RNA recognition at the peptide and protein module level provide novel insights into the principles, patterns and diversity of the adaptive transitions associated with the recognition process.