Thermodynamics of cyclic nucleotide binding to the cAMP receptor protein and its T127L mutant

Isothermal titration calorimetry and surface plasmon resonance methods to probe protein-protein interactions

Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) and surface plasmon resonance (SPR) are two commonly used methods to probe biomolecular interactions. ITC can provide information about the binding affinity, stoichiometry, changes in Gibbs free energy, enthalpy, entropy, and heat capacity upon binding. SPR can provide information about the association and dissociation kinetics, binding affinity, and stoichiometry. Both methods can determine the nature of protein-protein interactions and help understand the physicochemical principles underlying complex biochemical pathways and communication networks. This methods article discusses the practical knowledge of how to set up and troubleshoot these two experiments with some examples.

cAMP Activation of the cAMP Receptor Protein, a Model Bacterial Transcription Factor

The active and inactive structures of the Escherichia coli cAMP receptor protein (CRP), a model bacterial transcription factor, are compared to generate a paradigm in the cAMP-induced activation of CRP. The resulting paradigm is shown to be consistent with numerous biochemical studies of CRP and CRP*, a group of CRP mutants displaying cAMP-free activity. The cAMP affinity of CRP is dictated by two factors: (i) the effectiveness of the cAMP pocket and (ii) the protein equilibrium of apo-CRP. How these two factors interplay in determining the cAMP affinity and cAMP specificity of CRP and CRP* mutants are discussed. Both the current understanding and knowledge gaps of CRP-DNA interactions are also described. This review ends with a list of several important CRP issues that need to be addressed in the future.

Mycobacterial Regulatory Systems Involved in the Regulation of Gene Expression Under Respiration-Inhibitory Conditions

Mycobacterium tuberculosis is the causative agent of tuberculosis. M. tuberculosis can survive in a dormant state within the granuloma, avoiding the host-mounting immune attack. M. tuberculosis bacilli in this state show increased tolerance to antibiotics and stress conditions, and thus the transition of M. tuberculosis to the nonreplicating dormant state acts as an obstacle to tuberculosis treatment. M. tuberculosis in the granuloma encounters hostile environments such as hypoxia, nitric oxide, reactive oxygen species, low pH, and nutrient deprivation, etc., which are expected to inhibit respiration of M. tuberculosis. To adapt to and survive in respiration-inhibitory conditions, it is required for M. tuberculosis to reprogram its metabolism and physiology. In order to get clues to the mechanism underlying the entry of M. tuberculosis to the dormant state, it is important to understand the mycobacterial regulatory systems that are involved in the regulation of gene expression in response to respiration inhibition. In this review, we briefly summarize the information regarding the regulatory systems implicated in upregulation of gene expression in mycobacteria exposed to respiration-inhibitory conditions. The regulatory systems covered in this review encompass the DosSR (DevSR) two-component system, SigF partner switching system, MprBA-SigE-SigB signaling pathway, cAMP receptor protein, and stringent response.

Genetically Engineering Escherichia coli to Produce Xylitol from Corncob Hydrolysate without Lime Detoxification

Before fermentation with hemicellulosic hydrolysate as a substrate, it is generally necessary to detoxify the toxic substances that are harmful to microorganism growth. Cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) is a global regulator, and mutation of its key sites may have an important impact on E. coli virulence tolerance. Using corncob hydrolysate without ion-exchange or lime detoxification as the substrate, shake flask fermentation experiments showed that CRP mutant IS5-dG (I112L, T127G, A144T) produced 18.4 g/L of xylitol within 34 h, and the OD₆₀₀ was 9.7 at 24 h; these values were 41.5% and 21.3% higher than those of the starting strain, IS5-d, respectively. This mutant produced 82 g/L of xylitol from corncob hydrolysate without ion-exchange or lime detoxification during fed-batch fermentation in a 15-L bioreactor, with a productivity of 1.04 g/L/h; these values were 173% and 174% higher than the starting strain, respectively. To our knowledge, this is the highest xylitol concentration and productivity produced by microbial fermentation using completely non-detoxified hemicellulosic hydrolysate as the substrate to date. This study also showed that alkali neutralization, high temperature sterilization, and fermentation of the hydrolysate had important effects on the xylose loss rate and xylitol production.

Low CyaA expression and anti-cooperative binding of cAMP to CRP frames the scope of the cognate regulon of Pseudomonas putida

Although the soil bacterium Pseudomonas putida KT2440 bears a bona fide adenylate cyclase gene (cyaA), intracellular concentrations of 3',5'-cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) are barely detectable. By using reporter technology and direct quantification of cAMP under various conditions, we show that such low levels of the molecule stem from the stringent regulation of its synthesis, efflux and degradation. Poor production of cAMP was the result of inefficient translation of cyaA mRNA. Moreover, deletion of the cAMP-phosphodiesterase pde gene led to intracellular accumulation of the cyclic nucleotide, exposing an additional cause of cAMP drain in vivo. But even such low levels of the signal sustained activation of promoters dependent on the cAMP-receptor protein (CRP). Genetic and biochemical evidence indicated that the phenomenon ultimately rose from the unusual binding parameters of cAMP to CRP. This included an ultratight cAMP-Crp_{P. putida} affinity (K_D of 45.0 ± 3.4 nM) and an atypical 1:1 effector/dimer stoichiometry that obeyed an infrequent anti-cooperative binding mechanism. It thus seems that keeping the same regulatory parts and their relational logic but changing the interaction parameters enables genetic devices to take over entirely different domains of the functional landscape.

Combination of the CRP mutation and ptsG deletion in Escherichia coli to efficiently synthesize xylitol from corncob hydrolysates

The biotechnology-based production of xylitol has received widespread attention because it can use cheap and renewable lignocellulose as a raw material, thereby decreasing costs and pollution. The simultaneous use of various sugars in lignocellulose hydrolysates is a primary prerequisite for efficient xylitol production. In this study, a ΔptsG and crp* combinatorial strategy was used to generate Escherichia coli W3110 strain IS5-dI, which completely eliminated glucose repression and simultaneously used glucose and xylose. This strain produced 164 g/L xylitol from detoxified corncob hydrolysates during a fed-batch fermentation in a 15-L bioreactor, which was 14.7% higher than the xylitol produced by the starting strain, IS5-d (143 g/L), and the xylitol productivity was 3.04 g/L/h. These results represent the highest xylitol concentration and productivity reported to date for bacteria and hemicellulosic sugars. Additionally, strain IS5-dG, which differs from IS5-dI at CRP amino acid residue 127 (I127G), was tolerant to the toxins in corncob hydrolysates. In a fed-batch fermentation experiment involving a 15-L bioreactor, IS5-dG produced 137 g/L xylitol from non-detoxified corncob hydrolysates, with a productivity of 1.76 g/L/h. On the basis of these results, we believe that IS5-dI and IS5-dG may be useful host strains for the industrial-scale production of xylitol from detoxified or non-detoxified corncob hydrolysates.

Nucleotide signaling pathway convergence in a cAMP-sensing bacterial c-di-GMP phosphodiesterase

Bacterial usage of the cyclic dinucleotide c‐di‐GMP is widespread, governing the transition between motile/sessile and unicellular/multicellular behaviors. There is limited information on c‐di‐GMP metabolism, particularly on regulatory mechanisms governing control of EAL c‐di‐GMP phosphodiesterases. Herein, we provide high‐resolution structures for an EAL enzyme Bd1971, from the predatory bacterium Bdellovibrio bacteriovorus, which is controlled by a second signaling nucleotide, cAMP. The full‐length cAMP‐bound form reveals the sensory N‐terminus to be a domain‐swapped variant of the cNMP/CRP family, which in the cAMP‐activated state holds the C‐terminal EAL enzyme in a phosphodiesterase‐active conformation. Using a truncation mutant, we trap both a half‐occupied and inactive apo‐form of the protein, demonstrating a series of conformational changes that alter juxtaposition of the sensory domains. We show that Bd1971 interacts with several GGDEF proteins (c‐di‐GMP producers), but mutants of Bd1971 do not share the discrete phenotypes of GGDEF mutants, instead having an elevated level of c‐di‐GMP, suggesting that the role of Bd1971 is to moderate these levels, allowing “action potentials” to be generated by each GGDEF protein to effect their specific functions.

Asymmetric configurations in a reengineered homodimer reveal multiple subunit communication pathways in protein allostery

Many allosteric proteins form homo-oligomeric complexes to regulate a biological function. In homo-oligomers, subunits establish communication pathways that are modulated by external stimuli like ligand binding. A challenge for dissecting the communication mechanisms in homo-oligomers is identifying intermediate liganded states, which are typically transiently populated. However, their identities provide the most mechanistic information on how ligand-induced signals propagate from bound to empty subunits. Here, we dissected the directionality and magnitude of subunit communication in a reengineered single-chain version of the homodimeric transcription factor cAMP receptor protein. By combining wild-type and mutant subunits in various asymmetric configurations, we revealed a linear relationship between the magnitude of cooperative effects and the number of mutant subunits. We found that a single mutation is sufficient to change the global allosteric behavior of the dimer even when one subunit was wild type. Dimers harboring two mutations with opposite cooperative effects had different allosteric properties depending on the arrangement of the mutations. When the two mutations were placed in the same subunit, the resulting cooperativity was neutral. In contrast, when placed in different subunits, the observed cooperativity was dominated by the mutation with strongest effects over cAMP affinity relative to wild type. These results highlight the distinct roles of intrasubunit interactions and intersubunit communication in allostery. Finally, dimers bound to either one or two cAMP molecules had similar DNA affinities, indicating that both asymmetric and symmetric liganded states activate DNA interactions. These studies have revealed the multiple communication pathways that homo-oligomers employ to transduce signals.

Fitting two- and three-site binding models to isothermal titration calorimetric data

As isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) gains popularity for the characterization of enthalpies and equilibrium association constants of simple 1:1 biomolecular interactions, its use for more complex systems is growing. The method is increasingly used to study interactions in which a single binding partner (molecule "A") interacts with multiple copies of a second partner ("B"); thus examinations of ABB and ABBB interactions are not uncommon. The structure of ITC data (commonly formatted as isotherms) has a strong bearing on the ability of the researcher to extract the necessary parameters from them. Usually, only 10-30 injections are recorded in a single ITC experiment. Even if replicates are performed, the data must support the extraction of up to twelve parameters from an ABBB system. Further, the refinement of some of the parameters is largely driven by only a subset of the data. The ability of ITC data to guide the deterministic estimation of these parameters may therefore be questioned. This work assesses the ability of both empirical and simulated ITC data of ABB and ABBB systems to support the simultaneous estimation of the desired thermodynamic parameters. The results demonstrate that multiphasic isotherms tend to (but do not always) support the estimation of multiple parameters. On the other hand, uniphasic data obtained from multi-site binding systems are more problematic. In all cases, a thorough exploration of how precisely the estimated parameters are specified by the data is justified.

Transcriptomic analysis reveals new regulatory roles of Clp signaling in secondary metabolite biosynthesis and surface motility in Lysobacter enzymogenes OH11

Lysobacter enzymogenes is a bacterial biological control agent emerging as a new source of antibiotic metabolites, such as heat-stable antifungal factor (HSAF) and the antibacterial factor WAP-8294A2. The regulatory mechanism(s) for antibiotic metabolite biosynthesis remains largely unknown in L. enzymogenes. Clp, a cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP)-receptor-like protein, is shown to function as a global regulator in modulating biocontrol-associated traits in L. enzymogenes. However, the genetic basis of Clp signaling remains unclear. Here, we utilized transcriptome/microarray analysis to determine the Clp regulon in L. enzymogenes. We showed that Clp is a global regulator in gene expression, as the transcription of 775 genes belonging to 19 functional groups was differentially controlled by Clp signaling. Analysis of the Clp regulon detected previously characterized Clp-modulated functions as well as novel loci. These include novel loci involved in antibiotic metabolite biosynthesis and surface motility in L. enzymogenes. We further showed experimentally that Clp signaling played a positive role in regulating the biosynthesis of HSAF and WAP-8294A2, as well as surface motility which is a type-IV-pilus-dependent trait. The regulation by Clp signaling of antibiotic (HSAF and WAP-8294A2) biosynthesis and surface motility was found to be independent. Importantly, we identified a factor Lysobacter acetyltransferase (Lat), a homologue of histone acetyltransferase Hpa2, which was regulated by Clp and involved in HSAF biosynthesis, but not associated with WAP-8294A2 production and surface motility. Overall, our study provided new insights into the regulatory role and molecular mechanism of Clp signaling in L. enzymogenes.

The Crp regulator of Pseudomonas putida: evidence of an unusually high affinity for its physiological effector, cAMP

Although the genome of Pseudomonas putida KT2440 encodes an orthologue of the crp gene of Escherichia coli (encoding the cAMP receptor protein), the regulatory scope of this factor seems to be predominantly co-opted in this bacterium for controlling non-metabolic functions. In order to investigate the reasons for such a functional divergence in otherwise nearly identical proteins, the Crp regulator of P. putida (Crp(P. putida)) was purified to apparent homogeneity and subject to a battery of in vitro assays aimed at determining its principal physicochemical properties. Analytical ultracentrifugation indicated effector-free Crp(P. putida) to be a dimer in solution that undergoes a significant change in its hydrodynamic shape in the presence of cAMP. Such a conformational transition was confirmed by limited proteolysis of the protein in the absence or presence of the inducer. Thermodynamic parameters calculated by isothermal titration calorimetry revealed a tight cAMP-Crp(P. putida) association with an apparent K(D) of 22.5 ± 2.8 nM, i.e. much greater affinity than that reported for the E. coli's counterpart. The regulator also bound cGMP, but with a K(D) = 2.6 ± 0.3 µM. An in vitro transcription system was then set up with purified P. putida's RNA polymerase for examining the preservation of the correct protein-protein architecture that makes Crp to activate target promoters. These results, along with cognate gel retardation assays indicated that all basic features of the reference Crp(E. coli) protein are kept in the P. putida's counterpart, albeit operating under a different set of parameters, the extraordinarily high affinity for cAMP being the most noticeable.

Roles of hinge region, loops 3 and 4 in the activation of Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein

The cAMP receptor protein (CRP) requires cAMP for an allosteric change and regulates more than 150 genes in Escherichia coli. In this study, the modular half of cAMP receptor protein was used to investigate the allosteric signal transmission pathway induced by cAMP binding. The activation of CRP upon cAMP binding is indicated to be realignment of the two subunits within the CRP dimer. The interaction of loop 3 and Phe136 do not involve in signal transmission.

Cyclic GMP controls Rhodospirillum centenum cyst development

Adenylyl cyclases are widely distributed across all kingdoms whereas guanylyl cyclases are generally thought to be restricted to eukaryotes. Here we report that the α-proteobacterium Rhodospirillum centenum secretes cGMP when developing cysts and that a guanylyl cyclase deletion strain fails to synthesize cGMP and is defective in cyst formation. The R. centenum cyclase was purified and shown to effectively synthesize cGMP from GTP in vitro, demonstrating that it is a functional guanylyl cyclase. A homologue of the Escherichia coli cAMP receptor protein (CRP) is linked to the guanylyl cyclase and when deleted is deficient in cyst development. Isothermal calorimetry (ITC) and differential scanning fluorimetry (DSF) analyses demonstrate that the recombinant CRP homologue preferentially binds to, and is stabilized by cGMP, but not cAMP. This study thus provides evidence that cGMP has a crucial role in regulating prokaryotic development. The involvement of cGMP in regulating bacterial development has broader implications as several plant-interacting bacteria contain a similar cyclase coupled by the observation that Azospirillum brasilense also synthesizes cGMP when inducing cysts.

Mycobacterium tuberculosis cAMP receptor protein (Rv3676) differs from the Escherichia coli paradigm in its cAMP binding and DNA binding properties and transcription activation properties

The pathogen Mycobacterium tuberculosis produces a burst of cAMP upon infection of macrophages. Bacterial cyclic AMP receptor proteins (CRP) are transcription factors that respond to cAMP by binding at target promoters when cAMP concentrations increase. Rv3676 (CRP(Mt)) is a CRP family protein that regulates expression of genes (rpfA and whiB1) that are potentially involved in M. tuberculosis persistence and/or emergence from the dormant state. Here, the CRP(Mt) homodimer is shown to bind two molecules of cAMP (one per protomer) at noninteracting sites. Furthermore, cAMP binding by CRP(Mt) was relatively weak, entropy driven, and resulted in a relatively small enhancement in DNA binding. Tandem CRP(Mt)-binding sites (CRP1 at -58.5 and CRP2 at -37.5) were identified at the whiB1 promoter (PwhiB1). In vitro transcription reactions showed that CRP1 is an activating site and that CRP2, which was only occupied in the presence of cAMP or at high CRP(Mt) concentrations in the absence of cAMP, is a repressing site. Binding of CRP(Mt) to CRP1 was not essential for open complex formation but was required for transcription activation. Thus, these data suggest that binding of CRP(Mt) to the PwhiB1 CRP1 site activates transcription at a step after open complex formation. In contrast, high cAMP concentrations allowed occupation of both CRP1 and CRP2 sites, resulting in inhibition of open complex formation. Thus, M. tuberculosis CRP has evolved several distinct characteristics, compared with the Escherichia coli CRP paradigm, to allow it to regulate gene expression against a background of high concentrations of cAMP.

Transcriptional effects of CRP* expression in Escherichia coli

Background

Escherichia coli exhibits diauxic growth in sugar mixtures due to CRP-mediated catabolite repression and inducer exclusion related to phosphotransferase system enzyme activity. Replacement of the native crp gene with a catabolite repression mutant (referred to as crp*) enables co-utilization of glucose and other sugars in E. coli. While previous studies have examined the effects of expressing CRP* mutants on the expression of specific catabolic genes, little is known about the global transcriptional effects of CRP* expression. In this study, we compare the transcriptome of E. coli W3110 (expressing wild-type CRP) to that of mutant strain PC05 (expressing CRP*) in the presence and absence of glucose.

Results

The glucose effect is significantly suppressed in strain PC05 relative to strain W3110. The expression levels of glucose-sensitive genes are generally not altered by glucose to the same extent in strain PCO5 as compared to W3110. Only 23 of the 80 genes showing significant differential expression in the presence of glucose for strain PC05 are present among the 418 genes believed to be directly regulated by CRP. Genes involved in central carbon metabolism (including several TCA cycle genes) and amino acid biosynthesis, as well as genes encoding nutrient transport systems are among those whose transcript levels are most significantly affected by CRP* expression.

We present a detailed transcription analysis and relate these results to phenotypic differences between strains expressing wild-type CRP and CRP*. Notably, CRP* expression in the presence of glucose results in an elevated intracellular NADPH concentration and reduced NADH concentration relative to wild-type CRP. Meanwhile, a more drastic decrease in the NADPH/NADP⁺ ratio is observed for the case of CRP* expression in strains engineered to reduce xylose to xylitol via a heterologously expressed, NADPH-dependent xylose reductase. Altered expression levels of transhydrogenase and TCA cycle genes, among others, are consistent with these observations.

Conclusion

While the simplest model of CRP*-mediated gene expression assumes insensitivity to glucose (or cAMP), our results show that gene expression in the context of CRP* is very different from that of wild-type in the absence of glucose, and is influenced by the presence of glucose. Most of the transcription changes in response to CRP* expression are difficult to interpret in terms of possible systematic effects on metabolism. Elevated NADPH availability resulting from CRP* expression suggests potential biocatalytic applications of crp* strains that extend beyond relief of catabolite repression.

Kinetic studies of cAMP-induced propagation of the allosteric signal in the cAMP receptor protein from Escherichia coli with the use of site-directed mutagenesis

The cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) - general transcription factor in Escherichia coli - changes their conformation after the cAMP binding. For CRP mutants bearing the amino acids substitutions in position 138 located within the hinge region, the fluorescence stopped-flow measurements have been employed to study the kinetics of the conformational changes. By using two naturally appearing Tryptophan residues (W13, W85) localized nearby the ligand binding pocket and 1,5-I-AEDANS-labeled C178 localized in the helix-turn-helix (HTH) motif within the C-terminal domain as a fluorescence probes, we observed a first and a consensus steps of CRP-cAMP association, respectively. The collected data suggest that the kinetic parameters determined for mutants, reflect a component of the conformational change occurring in the native protein. Therefore, the independent association of two cAMP molecules to the wt protein is followed by at least a three-step conformational change which alters the surroundings of HTH motifs.

Two-state allosteric modeling suggests protein equilibrium as an integral component for cyclic AMP (cAMP) specificity in the cAMP receptor protein of Escherichia coli

Activation of the cAMP receptor protein (CRP) from Escherichia coli is highly specific to its allosteric ligand, cAMP. Ligands such as adenosine and cGMP, which are structurally similar to cAMP, fail to activate wild-type CRP. However, several cAMP-independent CRP variants (termed CRP*) exist that can be further activated by both adenosine and cGMP, as well as by cAMP. This has remained a puzzle because the substitutions in many of these CRP* variants lie far from the cAMP-binding pocket (>10 A) and therefore should not directly affect that pocket. Here we show a surprising similarity in the altered ligand specificity of four CRP* variants with a single substitution in D53S, G141K, A144T, or L148K, and we propose a common basis for this phenomenon. The increased active protein population caused by an equilibrium shift in these variants is hypothesized to preferentially stabilize ligand binding. This explanation is completely consistent with the cAMP specificity in the activation of wild-type CRP. The model also predicts that wild-type CRP should be activated even by the lower-affinity ligand, adenosine, which we experimentally confirmed. The study demonstrates that protein equilibrium is an integral factor for ligand specificity in an allosteric protein, in addition to the direct effects of ligand pocket residues.

The role of loops 3 and 4 in the interdomains and intersubunits communication of E. coli cAMP receptor protein

Cyclic AMP serves as an intracellular messenger in cells and regulates a variety of biological functions by transmitting information through proteins. These proteins of different functions all consist of a cAMP-binding motif, and the structure of this motif is highly conserved with an exception of the loop 3 and 4. In current study, cAMP receptor protein was employed as a model system to investigate the function of the two loops. The results indicated that the loop 3 involves in the intersubunits communication of CRP, whereas the loop 4 involves in cAMP binding and interdomains communication.

A CE assay for the detection of agonist-stimulated adenylyl cyclase activity

A CE assay was developed for the detection of adenylyl cyclase (AC) activity stimulated at the AC and G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) level. In the assay, cell membranes overexpressing GPCR and/or AC were incubated with modulators and substrate ATP to produce cAMP in a dose-dependent manner. In both the CE-UV and a radiochemical assay, the addition of forskolin (FSK) resulted in a two- to three-fold maximum increase in AC activity with EC50s of 4.2 +/- 0.7 and 2.4 +/- 0.7 microM, respectively, demonstrating that similar results were obtained by both assays. GPCR activation was also detected using cell membranes overexpressing AC and the beta2-adrenergic receptor (beta2AR) fused to the stimulatory G protein. Terbutaline (beta2AR agonist) increased the basal rate of cAMP formation 1.7 +/- 0.1-fold resulting in an EC50 of 62 +/- 10 nM. The assay's ability to detect antagonists is demonstrated by the expected right-shifted EC50 of terbutaline by the beta2AR antagonist propranolol. The CE-UV assay offers advantages over the traditional radioactivity assay in terms of safety and labor.

Xanthomonas campestris cell-cell communication involves a putative nucleotide receptor protein Clp and a hierarchical signalling network

The bacterial pathogen Xanthomonas campestris pv. campestris co-ordinates virulence factor production and biofilm dispersal through a diffusible signal factor (DSF)-mediated cell-cell communication mechanism. The RpfC/RpfG two-component system plays a key role in DSF signal transduction and appears to modulate downstream DSF regulon by changing intracellular content of cyclic dimeric GMP (c-di-GMP), an unusual nucleotide second messenger. Here we show that Clp, a conserved global regulator showing a strong homology to the cAMP nucleotide receptor protein Crp of Escherichia coli, is essential for DSF regulation of virulence factor production but not for biofilm dispersal. Deletion of clp in Xcc changed the transcriptional expression of 299 genes including a few encoding transcription factors. Further genetic and microarray analysis led to identification of a homologue of the transcriptional regulator Zur, and a novel TetR-type transcription factor FhrR. These two regulatory factors regulated different sets of genes within Clp regulon. These results outline a hierarchical signalling network by which DSF modulates different biological functions, and may also provide a clue on how the novel nucleotide signal can be coupled to its downstream regulatory networks.

Studying multisite binary and ternary protein interactions by global analysis of isothermal titration calorimetry data in SEDPHAT: application to adaptor protein complexes in cell signaling

Multisite interactions and the formation of ternary or higher-order protein complexes are ubiquitous features of protein interactions. Cooperativity between different ligands is a hallmark for information transfer, and is frequently critical for the biological function. We describe a new computational platform for the global analysis of isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) data for the study of binary and ternary multisite interactions, implemented as part of the public domain multimethod analysis software SEDPHAT. The global analysis of titrations performed in different orientations was explored, and the potential for unraveling cooperativity parameters in multisite interactions was assessed in theory and experiment. To demonstrate the practical potential and limitations of global analyses of ITC titrations for the study of cooperative multiprotein interactions, we have examined the interactions of three proteins that are critical for signal transduction after T-cell activation, LAT, Grb2, and Sos1. We have shown previously that multivalent interactions between these three molecules promote the assembly of large multiprotein complexes important for T-cell receptor activation. By global analysis of the heats of binding observed in sets of ITC injections in different orientations, which allowed us to follow the formation of binary and ternary complexes, we observed negative and positive cooperativity that may be important to control the pathway of assembly and disassembly of adaptor protein particles.

Biomolecular interaction analysis in functional proteomics

To understand the function of highly complex eukaryotic tissues like the human brain, in depth knowledge about cellular protein networks is required. Biomolecular interaction analysis (BIA), as a part of functional proteomics, aims to quantify interaction patterns within a protein network in detail. We used the cAMP dependent protein kinase (PKA) as a model system for the binding analysis between small natural ligands, cAMP and cAMP analogues, with their physiological interaction partner, the regulatory subunit of PKA. BIA comprises a variety of methods based on physics, biochemistry and molecular biology. Here we compared side by side real time SPR (surface plasmon resonance, Biacore), a bead based assay (AlphaScreen), a fluorescence based method (Fluorescence polarisation) and ITC (isothermal titration calorimetry). These in vitro methods were complemented by an in cell reporter assay, BRET(2) (bioluminescence resonance energy transfer), allowing to test the effects of cAMP analogues in living cells.

Asymmetric allosteric activation of the symmetric ArgR hexamer

Hexameric arginine repressor, ArgR, bound to L-arginine serves both as the master transcriptional repressor/activator at diverse regulons in a wide range of bacteria and as a required cofactor for resolution of ColE1 plasmid multimers. Multifunctional ArgR is thus unusual in possessing features of specific gene regulators, global regulators, and non-specific gene organizers; its closest functional analog is probably CAP, the cyclic AMP receptor/activator protein. Isothermal titration calorimetry, surface plasmon resonance, and proteolysis indicate that binding of a single L-argine [corrected] per ArgR hexamer triggers a global conformation [corrected] change and resets the affinities of the remaining five sites, making them 100-fold weaker. The analysis suggests a novel thermodynamic signature for this mechanism of activation.

Interplay between site-specific mutations and cyclic nucleotides in modulating DNA recognition by Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein

Mutagenesis of various amino acids in Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) has been shown to modulate protein compressibility and dynamics [Gekko et al. (2004) Biochemistry 43, 3844-3852]. Cooperativity of cAMP binding to CRP and the apparent DNA binding affinity are perturbed [Lin and Lee (2002) Biochemistry 41, 11857-11867]. The aim of this study is to explore the effects of mutation on the surface chemistry of CRP and to define the consequences of these changes in affecting specific DNA sequence recognition by CRP. Furthermore, the role of the interplay between mutation and specific identity of the bound cyclic nucleotide in this DNA recognition was explored. In the current study, effects of eight site-specific mutations (K52N, D53H, S62F, T127L, G141Q, L148R, H159L, and K52N/H159L) on DNA recognition of four sequences (Class I (site PI of lac), Class II (site PI of gal), and synthetic sequences that are hybrids of Classes I and II sites) modulated by three different cyclic nucleotides (cAMP, cCMP, and cGMP) were investigated. All mutations altered the surface chemistry of CRP as evidenced by the change in elution properties of these proteins from different matrixes. While T127L, S62F, K52N, and H159L exhibited unexpected behavior under combinations of specific experimental conditions, such as the identity of bound cyclic nucleotide and DNA sequence, in general, results showed that the affinities of CRP for DNA were sequence-dependent, increasing in the order of lacgal26 < gal26 < lac26 < gallac26 for all the mutants in the presence of 200 microM cAMP. The apparent association constants significantly increased in the order of no cyclic nucleotide approximately cGMP < cCMP < cAMP for all the examined DNA sequences. Linear correlation between the DeltaG for CRP-DNA complex formation and the cooperativity energy for cAMP binding was observed with gallac26, gal26, and lacgal26; however, the slope of this linear correlation is DNA sequence dependent. Structural information was presented to rationalize the interplay between CRP sequence and cyclic nucleotides in defining the recognition of DNA sequences.

Two cAMP receptor proteins with different biochemical properties in the filamentous cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. PCC 7120

Two open reading frames (ORFs), alr0295 and alr2325, are found to encode putative cAMP receptor proteins (CRPs) in the genome of the filamentous cyanobacterium Anabaena sp. PCC 7120. These ORFs were named cAMP receptor protein-like gene A in Anabaena sp. PCC 7120 (ancrpA) and cAMP receptor protein-like gene B in Anabaena sp. PCC 7120 (ancrpB), respectively, and those translated products were investigated. The equilibrium dialysis measurements revealed that AnCrpA bound with cAMP specifically, while AnCrpB bound with both cAMP and cGMP, though the affinity for cGMP was weak. The binding affinity for cAMP of AnCrpA showed the lowest dissociation constant, approximately 0.8 microM, among bacterial CRPs. A gel mobility shift assay elucidated that AnCrpA and AnCrpB formed a complex with the consensus DNA sequence in the presence of cAMP, although AnCrpB did not have ordinary DNA-binding motifs.

Interaction of CRP L124 with cAMP affects CRP cAMP binding constants, cAMP binding cooperativity, and CRP allostery

A cyclic nucleotide-binding pocket of the CRP dimer is composed of amino acid residues contributed by both subunits. Leucine (L) 124 of one subunit packs against the adenine ring of cAMP bound to the opposing subunit. We have undertaken a study designed to evaluate the role of L124 in CRP allostery. Wild-type (WT) apo-CRP is a 47 kDa protease-resistant dimer composed of identical subunits that exhibits a biphasic isotherm in cAMP titration studies. The WT CRP-cAMP complex is a protease-sensitive dimer degraded by protease to a dimer core that ranges between 26.5 and 30.5 kDa. Substitution of L124 with isoleucine (I), valine (V), cysteine (C), or alanine (A) generated a series of CRP variants that exhibited unique differences in apo-CRP resistance to protease, the mass of the core fragments generated in protease digestion reactions, cAMP-mediated allostery, and CRP-cAMP complex functionality. Differences in the affinity of the position 124 CRP variants for cAMP were observed. The binding constants that drive the formation of the WT and L124I CRP-cAMP complexes deviated by not more than a factor of 1.5. In contrast, the L124V, L124A, and L124C forms of CRP exhibited both a decreased K(cAMP1)(app) and an increased K(cAMP2)(app) to produce 2.4-, 55-, and 204-fold reductions, respectively, in the difference between these two parameters compared to that observed for WT CRP. The data indicate that the van der Waals volume and/or the hyrophobicity of the L124 side chain are important determinants of CRP cAMP binding properties and affect, either directly or indirectly, cAMP-mediated conformation changes in CRP.

The citrate carrier CitS probed by single-molecule fluorescence spectroscopy

A prominent region of the Na(+)-dependent citrate carrier (CitS) from Klebsiella pneumoniae is the highly conserved loop X-XI, which contains a putative citrate binding site. To monitor potential conformational changes within this region by single-molecule fluorescence spectroscopy, the target cysteines C398 and C414 of the single-Cys mutants (CitS-sC398, CitS-sC414) were selectively labeled with the thiol-reactive fluorophores AlexaFluor 546/568 C(5) maleimide (AF(546), AF(568)). While both single-cysteine mutants were catalytically active citrate carriers, labeling with the fluorophore was only tolerated at C398. Upon citrate addition to the functional protein fluorophore conjugate CitS-sC398-AF(546), complete fluorescence quenching of the majority of molecules was observed, indicating a citrate-induced conformational change of the fluorophore-containing domain of CitS. This quenching was specific for the physiological substrate citrate and therefore most likely reflecting a conformational change in the citrate transport mechanism. Single-molecule studies with dual-labeled CitS-sC398-AF(546/568) and dual-color detection provided strong evidence for a homodimeric association of CitS.

Structure and dynamics of the modular halves of Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein

E. coli cyclic AMP receptor protein, CRP, is a modular protein that consists of a covalent linkage of two common structural domains. To probe the mechanism for intramolecular communications and to define the unique properties acquired by covalent linkage, the structural, and functional properties of the cAMP- and DNA-binding domains of CRP were studied separately as two independent polypeptides. The N-terminal cAMP-binding domain (alpha-CRP), including S-CRP and CH-CRP, which were generated by digestion of CRP by subtilisin and chymotrypsin, respectively, are mainly populated by beta-sheets. The C-terminal DNA-binding domain, designated as beta-CRP, consists of mostly alpha-helices. The residues of S-CRP and CH-CRP are from 1 to 116 and 1 to 136 of intact wild-type CRP, and those of beta-CRP are from 108 to 209. The secondary structures of alpha-CRP and beta-CRP were monitored by FT-IR, and they are similar to those of the corresponding parts in intact wild-type CRP. Results from hydrogen-deuterium exchange experiments indicated that beta-CRP is more dynamic than alpha-CRP. In an earlier study, it was shown that alpha-CRP retains the function of binding cAMP [Heyduk, E., et al. (1992) Biochemistry 31, 3682-3688]. beta-CRP was able to bind to DNA, although only weakly, and was not sequence specific. Thus, a covalent linkage between the two domains is essential for the realization of the intramolecular signal transmission between the domains triggered by ligand binding. The acquisition of this unique property is intimately associated with the dynamics of the molecule.

Communications between the high-affinity cyclic nucleotide binding sites in E. coli cyclic AMP receptor protein: effect of single site mutations

The binding of adenosine 3',5'-cyclic monophosphate (cAMP) and its nonfunctional analogue, guanosine 3',5'-cyclic monophosphate (cGMP), to the adenosine 3',5'-cyclic monophosphate receptor protein (CRP) from Escherichia coli was investigated by means of fluorescence and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) at pH 7.8 and 25 degrees C. A biphasic fluorescence titration curve was observed, confirming the previous observation reported by this laboratory (Heyduk and Lee (1989) Biochemistry 28, 6914-6924). However, the triphasic titration curve obtained from the ITC study suggests that the cAMP binding to CRP is more complicated than the previous conclusion that CRP binds sequentially two molecules of cAMP with negative cooperativity. The binding data can best be represented by a model for two identical interactive high-affinity sites and one low-affinity binding site. Unlike cAMP, the binding of cGMP to CRP exhibits no cooperativity between the high-affinity sites. The effects of mutations on the bindings of cAMP and cGMP to CRP were also investigated. The eight CRP mutants studied were K52N, D53H, S62F, T127L, G141Q, L148R, H159L, and K52N/H159L. These sites are located neither in the ligand binding site nor at the subunit interface. The binding was monitored by fluorescence. Although these mutations are at a variety of locations in CRP, the basic mechanism of CRP binding to cyclic nucleotides has not been affected. Two cyclic nucleotide molecules bind to the high-affinity sites of CRP. The cooperativity of cAMP binding is affected by mutation. It ranges from negative to positive cooperativity. The binding of cGMP shows none. With the exception of the T127L mutant, the free energy change for DNA-CRP complex formation increases linearly with increasing free energy change associated with the cooperativity of cAMP binding. This linear relationship implies that the protein molecule modulates the signal in the binding of cAMP, even though the mutation is not directly involved in cAMP or DNA binding. In addition, the significant differences in the amplitude of fluorescent signal indicate that the mutations also affect the surface characteristics of CRP. These results imply that these mutations are not perturbing specific pathways of signal transmission. Instead, these results are more consistent with the concept that CRP exists as an ensemble of native states, the distribution of which can be altered by these mutations.

Ligand-induced conformational and structural dynamics changes in Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein

Cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) regulates the expression of a large number of genes in E. coli. It is activated by cAMP binding, which leads to some yet undefined conformational changes. These changes do not involve significant redistribution of secondary structures. A potential mechanism of activation is a ligand-induced change in structural dynamics. Hence, the cAMP-mediated conformational and structural dynamics changes in the wild-type CRP were investigated using hydrogen-deuterium exchange and Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy. Upon cAMP binding, the two functional domains within the wild-type CRP undergo conformational and structural dynamics changes in two opposite directions. While the smaller DNA-binding domain becomes more flexible, the larger cAMP-binding domain shifts to a less dynamic conformation, evidenced by a faster and a slower amide H-D exchange, respectively. To a lesser extent, binding of cGMP, a nonfunctional analogue of cAMP, also stabilizes the cAMP-binding domain, but it fails to mimic the relaxation effect of cAMP on the DNA-binding domain. Despite changes in the conformation and structural dynamics, cAMP binding does not alter significantly the secondary structural composition of the wild-type CRP. The apparent difference between functional and nonfunctional analogues of cAMP is the ability of cAMP to effect an increase in the dynamic motions of the DNA binding domain.

Ability of E. coli cyclic AMP receptor protein to differentiate cyclic nucelotides: effects of single site mutations

Escherichia coli cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) is a global transcriptional regulator which controls the expression of many different genes. Although different cyclic nucleotides can bind to CRP with almost equal affinity, only in the presence of cAMP could wild-type CRP bind to specific DNA sequences. Molecular genetic studies have identified a class of mutants, CRP*, which either do not require exogenous cAMP for activation or can be activated by cGMP. Thus, these mutants might aid in identifying the structural elements that are involved in the modulation of CRP to correctly differentiate the messages embedded in cyclic nucleotides. In this in vitro study, five CRP* mutants, namely, D53H, S62F, G141Q, G141K, and L148R, were tested for their abilities to bind the lac promoter sequence and the effects of cyclic nucleotides in modulating DNA sequence recognition. For comparison, non-CRP* mutants K52N, T127L, H159L, and K52N/H159L were studied. cCMP and cGMP can replace cAMP as an allosteric effector in all of these CRP mutants except S62F and non-CRP* mutants. The D53H, G141Q, G141K, and L148R mutants exhibit significantly higher affinity for the lac promoter sequence than wild-type CRP while S62F and the non-CRP* mutants exhibit reduced affinity. To probe the pathway of communication, the energetics of subunit assembly in these mutants were monitored by sedimentation equilibrium, and the conformational states of these mutants were probed by proteolysis and accessibility of Cys178 to chemical modifications. Results from these studies imply that signals due to mutations are mostly transmitted through the subunit interface. Thus, residues in CRP outside of the cyclic nucleotide binding site modulate the ability of CRP to differentiate these three cyclic nucleotides through long-range communication. Furthermore, this study shows that CRP* mutations do not impart any unique properties to CRP except that the DNA binding constants are shifted to a regime of higher affinity.

CooA: a heme-containing regulatory protein that serves as a specific sensor of both carbon monoxide and redox state

CooA, the heme-containing carbon monoxide (CO) sensor from the bacterium Rhodospirillum rubrum, is a transcriptional factor that activates expression of certain genes in response to CO. As with other heme proteins, CooA is unable to bind CO when the Fe heme is oxidized, consistent with the fact that some of the regulated gene products are oxygen-labile. Upon reduction, there is an unusual switch of protein ligands to the six-coordinate heme and the reduced heme is able to bind CO. CO binding stabilizes a conformation of the dimeric protein that allows sequence-specific DNA binding, and transcription is activated through contacts between CooA and RNA polymerase. CooA is therefore a novel redox sensor as well as a specific CO sensor. CooA is a homolog of catabolite responsive protein (CRP), whose transcriptionally active conformation has been known for some time. The recent solution of the crystal structure of the CO-free (transcriptionally inactive) form of CooA has allowed insights into the mechanism by which both proteins respond to their specific small-molecule effectors.

Thermodynamics of peptide inhibitor binding to HIV-1 gp41

The gp41 subunit of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 envelope glycoprotein mediates fusion of the cellular and viral membranes. The gp41 ectodomain is a trimer of alpha-helical hairpins, where N-terminal helices form a parallel three-stranded coiled-coil core and C-terminal helices pack around the core. A deep hydrophobic pocket on the N-terminal core represents an attractive target for antiviral therapeutics. We have employed a soluble derivative of the gp41 core ectodomain and small cyclic disulfide D-peptide inhibitors to define the stoichiometry, affinity, and thermodynamics of ligand binding to this pocket using isothermal titration calorimetry. These inhibitors bind with micromolar affinity to the pocket with the expected stoichiometry of three peptides per gp41 core trimer. There are no cooperative interactions among the three binding sites. Linear eight- or nine-residue D-peptides derived from the pocket-binding domain of the cyclic molecules also bind specifically. A negative heat capacity change is observed and is consistent with burial of hydrophobic surface upon binding. Contrary to expectations for a reaction dominated by the classical hydrophobic effect, peptide binding is enthalpically driven and is opposed by an unfavorable negative entropy change. The calorimetry data support models whereby dominant negative inhibitors bind to a transiently exposed surface on the prefusion intermediate state of gp41 and disrupt subsequent resolution to the fusion-active six-stranded hairpin conformation.

Allosteric regulation of the cAMP receptor protein

The cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) of Escherichia coli is a dimer made up of identical subunits. Each CRP subunit contains a cyclic nucleotide binding pocket and the CRP dimer exhibits negative cooperativity in binding cAMP. In solutions containing cAMP, CRP undergoes sequential conformation changes from the inactive apo-form through the active CRP:(cAMP)(1) complex to the less active CRP:(cAMP)(2) complex depending on the cAMP concentration. Apo-CRP binds DNA with low affinity and no apparent sequence specificity. The CRP:(cAMP)(1) complex exhibits high affinity, sequence-specific DNA binding and interacts with RNA polymerase, whether free in solution or complexed with DNA. The results of genetic, biochemical and biophysical studies have helped to uncover many of the details of cAMP-mediated allosteric control over CRP conformation and activity as a transcription factor. These studies indicate that cAMP binding produces only small, but significant, changes in CRP structure; changes that include subunit realignment and concerted motion of the secondary structure elements within the C-terminal DNA binding domain of each subunit. These adjustments promote CRP surface-patch interaction with RNA polymerase and protrusion of the F-helix to promote CRP site-specific interaction with DNA. Interactions between CRP and RNA polymerase at CRP-dependent promoters produce active ternary transcription complexes.

The structure of the T127L/S128A mutant of cAMP receptor protein facilitates promoter site binding

The x-ray crystal structure of the cAMP-ligated T127L/S128A double mutant of cAMP receptor protein (CRP) was determined to a resolution of 2.2 A. Although this structure is close to that of the x-ray crystal structure of cAMP-ligated CRP with one subunit in the open form and one subunit in the closed form, a bound syn-cAMP is clearly observed in the closed subunit in a third binding site in the C-terminal domain. In addition, water-mediated interactions replace the hydrogen bonding interactions between the N(6) of anti-cAMP bound in the N-terminal domains of each subunit and the OH groups of the Thr(127) and Ser(128) residues in the C alpha-helix of wild type CRP. This replacement induces flexibility in the C alpha-helix at Ala(128), which swings the C-terminal domain of the open subunit more toward the N-terminal domain in the T127L/S128A double mutant of CRP (CRP*) than is observed in the open subunit of cAMP-ligated CRP. Isothermal titration calorimetry measurements on the binding of cAMP to CRP* show that the binding mechanism changes from an exothermic independent two-site binding mechanism at pH 7.0 to an endothermic interacting two-site mechanism at pH 5.2, similar to that observed for CRP at both pH levels. Differential scanning calorimetry measurements exhibit a broadening of the thermal denaturation transition of CRP* relative to that of CRP at pH 7.0 but similar to the multipeak transitions observed for cAMP-ligated CRP. These properties and the bound syn-cAMP ligand, which has only been previously observed in the DNA bound x-ray crystal structure of cAMP-ligated CRP by Passner and Steitz (Passner, J. M., and Steitz, T. A. (1997) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 94, 2843-2847), imply that the cAMP-ligated CRP* structure is closer to the conformation of the allosterically activated structure than cAMP-ligated CRP. This may be induced by the unique flexibility at Ala(128) and/or by the bound syn-cAMP in the hinge region of CRP*.

Modeling the cAMP-induced allosteric transition using the crystal structure of CAP-cAMP at 2.1 A resolution

After an allosteric transition produced by the binding of cyclic AMP (cAMP), the Escherichia coli catabolite gene activator protein (CAP) binds DNA specifically and activates transcription. The three-dimensional crystal structure of the CAP-cAMP complex has been refined at 2.1 A resolution, thus enabling a better evaluation of the structural basis for CAP phenotypes, the interactions of cAMP with CAP and the roles played by water structure. A review of mutational analysis of CAP together with the additional structural information presented here suggests a possible mechanism for the cAMP-induced allostery required for DNA binding and transcriptional activation. We hypothesize that cAMP binding may reorient the coiled-coil C-helices, which provide most of the dimer interface, thereby altering the relative positions of the DNA-binding domains of the CAP dimer. Additionally, cAMP binding may cause a further rearrangement of the DNA-binding and cAMP-binding domains of CAP via a flap consisting of beta-strands 4 and 5 which lies over the cAMP.

Structural understanding of the allosteric conformational change of cyclic AMP receptor protein by cyclic AMP binding

Cyclic AMP receptor protein (CRP) plays a key role in the regulation of more than 150 genes. CRP is allosterically activated by cyclic AMP and binds to specific DNA sites. A structural understanding of this allosteric conformational change, which is essential for its function, is still lacking because the structure of apo-CRP has not been solved. Therefore, we performed various NMR experiments to obtain apo-CRP structural data. The secondary structure of apo-CRP was determined by analyses of the NOE connectivities, the amide proton exchange rates, and the (1)H-(15)N steady-state NOE values. A combination of the CSI-method and TALOS prediction was also used to supplement the determination of the secondary structure of apo-CRP. This secondary structure of apo-CRP was compared with the known structure of cyclic AMP-bound CRP. The results suggest that the allosteric conformational change of CRP caused by cyclic AMP binding involves subunit realignment and domain rearrangement, resulting in the exposure of helix F onto the surface of the protein. Additionally, the results of the one-dimensional [(13)C]carbonyl NMR experiments show that the conformational change of CRP caused by the binding of cyclic GMP, an analogue of cyclic AMP, is different from that caused by cyclic AMP binding.

Intersubunit association induces unique allosteric dependence of the T127L CRP mutant on pH

The allosteric activation of the T127-->L mutant of 3',5'-cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) receptor protein (CRP) by cAMP changes from an exothermic, independent two-site binding mechanism at pH 7.0 to an endothermic, interacting two-site binding mechanism at pH 5.2, similar to that observed for CRP at pH 7.0 and 5.2. Since the T127-->L mutation at the subunit interface of the CRP dimer creates a more perfect leucine-zipper motif, it is believed to increase the intersubunit association and the stability of the CRP, as is observed by the higher thermal stability of the T127L mutant relative to that of CRP in differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) measurements. The DSC scans also exhibit a single thermal denaturation transition for CRP and a S128A mutant from pH 5.2 to 7. 0, while the broader transition peak of the T127L mutant becomes resolvable into two transitions below pH < or =5.2. Circular dichroism measurements on T127L and CRP at pH 7.0 and 5.2 show changes in the tertiary structure of both proteins with the exception of the tertiary structure around the two tryptophan residues in the amino-terminal domain. Although gel electrophoresis of the proteolysis (pH 5.2) products of T127L, CRP, and their cAMP- and cGMP-ligated complexes shows the subunit band and an amino-terminal domain fragment band, the fully allosterically activated complexes of T127L and CRP show the amino-terminal domain fragment band but not the subunit band. The results are interpreted in terms of the allosteric activation of CRP by cAMP by a conformational change from an "open" to a "closed" form of CRP, which involves changes in the tertiary structure of the carboxyl-terminal domains that are partially induced by an increase in the intersubunit association in T127L. While T127L retains its intersubunit association from pH 5.2 to 7.0, changes occur in the carboxyl-terminal domain so that the endothermic, allosteric activation mechanism of CRP by cAMP is restored in T127L at pH 5.2.

Position 127 amino acid substitutions affect the formation of CRP:cAMP:lacP complexes but not CRP:cAMP:RNA polymerase complexes at lacP

The lacP DNA binding and activation characteristics of CRP having amino acid substitutions at position 127 were investigated. Wild-type (WT) and T127C CRP footprinted lacP DNA in the presence of DNase I in a cAMP-dependent manner. The T127G, T127I, and T127S forms of CRP failed to footprint lacP both in the absence and in the presence of cAMP. Consistent with these data, WT and T127C CRP:cAMP complexes exhibited high affinity for the lacP CRP site whereas T127G, T127I, or T127S CRP:cAMP complexes exhibited low affinity for the lacP CRP site. CRP:cAMP:RNA polymerase (RNAP) complexes formed at lacP in reactions that contained WT, T127C, T127G, T127I, or T127S CRP. These results demonstrate that allosteric changes important for cAMP-mediated CRP activation are differentially affected by amino acid substitution at position 127. Proper cAMP-mediated reorientation of the DNA binding helices required either threonine or cysteine at position 127. However, cAMP-dependent interaction of CRP with RNAP was accomplished regardless of the amino acid at position 127. RNAP:lacP complexes that supported high-level lac RNA synthesis formed rapidly in reactions that contained WT or T127C CRP whereas RNAP:lacP complexes that supported only low-level lac RNA synthesis formed at slower rates in reactions that contained T127I or T127S CRP. The T127G CRP:cAMP:RNAP:lacP complex failed to activate lacP. The results of this study lead us to conclude that threonine 127 plays an important role in transduction of the signal from the CRP cyclic nucleotide binding pocket that promotes proper orientation of the DNA binding helices and only a minor, if any, role in the functional exposure of the CRP RNAP interaction domain.

Effect of mutations at the monomer-monomer interface of cAMP receptor protein on specific DNA binding

To determine the thermodynamic role of binding of an operon to cAMP receptor protein (CRP) in the activation of transcription, isothermal titration calorimetry measurements were performed on the binding of three 40-base pair DNA sequences to the cyclic nucleoside complexes of CRP and its mutants at 296 K. The three 40-base pair sequences consisted of a consensus DNA (conDNA) duplex derived from the CRP-binding site sequences of the operons activated by CRP and two DNA sequences based on the CRP-binding site sequences of the lac operon (lacDNA) and of the gal operon (galDNA). The mutants of CRP consisted of a T127L mutant, a S128A mutant, and a mutant containing both mutations (CRP*) which not only alter the transcriptional activity of the CRP complexes but also are involved in the monomer-monomer interfacial interactions of the CRP dimer. The binding reactions of the DNA duplexes to the fully cNMP-ligated CRP-mutant complexes were endothermic with binding constants as high as 6.6 +/- 1.1 x 10(6) M-1 (conDNA.CRP(cAMP)2). ConDNA binding to the unligated T127L and CRP* mutants was observed as well as conDNA and lacDNA binding to CRP with cAMP bound to only one monomer. The reduction of the binding constants with increase in KCl concentration indicated the formation of two ion pairs for the cAMP-ligated CRP and S128A complexes and four ion pairs for the cAMP-ligated T127L and CRP* complexes. Reduction of the DNA binding constants upon substitution of D2O for H2O in the buffer, the large heat capacity changes, and the enthalpy-entropy compensation exhibited by the binding reactions indicate the importance of dehydration in the binding reaction. Small angle neutron scattering measurements on the lacDNA.CRP(cAMP)2 complex in D2O/H2O mixtures show that the DNA is bent around the cAMP-ligated protein in solution.

Thermodynamics of nucleotide interactions with the Azotobacter vinelandii nitrogenase iron protein

The nitrogenase iron (Fe) protein binds two molecules of MgATP or MgADP, which results in protein conformational changes that are important for subsequent steps of the nitrogenase reaction mechanism. In the present work, isothermal titration calorimetry has been used to deconvolute the apparent binding constants (K'a1 and K'a2) and the thermodynamic terms (delta H' degree and delta S' degree) for each of the two binding events of MgATP or MgADP to either the reduced or oxidized states of the Fe protein from Azotobacter vinelandii. The Fe protein was found to bind two nucleotides with positive cooperativity and the oxidation state of the [4Fe-4S] cluster of the Fe protein was found to influence the affinity for binding nucleotides, with the oxidized ([4Fe-4S]2+) state having up to a 15-fold higher affinity for nucleotides when compared to the reduced ([4Fe-4S]1+) state. The first nucleotide binding reaction was found to be driven by a large favorable entropy change (delta S' degree = 10-21 cal mol-1 K-1), with a less favorable or unfavorable enthalpy change (delta H' degree = +1.5 to -3.3 kcal mol-1). In contrast, the second nucleotide binding reaction was found to be driven by a favorable change in enthalpy (delta H' degree = -3.1 to -13.0 kcal mol-1), with generally less favorable entropy changes. A plot of the associated enthalpy (-delta H' degree) and entropy terms (-T delta S' degree) for each nucleotide and protein binding reaction revealed a linear relationship with a slope of 1.12, consistent with strong enthalpy-entropy compensation. These results indicate that the binding of the first nucleotide to the nitrogenase Fe protein results in structural changes accompanied by the reorganization of bound water molecules, whereas the second nucleotide binding reaction appears to result in much smaller structural changes and is probably largely driven by bonding interactions. Evidence is presented that the total free energy change (delta G' degree) derived from the binding of two nucleotides to the Fe protein accounts for the total change in the midpoint potential of the [4Fe-4S] cluster.

Determination of the conformations of cAMP receptor protein and its T127L,S128A mutant with and without cAMP from small angle neutron scattering measurements

Small angle neutron scattering (SANS) measurements were performed on solutions of cAMP receptor protein (CRP) and on solutions of the T127L,S128A double mutant of CRP (CRP*) in D2O K3PO4 buffer containing 0.5 M KCl, in the absence and presence of 3',5' cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP). Energy-minimized structures of the CRP were calculated by minimization of the x-ray crystallographic structure of CRP in either the exclusively "closed" form where the alpha-helices of the carboxyl-terminal domain are folded close to the amino-terminal domain and in the exclusively "open" form where the alpha-helices of the carboxyl-terminal domain are folded away from the amino-terminal domain. Neutron scattering models show that the CRP SANS data follow closely the data curve predicted for unligated CRP in the open form, whereas the cAMP-ligated data are more in agreement with the data predicted for the minimized cAMP-ligated CRP structure in the closed form. Thus, it appears that CRP undergoes a conformational change from the open form to the closed form in solution upon ligation with cAMP. The SANS data from the CRP* and cAMP-ligated CRP* are coincidental, which implies that there is very little structural difference between the two species of CRP*. This is in agreement with in vivo results, which show that whereas CRP activates transcription in the cell only in the presence of cAMP, CRP* activates transcription in the absence of cAMP, implying that CRP* is already in the correct conformation for the activation of transcription.

The structure of a CAP-DNA complex having two cAMP molecules bound to each monomer

The 2.2 A resolution crystal structure of the Escherichia coli catabolite gene activator protein (CAP) complexed with cAMP and a 46-bp DNA fragment reveals a second cAMP molecule bound to each protein monomer. The second cAMP is in the syn conformation and is located on the DNA binding domain interacting with the helix-turn-helix, a beta-hairpin from the regulatory domain and the DNA (via water molecules). The presence of this second cAMP site resolves the apparent discrepancy between the NMR and x-ray data on the conformation of cAMP, and explains the cAMP concentration-dependent behaviors of the protein. In addition, this site's close proximity to mutations affecting transcriptional activation and its water-mediated interactions with a DNA recognition residue (E181) and DNA raise the possibility that this site has biological relevance.