Functional roles of individual recombinase monomers in strand breakage and strand union during site-specific DNA recombination

A Flp-SUMO hybrid recombinase reveals multi-layered copy number control of a selfish DNA element through post-translational modification

Mechanisms for highly efficient chromosome-associated equal segregation, and for maintenance of steady state copy number, are at the heart of the evolutionary success of the 2-micron plasmid as a stable multi-copy extra-chromosomal selfish DNA element present in the yeast nucleus. The Flp site-specific recombination system housed by the plasmid, which is central to plasmid copy number maintenance, is regulated at multiple levels. Transcription of the FLP gene is fine-tuned by the repressor function of the plasmid-coded partitioning proteins Rep1 and Rep2 and their antagonist Raf1, which is also plasmid-coded. In addition, the Flp protein is regulated by the host’s post-translational modification machinery. Utilizing a Flp-SUMO fusion protein, which functionally mimics naturally sumoylated Flp, we demonstrate that the modification signals ubiquitination of Flp, followed by its proteasome-mediated degradation. Furthermore, reduced binding affinity and cooperativity of the modified Flp decrease its association with the plasmid FRT (Flp recombination target) sites, and/or increase its dissociation from them. The resulting attenuation of strand cleavage and recombination events safeguards against runaway increase in plasmid copy number, which is deleterious to the host—and indirectly—to the plasmid. These results have broader relevance to potential mechanisms by which selfish genomes minimize fitness conflicts with host genomes by holding in check the extra genetic load they pose.

Plasmids of budding yeasts, exemplified by the 2-micron plasmid of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, and mammalian papilloma and gammaherpes viruses typify eukaryotic extra-chromosomal selfish DNA elements. The plasmid and the viral episomes, despite the long evolutionary divergence of their hosts, share striking similarities in lifestyles. These include the ability to segregate to daughter cells by hitchhiking on chromosomes and to switch from cell cycle regulated replication to iterative replication for copy number maintenance. While selfish elements, including those integrated into chromosomes, rely on their hosts’ genetic potential for long-term survival, their genetic load is carefully regulated to minimize fitness conflicts with the hosts. Our study focuses on the Flp site-specific recombinase, which is central to the copy number control of the 2-micron plasmid and whose steady state levels are regulated through transcriptional control by plasmid coded proteins and through post-translational modification by the host’s sumoylation machinery. We demonstrate that sumoylation, in addition, attenuates the catalytic activity of Flp by diminishing its DNA binding affinity and inter-monomer cooperativity, providing another layer of protection against runaway increase in plasmid copy number. Population control by self-imposed and host-mediated mechanisms is likely a general strategy among selfish elements to ensure nearly conflict-free coexistence with host genomes.

An Overview of Tyrosine Site-specific Recombination: From an Flp Perspective

Tyrosine site-specific recombinases (YRs) are widely distributed among prokaryotes and their viruses, and were thought to be confined to the budding yeast lineage among eukaryotes. However, YR-harboring retrotransposons (the DIRS and PAT families) and DNA transposons (Cryptons) have been identified in a variety of eukaryotes. The YRs utilize a common chemical mechanism, analogous to that of type IB topoisomerases, to bring about a plethora of genetic rearrangements with important physiological consequences in their respective biological contexts. A subset of the tyrosine recombinases has provided model systems for analyzing the chemical mechanisms and conformational features of the recombination reaction using chemical, biochemical, topological, structural, and single molecule-biophysical approaches. YRs with simple reaction requirements have been utilized to bring about programmed DNA rearrangements for addressing fundamental questions in developmental biology. They have also been employed to trace the topological features of DNA within high-order DNA interactions established by protein machines. The directed evolution of altered specificity YRs, combined with their spatially and temporally regulated expression, heralds their emergence as vital tools in genome engineering projects with wide-ranging biotechnological and medical applications.

The partitioning and copy number control systems of the selfish yeast plasmid: an optimized molecular design for stable persistence in host cells

The multi-copy 2 micron plasmid of Saccharomyces cerevisiae, a resident of the nucleus, is remarkable for its high chromosome-like stability. The plasmid does not appear to contribute to the fitness of the host, nor does it impose a significant metabolic burden on the host at its steady state copy number. The plasmid may be viewed as a highly optimized selfish DNA element whose genome design is devoted entirely towards efficient replication, equal segregation and copy number maintenance. A partitioning system comprised of two plasmid coded proteins, Rep1 and Rep2, and a partitioning locus STB is responsible for equal or nearly equal segregation of plasmid molecules to mother and daughter cells. Current evidence supports a model in which the Rep-STB system promotes the physical association of the plasmid with chromosomes and thus plasmid segregation by a hitchhiking mechanism. The Flp site-specific recombination system housed by the plasmid plays a critical role in maintaining steady state plasmid copy number. A decrease in plasmid population due to rare missegregation events is rectified by plasmid amplification via a recombination induced rolling circle replication mechanism. Appropriate plasmid amplification, without runaway increase in copy number, is ensured by positive and negative regulation of FLP gene expression by plasmid coded proteins and by the control of Flp level/activity through host mediated post-translational modification(s) of Flp. The Flp system has been successfully utilized to understand mechanisms of site-specific recombination, to bring about directed genetic alterations for addressing fundamental problems in biology, and as a tool in biotechnological applications.

Recombination of Hybrid Target Sites by Binary Combinations of Flp Variants: Mutations that Foster Interprotomer Collaboration and Enlarge Substrate Tolerance

Strategies of directed evolution and combinatorial mutagenesis applied to the Flp site-specific recombinase have yielded recombination systems that utilize bi-specific hybrid target sites. A hybrid site is assembled from two half-sites, each harboring a distinct binding specificity. Satisfying the two specificities by a binary combination of Flp variants, while necessary, may not be sufficient to elicit recombination. We have identified amino acid substitutions that foster interprotomer collaboration between partner Flp variants to potentiate strand exchange in hybrid sites. One such substitution, A35T, acts specifically in cis with one of the two partners of a variant pair, Flp(K82M) and Flp(A35T, R281V). The same A35T mutation is also present within a group of mutations that rescue a Flp variant, Flp(Y60S), that is defective in establishing monomer-monomer interactions on the native Flp target site. Strikingly, these mutations are localized to peptide regions involved in interdomain and interprotomer interactions within the recombination complex. The same group of mutations, when transferred to the context of wild-type Flp, can relax its specificity to include non-native target sites. The hybrid Flp systems described here mimic the naturally occurring XerC/XerD recombination system that utilizes two recombinases with distinct DNA binding specificities. The ability to overcome the constraints of binding site symmetry in Flp recombination has important implications in the targeted manipulations of genomes.

Stepwise manipulation of DNA specificity in Flp recombinase: progressively adapting Flp to individual and combinatorial mutations in its target site

The Flp protein from Saccharomyces cerevisiae is one of the site-specific tyrosine family recombinases that are used widely in genomic engineering. As a first step towards mediating directed DNA rearrangements at non-native Flp recombination targets (mFRTs), we have evolved three separate groups of Flp variants that preferentially act on mFRTs containing substitutions at the first, seventh or both positions of the Flp-binding elements. The variants that recombine the double-mutant mFRT contain a subset of the mutations present in those that are active on the single-mutant mFRTs, plus additional mutations. Specificity for and discrimination between target sites, effected primarily by amino acid residues that contact DNA, can be modulated by those that do not interact with DNA or with a DNA-contacting residue. The degree of modulation can range from relaxed DNA specificity to almost completely altered specificity. Our results suggest that combined DNA shuffling and mutagenesis of libraries of Flp variants active on distinct mFRTs can yield variants that can recombine mFRTs containing combinations of the individual mutations.

Symmetric DNA sites are functionally asymmetric within Flp and Cre site-specific DNA recombination synapses

Flp and Cre-mediated recombination on symmetrized FRT and loxP sites, respectively, in circular plasmid substrates yield both DNA inversion and deletion. However, upon sequestering three negative supercoils outside the recombination complex using the resII-resIII synapse formed by Tn3 resolvase and the LER synapse formed by phage Mu transposase in the case of Flp and Cre, respectively, the reactions are channeled towards inversion at the expense of deletion. The inversion product is a trefoil, its unique topology being conferred by the external resolvase or LER synapse. Thus, Flp and Cre assign their symmetrized substrates a strictly antiparallel orientation with respect to strand cleavage and exchange. These conclusions are supported by the product profiles from tethered parallel and antiparallel native FRT sites in dilution and competition assays. Furthermore, the observed recombination bias favoring deletion over inversion in a nicked circular substrate containing two symmetrized FRT sites is consistent with the predictions from Monte Carlo simulations based on antiparallel synapsis of the DNA partners.

Inhibition of Flp recombinase by the topoisomerase I-targeting drugs, camptothecin and NSC-314622

Recombinases of the lambda-Int family and type IB topoisomerases act by introducing transient single strand breaks in DNA using chemically identical reaction schemes. Recent structural data have supported the relationship between the two enzyme groups by revealing considerable similarities in the architecture of their catalytic pockets. In this study we show that the Int-type recombinase Flp is inhibited by the two structurally unrelated topoisomerase I-directed anti-cancer drugs, camptothecin (CPT) and NSC-314622. The interaction of these drugs with topoisomerase I is very specific with several single amino acid substitutions conferring drug resistance to the enzyme. Thus, the observed interaction of CPT and NSC-314622 with Flp, which is comparable to their interaction with the cleavage complex formed by topoisomerase I, strongly supports a close mechanistic and evolutionary relationship between the two enzymes. The results suggest that Flp and other Int family recombinases may provide model systems for dissecting the molecular mechanisms of topoisomerase I-directed anti-cancer therapeutic agents.

DNA recognition, strand selectivity, and cleavage mode during integrase family site-specific recombination

We have probed the association of Flp recombinase with its DNA target using protein footprinting assays. The results are consistent with the domain organization of the Flp protein and with the general features of the protein-DNA interactions revealed by the crystal structures of the recombination intermediates formed by Cre, the Flp-related recombinase. The similarity in the organization of the Flp and Cre target sites and in their recognition by the respective recombinases implies that the overall DNA-protein geometry during strand cleavage in the two systems must also be similar. Within the functional recombinase dimer, it is the interaction between two recombinase monomers bound on either side of the strand exchange region (or spacer) that provides the allosteric activation of a single active site. Whereas Cre utilizes the cleavage nucleophile (the active site tyrosine) in cis, Flp utilizes it in trans (one monomer donating the tyrosine to its partner). By using synthetic Cre and Flp DNA substrates that are geometrically restricted in similar ways, we have mapped the positioning of the active and inactive tyrosine residues during cis and trans cleavage events. We find that, for a fixed substrate geometry, Flp and Cre cleave the labile phosphodiester bond at the same spacer end, not at opposite ends. Our results provide a model that accommodates local heterogeneities in peptide orientations in the two systems while preserving the global functional architecture of the reaction complex.

Geometry of site alignment during int family recombination: antiparallel synapsis by the Flp recombinase

The Flp site-specific recombinase functions in the copy number amplification of the yeast 2 microm plasmid. The recombination reaction is catalyzed by four monomers of Flp bound to two separate, but identical, recombination sites (FRT sites) and occurs in two sequential pairs of strand exchanges. The relative orientation of the two recombination sites during synapsis was examined. Topoisomerase relaxation and nick ligation were used to detect topological nodes introduced by the synapse prior to the chemical steps of recombination. A single negative supercoil was found to be trapped by Flp in substrates with inverted FRT sites whereas no trapped supercoils were observed with direct repeats. The topology of products resulting from Flp-mediated recombination adjacent to a well characterised synapse, that of Tn3 resolvase/res, was analyzed. The deletion and inversion reactions yielded the four noded catenane and the three noded knot, respectively, as the simplest and the most abundant products. The linking number change introduced by the Flp-mediated inversion reaction was determined to be +/-2. The most parsimonious explanation of these results is that Flp aligns its recombination sites with antiparallel geometry. The majority of synapses appear to occur without entrapment of additional random plectonemic DNA supercoils between the sites and no additional crossings are introduced as a result of the chemical steps of recombination.

Resolution of tethered antiparallel and parallel holliday junctions by the Flp site-specific recombinase

Members of the integrase family site-specific recombinases (also called the tyrosine family) bring about recombination in two steps by exchanging pairs of single strands at a time. The product of the first exchange reaction is a four-way DNA junction, the Holliday intermediate. The conformational dynamics by which the recombination complex "isomerizes" from the Holliday-forming to the Holliday-resolving mode are not well understood. Experiments with the lambda Int and Escherichia coli XerC/XerD systems imply that the strand configurations at the branch point of the protein-free junction dictate the resolution mode in the protein-bound junction. We have examined the question of strand bias during resolution for the Flp system by using a series of synthetic Holliday junctions that are conformationally constrained by local sequences or by strand tethering. We have not observed a strong resolution bias in favor of the strands designed to assume the "crossed" configuration within the unbound junction. The resolution patterns with antiparallel junctions in a variety of substrate contexts reveal either parity in strand choice, or only modest disparity. On the other hand, the highly biased resolutions observed in the case of tethered parallel junctions can be explained by the non-equivalence in protein occupancy of the DNA arms of these substrates and/or inefficient conversion of cleavage events to recombinants at the tethered ends.

Wild-type Flp recombinase cleaves DNA in trans

Site-specific recombinases of the Integrase family utilize a common chemical mechanism to break DNA strands during recombination. A conserved Arg-His-Arg triad activates the scissile phosphodiester bond, and an active-site tyrosine provides the nucleophile to effect DNA cleavage. Is the tyrosine residue for the cleavage event derived from the same recombinase monomer which provides the RHR triad (DNA cleavage in cis), or are the triad and tyrosine derived from two separate monomers (cleavage in trans)? Do all members of the family follow the same cleavage rule, cis or trans? Solution studies and available structural data have provided conflicting answers. Experimental results with the Flp recombinase which strongly support trans cleavage have been derived either by pairing two catalytic mutants of Flp or by pairing wild-type Flp and a catalytic mutant. The inclusion of the mutant has raised new concerns, especially because of the apparent contradictions in their cleavage modes posed by other Int family members. Here we test the cleavage mode of Flp using an experimental design which excludes the use of the mutant protein, and show that the outcome is still only trans DNA cleavage.

Comparative kinetic analysis of FLP and cre recombinases: mathematical models for DNA binding and recombination

The integrase class site specific recombinases FLP from Saccharomyces cerevisiae, and Cre from bacteriophage P1, have been extensively used to direct DNA rearrangements in heterologous organisms. Although their reaction mechanisms have been relatively well characterised, little comparative analysis of the two enzymes has been published. We present a comparative kinetic analysis of FLP and Cre, which identifies important differences. Gel mobility shift assays show that Cre has a higher affinity for its target, loxP (7. 4x10(10) M-1), than FLP for its target, FRT (8.92x10(8) M-1). We show that both recombinases bind the two halves of their target sites cooperatively, and that Cre shows approximately threefold higher cooperativity than FLP. Using a mathematical model describing the sequential binding of recombinase monomers to DNA, we have determined values for the association and dissociation rate constants for FLP and Cre.FLP and Cre also showed different characteristics in in vitro recombination assays. In particular, approximately tenfold more active FLP was required than Cre to optimally recombine a given quantity of excision substrate. FLP was able to reach maximum excision levels approaching 100%, whilst Cre-mediated excision did not exceed 75%. To investigate possible reasons for these differences a mathematical model describing the excision recombination reaction was established. Using measured DNA binding parameters for FLP and Cre in the model, and comparing simulated and experimental recombination data, the values of the remaining unknown parameters were determined. This analysis indicates that the synaptic complex is more stable for Cre than for FLP.

Flp ribonuclease activities. Mechanistic similarities and contrasts to site-specific DNA recombination

The ribonuclease active site harbored by the Flp site-specific recombinase can act on two neighboring phosphodiester bonds to yield mechanistically distinct chain breakage reactions. One of the RNase reactions apparently proceeds via a covalent enzyme intermediate and targets the phosphodiester position involved in DNA recombination (Flp RNase I activity). The second activity (Flp RNase II) targets the phosphodiester immediately to the 3' side but appears not to involve an enzyme-linked intermediate. Flp RNase I is absolutely dependent upon Tyr-343 of Flp and is competitive with respect to the normal strand joining reaction. It can utilize the 2'-hydroxyl group from any one of the four ribonucleotides with comparable efficiencies in the cleavage reaction. On the other hand, the RNase II reaction mediated by Flp(Y343F) is specific for U and cannot utilize the 2'-hydroxyl group from ribo-A, -G, or -C under standard reaction conditions. The RNase II activity is also sensitive to the 3'-neighboring base. Although dT is functional, the activity is stimulated by U or U-2'-OMe. The Flp RNase II reaction effectively competes with the normal strand cleavage reaction mediated by Tyr-343, even though their phosphodiester targets are not the same.

Alcoholysis and strand joining by the Flp site-specific recombinase. Mechanistically equivalent reactions mediated by distinct catalytic configurations

The strand joining step of recombination mediated by the Flp site-specific recombinase involves the attack of a 3'-phosphotyrosyl bond by a 5'-hydroxyl group from DNA. The nucleophile in this reaction, the 5'-OH, can be substituted by glycerol or other polyhydric alcohols. The strand joining and glycerolysis reactions are mechanistically equivalent and are competitive to each other. The target diester in strand joining can be a 3'-phosphate covalently linked either to a short tyrosyl peptide or to the whole Flp protein via Tyr-343. By contrast, only the latter type of 3'-phosphotyrosyl linkage is a substrate for glycerolysis. As a result, in activated DNA substrates (containing the scissile phosphate linked to a short Flp peptide), Flp(Y343F) can mediate the joining reaction utilizing the 5'-hydroxyl attack but fails to promote glycerolysis. Wild type Flp promotes both reactions in these substrates. The strand joining and glycerolysis reactions are absolutely dependent on the catalytic histidine at position 305 of Flp. Our results fit into a model in which a Flp dimer, with one monomer covalently attached to the 3'-phosphate, is essential for orienting the target diester or the nucleophile (or both) during glycerolysis. The requirement for this dimeric complex is relaxed in the strand joining reaction because of the ability of DNA to orient the nucleophile (5'-OH) by complementary base pairing. The experimental outcomes described here have parallels to the "cleavage-dependent ligation" carried out by a catalytic variant of Flp, Flp(R308K) (Zhu, X.-D., and Sadowski, P. D. (1995) J. Biol. Chem. 270, 23044-23054).

Unveiling two distinct ribonuclease activities and a topoisomerase activity in a site-specific DNA recombinase

The site-specific DNA recombinase Flp shows two types of RNA cleavage activities on hybrid DNA-RNA substrates. One targets the phosphodiester position involved in DNA recombination and follows a related mechanistic path. In this two-step reaction, first-strand scission is mediated by a nucleophilic attack of the scissile phosphodiester bond by the active site tyrosine of Flp. The resultant 3'-O-phosphoryl tyrosine bond is then attacked by the adjacent 2'-hydroxyl group. The second activity targets the immediately adjacent phosphodiester bond to the 3' side using a distinct mechanism. In this reaction, the vicinal 2'-hydroxyl directly attacks the phosphate group in a manner that is reminiscent of the pancreatic RNase mechanism. The Flp protein can also be shown to possess a topoisomerase-like activity.

Asymmetry in Flp-mediated cleavage

Flp is a member of the integrase family of site-specific recombinases. Members of the integrase family mediate DNA strand cleavage via a transesterification reaction involving an active site tyrosine residue. The first step of the reaction results in covalent linkage of the protein to the 3'-phosphoryl DNA terminus, leaving a 5'-hydroxyl group at the site of the nick. We have used Flp recognition target (FRT) sites containing a 5'-bridging phosphorothioate linkage at the site of Flp cleavage to accumulate intermediates in which Flp is covalently bound at a cleavage site. We have probed these intermediates with dimethylsulfate using methylation protection and find that Flp-mediated cleavage is associated with protection of two adenine residues that are opposite the sites of cleavage and covalent attachment by Flp. Methylation interference studies showed that cleavage and covalent attachment are also accompanied by differences in the contacts of Flp with each of the two cleavage sites and with the surrounding symmetry elements. Therefore, we provide evidence that Flp-mediated cleavage and covalent attachment result in changes to the conformation of the Flp-FRT complex. These changes may be required for Flp-mediated strand exchange activity.

A tetramer of the Flp recombinase silences the trimers within it during resolution of a Holliday junction substrate

Recombination catalyzed by the Flp site-specific recombinase involves breakage and joining of four DNA strands between two target substrates. The reaction is carried out in two steps of pairwise strand exchanges by a DNA-protein assembly in which four Flp monomers act cooperatively to execute strand cleavage and joining. Two models for recombination have been proposed. In the trimer model, the two active sites required for each step are assembled from three Flp monomers. In the tetramer (or dimer of asymmetric dimers) model, the two active sites are assembled from four Flp monomers, two monomers each contributing one active site. Experiments in which the two models challenge each other reveal that, within the Flp tetramer arranged on a Holliday junction, the two active sites required for its resolution are derived from all four, rather than three, Flp monomers. Thus, the relative protein subunit configuration of the tetramer silences the trimers within it by excluding them from assembling a functional active site pair.

The yeast site-specific recombinase Flp mediates alcoholysis and hydrolysis of the strand cleavage product: mimicking the strand-joining reaction with non-DNA nucleophiles

The yeast site-specific recombinase Flp is covalently linked to DNA via a 3'-phosphotyrosyl bond during the strand-breakage step of recombination. We show that this phosphotyrosyl diester bond formed between Flp and DNA can serve as the target for alcoholysis or hydrolysis in an Flp-assisted reaction. Flp does not mediate alcoholysis of the labile phosphodiester bond within the DNA chain under our assay conditions. The body of available evidence supports the notion that the alcoholysis/hydrolysis reaction is mechanistically analogous to the strand-joining step of the recombination pathway. The only difference is that the DNA 5'-hydroxyl group that acts as the nucleophile during recombination is substituted by a non-DNA nucleophile. We find that the alcoholysis reaction occurs only within the normal cleavage complex produced by the "shared active site" assembled at the interface of two Flp monomers. Unlike the strand-joining reaction, alcoholysis does not occur on an activated DNA substrate linked at its 3'-phosphate end to a short tyrosyl peptide (not to the full-length Flp), and bound non-covalently by a Flp monomer. However, even in this substrate that mimics the strand-cleaved state, the joining reaction is competitively inhibited by a polyhydric alcohol such as glycerol.