Double hairpin complexes allow accommodation of all four base pairs in triple helices containing both DNA and RNA strands

In vitro selection of DNA aptamers against the HIV-1 TAR RNA hairpin

In vitro selection was performed to identify DNA aptamers against the TAR RNA stem-loop structure of HIV-1. A counterselection step allowed the elimination of kissing complex-forming aptamers previously selected (Boiziau et al. J. Biol. Chem. 1999; 274:12730). This led to the emergence of oligonucleotides, most of which contained two consensus sequences, one targeted to the stem 3'-strand (5'-CCCTAGTTA) and the other complementary to the TAR apical loop (5'-CTCCC). The best aptamer could be shortened to a 19-mer oligonucleotide, characterized by a dissociation constant of 50 nM. A 16-mer oligonucleotide complementary to the TAR stem 3'-strand could also be derived from the identified aptamers, with an equal affinity (Kd = 50 nM). Experiments performed to elucidate the interaction between TAR and the aptamers (UV melting measures, enzymatic and chemical footprints) demonstrated that the TAR stem 5'-strand was not simply displaced as a result of the complex formation but unexpectedly remained associated on contact with the antisense oligonucleotide. We suggest that a multistranded structure could be formed.

Modulation of RNA function by oligonucleotides recognizing RNA structure

Numerous RNA structures are responsible for regulatory processes either because they constitute a signal, like the hairpins or pseudoknots involved in ribosomal frameshifting, or because they are binding sites for proteins such as the trans-activating responsive RNA element of the human immunodeficiency virus whose binding to the viral protein Tat and cellular proteins allows full-length transcription of the retroviral genome. Selective ligands able to bind with high affinity to such RNA motifs may serve as tools for dissecting the molecular mechanisms in which they are involved. Such ligands might also constitute prototypes of therapeutic agents when RNA structures play a role in the expression of dysfunctional genes or in the multiplication of pathogens. Different classes of ligands (aminoglycosides, interacalating agents, peptides) are of interest to this aim. However, oligonucleotides deserve particular consideration. They have been extensively used in the frame of the antisense strategy. The apparent simplicity of this rational approach is, at first sight, very attractive. Indeed, numerous successful studies have been published describing the efficient inhibition of translation, splicing, or reverse transcription in cell-free systems, in cultured cells, or in vivo by oligomers complementary to an RNA region. However, RNA structures restrict the access of the target site to the antisense sequence: The competition between the intramolecular association of RNA regions weakens or even abolishes the antisense effect. Various possibilities have been developed to circumvent this limitation. This includes both rational and combinatorial strategies. High-affinity oligomers were designed to invade the RNA structure. Alternatively, triplex-forming oligonucleotides (TFO) and aptamers may recognize the folded RNA motif. Whereas the use of TFOs is rather limited owing to the strong sequence constraints for triple-helix formation, in vitro selection offers a way to explore vast oligoribo or oligodeoxyribo libraries to identify strong, selective oligonucleotide binders. The candidates (aptamers) selected against the TAR RNA element of HIV-1, which form stable loop-loop (kissing) complexes with the target, provide interesting examples of oligonucleotides recognizing a functional RNA structure through an important contribution of tertiary interactions.

RNA and N3'-->P5' kissing aptamers targeted to the trans-activation responsive (TAR) RNA of the human immunodeficiency virus-1

We used in vitro selection to identify RNA aptamers able to selectively bind to the TAR RNA motif of HIV-1, an unperfect RNA hairpin involved in the transcription of the retroviral genome. We selected aptameric RNA hairpins giving rise to kissing complexes with TAR. The N3'-->P5' phosphoramidate variant of the aptamer bind to TAR with a Kd in the low nanomolar range. However, only the RNA-RNA loop-loop complex is recognized by the Rop protein of E. coli which is specific for kissing complexes.

Energetics of strand-displacement reactions in triple helices: a spectroscopic study

DNA triple helices offer exciting new perspectives toward oligonucleotide-directed inhibition of gene expression. Purine and GT triplexes appear to be the most promising motifs for stable binding under physiological conditions compared to the pyrimidine motif, which forms at relatively low pH. There are, however, very little data available for comparison of the relative stabilities of the different classes of triplexes under identical conditions. We, therefore, designed a model system which allowed us to set up a competition between the oligonucleotides of the purine and pyrimidine motifs targeting the same Watson-Crick duplex. Several conclusions may be drawn: (i) a weak hypochromism at 260 nm is associated with purine triplex formation; (ii) delta H degree of GA, GT and TC triplex formation (at pH 7.0) was calculated as -0.1, -2.5 and -6.1 kcal/mol per base triplet, respectively. This unexpectedly low delta H degree for the purine triple helix formation implies that its delta G degree is nearly temperature-independent and it explains why these triplexes may still be observed at high temperatures. In contrast, the pyrimidine triplex is strongly favoured at lower temperatures; (iii) as a consequence, in a system where two third-strands compete for triplex formation, displacement of the GA or GT strand by a pyrimidine strand may be observed at neutral pH upon lowering the temperature. This original purine-to-pyrimidine triplex conversion shows a significant hypochromism at 260 nm and a hyperchromism at 295 nm which is similar to the duplex-to-triplex conversion in the pyrimidine motif. Further evidence for this triplex-to-triplex conversion is provided by mung bean-nuclease foot-printing assay.

Repairing the sickle cell mutation. I. Specific covalent binding of a photoreactive third strand to the mutated base pair

A DNA third strand with a 3'-psoralen substituent was designed to form a triplex with the sequence downstream of the T.A mutant base pair of the human sickle cell beta-globin gene. Triplex-mediated psoralen modification of the mutant T residue was sought as an approach to gene repair. The 24-nucleotide purine-rich target sequence switches from one strand to the other and has four pyrimidine interruptions. Therefore, a third strand sequence favorable to two triplex motifs was used, one parallel and the other antiparallel to it. To cope with the pyrimidine interruptions, which weaken third strand binding, 5-methylcytosine and 5-propynyluracil were used in the third strand. Further, a six residue "hook" complementary to an overhang of a linear duplex target was added to the 5'-end of the third strand via a T(4) linker. In binding to the overhang by Watson-Crick pairing, the hook facilitates triplex formation. This third strand also binds specifically to the target within a supercoiled plasmid. The psoralen moiety at the 3'-end of the third strand forms photoadducts to the targeted T with high efficiency. Such monoadducts are known to preferentially trigger reversion of the mutation by DNA repair enzymes.

Antisense effects of oligonucleotides complementary to the hairpin of the Leishmania mini-exon RNA

We investigated the binding and the translation inhibitory properties of hexadecamers complementary to the mini-exon sequence of the protozoan parasite Leishmania amazonensis. This targeted RNA region folds into a hairpin. Large differences were observed in the antisense properties of the different oligomers although their binding to RNA always requires the disruption of the stem region.

Recognition of hairpin-containing single-stranded DNA by oligonucleotides containing internal acridine derivatives

Oligodeoxynucleotides with an internal intercalating agent have been targeted to single-stranded sequences containing hairpin structures. The oligonucleotide binds to nonadjacent single-stranded sequences on both sides of the hairpin structure in such a way as to form a three-way junction. The acridine derivative is inserted at a position that allows it to interact with the three-way junction. The melting temperature (Tm) of complexes formed between the hairpin-containing target and oligonucleotides containing one internal acridine derivative was higher than that obtained with the same target and an unmodified oligonucleotide (DeltaTm = +13 degrees C). The internal acridine provided the oligonucleotide with a higher affinity than covalent attachment to the 5' end. Oligonucleotides could also be designed to recognize a hairpin-containing single-stranded nucleic acid by formation of Watson-Crick hydrogen bonds with a single-stranded part and Hoogsteen hydrogen bonds with the stem of the hairpin. An internal acridine derivative was introduced at the junction between the two domains, the double helix domain with Watson-Crick base pairs and the triple helix domain involving Hoogsteen base triplets in the major groove of the hairpin stem. Oligonucleotides with an internal acridine or an acridine at their 5' end have similar binding affinities for the stem-loop-containing target. The bis-modified oligonucleotide containing two acridines, one at the 5' end and one at an internal site, did not exhibit a higher affinity than the oligonucleotides with only one intercalating agent. The design of oligonucleotides with an internal intercalating agent might be of interest to control gene expression through recognition of secondary structures in single-stranded targets.

Antisense oligonucleotides containing modified bases inhibit in vitro translation of Leishmania amazonensis mRNAs by invading the mini-exon hairpin

Complementary oligodeoxynucleotides (ODNs) that contain 2-aminoadenine and 2-thiothymine interact weakly with each other but form stable hybrids with unmodified complements. These selectively binding complementary (SBC) agents can invade duplex DNA and hybridize to each strand (Kutyavin, I. V., Rhinehart, R. L., Lukhtanov, E. A., Gorn, V. V., Meyer, R. B., and Gamper, H. B. (1996) Biochemistry 35, 11170-11176). Antisense ODNs with similar properties should be less encumbered by RNA secondary structure. Here we show that SBC ODNs strand invade a hairpin in the mini-exon RNA of Leishmania amazonensis and that the resulting heteroduplexes are substrates for Escherichia coli RNase H. SBC ODNs either with phosphodiester or phosphorothioate backbones form more stable hybrids with RNA than normal base (NB) ODNs. Optimal binding was observed when the entire hairpin sequence was targeted. Translation of L. amazonensis mRNA in a cell-free extract was more efficiently inhibited by SBC ODNs complementary to the mini-exon hairpin than by the corresponding NB ODNs. Nonspecific protein binding in the cell-free extract by phosphorothioate SBC ODNs rendered them ineffective as antisense agents in vitro. SBC phosphorothioate ODNs displayed a modest but significant improvement of leishmanicidal properties compared with NB phosphorothioate ODNs.

Effect of cations on purine.purine.pyrimidine triple helix formation in mixed-valence salt solutions

The effect of various monovalent, divalent and oligovalent cations on the reaction of triplex formation by GT and AG motif triplex-forming oligonucleotides, designed to bind to biologically relevant polypurine-polypyrimidine sequences occurring in the promoters of the murine Ki-ras and human bcr genes, has been investigated by means of electrophoresis mobility shift assays (EMSA) and DNase I footprinting experiments. We found that in the presence of 10 mm MgCl2 the triple helices were progressively destabilized by adding increasing amounts of NaCl, from 20 to 140 mm, to the solution. We also observed that, while the total monovalent-ion concentration was constant at 100 mm, the exchange of sodium with potassium, but not lithium, results in a further destabilization of the triple helices, due to self-association equilibria involving the G-rich triplex-forming oligonucleotides. Potassium was found to destabilize triplex DNA even when the triple helices are preformed in the absence of K+. However, footprinting experiments also showed that the inhibitory effect of K+ on triplex DNA is partially compensated for by millimolar amounts of divalent transition metal ions such as Mn2+ and Ni2+, which upon coordinating to N7 of guanine are expected to enhance hydrogen-bond formation between the target and the third strand, and to reduce the assembly in quadruple structures of G-rich triplex-forming oligonucleotides. Triplex enhancement in the presence of potassium was also observed, but to a lesser extent, when spermine was added to the reaction mixture. Here, the ion effect on triplex DNA is rationalized in terms of competition among the different valence cations to bind to triplex DNA, and differential cation stabilization of unusual quadruplex structures formed by the triplex-forming oligonucleotides.

A fluorescent base analog for probing triple helix formation

Benzo[g]quinazoline-2,4-(1H,3H)-dione (BgQ), a fluorescent thymine analog, was incorporated into an oligopyrimidine (III) able to give rise to a triple-stranded structure by clamping a purine 11-mer (I). The formation of the I-III complex resulted in both a shift of the fluorescence emission maximum and a decreased fluorescence intensity. No such variations were observed on the formation of a Watson-Crick duplex between I and the complementary strand in which a T residue was substituted for BgQ. Therefore, the fluorescence emission of BgQ can be used to selectively monitor the formation of triple helices.

Benzoquinazoline derivatives as substitutes for thymine in nucleic acid complexes. Use of fluorescence emission of benzo[g]quinazoline-2,4-(1H,3H)-dione in probing duplex and triplex formation

Triple helix formation obeys structural features that do not allow accommodation of every double-stranded sequence; it requires the occurrence of homopurine stretches. A further constraint comes from the weak energy of interaction between the third strand and the double-stranded target. In an attempt to design bases leading to increased stability of triplexes, we explored the ability of modified bases with an extended aromatic domain to increase third strand binding through stacking interactions. We report here the use of benzo[g]- and benzo[f]quinazoline-2,4-dione-(1H,3H)-dione as substitutes for thymine in the canonical TAT triplet. The synthesis and characterization of the beta nucleoside derivatives of benzoquinazolines are described. Triplex-forming oligonucleotides containing these modified bases have been prepared, and their ability to form triplexes has been evaluated by UV absorption-monitored thermal denaturation measurements. Benzo[g]quinazoline and benzo[f]quinazoline formed triple-stranded structures with slightly decreased stabilities. In addition, benzo[g]quinazoline revealed strong fluorescence emission properties which can be used to monitor selectively the formation of triple-helical structures. Annealing of benzo[g]quinazoline to complementary strands did not produce any fluorescence modification. But when it was introduced into the Hoogsteen strand of PyPuPy complexes, the fluorescence intensity was reduced and the emission maximum was shifted to short wavelengths.

Therapeutic potential and mechanism of action of oligonucleotides and ribozymes

Specific inactivation of gene expression is an attractive approach for rational drug design to combat degenerative diseases and infectious agents. Oligonucleotide-directed triple-helix formation at cis-acting elements of gene promoters, short oligonucleotides containing base sequences that are complementary to the messenger RNA (antisense oligos), and RNA enzymes (ribozymes) that specifically cleave messenger RNA molecules are currently being used both as experimental tools and as therapeutic agents. Mechanisms of action of various oligonucleotide-based drugs, recent developments in the drug-delivery approaches, and future potentials are discussed in this review.

Identification of aptamers against the DNA template for in vitro transcription of the HIV-1 TAR element

We have extracted from a random population of about 10(9) oligodeoxynucleotides a series of 21-mers that are able to bind to a folded DNA 76-mer used as a template for in vitro transcription of the TAR element of the retrovirus HIV-1, by the T7 RNA polymerase. Five aptastrucs, that is, aptamers able to bind to the structure, out of 15 analyzed sequences, share the consensus motif 5'-PyGGG(TG)PyC, complementary in part to a weak double-stranded region of the target. (The parentheses indicate that either T or G is missing in one of these aptastrucs.) A dissociation constant of about 3 microM was evaluated by electrophoretic mobility shift assay for the winner sequence. Interactions between the aptastruc and the target sequences involve more than Watson-Crick base pairing of the consensus octamer. The binding is chemistry dependent. Phosphorothioate oligodeoxyribonucleotides and 2'-O-methyl oligoribonucleotides derived from the selected aptastrucs exhibit a weak if any affinity for the target.