Protection patterns of tRNAs do not change during ribosomal translocation

Ribosome structural dynamics in translocation: yet another functional role for ribosomal RNA

Ribosomes are remarkable ribonucleoprotein complexes that are responsible for protein synthesis in all forms of life. They polymerize polypeptide chains programmed by nucleotide sequences in messenger RNA in a mechanism mediated by transfer RNA. One of the most challenging problems in the ribosome field is to understand the mechanism of coupled translocation of mRNA and tRNA during the elongation phase of protein synthesis. In recent years, the results of structural, biophysical and biochemical studies have provided extensive evidence that translocation is based on the structural dynamics of the ribosome itself. Detailed structural analysis has shown that ribosome dynamics, like aminoacyl-tRNA selection and catalysis of peptide bond formation, is made possible by the properties of ribosomal RNA.

Bases in 16S rRNA important for subunit association, tRNA binding, and translocation

Ribosomes are the cellular machinery responsible for protein synthesis. A well-orchestrated step in the elongation cycle of protein synthesis is the precise translocation of the tRNA-mRNA complex within the ribosome. Here we report the application of a new in vitro modification-interference method for the identification of bases in 16S rRNA that are essential for translocation. Our results suggest that conserved bases U56, U723, A1306, A1319, and A1468 in 16S rRNA are important for translocation. These five bases were deleted or mutated so their role in translation could be studied. Depending on the type of mutation, we observed inhibition of growth rate, subunit association, tRNA binding, and/or translocation. Interestingly, deletion of U56 or A1319 or mutation of A1319 to C showed a lethal phenotype and were defective in protein synthesis in vitro. Further analysis showed that deletion of U56 or A1319 caused defects in 30S subunit assembly, subunit association, and tRNA binding. In contrast, the A1319C mutation showed no defects in subunit association; however, the extent of tRNA binding and translocation was significantly reduced. These results show that conserved bases located as far as 100 A from the tRNA binding sites can be important for translation.

Characterization of RNA-protein interactions by phosphorothioate footprinting and its applications to the ribosome

Analogs of naturally occurring substances obtained by chemical modifications are powerful tools to study intra- and intermolecular interactions. We have used the phosphorothioate technique to analyze RNA-protein interactions, here the interactions of transfer RNAs (tRNAs) with the three ribosomal binding sites. We describe preparation and purification of thioated tRNAs, formation of functional complexes of programmed ribosomes with tRNAs, and the evaluation of the observed phosphorothioate footprints on the tRNAs.

A conserved base-pair between tRNA and 23 S rRNA in the peptidyl transferase center is important for peptide release

The 3' terminus of tRNAs has the universally conserved bases C74C75A76 that interact with the ribosomal large subunit. In the ribosomal P site, bases C74 and C75 of tRNA, form Watson-Crick base-pairs with G2252 and G2251, respectively, present in the conserved P-loop of 23 S rRNA. Previous studies have suggested that the G2252-C74 base-pair is important for peptide bond formation. Using a pure population of mutant ribosomes, we analyzed the precise role of this base-pair in peptide bond formation, elongation factor G-dependent translocation, and peptide release by release factor 1. Surprisingly, our results show that the G2252-C74 base-pair is not essential for peptide bond formation with intact aminoacyl tRNAs as substrates and for EF-G catalyzed translocation. Interestingly, however, peptide release was reduced substantially when base-pair formation between G2252 and C74 of P site tRNA was disrupted, indicating that this conserved base-pair plays an important role in ester bond hydrolysis during translation termination.

Deletion of a Conserved, Central Ribosomal Intersubunit RNA Bridge

Elucidation of the structure of the ribosome has stimulated numerous proposals for the roles of specific rRNA elements, including the universally conserved helix 69 (H69) of 23S rRNA, which forms intersubunit bridge B2a and contacts the D stems of A- and P-site tRNAs. H69 has been proposed to be involved not only in subunit association and tRNA binding but also in initiation, translocation, translational accuracy, the peptidyl transferase reaction, and ribosome recycling. Consistent with such proposals, deletion of H69 confers a dominant lethal phenotype. Remarkably, in vitro assays show that affinity-purified Deltah69 ribosomes have normal translational accuracy, synthesize a full-length protein from a natural mRNA template, and support EF-G-dependent translocation at wild-type rates. However, Deltah69 50S subunits are unable to associate with 30S subunits in the absence of tRNA, are defective in RF1-catalyzed peptide release, and can be recycled in the absence of RRF.

Function of the ribosomal E-site: a mutagenesis study

Ribosomes synthesize proteins according to the information encoded in mRNA. During this process, both the incoming amino acid and the nascent peptide are bound to tRNA molecules. Three binding sites for tRNA in the ribosome are known: the A-site for aminoacyl-tRNA, the P-site for peptidyl-tRNA and the E-site for the deacylated tRNA leaving the ribosome. Here, we present a study of Escherichia coli ribosomes with the E-site binding destabilized by mutation C2394G of the 23S rRNA. Expression of the mutant 23S rRNA in vivo caused increased frameshifting and stop codon readthrough. The progression of these ribosomes through the ribosomal elongation cycle in vitro reveals ejection of deacylated tRNA during the translocation step or shortly after. E-site compromised ribosomes can undergo translocation, although in some cases it is less efficient and results in a frameshift. The mutation affects formation of the P/E hybrid site and leads to a loss of stimulation of the multiple turnover GTPase activity of EF-G by deacylated tRNA bound to the ribosome.

Non-bridging phosphate oxygen atoms within the tRNA anticodon stem-loop are essential for ribosomal A site binding and translocation

The conformation of the anticodon stem-loop of tRNAs required for correct decoding by the ribosome depends on intramolecular and intermolecular interactions that are independent of the tRNA nucleotide sequence. Non-bridging phosphate oxygen atoms have been shown to be critical for the structure and function of several RNAs. However, little is known about the role they play in ribosomal A site binding and translocation of tRNA to the P site. Here, we show that non-bridging phosphate oxygen atoms within the tRNA anticodon stem-loop at positions 33, 35, and 37 are important for A site binding. Those at positions 34 and 36 are not necessary for binding, but are essential for translocation. Our results correlate with structural data, indicating that position 34 interacts with the highly conserved 16S rRNA base G966 and position 36 interacts with the universally conserved tRNA base U33 during translocation to the P site.

Photolabile anticodon stem-loop analogs of tRNAPhe as probes of ribosomal structure and structural fluctuation at the decoding center

With the recent availability of high-resolution structures of bacterial ribosomes, studies of ribosome-catalyzed protein biosynthesis are now focusing on the nature of conformational changes that occur as the ribosome exerts its complex catalytic function. Photocrosslinking can be relevant for this purpose by providing clues to ribosomal structural fluctuations and dynamics. Here we describe crosslinking experiments on 70S ribosomes using two photolabile anticodon stem-loop derivatives of Escherichia coli tRNAPhe carrying a 4-thiouridine in either position 33 or 37 and denoted Ph-ASLs. One or both of these Ph-ASLs bind to the tRNA A-, P-, and E-sites on the ribosome, with both binding to and photocrosslinking from the E-site showing strong dependence on the presence of a tRNA in the P-site. Both Ph-ASLs crosslink to the extreme 3'-end of 16S rRNA from both the P- and E-sites, providing direct confirmatory evidence in solution for the folding back of the 3'-end toward the decoding region. This suggests that the 3'-end of 16S rRNA may act as a switch in controlling mRNA access to the decoding center, a phenomenon of potential relevance for the translation of leaderless mRNA. E-site bound Ph-ASLs also form photocrosslinks to nucleotides 1395-1398, 1399-1400, and 1491-1494 at the top of helix 44 of 16S rRNA, indicating movement of the decoding center from a position between the A- and P-sites seen in the crystal structure to one neighboring the E-site.

Conformational change in the 16S rRNA in the Escherichia coli 70S ribosome induced by P/P- and P/E-site tRNAPhe binding

The effects of P/P- and P/E-site tRNA(Phe) binding on the 16S rRNA structure in the Escherichia coli 70S ribosome were investigated using UV cross-linking. The identity and frequency of 16S rRNA intramolecular cross-links were determined in the presence of deacyl-tRNA(Phe) or N-acetyl-Phe-tRNA(Phe) using poly(U) or an mRNA analogue containing a single Phe codon. For N-acetyl-Phe-tRNA(Phe) with either poly(U) or the mRNA analogue, the frequency of an intramolecular cross-link C967 x C1400 in the 16S rRNA was decreased in proportion to the binding stoichiometry of the tRNA. A proportional effect was true also for deacyl-tRNA(Phe) with poly(U), but the decrease in the C967 x C1400 frequency was less than the tRNA binding stoichiometry with the mRNA analogue. The inhibition of the C967 x C1400 cross-link was similar in buffers with, or without, polyamines. The exclusive participation of C967 with C1400 in the cross-link was confirmed by RNA sequencing. One intermolecular cross-link, 16S rRNA (C1400) to tRNA(Phe)(U33), was made with either poly(U) or the mRNA analogue. These results indicate a limited structural change in the small subunit around C967 and C1400 during tRNA P-site binding sensitive to the type of mRNA that is used. The absence of the C967 x C1400 cross-link in 70S ribosome complexes with tRNA is consistent with the 30S and 70S crystal structures, which contain tRNA or tRNA analogues; the occurrence of the cross-link indicates an alternative arrangement in this region in empty ribosomes.

Domain movements of elongation factor eEF2 and the eukaryotic 80S ribosome facilitate tRNA translocation

An 11.7-A-resolution cryo-EM map of the yeast 80S.eEF2 complex in the presence of the antibiotic sordarin was interpreted in molecular terms, revealing large conformational changes within eEF2 and the 80S ribosome, including a rearrangement of the functionally important ribosomal intersubunit bridges. Sordarin positions domain III of eEF2 so that it can interact with the sarcin-ricin loop of 25S rRNA and protein rpS23 (S12p). This particular conformation explains the inhibitory action of sordarin and suggests that eEF2 is stalled on the 80S ribosome in a conformation that has similarities with the GTPase activation state. A ratchet-like subunit rearrangement (RSR) occurs in the 80S.eEF2.sordarin complex that, in contrast to Escherichia coli 70S ribosomes, is also present in vacant 80S ribosomes. A model is suggested, according to which the RSR is part of a mechanism for moving the tRNAs during the translocation reaction.

An elongation factor G-induced ribosome rearrangement precedes tRNA-mRNA translocation

The elongation cycle of protein synthesis is completed by translocation, a rearrangement during which two tRNAs bound to the mRNA move on the ribosome. The reaction is promoted by elongation factor G (EF-G) and accelerated by GTP hydrolysis. Here we report a pre-steady-state kinetic analysis of translocation. The kinetic model suggests that GTP hydrolysis drives a conformational rearrangement of the ribosome that precedes and limits the rates of tRNA-mRNA translocation and Pi release from EF-G.GDP.Pi. The latter two steps are intrinsically rapid and take place at random. These results indicate that the energy of GTP hydrolysis is utilized to promote the ribosome rearrangement and to bias spontaneous fluctuations within the ribosome-EF-G complex toward unidirectional movement of mRNA and tRNA.

Rapid kinetic analysis of EF-G-dependent mRNA translocation in the ribosome

Precise and coordinated movement of the tRNA-mRNA complex within the ribosome is a fundamental step during protein biosynthesis. The molecular mechanism for this process is still poorly understood. Here we describe a new sensitive method for monitoring elongation factor G-dependent translocation of the mRNA in the ribosome. In this method, the fluorescent probe pyrene is covalently attached to the 3' end of a short mRNA sequence at position +9. Translocation of the mRNA by one codon results in a significant decrease in the fluorescence emission of pyrene and can be used to directly monitor mRNA movement using rapid kinetic methods. Importantly, this method offers the flexibility of using any tRNA or tRNA analog in order to elucidate the molecular mechanism of translocation. Our results show that the mRNA is translocated at the same rate as the tRNAs, which is consistent with the view that the movement of the tRNAs and the mRNA are coupled in the ribosome. Furthermore, an anticodon stem-loop analog of tRNA is translocated from the ribosomal A site at a rate constant that is 350-fold lower than peptidyl tRNA, indicating that the D stem, T stem and acceptor stem of A site tRNA contribute significantly to the rate of translocation.

After the ribosome structure: how does translocation work?

Structures of the ribosomal large and small subunits have been solved to atomic resolution by X-ray crystallography. These structures provide a new foundation to address the complex process of protein biosynthesis by the ribosome. Translocation of the tRNA-mRNA complex is one of the most fascinating tasks performed by the ribosome. The impact of the crystal structures in understanding the molecular mechanism of translocation is highlighted in this review.

Ribosomal Tolerance and Peptide Bond Formation

In the ribosome, the decoding and peptide bond formation sites are composed entirely of ribosomal RNA, thus confirming that the ribosome is a ribozyme. Precise alignment of the aminoacylated and peptidyl tRNA 3'-ends, which is the major enzymatic contribution of the ribosome, is dominated by remote interactions of the tRNA double helical acceptor stem with the distant rims of the peptidyl transferase center. An elaborate architecture and a sizable symmetry-related region within the otherwise asymmetric ribosome guide the A --> P passage of the tRNA 3'-end by a spiral rotatory motion, and ensures its outcome: stereochemistry suitable for peptide bond formation and geometry facilitating the entrance of newly formed proteins into their exit tunnel.

Universally conserved interactions between the ribosome and the anticodon stem-loop of A site tRNA important for translocation

The iterative movement of the tRNA-mRNA complex through the ribosome is a hallmark of the elongation phase of protein synthesis. We used synthetic anticodon stem-loop analogs (ASL) of tRNA(Phe) to systematically identify ribose 2'-hydroxyl groups that are essential for binding and translocation from the ribosomal A site. Our results show that 2'-hydroxyl groups at positions 33, 35, and 36 in the A site ASL are important for translocation. Consistent with the view that the molecular basis of translocation may be similar in all organisms, the 2'-hydroxyl groups at positions 35 and 36 in the ASL interact with universally conserved bases G530 and A1493, respectively, in 16S rRNA. Furthermore, these interactions are also essential for the decoding process, indicating a functional relationship between decoding and translocation.

Evolutionary conservation of reactions in translation

Current X-ray diffraction and cryoelectron microscopic data of ribosomes of eubacteria have shed considerable light on the molecular mechanisms of translation. Structural studies of the protein factors that activate ribosomes also point to many common features in the primary sequence and tertiary structure of these proteins. The reconstitution of the complex apparatus of translation has also revealed new information important to the mechanisms. Surprisingly, the latter approach has uncovered a number of proteins whose sequence and/or structure and function are conserved in all cells, indicating that the mechanisms are indeed conserved. The possible mechanisms of a new initiation factor and two elongation factors are discussed in this context.

Codon-anticodon interaction at the P site is a prerequisite for tRNA interaction with the small ribosomal subunit

The arrival of high resolution crystal structures for the ribosomal subunits opens a new phase of molecular analysis and asks for corresponding analyses of ribosomal function. Here we apply the phosphorothioate technique to dissect tRNA interactions with the ribosome. We demonstrate that a tRNA bound to the P site of non-programmed 70 S ribosomes contacts predominantly the 50 S, as opposed to the 30 S subunit, indicating that codon-anticodon interaction at the P site is a prerequisite for 30 S binding. Protection patterns of tRNAs bound to isolated subunits and programmed 70 S ribosomes were compared. The results suggest the presence of a movable domain in the large ribosomal subunit that carries tRNA and reveal that only approximately 15% of a tRNA, namely residues 30 +/- 1 to 43 +/- 1, contact the 30 S subunit of programmed 70 S ribosomes, whereas the remaining 85% make contact with the 50 S subunit. Identical protection patterns of two distinct elongator tRNAs at the P site were identified as tRNA species-independent phosphate backbone contacts. The sites of protection correlate nicely with the predicted ribosomal-tRNA contacts deduced from a 5.5-A crystal structure of a programmed 70 S ribosome, thus refining which ribosomal components are critical for tRNA fixation at the P site.

Ribosome structure and the mechanism of translation

The publication of crystal structures of the 50S and 30S ribosomal subunits and the intact 70S ribosome is revolutionizing our understanding of protein synthesis. This review is an attempt to correlate the structures with biochemical and genetic data to identify the gaps and limits in our current knowledge of the mechanisms involved in translation.

Coupling of open reading frames by translational bypassing

Translational bypassing joins the information found within two disparate open reading frames into a single polypeptide chain. The underlying mechanism centers on the decoding properties of peptidyl-transfer RNA (tRNA) and involves three stages: take-off, scanning, and landing. In take-off, the peptidyl-tRNA/messenger RNA (mRNA) complex in the P site of the ribosome dissociates, and the mRNA begins to move through the ribosome. In scanning, the peptidyl-tRNA probes the mRNA sliding through the decoding center. In landing, the peptidyl-tRNA re-pairs with a codon with which it can form a stable interaction. Although few examples of genes are known that rely on translational bypassing to couple open reading frames, ribosomes appear to have an innate capacity for bypassing. This suggests that the strategy of translational bypassing may be more common than presently appreciated. The best characterized example of this phenomenon is T4 gene 60, in which a complex set of signals stimulates bypassing of 50 nucleotides between the two open reading frames. In this review, we focus on the bypassing mechanism of gene 60 in terms of take-off, scanning, and landing.

Movement of the decoding region of the 16 S ribosomal RNA accompanies tRNA translocation

The ribosome undergoes pronounced periodic conformational changes during protein synthesis. Of particular importance are those occurring around the decoding site, the region of the 16 S rRNA interacting with the mRNA-(tRNA)(2) complex. We have incorporated structural information from X-ray crystallography and nuclear magnetic resonance into cryo-electron microscopic maps of ribosomal complexes designed to capture structural changes at the translocation step of the polypeptide elongation cycle. The A-site region of the decoding site actively participates in the translocation of the tRNA from the A to the P-site upon GTP hydrolysis by elongation factor G, shifting approximately 8 A toward the P-site. This implies that elongation factor G actively pushes both the decoding site and the mRNA/tRNA complex during translocation.

Ribosomal protein L2 is involved in the association of the ribosomal subunits, tRNA binding to A and P sites and peptidyl transfer

Ribosomal proteins L2, L3 and L4, together with the 23S RNA, are the main candidates for catalyzing peptide bond formation on the 50S subunit. That L2 is evolutionarily highly conserved led us to perform a thorough functional analysis with reconstituted 50S particles either lacking L2 or harboring a mutated L2. L2 does not play a dominant role in the assembly of the 50S subunit or in the fixation of the 3'-ends of the tRNAs at the peptidyl-transferase center. However, it is absolutely required for the association of 30S and 50S subunits and is strongly involved in tRNA binding to both A and P sites, possibly at the elbow region of the tRNAs. Furthermore, while the conserved histidyl residue 229 is extremely important for peptidyl-transferase activity, it is apparently not involved in other measured functions. None of the other mutagenized amino acids (H14, D83, S177, D228, H231) showed this strong and exclusive participation in peptide bond formation. These results are used to examine critically the proposed direct involvement of His229 in catalysis of peptide synthesis.

Photoaffinity polyamines: interactions with AcPhe-tRNA free in solution or bound at the P-site of Escherichia coli ribosomes

Two photoreactive derivatives of spermine, azidobenzamidino (ABA)-spermine and azidonitrobenzoyl (ANB)-spermine, were used for mapping of polyamine binding sites in AcPhe-tRNA free in solution or bound at the P-site of Escherichia coli poly(U)-programmed ribosomes. Partial nuclease digestion indicated that the deep pocket formed by nucleosides of the D-stem and the variable loop, as well as the anticodon stem, are preferable polyamine binding sites for AcPhe-tRNA in the free state. ABA-spermine was a stronger cross-linker than ANB-spermine. Both photoprobes were linked to AcPhe-tRNA with higher affinity when the latter was non-enzymatically bound to poly(U)-programmed ribosomes. In particular, the cross-linking at the TpsiC stem and acceptor stem was substantially promoted. The photolabeled AcPhe-tRNA.poly(U).ribosome complex exhibited moderate reactivity towards puromycin. The attachment of photoprobes to AcPhe-tRNA was mainly responsible for this defect. A more complicated situation was revealed when the AcPhe-tRNA.poly(U).ribosome complex was formed in the presence of translation factors; the reactivity towards puromycin was stimulated by irradiating such a complex in the presence of photoprobes at 50 microM, with higher concentrations being inhibitory. The stimulatory effect was closely related with the binding of photoprobes to ribosomes. The results are discussed on the basis of possible AcPhe-tRNA conformational changes induced by the incorporation of photoprobes.

Visualization of tRNA movements on the Escherichia coli 70S ribosome during the elongation cycle

Three-dimensional cryomaps have been reconstructed for tRNA-ribosome complexes in pre- and posttranslocational states at 17-A resolution. The positions of tRNAs in the A and P sites in the pretranslocational complexes and in the P and E sites in the posttranslocational complexes have been determined. Of these, the P-site tRNA position is the same as seen earlier in the initiation-like fMet-tRNA(f)(Met)-ribosome complex, where it was visualized with high accuracy. Now, the positions of the A- and E-site tRNAs are determined with similar accuracy. The positions of the CCA end of the tRNAs at the A site are different before and after peptide bond formation. The relative positions of anticodons of P- and E-site tRNAs in the posttranslocational state are such that a codon-anticodon interaction at the E site appears feasible.

Sordarin inhibits fungal protein synthesis by blocking translocation differently to fusidic acid

Sordarin derivatives are selective inhibitors of fungal protein synthesis, which specifically impair elongation factor 2 (EF-2) function. We have studied the effect of sordarin on the ribosome-dependent GTPase activity of EF-2 from Candida albicans in the absence of any other component of the translation system. The effect of sordarin turned out to be dependent both on the ratio of ribosomes to EF-2 and on the nature of the ribosomes. When the amount of EF-2 exceeded that of ribosomes sordarin inhibited the GTPase activity following an inverted bell-shaped dose-response curve, whereas when EF-2 and ribosomes were in equimolar concentrations sordarin yielded a typical sigmoidal dose-dependent inhibition. However, when ricin-treated ribosomes were used, sordarin stimulated the hydrolysis of GTP. These results were compared with those obtained with fusidic acid, showing that both drugs act in a different manner. All these data are consistent with sordarin blocking the elongation cycle at the initial steps of translocation, prior to GTP hydrolysis. In agreement with this conclusion, sordarin prevented the formation of peptidyl-[(3)H]puromycin on polysomes from Candida albicans.

Structure and structural variations of the Escherichia coli 30 S ribosomal subunit as revealed by three-dimensional cryo-electron microscopy

A three-dimensional reconstruction of the 30 S subunit of the Escherichia coli ribosome was obtained at 23 A resolution. Because of the improved resolution, many more structural details are seen as compared to those obtained in earlier studies. Thus, the new structure is more suitable for comparison with the 30 S subunit part of the 70 S ribosome, whose structure is already known at a better resolution. In addition, we observe relative and, to some extent, independent movements of three main structural domains of the 30 S subunit, namely head, platform and the main body, which lead to partial blurring of the reconstructed volume. An attempt to subdivide the data set into conformationally defined subsets reveals the existence of conformers in which these domains have different orientations with respect to one another. This result suggests the existence of dynamic properties of the 30 S subunit that might be required for facilitating its interactions with mRNA, tRNA and other ligands during protein biosynthesis.