Regulation of photoreceptor phosphodiesterase (PDE6) by phosphorylation of its inhibitory gamma subunit re-evaluated

Photoreceptor phosphodiesterase (PDE6): activation and inactivation mechanisms during visual transduction in rods and cones

Rod and cone photoreceptors of the vertebrate retina utilize cGMP as the primary intracellular messenger for the visual signaling pathway that converts a light stimulus into an electrical response. cGMP metabolism in the signal-transducing photoreceptor outer segment reflects the balance of cGMP synthesis (catalyzed by guanylyl cyclase) and degradation (catalyzed by the photoreceptor phosphodiesterase, PDE6). Upon light stimulation, rapid activation of PDE6 by the heterotrimeric G-protein (transducin) triggers a dramatic drop in cGMP levels that lead to cell hyperpolarization. Following cessation of the light stimulus, the lifetime of activated PDE6 is also precisely regulated by additional processes. This review summarizes recent advances in the structural characterization of the rod and cone PDE6 catalytic and regulatory subunits in the context of previous biochemical studies of the enzymological properties and allosteric regulation of PDE6. Emphasis is given to recent advances in understanding the structural and conformational changes underlying the mechanism by which the activated transducin α-subunit binds to-and relieves inhibition of-PDE6 catalysis that is controlled by its intrinsically disordered, inhibitory γ-subunit. The role of the regulator of G-protein signaling 9-1 (RGS9-1) in regulating the lifetime of the transducin-PDE6 is also briefly covered. The therapeutic potential of pharmacological compounds acting as inhibitors or activators targeting PDE6 is discussed in the context of inherited retinal diseases resulting from mutations in rod and cone PDE6 genes as well as other inherited defects that arise from excessive cGMP accumulation in retinal photoreceptor cells.

cAMP controls rod photoreceptor sensitivity via multiple targets in the phototransduction cascade

In early studies, both cyclic AMP (cAMP) and cGMP were considered as potential secondary messengers regulating the conductivity of the vertebrate photoreceptor plasma membrane. Later discovery of the cGMP specificity of cyclic nucleotide–gated channels has shifted attention to cGMP as the only secondary messenger in the phototransduction cascade, and cAMP is not considered in modern schemes of phototransduction. Here, we report evidence that cAMP may also be involved in regulation of the phototransduction cascade. Using a suction pipette technique, we recorded light responses of isolated solitary rods from the frog retina in normal solution and in the medium containing 2 µM of adenylate cyclase activator forskolin. Under forskolin action, flash sensitivity rose more than twofold because of a retarded photoresponse turn-off. The same concentration of forskolin lead to a 2.5-fold increase in the rod outer segment cAMP, which is close to earlier reported natural day/night cAMP variations. Detailed analysis of cAMP action on the phototransduction cascade suggests that several targets are affected by cAMP increase: (a) basal dark phosphodiesterase (PDE) activity decreases; (b) at the same intensity of light background, steady background-induced PDE activity increases; (c) at light backgrounds, guanylate cyclase activity at a given fraction of open channels is reduced; and (d) the magnitude of the Ca²⁺ exchanger current rises 1.6-fold, which would correspond to a 1.6-fold elevation of [Ca²⁺]_in. Analysis by a complete model of rod phototransduction suggests that an increase of [Ca²⁺]_in might also explain effects (b) and (c). The mechanism(s) by which cAMP could regulate [Ca²⁺]_in and PDE basal activity is unclear. We suggest that these regulations may have adaptive significance and improve the performance of the visual system when it switches between day and night light conditions.

Structural characterization of the rod cGMP phosphodiesterase 6

Rod cGMP phosphodiesterase 6 (PDE6) is a key enzyme of the phototransduction cascade, consisting of PDE6alpha, PDE6beta, and two regulatory PDE6gamma subunits. PDE6 is membrane associated through isoprenyl membrane anchors attached to the C-termini of PDE6alpha and PDE6beta and can form a complex with prenyl-binding protein delta (PrBP/delta), an isoprenyl-binding protein that is highly expressed in photoreceptors. The stoichiometry of PDE6-PrBP/delta binding and the mechanism by which the PDE6-PrBP/delta complex assembles have not been fully characterized, and the location of regulatory PDE6gamma subunits within the protein assembly has not been elucidated. To clarify these questions, we have developed a rapid purification method for PDE6-PrBP/delta from bovine rod outer segments utilizing recombinant PrBP/delta. Transmission electron microscopy of negatively stained samples revealed the location of PrBP/delta and, thus, where the carboxyl-termini of PDE6alpha and PDE6beta must be located. The three-dimensional structure of the PDE6alphabetagamma complex was determined up to 18 A resolution from single-particle projections and was interpreted by model building to identify the probable location of isoprenylation, PDE6gamma subunits, and catalytic sites.

Light-dependent phosphorylation of the gamma subunit of cGMP-phophodiesterase (PDE6gamma) at residue threonine 22 in intact photoreceptor neurons

The gamma subunit of rod-specific cGMP phosphodiesterase 6 (PDE6gamma), an effector of the G-protein GNAT1, is a key regulator of phototransduction. The results of several in vitro biochemical reconstitution experiments conducted to examine the effects of phosphorylation of PDE6gamma on its ability to regulate the PDE6 catalytic core have been inconsistent, showing that phosphorylation of PDE6gamma may increase or decrease the ability of PDE6gamma to deactivate phototransduction. To resolve role of phosphorylation of PDE6gamma in living photoreceptors, we generated transgenic mice in which either one or both Threonine (T) sites in PDE6gamma (T22 and T35), which are candidates for putative regulatory phosphorylation, were substituted with alanine (A). Phosphorylation of these sites was examined as a function of light exposure. We found that phosphorylation of T22 increases with light exposure in intact mouse rods while constitutive phosphorylation of T35 is unaffected by light in intact mouse rods and cones. Phosphorylation of the cone isoform of PDE6gamma, PDE6H, is constitutively phosphorylated at the T20 residue. Light-induced T22 phosphorylation was lost in T35A transgenic rods, and T35 phosphorylation was extinguished in T22A transgenic rods. The interdependency of phosphorylation of T22 and T35 suggests that light-induced, post-translational modification of PDE6gamma is essential for the regulation of G-protein signaling.

The retinal cGMP phosphodiesterase gamma-subunit - a chameleon

Intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) represent an emerging class of proteins (or domains) that are characterized by a lack of ordered secondary and tertiary structure. This group of proteins has recently attracted tremendous interest primarily because of a unique feature: they can bind to different targets due to their structural plasticity, and thus fulfill diverse functions. The inhibitory gamma-subunit (PDEgamma) of retinal PDE6 is an intriguing IDP, of which unique protein properties are being uncovered. PDEgamma critically regulates the turn on as well as the turn off of visual signaling through alternate interactions with the PDE6 catalytic core, transducin, and the regulator of G protein signaling RGS9-1. The intrinsic disorder of PDEgamma does not compromise, but rather, optimizes its functionality. PDEgamma "curls up" when free in solution but "stretches out" when binding with the PDE6 catalytic core. Conformational changes of PDEgamma also likely occur in its C-terminal PDE6-binding region upon interacting with transducin during PDE6 activation. Growing evidence shows that PDEgamma is also a player in non-phototransduction pathways, suggesting additional protein targets. Thus, PDEgamma is highly likely to be adaptive in its structure and function, hence a "chameleon".

Retinal anatomy and visual performance in a diurnal cone-rich laboratory rodent, the Nile grass rat (Arvicanthis niloticus)

Unlike laboratory rats and mice, muridae of the Arvicanthis family (A. ansorgei and A. niloticus) are adapted to functioning best in daylight. To date, they have been used as experimental models mainly in studies of circadian rhythms. However, recent work aimed at optimizing photoreceptor-directed gene delivery vectors (Khani et al. [2007] Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 48:3954-3961) suggests their potential usefulness for studying retinal pathologies and therapies. In the present study we analyzed the retinal anatomy and visual performance of the Nile grass rat (A. niloticus) using immunohistofluorescence and the optokinetic response (OKR). We found that approximately 35-40% of photoreceptors are cones; that many neural features of the inner retina are similar to those in other diurnal mammals; and that spatial acuity, measured by the OKR, is more than two times that of the usual laboratory rodents. These observations are consistent with the known diurnal habits of this animal, and further support its pertinence as a complementary model for studies of structure, function, and pathology in cone-rich mammalian retinae.

Modulation of phosphodiesterase6 turnoff during background illumination in mouse rod photoreceptors

In rod photoreceptors of wild-type mice, background light produces an acceleration of the decay of responses to brief flashes, accompanied by a decrease in the rate-limiting time constant for response decay. In rods in which phosphodiesterase gamma (PDEgamma) lacks one of its sites of phosphorylation (T35A rods), both the waveform of response decay and the rate-limiting time constant are nearly unaffected by backgrounds. These effects are not the result of the removal of the phosphorylation site per se, because rods lacking both of the phosphorylation sites of PDEgamma (T22A/T35A rods) adapt to light in a nearly normal manner. Because PDEgamma is one of the proteins of the GTPase activating protein (GAP) complex, our experiments argue for a novel mechanism of photoreceptor light adaptation produced by modulation of GAP-dependent hydrolysis of transducin alpha GTP. In PDEgamma T35A rods, a change in the conformation of the PDEgamma subunit may hinder or mask this mechanism, which in mammals appears to be primarily responsible for the quickening of the temporal resolution of the rod response in backgrounds. Modulation of PDE turnoff also helps to prevent premature saturation of the rod in bright backgrounds, thus making an important contribution to light adaptation. Our experiments provide evidence for modulation of GAP protein-dependent response turnoff, which may also play a role in controlling signal duration at hormone receptors and synapses in the CNS.

Removal of phosphorylation sites of gamma subunit of phosphodiesterase 6 alters rod light response

The phosphodiesterase 6 gamma (PDE6 gamma) inhibitory subunit of the rod PDE6 effector enzyme plays a central role in the turning on and off of the visual transduction cascade, since binding of PDE6 gamma to the transducin alpha subunit (T alpha) initiates the hydrolysis of the second messenger cGMP, and PDE6 gamma in association with RGS9-1 and the other GAP complex proteins (G beta 5, R9AP) accelerates the conversion of T alpha GTP to T alpha GDP, the rate-limiting step in the decay of the rod light response. Several studies have shown that PDE6 gamma can be phosphorylated at two threonines, T22 and T35, and have proposed that phosphorylation plays some role in the physiology of the rod. We have examined this possibility by constructing mice in which T22 and/or T35 were replaced with alanines. Our results show that T35A rod responses rise and decay more slowly and are less sensitive to light than wild-type (WT). T22A responses show no significant difference in initial time course with WT but decay more rapidly, especially at dimmer intensities. When the T22A mutation is added to T35A, double mutant rods no longer showed the prolonged decay of T35A rods but remained slower than WT in initial time course. Our experiments suggest that the polycationic domain of PDE6 gamma containing these two phosphorylation sites can influence the rate of PDE6 activation and deactivation and raise the possibility that phosphorylation or dephosphorylation of PDE6 gamma could modify the time course of transduction, thereby influencing the wave form of the light response.

The Inhibitory γ Subunit of the Rod cGMP Phosphodiesterase Binds the Catalytic Subunits in an Extended Linear Structure

The unique feature of rod photoreceptor cGMP phosphodiesterase (PDE6) is the presence of inhibitory subunits (Pgamma), which interact with the catalytic heterodimer (Palphabeta) to regulate its activity. This uniqueness results in an extremely high sensitivity and sophisticated modulations of rod visual signaling where the Pgamma/Palphabeta interactions play a critical role. The quaternary organization of the alphabetagammagamma heterotetramer is poorly understood and contradictory patterns of interaction have been previously suggested. Here we provide evidence that supports a specific interaction, by systematically and differentially analyzing the Pgamma-binding regions on Palpha and Pbeta through photolabel transfer from various Pgamma positions throughout the entire molecule. The Pgamma N-terminal Val16-Phe30 region was found to interact with the Palphabeta GAFa domain, whereas its C terminus (Phe73-Ile87) interacted with the Palphabeta catalytic domain. The interactions of Pgamma with these two domains were bridged by its central Ser40-Phe50 region through interactions with GAFb and the linker between GAFb and the catalytic domain, indicating a linear and extended interaction between Pgamma and Palphabeta. Furthermore, a photocross-linked product alphabetagamma(gamma) was specifically generated by the double derivatized Pgamma, in which one photoprobe was located in the polycationic region and the other in the C terminus. Taken together the evidence supports the conclusion that each Pgamma molecule binds Palphabeta in an extended linear interaction and may even interact with both Palpha and Pbeta simultaneously.

Efficacy and selectivity of phosphodiesterase-targeted drugs in inhibiting photoreceptor phosphodiesterase (PDE6) in retinal photoreceptors

PURPOSE

Phosphodiesterase (PDE) inhibitors are important therapeutic agents, but their effects on photoreceptor PDE (PDE6) and photoreceptor cells are poorly understood. The potency and selectivity of various classes of PDE inhibitors on purified rod and cone PDE6 and on intact rod outer segments (ROS) were characterized.

METHODS

The inhibition constant (K(i)) of isozyme-selective PDE inhibitors was determined for purified rod and cone PDE6. Perturbations of cGMP levels in isolated ROS suspensions by PDE inhibitors were quantitated by a cGMP enzyme-linked immunoassay.

RESULTS

Most PDE5-selective inhibitors were excellent PDE6 inhibitors. Vardenafil, a potent PDE5 inhibitor (K(i) = 0.2 nM), was the most potent PDE6 inhibitor tested (K(i) = 0.7 nM). Zaprinast was the only drug that inhibited PDE6 more potently than did PDE5. PDE1-selective inhibitors were equally effective in inhibiting PDE6. In intact ROS, PDE inhibitors elevated cGMP levels, but none fully inhibited PDE6. Their potency for elevating cGMP levels in ROS was much lower than their ability to inhibit the purified enzyme. Competition between PDE5/6-selective drugs and the inhibitory gamma-subunit for the active site of PDE6 is proposed to reduce the effectiveness of drugs at the enzyme-active site.

CONCLUSIONS

Several classes of PDE inhibitors inhibit PDE6 equally as well as the PDE family to which they are targeted. In intact ROS, high PDE6 concentrations, binding of the gamma-subunit to the active site, and calcium feedback mechanisms attenuate the effectiveness of PDE inhibitors to inhibit PDE6 and disrupt the cGMP signaling pathway during visual transduction.

Asymmetric interaction between rod cyclic GMP phosphodiesterase gamma subunits and alphabeta subunits

Rod phosphodiesterase (PDE6) is the central effector enzyme in vertebrate visual transduction. Holo-PDE6 consists of two similar catalytic subunits (Palphabeta) and two identical inhibitory subunits (Pgamma). Palphabeta is the only heterodimer in the PDE superfamily, yet its significance for the function of PDE6 is poorly understood. An unequal interaction of Pgamma with Pbeta as compared with Palpha in the PDE6 complex has not been reported. We investigated the interaction interface between full-length Pgamma and Palphabeta, by differentiating Pgamma interaction with each individual Palphabeta subunit through radiolabel transfer from various positions throughout the entire Pgamma molecule. The efficiency of radiolabel transfer indicates that the close vicinity of serine 40 on Pgamma makes a major contribution to the interaction with Palphabeta. In addition, a striking asymmetry of interaction between the Pgamma polycationic region and the Palphabeta subunits was observed when the stoichiometry of Pgamma versus the Palphabeta dimer was below 2. Preferential photolabeling on Pbeta from Pgamma position 40 and on Palpha from position 30 increased while lowering the Pgamma/Palphabeta ratio, but diminished when the Pgamma/Palphabeta ratio was over 2. Our finding leads to the conclusion that two classes of Pgamma binding sites exist on Palphabeta, each composed of GAF domains in both Palpha and Pbeta, differing from the conventional models suggesting that each Pgamma binds only one of the Palphabeta catalytic subunits. This new model leads to insight into how the unique Palphabeta heterodimer contributes to the sophisticated regulation in visual transduction through interaction with Pgamma.

Characteristics of photoreceptor PDE (PDE6): similarities and differences to PDE5

Phosphodiesterase 6 (PDE6) is highly concentrated in the retina. It is most abundant in the internal membranes of retinal photoreceptors, where it reduces cytoplasmic levels of cyclic guanosine monophosphate (cGMP) in rod and cone outer segments in response to light. The rod PDE6 holoenzyme comprises alpha and beta catalytic subunits and two identical inhibitory gamma subunits. Each catalytic subunit contains three distinct globular domains corresponding to the catalytic domain and two GAF domains (responsible for allosteric cGMP binding). The PDE6 catalytic subunits resemble PDE5 in amino-acid sequence as well as in three-dimensional structure of the catalytic dimer; preference for cGMP over cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) as a substrate; and the ability to bind cGMP at the regulatory GAF domains. Most PDE5 inhibitors inhibit PDE6 with similar potency, and electroretinogram studies show modest effects of PDE5 inhibitors on visual function-an observation potentially important in designing PDE5-specific therapeutic agents.

The inhibitory gamma subunit of the type 6 retinal cGMP phosphodiesterase functions to link c-Src and G-protein-coupled receptor kinase 2 in a signaling unit that regulates p42/p44 mitogen-activated protein kinase by epidermal growth factor

The inhibitory gamma subunit of the retinal photoreceptor type 6 cGMP phosphodiesterase (PDEgamma) is phosphorylated by G-protein-coupled receptor kinase 2 on threonine 62 and regulates the epidermal growth factor- dependent stimulation of p42/p44 mitogen-activated protein kinase in human embryonic kidney 293 cells. We report here that PDEgamma is in a pre-formed complex with c-Src and that stimulation of cells with epidermal growth factor promotes the association of GRK2 with this complex. c-Src has a critical role in the stimulation of the p42/p44 mitogen-activated protein kinase cascade by epidermal growth factor, because c-Src inhibitors block the activation of this kinase by the growth factor. Mutation of Thr-62 (to Ala) in PDEgamma produced a GRK2 phosphorylation-resistant mutant that was less effective in associating with GRK2 in response to epidermal growth factor and did not potentiate the stimulation of p42/p44 mitogen-activated protein kinase by this growth factor. The transcript for a short splice variant version of PDEgamma lacking the Thr-62 phosphorylation site is also expressed in certain mammalian cells and, in common with the Thr-62 mutant, failed to potentiate the stimulatory effect of epidermal growth factor on p42/p44 mitogen-activated protein kinase. The mutation of Thr-22 (to Ala) in PDEgamma, which is a site for phosphorylation by p42/p44 mitogen-activated protein kinase, resulted in a prolonged activation of p42/p44 mitogen-activated protein kinase by epidermal growth factor, suggesting a role for this phosphorylation event in the negative feedback control of PDEgamma.

Binding of cGMP to GAF domains in amphibian rod photoreceptor cGMP phosphodiesterase (PDE). Identification of GAF domains in PDE alphabeta subunits and distinct domains in the PDE gamma subunit involved in stimulation of cGMP binding to GAF domains

Retinal cGMP phosphodiesterase (PDE6) is a key enzyme in vertebrate phototransduction. Rod PDE contains two homologous catalytic subunits (Palphabeta) and two identical regulatory subunits (Pgamma). Biochemical studies have shown that amphibian Palphabeta has high affinity, cGMP-specific, non-catalytic binding sites and that Pgamma stimulates cGMP binding to these sites. Here we show by molecular cloning that each catalytic subunit in amphibian PDE, as in its mammalian counterpart, contains two homologous tandem GAF domains in its N-terminal region. In Pgamma-depleted membrane-bound PDE (20-40% Pgamma still present), a single type of cGMP-binding site with a relatively low affinity (K(d) approximately 100 nm) was observed, and addition of Pgamma increased both the affinity for cGMP and the level of cGMP binding. We also show that mutations of amino acid residues in four different sites in Pgamma reduced its ability to stimulate cGMP binding. Among these, the site involved in Pgamma phosphorylation by Cdk5 (positions 20-23) had the largest effect on cGMP binding. However, except for the C terminus, these sites were not involved in Pgamma inhibition of the cGMP hydrolytic activity of Palphabeta. In addition, the Pgamma concentration required for 50% stimulation of cGMP binding was much greater than that required for 50% inhibition of cGMP hydrolysis. These results suggest that the Palphabeta heterodimer contains two spatially and functionally distinct types of Pgamma-binding sites: one for inhibition of cGMP hydrolytic activity and the second for activation of cGMP binding to GAF domains. We propose a model for the Palphabeta-Pgamma interaction in which Pgamma, by binding to one of the two sites in Palphabeta, may preferentially act either as an inhibitor of catalytic activity or as an activator of cGMP binding to GAF domains in frog PDE.