The interactions of cyanobacterial cytochrome c6 and cytochrome f, characterized by NMR

Phylogenetic and functional analysis of cyanobacterial Cytochrome c6-like proteins

All known photosynthetic cyanobacteria carry a cytochrome c 6 protein that acts transferring electrons from cytochrome b 6 f complex to photosystem I, in photosynthesis, or cytochrome c oxidase, in respiration. In most of the cyanobacteria, at least one homologue to cytochrome c 6 is found, the so-called cytochrome c 6B or cytochrome c 6C. However, the function of these cytochrome c 6-like proteins is still unknown. Recently, it has been proposed a common origin of these proteins as well as the reclassification of the cytochrome c 6C group as c 6B, renaming the new joint group as cytochrome c 6BC. Another homologue to cytochrome c 6 has not been classified yet, the formerly called cytochrome c 6-3, which is present in the heterocyst-forming filamentous cyanobacteria Nostoc sp. PCC 7119. In this work, we propose the inclusion of this group as an independent group in the genealogy of cytochrome c 6-like proteins with significant differences from cytochrome c 6 and cytochrome c 6BC, with the proposed name cytochrome c 6D. To support this proposal, new data about phylogeny, genome localisation and functional properties of cytochrome c 6-like proteins is provided. Also, we have analysed the interaction of cytochrome c 6-like proteins with cytochrome f by isothermal titration calorimetry and by molecular docking, concluding that c 6-like proteins could interact with cytochrome b 6 f complex in a similar fashion as cytochrome c 6. Finally, we have analysed the reactivity of cytochrome c 6-like proteins with membranes enriched in terminal oxidases of cyanobacteria by oxygen uptake experiments, concluding that cytochrome c 6D is able to react with the specific copper-oxidase of the heterocysts, the cytochrome c oxidase 2.

NMR studies of the interaction between inner membrane-associated and periplasmic cytochromes from Geobacter sulfurreducens

Geobacter sulfurreducens is a dissimilatory metal-reducing bacterium with notable properties and significance in biotechnological applications. Biochemical studies suggest that the inner membrane-associated diheme cytochrome MacA and the periplasmic triheme cytochrome PpcA from G. sulfurreducens can exchange electrons. In this work, NMR chemical shift perturbation measurements were used to map the interface region and to measure the binding affinity between PpcA and MacA. The results show that MacA binds to PpcA in a cleft defined by hemes I and IV, favoring the contact between PpcA heme IV and the MacA high-potential heme. The dissociation constant values indicate the formation of a low-affinity complex between the proteins, which is consistent with the transient interaction observed in electron transfer complexes.

Cyt c6-3: A New Isoform of Photosynthetic Cyt c6 Exclusive to Heterocyst-Forming Cyanobacteria

All known cyanobacteria contain Cyt c6, a small soluble electron carrier protein whose main function is to transfer electrons from the Cyt b6f complex to PSI, although it is also involved in respiration. We have previously described a second isoform of this protein, the Cyt c6-like, whose function remains unknown. Here we describe a third isoform of Cyt c6 (here called Cytc6-3), which is only found in heterocyst-forming filamentous cyanobacteria. Cyt c6-3 is expressed in vegetative cells but is specifically repressed in heterocysts cells under diazotrophic growth conditions. Although there is a close structural similarity between Cyt c6-3 and Cyt c6 related to the general protein folding, Cyt c6-3 presents differential electrostatic surface features as compared with Cyt c6, its expression is not copper dependent and has a low reactivity towards PSI. According to the different expression pattern, functional reactivity and structural properties, Cyt c6-3 has to play an as yet to be defined regulatory role related to heterocyst differentiation.

Insights into the role of substrates on the interaction between cytochrome b5 and cytochrome P450 2B4 by NMR

Mammalian cytochrome b5 (cyt b5) is a membrane-bound protein capable of donating an electron to cytochrome P450 (P450) in the P450 catalytic cycle. The interaction between cyt b5 and P450 has been reported to be affected by the substrates of P450; however, the mechanism of substrate modulation on the cyt b5-P450 complex formation is still unknown. In this study, the complexes between full-length rabbit cyt b5 and full-length substrate-free/substrate-bound cytochrome P450 2B4 (CYP2B4) are investigated using NMR techniques. Our findings reveal that the population of complexes is ionic strength dependent, implying the importance of electrostatic interactions in the complex formation process. The observation that the cyt b5-substrate-bound CYP2B4 complex shows a weaker dependence on ionic strength than the cyt b5-substrate-free CYP2B4 complex suggests the presence of a larger fraction of steoreospecific complexes when CYP2B4 is substrate-bound. These results suggest that a CYP2B4 substrate likely promotes specific interactions between cyt b5 and CYP2B4. Residues D65, V66, T70, D71 and A72 are found to be involved in specific interactions between the two proteins due to their weak response to ionic strength change. These findings provide insights into the mechanism underlying substrate modulation on the cyt b5-P450 complexation process.

Respiratory complexes III and IV can each bind two molecules of cytochrome c at low ionic strength

The transient interactions of respiratory cytochrome c with complexes III and IV is herein investigated by using heterologous proteins, namely human cytochrome c, the soluble domain of plant cytochrome c1 and bovine cytochrome c oxidase. The binding molecular mechanisms of the resulting cross-complexes have been analyzed by Nuclear Magnetic Resonance and Isothermal Titration Calorimetry. Our data reveal that the two cytochrome c-involving adducts possess a 2:1 stoichiometry - that is, two cytochrome c molecules per adduct - at low ionic strength. We conclude that such extra binding sites at the surfaces of complexes III and IV can facilitate the turnover and sliding of cytochrome c molecules and, therefore, the electron transfer within respiratory supercomplexes.

Crystal structure of the electron carrier domain of the reaction center cytochrome c(z) subunit from green photosynthetic bacterium Chlorobium tepidum

In green sulfur photosynthetic bacteria, the cytochrome c(z) (cyt c(z)) subunit in the reaction center complex mediates electron transfer mainly from menaquinol/cytochrome c oxidoreductase to the special pair (P840) of the reaction center. The cyt c(z) subunit consists of an N-terminal transmembrane domain and a C-terminal soluble domain that binds a single heme group. The periplasmic soluble domain has been proposed to be highly mobile and to fluctuate between oxidoreductase and P840 during photosynthetic electron transfer. We have determined the crystal structure of the oxidized form of the C-terminal functional domain of the cyt c(z) subunit (C-cyt c(z)) from thermophilic green sulfur bacterium Chlorobium tepidum at 1.3-A resolution. The overall fold of C-cyt c(z) consists of four alpha-helices and is similar to that of class I cytochrome c proteins despite the low similarity in their amino acid sequences. The N-terminal structure of C-cyt c(z) supports the swinging mechanism previously proposed in relation with electron transfer, and the surface properties provide useful information on possible interaction sites with its electron transfer partners. Several characteristic features are observed for the heme environment: These include orientation of the axial ligands with respect to the heme plane, surface-exposed area of the heme, positions of water molecules, and hydrogen-bond network involving heme propionate groups. These structural features are essential for elucidating the mechanism for regulating the redox state of cyt c(z).

NMR study of the electron transfer complex of plant ferredoxin and sulfite reductase: mapping the interaction sites of ferredoxin

Plant ferredoxin serves as the physiological electron donor for sulfite reductase, which catalyzes the reduction of sulfite to sulfide. Ferredoxin and sulfite reductase form an electrostatically stabilized 1:1 complex for the intermolecular electron transfer. The protein-protein interaction between these proteins from maize leaves was analyzed by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Chemical shift perturbation and cross-saturation experiments successfully mapped the location of two major interaction sites of ferredoxin: region 1 including Glu-29, Glu-30, and Asp-34 and region 2 including Glu-92, Glu-93, and Glu-94. The importance of these two acidic patches for interaction with sulfite reductase was confirmed by site-specific mutation of acidic ferredoxin residues in regions 1 and 2, separately and in combination, by which the ability of mutant ferredoxins to transfer electrons and bind to sulfite reductase was additively lowered. Taken together, this study gives a clear illustration of the molecular interaction between ferredoxin and sulfite reductase. We also present data showing that this interaction surface of ferredoxin significantly differs from that when ferredoxin-NADP(+) reductase is the interaction partner.

Sulphate respiration from hydrogen in Desulfovibrio bacteria: a structural biology overview

Sulphate-reducing organisms are widespread in anaerobic enviroments, including the gastrointestinal tract of man and other animals. The study of these bacteria has attracted much attention over the years, due also to the fact that they can have important implications in industry (in biocorrosion and souring of oil and gas deposits), health (in inflamatory bowel diseases) and the environment (bioremediation). The characterization of the various components of the electron transport chain associated with the hydrogen metabolism in Desulfovibrio has generated a large and comprehensive list of studies. This review summarizes the more relevant aspects of the current information available on the structural data of various molecules associated with hydrogen metabolism, namely hydrogenases and cytochromes. The transmembrane redox complexes known to date are also described and discussed. Redox-Bohr and cooperativity effects, observed in a few cytochromes, and believed to be important for their functional role, are discussed. Kinetic studies performed with these redox proteins, showing clues to their functional inter-relationship, are also addressed. These provide the groundwork for the application of a variety of molecular modelling approaches to understanding electron transfer and protein interactions among redox partners, leading to the characterization of several transient periplasmic complexes. In contrast to the detailed understanding of the periplasmic hydrogen oxidation process, very little is known about the cytoplasmic side of the respiratory electron transfer chain, in terms of molecular components (with exception of the terminal reductases), their structure and the protein-protein interactions involved in sulphate reduction. Therefore, a thorough understanding of the sulphate respiratory chain in Desulfovibrio remains a challenging task.

Role of the surface charges D72 and K8 in the function and structural stability of the cytochrome c6 from Nostoc sp. PCC 7119

We investigated the role of electrostatic charges at positions D72 and K8 in the function and structural stability of cytochrome c6 from Nostoc sp. PCC 7119 (cyt c6). A series of mutant forms was generated to span the possible combinations of charge neutralization (by mutation to alanine) and charge inversion (by mutation to lysine and aspartate, respectively) in these positions. All forms of cyt c6 were functionally characterized by laser flash absorption spectroscopy, and their stability was probed by urea-induced folding equilibrium relaxation experiments and differential scanning calorimetry. Neutralization or inversion of the positive charge at position K8 reduced the efficiency of electron transfer to photosystem I. This effect could not be reversed by compensating for the change in global charge that had been introduced by the mutation, indicating a specific role for K8 in the formation of the electron transfer complex between cyt c6 and photosystem I. Replacement of D72 by asparagine or lysine increased the efficiency of electron transfer to photosystem I, but destabilized the protein. D72 apparently participates in electrostatic interactions that stabilize the structure of cyt c6. The destabilizing effect was reduced when aspartate was replaced by the small amino acid alanine. Complementing the mutation D72A with a charge neutralization or inversion at position K8 led to mutant forms of cyt c6 that were more stable than the wild-type under all tested conditions.

An NMR-based docking model for the physiological transient complex between cytochromefand cytochromec6

The physiological transient complex between cytochrome f (Cf) and cytochrome c(6) (Cc(6)) from the cyanobacterium Nostoc sp. PCC 7119 has been analysed by NMR spectroscopy. The binding constant at low ionic strength is 8 +/- 2 mM(-1), and the binding site of Cc(6) for Cf is localized around its exposed haem edge. On the basis of the experimental data, the resulting docking simulations suggest that Cc(6) binds to Cf in a fashion that is analogous to that of plastocyanin but differs between prokaryotes and eukaryotes.

NMR Analysis of the Transient Complex between Membrane Photosystem I and Soluble Cytochrome c6

A structural analysis of the surface areas of cytochrome c(6), responsible for the transient interaction with photosystem I, was performed by NMR transverse relaxation-optimized spectroscopy. The hemeprotein was titrated by adding increasing amounts of the chlorophyllic photosystem, and the NMR spectra of the free and bound protein were analyzed in a comparative way. The NMR signals of cytochrome c(6) residues located at the hydrophobic and electrostatic patches, which both surround the heme cleft, were specifically modified by binding. The backbones of internal residues close to the hydrophobic patch of cytochrome c(6) were also affected, a fact that is ascribed to the conformational changes taking place inside the hemeprotein when interacting with photosystem I. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first structural analysis by NMR spectroscopy of a transient complex between soluble and membrane proteins.

Binding Mechanism of Nonspecific Lipid Transfer Proteins and Their Role in Plant Defense

Plant nonspecific lipid transfer proteins (nsLTPs) are small basic proteins that transport phospholipids between membranes. On the basis of molecular mass, nsLTPs are subdivided into nsLTP1 and nsLTP2. NsLTPs are all helical proteins stabilized by four conserved disulfide bonds. The existence of an internal hydrophobic cavity, running through the molecule, is a typical characteristic of nsLTPs that serves as the binding site for lipid-like substrates. NsLTPs are known to participate in plant defense, but the exact mechanism of their antimicrobial action against fungi or bacteria is still unclear. To trigger plant defense responses, a receptor at the plant surface needs to recognize the complex of a fungal protein (elicitin) and ergosterol. NsLTPs share high structural similarities with elicitin and need to be associated with a hydrophobic ligand to stimulate a defense response. In this study, binding of sterol molecules with rice nsLTPs is analyzed using various biophysical methods. NsLTP2 can accommodate a planar sterol molecule, but nsLTP1 binds only linear lipid molecules. Although the hydrophobic cavity of rice nsLTP2 is smaller than that of rice nsLTP1, it is flexible enough to accommodate the voluminous sterol molecule. The dissociation constant for the nsLTP2/cholesterol complex is approximately 71.21 microM as measured by H/D exchange and mass spectroscopic detection. Schematic models of the nsLTP complex structure give interesting clues about the reason for differential binding modes. Comparisons of NMR spectra of the sterol/rice nsLTP2 complex and free nsLTP2 revealed the residues involved in binding.

Transient complexes of redox proteins: structural and dynamic details from NMR studies

Redox proteins participate in many metabolic routes, in particular those related to energy conversion. Protein-protein complexes of redox proteins are characterized by a weak affinity and a short lifetime. Two-dimensional NMR spectroscopy has been applied to many redox protein complexes, providing a wealth of information about the process of complex formation, the nature of the interface and the dynamic properties of the complex. These studies have shown that some complexes are non-specific and exist as a dynamic ensemble of orientations while in other complexes the proteins assume a single orientation. The binding interface in these complexes consists of a small hydrophobic patch for specificity, surrounded by polar, uncharged residues that may enhance dissociation, and, in most complexes, a ring or patch of charged residues that enhances the association by electrostatic interactions. The entry and exit port of the electrons is located within the hydrophobic interaction site, ensuring rapid electron transfer from one redox centre to the next.

The parsley plastocyanin-turnip cytochrome f complex: a structurally distorted but kinetically functional acidic patch

In general, inter-protein electron transfer proceeds via the formation of transient complexes. The initial stage of the interaction between plastocyanin (PCu) and cytochrome f (cyt f ) from plants is mediated by complementary electrostatics. Given the diffuse nature of its acidic patch, parsley PCu is an atypical example of a plant PCu. The interaction of this PCu with turnip cyt f was investigated by stopped-flow kinetics, NMR spectroscopy and protein-docking simulations. We show that, despite the altered acidic patch, parsley PCu is as efficient as spinach PCu in accepting electrons from cyt f, over the physiological range of ionic strength. At high ionic strength, the rate constant for the reaction of cyt f with parsley PCu is twice that of the spinach protein. This difference in reactivity is attributed to variations in the hydrophobic patch of parsley PCu. The results of NMR studies and protein-docking simulations indicate that parsley PCu and its spinach analogue adopt different orientations in their complexes with cyt f.

Mapping of the Binding Site on Pseudoazurin in the Transient 152 kDa Complex with Nitrite Reductase

Nitrite reductase (NiR) catalyzes the reduction of nitrite to nitrite oxide as a part of the denitrification process. In Alcaligenes faecalis S-6, the copper protein pseudoazurin acts as electron donor to NiR. The binding surface of pseudoazurin involved in the formation of the 152 kDa complex with NiR has been determined by NMR using cross saturation from NiR to perdeuterated pseudoazurin. Due to the transient nature of the complex, saturation effects can be observed on the resonances of the unbound protein. The binding site comprises the hydrophobic area surrounding the exposed copper ligand His81, suggesting that this residue is important for efficient electron transfer.

The architecture of the binding site in redox protein complexes: Implications for fast dissociation

Interprotein electron transfer is characterized by protein interactions on the millisecond time scale. Such transient encounters are ensured by extremely high rates of complex dissociation. Computational analysis of the available crystal structures of redox protein complexes reveals features of the binding site that favor fast dissociation. In particular, the complex interface is shown to have low geometric complementarity and poor packing. These features are consistent with the necessity for fast dissociation since the absence of close packing facilitates solvation of the interface and disruption of the complex.

Electron transfer between membrane complexes and soluble proteins in photosynthesis

Photosynthesis consists of a series of endergonic redox reactions, with light as the source of energy, chlorophyll as the energy converter, and electrons flowing through membrane and soluble proteins. Here, we give an account of the most recent results on the structure-function relationships of the membrane-embedded complexes cytochrome b(6)-f and photosystem I and of the two soluble proteins (cytochrome c(6) and plastocyanin) that serve as alternative electron carriers between them. Particular attention is paid to the evolutionary aspects of the reaction mechanism and transient protein-protein interactions between the membrane complexes and their partners in cyanobacteria, eukaryotic algae, and plants.

Close encounters of the transient kind: protein interactions in the photosynthetic redox chain investigated by NMR spectroscopy

Plastocyanin and cytochrome c(6) function as electron shuttles between cytochrome f and photosystem I in the photosynthetic redox chain. To transfer electrons the partners form transient complexes, which are remarkably short-lived (milliseconds or less). Recent nuclear magnetic resonance studies have revealed details of the molecular interfaces found in such complexes. General features include a small binding site with a hydrophobic core and a polar periphery, including some charged residues. Furthermore, it was found that the interactions are relatively nonspecific. The structural information, in combination with kinetic and theoretical analyses of protein complexes, provides new insight into the nature of transient protein interactions.

Metalloprotein association, self-association, and dynamics governed by hydrophobic interactions: simultaneous occurrence of gated and true electron-transfer reactions between cytochrome f and cytochrome c(6) from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii

Noninvasive reconstitution of the heme in cytochrome c(6) with zinc(II) ions allowed us to study the photoinduced electron-transfer reaction (3)Zncyt c(6) + cyt f(III) --> Zncyt c(6)(+) + cyt f(II) between physiological partners cytochrome c(6) and cytochrome f, both from Chlamydomonas reinhardtii. The reaction kinetics was analyzed in terms of protein docking and electron transfer. In contrast to various protein pairs studied before, both the unimolecular and the bimolecular reactions of this oxidative quenching take place at all ionic strengths from 2.5 through 700 mM. The respective intracomplex rate constants are k(uni) (1.2 +/- 0.1) x 10(4) s(-1) for persistent and k(bi) (9 +/- 4) x 10(2) s(-1) for the transient protein complex. The former reaction seems to be true electron transfer, and the latter seems to be electron transfer gated by a structural rearrangement. Remarkably, these reactions occur simultaneously, and both rate constants are invariant with ionic strength. The association constant K(a) for zinc cytochrome c(6) and cytochrome f(III) remains (5 +/- 3) x 10(5) M(-1) in the ionic strength range from 700 to 10 mM and then rises slightly to (7 +/- 2) x 10(6) M(-1), as ionic strength is lowered to 2.5 mM. Evidently, docking of these proteins from C. reinhardtii is due to hydrophobic interaction, slightly augmented by weak electrostatic attraction. Kinetics, chromatography, and cross-linking consistently show that cytochrome f self-dimerizes at ionic strengths of 200 mM and higher. Cytochrome f(III) quenches triplet state (3)Zncyt c(6), but its dimer does not. Formation of this unreactive dimer is an important step in the mechanism of electron transfer. Not only association between the reacting proteins, but also their self-association, should be considered when analyzing reaction mechanisms.

Transient protein interactions studied by NMR spectroscopy: the case of cytochrome C and adrenodoxin

The interaction between yeast iso-1-cytochrome c (C102T) and two forms of bovine adrenodoxin, the wild type and a truncated form comprising residues 4-108, has been investigated using a combination of one- and two-dimensional heteronuclear NMR spectroscopy. Chemical shift perturbations and line broadening of amide resonances in the [(15)N,(1)H]HSQC spectrum for both (15)N-labeled cytochrome c and adrenodoxin in the presence of the unlabeled partner protein indicate the formation of a transient complex, with a K(a) of (4 +/- 1) x 10(4) M(-)(1) and a lifetime of <3 ms. The perturbed residues map over a large surface area for both proteins. For cytochrome c, the dominating effects are located around the exposed heme edge but with other areas also affected upon formation of the complex. In the case of adrenodoxin, effects are seen in both the recognition and core domains, with the largest perturbations in the recognition domain. These results indicate that the complex has a dynamic nature, with delocalized binding of cytochrome c on adrenodoxin. A comparison with other transient complexes of redox proteins places this complex between well-defined complexes such as the cytochrome c-cytochrome c peroxidase complex and entirely dynamic complexes such as the cytochrome b(5)-myoglobin complex.

Conformational reorganisation in interfacial protein electron transfer

Protein-protein electron transfer (ET) plays an essential role in all redox chains. Earlier studies which used cross-linking and increased solution viscosity indicated that the rate of many ET reactions is limited (i.e., gated) by conformational reorientations at the surface interface. These results are later supported by structural studies using NMR and molecular modelling. New insights into conformational gating have also come from electrochemical experiments in which proteins are noncovalently adsorbed on the electrode surface. These systems have the advantage that it is relatively easy to vary systematically the driving force and electronic coupling. In this review we summarize the current knowledge obtained from these electrochemical experiments and compare it with some of the results obtained for protein-protein ET.

Interaction of cytochrome c with cytochrome c oxidase: an NMR study on two soluble fragments derived from Paracoccus denitrificans

The functional interactions between the various components of the respiratory chain are relatively short-lived, thus allowing high turnover numbers but at the same time complicating the structural analysis of the complexes. Chemical shift mapping by NMR spectroscopy is a useful tool to investigate such transient contacts, since it can monitor changes in the electron-shielding properties of a protein as the result of temporary contacts with a reaction partner. In this study, we investigated the molecular interaction between two components of the electron-transfer chain from Paracoccus denitrificans: the engineered, water-soluble fragment of cytochrome c(552) and the Cu(A) domain from the cytochrome c oxidase. Comparison of [(15)N,(1)H]-TROSY spectra of the [(15)N]-labeled cytochrome c(552) fragment in the absence and in the presence of the Cu(A) fragment showed chemical shift changes for the backbone amide groups of several, mostly uncharged residues located around the exposed heme edge in cytochrome c(552). The detected contact areas on the cytochrome c(552) surface were comparable under both fully reduced and fully oxidized conditions, suggesting that the respective chemical shift changes represent biologically relevant protein-protein interactions.