Partial agonism in a G Protein-coupled receptor: role of the retinal ring structure in rhodopsin activation

Mechanism of Activation of the Visual Receptor Rhodopsin

Rhodopsin is the photoreceptor in human rod cells responsible for dim-light vision. The visual receptors are part of the large superfamily of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) that mediate signal transduction in response to diverse diffusible ligands. The high level of sequence conservation within the transmembrane helices of the visual receptors and the family A GPCRs has long been considered evidence for a common pathway for signal transduction. I review recent studies that reveal a comprehensive mechanism for how light absorption by the retinylidene chromophore drives rhodopsin activation and highlight those features of the mechanism that are conserved across the ligand-activated GPCRs.

Characterizing rhodopsin signaling by EPR spectroscopy: from structure to dynamics

Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy, together with spin labeling techniques, has played a major role in the characterization of rhodopsin, the photoreceptor protein and G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) in rod cells. Two decades ago, these biophysical tools were the first to identify transmembrane helical movements in rhodopsin upon photo-activation, a critical step in the study of GPCR signaling. EPR methods were employed to identify functional loop dynamics within rhodopsin, to measure light-induced millisecond timescale changes in rhodopsin conformation, to characterize the effects of partial agonists on the apoprotein opsin, and to study lipid interactions with rhodopsin. With the emergence of advanced pulsed EPR techniques, the stage was set to determine the amplitude of structural changes in rhodopsin and the dynamics in the rhodopsin signaling complexes. Work in this area has yielded invaluable information about mechanistic properties of GPCRs. Using EPR techniques, receptors are studied in native-like membrane environments and the effects of lipids on conformational equilibria can be explored. This perspective addresses the impact of EPR methods on rhodopsin and GPCR structural biology, highlighting historical discoveries made with spin labeling techniques, and outlining exciting new directions in the field.

Low-Temperature Trapping of Photointermediates of the Rhodopsin E181Q Mutant

Three active-site components in rhodopsin play a key role in the stability and function of the protein: 1) the counter-ion residues which stabilize the protonated Schiff base, 2) water molecules, and 3) the hydrogen-bonding network. The ionizable residue Glu-181, which is involved in an extended hydrogen-bonding network with Ser-186, Tyr-268, Tyr-192, and key water molecules within the active site of rhodopsin, has been shown to be involved in a complex counter-ion switch mechanism with Glu-113 during the photobleaching sequence of the protein. Herein, we examine the photobleaching sequence of the E181Q rhodopsin mutant by using cryogenic UV-visible spectroscopy to further elucidate the role of Glu-181 during photoactivation of the protein. We find that lower temperatures are required to trap the early photostationary states of the E181Q mutant compared to native rhodopsin. Additionally, a Blue Shifted Intermediate (BSI, λ_max = 498 nm, 100 K) is observed after the formation of E181Q Bathorhodopsin (Batho, λ_max = 556 nm, 10 K) but prior to formation of E181Q Lumirhodopsin (Lumi, λ_max = 506 nm, 220 K). A potential energy diagram of the observed photointermediates suggests the E181Q Batho intermediate has an enthalpy value 7.99 KJ/mol higher than E181Q BSI, whereas in rhodopsin, the BSI is 10.02 KJ/mol higher in enthalpy than Batho. Thus, the Batho to BSI transition is enthalpically driven in E181Q and entropically driven in native rhodopsin. We conclude that the substitution of Glu-181 with Gln-181 results in a significant perturbation of the hydrogen-bonding network within the active site of rhodopsin. In addition, the removal of a key electrostatic interaction between the chromophore and the protein destabilizes the protein in both the dark state and Batho intermediate conformations while having a stabilizing effect on the BSI conformation. The observed destabilization upon this substitution further supports that Glu-181 is negatively charged in the early intermediates of the photobleaching sequence of rhodopsin.

Impacts of retinal polyene (de)methylation on the photoisomerization mechanism and photon energy storage of rhodopsin

Similar to native rhodopsin, a two-mode space-saving isomerization mechanism drives the photoreaction in (de)methylated rhodopsin analogues.

Binding specificity of retinal analogs to photoactivated visual pigments suggest mechanism for fine-tuning GPCR-ligand interactions

11-cis-retinal acts as an inverse agonist stabilizing the inactive conformation of visual pigments, and upon photoactivation, it isomerizes to all-trans-retinal, initiating signal transduction. We have analyzed opsin regeneration with retinal analogs for rhodopsin and red cone opsin. We find differential binding of the analogs to the receptors after photobleaching and a dependence of the binding kinetics on the oligomerization state of the protein. The results outline the sensitivity of retinal entry to the binding pocket of visual receptors to the specific conformation adopted by the receptor and by the molecular architecture defined by specific amino acids in the binding pocket and the retinal entry site, as well as the topology of the retinal analog. Overall, our findings highlight the specificity of the ligand-opsin interactions, a feature that can be shared by other G-protein-coupled receptors.

Influence of cage confinement on the photochemistry of matrix-isolated E-β-ionone: FT-IR and DFT study

β-ionone, a model compound of carotenoids ring structure, was investigated by FT-IR spectroscopy in a low-temperature argon matrix as well as using B3LYP/6-311++G(d,p) and MP2/6-311++G(d,p) quantum-chemical calculations. The spectrum of matrix-isolated E-β-ionone was analyzed and attributed to six conformers of the compound. Then, matrix-isolated E-β-ionone was submitted to UV irradiation using either a broadband source (with different cutoff filters) or a narrowband laser/MOPO system (at various wavelengths). Upon 240 nm narrowband irradiation, the formation of both Z-retro-γ-ionone and Z-β-ionone was observed, the reactant and the photoproducts being in a photostationary equilibrium. Under these conditions, the matrix environment was found to hamper subsequent reactions of Z-retro-γ-ionone and Z-β-ionone, so that this last species could be observed directly for the first time. Furthermore, the formation of Z-retro-γ-ionone was shown to occur directly via an intramolecular [1,5] H-atom shift and thereby, under the constraints imposed by the matrix confinement, the conformations assumed by this photoproduct were found to be strictly determined by those initially assumed by the reactant molecules. Broadband irradiation resulted in the completion of the reaction (disappearance of the reactant) and the sole observation of Z-retro-γ-ionone. These results imply that under these conditions the Z-β-ionone is unstable, very likely decaying to additional conformers of Z-retro-γ-ionone, as reflected in the broader bands due to this photoproduct observed in the infrared spectra of the broadband irradiated matrix.

UV-visible and infrared methods for investigating lipid-rhodopsin membrane interactions

We describe experimental UV-visible and Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopic methods for characterizing lipid-protein interactions for rhodopsin in a membrane bilayer environment. The combination of FTIR and UV-visible difference spectroscopy is used to monitor the structural and functional changes during rhodopsin activation. Investigations of how membrane lipids stabilize various rhodopsin photoproducts are analogous to mutating the protein in terms of gain or loss of function. Interpretation of the results entails a flexible surface model for explaining membrane lipid-protein interactions through material properties relevant to biological activity.

Solid-state 2H NMR relaxation illuminates functional dynamics of retinal cofactor in membrane activation of rhodopsin

Rhodopsin is a canonical member of the family of G protein-coupled receptors, which transmit signals across cellular membranes and are linked to many drug interventions in humans. Here we show that solid-state (2)H NMR relaxation allows investigation of light-induced changes in local ps-ns time scale motions of retinal bound to rhodopsin. Site-specific (2)H labels were introduced into methyl groups of the retinal ligand that are essential to the activation process. We conducted solid-state (2)H NMR relaxation (spin-lattice, T(1Z), and quadrupolar-order, T(1Q)) experiments in the dark, Meta I, and Meta II states of the photoreceptor. Surprisingly, we find the retinylidene methyl groups exhibit site-specific differences in dynamics that change upon light excitation--even more striking, the C9-methyl group is a dynamical hotspot that corresponds to a crucial functional hotspot of rhodopsin. Following 11-cis to trans isomerization, the (2)H NMR data suggest the β-ionone ring remains in its hydrophobic binding pocket in all three states of the protein. We propose a multiscale activation mechanism with a complex energy landscape, whereby the photonic energy is directed against the E2 loop by the C13-methyl group, and toward helices H3 and H5 by the C5-methyl of the β-ionone ring. Changes in retinal structure and dynamics initiate activating fluctuations of transmembrane helices H5 and H6 in the Meta I-Meta II equilibrium of rhodopsin. Our proposals challenge the Standard Model whereby a single light-activated receptor conformation yields the visual response--rather an ensemble of substates is present, due to the entropy gain produced by photolysis of the inhibitory retinal lock.

Cyclopropyl and isopropyl derivatives of 11-cis and 9-cis retinals at C-9 and C-13: subtle steric differences with major effects on ligand efficacy in rhodopsin

Retinal is the natural ligand (chromophore) of the vertebrate rod visual pigment. It occurs in either the 11-cis (rhodopsin) or the 9-cis (isorhodopsin) configuration. In its evolution to a G protein coupled photoreceptor, rhodopsin has acquired exceptional photochemical properties. Illumination isomerizes the chromophore to the all-trans isomer, which acts as a full agonist. This process is extremely efficient, and there is abundant evidence that the C-9 and C-13 methyl groups of retinal play a pivotal role in this process. To examine the steric limits of the C-9 and C-13 methyl binding pocket of the binding site, we have prepared C-9 and C-13 cyclopropyl and isopropyl derivatives of its native ligands and of α-retinal at C-9. Most isopropyl analogues show very poor binding, except for 9-cis-13-isopropylretinal. Most cyclopropyl derivatives exhibit intermediate binding activity, except for 9-cis-13-cyclopropylretinal, which presents good binding activity. In general, the binding site shows preference for the 9-cis analogues over the 11-cis analogues. In fact, 13-isopropyl-9-cis-retinal acts as a superagonist after illumination. Another surprising finding was that 9-cyclopropylisorhodopsin is more like native rhodopsin with respect to spectral and photochemical properties, whereas 9-cyclopropylrhodopsin behaves more like native isorhodopsin in these aspects.

Light-induced activation of bacterial phytochrome Agp1 monitored by static and time-resolved FTIR spectroscopy

Phytochromes, which regulate many biological processes in plants, bacteria, and fungi, can exist in two stable states, Pr and Pfr, that can be interconverted by light, via a number of intermediates such as meta-Rc. Herein we employ FTIR spectroscopy to study the Pr-to-Pfr conversion of the bacteriophytochrome Agp1 from Agrobacterium tumefaciens. Static FTIR Pfr/Pr and meta-Rc/Pr difference spectra are disentangled in terms of cofactor and protein structural changes. Guided by DFT calculations on cofactor models, the chromophore conformational changes can be grouped into structural adjustments of the cofactor-protein interactions localized in the C-D dipyrrole moiety, that is, the photoisomerisation site, and in the A-B dipyrrole moiety including the protein attachment site. Whereas changes at the C and D rings appear to be largely completed in the meta-Rc state, the structural changes in the A-B unit occur during the transition from meta-Rc to Pfr, concomitant with the main protein structural changes, as demonstrated by static and time-resolved FTIR difference spectroscopy. We employ this technique to monitor, for the first time, the dynamics of the photocycle of phytochrome on the millisecond timescale. By extending the studies to genetically engineered protein variants of Agp1, we further demonstrate that H250 and D197 as well as the PHY domain are essential for formation of the Pfr state. Based on the IR spectroscopic and available crystallographic data we discuss the role of critical amino acid residues for the protein-cofactor interactions during the photoinduced reaction cycle.

Assays for inverse agonists in the visual system

Visual pigment proteins belong to the superfamily of G protein-coupled receptors and are the light-sensitive molecules in rod and cone photoreceptor cells. The protein moiety is known as opsin and the ligand in the dark is 11-cis retinal, which serves as both the photon detector and an inverse agonist. While much is known about properties of the rod pigment rhodopsin, much less is understood about cone visual pigments. Being able to identify ligands that effect opsins give an insight into structure-activity relationships. The action of some ligands indicates that there are differences between not only rod and cone opsins but also among the different classes of cone opsins. Furthermore, inverse agonists of cone opsins may have potential therapeutic uses under conditions when the native 11-cis retinal ligand is absent. A method for determining the effects of ligands on rod and cone opsin activity is described.

In vitro assays of rod and cone opsin activity: retinoid analogs as agonists and inverse agonists

Upon absorption of a photon, the bound 11-cis-retinoid isomerizes to the all-trans form resulting in a protein conformational change that enables it to activate its G protein, transducin, to begin the visual signal transduction cascade. The native ligand, 11-cis-retinal, acts as an inverse agonist to both the apoproteins of rod and cone visual pigments (opsins); all-trans-retinal is an agonist. Truncated analogs of retinal have been used to characterize structure-function relationships with rod opsins, but little has been done with cone opsins. Activation of transducin by an opsin is one method to characterize the conformational state of the opsin. This chapter describes an in vitro transducin activation assay that can be used with cone opsins to determine the degree to which different ligands can act as an agonist or an inverse agonist to gain insight into the ligand-binding pocket of cone opsins and differences between the different classes of opsins. The understanding of the effects of ligands on cone opsin activity can potentially be applied to future therapeutic agents targeting opsins.

A G protein-coupled receptor at work: the rhodopsin model

G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) are ubiquitous signal transducers in cell membranes, as well as important drug targets. Interaction with extracellular agonists turns the seven transmembrane helix (7TM) scaffold of a GPCR into a catalyst for GDP and GTP exchange in heterotrimeric Galphabetagamma proteins. Activation of the model GPCR, rhodopsin, is triggered by photoisomerization of its retinal ligand. From the augmentation of biochemical and biophysical studies by recent high-resolution 3D structures, its activation intermediates can now be interpreted as the stepwise engagement of protein domains. Rearrangement of TM5-TM6 opens a crevice at the cytoplasmic side of the receptor into which the C terminus of the Galpha subunit can bind. The Galpha C-terminal helix is used as a transmission rod to the nucleotide binding site. The mechanism relies on dynamic interactions between conserved residues and could therefore be common to other GPCRs.

Retinal dynamics during light activation of rhodopsin revealed by solid-state NMR spectroscopy

Rhodopsin is a canonical member of class A of the G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) that are implicated in many of the drug interventions in humans and are of great pharmaceutical interest. The molecular mechanism of rhodopsin activation remains unknown as atomistic structural information for the active metarhodopsin II state is currently lacking. Solid-state (2)H NMR constitutes a powerful approach to study atomic-level dynamics of membrane proteins. In the present application, we describe how information is obtained about interactions of the retinal cofactor with rhodopsin that change with light activation of the photoreceptor. The retinal methyl groups play an important role in rhodopsin function by directing conformational changes upon transition into the active state. Site-specific (2)H labels have been introduced into the methyl groups of retinal and solid-state (2)H NMR methods applied to obtain order parameters and correlation times that quantify the mobility of the cofactor in the inactive dark state, as well as the cryotrapped metarhodopsin I and metarhodopsin II states. Analysis of the angular-dependent (2)H NMR line shapes for selectively deuterated methyl groups of rhodopsin in aligned membranes enables determination of the average ligand conformation within the binding pocket. The relaxation data suggest that the beta-ionone ring is not expelled from its hydrophobic pocket in the transition from the pre-activated metarhodopsin I to the active metarhodopsin II state. Rather, the major structural changes of the retinal cofactor occur already at the metarhodopsin I state in the activation process. The metarhodopsin I to metarhodopsin II transition involves mainly conformational changes of the protein within the membrane lipid bilayer rather than the ligand. The dynamics of the retinylidene methyl groups upon isomerization are explained by an activation mechanism involving cooperative rearrangements of extracellular loop E2 together with transmembrane helices H5 and H6. These activating movements are triggered by steric clashes of the isomerized all-trans retinal with the beta4 strand of the E2 loop and the side chains of Glu(122) and Trp(265) within the binding pocket. The solid-state (2)H NMR data are discussed with regard to the pathway of the energy flow in the receptor activation mechanism.

Electrostatic control of the photoisomerization efficiency and optical properties in visual pigments: on the role of counterion quenching

Hybrid QM(CASPT2//CASSCF/6-31G*)/MM(Amber) computations have been used to map the photoisomerization path of the retinal chromophore in Rhodopsin and explore the reasons behind the photoactivity efficiency and spectral control in the visual pigments. It is shown that while the electrostatic environment plays a central role in properly tuning the optical properties of the chromophore, it is also critical in biasing the ultrafast photochemical event: it controls the slope of the photoisomerization channel as well as the accessibility of the S(1)/S(0) crossing space triggering the ultrafast decay. The roles of the E113 counterion, the E181 residue, and the other amino acids of the protein pocket are explicitly analyzed: it appears that counterion quenching by the protein environment plays a key role in setting up the chromophore's optical properties and its photochemical efficiency. A unified scenario is presented that discloses the relationship between spectroscopic and mechanistic properties in rhodopsins and allows us to draw a solid mechanism for spectral tuning in color vision pigments: a tunable counterion shielding appears as the elective mechanism for L<-->M spectral modulation, while a retinal conformational control must dictate S absorption. Finally, it is suggested that this model may contribute to shed new light into mutations-related vision deficiencies that opens innovative perspectives for experimental biomolecular investigations in this field.

Beta-ionone activates and bleaches visual pigment in salamander photoreceptors

Vision begins with photoisomerization of 11-cis retinal to the all-trans conformation within the chromophore-binding pocket of opsin, leading to activation of a biochemical cascade. Release of all-trans retinal from the binding pocket curtails but does not fully quench the ability of opsin to activate transducin. All-trans retinal and some other analogs, such as beta-ionone, enhance opsin's activity, presumably on binding the empty chromophore-binding pocket. By recording from isolated salamander photoreceptors and from patches of rod outer segment membrane, we now show that high concentrations of beta-ionone suppressed circulating current in dark-adapted green-sensitive rods by inhibiting the cyclic nucleotide-gated channels. There were also decreases in circulating current and flash sensitivity, and accelerated flash response kinetics in dark-adapted blue-sensitive (BS) rods and cones, and in ultraviolet-sensitive cones, at concentrations too low to inhibit the channels. These effects persisted in BS rods even after incubation with 9-cis retinal to ensure complete regeneration of their visual pigment. After long exposures to high concentrations of beta-ionone, recovery was incomplete unless 9-cis retinal was given, indicating that visual pigment had been bleached. Therefore, we propose that beta-ionone activates and bleaches some types of visual pigments, mimicking the effects of light.

Accelerated accumulation of lipofuscin pigments in the RPE of a mouse model for ABCA4-mediated retinal dystrophies following Vitamin A supplementation

PURPOSE

Dietary supplementation with vitamin A is sometimes prescribed as a treatment for retinitis pigmentosa, a group of inherited retinal degenerations that cause progressive blindness. Loss-of-function mutations in the ABCA4 gene are responsible for a subset of recessive retinitis pigmentosa. Other mutant alleles of ABCA4 cause the related diseases, recessive cone-rod dystrophy, and recessive Stargardt macular degeneration. Mice with a knockout mutation in the abca4 gene massively accumulate toxic lipofuscin pigments in the retinal pigment epithelium. Treatment of these mice with fenretinide, an inhibitor of vitamin A delivery to the eye, blocks formation of these toxic pigments. Here the authors tested the hypothesis that dietary supplementation with vitamin A may accelerate lipofuscin pigment formation in abca4(-/-) mice.

METHODS

Wild-type and abca4(-/-) mice were fed normal or vitamin A-supplemented diets. Tissues from these mice were analyzed biochemically for retinoids and lipofuscin pigments. Eyes from these mice were analyzed morphologically for lipofuscin in the retinal pigment epithelium and for degeneration of photoreceptors. Visual function in these mice was analyzed by electroretinography.

RESULTS

Mice that received vitamin A supplementation had dramatically higher levels of retinyl esters in the liver and retinal pigment epithelium. Lipofuscin pigments were significantly increased by biochemical and morphologic analysis in wild-type and abca4(-/-) mice fed the vitamin A-supplemented diet. Photoreceptor degeneration was observed in 11-month-old albino, but not pigmented, abca4(-/-) mice on both diets.

CONCLUSIONS

Vitamin A supplementation should be avoided in patients with ABCA4 mutations or other retinal or macular dystrophies associated with lipofuscin accumulation in the retinal pigment epithelium.

Sequence of late molecular events in the activation of rhodopsin

Activation of the G protein-coupled receptor rhodopsin involves both the motion of transmembrane helix 6 (TM6) and proton exchange events. To study how these activation steps relate to each other, spin-labeled rhodopsin in solutions of dodecyl maltoside was used so that time-resolved TM6 motion and proton exchange could each be monitored as a function of pH and temperature after an activating light flash. The results reveal that the motion of TM6 is not synchronized with deprotonation of the Schiff base that binds the chromophore to the protein but is an order of magnitude slower at 30 degrees C. However, TM6 motion and the uptake of a proton from solution in the neutral pH range follow the same time course. Importantly, the motion of TM6 is virtually independent of pH, as is Schiff base deprotonation under the conditions used, whereas proton uptake titrates with a pK of 6.5. This finding shows that proton uptake is a consequence rather than a cause of helix motion. Activated rhodopsin binds to and subsequently activates the cognate G protein, transducin. It has been shown that peptides derived from the C terminus of the transducin alpha-subunit mimic in part binding of the intact G protein. These peptides are found to bind to rhodopsin after TM6 movement, resulting in the release of protons. Collectively, the data suggest the following temporal sequence of events involved in activation: (i) internal Schiff base proton transfer; (ii) TM6 movement; and (iii) proton uptake from solution and binding of transducin.

Rhodopsin and 9-demethyl-retinal analog: effect of a partial agonist on displacement of transmembrane helix 6 in class A G protein-coupled receptors

Rhodopsin is the visual pigment of rod cells and a prototypical G protein-coupled receptor. It is activated by cis-->trans photoisomerization of the covalently bound chromophore 11-cis-retinal, which acts in the cis configuration as an inverse agonist. Light-induced formation of the full agonist all-trans-retinal in situ triggers conformational changes in the protein moiety. Partial agonists of rhodopsin include a retinal analog lacking the methyl group at C-9, termed 9-demethyl-retinal (9-dm-retinal). Rhodopsin reconstituted with this retinal (9-dm-rhodopsin) activates G protein poorly. Here we investigated the molecular nature of the partial agonism in 9-dm-rhodopsin using site-directed spin labeling. Earlier site-directed spin labeling studies of rhodopsin identified a rigid-body tilt of the cytoplasmic segment of [corrected] transmembrane helix 6 (TM6) by approximately 6A as a central event in rhodopsin activation. Data presented here provide additional evidence for this mechanism. Only a small fraction of photoexcited 9-dm pigments reaches the TM6-tilted conformation. This fraction can be increased by increasing proton concentration or [corrected] by anticipation of the activating protonation step by the mutation E134Q in 9-dm-rhodopsin. These results on protein conformation are in complete accord with previous findings regarding the biological activity of the 9-dm pigments. When the proton concentration is further increased, a new state arises in 9-dm pigments that is linked to direct proton uptake at the retinal Schiff base. This state apparently has a conformation distinguishable from the active state.

Conformational changes in G-protein-coupled receptors-the quest for functionally selective conformations is open

The G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) represent one the largest families of drug targets. Upon agonist binding a receptor undergoes conformational rearrangements that lead to a novel protein conformation which in turn can interact with effector proteins. During the last decade significant progress has been made to prove that different conformational changes occur. Today it is mostly accepted that individual ligands can induce different receptor conformations. However, the nature or molecular identity of the different conformations is still ill-known. Knowledge of the potential functionally selective conformations will help to develop drugs that select specific conformations of a given GPCR which couple to specific signalling pathways and may, ultimately, lead to reduced side effects. In this review we will summarize recent progress in biophysical approaches that have led to the current understanding of conformational changes that occur during GPCR activation.

Dynamic structure of retinylidene ligand of rhodopsin probed by molecular simulations

Rhodopsin is currently the only available atomic-resolution template for understanding biological functions of the G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) family. The structural basis for the phenomenal dark state stability of 11-cis-retinal bound to rhodopsin and its ultrafast photoreaction are active topics of research. In particular, the beta-ionone ring of the retinylidene inverse agonist is crucial for the activation mechanism. We analyzed a total of 23 independent, 100 ns all-atom molecular dynamics simulations of rhodopsin embedded in a lipid bilayer in the microcanonical (N,V,E) ensemble. Analysis of intramolecular fluctuations predicts hydrogen-out-of-plane (HOOP) wagging modes of retinal consistent with those found in Raman vibrational spectroscopy. We show that sampling and ergodicity of the ensemble of simulations are crucial for determining the distribution of conformers of retinal bound to rhodopsin. The polyene chain is rigidly locked into a single, twisted conformation, consistent with the function of retinal as an inverse agonist in the dark state. Most surprisingly, the beta-ionone ring is mobile within its binding pocket; interactions are non-specific and the cavity is sufficiently large to enable structural heterogeneity. We find that retinal occupies two distinct conformations in the dark state, contrary to most previous assumptions. The beta-ionone ring can rotate relative to the polyene chain, thereby populating both positively and negatively twisted 6-s-cis enantiomers. This result, while unexpected, strongly agrees with experimental solid-state (2)H NMR spectra. Correlation analysis identifies the residues most critical to controlling mobility of retinal; we find that Trp265 moves away from the ionone ring prior to any conformational transition. Our findings reinforce how molecular dynamics simulations can challenge conventional assumptions for interpreting experimental data, especially where existing models neglect conformational fluctuations.

Coupling of Protonation Switches During Rhodopsin Activation†

Recent studies of the activation mechanism of rhodopsin involving Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy and a combination of chromophore modifications and site-directed mutagenesis reveal an allosteric coupling between two protonation switches. In particular, the ring and the 9-methyl group of the all-trans retinal chromophore serve to couple two proton-dependent activation steps: proton uptake by a cytoplasmic network between transmembrane (TM) helices 3 and 6 around the conserved ERY (Glu-Arg-Tyr) motif and disruption of a salt bridge between the retinal protonated Schiff base (PSB) and a protein counterion in the TM core of the receptor. Retinal analogs lacking the ring or 9-methyl group are only partial agonists--the conformational equilibrium between inactive Meta I and active Meta II photoproduct states is shifted to Meta I. An artificial pigment was engineered, in which the ring of retinal was removed and the PSB salt bridge was weakened by fluorination of C14 of the retinal polyene. These modifications abolished allosteric coupling of the proton switches and resulted in a stabilized Meta I state with a deprotonated Schiff base (Meta I(SB)). This state had a partial Meta II-like conformation due to disruption of the PSB salt bridge, but still lacked the cytoplasmic proton uptake reaction characteristic of the final transition to Meta II. As activation of native rhodopsin is known to involve deprotonation of the retinal Schiff base prior to formation of Meta II, this Meta I(SB) state may serve as a model for the structural characterization of a key transient species in the activation pathway of a prototypical G protein-coupled receptor.

The Angiotensin II AT1 Receptor Structure-Activity Correlations in the Light of Rhodopsin Structure

The most prevalent physiological effects of ANG II, the main product of the renin-angiotensin system, are mediated by the AT1 receptor, a rhodopsin-like AGPCR. Numerous studies of the cardiovascular effects of synthetic peptide analogs allowed a detailed mapping of ANG II's structural requirements for receptor binding and activation, which were complemented by site-directed mutagenesis studies on the AT1 receptor to investigate the role of its structure in ligand binding, signal transduction, phosphorylation, binding to arrestins, internalization, desensitization, tachyphylaxis, and other properties. The knowledge of the high-resolution structure of rhodopsin allowed homology modeling of the AT1 receptor. The models thus built and mutagenesis data indicate that physiological (agonist binding) or constitutive (mutated receptor) activation may involve different degrees of expansion of the receptor's central cavity. Residues in ANG II structure seem to control these conformational changes and to dictate the type of cytosolic event elicited during the activation. 1) Agonist aromatic residues (Phe8 and Tyr4) favor the coupling to G protein, and 2) absence of these residues can favor a mechanism leading directly to receptor internalization via phosphorylation by specific kinases of the receptor's COOH-terminal Ser and Thr residues, arrestin binding, and clathrin-dependent coated-pit vesicles. On the other hand, the NH2-terminal residues of the agonists ANG II and [Sar1]-ANG II were found to bind by two distinct modes to the AT1 receptor extracellular site flanked by the COOH-terminal segments of the EC-3 loop and the NH2-terminal domain. Since the [Sar1]-ligand is the most potent molecule to trigger tachyphylaxis in AT1 receptors, it was suggested that its corresponding binding mode might be associated with this special condition of receptors.

Structural analysis and dynamics of retinal chromophore in dark and meta I states of rhodopsin from 2H NMR of aligned membranes

Rhodopsin is a prototype for G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) that are implicated in many biological responses in humans. A site-directed (2)H NMR approach was used for structural analysis of retinal within its binding cavity in the dark and pre-activated meta I states. Retinal was labeled with (2)H at the C5, C9, or C13 methyl groups by total synthesis, and was used to regenerate the opsin apoprotein. Solid-state (2)H NMR spectra were acquired for aligned membranes in the low-temperature lipid gel phase versus the tilt angle to the magnetic field. Data reduction assumed a static uniaxial distribution, and gave the retinylidene methyl bond orientations plus the alignment disorder (mosaic spread). The dark-state (2)H NMR structure of 11-cis-retinal shows torsional twisting of the polyene chain and the beta-ionone ring. The ligand undergoes restricted motion, as evinced by order parameters of approximately 0.9 for the spinning C-C(2)H(3) groups, with off-axial fluctuations of approximately 15 degrees . Retinal is accommodated within the rhodopsin binding pocket with a negative pre-twist about the C11=C12 double bond that explains its rapid photochemistry and the trajectory of 11-cis to trans isomerization. In the cryo-trapped meta I state, the (2)H NMR structure shows a reduction of the polyene strain, while torsional twisting of the beta-ionone ring is maintained. Distortion of the retinal conformation is interpreted through substituent control of receptor activation. Steric hindrance between trans retinal and Trp265 can trigger formation of the subsequent activated meta II state. Our results are pertinent to quantum and molecular mechanics simulations of ligands bound to GPCRs, and illustrate how (2)H NMR can be applied to study their biological mechanisms of action.

A novel, conformation-specific allosteric inhibitor of the tachykinin NK2 receptor (NK2R) with functionally selective properties

The orthosteric agonist neurokinin A (NKA) interacts with the tachykinin NK2 receptors (NK2Rs) via an apparent sequential binding process, which stabilizes the receptor in at least two different active conformations (A1L and A2L). The A1L conformation exhibits fast NKA dissociation kinetics and triggers intracellular calcium elevation; the A2L conformation exhibits slow NKA dissociation kinetics and triggers cAMP production. The new compound LPI805 is a partial and noncompetitive inhibitor of NKA binding to NK2Rs. Analysis of NKA dissociation in the presence of LPI805 suggests that LPI805 decreases the number of NKA-NK2R complexes in A2L conformation while increasing those in the A1L conformation. Analysis of signaling pathways of NK2Rs shows that LPI805 dramatically inhibits the NKA-induced cAMP response while slightly enhancing the NKA-induced calcium response. Analysis of NKA association kinetics reveals that LPI805 promotes strong and specific destabilization of the NKA-NK2R complexes in the A2L conformation whereas access of NKA to the A1L conformations is unchanged. Thus, to our knowledge, LPI805 is the first example of a conformation-specific allosteric antagonist of a G-protein-coupled receptor. This work establishes the use of allosteric modulators in order to promote functional selectivity on certain agonist-receptor interactions.

Linkage Between the Intramembrane H-bond Network Around Aspartic Acid 83 and the Cytosolic Environment of Helix 8 in Photoactivated Rhodopsin

Understanding the coupling between conformational changes in the intramembrane domain and at the membrane-exposed surface of the bovine photoreceptor rhodopsin, a prototypical G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR), is crucial for the elucidation of molecular mechanisms in GPCR activation. Here, we have combined Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) and fluorescence spectroscopy to address the coupling between conformational changes in the intramembrane region around the retinal and the environment of helix 8, a putative cytosolic surface switch region in class-I GPCRs. Using FTIR/fluorescence cross-correlation we show specifically that surface alterations monitored by emission changes of fluorescein bound to Cys316 in helix 8 of rhodopsin are highly correlated with (i) H-bonding to Asp83 proximal of the retinal Schiff base but not to Glu122 close to the beta-ionone and (ii) with a metarhodopsin II (MII)-specific 1643 cm(-1) IR absorption change, indicative of a partial loss of secondary structure in helix 8 upon MII formation. These correlations are disrupted by limited C-terminal proteolysis but are maintained upon binding of a transducin alpha-subunit (G(talpha))-derived peptide, which stabilizes the MII state. Our results suggest that additional C-terminal cytosolic loop contacts monitored by an amide II absorption at 1557 cm(-1) play a functionally crucial role in keeping helix 8 in the position in which its environment is strongly coupled to the retinal-binding site near the Schiff base. In the intramembrane region, this coupling is mediated by the H-bonding network that connects Asp83 to the NPxxY(x)F motif preceding helix 8.

Deactivation and proton transfer in light-induced metarhodopsin II/metarhodopsin III conversion: a time-resolved fourier transform infrared spectroscopic study

Vertebrate rhodopsin shares with other retinal proteins the 11-cis-retinal chromophore and the light-induced 11-cis/trans isomerization triggering its activation pathway. However, only in rhodopsin the retinylidene Schiff base bond to the apoprotein is eventually hydrolyzed, making a complex regeneration pathway necessary. Metabolic regeneration cannot be short-cut, and light absorption in the active metarhodopsin (Meta) II intermediate causes anti/syn isomerization around the retinylidene linkage rather than reversed trans/cis isomerization. A new deactivating pathway is thereby triggered, which ends in the Meta III "retinal storage" product. Using time-resolved Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy, we show that the identified steps of receptor activation, including Schiff base deprotonation, protein structural changes, and proton uptake by the apoprotein, are all reversed. However, Schiff base reprotonation is much faster than the activating deprotonation, whereas the protein structural changes are slower. The final proton release occurs with pK approximately 4.5, similar to the pK of a free Glu residue and to the pK at which the isolated opsin apoprotein becomes active. A forced deprotonation, equivalent to the forced protonation in the activating pathway, which occurs against the unfavorable pH of the medium, is not observed. This explains properties of the final Meta III product, which displays much higher residual activity and is less stable than rhodopsin arising from regeneration with 11-cis-retinal. We propose that the anti/syn conversion can only induce a fast reorientation and distance change of the Schiff base but fails to build up the full set of dark ground state constraints, presumably involving the Glu(134)/Arg(135) cluster.

G protein-coupled receptor rhodopsin

The rhodopsin crystal structure provides a structural basis for understanding the function of this and other G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs). The major structural motifs observed for rhodopsin are expected to carry over to other GPCRs, and the mechanism of transformation of the receptor from inactive to active forms is thus likely conserved. Moreover, the high expression level of rhodopsin in the retina, its specific localization in the internal disks of the photoreceptor structures [termed rod outer segments (ROS)], and the lack of other highly abundant membrane proteins allow rhodopsin to be examined in the native disk membranes by a number of methods. The results of these investigations provide evidence of the propensity of rhodopsin and, most likely, other GPCRs to dimerize, a property that may be pertinent to their function.

Structural and functional properties of metarhodopsin III: recent spectroscopic studies on deactivation pathways of rhodopsin

The activation of rhodopsin has been the focus of researchers over the past decades, revealing many aspects of the activation pathways of this prototypical G protein-coupled receptor on a molecular level, starting with the light-dependent isomerization of its retinal chromophore from 11-cis to all-trans and leading eventually to the large scale helix movements in the transition to the active receptor state, Meta II. Comparatively little is known, however, on the deactivation pathways of the light receptor, which represent essential steps in maintaining a functional photoreceptor cell. Rhodopsin's active receptor species, Meta II, decays by two fundamentally different pathways, either forming the apoprotein opsin by release of the activating all-trans retinal ligand from its binding pocket, or by a thermal isomerization of this ligand to a less activating species in the transition to metarhodopsin III (Meta III). Both decay products, opsin and Meta III, are largely inactive under physiological conditions, yet they do not restore the complete inactivity of the dark state. Although some properties of Meta III have been described already in the 1960s, its molecular nature and the pathways of its formation have remained rather obscure. In this review, we focus on recent studies from our laboratories, which have provided a major progress in our understanding of the Meta III deactivation pathway and its potential physiological roles. Using Fourier-transform infrared (FTIR) difference spectroscopy in combination with a variety of other spectroscopic and biochemical techniques and quantum chemical calculations, we have developed a general picture of the interplay between the retinal ligand and the receptor protein, which is compared to similar reaction mechanisms in invertebrate photoreceptors and microbial retinal proteins.

The role of the 11-cis-retinal ring methyl substituents in visual pigment formation

Artificial visual pigment formation from ring-demethylated retinals was studied in an effort to understand the effect that methyl groups on the chromophore cyclohexenyl ring have on the visual cycle. The stereoselective synthesis of the 11-cis-ring-demethylated analogues involves thallium-accelerated Suzuki cross-coupling reactions and highly stereocontrolled Wittig reactions to form key bonds. Only 11-cis-1,1,5-trisdemethylretinal (2) failed to form an artificial pigment, whilst variable pigment-formation yields were determined for the remaining analogues, increasing with the number (and location) of the chromophore hydrophobic ring methyl groups. Our results with the monodemethylated analogues 11-cis-5-demethylretinal (4) and 11-cis-1-demethylretinal (5) show that the C1-2-CH(3) groups are more important for pigment formation than the C5-CH(3) substituent. This is reflected in the absorption maxima of the artificial pigments, with values closer to that of native rhodopsin for 4. Docking studies based on a rhodopsin crystal structure, however, predict a lower pigment stability for 4 than for 5. Gas-phase DFT (B3LYP/6-31G*) computations of the free-ligand geometries, conformational searches about the C6--C7 bond, and docking studies revealed that, although the conformation of bound 5 is close to that of the native chromophore, the ligand needs to overcome the energy cost of shifting the unbound favored 6-s-trans conformation to the bound 6-s-cis form. In addition, the presence of an extra methyl group at C18 (11-cis-18-methylretinal, 7) is tolerated well and adds further stability to the complex, most probably due to increased hydrophobic interactions.

The Role of the β-Ionone Ring in the Photochemical Reaction of Rhodopsin

Time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) calculations on the photoabsorption process of the 11-cis retinal protonated Schiff base (PSB) chromophore show that the Franck-Condon relaxation of the first excited state of the chromophore involves a torsional twist motion of the beta-ionone ring relative to the conjugated retinyl chain. For the ground state, the beta-ionone ring and the retinyl chain of the free retinal PSB chromophore form a -40 degrees dihedral angle as compared to -94 degrees for the first excited state. The double bonds of the retinal are shorter for the fully optimized structure of the excited state than for the ground state suggesting a higher cis-trans isomerization barrier for the excited state than for the ground state. According to the present TDDFT calculations, the excitation of the retinal PSB chromophore does not primarily lead to a reaction along the cis-trans torsional coordinate at the C11-C12 bond. The activation of the isomerization center seems to occur at a later stage of the photo reaction. The results obtained at the TDDFT level are supported by second-order Møller-Plesset (MP2) and approximate singles and doubles-coupled cluster (CC2) calculations on retinal chromophore models; the MP2 and CC2 calculations yield for them qualitatively the same ground state and excited-state structures as obtained in the density functional theory and TDDFT calculations.

A methyl group at C7 of 11-cis-retinal allows chromophore formation but affects rhodopsin activation

The newly synthesized 11-cis-7-methylretinal can form an artificial visual pigment with kinetic and spectroscopic properties similar to the native pigment in the dark-state. However, its photobleaching behavior is altered, showing a Meta I-like photoproduct. This behavior reflects a steric constraint imposed by the 7-methyl group that affects the conformational change in the binding pocket as a result of retinal photoisomerization. Transducin activation is reduced, when compared to the native pigment with 11-cis-retinal. Molecular dynamics simulations suggest coupling of the C7 methyl group and the beta-ionone ring with Met207 in transmembrane helix 5 in agreement with recent experimental results.

The all-trans-15-syn-retinal chromophore of metarhodopsin III is a partial agonist and not an inverse agonist

Meta III is formed during the decay of rhodopsin's active receptor state at neutral to alkaline pH by thermal isomerization of the retinal Schiff base C15=N bond, converting the ligand from all-trans 15-anti to all-trans 15-syn. The thereby induced change of ligand geometry switches the receptor to an inactive conformation, such that the decay pathway to Meta III contributes to the deactivation of the signaling state at higher pH values. We have examined the conformation of Meta III over a wider pH range and found that Meta III exists in a pH-dependent conformational equilibrium between this inactive conformation at neutral to alkaline pH and an active conformation similar to that of Meta II, which, however, is assumed at very acidic pH only. The apparent pKa of this transition is around 5.1 and thus several units lower than that of the Meta I/Meta II photoproduct equilibrium with its all-trans 15-anti ligand, but still about 1 unit higher than that of the opsin conformational equilibrium in the absence of ligand. The all-trans-15-syn-retinal chromophore is therefore not an inverse agonist like 11-cis- or 9-cis-retinal, which lock the receptor in an inactive conformation, but a classical partial agonist, which is capable of activating the receptor, yet with an efficiency considerably lower than the full agonist all-trans 15-anti. As the Meta III chromophore differs structurally from this full agonist only in the isomeric state of the C15=N bond, this ligand represents an excellent model system to study principal mechanisms of partial agonism which are helpful to understand the partial agonist behavior of other ligands.

Methyl Substituents at the 11 or 12 Position of Retinal Profoundly and Differentially Affect Photochemistry and Signalling Activity of Rhodopsin

The C-11=C-12 double bond of the retinylidene chromophore of rhodopsin holds a central position in its light-induced photoisomerization and hence the photosensory function of this visual pigment. To probe the local environment of the HC-11=C-12H element we have prepared the 11-methyl and 12-methyl derivatives of 11-Z retinal and incorporated these into opsin to generate the rhodopsin analogs 11-methyl and 12-methyl rhodopsin. These analog pigments form with much slower kinetics and lower efficiency than the native pigment. The initial photochemistry and the signaling activity of the analog pigments were investigated by UV-vis and FTIR spectroscopy, and by a G protein activation assay. Our data indicate that the ultrafast formation of the first photointermediate is strongly perturbed by the presence of an 11-methyl substituent, but much less by a 12-methyl substituent. These results support the current concept of the mechanism of the primary photoisomerization event in rhodopsin. An important stronghold of this concept is an out-of-plane movement of the C-12H element, which is facilitated by torsion as well as extended positive charge delocalization into the C-10-C-13 segment of the chromophore. We argue that this mechanism is maintained principally with a methyl substituent at C-12. In addition, we show that both an 11-methyl and a 12-methyl substitutent perturb the photointermediate cascade and finally yield a low-activity state of the receptor. The 11-methyl pigment retains about 30% of the G protein activation rate of native rhodopsin, while the 12-methyl chromophore behaves like an inverse agonist up to at least 20 degrees C, trapping the protein in a perturbed Meta-I-like conformation. We conclude that the isomerization region of the chromophore and the spatial structure of the binding site are finely tuned, in order to achieve a high photosensory potential with an efficient pathway to a high-activity state.

Modulating Rhodopsin Receptor Activation by Altering the pKa of the Retinal Schiff Base

The visual pigment rhodopsin is a seven-transmembrane (7-TM) G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR). Activation of rhodopsin involves two pH-dependent steps: proton uptake at a conserved cytoplasmic motif between TM helices 3 and 6, and disruption of a salt bridge between a protonated Schiff base (PSB) and its carboxylate counterion in the transmembrane core of the receptor. Formation of an artificial pigment with a retinal chromophore fluorinated at C14 decreases the intrinsic pKa of the PSB and thereby destabilizes this salt bridge. Using Fourier transform infrared difference and UV-visible spectroscopy, we characterized the pH-dependent equilibrium between the active photoproduct Meta II and its inactive precursor, Meta I, in the 14-fluoro (14-F) analogue pigment. The 14-F chromophore decreases the enthalpy change of the Meta I-to-Meta II transition and shifts the Meta I/Meta II equilibrium toward Meta II. Combining C14 fluorination with deletion of the retinal beta-ionone ring to form a 14-F acyclic artificial pigment uncouples disruption of the Schiff base salt bridge from transition to Meta II and in particular from the cytoplasmic proton uptake reaction, as confirmed by combining the 14-F acyclic chromophore with the E134Q mutant. The 14-F acyclic analogue formed a stable Meta I state with a deprotonated Schiff base and an at least partially protonated protein counterion. The combination of retinal modification and site-directed mutagenesis reveals that disruption of the protonated Schiff base salt bridge is the most important step thermodynamically in the transition from Meta I to Meta II. This finding is particularly important since deprotonation of the retinal PSB is known to precede the transition to the active state in rhodopsin activation and is consistent with models of agonist-dependent activation of other GPCRs.