Conformational dynamics of P-glycoprotein in lipid nanodiscs and detergent micelles reveal complex motions on a wide time scale

Advances in Membrane Mimetic Systems for Manipulation and Analysis of Membrane Proteins: Detergents, Polymers, Lipids and Scaffolds

Extracting membrane proteins from the hydrophobic environment of the biological membrane, in a physiologically relevant and stable state, suitable for downstream analysis remains a challenge. The traditional route to membrane protein extraction has been to use detergents and the last 15 years or so have seen a veritable explosion in the development of novel detergents with improved properties, making them more suitable for individual proteins and specific applications. There have also been significant advances in the development of encapsulation of membrane proteins in lipid based nanodiscs, either directly from the native membrane using polymers allowing effective capture of the protein and protein-associated membrane lipids, or via reconstitution of detergent extracted and purified protein into nanodiscs of defined lipid composition. All of these advances have been successfully applied to the study of membrane proteins via a range of techniques and there have been some spectacular membrane protein structures solved. In addition, the first detailed structural and biophysical analyses of membrane proteins retained within a biological membrane have been reported. Here we summarise and review the recent advances with respect to these new agents and systems for membrane protein extraction, reconstitution and analysis.

Atomic force microscope kymograph analysis: A case study of two membrane proteins

Kymograph analysis is employed across the biological atomic force microscopy (AFM) community to boost temporal resolution. The method is well suited for revealing protein dynamics at the single molecule level in near-native conditions. Yet, kymograph analysis comes with limitations that depend on several factors including protein geometry and instrumental drift. This work focuses on conformational dynamics of difficult-to-study sparse distributions of membrane proteins. We compare and contrast AFM kymograph analysis for two proteins, one of which (SecDF) exhibits conformational dynamics primarily in the vertical direction (normal to the membrane surface) and the other (Pgp) exhibits a combination of lateral dynamics and vertical motion. Common experimental issues are analyzed including translational and rotational drift. Conformational transition detection is evaluated via kymograph simulations followed by state detection algorithms. We find that kymograph analysis is largely robust to lateral drift. Displacement of the AFM line scan trajectory away from the protein center of mass by a few nanometers, roughly half of the molecule diameter, does not significantly affect transition detection nor generate undue dwell time errors. On the other hand, for proteins like Pgp that exhibit significant azimuthal maximum height dependence, rotational drift can potentially produce artifactual transitions. Measuring the height of a membrane protein protrusion is generally superior to measurement of width, confirming intuition based on vertical resolution superiority. In low signal-to-noise scenarios, common state detection algorithms struggle with transition detection as opposed to infinite hidden Markov models. AFM kymography represents a valuable addition to the membrane biophysics toolkit; continued hardware and software improvements are poised to expand the method's impact in the field.

The transport activity of the multidrug ABC transporter BmrA does not require a wide separation of the nucleotide-binding domains

ATP-binding cassette (ABC) transporters are ubiquitous membrane proteins responsible for the translocation of a wide diversity of substrates across biological membranes. Some of them confer multidrug or antimicrobial resistance to cancer cells and pathogenic microorganisms, respectively. Despite a wealth of structural data gained in the last two decades, the molecular mechanism of these multidrug efflux pumps remains elusive, including the extent of separation between the two nucleotide-binding domains (NBDs) during the transport cycle. Based on recent outward-facing structures of BmrA, a homodimeric multidrug ABC transporter from Bacillus subtilis, we introduced a cysteine mutation near the C-terminal end of the NBDs to analyze the impact of disulfide-bond formation on BmrA function. Interestingly, the presence of the disulfide bond between the NBDs did not prevent the ATPase, nor did it affect the transport of Hoechst 33342 and doxorubicin. Yet, the 7-amino-actinomycin D was less efficiently transported, suggesting that a further opening of the transporter might improve its ability to translocate this larger compound. We solved by cryo-EM the apo structures of the cross-linked mutant and the WT protein. Both structures are highly similar, showing an intermediate opening between their NBDs while their C-terminal extremities remain in close proximity. Distance measurements obtained by electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy support the intermediate opening found in these 3D structures. Overall, our data suggest that the NBDs of BmrA function with a tweezers-like mechanism distinct from the related lipid A exporter MsbA.

Advantages and potential limitations of applying AFM kymograph analysis to pharmaceutically relevant membrane proteins in lipid bilayers

Membrane proteins play critical roles in disease and in the disposition of many pharmaceuticals. A prime example is P-glycoprotein (Pgp) which moves a diverse range of drugs across membranes and out of the cell before a therapeutic payload can be delivered. Conventional structural biology methods have provided a valuable framework for comprehending the complex conformational changes underlying Pgp function, which also includes ATPase activity, but the lack of real-time information hinders understanding. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) is a single-molecule technique that is well-suited for studying active membrane proteins in bilayers and is poised to advance the field beyond static snapshots. After verifying Pgp activity in surface-support bilayers, we used kymograph analysis in conjunction with AFM imaging and simulations to study structural transitions at the 100 ms timescale. Though kymographs are frequently employed to boost temporal resolution, the limitations of the method have not been well characterized, especially for sparse non-crystalline distributions of pharmaceutically relevant membrane proteins like Pgp. Common experimental challenges are analyzed, including protein orientation, instrument noise, and drift. Surprisingly, a lateral drift of 75% of the protein dimension leads to only a 12% probability of erroneous state transition detection; average dwell time error achieves a maximum value of 6%. Rotational drift of proteins like Pgp, with azimuthally-dependent maximum heights, can lead to artifactual transitions. Torsional constraints can alleviate this potential pitfall. Confidence in detected transitions can be increased by adding conformation-altering ligands such as non-hydrolysable analogs. Overall, the data indicate that AFM kymographs are a viable method to access conformational dynamics for Pgp, but generalizations of the method should be made with caution.

Cross-Linking Mass Spectrometry on P-Glycoprotein

The ABC transporter P-glycoprotein (Pgp) has been found to be involved in multidrug resistance in tumor cells. Lipids and cholesterol have a pivotal role in Pgp's conformations; however, it is often difficult to investigate it with conventional structural biology techniques. Here, we applied robust approaches coupled with cross-linking mass spectrometry (XL-MS), where the natural lipid environment remains quasi-intact. Two experimental approaches were carried out using different cross-linkers (i) on living cells, followed by membrane preparation and immunoprecipitation enrichment of Pgp, and (ii) on-bead, subsequent to membrane preparation and immunoprecipitation. Pgp-containing complexes were enriched employing extracellular monoclonal anti-Pgp antibodies on magnetic beads, followed by on-bead enzymatic digestion. The LC-MS/MS results revealed mono-links on Pgp's solvent-accessible residues, while intraprotein cross-links confirmed a complex interplay between extracellular, transmembrane, and intracellular segments of the protein, of which several have been reported to be connected to cholesterol. Harnessing the MS results and those of molecular docking, we suggest an epitope for the 15D3 cholesterol-dependent mouse monoclonal antibody. Additionally, enriched neighbors of Pgp prove the strong connection of Pgp to the cytoskeleton and other cholesterol-regulated proteins. These findings suggest that XL-MS may be utilized for protein structure and network analyses in such convoluted systems as membrane proteins.

Structural mass spectrometry approaches to understand multidrug efflux systems

Multidrug efflux pumps are ubiquitous across both eukaryotes and prokaryotes, and have major implications in antimicrobial and multidrug resistance. They reside within cellular membranes and have proven difficult to study owing to their hydrophobic character and relationship with their compositionally complex lipid environment. Advances in structural mass spectrometry (MS) techniques have made it possible to study these systems to elucidate critical information on their structure-function relationships. For example, MS techniques can report on protein structural dynamics, stoichiometry, connectivity, solvent accessibility, and binding interactions with ligands, lipids, and other proteins. This information proving powerful when used in conjunction with complementary structural biology methods and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations. In the present review, aimed at those not experts in MS techniques, we report on the current uses of MS in studying multidrug efflux systems, practical considerations to consider, and the future direction of the field. In the first section, we highlight the importance of studying multidrug efflux proteins, and introduce a range of different MS techniques and explain what information they yield. In the second section, we review recent studies that have utilised MS techniques to study and characterise a range of different multidrug efflux systems.

Hydrogen/deuterium exchange-mass spectrometry of integral membrane proteins in native-like environments: current scenario and the way forward

Integral membrane proteins (IMPs) perform a range of diverse functions and their dysfunction underlies numerous pathological conditions. Consequently, IMPs constitute most drug targets, and the elucidation of their mechanism of action has become an intense field of research. Historically, IMP studies have relied on their extraction from membranes using detergents, which have the potential to perturbate their structure and dynamics. To circumnavigate this issue, an array of membrane mimetics has been developed that aim to reconstitute IMPs into native-like lipid environments that more accurately represent the biological membrane. Hydrogen/deuterium exchange-mass spectrometry (HDX-MS) has emerged as a versatile tool for probing protein dynamics in solution. The continued development of HDX-MS methodology has allowed practitioners to investigate IMPs using increasingly native-like membrane mimetics, and even pushing the study of IMPs into the in vivo cellular environment. Consequently, HDX-MS has come of age and is playing an ever-increasingly important role in the IMP structural biologist toolkit. In the present mini-review, we discuss the evolution of membrane mimetics in the HDX-MS context, focusing on seminal publications and recent innovations that have led to this point. We also discuss state-of-the-art methodological and instrumental advancements that are likely to play a significant role in the generation of high-quality HDX-MS data of IMPs in the future.

Hydrogen-deuterium exchange coupled to mass spectrometry: A multifaceted tool to decipher the molecular mechanism of transporters

Transporters regulate trafficking through the biological membrane of living cells and organelles. Therefore, these proteins play an important role in key cellular processes. Obtaining a molecular-level description of the mechanism of transporters is highly desirable to understand and modulate such processes. Different challenges currently complicate this effort, mostly due to transporters' intrinsic properties. They are dynamic and often averse to in vitro characterization. The crossing of the membrane via a transporter depends on both global and local structural changes that will enable substrate binding from one side of the membrane and release on the other. Dedicated approaches are required to monitor these dynamic changes, ideally within the complex membrane environment. Hydrogen-deuterium exchange coupled to mass spectrometry (HDX-MS) has recently emerged as a powerful biophysical tool to understand transporters' mechanism. This mini-review aims to offer to the reader an overview of the field of HDX-MS applied to transporters. It first summarizes the current workflow for HDX-MS measurements on transporters. It then provides illustrative examples on the molecular insights that are accessible thanks to the technique; following conformational transitions between different states, observing structural changes upon ligand binding and finally understanding the role of lipid-protein interactions.

Structural mass spectrometry of membrane proteins

The analysis of proteins and protein complexes by mass spectrometry (MS) has come a long way since the invention of electrospray ionization (ESI) in the mid 80s. Originally used to characterize small soluble polypeptide chains, MS has progressively evolved over the past 3 decades towards the analysis of samples of ever increasing heterogeneity and complexity, while the instruments have become more and more sensitive and resolutive. The proofs of concepts and first examples of most structural MS methods appeared in the early 90s. However, their application to membrane proteins, key targets in the biopharma industry, is more recent. Nowadays, a wealth of information can be gathered from such MS-based methods, on all aspects of membrane protein structure: sequencing (and more precisely proteoform characterization), but also stoichiometry, non-covalent ligand binding (metals, drug, lipids, carbohydrates), conformations, dynamics and distance restraints for modelling. In this review, we present the concept and some historical and more recent applications on membrane proteins, for the major structural MS methods.

Long Range Communication between the Drug-Binding Sites and Nucleotide Binding Domains of the Efflux Transporter ABCB1

The ABC efflux pump P-glycoprotein (P-gp) transports a wide variety of drugs and is inhibited by others. Some drugs stimulate ATP hydrolysis at the nucleotide binding domains (NBDs) and are transported, others uncouple ATP hydrolysis and transport, and others inhibit ATP hydrolysis. The molecular basis for the different behavior of these drugs is not well understood despite the availability of several structural models of P-gp complexes with ligands bound. Hypothetically, ligands differentially alter the conformational dynamics of peptide segments that mediate the coupling between the drug binding sites and the NBDs. Here, we explore by hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry the dynamic consequences of a classic substrate and inhibitor, vinblastine and zosuquidar, binding to mouse P-gp (mdr1a) in lipid nanodiscs. The dynamics of P-gp in nucleotide-free, pre-hydrolysis, and post-hydrolysis states in the presence of each drug reveal distinct mechanisms of ATPase stimulation and implications for transport. For both drugs, there are common regions affected in a similar manner, suggesting that particular networks are the key to stimulating ATP hydrolysis. However, drug binding effects diverge in the post-hydrolysis state, particularly in the intracellular helices (ICHs 3 and 4) and neighboring transmembrane helices. The local dynamics and conformational equilibria in this region are critical for the coupling of drug binding and ATP hydrolysis and are differentially modulated in the catalytic cycle.

Advances in Hydrogen/Deuterium Exchange Mass Spectrometry and the Pursuit of Challenging Biological Systems

Solution-phase hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX) coupled to mass spectrometry (MS) is a widespread tool for structural analysis across academia and the biopharmaceutical industry. By monitoring the exchangeability of backbone amide protons, HDX-MS can reveal information about higher-order structure and dynamics throughout a protein, can track protein folding pathways, map interaction sites, and assess conformational states of protein samples. The combination of the versatility of the hydrogen/deuterium exchange reaction with the sensitivity of mass spectrometry has enabled the study of extremely challenging protein systems, some of which cannot be suitably studied using other techniques. Improvements over the past three decades have continually increased throughput, robustness, and expanded the limits of what is feasible for HDX-MS investigations. To provide an overview for researchers seeking to utilize and derive the most from HDX-MS for protein structural analysis, we summarize the fundamental principles, basic methodology, strengths and weaknesses, and the established applications of HDX-MS while highlighting new developments and applications.

Assessing the Role of Lipids in the Molecular Mechanism of Membrane Proteins

Membrane proteins have evolved to work optimally within the complex environment of the biological membrane. Consequently, interactions with surrounding lipids are part of their molecular mechanism. Yet, the identification of lipid-protein interactions and the assessment of their molecular role is an experimental challenge. Recently, biophysical approaches have emerged that are compatible with the study of membrane proteins in an environment closer to the biological membrane. These novel approaches revealed specific mechanisms of regulation of membrane protein function. Lipids have been shown to play a role in oligomerization, conformational transitions or allosteric coupling. In this review, we summarize the recent biophysical approaches, or combination thereof, that allow to decipher the role of lipid-protein interactions in the mechanism of membrane proteins.

Transport of Alzheimer's associated amyloid-β catalyzed by P-glycoprotein

P-glycoprotein (P-gp) is a critical membrane transporter in the blood brain barrier (BBB) and is implicated in Alzheimer’s disease (AD). However, previous studies on the ability of P-gp to directly transport the Alzheimer’s associated amyloid-β (Aβ) protein have produced contradictory results. Here we use molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, transport substrate accumulation studies in cell culture, and biochemical activity assays to show that P-gp actively transports Aβ. We observed transport of Aβ40 and Aβ42 monomers by P-gp in explicit MD simulations of a putative catalytic cycle. In in vitro assays with P-gp overexpressing cells, we observed enhanced accumulation of fluorescently labeled Aβ42 in the presence of Tariquidar, a potent P-gp inhibitor. We also showed that Aβ42 stimulated the ATP hydrolysis activity of isolated P-gp in nanodiscs. Our findings expand the substrate profile of P-gp, and suggest that P-gp may contribute to the onset and progression of AD.

Active participation of membrane lipids in inhibition of multidrug transporter P-glycoprotein

P-glycoprotein (Pgp) is a major efflux pump in humans, overexpressed in a variety of cancers and associated with the development of multi-drug resistance. Allosteric modulation by various ligands (e.g., transport substrates, inhibitors, and ATP) has been biochemically shown to directly influence structural dynamics, and thereby, the function of Pgp. However, the molecular details of such effects, particularly with respect to the role and involvement of the surrounding lipids, are not well established. Here, we employ all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to study the conformational landscape of Pgp in the presence of a high-affinity, third-generation inhibitor, tariquidar, in comparison to the nucleotide-free (APO) and the ATP-bound states, in order to characterize the mechanical effects of the inhibitor that might be of relevance to its blocking mechanism of Pgp. Simulations in a multi-component lipid bilayer show a dynamic equilibrium between open(er) and more closed inward-facing (IF) conformations in the APO state, with binding of ATP shifting the equilibrium towards conformations more prone to ATP hydrolysis and subsequent events in the transport cycle. In the presence of the inhibitor bound to the drug-binding pocket within the transmembrane domain (TMD), Pgp samples more open IF conformations, and the nucleotide binding domains (NBDs) become highly dynamic. Interestingly, and reproduced in multiple independent simulations, the inhibitor is observed to facilitate recruitment of lipid molecules into the Pgp lumen through the two proposed drug-entry portals, where the lipid head groups from the cytoplasmic leaflet penetrate into and, in some cases, translocate inside the TMD, while the lipid tails remain extended into the bulk lipid environment. These "wedge" lipids likely enhance the inhibitor-induced conformational restriction of the TMD leading to the differential modulation of coupling pathways observed with the NBDs downstream. We suggest a novel inhibitory mechanism for tariquidar, and potentially for related third-generation Pgp inhibitors, where lipids are seen to enhance the inhibitory role in the catalytic cycle of membrane transporters.

Hydrogen-Deuterium Exchange Mass Spectrometry for Probing Changes in Conformation and Dynamics of Proteins

Hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX-MS) is, nowadays, an increasingly important technique in studying protein conformation and dynamics. This technique possesses the advantages of low sample consumption, less limitation in protein size, and relatively simple experimental workflow. An HDX-MS experiment typically includes the steps of sample preparation, HDX reaction, quenching of HDX reaction, protease digestion, and LC-MS analysis. Although HDX-MS has been an established technique and automatic sample handling devices are commercially available nowadays, proper experimental conditions of each step are crucial for a successful HDX-MS experiment. This chapter is to provide a general guideline for each step in the HDX-MS workflow and highlight some precautions needed to be taken in order to acquire useful conformational and dynamic information.

Cholesterol Asymmetrically Modulates the Conformational Ensemble of the Nucleotide-Binding Domains of P-Glycoprotein in Lipid Nanodiscs

P-Glycoprotein (P-gp) is an ATP-dependent efflux pump that clears a wide variety of drugs and toxins from cells. P-gp undergoes large-scale structural changes and demonstrates conformational heterogeneity even within a single catalytic or drug-bound state, although the role of heterogeneity remains unclear. P-gp is found in a variety of cell types that vary in lipid composition, which modulates its activity. An understanding of structural or dynamic changes due to the lipid environment is lacking. We aimed to determine the effects of cholesterol in a membrane on the conformational behavior of P-gp in lipid nanodiscs. The presence of cholesterol stimulates ATP hydrolysis and alters lipid order and fluidity. Hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry demonstrates that cholesterol in the membrane induces asymmetric, long-range changes in the distributions and exchange kinetics of conformations of the nucleotide-binding domains, correlating the effects of lipid composition on activity with specific changes in the P-gp conformational landscape.

Conformational maps of human 20S proteasomes reveal PA28- and immuno-dependent inter-ring crosstalks

Hydrogen-Deuterium eXchange coupled to Mass Spectrometry (HDX-MS) is now common practice in structural biology. However, it is most of the time applied to rather small oligomeric complexes. Here, we report on the use of HDX-MS to investigate conformational differences between the human standard 20S (std20S) and immuno 20S (i20s) proteasomes alone or in complex with PA28αβ or PA28γ activators. Their solvent accessibility is analyzed through a dedicated bioinformatic pipeline including stringent statistical analysis and 3D visualization. These data confirm the existence of allosteric differences between the std20S and i20S at the surface of the α-ring triggered from inside the catalytic β-ring. Additionally, binding of the PA28 regulators to the 20S proteasomes modify solvent accessibility due to conformational changes of the β-rings. This work is not only a proof-of-concept that HDX-MS can be used to get structural insights on large multi-protein complexes in solution, it also demonstrates that the binding of the std20S or i20S subtype to any of its PA28 activator triggers allosteric changes that are specific to this 20S/PA28 pair.

ATP-dependent thermostabilization of human P-glycoprotein (ABCB1) is blocked by modulators

P-glycoprotein (P-gp), an ATP-binding cassette transporter associated with multidrug resistance in cancer cells, is capable of effluxing a number of xenobiotics as well as anticancer drugs. The transport of molecules through the transmembrane (TM) region of P-gp involves orchestrated conformational changes between inward-open and inward-closed forms, the details of which are still being worked out. Here, we assessed how the binding of transport substrates or modulators in the TM region and the binding of ATP to the nucleotide-binding domains (NBDs) affect the thermostability of P-gp in a membrane environment. P-gp stability after exposure at high temperatures (37-80°C) was assessed by measuring ATPase activity and loss of monomeric P-gp. Our results show that P-gp is significantly thermostabilized (>22°C higher IT50) by the binding of ATP under non-hydrolyzing conditions (in the absence of Mg2+). By using an ATP-binding-deficient mutant (Y401A) and a hydrolysis-deficient mutant (E556Q/E1201Q), we show that thermostabilization of P-gp requires binding of ATP to both NBDs and their dimerization. Additionally, we found that transport substrates do not affect the thermal stability of P-gp either in the absence or presence of ATP; in contrast, inhibitors of P-gp including tariquidar and zosuquidar prevent ATP-dependent thermostabilization in a concentration-dependent manner, by stabilizing the inward-open conformation. Altogether, our data suggest that modulators, which bind in the TM regions, inhibit ATP hydrolysis and drug transport by preventing the ATP-dependent dimerization of the NBDs of P-gp.

Bridging protein structure, dynamics, and function using hydrogen/deuterium-exchange mass spectrometry

Much of our understanding of protein structure and mechanistic function has been derived from static high-resolution structures. As structural biology has continued to evolve it has become clear that high-resolution structures alone are unable to fully capture the mechanistic basis for protein structure and function in solution. Recently Hydrogen/Deuterium-exchange Mass Spectrometry (HDX-MS) has developed into a powerful and versatile tool for structural biologists that provides novel insights into protein structure and function. HDX-MS enables direct monitoring of a protein's structural fluctuations and conformational changes under native conditions in solution even as it is carrying out its functions. In this review, we focus on the use of HDX-MS to monitor these dynamic changes in proteins. We examine how HDX-MS has been applied to study protein structure and function in systems ranging from large, complex assemblies to intrinsically disordered proteins, and we discuss its use in probing conformational changes during protein folding and catalytic function. STATEMENT FOR A BROAD AUDIENCE: The biophysical and structural characterization of proteins provides novel insight into their functionalities. Protein motions, ranging from small scale local fluctuations to larger concerted structural rearrangements, often determine protein function. Hydrogen/Deuterium-exchange Mass Spectrometry (HDX-MS) has proven a powerful biophysical tool capable of probing changes in protein structure and dynamic protein motions that are often invisible to most other techniques.

Mechanisms of promiscuity among drug metabolizing enzymes and drug transporters

Detoxication, or 'drug-metabolizing', enzymes and drug transporters exhibit remarkable substrate promiscuity and catalytic promiscuity. In contrast to substrate-specific enzymes that participate in defined metabolic pathways, individual detoxication enzymes must cope with substrates of vast structural diversity, including previously unencountered environmental toxins. Presumably, evolution selects for a balance of 'adequate' kcat /KM values for a wide range of substrates, rather than optimizing kcat /KM for any individual substrate. However, the structural, energetic, and metabolic properties that achieve this balance, and hence optimize detoxication, are not well understood. Two features of detoxication enzymes that are frequently cited as contributions to promiscuity include the exploitation of highly reactive versatile cofactors, or cosubstrates, and a high degree of flexibility within the protein structure. This review examines these intuitive mechanisms in detail and clarifies the contributions of the classic ligand binding models 'induced fit' (IF) and 'conformational selection' (CS) to substrate promiscuity. The available literature data for drug metabolizing enzymes and transporters suggest that IF is exploited by these promiscuous detoxication enzymes, as it is with substrate-specific enzymes, but the detoxication enzymes uniquely exploit 'IFs' to retain a wide range of substrates at their active sites. In contrast, whereas CS provides no catalytic advantage to substrate-specific enzymes, promiscuous enzymes may uniquely exploit it to recruit a wide range of substrates. The combination of CS and IF, for recruitment and retention of substrates, can potentially optimize the promiscuity of drug metabolizing enzymes and drug transporters.

A glimpse into the molecular mechanism of integral membrane proteins through hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry

Integral membrane proteins (IMPs) control countless fundamental biological processes and constitute the majority of drug targets. For this reason, uncovering their molecular mechanism of action has long been an intense field of research. They are, however, notoriously difficult to work with, mainly due to their localization within the heterogeneous of environment of the biological membrane and the instability once extracted from the lipid bilayer. High‐resolution structures have unveiled many mechanistic aspects of IMPs but also revealed that the elucidation of static pictures has limitations. Hydrogen–deuterium exchange coupled to mass spectrometry (HDX‐MS) has recently emerged as a powerful biophysical tool for interrogating the conformational dynamics of proteins and their interactions with ligands. Its versatility has proven particularly useful to reveal mechanistic aspects of challenging classes of proteins such as IMPs. This review recapitulates the accomplishments of HDX‐MS as it has matured into an essential tool for membrane protein structural biologists.

Nanodiscs as a New Tool to Examine Lipid-Protein Interactions

The interactions between lipids and proteins are one of the most fundamental processes in living organisms, responsible for critical cellular events ranging from replication, cell division, signaling, and movement. Enabling the central coupling responsible for maintaining the functionality of the breadth of proteins, receptors, and enzymes that find their natural home in biological membranes, the fundamental mechanisms of recognition of protein for lipid, and vice versa, have been a focal point of biochemical and biophysical investigations for many decades. Complexes of lipids and proteins, such as the various lipoprotein factions, play central roles in the trafficking of important proteins, small molecules and metabolites and are often implicated in disease states. Recently an engineered lipoprotein particle, termed the nanodisc, a modified form of the human high density lipoprotein fraction, has served as a membrane mimetic for the investigation of membrane proteins and studies of lipid-protein interactions. In this review, we summarize the current knowledge regarding this self-assembling lipid-protein complex and provide examples for its utility in the investigation of a large number of biological systems.

Dynamics and Location of the Allosteric Midazolam Site in Cytochrome P4503A4 in Lipid Nanodiscs

Promiscuous and allosteric drug interactions with cytochrome P450 3A4 (CYP3A4) are ubiquitous but incompletely understood at the molecular level. A classic allosteric CYP3A4 drug interaction includes the benzodiazepine midazolam (MDZ). MDZ exhibits homotropic and heterotropic allostery when metabolized to 1'-hydroxy and 4-hydroxy metabolites in varying ratios. The combination of hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX-MS) and Gaussian accelerated molecular dynamics (GaMD) simulations of CYP3A4 in lipid nanodiscs and in a lipid bilayer, respectively, reveals MDZ-dependent changes in dynamics in a membrane environment. The F-, G-, and intervening helices, as well as the loop preceding the β1-sheets, display the largest observed changes in HDX. The GaMD suggests a potential allosteric binding site for MDZ in the F'- and G'-regions, which undergo significant increases in HDX at near-saturating MDZ concentrations. The HDX-MS and GaMD results confirm that changes in dynamics are most significant near the developing consensus allosteric site, and these changes are distinct from those observed previously with the nonallosteric inhibitor ketoconazole. The results suggest that the allosteric MDZ remains mobile in its binding site at the Phe-cluster. The results further suggest that this binding site remains dynamic or changes the depth of insertion in the membrane.

Dynamics of ABC Transporter P-glycoprotein in Three Conformational States

We used hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDX-MS) to obtain a comprehensive view of transporter dynamics (85.8% sequence coverage) occurring throughout the multidrug efflux transporter P-glycoprotein (P-gp) in three distinct conformational states: predominantly inward-facing apo P-gp, pre-hydrolytic (E552Q/E1197Q) P-gp bound to Mg⁺²-ATP, and outward-facing P-gp bound to Mg⁺²-ADP-VO₄⁻³. Nucleotide affinity was measured with bio-layer interferometry (BLI), which yielded kinetics data that fit a two Mg⁺²-ATP binding-site model. This model has one high affinity site (3.2 ± 0.3 µM) and one low affinity site (209 ± 25 µM). Comparison of deuterium incorporation profiles revealed asymmetry between the changes undergone at the critical interfaces where nucleotide binding domains (NBDs) contact intracellular helices (ICHs). In the pre-hydrolytic state, both interfaces between ICHs and NBDs decreased exchange to similar extents relative to inward-facing P-gp. In the outward-facing state, the ICH-NBD1 interface showed decreased exchange, while the ICH-NBD2 interface showed less of an effect. The extracellular loops (ECLs) showed reduced deuterium uptake in the pre-hydrolytic state, consistent with an occluded conformation. While in the outward-facing state, increased ECL exchange corresponding to EC domain opening was observed. These findings point toward asymmetry between both NBDs, and they suggest that pre-hydrolytic P-gp occupies an occluded conformation.

Cryo-EM structure of OSCA1.2 from Oryza sativa elucidates the mechanical basis of potential membrane hyperosmolality gating

Sensing and responding to environmental water deficiency and osmotic stresses are essential for the growth, development, and survival of plants. Recently, an osmolality-sensing ion channel called OSCA1 was discovered that functions in sensing hyperosmolality in Arabidopsis Here, we report the cryo-electron microscopy (cryo-EM) structure and function of an OSCA1 homolog from rice (Oryza sativa; OsOSCA1.2), leading to a model of how it could mediate hyperosmolality sensing and transport pathway gating. The structure reveals a dimer; the molecular architecture of each subunit consists of 11 transmembrane (TM) helices and a cytosolic soluble domain that has homology to RNA recognition proteins. The TM domain is structurally related to the TMEM16 family of calcium-dependent ion channels and lipid scramblases. The cytosolic soluble domain possesses a distinct structural feature in the form of extended intracellular helical arms that are parallel to the plasma membrane. These helical arms are well positioned to potentially sense lateral tension on the inner leaflet of the lipid bilayer caused by changes in turgor pressure. Computational dynamic analysis suggests how this domain couples to the TM portion of the molecule to open a transport pathway. Hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (HDXMS) experimentally confirms the conformational dynamics of these coupled domains. These studies provide a framework to understand the structural basis of proposed hyperosmolality sensing in a staple crop plant, extend our knowledge of the anoctamin superfamily important for plants and fungi, and provide a structural mechanism for potentially translating membrane stress to transport regulation.

Substrate-induced conformational dynamics of the dopamine transporter

The dopamine transporter is a member of the neurotransmitter:sodium symporters (NSSs), which are responsible for termination of neurotransmission through Na+-driven reuptake of neurotransmitter from the extracellular space. Experimental evidence elucidating the coordinated conformational rearrangements related to the transport mechanism has so far been limited. Here we probe the global Na+- and dopamine-induced conformational dynamics of the wild-type Drosophila melanogaster dopamine transporter using hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry. We identify Na+- and dopamine-induced changes in specific regions of the transporter, suggesting their involvement in protein conformational transitions. Furthermore, we detect ligand-dependent slow cooperative fluctuations of helical stretches in several domains of the transporter, which could be a molecular mechanism that assists in the transporter function. Our results provide a framework for understanding the molecular mechanism underlying the function of NSSs by revealing detailed insight into the state-dependent conformational changes associated with the alternating access model of the dopamine transporter.

Hydrogen-deuterium exchange mass spectrometry of membrane proteins in lipid nanodiscs

Hydrogen deuterium exchange mass spectrometry (H/DX MS) provides a quantitative comparison of the relative rates of exchange of amide protons for solvent deuterons. In turn, the rate of amide exchange depends on a complex combination of the stability of local secondary structure, solvent accessibility, and dynamics. H/DX MS has, therefore, been widely used to probe structure and function of soluble proteins, but its application to membrane proteins was limited previously to detergent solubilized samples. The large excess of lipids from model membranes, or from membrane fractions derived from in vivo samples, presents challenges with mass spectrometry. The lipid nanodisc platform, consisting of apolipoprotein A-derived membrane scaffold proteins, provides a native like membrane environment in which to capture analyte membrane proteins with a well defined, and low, ratio of lipid to protein. Membrane proteins in lipid nanodiscs are amenable to H/DX MS, and this is expected to lead to a rapid increase in the number of membrane proteins subjected to this analysis. Here we review the few literature examples of the application of H/DX MS to membrane proteins in nanodiscs. The incremental improvements in the experimental workflow of the H/DX MS are described and potential applications of this approach to study membrane proteins are described.

The hydrodynamic motion of Nanodiscs

We present a fluorescence-based methodology for monitoring the rotational dynamics of Nanodiscs. Nanodiscs are nano-scale lipid bilayers surrounded by a helical membrane scaffold protein (MSP) that have found considerable use in studying the interactions between membrane proteins and their lipid bilayer environment. Using a long-lifetime Ruthenium label covalently attached to the Nanodiscs, we find that Nanodiscs of increasing diameter, made by varying the number of helical repeats in the MSP, display increasing rotational correlation times. We also model our system using both analytical equations that describe rotating spheroids and numerical calculations performed on atomic models of Nanodiscs. Using these methods, we observe a linear relationship between the experimentally determined rotational correlation times and those calculated from both analytical equations and numerical solutions. This work sets the stage for accurate, label-free quantification of protein-lipid interactions at the membrane surface.

Substrate polyspecificity and conformational relevance in ABC transporters: new insights from structural studies

Transport of molecules and ions across biological membranes is an essential process in all organisms. It is carried out by a range of evolutionarily conserved primary and secondary transporters. A significant portion of the primary transporters belong to the ATP-binding cassette (ABC) superfamily, which utilise the free-energy from ATP hydrolysis to shuttle many different substrates across various biological membranes, and consequently, are involved in both normal and abnormal physiology. In humans, ABC transporter-associated pathologies are perhaps best exemplified by multidrug-resistance transporters that efflux many xenobiotic compounds due to their remarkable substrate polyspecificity. Accordingly, understanding the transport mechanism(s) is of great significance, and indeed, much progress has been made in recent years, particularly from structural studies on ABC exporters. Consequently, the general mechanism of 'alternate access' has been modified to describe individual transporter nuances, though some aspects of the transport process remain unclear. Moreover, as new information has emerged, the physiological relevance of the 'open-apo' conformation of MsbA (a bacterial exporter) has been questioned and, by extension, its contribution to mechanistic models. We present here a comprehensive overview of the most recently solved structures of ABC exporters, focusing on new insights regarding the nature of substrate polyspecificity and the physiological relevance of the 'open-apo' conformation. This review evaluates the claim that the latter may be an artefact of detergent solubilisation, and we hypothesise that the biophysical properties of the membrane play a key role in the function of ABC exporters allowing them to behave like a 'spring-hinge' during their transport cycle.

Evidence for the critical role of transmembrane helices 1 and 7 in substrate transport by human P-glycoprotein (ABCB1)

P-glycoprotein (P-gp) is an ABC transporter that exports many amphipathic or hydrophobic compounds, including chemically and functionally dissimilar anticancer drugs, from cells. To understand the role of transmembrane helices (TMH) 1 and 7 in drug-binding and transport, we selected six residues from both TMH1 (V53, I59, I60, L65, M68 and F72) and TMH7 (V713, I719, I720, Q725, F728 and F732); and substituted them with alanine by gene synthesis to generate a variant termed "TMH1,7 mutant P-gp". The expression and function of TMH1,7 mutant P-gp with twelve mutations was characterized using the BacMam baculovirus-HeLa cell expression system. The expression and conformation of TMH1,7 mutant P-gp was not altered by the introduction of the twelve mutations, as confirmed by using the human P-gp-specific antibodies UIC2, MRK16 and 4E3. We tested 25 fluorescently-labeled substrates and found that only three substrates, NBD-cyclosporine A, Rhod-2-AM and X-Rhod-1-AM were transported by the TMH1,7 mutant. The basal ATPase activity of TMH1,7 mutant P-gp was lower (40-50%) compared to wild-type (WT) P-gp, despite similar level of expression. Although most of the substrates modulate ATPase activity of P-gp, the activity of TMH1,7 mutant transporter was not significantly modulated by any of the tested substrates. Docking of selected substrates in homology models showed comparable docking scores for the TMH1,7 mutant and WT P-gp, although the binding conformations were different. Both the ATPase assay and in silico docking analyses suggest that the interactions with residues in the drug-binding pocket are altered as a consequence of the mutations. We demonstrate that it is possible to generate a variant of P-gp with a loss of broad substrate specificity and propose that TMH1 and TMH7 play a critical role in the drug efflux function of this multidrug transporter.

The conformation and dynamics of P-glycoprotein in a lipid bilayer investigated by atomic force microscopy

The membrane-bound P-glycoprotein (Pgp) transporter plays a major role in human disease and drug disposition because of its ability to efflux a chemically diverse range of drugs through ATP hydrolysis and ligand-induced conformational changes. Deciphering these structural changes is key to understanding the molecular basis of transport and to developing molecules that can modulate efflux. Here, atomic force microscopy (AFM) is used to directly image individual Pgp transporter molecules in a lipid bilayer under physiological pH and ambient temperature. Analysis of the Pgp AFM images revealed "small" and "large" protrusions from the lipid bilayer with significant differences in protrusion height and volume. The geometry of these "small" and "large" protrusions correlated to the predicted extracellular (EC) and cytosolic (C) domains of the Pgp X-ray crystal structure, respectively. To assign these protrusions, simulated AFM images were produced from the Pgp X-ray crystal structures with membrane planes defined by three computational approaches, and a simulated 80 Å AFM cantilever tip. The theoretical AFM images of the EC and C domains had similar heights and volumes to the "small" and "large" protrusions in the experimental AFM images, respectively. The assignment of the protrusions in the AFM images to the EC and C domains was confirmed by changes in protrusion volume by Pgp-specific antibodies. The Pgp domains showed a considerable degree of conformational dynamics in time resolved AFM images. With this information, a model of Pgp conformational dynamics in a lipid bilayer is proposed within the context of the known Pgp X-ray crystal structures.