A COMPARISON OF PERIPHERAL NERVE REGENERATION IN ACELLULAR MUSCLE AND NERVE AUTOGRAFTS

Fabrication and characterization of 3D microtubular collagen scaffolds for peripheral nerve repair

Understanding the structure-function relationship in biomaterial constructs is critical in optimizing biological outcomes. For ensheathed structures such as peripheral nerve, engineering implantable tissue substitutes has been challenging. This is due to a unique geometry of thin-walled microtube arrays composed mostly of basement membrane. In this work, we propose a sacrificial templating method to create Matrigel scaffolds that resemble endogenous peripheral nerve. These paralleled microtube constructs possess high void space and membrane-like walls. Additionally, we investigated the effect of chemical crosslinking in altering the physical, mechanical, and biologic properties of Matrigel. Results show that both glutaraldehyde and genipin increased the modulus and failure stress of Matrigel while also improving degradation resistance. However, glutaraldehyde crosslinking induced some cytotoxicity whereas genipin showed good biocompatibility. PC-12 cells, Schwann cells, and primary chick dorsal root ganglia cultured onto microtube scaffolds demonstrated viability up to 10 days. Strong cellular alignment along the channels was observed in Schwann cells whereas neurite outgrowth in primary chick dorsal root ganglia was also biased along the major axis of the microtubes. This suggests that the microtubes may mediate cell orientation and axon pathfinding. This proof of concept study provides a tunable workflow that may be adapted to other collagen types.

Inferior alveolar nerve regeneration after bifocal distraction osteogenesis in dogs

PURPOSE

Bifocal distraction osteogenesis has been shown to be a reliable method for reconstructing missing bone segments. However, no reports have been published regarding inferior alveolar nerve regeneration during this procedure. We assumed that the nerve could regenerate with the bone regeneration during bifocal distraction, if the nerve had been saved at a mesial site of the transport disc. In the present study, we investigated that possibility in dogs.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Using a bifocal distraction osteogenesis method, we produced a 10-mm mandibular defect, including the nerve defect, and distracted the transport disc at a rate of 1 mm/day in 12 dogs. The nerve was saved at the mesial site of the transport disc. The regenerated nerve was evaluated by a jaw opening reflex examination performed once daily. Histologic examinations with hematoxylin-eosin and immunohistochemical staining with neurofilament and S-100 antibody were also performed on all dogs after death at 3, 6, and 12 months after the first operation.

RESULTS

The jaw opening reflex had recovered in all dogs. The average period of recovery was 109.5 ± 24.7 days. On histologic examination, although consecutive nerves were observed in all areas, cellular nerve fascicles were seen, consistent with wallerian degeneration at 3 and 6 months in the nerve connection area on the distal side of the transport disc.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results have indicated that inferior alveolar nerve regeneration after bifocal distraction osteogenesis is successful in dogs. Although our research is still at the stage of animal experiments, future application in humans can be considered to be possible.

Standardized criterion to analyze and directly compare various materials and models for peripheral nerve regeneration

Progress in understanding conditions for optimal peripheral nerve regeneration has been stunted due to lack of standardization of experimental conditions and assays. In this paper we review the large database that has been generated using the Lundborg nerve chamber model and compare various theories for their ability to explain the experimental data. Data were normalized based on systematic use of the critical axon elongation, the gap length at which the probability of axon reconnection between the stumps is just 50%. Use of this criterion has led to a rank-ordering of devices or treatments and has led, in turn, to conclusions about the conditions that facilitate regeneration. Experimental configurations that have maximized facilitation of peripheral nerve regeneration are those in which the tube wall comprised degradable polymers, including collagen and certain synthetic biodegradable polymers, and was cell-permeable rather than protein-permeable. Tube fillings that showed very high regenerative activity were suspensions of Schwann cells, a solution either of acidic or basic fibroblast growth factor, insoluble ECM substrates rather than solutions or gels, polyamide filaments oriented along the tube axis and highly porous, insoluble analogs of the ECM with specific structure and controlled degradation rate. It is suggested that the data are best explained by postulating that the quality of regeneration depends on two critical processes. The first is compression of stumps and regenerating nerve by a thick myofibroblast layer that surrounds these tissues and blocks synthesis of a nerve of large diameter (pressure cuff theory). The second is synthesis of linear columns of Schwann cells that serve as tracks for axon elongation (basement membrane microtube theory). It is concluded that experimental configurations that show high regenerative activity suppress the first process while facilitating the second.

Toward engineering functional organ modules by additive manufacturing

Tissue engineering is emerging as a possible alternative to methods aimed at alleviating the growing demand for replacement tissues and organs. A major pillar of most tissue engineering approaches is the scaffold, a biocompatible network of synthetic or natural polymers, which serves as an extracellular matrix mimic for cells. When the scaffold is seeded with cells it is supposed to provide the appropriate biomechanical and biochemical conditions for cell proliferation and eventual tissue formation. Numerous approaches have been used to fabricate scaffolds with ever-growing complexity. Recently, novel approaches have been pursued that do not rely on artificial scaffolds. The most promising ones utilize matrices of decellularized organs or methods based on multicellular self-assembly, such as sheet-based and bioprinting-based technologies. We briefly overview some of the scaffold-free approaches and detail one that employs biological self-assembly and bioprinting. We describe the technology and its specific applications to engineer vascular and nerve grafts.

The use of anabolic steroids as a strategy in reversing denervation atrophy after delayed nerve repair

BACKGROUND

Denervation atrophy is one factor contributing to suboptimal motor recovery following major nerve repair. The hypertrophic effects of anabolic steroids may have a potential role in improving reinnervated muscle strength after delayed repair.

METHODS

Forty-five immature female Sprague-Dawley rats underwent three surgeries and final testing. The tibial nerve was transected in the hind limb of the experimental (n = 13) and control (n = 14) animals and exposed, but not transected in the sham (n = 15) group animals. Three months later, once denervation atrophy was established, all transected nerves underwent repair using an autograft from the contralateral limb. After waiting an additional month to allow axonal regeneration to the gastrocnemius muscles, the rodents were implanted with a subcutaneous infusion pump. For the experimental group, nandrolone was administered over the next 30 days via this pump, while the control and sham group pumps were filled with carrier only.

RESULTS

Final testing, 6 weeks later, showed improved muscle contraction strength in the steroid-treated animals (72% of sham group strength) compared to control animals (57% of sham group strength, p < 0.5). A trend towards increased weight and muscle belly diameter in the steroid-treated group was not statistically significant.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings support the potential role of anabolic steroids in improving recovery of atrophic muscle after delayed reinnervation.

Radial nerve repair using an autologous denatured muscle graft: comparison with outcomes of nerve graft repair

BACKGROUND

The efficiency of denatured muscle grafting in nerve repair has been confirmed in experimental models and animals. The first clinical trials to repair digital nerves and mixed sensory-motor nerves were encouraging regarding sensory recovery but motor recovery was poor, probably because of delayed repair. We present the functional outcome of repair of motor nerves using denatured muscle graft and compare the results with those using standard nerve graft techniques.

METHODS

This prospective study included 9 radial nerve defects repaired with denatured muscle grafts and 23 radial nerve defects repaired using nerve grafts. Missile induced nerve injury, mid-arm level of lesion, a nerve gap smaller than 6 cm, and a preoperative interval of less than 5 months were characteristics shared by all patients. None of the patients had concomitant vascular injury, severe scarring, or significant soft tissue damage in the region of nerve repair. Motor recovery was estimated with 0-5 points, at least 4.7 years after surgery, according to the BMRC scale.

RESULTS

A successful outcome (>or=M3) was achieved in 7 out of the 9 patients treated using a muscle graft and in 21 out of the 23 patients treated using nerve grafts (P > 0.05). Excellent recovery and the clinically significant re-establishment of thumb extension (M5 grade) were never achieved in the patients treated using muscle grafts. The average motor score was significantly better in patients treated with nerve grafts than in those who received muscle grafts (3.8 +/- 0.9 and 3.2 +/- 0.8; P = 0.035). With the patients who received muscle grafts, an inverse correlation existed between motor recovery and the length of the nerve gap (P = 0.017).

CONCLUSIONS

Denatured muscle grafts can be useful for bridging short radial nerve defects, but the quality of recovery is significantly worse than after nerve graft repair. Even if relatively short nerve defects are bridged with denatured muscle grafts, the outcomes correlate inversely with the length of the gap.

Saliva Secretion Stimulated by Grafted Nerve in Submandibular Gland Allograft in Dogs

BACKGROUND

Recent studies have described submandibular gland allografts in animal models; however, the amount of saliva secretion or nervous regeneration in those animals have not been reported. Herein, we investigated saliva secretion from submandibular gland allografts in beagle dogs.

METHODS

Using a vascularized submandibular gland transplantation method, we extracted portions of the submandibular gland including the duct from beagle dogs and placed them into the submental region of age- and weight-matched dogs. Differences in the amount of saliva secretion and histologic appearance were compared based on the existence of chorda tympani branches in the allograft.

RESULTS

At 10 weeks after transplantation, the amount of resting saliva in the group grafted with the nerve was clearly increased, whereas the quantity of that in the group that underwent transplantation without the nerve was quite low. In the former group, responses were demonstrated after taste stimulation and electronic nerve stimulation.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results showed a clear relationship between the presence of a nerve in grafted submandibular glands and saliva secretion.

Possibility of using nerve segments dissected from human cadavers for grafting: preliminary report

An intercostal nerve obtained from a human cadaver 6 h post-mortem was transplanted into the rat sciatic nerve and nerve regeneration was observed 4 and 8 weeks after surgery. Sciatic nerves from deceased rats up to 2 days post-mortem were also transplanted for comparison. Good nerve regeneration was observed through the human cadaver-derived graft to the distal segment at the medial plantal nerve 8 weeks after surgery. The results of the present study indicate the possibility that nerves from human cadavers can be used for nerve grafting in clinical applications.

The course of aberrant reinnervation following nerve repair with fresh or denatured muscle autografts

Denatured muscle grafts obtained by freeze thawing have been proposed to replace losses in the peripheral nerves. In the present report, we compare the performance of such grafts with fresh grafts in the rat median nerve. A long-term effect of muscle interposition on reinnervation was studied by behavioral assessment, muscle ATPase histochemistry, and retrograde labeling of motoneurons. There was no difference in grasping strength recovery between fresh and denatured 10-mm-long muscle grafts. Recovery was delayed and incomplete. Twelve months after surgery, only 50% of the normal grasping strength was attained. Grasping recovery was not observed in the 20-mm-long graft groups. Pathway reinnervation was non-specific with a huge amount of motor fiber misdirection. A decrease in the number of misdirected motor fibers occurred with time and activity recovery. Muscle reinnervation was not specific with disturbance of the mosaic pattern and type-grouping formation. Preference of type I axons for reinnervating deeper zones was observed. Type I aberrant reinnervation was demonstrated in the muscle periphery. The mosaic distribution of type I and II muscle fibers was not stable, and readjustments were observed with time, correlating with grasping improvement. During grasping strength recovery, there was a decrease in the number of type I fibers peripherally located and an increase of those deeply disposed. A time- and activity-related recovery was associated with readjustment in the pathways and muscle fiber rearrangement. We suggest that muscle activity generates specificity.