Automated signal quality assessment of mobile phone-recorded heart sound signals

Reference free auscultation quality metric and its trends

Stethoscopes are used ubiquitously in clinical settings to 'listen' to lung sounds. The use of these systems in a variety of healthcare environments (hospitals, urgent care rooms, private offices, community sites, mobile clinics, etc.) presents a range of challenges in terms of ambient noise and distortions that mask lung signals from being heard clearly or processed accurately using auscultation devices. With advances in technology, computerized techniques have been developed to automate analysis or access a digital rendering of lung sounds. However, most approaches are developed and tested in controlled environments and do not reflect real-world conditions where auscultation signals are typically acquired. Without a priori access to a recording of the ambient noise (for signal-to-noise estimation) or a reference signal that reflects the true undistorted lung sound, it is difficult to evaluate the quality of the lung signal and its potential clinical interpretability. The current study proposes an objective reference-free Auscultation Quality Metric (AQM) which incorporates low-level signal attributes with high-level representational embeddings mapped to a nonlinear quality space to provide an independent evaluation of the auscultation quality. This metric is carefully designed to solely judge the signal based on its integrity relative to external distortions and masking effects and not confuse an adventitious breathing pattern as low-quality auscultation. The current study explores the robustness of the proposed AQM method across multiple clinical categorizations and different distortion types. It also evaluates the temporal sensitivity of this approach and its translational impact for deployment in digital auscultation devices.

Automated Quality Assessment for Accelerometer-Based Heart Sounds Recorded with a Novel Subcutaneous Medical Implant

In the context of monitoring patients with heart failure conditions, the automated assessment of heart sound quality is of major importance to insure the relevance of the medical analysis of the heart sound data. We propose in this study a technique of quality classification based on the selection of a small set of representative features. The first features are chosen to characterize whether the periodicity, complexity or statistical nature of the heart sound recordings. After segmentation process, the latter features are probing the detectability of the heart sounds in cardiac cycles. Our method is applied on a novel subcutaneous medical implant that combines ECG and accelerometric-based heart sound measurements. The actual prototype is in pre-clinical phase and has been implanted on 4 pigs, which anatomy and activity constitute a challenging environment for obtaining clean heart sounds. As reference quality labeling, we have performed a three-class manual annotation of each recording, qualified as "good", "unsure" and "bad". Our method allows to retrieve good quality heart sounds with a sensitivity and an accuracy of 82% ± 2% and 88% ± 6% respectively. Clinical Relevance- By accurately recovering high quality heart sound sequences, our method will enable to monitor reliable physiological indicators of heart failure complications such as decompensation.

An audio processing pipeline for acquiring diagnostic quality heart sounds via mobile phone

Recently, heart sound signals captured using mobile phones have been employed to develop data-driven heart disease detection systems. Such signals are generally captured in person by trained clinicians who can determine if the recorded heart sounds are of diagnosable quality. However, mobile phones have the potential to support heart health diagnostics, even where access to trained medical professionals is limited. To adopt mobile phones as self-diagnostic tools for the masses, we would need to have a mechanism to automatically establish that heart sounds recorded by non-expert users in uncontrolled conditions have the required quality for diagnostic purposes. This paper proposes a quality assessment and enhancement pipeline for heart sounds captured using mobile phones. The pipeline analyzes a heart sound and determines if it has the required quality for diagnostic tasks. Also, in cases where the quality of the captured signal is below the required threshold, the pipeline can improve the quality by applying quality enhancement algorithms. Using this pipeline, we can also provide feedback to users regarding the cause of low-quality signal capture and guide them towards a successful one. We conducted a survey of a group of thirteen clinicians with auscultation skills and experience. The results of this survey were used to inform and validate the proposed quality assessment and enhancement pipeline. We observed a high level of agreement between the survey results and fundamental design decisions within the proposed pipeline. Also, the results indicate that the proposed pipeline can reduce our dependency on trained clinicians for capture of diagnosable heart sounds.

Automated Assessment of the Quality of Phonocardographic Recordings through Signal-to-Noise Ratio for Home Monitoring Applications

The signal quality limits the applicability of phonocardiography at the patients’ domicile. This work proposes the signal-to-noise ratio of the recorded signal as its main quality metrics. Moreover, we define the minimum acceptable values of the signal-to-noise ratio that warrantee an accuracy of the derived parameters acceptable in clinics. We considered 25 original heart sounds recordings, which we corrupted by adding noise to decrease their signal-to-noise ratio. We found that a signal-to-noise ratio equal to or higher than 14 dB warrants an uncertainty of the estimate of the valve closure latencies below 1 ms. This accuracy is higher than that required by most clinical applications. We validated the proposed method against a public database, obtaining results comparable to those obtained on our sample population. In conclusion, we defined (a) the signal-to-noise ratio of the phonocardiographic signal as the preferred metric to evaluate its quality and (b) the minimum values of the signal-to-noise ratio required to obtain an uncertainty of the latency of heart sound components compatible with clinical applications. We believe these results are crucial for the development of home monitoring systems aimed at preventing acute episodes of heart failure and that can be safely operated by naïve users.

Automated Signal Quality Assessment for Heart Sound Signal by Novel Features and Evaluation in Open Public Datasets

Automated heart sound signal quality assessment is a necessary step for reliable analysis of heart sound signal. An unavoidable processing step for this objective is the heart sound segmentation, which is still a challenging task from a technical viewpoint. In this study, ten features are defined to evaluate the quality of heart sound signal without segmentation. The ten features come from kurtosis, energy ratio, frequency-smoothed envelope, and degree of sound periodicity, where five of them are novel in signal quality assessment. We have collected a total of 7893 recordings from open public heart sound databases and performed manual annotation for each recording as gold standard quality label. The signal quality is classified based on two schemes: binary classification (“unacceptable” and “acceptable”) and triple classification (“unacceptable”, “good,” and “excellent”). Sequential forward feature selection shows that the feature “the degree of periodicity” gives an accuracy rate of 73.1% in binary SVM classification. The top five features dominate the classification performance and give an accuracy rate of 92%. The binary classifier has excellent generalization ability since the accuracy rate reaches to (90.4 ± 0.5) % even if 10% of the data is used to train the classifier. The rate increases to (94.3 ± 0.7) % in 10-fold validation. The triple classification has an accuracy rate of (85.7 ± 0.6) % in 10-fold validation. The results verify the effectiveness of the signal quality assessment, which could serve as a potential candidate as a preprocessing in future automatic heart sound analysis in clinical application.

Neonatal Heart and Lung Sound Quality Assessment for Robust Heart and Breathing Rate Estimation for Telehealth Applications

With advances in digital stethoscopes, internet of things, signal processing and machine learning, chest sounds can be easily collected and transmitted to the cloud for remote monitoring and diagnosis. However, low quality of recordings complicates remote monitoring and diagnosis, particularly for neonatal care. This paper proposes a new method to objectively and automatically assess the signal quality to improve the accuracy and reliability of heart rate (HR) and breathing rate (BR) estimation from noisy neonatal chest sounds. A total of 88 10-second long chest sounds were taken from 76 preterm and full-term babies. Six annotators independently assessed the signal quality, number of detectable beats, and breathing periods from these recordings. For quality classification, 187 and 182 features were extracted from heart and lung sounds, respectively. After feature selection, class balancing, and hyperparameter optimization, a dynamic binary classification model was trained. Then HR and BR were automatically estimated from the chest sound and several approaches were compared.The results of subject-wise leave-one-out cross-validation, showed that the model distinguished high and low quality recordings in the test set with 96% specificity, 81% sensitivity and 93% accuracy for heart sounds, and 86% specificity, 69% sensitivity and 82% accuracy for lung sounds. The HR and BR estimated from high quality sounds resulted in significantly less median absolute error (4 bpm and 12 bpm difference, respectively) compared to those from low quality sounds. The methods presented in this work, facilitates automated neonatal chest sound auscultation for future telehealth applications.

Stretchable Composite Acoustic Transducer for Wearable Monitoring of Vital Signs

A highly flexible, stretchable, and mechanically robust low-cost soft composite consisting of silicone polymers and water (or hydrogels) is reported. When combined with conventional acoustic transducers, the materials reported enable high performance real-time monitoring of heart and respiratory patterns over layers of clothing (or furry skin of animals) without the need for direct contact with the skin. The approach enables an entirely new method of fabrication that involves encapsulation of water and hydrogels with silicones and exploits the ability of sound waves to travel through the body. The system proposed outperforms commercial, metal-based stethoscopes for the auscultation of the heart when worn over clothing and is less susceptible to motion artefacts. The system both with human and furry animal subjects (i.e., dogs), primarily focusing on monitoring the heart, is tested; however, initial results on monitoring breathing are also presented. This work is especially important because it is the first demonstration of a stretchable sensor that is suitable for use with furry animals and does not require shaving of the animal for data acquisition.

Automatic Signal Quality Index Determination of Radar-Recorded Heart Sound Signals Using Ensemble Classification

OBJECTIVE

Radar technology promises to be a touchless and thereby burden-free method for continuous heart sound monitoring, which can be used to detect cardiovascular diseases. However, the first and most crucial step is to differentiate between high- and low-quality segments in a recording to assess their suitability for a subsequent automated analysis. This paper gives a comprehensive study on this task and first addresses the specific characteristics of radar-recorded heart sound signals.

METHODS

To gather heart sound signals recorded from radar, a bistatic radar system was built and installed at the university hospital. Under medical supervision, heart sound data were recorded from 30 healthy test subjects. The signals were segmented and labeled as high- or low-quality by a medical expert. Different state-of-the-art pattern classification algorithms were evaluated for the task of automated signal quality determination and the most promising one was optimized and evaluated using leave-one-subject-out cross validation.

RESULTS

The proposed classifier is able to achieve an accuracy of up to 96.36% and demonstrates a superior classification performance compared with the state-of-the-art classifier with a maximum accuracy of 76.00%.

CONCLUSION

This paper introduces an ensemble classifier that is able to perform automated signal quality determination of radar-recorded heart sound signals with a high accuracy.

SIGNIFICANCE

Besides achieving a higher performance compared with state-of-the-art classifiers, this study is the first one to deal with the quality determination of heart sounds that are recorded by radar systems. The proposed method enables contactless and continuous heart sound monitoring for the detection of cardiovascular diseases.

Development of a Low-Cost Wireless Phonocardiograph With a Bluetooth Headset under Resource-Limited Conditions

Commercially available digital stethoscopes can be used as a phonocardiograph to record heart sounds. However, procuring a costly digital stethoscope may not be possible under resource-limited conditions. A low-cost, wire connected, and mobile phone-assisted phonocardiograph has been reported previously. The aim of this study was to develop a low-cost and wireless phonocardiograph for resource-limited settings. A Bluetooth headset was dismantled to find its microphone. A stethoscope ear knob was cut to make a small bell and it was attached to the microphone. This modified Bluetooth headset was capable of recording sounds while connected to a mobile device with audio recording application. The modified Bluetooth headset, mobile phone, and audio recording software can serve as a wireless phonocardiograph (WiPCGh). Heart sounds were successfully recorded with the help of the newly developed WiPCGh. The audio files were shared with a personal computer (PC) via Bluetooth. The wave form was analyzed in a PC-based audio editing application. First and second heart sounds with systolic and diastolic murmur were identified. WiPCGh can be utilized in recording heart sounds for academic and telemedicine purposes. However, the capability of WiPCGh in the diagnosis of cardiac diseases is yet to be explored in future studies.

Novel features from autocorrelation and spectrum to classify Phonocardiogram quality

Phonocardiogram (PCG) or auscultation via a stethoscope forms the basis of preliminary medical screening. But PCG recorded in an uncontrolled environment is inherently noisy. In this paper we have derived novel features from the spectral domain and autocorrelation waveforms. These are used to identify the quality of a PCG recording and accepting only diagnosable quality recordings for further analysis. These features proved to be robust irrespective of variations in devices and in data collection protocols employed to ensure consistent data quality. A freely available, large, diverse, medical-grade PCG dataset was used for creating the training models. Results show that the proposed methodology yields an accuracy score of ~75% on our in-house PCG dataset, collected using a low-cost smartphone-based digital stethoscope.