The experience of having a positive HIV antibody test

Factors affecting GUM clinic attenders decisions and intentions to seek HIV testing

Objectives: To evaluate factors that predict HIV testing using the model of health care utilisation as its conceptual framework and to analyse some of the factors that encourage or inhibit seeking an HIV test in this population.

Method: A cross sectional questionnaire study in two Genito-Urinary Medicine (GUM) clinics in central Scotland. A final sample of 195 represented a 91% response rate. Participants were categorised by their HIV testing status (already tested, planning to be tested, no intention to seek testing).

Results: The ‘already tested’ and ‘planning to be tested’ groups were combined as there were no significant differences on reported risk behaviours. Analysis therefore compared two groups those ‘testing’ (n = 66) and ‘not testing’ (n = 129). 67% of those not tested for HIV reported at least one HIV risk factor. Perceived risk was the strongest predictor of HIV testing using our model. Perception of risk and actual risk were not correlated. Those not seeking testing endorsed less benefits of testing and more denial of the need to be tested. Same day testing and testing without an appointment were endorsed as factors to promote testing.

Conclusion: To encourage people who have high risk factors to access HIV testing, programmes should: (1) highlight the benefits of testing which would be lost if people do not test, eg. effective drug treatments (2) increase the range of HIV testing services available (eg. same day testing). Furthermore, studies to determine the main predictors of perceived risk are needed if we are to increase testing in relevant populations.

Re-appraising HIV Testing among Scottish Gay Men: The Impact of New HIV Treatments

This paper explores Scottish gay men's understandings of HIV testing within the context of changes stemming from the availability of new treatments for HIV. Transcripts of one-toone interviews with 18 gay men were analysed together with those from four focus groups (n= 19) concerning HIV testing, HIV status and HIV risk management. Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis was employed to identify recurrent themes. We focus upon a rise of HIV-optimism, risk-complacency and HIV fatigue and chart the apparent transformation of HIV diagnosis from 'death sentence' to 'life sentence'. In turn, we explore how these changes have impacted upon HIV testing. As HIV management becomes increasingly medicalized, we highlight the ongoing need to attend to psychological and social issues.

Impact on HIV test providers of giving a positive test result

The provision of a positive HIV antibody test result and the direction and support given to the test recipient are critical components of care and prevention. There has been little research that describes what happens in such interactions between recipient and provider. The impact on the test provider of delivering the HIV test result is an important issue to consider. The discomfort experienced by some health providers in giving a positive test result may have adverse effects on the client interaction or may carry over into subsequent client interactions. Utilizing a thematic analysis on interview data from 24 HIV test providers, we describe the impact of delivering a positive test result on HIV test providers, identify the factors that influence this impact, and describe strategies used to manage the impact. As with other health care professionals communicating "bad news,"HIV test providers experience a variety of impacts. While a small number of providers indicated little or no impact of delivering the HIV positive test result because the diagnosis is ''not the end of the world,'' most indicated it was difficult as it was anticipated that the test recipient would (or did) find the news distressing. Several coping strategies were identified.

The utilization of testing and counseling for HIV: a review of the social and behavioral evidence

Against the background of debates about expanding HIV testing and counseling, we summarize the evidence on the social and behavioral dimension of testing and its implications for programs. The discrepancy between acceptance of testing and returning for results and the difficulties of disclosure are examined in light of research on risk perceptions and the influence of gender and stigma. We also summarize the evidence on the provision of testing and counseling, the implementation of practices regarding confidentiality and consent, and the results of interventions. We demonstrate that social factors have a considerable impact on testing, show that the services linked to testing are key determinants of utilization, and consider the implications of these findings for HIV testing programs.

Perceptions of Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) Testing Services Among HIV-Positive Persons Not in Medical Care

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) counseling, testing, and referral (CTR) are provided in a wide variety of settings.

GOAL

To compare, by test setting, the perceptions of the testing experience among HIV-positive persons who were not receiving medical care.

DESIGN

A baseline questionnaire was administered at enrollment into the Antiretroviral Treatment Access Study by the use of audio computer-assisted self-interview.

RESULTS

Of 316 respondents, 27% reported that the counselor did not spend enough time with them and 22% that the counselor did not answer all questions. The odds were higher that persons in the following settings, compared with those at HIV test sites, would report that the counselor did not spend enough time with them: office of private physician or health maintenance organization (HMO) (adjusted odds ratio [AOR], 5.24; 95% confidence interval, 1.26-21.7), jail (AOR, 5.10; 95% CI, 1.06-24.6), and emergency room (ER) or hospital overnight visit (AOR, 2.93; 95% CI, 1.15-7.44). Similarly, the odds were higher that persons in the following settings compared with those at HIV test sites would report that the counselor did not answer all questions: office of private physician or HMO (AOR, 9.62; 95% CI, 2.22-41.7), jail (AOR, 7.87; 95% CI, 1.50-41.4), and ER or hospital overnight visit (AOR, 3.32; 95% CI, 1.11-9.90).

CONCLUSION

Further training and quality assurance in HIV CTR may be needed in some test settings.

Desired elements of HIV testing services: test recipient perspectives

Thematic analysis of transcripts from interviews with a purposive sample of 39 voluntary human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) test recipients in Ontario (selected on the basis of HIV serostatus, risk behaviors, region of residence, gender, and testing format) was used to identify elements of HIV testing services of concern to test recipients. Colleague review was used to ensure dependability of findings, and emergent themes were compared with the existing literature on patient satisfaction. Data analysis identified a comprehensive set of 28 service elements, including components related to access and availability (convenience, physical accessibility, familiarity), structure of the service (privacy, and characteristics of the venue, session, and test provider), technical and medical aspects of the testing process (including blood-taking, file maintenance, obtaining informed consent, waiting period, and manner of result provision), and both cognitive and socioemotional aspects of the interpersonal process (including decision-making support, personalized risk information, receipt of appropriate emotional support, and service referrals). Results suggest that information on, and training in, counseling skills for both physician and nonphysician test counselors is important in the provision of quality testing services. Results also suggest that test recipients would appreciate choice in testing service options, and within the test session, individualized information, and counseling.

Coping strategies of people with HIV/AIDS in negative health care experiences

The purpose of the study was to gain insight into coping strategies of people with HIV/AIDS (PWHAs) in Taiwan who had negative health care experiences. This study used a phenomenological approach. Participants were 14 PWHAs with an average age of 35 years who had known their positive HIV status for an average of 24.9 months. Two coping strategies used to deal with negative health care experiences included, 'don't make a big fuss about it', and 'building defenses and finding alternatives'. Cultural aspects of PWHAs' coping strategies are discussed as they distinguish Chinese from western culture.

Receiving a positive HIV test result: the experience of patients in Europe

OBJECTIVE

To describe HIV-infected people's experience of the HIV test procedure in Europe.

METHODS

Between August 1996 and September 1997, anonymous self-administered questionnaires were distributed to HIV-infected people in 11 European countries.

RESULTS

A total of 1366 people completed the questionnaire (50% response rate). Of these, 194 (16%) had more than five negative HIV tests before being diagnosed as HIV positive, 179 (14%) were tested without consent and 192 (15%) were informed about the HIV positive test result by mail or by telephone. Of the 963 people who received a positive test result during a consultation, 247 (26%) reported that this visit lasted less than 10 min, 336 (35%) between 10 and 20 min, and 289 (30%) more than 20 min. Over half the total respondents (591, 54%) felt they did not receive adequate support when they were informed about being HIV positive, with 249 (19%) experiencing feelings of rejection. People who were diagnosed as HIV positive after 1994 reported more frequently receiving adequate support, information and understanding when the positive test result was revealed compared with those diagnosed before 1990.

CONCLUSION

A large number of our study participants did not endorse the way HIV tests were conducted and positive test results revealed. Although there was an improvement over time in the way HIV tests were conducted, they often did not conform to international guidelines.

The last resort would be to go to the GP'. Understanding the perceptions and use of general practitioner services among people with HIV/AIDS

In England and Wales, departments of Genito-Urinary Medicine have led the clinical response to HIV infection and AIDS (HIV/AIDS). They provide an open-access self-referral service on a basis of strict confidentiality. People with HIV/AIDS have been found to be reluctant to involve their general practitioner (GP) in their care. Previous research has not investigated their decisions about service use in the context of their broader strategies for coping with the multiple psychological and social challenges, which are posed by HIV/AIDS as a chronic, stigmatised condition. We report a depth-interview study of twenty people with HIV/AIDS in a low-prevalence nonmetropolitan urban area of England. Their health care choices were products of complex judgements. Five concerns predominated: expertise, security, rights to care, confidentiality and the maintenance of normality. Transfer to GP care signified a transition from essential wellness to essential illness and represented a loss of biographical continuity. Their other concerns express problems of information management, which are universal features of stigmatising conditions. These may be heightened in the case of locally provided services, where any leakage of discrediting information is likely to impact directly on everyday life. These concerns should be understood and respected in policy initiatives to develop services.

HIV-positive women living in the metropolitan Toronto area: their experiences and perceptions related to HIV testing. The HIV Women's Study Group

Forty HIV-positive women from diverse socioeconomic backgrounds were interviewed. Most (90%) did not perceive themselves to be at risk of HIV infection prior to knowing their HIV-positive status. The majority (61%) were tested because they developed symptoms, or because someone with whom they were intimate, or their child, tested positive for HIV or became ill. The majority (93%) of the women interviewed indicated that they did not receive both pre- and post-test counselling. The findings from this study suggest that encouraging individuals to be tested if they have engaged in "at risk" activities will not be appropriate for individuals who have no perception of risk, and other strategies to encourage appropriate testing may be needed. This research also suggests that continued emphasis needs to be placed on the counselling process, and that consideration may need to be given to multiple counselling sessions to ensure individuals clearly understand the information provided.

Decision making in HIV testing among a group with low HIV risk

Relatively little is known about how individuals (apart from gay and bisexual men) decide to have an HIV test and how, once they have presented for testing, they make decisions about proceeding through the testing trajectory. This paper reports on a qualitative study in which 55 mainly heterosexual respondents with low HIV risk were interviewed about their experiences of decision making around HIV testing. Reasons for deciding to be tested centred on a desire for reassurance and the circumstances of the respondents' current relationship. The most common relationship reason focused on a desire to confirm HIV status before beginning sexual relations or engaging in unprotected sex with a partner. Although some respondents recognized that other individuals had influenced their decision to be tested, few said that pre-test counselling had been influential in this respect. Instead, it was said to have promoted feelings of 'ownership' of a decision which had already been taken prior to counselling. The potential effects of HIV testing on HIV risk behaviour were also examined and a non-significant increase in unprotected sex was reported between the month before the test and the month after. The implications of these findings for the provision of HIV testing services are explored.

A review of research on the nature and quality of HIV testing services: a proposal for process-based studies

Considerable research has been conducted on various issues associated with HIV testing. However, rather than conceptualizing HIV testing as a dynamic process which consists of interrelated elements, this body of work has focused on discrete aspects of the HIV testing process. As an example of such research, studies which have examined HIV testing in terms of various behavioural and psychological outcomes are critically reviewed. Their limitations are attributed to their failure to account for all the elements involved in the HIV testing process that-singly and in dynamic combination-could have produced the measured outcomes. It is contended that if research on HIV testing is to be of use in the development and improvement of HIV testing services, it should be able to identify and describe in detail the factors that might lead to various outcomes of testing. This requires an in-depth examination of all aspects of the HIV testing process and their interrelationships from the perspectives of those undergoing testing and those providing testing services. The principal process elements in HIV testing are described; existing research on these topics is critically reviewed; and recommendations are made for future research. The process elements of HIV testing are identified as making a decision to be tested; accessing testing services; test counseling; and waiting for the test result. Of these, most consideration is accorded to the HIV test counselling process. It is contended that research is needed which examines both clients' and counsellors' expectations, experiences of and satisfaction with HIV test counselling. Specific issues that could usefully be addressed by future research include the process of obtaining clients' informed consent for testing; the ways in which test results are conveyed to clients; the strategies used in HIV counselling to help clients avoid or reduce behaviours in the future; partner notification; and which professional groups are best placed to conduct HIV test counselling. Finally, the question of which research methods might be suitable for process-based studies is considered. It is concluded that qualitative methods could be particularly appropriate as they are well-placed to chart in detail the varied aspects of the HIV testing process and their interrelationships.

'Doing the right thing': the symbolic meanings and experiences of having an HIV antibody test

Very few studies have been undertaken to explore in depth the reasons why individuals seek HIV antibody testing. This paper discusses the socio-cultural meanings surrounding the HIV antibody test, using the findings from a qualitative study directed at understanding why 'low risk' individuals make the decision to have an HIV test, their experiences of testing and their use of the result, especially in negotiating sexual relationships. It is concluded that the less obvious reasons for taking the test include pressure from parents or lovers, as a symbolic closure or commencement of a sexual relationship, the discourse of mutuality, the privileging of 'knowledge' and notions of responsibility and purity. Implications for AIDS education programs and policy are addressed.

How should a positive HIV result be given? The patients' view

The study aimed at obtaining information about the experience of how the diagnosis of HIV infection was given. Thirty asymptomatic HIV seropositive subjects completed a self-report questionnaire enquiring about their views of the process of communication of a positive test result. Subjects' current mood was assessed with the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HAD). Only about one-third of subjects were definitely satisfied with the way they were told the diagnosis. Satisfaction was associated with perceived reassurance and sympathy, and with the quality of the information given. The views of patients, as reported in this study, should be taken into account when training staff in the notification of HIV test results.

How should an AIDS diagnosis be given? The views of patients

The report aimed at obtaining information about patients' experience of how the diagnosis of AIDS was given to them by their doctors, and about patients' satisfaction with the consultation. Thirty people with AIDS completed a self-report questionnaire enquiring about their views and satisfaction with the process of communication of the diagnosis. Results showed that about two-thirds of patients were satisfied, while almost a quarter were definitely not satisfied with the consultation. Satisfaction was associated with the general attitude of the person giving the diagnosis and with the quality of the information given. The relevance of the findings for the training of doctors is discussed.

Planning health care for people with HIV infection and AIDS

In recent years planners of health services have been urged to design a comprehensive range of services which are responsive to the needs of people with HIV infection and AIDS and those who might be worried about HIV transmission. Models of care have been tried and tested and pilot services which aim to inform the development of the services scrutinised. Though in general this community care is seen as the preferred option with adequate backup support from acute services. More than anything, there is a recognition that the service must be responsive to local needs. Because patterns of HIV infection and prevalence of AIDS are so variable there is no substitute for the systematic development of timely local knowledge as the basis of local planning.