Absence of Adaptive Response to Low Doses of X-rays in Preimplantation Embryos and Spleen Lymphocytes of an Inbred Mouse Strain as Compared to Human Peripheral Lymphocytes: A Cytogenetic Study

Ionizing Radiation and Translation Control: A Link to Radiation Hormesis?

Protein synthesis, or mRNA translation, is one of the most energy-consuming functions in cells. Translation of mRNA into proteins is thus highly regulated by and integrated with upstream and downstream signaling pathways, dependent on various transacting proteins and cis-acting elements within the substrate mRNAs. Under conditions of stress, such as exposure to ionizing radiation, regulatory mechanisms reprogram protein synthesis to translate mRNAs encoding proteins that ensure proper cellular responses. Interestingly, beneficial responses to low-dose radiation exposure, known as radiation hormesis, have been described in several models, but the molecular mechanisms behind this phenomenon are largely unknown. In this review, we explore how differences in cellular responses to high- vs. low-dose ionizing radiation are realized through the modulation of molecular pathways with a particular emphasis on the regulation of mRNA translation control.

Non-induction of radioadaptive response in zebrafish embryos by neutrons

In vivo neutron-induced radioadaptive response (RAR) was studied using zebrafish (Danio rerio) embryos. The Neutron exposure Accelerator System for Biological Effect Experiments (NASBEE) facility at the National Institute of Radiological Sciences (NIRS), Japan, was employed to provide 2-MeV neutrons. Neutron doses of 0.6, 1, 25, 50 and 100 mGy were chosen as priming doses. An X-ray dose of 2 Gy was chosen as the challenging dose. Zebrafish embryos were dechorionated at 4 h post fertilization (hpf), irradiated with a chosen neutron dose at 5 hpf and the X-ray dose at 10 hpf. The responses of embryos were assessed at 25 hpf through the number of apoptotic signals. None of the neutron doses studied could induce RAR. Non-induction of RAR in embryos having received 0.6- and 1-mGy neutron doses was attributed to neutron-induced hormesis, which maintained the number of damaged cells at below the threshold for RAR induction. On the other hand, non-induction of RAR in embryos having received 25-, 50- and 100-mGy neutron doses was explained by gamma-ray hormesis, which mitigated neutron-induced damages through triggering high-fidelity DNA repair and removal of aberrant cells through apoptosis. Separate experimental results were obtained to verify that high-energy photons could disable RAR. Specifically, 5- or 10-mGy X-rays disabled the RAR induced by a priming dose of 0.88 mGy of alpha particles delivered to 5-hpf zebrafish embryos against a challenging dose of 2 Gy of X-rays delivered to the embryos at 10 hpf.

Studies of adaptive response and mutation induction in MCF-10A cells following exposure to chronic or acute ionizing radiation

A phenomenon in which exposure to a low adapting dose of radiation makes cells more resistant to the effects of a subsequent high dose exposure is termed radio-adaptive response. Adaptive response could hypothetically reduce the risk of late adverse effects of chronic or acute radiation exposures in humans. Understanding the underlying mechanisms of such responses is of relevance for radiation protection as well as for the clinical applications of radiation in medicine. However, due to the variability of responses depending on the model system and radiation condition, there is a need to further study under what conditions adaptive response can be induced. In this study, we analyzed if there is a dose rate dependence for the adapting dose, assuming that the adapting dose induces DNA response/repair pathways that are dose rate dependent. MCF-10A cells were exposed to a 50mGy adapting dose administered acutely (0.40Gy/min) or chronically (1.4mGy/h or 4.1mGy/h) and then irradiated by high acute challenging doses. The endpoints of study include clonogenic cell survival and mutation frequency at X-linked hprt locus. In another series of experiment, cells were exposed to 100mGy and 1Gy at different dose rates (acutely and chronically) and then the mutation frequencies were studied. Adaptive response was absent at the level of clonogenic survival. The mutation frequencies were significantly decreased in the cells pre-exposed to 50mGy at 1.4mGy/h followed by 1Gy acute exposure as challenging dose. Importantly, at single dose exposures (1 Gy or 100mGy), no differences at the level of mutation were found comparing different dose rates.

Repair of DNA double-strand breaks is not modulated by low-dose gamma radiation in C57BL/6J mice

In this study, we sought to determine whether low-dose ionizing radiation, previously shown to induce a systemic adaptive response in C57BL/6J mice, is capable of enhancing the rate of DNA double-strand break repair. Repair capacity was determined by measuring γ-H2AX levels in splenic and thymic lymphocytes, using flow cytometry, at different times after a challenge irradiation (2 Gy, (60)Co). Irradiation with low doses (20 and 100 mGy) was conducted in vivo, whereas the challenge dose was applied to primary cultures of splenocytes and thymocytes in vitro 24 h later. Obtained kinetics curves of formation and loss of γ-H2AX indicated that cells from low-dose irradiated mice did not express more efficient DNA double-strand break repair compared to controls. Immunoblot analysis of γ-H2AX and Phospho-Ser-1981 ATM confirmed that DNA damage signaling was not modulated by preliminary low-dose radiation. Mouse embryonic fibroblasts of C57BL genetic background failed to show clonogenic survival radioadaptive response or enhanced repair of DNA double-strand breaks as evaluated by immunofluorescence microscopy of γ-H2AX foci. Our results indicate that radiation adaptive responses at systemic levels, such as increases in the tumor latency times in aging mice, may not be mediated by modulated DNA repair, and that the genetic background may affect expression of a radioadaptive response.

Lack of adaptive response of gamma radiation for protection against neutron-induced teratogenesis

BACKGROUND

Although there are some reports on neutron teratology, there is little information on the adaptive response of gamma radiation for protection against neutron-induced teratogenesis. This study examined whether or not a low dose of gamma radiation can induce an adaptive response in mouse fetuses exposed to a subsequent dose of neutrons in vivo.

METHODS

Pregnant ICR mice were exposed to a priming dose of 0.3 Gy (0.9 Gy/min) of gamma rays on day 10.5 of gestation and challenged with 0.8 Gy (0.94 Gy/minute) of neutrons 24 h later. The mice were sacrificed on day 18.5 of gestation. The fetuses were examined for mortality, growth retardation, and other morphologic abnormalities.

RESULTS

The tail length in the 0.3 Gy of gamma rays + 0.8 Gy of neutrons group was significantly shorter than in the 0.8 Gy of neutrons group. Although there was no significant difference compared with the 0.8 Gy of neutrons group, the number of live fetuses in the 0.3 Gy of gamma rays +0.8 Gy of neutrons group was lower. There was no evidence of primed exposure-related reductions in the malformed fetuses. Although there was no significant difference compared with the unprimed group, the number of malformed offspring in the primed group was higher. Furthermore, the incidence of kinked tail and adactyly was significantly higher in the primed mice than in the unprimed mice.

CONCLUSIONS

Overall, this study shows that exposure to 0.3 Gy of gamma rays failed to induce an adaptive response of fetogenesis to a neutron challenge dose.

Low-dose whole-body irradiation induced radioadaptive response in C57BL/6 mice

Radioadaptive survival responses after relatively low doses of radiation were investigated in C57BL/6 mice. The 8-week-old mice received whole-body mid-lethal challenging irradiation (5.9 Gy) at various intervals after conditioning whole-body irradiation with 50-400 mGy. Thereafter, survival of the mice was observed for 30 days. The mice receiving 400 mGy at 6 h before the challenging dose had a lower survival rate than the control group, but it was not observed when the conditioning 400-mGy irradiation was given 24 h beforehand. The conditioning doses of 100 and 200 mGy did not influence the survival of mice after the challenging dose. The mice receiving 50 mGy at 1 day, 3 days or 1 week before the challenging dose had a higher survival rate than the control, although this adaptive response was not observed when 50 mGy was given 6 h, 12 h, 3.5 weeks, or 5 weeks beforehand. When 50 mGy was given 2 weeks before the challenging dose, the adaptive response was observed in an experiment in which the mice were caged in our laboratory at the age of 5 weeks, whereas it was not observed in another experiment in which the mice were caged at 3 weeks. This study confirmed the presence of radioadaptive survival responses at the dose of 50 mGy given relatively shortly before the challenging dose.

Absence of radioadaptive responses in four cell-lines in vitro as determined by colony formation assay

The purpose of this study was to investigate radioadaptive response in 4 cell-lines under identical conditions using a colony assay. First, 4 cell-lines (V79, HeLa S3, EMT6 and SCCVII) were exposed to 8 Gy at various intervals after pretreatment with an adapting dose of 50 mGy or without it. Second, V79 cells were exposed to 8 Gy at 4.5 hrs after an adapting dose of 0 to 400 mGy. Third, V79 cells were exposed to 2, 4 or 6 Gy at 6 hrs after an adapting dose of 0 or 50 mGy. In the last experiment, an adapting dose was given either immediately after cell plating or 24 hrs later. Cell survival was assessed by a standard colony assay. Adaptive response was not observed in any of the 4 lines tested. In V79 cells, no adaptive response was seen even by changing the adapting dose, challenging dose, and timing of adapting radiation after cell plating. Although radioadaptive response has been reported for the V79 cell-line, we could not reproduce the result. We also failed to demonstrate the phenomenon in the other 3 tumor cell-lines in culture.

Bystander effects, adaptive response and genomic instability induced by prenatal irradiation

The developing human embryo and fetus undergo very radiosensitive stages during the prenatal development. It is likely that the induction of low dose related effects such as bystander effects, the adaptive response, and genomic instability would have profound effects on embryonic and fetal development. In this paper, I review what has been reported on the induction of these three phenomena in exposed embryos and fetuses. All three phenomena have been shown to occur in murine embryonic or fetal cells and structures, although the induction of an adaptive response (and also likely the induction of bystander effects) are limited in terms of when during development they can be induced and the dose or dose-rate used to treat animals in utero. In contrast, genomic instability can be induced throughout development, and the effects of radiation exposure on genome instability can be observed for long times after irradiation including through pre- and postnatal development and into the next generation of mice. There are clearly strain-specific differences in the induction of these phenomena and all three can lead to long-term detrimental effects. This is true for the adaptive response as well. While induction of an adaptive response can make fetuses more resistant to some gross developmental defects induced by a subsequent high dose challenge with ionizing radiation, the long-term effects of this low dose exposure are detrimental. The negative effects of all three phenomena reflect the complexity of fetal development, a process where even small changes in the timing of gene expression or suppression can have dramatic effects on the pattern of biological events and the subsequent development of the mammalian organism.

An examination of radiation hormesis mechanisms using a multistage carcinogenesis model

A multistage cancer model that describes the putative rate-limiting steps in carcinogenesis is developed and used to investigate the potential impact on cumulative lung cancer incidence of the hormesis mechanisms suggested by Feinendegen and Pollycove. In the model, radiation and endogenous processes damage the DNA of target cells in the lung. Some fraction of the misrepaired or unrepaired DNA damage induces genomic instability and, ultimately, leads to the accumulation of malignant cells. The model explicitly accounts for cell birth and death processes, the clonal expansion of initiated cells, malignant conversion, and a lag period for tumor formation. Radioprotective mechanisms are incorporated into the model by postulating dose and dose-rate-dependent radical scavenging. The accuracy of DNA damage repair also depends on dose and dose rate. As currently formulated, the model is most applicable to low-linear-energy-transfer (LET) radiation delivered at low dose rates. Sensitivity studies are conducted to identify critical model inputs and to help define the shapes of the cumulative lung cancer incidence curves that may arise when dose and dose-rate-dependent cellular defense mechanisms are incorporated into a multistage cancer model. For lung cancer, both linear no-threshold (LNT-), and non-LNT-shaped responses can be obtained. If experiments demonstrate that the effects of DNA damage repair and radical scavenging are enhanced at least three-fold under low-dose conditions, our studies would support the existence of U-shaped responses. The overall fidelity of the DNA damage repair process may have a large impact on the cumulative incidence of lung cancer. The reported studies also highlight the need to know whether or not (or to what extent) multiply damaged DNA sites are formed by endogenous processes. Model inputs that give rise to U-shaped responses are consistent with an effective cumulative lung cancer incidence threshold that may be as high as 300 mGy (4 mGy per year for 75 years) for low-LET radiation.

Responses to low doses of ionizing radiation in biological systems

Biological tissues operate through cells that act together within signaling networks. These assure coordinated cell function in the face of constant exposure to an array of potentially toxic agents, externally from the environment and endogenously from metabolism. Living tissues are indeed complex adaptive systems.To examine tissue effects specific for low-dose radiation, (1) absorbed dose in tissue is replaced by the sum of the energies deposited by each track event, or hit, in a cell-equivalent tissue micromass (1 ng) in all micromasses exposed, that is, by the mean energy delivered by all microdose hits in the exposed micromasses, with cell dose expressing the total energy per micromass from multiple microdoses; and (2) tissue effects are related to cell damage and protective cellular responses per average microdose hit from a given radiation quality for all such hits in the exposed micromasses.The probability of immediate DNA damage per low-linear-energy-transfer (LET) average micro-dose hit is extremely small, increasing over a certain dose range in proportion to the number of hits. Delayed temporary adaptive protection (AP) involves (a) induced detoxification of reactive oxygen species, (b) enhanced rate of DNA repair, (c) induced removal of damaged cells by apoptosis followed by normal cell replacement and by cell differentiation, and (d) stimulated immune response, all with corresponding changes in gene expression. These AP categories may last from less than a day to weeks and be tested by cell responses against renewed irradiation. They operate physiologically against nonradiogenic, largely endogenous DNA damage, which occurs abundantly and continually. Background radiation damage caused by rare microdose hits per micromass is many orders of magnitude less frequent. Except for apoptosis, AP increasingly fails above about 200 mGy of low-LET radiation, corresponding to about 200 microdose hits per exposed micromass. This ratio appears to exceed approximately 1 per day for protracted exposure. The balance between damage and protection favors protection at low cell doses and damage at high cell doses. Bystander effects from high-dosed cells to nonirradiated neighboring cells appear to include both damage and protection.Regarding oncogenesis, a model based on the aforementioned dual response pattern at low doses and dose rates is consistant with the nonlinear reponse data and contradicts the linear no-threshold dose-risk hypothesis for radiation-induced cancer. Indeed, a dose-cancer risk function should include both linear and nonlinear terms.

How radiosensitive are the developing embryo and fetus?

In its 1990 recommendations, the ICRP considered the radiation risks after exposure during prenatal development. This report is a critical review of new experimental animal data on biological effects and evaluations of human studies after prenatal radiation published since the 1990 recommendations.

Thus, the report discusses the effects after radiation exposure during pre-implantation, organogenesis, and fetogenesis. The aetiology of long-term effects on brain development is discussed, as well as evidence from studies in man on the effects of in-utero radiation exposure on neurological and mental processes. Animal studies of carcinogenic risk from in-utero radiation and the epidemiology of childhood cancer are discussed, and the carcinogenic risk to man from in-utero radiation is assessed. Open questions and needs for future research are elaborated.

The report reiterates that the mammalian embryo and fetus are highly radiosensitive. The nature and sensitivity of induced biological effects depend upon dose and developmental stage at irradiation. The various effects, as studied in experimental systems and in man, are discussed in detail. It is concluded that the findings in the report strengthen and supplement the 1990 recommendations of the ICRP.

DNA damage response pathway in radioadaptive response

Radioadaptive response is a biological defense mechanism in which low-dose ionizing irradiation elicits cellular resistance to the genotoxic effects of subsequent irradiation. However, its molecular mechanism remains largely unknown. We previously demonstrated that the dose recognition and adaptive response could be mediated by a feedback signaling pathway involving protein kinase C (PKC), p38 mitogen activated protein kinase (p38MAPK) and phospholipase C (PLC). Further, to elucidate the downstream effector pathway, we studied the X-ray-induced adaptive response in cultured mouse and human cells with different genetic background relevant to the DNA damage response pathway, such as deficiencies in TP53, DNA-PKcs, ATM and FANCA genes. The results showed that p53 protein played a key role in the adaptive response while DNA-PKcs, ATM and FANCA were not responsible. Wortmannin, a specific inhibitor of phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase (PI3K), mimicked the priming irradiation in that the inhibitor alone rendered the cells resistant against the induction of chromosome aberrations and apoptosis by the subsequent X-ray irradiation. The adaptive response, whether it was afforded by low-dose X-rays or wortmannin, occurred in parallel with the reduction of apoptotic cell death by challenging doses. The inhibitor of p38MAPK which blocks the adaptive response did not suppress apoptosis. These observations indicate that the adaptive response and apoptotic cell death constitute a complementary defense system via life-or-death decisions. The p53 has a pivotal role in channeling the radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) into an adaptive legitimate repair pathway, where the signals are integrated into p53 by a circuitous PKC-p38MAPK-PLC damage sensing pathway, and hence turning off the signals to an alternative pathway to illegitimate repair and apoptosis. A possible molecular mechanism of adaptive response to low-dose ionizing irradiation has been discussed in relation to the repair of DSBs and implicated to the current controversial observations on the expression of adaptive response.

Involvement of p53-dependent apoptosis in radiation teratogenesis and in the radioadaptive response in the late organogenesis of mice

The irradiation of fetuses at the late period of organogenesis has been known to induce a dramatic increase in malformations. The mechanisms involved, however, have remained unclear for a long time. Using the mouse limb bud system, we first found that radiation-induced apoptosis is involved in the malformation, namely, radiation-induced apoptosis in the predigital regions of embryonic limb buds is responsible for digital defects in mice. An examination of embryonic C57BL/6J mice with different p53 (trp53) status enabled us to further find that susceptibility to radiation-induced apoptosis in the predigital regions and digital defects depend on both the p53 status and the radiation dose; p53 wild-type mice appeared to be the most sensitive, while p53 knockout mice were the most resistant. These results indicate that p53-dependent apoptosis mediates radiation-induced digital defects in the later organogenesis period. The existence of a radioadaptive response in embryonic mice, which has not been reported so far, was found by irradiating embryos with either 5 cGy or 30 cGy on embryonic day 11 prior to a challenging irradiation at 3 Gy on embryonic day 12. p53-heterozygous embryos did not show the radioadaptive response, indicating the involvement of p53 in the radioadaptive response in embryogenesis.

Role of radioadaptation on radiation-induced thymic lymphoma in mice

Thymic lymphoma (TL) was observed in different stages of development in 46% of male mice (23/50) following exposure to an acute challenge dose of 2 Gy 60Co gamma-rays. With an adapting dose of 1 cGy 24 h prior to the challenge dose of 2 Gy, similar growth of TL was seen in 42.5% of mice (17/40). TL was not found in unirradiated control mice (0/50) or in the group treated with 1 cGy (0/50). Multiple adapting doses for 5 or 10 consecutive days induced TL in 8/50 and 9/50 mice, respectively (17% in average). When multiple adapting doses were followed by the challenge dose, the yield of TL was much lower, 16% (8/50) and 30% (15/50), respectively. By 15, 30, 60, 90, and 120 days after exposure with 3 Gy of 60Co gamma-rays, TL developed in 30, 70, 70, 80 and 85% of the female mice, respectively. When mice were conditioned with an adapting dose of 1 cGy 24 h prior to the challenge dose, TL was not found 15 days post-irradiation, while about a 25% reduction in the occurrence of TL was noticed at all other intervals. The results suggested that an adapting dose could play a role in bringing about a change in terms of delay and inhibition of the acute effects of radiation, i.e., the onset of TL in mice.

On the reaction kinetics of the radioadaptive response in cultured mouse cells

The reaction kinetics of radioadaptive response of low doses of X-rays have been studied in quiescent cultured mouse cells. Mouse m5S cells pre-exposed in G1 to low doses of X-rays became insensitive to the induction of chromosome aberrations, mutation toward 6-thioguanine resistance, and cell killing. Adapted cells were, however, more susceptible to morphological transformation by subsequent high challenging doses of X-rays. The cytogenetic adaptation, which lasted about 20 h pertained to a narrow dose range. X-ray doses below and above 0.1 Gy appeared to be recognized as different signals; higher doses of X-rays were incapable of inducing adaptation and rapidly extinguished the adapted condition. Treatment with 12-O-tetradecanoyl-phorbol 13-acetate (TPA) and hydrogen peroxide, but not the xanthine/xanthine oxidase superoxide-generating system, mimicked X-rays in inducing adaptation when applied at low doses. Over-exposure to TPA or inhibitors of protein kinase C (PKC) abrogated the adaptive response to X-rays, providing evidence for the involvement of a PKC-mediated signalling pathway. The lack of radioadaptive response in a tumorigenic variant, clone 6110, and its restoration in the morphological revertant obtained by introducing human chromosome 11 further suggested that interference of signalling pathways may alter radioadaptive responses in malignant cells.

Adaptive response of the chicken embryo to low doses of x-irradiation

Chicken embryos were x-irradiated in ovo with 5-30 cGy (=priming dose) at the 13th-15th day of development. After 3-48 h, brain- and liver-cell suspensions were x-irradiated in vitro with (challenge) doses of 4-32 Gy. Significantly less radiation damage was observed when the radiation response was measured by scheduled DNA synthesis, nucleoid sedimentation and viscosity of alkaline cell lysates 12-36 h after the priming exposure. In vivo, pre-irradiation with 10 cGy enhanced regeneration as evidenced by the DNA content of chicken embryo brain and liver 24 h following a challenge dose of 4 Gy. From nucleoid sedimentation analyses in brain and liver cells immediately after irradiation with 16 Gy and after a 30-min repair period in the presence of aphidicolin, dideoxythymidine and 3-aminobenzamide or in the absence of these DNA repair inhibitors, it is concluded that a reduction of the initial radiation damage is the dominant mechanism of the "radio-adaptive" response of the chicken embryo. Sedimentation of nucleoids from ethidium bromide (EB) (0.75-400 micrograms/ml)-treated cells suggests a higher tendency of "radio-adapted" cells to undergo positive DNA supercoiling in the presence of high EB concentrations.

No indications of an enhanced UV-light-induced unscheduled DNA synthesis in splenocytes of mice following a low-dose irradiation in vivo or in vitro

One of the open questions regarding the adaptive response to ionizing radiation is whether it can be induced in G0 lymphocytes. In the majority of experiments in which an adaptive response in G0 lymphocytes was observed, the adapting dose was applied in vivo. In order to investigate whether there is some in vivo component of adaptive response, mouse splenocytes of the C57BL/6 strain were irradiated with 0.1 Gy x-rays either in vivo or in vitro, and their UV-light-induced unscheduled DNA synthesis (UDS) levels were determined autoradiographically. An augmented UV-light-induced UDS following an adapting dose applied in vivo has previously been described by several authors in splenocytes of C57BL/6 mice, indicating that the adapting dose enhanced the DNA repair capacity of lymphocytes. In the present investigation, however, no evidence of an adaptive response could be seen regardless of whether the adapting dose was given in vivo or in vitro. Those results present a further indication for the fact that the adaptive response to ionizing radiation is not always inducible, even in lymphocytes of an inbred mouse strain in which its existence has been reported before.

Induction of cytogenetic adaptive response of mouse bone marrow cells to radiation by therapeutic doses of bleomycin sulfate and actinomycin D as assayed by the micronucleus test

An in vivo micronucleus assay using bone marrow cells of Syrian albino male mice for identifying the possibility of induction of adaptive response to various doses of radiation following treatment with chemotherapeutics is described. Single doses of bleomycin sulfate (BLM-S) at 300 micrograms/kg and actinomycin-D (ACT-D) at 10 micrograms/kg body weight (therapeutic dose range) were injected intravenously 3 h prior to whole body gamma-irradiation. Irradiation at various doses from 1-4 Gy was carried out at a dose rate of 45 cGy/min. Animals were killed at 24, 36 and 48 h post-irradiation. The results obtained in this study clearly indicate a significant difference for radiation induced micronuclei (MN) in polychromatic erythrocytes (PCEs) with P value < 0.001 over the dose range used. When used in combination with radiation, neither ACT-D nor BLM-S caused a synergistic or additive effect. Irradiated animals showed a higher incidence of micronuclei formation in the presence of ACT-D and BLM-S. However, in both cases, the number of MN induced in PCEs was less than the sum of MN induced by radiation and ACT-D or BLM-S alone. The effect of combined treatment was reduced by a factor of 1.5 for BLM-S and greater than 1.5 for ACT-D treated animals. These observations indicate that although a small amount of ACT-D or BLM-S reaches the bone marrow cells via the circulation, these drugs might produce effects which make bone marrow cells resistant to the clastogenic effects of radiation. Therefore, using these agents repeatedly for cancer treatment in combination with radiation might not cause severe adverse biological effects in normal hemopoeitic tissue.