The lived experience of Joint Hypermobility and Ehlers-Danlos Syndromes: a systematic review and thematic synthesis

An exploration of the journey to diagnosis of Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (EDS) for women living in Australia

INTRODUCTION

Ehlers-Danlos syndromes (EDS) is an umbrella term for a group of hereditary connective tissue disorders usually featuring hyperextensible skin, easy bruising, poor healing, and joint hypermobility. According to international Ehlers-Danlos support groups, the average time to diagnosis of this rare genetic condition is 10-12 years. Consequently, the journey to diagnosis can potentially be traumatic. This pilot study aims to explore female patients' journey to a diagnosis of EDS while living in Australia.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Over six weeks, from January to February 2023, a survey was distributed on EDS social media platforms including Facebook and LinkedIn. Ethical approval was obtained through the Ulster University Institute of Nursing and Health Research Ethics Filter Committee (FCNUR). Thematic and statistical analysis of the anonymous data was completed during March 2023.

RESULTS

152 women completed the survey. More than half of the respondents first noticed symptoms of EDS more than 15 years prior to diagnosis and more than three quarters of respondents received other diagnoses prior to their EDS diagnosis. Most respondents saw their general practitioner, a physiotherapist and/or a rheumatologist prior to being correctly diagnosed with the condition. While some respondents had positive experiences with these health professionals, many felt that they were not listened to and, after doing their own research, had to educate their health professional/s about EDS.

CONCLUSION

This pilot survey demonstrated that the journey to diagnosis of EDS for women in Australia is frequently long and traumatic. Participants indicated that more EDS education and training is needed for health professionals, especially GPs, to improve the diagnostic process.

IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE

Participants called for their self-reported symptoms to be listened to by health professionals and to be met with empathy and an open mind instead of being dismissed. Additional education and training to health professionals about connective tissue disorders including EDS may aid earlier diagnosis in Australia.

Social media use by patients with hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome

BACKGROUND

Patients with uncommon genetic conditions often face limited in-person resources for social and informational support. Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (hEDS) is a rare or underdiagnosed hereditary disorder of the connective tissue, and like those with similar diseases, patients with hEDS have begun to turn to social media in search of care and community. The aims of our study were to understand the usage habits and perceptions of utility of social media use for patients with hEDS in order to formulate suggestions for how clinicians may best engage these and similar patient populations about this topic.

METHODS

We conducted both a quantitative survey and qualitative interviews with patients who had received a robust clinical diagnosis of hEDS.

RESULTS

Twenty-four individuals completed the initial survey, and a subset of 21 of those participants completed an interview. Through thematic analysis, we identified four primary themes related to their experience with social media: (1) befriending others with their disease, (2) seeking and vetting information, (3) the risks and downsides of social media use, and (4) the desire for clinicians to discuss this topic with them.

CONCLUSION

We conclude by proposing five suggestions that emerge empirically from our data. These proposals will help clinicians engage their patients regarding social media use in order to promote its potential benefits and circumvent its potential harms as they pursue support for their hereditary condition.

An online pain management program for people with hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome or hypermobility spectrum disorder: a three-staged development process

PURPOSE

Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (hEDS) and hypermobility spectrum disorder (HSD) are painful, chronic and multi-systemic conditions. No online pain management programs for hEDS/HSD currently exist. We aimed to develop one by exploring what people with hEDS/HSD want in such programs.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A Delphi was conducted via online surveys of stakeholders: participants with hEDS/HSD and healthcare professionals (HCP). In survey 1, participants were asked if a hEDS/HSD-specific online pain management program was important, listing up to 20 topics important to know about pain. In survey 2, participants rated the importance of those topics. Consensus was set as ≥75% rating of at least "important". Using topics that reached consensus, the online program was developed. Usability testing was performed using the Systems Usability Scale (SUS).

RESULTS

396 hEDS/HSD and 29 HCP completed survey 1; 151 hEDS/HSD and 12 HCP completed survey 2. 81% of hEDS/HSD and 69% of HCP rated a hEDS/HSD-specific program as at least "important". Thirty-five topics reached consensus to guide content for the HOPE program (Hypermobile Online Pain managemEnt). SUS score was 82.5, corresponding to "high acceptability".

CONCLUSIONS

A hEDS/HSD-specific online pain management program is important to stakeholders. Utilising a Delphi approach to incorporate stakeholder input, an evidence-informed and user appropriate program was developed.

Healthcare experiences among adults with hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome and hypermobility spectrum disorder in the United States

PURPOSE

This cross-sectional mixed-method study examined healthcare experiences among individuals in the US with hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (hEDS) and hypermobility spectrum disorder (HSD), genetic connective tissue disorders. We hypothesized that many individuals with these conditions would report low satisfaction with healthcare and low health-related quality of life, and that lower healthcare satisfaction would be related to lower health-related quality of life and self-efficacy for symptom management.

METHODS

Adults living in the US with hEDS or HSD (N= 2125) completed an online survey assessing satisfaction with healthcare, health-related quality of life, and symptom management self-efficacy. Qualitative data also were gathered on desired changes to improve healthcare.

RESULTS

Participants reported low satisfaction with healthcare and lower health-related quality of life and symptom management self-efficacy than norm groups. Lower satisfaction with healthcare was associated with lower health-related quality of life and lower symptom management self-efficacy, ps <.001. The most common desired change to improve healthcare was more knowledge about hEDS and HSD among healthcare professionals.

CONCLUSIONS

U.S. adults with joint hypermobility report negative healthcare experiences and poor health-related quality of life. Future research should explore ways to improve the healthcare experiences and quality of care for individuals with hEDS and HSD.Implications for RehabilitationIndividuals with hypermobility spectrum disorder (HSD) and hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (hEDS) score worse than the U.S. population on most health-related quality of life domains and symptom management self-efficacy.Individuals with HSD and hEDS report low levels of satisfaction with healthcare compared to norm groups.Participants particularly wanted to see improvements in the level of awareness and education about HSD and hEDS among healthcare professionals, provider attitudes about HSD and hEDS, and healthcare accessibility and convenience.Individuals who were less satisfied with their healthcare reported lower health-related quality of life and lower symptom management self-efficacy, underscoring the importance of improving healthcare experiences.

A qualitative study of pain and related symptoms experienced by people with Ehlers-Danlos syndromes

Introduction

Individuals with Ehlers-Danlos syndromes (EDS) often have complex and multi-faceted symptoms across the lifespan. Pain and the related symptoms of fatigue and sleep disorders are common. The objective of this qualitative study was to understand how participants manage their pain and related symptoms.

Methods

The design was a qualitative thematic content analysis. Twenty-eight interviews were conducted to collect data from individuals who were participants in a prior quantitative longitudinal study. A semi-structured interview guide was designed to focus on and understand the trajectory of pain, sleep, fatigue, and general function. The interview continued with questions about coping mechanisms and obstacles to maintaining a sense of well-being.

Results

Symptoms reported by participants were widespread and often interwoven. Pain was universal and often resulted in fatigue and disordered sleep which impacted physical function. Most participants reported that their symptoms worsened over time. Participants reported a wide range of effective interventions and most reported developing self-care strategies to adapt to their disabilities/limitations. Solutions included complementary interventions discovered when conventional medicine was unsuccessful. Very few relied on a "system" of health care and instead developed their own strategies to adapt to their disabilities/limitations.

Discussion

EDS symptoms are often debilitating, and their progression is unknown. For most participants, symptoms worsened over the time. Even though participants in our study, by experience, were self-reliant, the importance of knowledgeable medical providers to help guide self-care should be emphasized.

A narrative review of the literature on illness uncertainty in hypermobile ehlers-danlos syndrome: implications for research and clinical practice

BACKGROUND

Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (hEDS) is characterized by joint and skin laxity, and often accompanied by chronic pain, dysautonomia, increased distress and, functional limitations. The journey to accurate diagnosis is often prolonged due to unclear etiology of symptoms. This manuscript is a narrative review of the literature on illness uncertainty (IU) in hEDS, highlighting the unique facets of IU in this population, as compared to the broader chronic pain population (given symptom overlap between these two disease groups), that warrant additional investigation. Additionally, we considered the unique challenges associated with IU in the context of the developmental nuances of pediatric populations. Specifically, we aimed to (1) map the extant literature of the IU experience in chronic pain conditions broadly including the pediatric and adult research to identify key concepts related to IU and incorporate potential developmental considerations in IU; (2) delineate and describe the IU experience specifically in patients with hEDS, with the goal of identifying gaps in the literature based on aspects of presentation in hEDS that do and do not differ from the broader chronic pain population; and (3) elucidate the potential areas of adverse impact of IU in both general chronic pain populations, and those with hEDS specifically, to provide actionable areas for future research and clinical care of individuals with hEDS. Results of this review indicate that IU has been well-studied in chronic pain generally, but inadequately evaluated in hEDS specifically. Specific features of hEDS (complexity of the disorder, involvement of multiple bodily systems, contribution of organic pathology) may uniquely contribute to IU in this population. This review suggests that ambiguities surrounding the diagnosis of hEDS, symptom course, and treatment recommendations, along with misdiagnosis, perceived dismissal of symptoms, or attribution of symptoms to mental health concerns might increase risk for IU and related distress in patients.

CONCLUSION

Findings from the present review suggest that distinct features of hEDS yield a set of driving factors for IU that may be somewhat different than those faced by patients with chronic pain or other medical conditions. The development of a validated measure of IU to appropriately assess this construct in patients with hEDS is a research priority. In the clinical setting, providers should be attentive to the potentially aversive diagnostic and treatment experiences reported by patients and attempt to provide clear explanations based on the extant knowledge of hEDS, and implement best-practice recommendations for multidisciplinary treatment.

Rare Disease, Advocacy and Justice: Intersecting Disparities in Research and Clinical Care

Rare genetic diseases collectively impact millions of individuals in the United States. These patients and their families share many challenges including delayed diagnosis, lack of knowledgeable providers, and limited economic incentives to develop new therapies for small patient groups. As such, rare disease patients and families often must rely on advocacy, including both self-advocacy to access clinical care and public advocacy to advance research. However, these demands raise serious concerns for equity, as both care and research for a given disease can depend on the education, financial resources, and social capital available to the patients in a given community. In this article, we utilize three case examples to illustrate ethical challenges at the intersection of rare diseases, advocacy and justice, including how reliance on advocacy in rare disease may drive unintended consequences for equity. We conclude with a discussion of opportunities for diverse stakeholders to begin to address these challenges.

Clinician-associated traumatization from difficult medical encounters: Results from a qualitative interview study on the Ehlers-Danlos Syndromes

Patients with hypermobile Ehlers Danlos Syndrome often experience psychological distress resulting from the perceived hostility and disinterest of their clinicians. We conducted 26 in-depth interviews with patients to understand the origins of this trauma and how it could be addressed in practice. We found that the cumulative effects of numerous negative encounters lead patients to lose trust in their healthcare providers and the healthcare system, and to develop acute anxiety about returning to clinic to seek further care. We describe this as clinician-associated traumatization. Ultimately, our interviewees described the result of this traumatization as worse - but preventable - health outcomes.

What are the most important symptoms to assess in hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome? A questionnaire study based on the Delphi technique

PURPOSE

This study aims to determine from questionnaires, submitted to patients with Ehlers-Danlos syndrome hypermobile type (hEDS), what symptoms they perceive as having the most impact on their well-being and, according to them, what symptoms should be assessed.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Three rounds of online questionnaires were conducted following the Delphi method. The first round allowed us to obtain the most important symptoms to assess according to the patients. The second and third round aimed at ranking the categories according to their order of importance. Establishment of a consensus was evaluated using Kendall's coefficient of concordance.

RESULTS

A total of 118 responses were analyzed for the first round and 87 for the second and the third round. Ten categories were extracted from the first round. Ranking of the 10 categories in the second round did not reach consensus (W = 0.33, p < 0.001) nor did the four most important categories in the third round (W = 0.43, p < 0.001). However, three categories stand out from ranking: "pain", "fatigue and sleep disorders", and "musculoskeletal disorders".

CONCLUSIONS

These categories seem to be the most important to assess in patients with hEDS, despite the lack of consensus on this ranking.Implications for rehabilitationPain, fatigue and sleep disorders, and musculoskeletal disorders should be given high consideration in the assessment of patients with hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (EDS).The high phenotypic variability in the hypermobile EDS requires individualized assessment for each patient and a multidisciplinary approach.

The Underrecognized Conditions of Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome and Hypermobility Spectrum Disorders in Women

Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome and hypermobility spectrum disorders are conditions that disproportionately affect women and can result in morbidity, disability, and a poorer quality of life. These conditions are often not recognized by health care professionals, leading to significant delays in diagnosis, especially in women. Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome and hypermobility spectrum disorders are known as complex, multisystemic conditions that are frequently comorbid with autonomic dysfunction, mast cell activation syndrome, and autism. Education of health care professionals, including nurses, on these conditions could lead to earlier diagnosis, with improved management and thus better outcomes for those affected by these conditions.

The Impact of Hypermobile “Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome” and Hypermobile Spectrum Disorder on Interpersonal Interactions and Relationships

Background

People with Ehlers-Danlos Syndromes and Hypermobility Spectrum Disorders are hampered in their social participation, especially in the social relationships they have.

Objective

The aim of this study is to research the impact of hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (hEDS) and Hypermobile Spectrum Disorders (HSD) on interpersonal interactions and relationships.

Methods

A phenomenological hermeneutic study was performed. Semi-structured interviews were used to explore the experiences of 11 participants.

Results

Four themes emerged from the data analysis. (1) people with hEDS or HSD can no longer do what they want to do and that affects their identity, (2) people with hEDS or HSD have to find a balance in the amount of activities they participate in, (3) having hEDS or HSD influences how to ask for, accept and give help, and (4) Relationships are affected in persons with hEDS or HSD. As well as changes in the social network, different types of relationships are influenced by the disease, including relationship with their partner, their children, their friends, strangers, fellow-sufferers and health care professionals.

Patients with Ehlers-Danlos syndrome on the diagnostic odyssey: Rethinking complexity and difficulty as a hero's journey

Patients with hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, an hereditary disorder of the connective tissue, often face a long and difficult diagnostic odyssey in pursuit of a name for their condition. Clinicians may dismiss subjective symptoms of chronic pain, thus prolonging patients' odysseys and worsening their care and satisfaction and creating antagonisms in the patient-provider relationship. A greater understanding of patient experiences is necessary in order to decrease burdens of this relationship and to improve care. To that end, we conducted 22 in-depth, semistructured interviews with individuals who had undergone this diagnostic odyssey. We focused on the impact that the odyssey had on their lives, both inside and outside the clinic. Through narrative analysis, we found a sort of "hero's journey" in the description of their cases, highlighting issues of uncertainty and integration as well as honoring their struggles. Interviewees had encountered difficulties in working with clinicians, in multiplying symptoms, and in negative psychosocial consequences. Attention to patients' lived experience may help to build empathy and understanding for the difficult and complex clinical situation presented by Ehlers-Danlos syndrome. Using the hero's journey as a lens onto this experience allows for a more patient-centered approach to this understanding and has potential value for comprehension of other complex diseases and invisible illnesses.

Mind the gaps: therapists' experiences of managing symptomatic hypermobility in Scotland

OBJECTIVES

The aim was to ascertain occupational therapist (OT) and physiotherapist (PT) experiences of managing hypermobility spectrum disorders (HSDs) and hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (hEDS) patients, specifically the training and confidence levels of therapists, use of evidence-based practice, accessibility of pain management and clinical psychology services, and perceived usefulness of a specialist centre in Scotland.

METHODS

A mixed-method survey was distributed to Rheumatology OTs/PTs in Scotland. It included multiple choice and open text questions, which were analysed to reflect therapists' experiences and perception of service need.

RESULTS

We found that therapists in Scotland do have expertise in the management of HSD/hEDS patients; however, this expertise tends to be concentrated in secondary care, which makes it difficult for patients who are managed in primary care to access. The majority of respondents reported lack of access to external training (80%). There was difficulty in referral to pain management services (55%) and clinical psychology (28%) among adult therapists. Paediatric services provided considerably better access to these disciplines. Of note, the majority of respondents were in favour of a specialist centre in Scotland for the training and education of therapists (94.7%) and the diagnosis and management of complex HSD/hEDS patients (73.7%).

CONCLUSION

More research is needed urgently to evaluate the effectiveness of therapy interventions to underpin a national guideline in order that we can improve outcomes for HSD/hEDS patients. A specialist centre with expert and engaged clinicians would be a valuable asset in coordinating patient-focused research and conducting good-quality clinical trials.

Developing a self-management intervention to manage hypermobility spectrum disorders (HSD) and hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (hEDS): an analysis informed by behaviour change theory

PURPOSE

Hypermobility Spectrum Disorders (HSD) and Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (hEDS) are heritable connective tissue disorders associated with joint instability and pain, but with scant guidance for supporting patients. The aim was to determine recommendations for an HSD/hEDS self-management intervention.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Barriers to self-management were mapped onto the Theoretical Domains Framework (TDF) and Capability, Opportunity, Motivation-Behaviour (COM-B) model in a behavioural analysis. A modified Nominal Group Technique was used to prioritise behaviour change technique (BCT) interventions (n = 9 women).

RESULTS

Possible BCTs incorporated.

EDUCATION

Incorporating self-help strategies, education to improve their knowledge of HSD/hEDS, and how to judge information about HSD/hEDS.

TRAINING

In activity pacing, assertiveness and communication skills, plus what to expect during pregnancy, when symptoms can worsen.

ENVIRONMENTAL RESTRUCTURING AND ENABLEMENT

Support from occupational therapists to maintain independence at work and home.

MODELLED BEHAVIOUR

That illustrates how other people with HSD/hEDS have coped with the psychosocial impact.

CONCLUSIONS

This study is the first to apply theoretically-informed approaches to the management of HSD/hEDS. Participants indicated poor access to psychological support, occupational therapy and a lack of knowledge about HSD/hEDS. Future research should evaluate which intervention options would be most acceptable and feasible.Implications for rehabilitationPatients with Hypermobility Spectrum Disorders or Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome can be active partners in the co-design of behaviour change interventions.Behaviour change interventions should target psychological support and patient education, particularly patient information.Additional behaviour change interventions included environmental restructuring and enablement; adaptations to participants' environment with input from occupational therapy.Participants were keen to suggest opportunities for behavioural modelling; positive fist-person modelling narratives, written by those with HSD/hEDS, which addressed how they coped with the psychosocial impact of their condition.

Psychosocial Influence of Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome in Daily Life of Patients: A Qualitative Study

(1) Background: Ehlers–Danlos syndrome is a heterogeneous group of connective tissue disorders causing pain, fatigue, and disabilities; it has several implications for patients who suffer from this disease. The major clinical manifestations of EDS include joint hypermobility, skin hyperextensibility, and generalized connective tissue fragility. This research aims to explore their perceptions and experiences about the phycological and social spheres. (2) Methods: Semistructured interviews were carried out. Participants were encouraged to talk about issues related to their disease by asking open-ended questions in one to one interview. The interview guide included questions to identify the syndrome’s influence on the social and psychological life of patients All interviews were audio recorded, fully transcribed, and analyzed using the phenomenological theoretical framework. The method of analysis was the thematic interpreting of perspectives and approaches. (3) Results: 31 individuals were proposed to participate in this study. Five patients refused to participate, so a total of 26 interviews were performed. Six themes ((1) Pain and its consequences on a daily basis; (2) The need to name the problem: the diagnosis; (3) Restructuring leisure and social relationships; (4) Limitations due to economic conditions; (5) Psychological impact of the disease situation; (6) Professional limitations) and four subthemes ((1) The value of partner support; (2) The weather influence on social plans; (3) Physical exercise and illness; (4) Support groups) emerged from the data. (4) Conclusions: This study revealed the impact of the syndrome on the social and daily life of patients, and not only in a physical level, but also in a psychological and social approach. These findings allow healthcare providers to know more about this disease in order to support and give advice to patients about the changes they will have to make.

Understanding the psychosocial impact of joint hypermobility syndrome and Ehlers-Danlos syndrome hypermobility type: a qualitative interview study

PURPOSE

Little attention has been paid to psychosocial factors in Joint Hypermobility Syndrome and Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (hypermobility type). This study sought to identify the psychosocial impact by examining participants' lived experiences; and identify characteristics of effective coping.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Adults with Joint Hypermobility Syndrome and Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (Hypermobility Type) were invited to discuss their own lived experiences and the impact of the condition. All met recognized criteria for clinically significant joint hypermobility, and had a self-confirmed diagnosis. The transcripts were coded and analyzed using inductive thematic analysis.

RESULTS

Seventeen participants (14 women, 3 men) purposively selected to broadly represent different genders, ages and ethnicities. Analysis identified five key themes: healthcare limitations, a lack of awareness of Joint Hypermobility, and Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome (Hypermobility Type) among healthcare professionals; a restricted life; social stigma; fear of the unknown; and ways of coping.

CONCLUSIONS

The results highlight the significant psychosocial impact on participants' lives. Coping approaches identified included acceptance, building social networks, learning about joint hypermobility, and adapting activities. Physiotherapists supported regular exercise. Further research should consider potential interventions to improve information provision, address psychological support, and increase awareness of hypermobility among healthcare professionals.Implications for rehabilitationParticipants who had help from family members to complete activities described guilt and shame, highlighting the need for a greater rehabilitation focus on maintaining independence.Difficulties with sexual relationships due to prolapse or erectile dysfunction, and associated anxieties have indicated a need for greater awareness of these issues within primary care.The provision of reliable information and materials is vital, both for healthcare professionals and patients, to reduce misinformation and fear.Physiotherapists with knowledge of Joint Hypermobility Syndrome and Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome hypermobility type were cited as sources of support and hope, which helped people to cope with and manage their condition.