The efficacy and safety of different techniques for trocar insertion in laparoscopic surgery

Effect of body habitus and parity on the initial Veres intraperitoneal CO2 insufflation pressure during laparoscopic access in women

STUDY OBJECTIVES

Since most gynecologists use the Veres/trocar entry, and because the Veres intraperitoneal (VIP) pressure appears to be the most reliable indicator of correct Veres needle placement, the objective of this study was to determine the effect of height, weight, body mass index (BMI), parity, and age on the initial Veres intraperitoneal CO2 insufflation pressure during laparoscopic access in women.

DESIGN

Prospective observational cohort study (Canadian Task Force classification II-1).

SETTING

University affiliated teaching hospital.

PATIENTS

We prospectively collected data on 356 women undergoing laparoscopy for a variety of indications by the senior author (G.A.V.). The median and (range) for height, weight, BMI, parity, and age were 1.64 m (1.45-1.85 m), 65 kg (40-120 kg), 24.3 kg/m2 (16-47 kg/m2), 1 (0-5) and 34 years (18-87 yrs), respectively.

INTERVENTION

Under general endotracheal anesthesia including muscle relaxants and with the patient in appropriate stirrups in the horizontal position, a nondisposable Veres needle was inserted at the umbilicus or left upper quadrant (Palmer's point) with CO2 flowing at 1 L/min. The initial Veres intraperitoneal insufflation pressure was recorded once the Veres needle was believed to be in the peritoneal cavity.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

The mode and the median VIP pressure was 4 mm Hg with a range of 2 to 10 mm Hg. With multivariate analysis, the VIP pressure correlated positively with the weight (r = 0.518, p <.001) and BMI (r = 0.545, p <.001) and negatively with the parity (r = -0.179, p <.001) of women. The correlation of the VIP pressure with height and age was r = 0.029 (p = .591) and r = -0.044 (p = .411), respectively.

CONCLUSION

A VIP pressure < or =10 mm Hg indicates intraperitoneal placement of the Veres needle. The VIP pressure correlates positively with the weight and BMI and negatively with the parity of women. There is no correlation of the VIP pressure with women's height and age.

Systematic review of the safety and effectiveness of methods used to establish pneumoperitoneum in laparoscopic surgery

BACKGROUND

A systematic review was conducted to determine which of the methods of obtaining peritoneal access and establishing pneumoperitoneum is the safest and most effective.

METHODS

Studies that met the inclusion criteria were identified from six bibliographic databases up to May 2002, the internet, hand-searches and reference lists. They were critically appraised using a validated checklist and data were extracted using standardized protocols.

RESULTS

Meta-analysis of prospective, non-randomized studies of open versus closed (needle/trocar) access indicated a trend during open access towards a reduced risk of major complications (pooled relative risk (RR(p)) 0.30, 95 per cent confidence interval (c.i.) 0.09 to 1.03). Open access was also associated with a trend towards a reduced risk of access-site herniation (RR(p) 0.21, 95 per cent c.i. 0.04 to 1.03) and, in non-obese patients, a 57 per cent reduced risk of minor complications (RR(p) 0.43, 95 per cent c.i. 0.20 to 0.92) and a trend for fewer conversions to laparotomy (RR(p) 0.21, 95 per cent c.i. 0.04 to 1.17). Data on major complications in studies of direct trocar versus needle/trocar access were inconclusive. Minor complications in randomized controlled trials were fewer with direct trocar access (RR(p) 0.19, 95 per cent c.i. 0.09 to 0.40), predominantly owing to a reduction in extraperitoneal insufflation.

CONCLUSION

The evidence on the comparative safety and effectiveness of the different access methods was not definitive, but there were trends in the data that merit further exploration.