Minimally invasive thermotherapy method for tumor treatment based on an exothermic chemical reaction

Enlarging the thermal coagulation volume during thermochemical ablation with alternating acid-base injection by shortening the injection interval: A computational study

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Thermochemical ablation (TCA) is a cancer treatment that utilises the heat released from the neutralisation of acid and base to raise tissue temperature to levels sufficient to induce thermal coagulation. Computational studies have demonstrated that the coagulation volume produced by sequential injection is smaller than that with simultaneous injection. By injecting the reagents in an ensuing manner, the region of contact between acid and base is limited to a thin contact layer sandwiched between the distribution of acid and base. It is hypothesised that increasing the frequency of acid-base injections into the tissue by shortening the injection interval for each reagent can increase the effective area of contact between acid and base, thereby intensifying neutralisation and the exothermic heat released into the tissue.

METHODS

To verify this hypothesis, a computational model was developed to simulate the thermochemical processes involved during TCA with sequential injection. Four major processes that take place during TCA were considered, i.e., the flow of acid and base, their neutralisation, the release of exothermic heat and the formation of thermal damage inside the tissue. Equimolar acid and base at 7.5 M was injected into the tissue intermittently. Six injection intervals, namely 3, 6, 15, 20, 30 and 60 s were investigated.

RESULTS

Shortening of the injection interval led to the enlargement of coagulation volume. If one considers only the coagulation volume as the determining factor, then a 15 s injection interval was found to be optimum. Conversely, if one places priority on safety, then a 3 s injection interval would result in the lowest amount of reagent residue inside the tissue after treatment. With a 3 s injection interval, the coagulation volume was found to be larger than that of simultaneous injection with the same treatment parameters. Not only that, the volume also surpassed that of radiofrequency ablation (RFA); a conventional thermal ablation technique commonly used for liver cancer treatment.

CONCLUSION

The numerical results verified the hypothesis that shortening the injection interval will lead to the formation of larger thermal coagulation zone during TCA with sequential injection. More importantly, a 3 s injection interval was found to be optimum for both efficacy (large coagulation volume) and safety (least amount of reagent residue).

Quantitative Dual-Energy CT Image Guidance for Thermochemical Ablation: In Vivo Results in the Rabbit VX2 Model

PURPOSE

To evaluate the feasibility of using dual-energy computed tomography (CT) and theranostic cesium hydroxide (CsOH) for image guidance of thermochemical ablation (TCA) in a rabbit VX2 tumor model.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In vivo experiments were performed on New Zealand white rabbits, where VX2 tumor fragments (0.3 mL) were inoculated into the right and left flanks (n = 16 rabbits, 32 tumors). Catheters were placed in the approximate center of 1- to 2-cm diameter tumors under ultrasound guidance. TCA was delivered in 1 of 3 treatment groups: untreated control, 5-M TCA, or 10-M TCA. The TCA base reagent was doped with 250-mM CsOH. Dual-energy CT was performed before and after TCA. Cesium (CS)-specific images were postprocessed on the basis of previous phantom calibrations to determine Cs concentration. Line profiles were drawn through the ablation center. Twenty-four hours after TCA, subjects were euthanized, and the resulting damage was evaluated with histopathology.

RESULTS

Cs was detected in 100% of treated tumors (n = 21). Line profiles indicated highest concentrations at the injection site and decreased concentrations at the tumor margins, with no Cs detected beyond the ablation zone. The maximum detected Cs concentration ranged from 14.39 to 137.33 mM. A dose-dependent trend in tissue necrosis was demonstrated between the 10-M TCA and 5-M TCA treatment groups (P = .0005) and untreated controls (P = .0089).

CONCLUSIONS

Dual-energy CT provided image guidance for delivery, localization, and quantification of TCA in the rabbit VX2 model.

An in silico derived dosage and administration guide for effective thermochemical ablation of biological tissues with simultaneous injection of acid and base

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Thermochemical ablation (TCA) is a thermal ablation technique involving the injection of acid and base, either sequentially or simultaneously, into the target tissue. TCA remains at the conceptual stage with existing studies unable to provide recommendations on the optimum injection rate, and reagent concentration and volume. Limitations in current experimental methodology have prevented proper elucidation of the thermochemical processes inside the tissue during TCA. Nevertheless, the computational TCA framework developed recently by Mak et al. [Mak et al., Computers in Biology and Medicine, 2022, 145:105494] has opened new avenues in the development of TCA. Specifically, a recommended safe dosage is imperative in driving TCA research beyond the conceptual stage.

METHODS

The aforesaid computational TCA framework for sequential injection was applied and adapted to simulate TCA with simultaneous injection of acid and base at equimolar and equivolume. The developed framework, which describes the flow of acid and base, their neutralisation, the rise in tissue temperature and the formation of thermal damage, was solved numerically using the finite element method. The framework will be used to investigate the effects of injection rate, reagent concentration, volume and type (weak/strong acid-base combination) on temperature rise and thermal coagulation formation.

RESULTS

A higher injection rate resulted in higher temperature rise and larger thermal coagulation. Reagent concentration of 7500 mol/m³ was found to be optimum in producing considerable thermal coagulation without the risk of tissue overheating. Thermal coagulation volume was found to be consistently larger than the total volume of acid and base injected into the tissue, which is beneficial as it reduces the risk of chemical burn injury. Three multivariate second-order polynomials that express the targeted coagulation volume as functions of injection rate and reagent volume, for the weak-weak, weak-strong and strong-strong acid-base combinations were also derived based on the simulated data.

CONCLUSIONS

A guideline for a safe and effective implementation of TCA with simultaneous injection of acid and base was recommended based on the numerical results of the computational model developed. The guideline correlates the coagulation volume with the reagent volume and injection rate, and may be used by clinicians in determining the safe dosage of reagents and optimum injection rate to achieve a desired thermal coagulation volume during TCA.

A computational framework to simulate the thermochemical process during thermochemical ablation of biological tissues

Thermochemical ablation (TCA) is a thermal ablation therapy that utilises heat released from acid-base neutralisation reaction to destroy tumours. This procedure is a promising low-cost solution to existing thermal ablation treatments such as radiofrequency ablation (RFA) and microwave ablation (MWA). Studies have demonstrated that TCA can produce thermal damage that is on par with RFA and MWA when employed properly. Nevertheless, TCA remains a concept that is tested only in a few animal trials due to the risks involved as the result of uncontrolled infusion and incomplete acid-base reaction. In this study, a computational framework that simulates the thermochemical process of TCA is developed. The proposed framework consists of three physics, namely chemical flow, neutralisation reaction and heat transfer. An important parameter in the TCA framework is the neutralisation reaction rate constant, which has values in the order of 10⁸ m³/(mol⋅s). The present study will demonstrate that since the rate constant impacts only the rate and direction of the reaction but has little influence on the extent of reaction, it is possible to replicate the thermochemical process of TCA by employing significantly smaller values of rate constant that are numerically tractable. Comparisons of the numerical results against experimental studies from the literature supports this. The aim of this framework is for researchers to advance and develop TCA to gain an in-depth understanding of the fundamental mechanisms of TCA and to develop a safe treatment protocol of TCA in the hope of advancing TCA into clinical trials.

Application of Trifluoroacetic Acid as a Theranostic Agent for Chemical Ablation of Solid Tissue

PURPOSE

To evaluate trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) as a theranostic chemical ablation agent and determine the efficacy of TFA for both noninvasive imaging and tissue destruction.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Fluorine-19 magnetic resonance imaging (¹⁹F-MRI) was optimized at 7 T using a custom-built volume coil. Fluorine images were acquired with both rapid acquisition with relaxation enhancement and balanced steady-state free precession (bSSFP) sequences with varying parameters to determine the optimal sequence for TFA. The theranostic efficacy of chemical ablation was examined by injecting TFA (100 μL; 0.25, 0.5, 1.0, and 2.0M) into ex vivo porcine liver. ¹⁹F and proton MRI were acquired and superimposed to visualize distribution of TFA in tissue and quantify sensitivity. Tissue damage was evaluated with gross examination, histology, and fluorescence microscopy.

RESULTS

The optimal ¹⁹F-MRI sequence was found to be bSSFP with a repetition time of 2.5 ms and flip angle of 70°. The minimum imageable TFA concentration was determined to be 6.7 ± 0.5 mM per minute of scan time (0.63×0.63×5.00 mm voxel), and real-time imaging (temporal resolution of at least 1 s^-1) was achieved with 2M TFA both in vitro and in ex vivo tissue. TFA successfully coagulated tissue, and damage was locally confined. In addition to hepatic cord disruption, cytoskeletal collapse and chromatin clumping were observed in severely damaged areas in tissues treated with 0.5M or higher TFA concentrations.

CONCLUSIONS

TFA was determined to be a theranostic agent for chemical ablation of solid tissue. Ablation was both efficacious and imageable in ex vivo healthy tissue, even at low concentrations or with high temporal resolution.

NaK alloy-induced in vivo tumor ablation therapy

PURPOSE

Alkali metal ablation is newly emerging as an effective, economic and minimally invasive ablation therapy. This study is dedicated to demonstrate the high efficiency of NaK alloy ablation on in vivo tumors with different stages in mice.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Panc02 tumor cells were injected into 21 female C57B/L mice, which were divided into three groups. Two experimental groups of mice received the same percutaneous NaK alloy injection for a week apart. The inner temperature response and surface temperature distribution were measured using a thermal couple and an infrared camera. After each ablation experiment, two mice in each group were chosen randomly to make pathological sections. The tumor volumes were measured once every two days. At the end, all tumors were cut off to calculate the tumor inhibition rates.

RESULTS

The NaK alloy-induced ablation therapy produced an obvious temperature increase (85 °C) in the ablation region and the high temperature distribution was relatively concentrated. The histopathology sections showed that developing stage tumors received incomplete destruction of the malignant cells compared with early stage tumors. The tumor inhibition rate in the early and developing tumor treatment groups were 88.5% and 67.6%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

This technology provides a nearly thorough ablation treatment for early stage tumors and also a palliative treatment for developing tumors.

Thermochemical ablation therapy of VX2 tumor using a permeable oil-packed liquid alkali metal

Objective

Alkali metal appears to be a promising tool in thermochemical ablation, but, it requires additional data on safety is required. The objective of this study was to explore the effectiveness of permeable oil-packed liquid alkali metal in the thermochemical ablation of tumors.

Methods

Permeable oil-packed sodium–potassium (NaK) was prepared using ultrasonic mixing of different ratios of metal to oil. The thermal effect of the mixture during ablation of muscle tissue ex vivo was evaluated using the Fluke Ti400 Thermal Imager. The thermochemical effect of the NaK-oil mixture on VX2 tumors was evaluated by performing perfusion CT scans both before and after treatment in 10 VX2 rabbit model tumors. VX2 tumors were harvested from two rabbits immediately after treatment to assess their viability using trypan blue and hematoxylin and eosin (H.E.) staining.

Results

The injection of the NaK–oil mixture resulted in significantly higher heat in the ablation areas. The permeable oil controlled the rate of heat released during the NaK reaction with water in the living tissue. Perfusion computed tomography and its parameter map confirmed that the NaK–oil mixture had curative effects on VX2 tumors. Both trypan blue and H.E. staining showed partial necrosis of the VX2 tumors.

Conclusions

The NaK–oil mixture may be used successfully to ablate tumor tissue in vivo. With reference to the controlled thermal and chemical lethal injury to tumors, using a liquid alkali in ablation is potentially an effective and safe method to treat malignant tumors.

Development of a Simple Miniature Thermochemical Ablation Device Suitable for Tumor Ablation Research in Rodent Models

Thermochemical ablation is a recently developed minimally invasive method with potential for solid tumor treatment such as in liver cancer. A recently described prototype device, however, is too large for use in the more common rodent models of cancer. In this report we describe a simple, low-cost variant of the device that is easy to assemble, small enough to be readily applicable to small animal models, and then demonstrate its use in an ex vivo model for ablation. It should therefore enable study of the method without requiring specialized equipment or access to a machine shop for device manufacture.

Chemothermal therapy for localized heating and ablation of tumor

Chemothermal therapy is a new hyperthermia treatment on tumor using heat released from exothermic chemical reaction between the injected reactants and the diseased tissues. With the highly minimally invasive feature and localized heating performance, this method is expected to overcome the ubiquitous shortcomings encountered by many existing hyperthermia approaches in ablating irregular tumor. This review provides a relatively comprehensive review on the latest advancements and state of the art in chemothermal therapy. The basic principles and features of two typical chemothermal ablation strategies (acid-base neutralization-reaction-enabled thermal ablation and alkali-metal-enabled thermal/chemical ablation) are illustrated. The prospects and possible challenges facing chemothermal ablation are analyzed. The chemothermal therapy is expected to open many clinical possibilities for precise tumor treatment in a minimally invasive way.

Dual mode single agent thermochemical ablation by simultaneous release of heat energy and acid: hydrolysis of electrophiles

PURPOSE

This study aimed to investigate two readily available electrophilic reagents, acetyl chloride (AcCl), and acetic anhydride (Ac(2)O), for their potential in tissue ablation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Reagents were diluted in diglyme as solutions up to 8 mol/L and tested in a gel phantom with NaOH solutions and ex vivo in porcine liver. Temperature, pH, and volume measurements were obtained. Infrared and gross pathological images were obtained in bisected specimens immediately after injection.

RESULTS

AcCl was much more reactive than Ac(2)O and AcCl was therefore used in the tissue studies. Temperature increases of up to 37°C were noted in vitro and 30°C in ex vivo tissues using 4 mol/L AcCl solutions. Experiments at 8 mol/L were abandoned due to the extreme reactivity at this higher concentration. A change in pH of up to 4 log units was noted with 4 mol/L solutions of AcCl with slight recovery over time. Ablated volumes were consistently higher than injected volumes.

CONCLUSIONS

Reaction of electrophiles in tissues shows promise as a new thermochemical ablation technique by means of only a single reagent. Further studies in this area are warranted.

In vivo comparison of simultaneous versus sequential injection technique for thermochemical ablation in a porcine model

PURPOSE

To investigate simultaneous and sequential injection thermochemical ablation in a porcine model, and compare them to sham and acid-only ablation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This IACUC-approved study involved 11 pigs in an acute setting. Ultrasound was used to guide placement of a thermocouple probe and coaxial device designed for thermochemical ablation. Solutions of 10 M acetic acid and NaOH were used in the study. Four injections per pig were performed in identical order at a total rate of 4 mL/min: saline sham, simultaneous, sequential, and acid only. Volume and sphericity of zones of coagulation were measured. Fixed specimens were examined by H&E stain.

RESULTS

Average coagulation volumes were 11.2 mL (simultaneous), 19.0 mL (sequential) and 4.4 mL (acid). The highest temperature, 81.3°C, was obtained with simultaneous injection. Average temperatures were 61.1°C (simultaneous), 47.7°C (sequential) and 39.5°C (acid only). Sphericity coefficients (0.83-0.89) had no statistically significant difference among conditions.

CONCLUSIONS

Thermochemical ablation produced substantial volumes of coagulated tissues relative to the amounts of reagents injected, considerably greater than acid alone in either technique employed. The largest volumes were obtained with sequential injection, yet this came at a price in one case of cardiac arrest. Simultaneous injection yielded the highest recorded temperatures and may be tolerated as well as or better than acid injection alone. Although this pilot study did not show a clear advantage for either sequential or simultaneous methods, the results indicate that thermochemical ablation is attractive for further investigation with regard to both safety and efficacy.

Thermochemical ablation in an ex-vivo porcine liver model using acetic acid and sodium hydroxide: proof of concept

PURPOSE

To establish proof of concept in tissue, using the exothermic neutralization reaction of acetic acid and sodium hydroxide in ex vivo porcine liver and to conduct an initial probe into the relationships of volume and concentration of reagents to temperatures and the areas affected.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 0.5 mL or 2 mL of either 5 mole/L or 10 mole/L acid and base solutions was injected simultaneously into the periphery of ex vivo porcine liver using a prototype injection device. Tissue temperature was recorded at the injection site for 5 minutes using a type T thermocouple temperature probe inserted parallel to and near the tip of the injection device. The injections were repeated for infrared thermography, and ablated tissues were sectioned quickly and imaged. A gross photograph was captured in each case to provide correlation.

RESULTS

Maximum temperatures (17°C baseline) ranged from 42.1° ± α3.34°C to 61.7° ± α10°C (P<.05) when injecting 0.5 mL of 5 mole/L reactants and 2 mL of 10 mole/L reactants, respectively. The maximum temperature measured by infrared imaging ranged from 31°-47°C. Using an infrared viewing scale from 19°-40°C, the cross-sectional area of tissue heating above baseline measured from 1.07 cm(2)± 0.45 to 4.95 cm(2)± 0.28 (P <05).

CONCLUSIONS

The reaction of acetic acid and sodium hydroxide releases significant heat energy at the site of injection, and histologic changes are consistent with coagulation necrosis. Increased reagent concentration and volume were associated with larger temperature changes and larger areas of hyperthermia at gross pathology and infrared imaging.

Quantification and controllability study of minimally invasive exothermic chemo-ablation therapy for tumor ablation

The recently proposed exothermic chemical reaction based tumor hyperthermia method presented a new way of realizing truly minimally invasive treatment for tumor. This method utilizes heat generated from the reaction between acid and alkali solutions to allow for tumor ablation. Successful clinical implementation of this method requires a clearer understanding and quantification of the ablation area such that a more controllable operation can be made. A number of in-vitro and in-vivo experiments are designed to examine the features of thermal chemo-ablation therapy which include micro and macro characteristics of ablated tissue and temperature change during the ablation process. A Quantitative study on the relationship between velocity and ablation volume as well as a Graphical User Interface in Matlab for computerized ablation area analysis are also presented in this article. We present in here two instrument designs for thermal chemo-ablation and have completed the prototype design for the injection pump which has been tested and successfully applied in ex-vivo and vivo experiments.