Longitudinal phenotypic study of late-onset retinal degeneration due to a founder variant c.562C>A p.(Pro188Thr) in the C1QTNF5 gene

An incipient late-onset retinal degeneration with a C1QTNF5 mutation: a case report with an 11-year follow-up

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to describe and diagnose the difficulty in a long-term follow-up (eleven years) patient with a very early presentation of late-onset retinal degeneration (L-ORD) and the significance of electrophysiological examinations and follow-up in assessing undiagnosed inherited retinal diseases.

METHODS

This is an observational case report of a 56-year-old woman, with scattered multiple yellow-white retinal dots firstly diagnosed as fundus albipunctatus. Ten years after presentation, a deterioration in rod and cone responses in ff-ERG was detected, which allowed us to discard the first diagnostic hypothesis and proceed with a genetic testing.

RESULTS

Ten years after presentation, she presented a clear progression of the abnormal photoreceptor response with a cone and rod involvement in ff-ERG, which was not compatible with the previous suspicion of fundus albipunctatus. Six months later, genetic testing results together with the typical progression of atrophic patchy lesions in multimodal imaging allowed a certain diagnosis of L-ORD, caused by an already reported pathogenic variant in the C1QTNF5 gene (c.563C > T; p. Pro188 Leu).

CONCLUSIONS

We demonstrate the importance of the ff-ERG examination and the follow-up (or ERG and imaging repetition) in the differential diagnosis of an incipient L-ORD, which can be easily misdiagnosed in the early stages, before the appearance of the characteristic chorioretinal atrophy seen with the progression of this rare disease.

Macular neovascularization in inherited retinal diseases: A review

Inherited retinal diseases (IRDs) are the most common cause of blindness in working-age adults. Macular neovascularization (MNV) may be a presenting feature or occurs as a late-stage complication in several IRDs. We performed an extensive literature review on MNV associated with IRDs. MNV is a well-known complication of Sorsby fundus dystrophy and pseudoxanthoma elasticum. Those with late-onset Stargardt disease may masquerade as exudative age-related macular degeneration (AMD) when MNV is the presenting feature. Peripherinopathies may develop MNV that responds well to a short course of anti-vascular endothelial growth factor (anti-VEGF) therapy, while bestrophinopathies tend to develop MNV in the early stages of the disease without vision loss. Enhanced S-cone syndrome manifests type 3 MNV that typically regresses into a subfoveal fibrotic nodule. MNV is only a rare complication in choroideraemia and rod-cone dystrophies. Most IRD-related MNVs exhibit a favorable visual prognosis requiring less intensive regimens of anti-vascular endothelial growth factor therapy compared to age-related macular degeneration. We discuss the role of key imaging modalities in the diagnosis of MNV across a wide spectrum of IRDs and highlight the gaps in our knowledge with respect to the natural history and prognosis to pave the way for future directions of research.

Treatment Strategy With Gene Editing for Late-Onset Retinal Degeneration Caused by a Founder Variant in C1QTNF5

Purpose

Genome editing is an emerging group of technologies with the potential to ameliorate dominant, monogenic human diseases such as late-onset retinal degeneration (L-ORD). The goal of this study was to identify disease stages and retinal locations optimal for evaluating the efficacy of a future genome editing trial.

Methods

Twenty five L-ORD patients (age range, 33-77 years; median age, 59 years) harboring the founder variant S163R in C1QTNF5 were enrolled from three centers in the United Kingdom and United States. Patients were examined with widefield optical coherence tomography (OCT) and chromatic perimetry under dark-adapted and light-adapted conditions to derive phenomaps of retinal disease. Results were analyzed with a model of a shared natural history of a single delayed exponential across all subjects and all retinal locations.

Results

Critical age for the initiation of photoreceptor loss ranged from 48 years at the temporal paramacular retina to 74 years at the inferior midperipheral retina. Subretinal deposits (sRET-Ds) became more prevalent as critical age was approached. Subretinal pigment epithelial deposits (sRPE-Ds) were detectable in the youngest patients showing no other structural or functional abnormalities at the retina. The sRPE-D thickness continuously increased, reaching 25 µm in the extrafoveal retina and 19 µm in the fovea at critical age. Loss of light sensitivity preceded shortening of outer segments and loss of photoreceptors by more than a decade.

Conclusions

Retinal regions providing an ideal treatment window exist across all severity stages of L-ORD.

Longitudinal Changes of Retinal Structure in Molecularly Confirmed C1QTNF5 Patients With Late-Onset Retinal Degeneration

Purpose

The purpose of this study was to present our findings on the natural history of late-onset retinal degeneration (LORD) in patients with molecularly confirmed C1QTNF5 heterozygous pathogenic variants and assess suitability of retinal structure parameters for disease monitoring.

Methods

Sixteen patients with C1QTNF5-LORD were retrospectively identified from Moorfields Eye Hospital, UK. Fundus autofluorescence (FAF), optical coherence tomography (OCT) scans, and best-corrected visual acuity (BCVA) were collected. Area of atrophy (AA) was manually drawn in FAF images. Ellipsoid zone (EZ) width and foveal retinal thickness of the whole retina and outer retina were extracted from OCT scans. Age-related changes were tested with linear-mixed models.

Results

Patients had median age of 62.3 years (interquartile range [IQR] = 58.8-65.4 years) at baseline, and median follow-up of 5.1 years (IQR = 2.6-7.6 years). AA, EZ width, and retinal thickness parameters remained unchanged until age 50 years, but showed significant change with age thereafter (all P < 0.0001). AA and EZ width progressed rapidly (dynamic range normalized rates = 4.3-4.5%/year) from age 53.9 and 50.8 years (estimated inflection points), respectively. Retinal thickness parameters showed slower progression rates (range = 1.6-2.5%/year) from age 60 to 62.3. BCVA (median = 0.3 LogMAR, IQR = 0.0-1.0 at baseline) showed a rapid decline (3.3%) from age 70 years. Findings from patients with earlier disease showed FAF atrophy manifests in the temporal retina initially, and then progresses nasally.

Conclusions

Patients with LORD remained asymptomatic until age 50 years, before suffering rapid outer retinal degeneration. EZ width and AA showed rapid progression and high interocular correlation, representing promising outcome metrics. Clinical measures also capturing the temporal retina may be preferable, enabling earlier detection and better disease monitoring.

Translational Relevance

Area of atrophy in FAF images and OCT-measured EZ width represent promising outcome metrics for disease monitoring in patients with C1QTNF5-LORD.

Application of Electrophysiology in Non-Macular Inherited Retinal Dystrophies

Inherited retinal dystrophies encompass a diverse group of disorders affecting the structure and function of the retina, leading to progressive visual impairment and, in severe cases, blindness. Electrophysiology testing has emerged as a valuable tool in assessing and diagnosing those conditions, offering insights into the function of different parts of the visual pathway from retina to visual cortex and aiding in disease classification. This review provides an overview of the application of electrophysiology testing in the non-macular inherited retinal dystrophies focusing on both common and rare variants, including retinitis pigmentosa, progressive cone and cone-rod dystrophy, bradyopsia, Bietti crystalline dystrophy, late-onset retinal degeneration, and fundus albipunctatus. The different applications and limitations of electrophysiology techniques, including multifocal electroretinogram (mfERG), full-field ERG (ffERG), electrooculogram (EOG), pattern electroretinogram (PERG), and visual evoked potential (VEP), in the diagnosis and management of these distinctive phenotypes are discussed. The potential for electrophysiology testing to allow for further understanding of these diseases and the possibility of using these tests for early detection, prognosis prediction, and therapeutic monitoring in the future is reviewed.

Distinct Phenotypic Consequences of Pathogenic Mutants Associated with Late-Onset Retinal Degeneration

A pathologic feature of late-onset retinal degeneration caused by the S163R mutation in C1q-tumor necrosis factor-5 (C1QTNF5) is the presence of unusually thick deposits between the retinal pigmented epithelium (RPE) and the vascular choroid, considered a hallmark of this disease. Following its specific expression in mouse RPE, the S163R mutant exhibits a reversed polarized distribution relative to the apically secreted wild-type C1QTNF5, and forms widespread, prominent deposits that gradually increase in size with aging. The current study shows that S163R deposits expand to a considerable thickness through a progressive increase in the basolateral RPE membrane, substantially raising the total RPE height, and enabling their clear imaging as a distinct hyporeflective layer by noninvasive optical coherence tomography in advanced age animals. This phenotype bears a striking resemblance to ocular pathology previously documented in patients harboring the S163R mutation. Therefore, a similar viral vector-based gene delivery approach was used to also investigate the behavior of P188T and G216C, two novel pathogenic C1QTNF5 mutants recently reported in patients for which histopathologic data are lacking. Both mutants primarily impacted the RPE/photoreceptor interface and did not generate basal laminar deposits. Distinct distribution patterns and phenotypic consequences of C1QTNF5 mutants were observed in vivo, which suggested that multiple pathobiological mechanisms contribute to RPE dysfunction and vision loss in this disorder.

Outer retinal corrugations in late-onset retinal degeneration: a diagnostic finding demonstrated with multimodal imaging

OBJECTIVE

Late-onset retinal degeneration (L-ORD) is a rare autosomal dominant retinal degeneration that presents in the sixth decade and leads to severe visual loss. The objective of this paper is to describe outer retinal corrugations as a diagnostic feature of L-ORD.

METHODS

This retrospective study reviewed consecutive patients diagnosed with L-ORD, confirmed through complete ophthalmic examination, multimodal imaging and genetic tests. Multimodal imaging investigations included spectral domain-optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT) and ultra-wide-field colour and autofluorescence fundus photographs.

RESULTS

A total of 13 eyes of 9 patients with L-ORD had outer retinal corrugations identified on OCT scans.

CONCLUSION

Outer retinal corrugations may be a diagnostic finding for L-ORD. The detection of this sign may aid diagnosis and characterisation of this disease and help in the differential diagnosis with other acquired pathologies.

Anterior segment phenotypic changes in late-onset retinal degeneration with Ser163Arg mutation in CTRP5/C1QTNF5

PURPOSE

Late-onset retinal degeneration (L-ORD) is a rare retinal dystrophy with anterior segment (AS) abnormalities, including long anterior zonules (LAZ) and iris atrophy. This investigation evaluates AS changes in a L-ORD cohort.

METHODS

Prospective, longitudinal study including L-ORD individuals (Ser163Arg) with ocular exam and standard slit-lamp photographs between 2011 and 2022. AS images were merged and assessed for LAZ number and zonule-free zone (ZFZ) radius. Further clinical findings such as iris atrophy patterns were reported descriptively.

RESULTS

Twelve eyes of 6 patients (4 males, median age = 60.5 years) were included, showing a median of 160 (11-372) LAZs, mainly localized superiorly (39%) and inferiorly (24%). There was a high inter-ocular correlation (rs = 0.94, p < 0.01), no difference in LAZ count between eyes (p = 0.82), and an inverse relationship between LAZ and age (r =  - 0.82; p < 0.05). The ZFZ had median 2.1 mm (1.3-5.4), with no inter-ocular difference (p = 0.31). Iris transillumination defects occurred in 11/12 eyes, with 4 major patterns identified: pupillary ruff rarefaction (10/12), patchy atrophy (6/12), notched defects (6/12), and radial streaks (2/12). In a short-term follow-up of 5.9 years, 4 eyes showed a reduction in LAZ count to median 139.5 (67-169) (p = 0.50) and a concomitant increase in ZFZ measurement to median 2.2 (1.7-2.6) (p = 0.17).

CONCLUSION

This study confirms symmetric LAZs count and ZFZ in L-ORD, with ZFZ measurements smaller than in previous cohorts. A reduction in LAZs count and an increase in ZFZ with age were suggested longitudinally, yet findings need further evaluation as follow-up was limited to two cases.

Current Management of Inherited Retinal Degeneration Patients in Europe: Results of a 2-Year Follow-Up Multinational Survey by the European Vision Institute Clinical Research Network - EVICR.net

INTRODUCTION

An increasing number of gene-specific therapies are being developed for inherited retinal degenerations (IRDs). Identification of well-characterized patients is an emerging need. We conducted the second multinational survey among the www.evicr.net and ERN-EYE members to understand the management and treatment of IRDs in Europe and compared it to the 2019 survey.

METHODS

An electronic survey questionnaire was developed and sent to 124 clinical centers (25 countries) by June/July 2021. Statistical analysis was performed with Excel and R.

RESULTS

The overall response rate was 44% but varied among countries. Only 9% of responding centers do not see IRD patients (2019 survey 14%), 42% follow at least 200 patients per year, 18% follow 500-999, and 2% more than 1,000. Databases exist in 86% of the centers (local 86%; national web based 12%). IRD patients are referred to www.evicr.net and ERN-EYE centers mainly by general ophthalmologists, patient self-referral, or medical retina specialists. Most IRD patients are first seen as adults. Signs and symptoms depend on age of onset: in infancy, nystagmus; at older age, night blindness and reduced visual field; reduced visual acuity is described at any age. Comprehensive ophthalmic examination always includes visual acuity and almost always visual field multimodal retinal imaging, electrophysiology, color vision testing, and refraction. Identification of genotypes is successful in 72% of centers in 40-80% of cases (2019 survey 69% of centers). The time for confirmation of the genetic diagnosis varies from 2-4 weeks to 24 months (2019 survey >4 weeks ≤10 years). Genetic testing is covered by public health service in 83%, private health insurance in 29%, research funds in 24%; 5% do not have access to genetic testing (2019 survey 15%). The most striking result is the high increase in the involvement of centers in natural history and gene therapy trials that more than doubled for the latter.

DISCUSSION

This second multinational survey on management of IRDs in Europe highlights persistent important differences in the number of IRD patients managed per center, comparable diagnostic work-up, and increasing genotyping in diagnostic laboratories. The important increase in involvement of centers in natural history and gene therapy trials reflects the rapidly evolving field of gene therapy development. The survey provides important follow-up data for researchers, clinicians, caregivers, patient advocate groups, pharmaceutical companies, and investors.

Late-Onset Retinal Degeneration: Clinical Perspectives

Late-onset retinal degeneration (L-ORD) is a type of retinal dystrophy marked by nyctalopia and subretinal pigment epithelium deposits, which eventually promote retinal atrophy with final visual compromise. L-ORD may also present with changes in the anterior segment, notably long anterior zonules and iris atrophy, distinguishing it from other inherited eye conditions. Although it can clinically simulate age-related macular degeneration, L-ORD has a different course of progression and prognosis, requiring adequate diagnosis for patient counseling. This review summarizes the main clinical, genetic, pathophysiological, diagnostic, and therapeutic aspects of L-ORD to help ophthalmologists identify and manage this rare ocular disease.