The application and impact of cryopreservation of early cleavage stage embryos in assisted reproduction

The impacts of the number of prefreeze and postthaw blastomeres on embryo implantation potential: A systematic analysis

To systematically analyze the potential of embryo implantation through comparison between the number of surviving blastomeres, the growth, and implantation rate.Retrospective analysis on implantation rate and the growth of prefreeze-postthaw embryos with different blastomeres in 1487 frozen embryo transfer cycles.In groups of postthaw embryos without damage, implantation rate and the average number of blastomere growth increased significantly with increasing number of blastomeres. The implantation rate and the number of blastomeres of embryos with 8-8c (the number of blastomeres in prefreeze embryo-the number of blastomeres in postthaw embryo) continued to grow at a significantly higher rate than that of 5-5c and 6-6c (P < .05). In groups of embryos with the same number of blastomeres before freezing and with partial damage after resuscitation, the implantation rates were lower and the average numbers of blastomere growth reduced as the number of damaged blastomeres increased. For embryos with good quality before freezing, 1 to 3 damaged blastomeres in postthawed embryos did not affect the development and implantation rate. Both implantation rate and growth rate of embryos with 8-6c were significantly higher than those of embryos with 6-6c (P < .05).The number of surviving blastomeres and growth in frozen-thawed embryos could be important index to predict embryo development potential and clinical outcome of implantation. For embryos with good quality, a small amount of damaged blastomeres would not weaken embryo development potential and implantation rate after being thawed.

Cryopreservation and long-term maintenance of bovine embryo-derived cell lines

The aim of this study was to develop methods for cryopreservation and long-term maintenance of putative bovine embryonic stem cells (ESCs). Putative bovine ESC (bESC) lines (n=3) isolated in conventional medium were used to compare slow-freezing and vitrification. After warming, vitrified cells (96.9%) demonstrated significantly (P<0.05) better survival than frozen-thawed cells (81.5%) and formed significantly more colonies with good morphology (vitrification: 93/93, 100.0%; slow-freezing: 74/106, 69.81%; P<0.05). The effect of inhibitors of differentiation (PD184352, SU5402, CHIR99021) on ESC maintenance was assessed on putative bESC lines established in N2B27-3i medium (n=8) or conventional medium (n=1) after culture over 30 passages (>240 days). All cell lines expressed ALP, SSEA1, SSEA4, OCT4, REX1 and SSEA1. OCT4 expression was confirmed by relative real-time PCR and was upregulated in early passages of putative bESCs cultured in N2B27-3i (2.9±0.89-fold higher at Passage (P) 2-4), whereas the converse was observed later (P22-26; 2.2±0.1-fold increase in conventional medium). Putative bESC lines isolated in N2B27-3i medium (n=3) or conventional medium (n=1) were vitrified at P18 and, after warming, were cultured for a further 12 passages. These cells survived vitrification and expressed OCT4, REX1, SSEA1, ALP, SSEA1 and SSEA4. These results demonstrate that putative bESC lines that express pluripotent markers can be cultured long term and retain expression of pluripotent markers after vitrification.

A critical appraisal of cryopreservation (slow cooling versus vitrification) of human oocytes and embryos

BACKGROUND

Vitrification is now a commonly applied technique for cryopreservation in assisted reproductive technology (ART) replacing, in many cases, conventional slow cooling methodology. This review examines evidence relevant to comparison of the two approaches applied to human oocytes and embryos at different developmental stages.

METHODS

Critical review of the published literature using PubMed with particular emphasis on studies which include data on survival and implantation rates, data from fresh control groups and evaluation of the two approaches in a single setting.

RESULTS

Slow cooling is associated with lower survival rates and compromised development relative to vitrification when applied to metaphase II (MII) oocytes, although the vitrification results have predominantly been obtained using direct contact with liquid nitrogen and there is some evidence that optimal protocols for slow cooling of MII oocytes are yet to be established. There are no prospective randomized controlled trials (RCTs) which support the use of either technique with pronuclear oocytes although vitrification has become the method of choice. Optimal slow cooling, using modifications of traditional methodology, and vitrification can result in high survival rates of early embryos, which implant at the same rate as equivalent fresh counterparts. Many studies report high survival and implantation rates following vitrification of blastocysts. Although slow cooling of blastocysts has been reported to be inferior in some studies, others comparing the two approaches in the same clinical setting have demonstrated comparable results. The variation in the extent of embryo selection applied in studies can lead to apparent differences in clinical efficiency, which may not be significant if expressed on a 'per oocyte used' basis.

CONCLUSIONS

Available evidence suggests that vitrification is the current method of choice when cryopreserving MII oocytes. Early cleavage stage embryos can be cryopreserved with equal success using slow cooling and vitrification. Successful blastocyst cryopreservation may be more consistently achieved with vitrification but optimal slow cooling can produce similar results. There are key limitations associated with the available evidence base, including a paucity of RCTs, limited reporting of live birth outcomes and limited reporting of detail which would allow assessment of the impact of differences in female age. While vitrification has a clear role in ART, we support continued research to establish optimal slow cooling methods which may assist in alleviating concerns over safety issues, such as storage, transport and the use of very high cryoprotectant concentrations.

Patients undergoing frozen-thawed embryo transfer have similar live birth rates in spontaneous and artificial cycles

PURPOSE

To evaluate the outcome of frozen-thawed embryo transfer (FET) when freezing takes place at the pronuclear stage, a retrospective analysis was performed comparing spontaneous and artificial cycles.

METHODS

148 women received FET in a spontaneous cycle (Group A) and 55 women received FET in an artificial cycle (Group B) induced by administering estrogen (E2) and progesterone (P). Pregnancy rates, endometrial thickness and serum levels of E2, P and luteinizing hormone (LH) were measured. Statistical analysis included the mean, the standard deviation, the Chi-squared test and the T-test.

RESULTS

The clinical pregnancy rate was 34.5% for Group A and 21.8% for Group B (p = 0.084), with a live birth rate of 20.9% and 12.7% respectively (p = 0.15). There was no difference in endometrial thickness or the P levels, while LH and E2 levels were significantly higher in group B (p < 0.0001).

CONCLUSION

Our retrospective study shows a trend towards higher pregnancy rates and live birth rates with the administration of FET during a spontaneous cycle compared to FET during an artificial cycle. Large randomized controlled trials are needed to confirm this trend.

The relationship between endometrial thickness and outcome of medicated frozen embryo replacement cycles

OBJECTIVE

To examine the relationship between endometrial thickness and outcome of medicated frozen-thawed embryo replacement (FER) cycles.

DESIGN

A retrospective observational study.

SETTING

Assisted conception unit at a university hospital.

PATIENT(S)

All patients who underwent an FER cycle between 1997 and April 2006 and met the inclusion criteria.

INTERVENTION(S)

For endometrial preparation, a daily dose of 6 mg of oral E(2) valerate was started on menstrual day 1, and P pessaries (800 mg daily) were administrated when the endometrial thickness had reached 7 mm or more, with ET taking place 2-3 days later. The FER cycles were categorized according to endometrial thickness measurement on the day of P supplementation.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Implantation, clinical pregnancy, ongoing pregnancy, and live birth rates.

RESULT(S)

In all, 768 consecutive medicated FER cycles were analyzed. The lowest pregnancy rates were associated with endometrial thickness <7 mm (n = 13) and >14 mm (n = 12; 7% in both groups). Significantly higher implantation (19% vs. 12%), clinical pregnancy (30% vs. 18%), ongoing pregnancy (27% vs. 16%), and live birth (25% vs. 14%) rates were achieved in cycles where endometrial thickness was 9-14 mm (n = 386), compared with those in which endometrial thickness was 7-8 mm (n = 357). These differences remained significant after adjusting for confounding variables (adjusted odds ratio [OR] = 1.83 [confidence interval {CI} = 1.3-2.6] for clinical pregnancy, 1.8 [CI = 1.2-2.6] for ongoing pregnancy and 1.9 [CI = 1.3-2.8] for live birth).

CONCLUSION(S)

In medicated FER cycles, an endometrial thickness of 9-14 mm measured on the day of P supplementation is associated with higher implantation and pregnancy rates compared with an endometrial thickness of 7-8 mm.

Human oocyte cryopreservation

The clinical role of oocyte cryopreservation in assisted reproduction, as an adjunct to sperm and embryo cryopreservation, has been comparatively slow to evolve as a consequence of theoretical concerns related to efficacy and safety. Basic biological studies in the 1990's alleviated many of these concerns leading to more widespread adoption of the technology. While a number of babies were born from the approach validated in the 1990's, its perceived clinical inefficiency led to the search for improved methods. Introduction of elevated dehydrating sucrose concentrations during cryopreservation increased survival and fertilization rates, but there is no well-controlled evidence of improved clinical outcome. Similarly, the use of sodium-depleted cryopreservation media has not been demonstrated to increase clinical efficiency. More recently, and in the absence of basic biological studies addressing safety issues, the application of vitrification techniques to human oocytes has resulted in reports of a number of live births. The small number of babies born from clinical oocyte cryopreservation and the paucity of well-controlled studies currently preclude valid comparisons between approaches. Legal restrictions on the ability to select embryos from cryopreserved oocytes in Italy, where many of the available reports originate, also obscure attempts to assess oocyte cryopreservation objectively.

Vitrification of preimplantation genetically diagnosed human blastocysts and its contribution to the cumulative ongoing pregnancy rate per cycle by using a closed device

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the survival rate and clinical results of our vitrification procedure on preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) blastocysts and to calculate its actual contribution to the reproductive outcome per cycle.

DESIGN

Retrospective clinical study.

SETTING

University Institute IVI, Valencia, Spain.

PATIENT(S)

Patients who requested cryotransfer of surplus PGD blastocysts after failed fresh elective transfer.

INTERVENTION(S)

Retrospectively collected data during 2 years of experience with blastocyst vitrification.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Primary outcome measures were the following: blastocyst recovery and survival; cryotransfer cancellation; and the implantation, pregnancy (PR), and ongoing-pregnancy rates. The secondary outcome measure was cumulative ongoing PR (COPR).

RESULT(S)

Cocultured vitrified PGD blastocysts were recovered and progressed in development after overnight culture (survival rate) at rates comparable to those of non-PGD blastocysts (49% and 42%, respectively). After transfer to 64% of patients, no statistical differences were found between PGD and non-PGD blastocyst groups concerning the following: PR (44% vs. 37%), implantation rate (40% vs. 27%), and ongoing-pregnancy rate (32% vs. 37%). Moreover, blastocyst vitrification significantly increased the COPR in both PGD and non-PGD cycles, from 47% (62/133) to 53% (70/133) and from 45% (24/53) to 53% (28/53), respectively.

CONCLUSION(S)

A preimplantation genetic diagnosis blastocyst vitrification procedure showed survival rates and improvements on the COPR that were comparable to those in non-PGD blastocyst cycles. Moreover, vitrification of biopsied and diagnosed embryos at the more advanced stages instead of at earlier cleavage stages is presented as an attractive strategy to consider in PGD programs.

Objective evaluation of the viability of cryopreserved oocytes

Recent studies of fundamental cryobiology, empirical observations and more systematic clinical experiences have generated a renewed interest in oocyte cryopreservation. Poor survival rate has long been the limiting factor which has prevented widespread adoption of oocyte storage. Slow-cooling and vitrification protocols developed in the last few years have apparently solved this problem, ensuring high recovery of viable oocytes from liquid nitrogen storage. However, the definition of oocyte viability appears rather vague. In fact, post-storage survival as assessed on morphological criteria, indicated by the absence of overt cell degeneration, is not necessarily synonymous with viability. Despite its sensitivity to low temperatures, the meiotic spindle can be preserved after cryopreservation and its constitution after thawing can be monitored non-invasively through polarized light microscopy. Assessment of oocyte cryopreservation via clinical parameters is a daunting task. Most studies are small and difficult to interpret because of confounding factors, such as age, patient selection and quality and strategy of use of the cryopreserved material. Some progress has been made, however, as suggested by recent experiences in which the implantation efficiency of embryos produced from thawed oocytes approaches that reported using cryopreserved embryos directly.

Embryonic factors affecting outcome from single cryopreserved embryo transfer

Multiple pregnancy minimization by single embryo transfer is becoming more prevalent, but is less common in the case of cryopreserved embryos. This study defines embryonic characteristics in single cryopreserved embryo transfers associated with success rates equivalent to those achieved when transferring two cryopreserved embryos. In a retrospective analysis of 6916 cryopreserved day-2 embryo transfer procedures, transfer of two cryopreserved embryos resulted in higher clinical pregnancy rates when compared with transfer of a single thawed embryo but was also associated with elevated multiple pregnancy rates (26.7% in women under 36). Optimal outcome (implantation rate of 30.9%) from single cryopreserved embryo transfer (SCET) in women under 36 was associated with cryopreservation at the 4-cell stage, loss of fewer than two blastomeres and subsequent cleavage of at least two surviving blastomeres. In comparison, transfer of two cryopreserved embryos in women under 36 resulted in pregnancy and implantation rates of 25.5 and 16.1% respectively. Interestingly, in cryopreserved 4-cell stage embryos, loss of a single blastomere did not reduce implantation potential and cleavage of only a single post-thaw blastomere was not indicative of increased implantation potential. Establishment of these critical thresholds provides a rational basis for SCET.