Incidence and natural history of preeclampsia/eclampsia at the university maternity of Antananarivo, Madagascar: high prevalence of the early-onset condition

Inter-facility transfers for emergency obstetrical and neonatal care in rural Madagascar: a cost-effectiveness analysis

CONTEXT

There is a substantial lack of inter-facility referral systems for emergency obstetrical and neonatal care in rural areas of sub-Saharan Africa. Data on the costs and cost-effectiveness of such systems that reduce preventable maternal and neonatal deaths are scarce.

SETTING

We aimed to determine the cost-effectiveness of a non-governmental organisation (NGO)-run inter-facility referral system for emergency obstetrical and neonatal care in rural Southern Madagascar by analysing the characteristics of cases referred through the intervention as well as its costs.

DESIGN

We used secondary NGO data, drawn from an NGO's monitoring and financial administration database, including medical and financial records.

OUTCOME MEASURES

We performed a descriptive and a cost-effectiveness analysis, including a one-way deterministic sensitivity analysis.

RESULTS

1172 cases were referred over a period of 4 years. The most common referral reasons were obstructed labour, ineffective labour and eclampsia. In total, 48 neonates were referred through the referral system over the study period. Estimated cost per referral was US$336 and the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER) was US$70 per additional life-year saved (undiscounted, discounted US$137). The sensitivity analysis showed that the intervention was cost-effective for all scenarios with the lowest ICER at US$99 and the highest ICER at US$205 per additional life-year saved. When extrapolated to the population living in the study area, the investment costs of the programme were US$0.13 per person and annual running costs US$0.06 per person.

CONCLUSIONS

In our study, the inter-facility referral system was a very cost-effective intervention. Our findings may inform policies, decision-making and implementation strategies for emergency obstetrical and neonatal care referral systems in similar resource-constrained settings.

Eclampsia in the 21st century

The reported incidence of eclampsia is 1.6 to 10 per 10,000 deliveries in developed countries, whereas it is 50 to 151 per 10,000 deliveries in developing countries. In addition, low-resource countries have substantially higher rates of maternal and perinatal mortalities and morbidities. This disparity in incidence and pregnancy outcomes may be related to universal access to prenatal care, early detection of preeclampsia, timely delivery, and availability of healthcare resources in developed countries compared to developing countries. Because of its infrequency in developed countries, many obstetrical providers and maternity units have minimal to no experience in the acute management of eclampsia and its complications. Therefore, clear protocols for prevention of eclampsia in those with severe preeclampsia and acute treatment of eclamptic seizures at all levels of healthcare are required for better maternal and neonatal outcomes. Eclamptic seizure will occur in 2% of women with preeclampsia with severe features who are not receiving magnesium sulfate and in <0.6% in those receiving magnesium sulfate. The pathogenesis of an eclamptic seizure is not well understood; however, the blood-brain barrier disruption with the passage of fluid, ions, and plasma protein into the brain parenchyma remains the leading theory. New data suggest that blood-brain barrier permeability may increase by circulating factors found in preeclamptic women plasma, such as vascular endothelial growth factor and placental growth factor. The management of an eclamptic seizure will include supportive care to prevent serious maternal injury, magnesium sulfate for prevention of recurrent seizures, and promoting delivery. Although routine imagining following an eclamptic seizure is not recommended, the classic finding is referred to as the posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome. Most patients with posterior reversible encephalopathy syndrome will show complete resolution of the imaging finding within 1 to 2 weeks, but routine imaging follow-up is unnecessary unless there are findings of intracranial hemorrhage, infraction, or ongoing neurologic deficit. Eclampsia is associated with increased risk of maternal mortality and morbidity, such as placental abruption, disseminated intravascular coagulation, pulmonary edema, aspiration pneumonia, cardiopulmonary arrest, and acute renal failure. Furthermore, a history of eclamptic seizures may be related to long-term cardiovascular risk and cognitive difficulties related to memory and concentration years after the index pregnancy. Finally, limited data suggest that placental growth factor levels in women with preeclampsia are superior to clinical markers in prediction of adverse pregnancy outcomes. This data may be extrapolated to the prediction of eclampsia in future studies. This summary of available evidence provides data and expert opinion on possible pathogenesis of eclampsia, imaging findings, differential diagnosis, and stepwise approach regarding the management of eclampsia before delivery and after delivery as well as current recommendations for the prevention of eclamptic seizures in women with preeclampsia.

Risk Factors for Early and Late Onset Preeclampsia in Reunion Island: Multivariate Analysis of Singleton and Twin Pregnancies. A 20-Year Population-Based Cohort of 2120 Preeclampsia Cases

Objectives: To develop a multivariate model for risk factors specific to early onset preeclampsia (EOP) and late onset preeclampsia (LOP) in our entire population (singleton and twin pregnancies). Material and methods: 20 year-observational population-based historical cohort study (2001–2020). All consecutive births delivered at the Centre Hospitalier Universitaire Hospitalier Sud Reunion’s maternity ward. A standardized validated epidemiological perinatal database was used. Results: During the 20-year period, there were 81,834 pregnancies and 83,497 infants born, 1232 dichorionic and 350 monochorionic twin pregnancies. There were 2120 cases of preeclampsia, of which 2001 were preeclamptic singleton pregnancies and 119 twin pregnancies (incidence 7.5% in twin pregnancies vs. 2.5% singletons, OR 3.0, p < 0.001). Independent risk factors for EOP and LOP in a multivariate model (controlling for the two major confounders: maternal ages—both risks for EOP and LOP, and maternal pre-pregnancy BMI—specific risk factor for LOP) were: history of preeclampsia (adjusted OR (aOR) 11.7 for EOP, 7.8 for LOP, p < 0.0001), chronic hypertension (aOR 7.3 for EOP, 3.9 for LOP, p < 0.0001), history of perinatal death (aOR 2.2 for EOP, p < 0.0001 and 1.48 for LOP, p = 0.007), primipaternity (aOR 3.0 for EOP and 3.6 for LOP, p = 0.001), dizygotic twin pregnancies (aOR 3.7 for EOP, p < 0.0001 and 2.1 for LOP, p = 0.003), monozygotic twin pregnancies (aOR 3.98 for EOP, p = 0.003 and non-significant (NS) for LOP), ovulation induction (aOR 5.6 for EOP, p = 0.004 and NS for LOP), and in vitro fertilization (aOR 2.8 for EOP, p = 0.05 and NS for LOP). Specific to LOP and NS for EOP: renal diseases (aOR for LOP 2.9, p = 0.007) and gestational diabetes mellitus (aOR 1.2, p = 0.04). Conclusions: Maternal ages over 35 years, chronic hypertension, history of preeclampsia, ovulation induction, in vitro fertilizations, history of perinatal deaths and twin pregnancy (in our experience, especially mono zygotic twin pregnancies) are significant risk factors for EOP. New paternity is an independent factor for both EOP and LOP.

Admission into intensive care unit in preeclampsia: a four-year population-based study in Reunion Island

INTRODUCTION

Preeclampsia is one of the leading causes of maternal and fetal morbidity and mortality. The objective of our study was to study risk factors and complications associated with severe preeclampsia requiring intensive care unit (ICU) admission.

METHODS

Retrospective comparative study over a period from 1st of January 2015 to 1st of January 2019 in the University's maternity unit of South Reunion (Indian Ocean). Our sampling included all preeclamptic patients who delivered in the Southern part of the island. Patients admitted to intensive care unit (ICU) and those who remained in the maternity unit (controls) were reviewed.

RESULTS

Out of 482 preeclampsia cases, 94 women (19.5%) needed a transfer in ICU, of which only 21 (4.3%) needed invasive intensive care. Mean length of stay was 2.4 ± 2.1 days. ICU admission was associated with HELLP syndrome (OR 8.5 [4.9-14.9], p<.001), severe post-partum hemorrhage (OR 5.86 [1.29-26.70], p=.01) and early onset of preeclampsia (<34 weeks gestation), 2.97 [1.9-4.7], p<.001), leading to higher rate of C-section (OR 2.83 [1.67-4.78], p<.001). There were three patients with a history of eclampsia and no case of maternal death was reported. Fetal prognosis was much poorer in maternal ICU admissions than in controls, with outcomes including lower birth weight (1776 vs. 2304 g, p<.001) and higher perinatal morbidity (infant respiratory distress syndrome 3.70 [1.94-7.05], p<.001) and mortality (<.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Women needing invasive ICU represented 4.3% of preeclampsia cases. This experience is of interest for lower resource settings such as in countries like Madagascar where very intensive ICU means are very poor, but simpler ICU surveillance is possible. Fetal prognosis was poor though no maternal death was reported. Thus, a multidisciplinary approach of patients with preeclampsia should be encouraged; admission into ICU should be facilitated, as soon as any sign of severity and complications appears.

The blurring boundaries between placental and maternal preeclampsia: a critical appraisal of 1800 consecutive preeclamptic cases

Objectives: To present a comprehensive overview of different risk factors for early onset preeclampsia (<34 weeks gestation, EOP) vs. late onset (LOP).Study design: South-Reunion University's maternity (Reunion Island, Indian Ocean). 18.5 year-observational population-based cohort study (2001-2019). Epidemiological perinatal database with information on obstetrical and neonatal risk factors. All consecutive singleton pregnancies (>21 weeks) compared with all preeclamptic pregnancies delivered in the south of Reunion island.Main outcome measures: Comparing risk factors between EOP and LOP.Results: Among 1814 singleton preeclamptic pregnancies (600 EOP and 1214 LOP), EOP women were older than LOP 29.5 vs. 28.6 years, p = .009, primigravidas (OR 0.78 [0.63-0.96], p = .02) were prone to LOP. History of preeclampsia (PE) (aOR 12.8 vs. 7.1), chronic hypertension (aOR 6.5 vs. 4.5) had much higher adjusted odds ratios for EOP than for LOP, p < .001. Specific to EOP: coagulopathies (aOR 2.95, p = .04), stimulated pregnancies (aOR 3.9, p = .02). Specific to LOP: renal diseases (aOR 2.0, p = .05) and protective effect for smoking (aOR 0.75, p = .008). EOP women were prone to have a lower BMI.Conclusion: "Placental preeclampsia" (defective placentation) being linked to early onset PE (<34 weeks gestation) while "maternal preeclampsia" (maternal cardiovascular predisposition) being typically manifesting as the late form of the disease LOP is not systematically verified. Future researches are needed to propose a more adapted paradigm.Highlights  Risk factors for different preeclampsia phenotypes (early/late); challenging proposed models.

Prevalence of hypertensive disorders of pregnancy and pregnancy outcomes in Sub-Saharan Africa: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Hypertensive disorders of pregnancy are one of the leading causes of poor pregnancy outcomes and are associated with increased rates of maternal mortality, preterm birth, small for gestational age newborns, stillbirth, and neonatal death. The overall and type-specific prevalence of hypertensive disorders of pregnancy and associated pregnancy outcomes are unknown in Sub-Saharan Africa. Therefore, this review aimed to identify the prevalence of hypertensive disorders of pregnancy and associated pregnancy outcomes in Sub-Saharan Africa. A systematic review and meta-analysis were conducted on observational facility-based studies irrespective of publication status, sample size, language, and follow-up duration from 19 countries between the years 2000 and 2018 in Sub-Saharan Africa. A review of studies using PubMed, EMBASE, African Index Medicus, and African Journals Online was completed with independent extraction of studies by review authors using the predefined inclusion criteria. Quality and risk of bias of individual studies were assessed using the Joanna Briggs Institute Checklist. Random effects model was used to estimate the pooled prevalence of hypertensive disorders of pregnancy and type-specific hypertensive disorders of pregnancy. A pooled adjusted odds ratio with 95% confidence interval for each study was calculated using comprehensive meta-analysis version 2 software to estimate the association of hypertensive disorders of pregnancy and its outcomes. The existence of heterogeneity was assessed using I2 and its corresponding P value. We assessed the presence of publication bias using the Egger's test. Subgroup analysis was performed to assess the potential effect of variables, and a sensitivity analysis was conducted to assess any undue influence from studies. The analysis included 70 studies. The pooled prevalence of hypertensive disorders of pregnancy (all types combined), chronic hypertension, gestational hypertension, preeclampsia, and eclampsia were 8% (95% confidence interval = [5, 10]), 0.9% (95% confidence interval = [0.4, 1.8]), 4.1% (95% confidence interval = [2.4, 7]), 4.1% (95% confidence interval = [3.2, 5.1]), and 1.5% (95% confidence interval = [1, 2]), respectively. Compared with normotensive pregnant or postpartum women, women with hypertensive disorders of pregnancy were associated with increased risk of maternal mortality, odds ratio = 17 (95% confidence interval = [9.6, 28.8]); cesarean section, odds ratio = 3.1 (95% confidence interval = [1.7, 5.6]); perinatal mortality, odds ratio = 8.2 (95% confidence interval = [2.8, 24]); low birth weight, odds ratio = 3.2 (95% confidence interval = [2, 5]); and preterm delivery, odds ratio = 7.8 (95% confidence interval = [2.5, 25.3]) according to this analysis. The pooled prevalence of hypertensive disorders of pregnancy was high in Sub-Saharan Africa compared to those reported from other regions. Pregnant or postpartum women with hypertensive disorders of pregnancy have increased risk of maternal mortality, cesarean section, preterm delivery, perinatal mortality, and low birth weight newborn. Therefore, creating awareness of the risks of hypertensive disorders of pregnancy is essential. Pregnant women with hypertensive disorders need due attention to manage appropriately and more importantly to have favorable outcomes in this population.

Statistical risk prediction models for adverse maternal and neonatal outcomes in severe preeclampsia in a low-resource setting: proposal for a single-centre cross-sectional study at Mpilo Central Hospital, Bulawayo, Zimbabwe

Hypertensive disorders in pregnancy are a leading cause of maternal and perinatal morbidity and mortality, especially in low-resource settings. Identifying mothers and babies at greatest risk of complications would enable intervention to be targeted to those most likely to benefit from them. However, current risk prediction models have a wide range of sensitivity (42-81%) and specificity (87-92%) indicating that improvements are needed. Furthermore, no predictive models have been developed or evaluated in Zimbabwe. This proposal describes a single centre retrospective cross-sectional study which will address the need to further develop and test statistical risk prediction models for adverse maternal and neonatal outcomes in low-resource settings; this will be the first such research to be carried out in Zimbabwe. Data will be collected on maternal demographics characteristics, outcome of prior pregnancies, past medical history, symptoms and signs on admission, results of biochemical and haematological investigations. Adverse outcome will be defined as a composite of maternal morbidity and mortality and perinatal morbidity and mortality. Association between variables and outcomes will be explored using multivariable logistic regression. Critically, new risk prediction models introduced for our clinical setting may reduce avoidable maternal and neonatal morbidity and mortality at local, national, regional and international level.