Predictive ability of the autoradiographic repair assay in rat liver cells compared with the Ames test

Effect of vitamin A dietary intake on in vitro and in vivo activation of aflatoxin B1

The mechanism by which vitamin A prevents or delays in chemical carcinogenesis remains unclear. In the present study, we assess the suggestive role of vitamin A in the initiation phase of carcinogenesis. We have conducted a dose-effect relationship between vitamin A dietary intake and aflatoxin B1 (AFB1) genotoxicity measured both in vitro and in vivo. Thus AFB1-induced mutagenesis in Salmonella typhimurium TA98 was investigated and compared to AFB1-induced single-strand breaks (SSBs) in DNA of rat hepatocytes. Rats were fed ad libitum with diet containing 0, 5, 50 or 500 IU of retinyl palmitate for 8 weeks. The AFB1-treated rats were injected i.p. with 1 mg/kg body weight. In the Ames test conditions TA98 back-reversion was negatively correlated with the log of vitamin A concentration in liver S9 fractions from experimental groups. However, the activities of metabolizing enzymes which specifically activate or deactivate AFB1 were found to be significantly decreased in vitamin A-deficient animals and weakly modified in vitamin A-supplemented animals. For in vivo experiments, the DNA elution rate of both AFB1-treated and untreated rats was increased in vitamin A deficiency condition (+79% and +17% respectively) and was reduced with the higher vitamin A dietary level (-44% and -53% respectively). DNA damage measured in vivo showed a significant positive correlation with mutagenic activity measured in the Ames test. These results confirm that the vitamin A status of animals can influence AFB1 genotoxic activity in vitro and indicate that this phenomenon also occurs in vivo. Thus a similar mechanism may be considered for the protective action of vitamin A both in vitro and in vivo. However, this mechanism is unlikely to involve modulation of the microsomal enzyme system responsible for AFB1 metabolism. Therefore a protective mechanism at the cytosolic or nuclear levels may be suggested.

Mutagenic and carcinogenic potency indices and their correlation

We have analyzed a significant number of studies existing in the literature, in which the ability of different short-term tests for predicting carcinogenicity in rodents was investigated. We have separated these studies into two groups. In the better known group of studies, qualitative predictivity was investigated (sensitivity and specificity). In the second group of studies (analyzed in greater detail), positive results were examined for the correlation between carcinogenic potency and potency of response in a given short-term test. There is substantial agreement between qualitative and quantitative predictivity; both appear to be situated between a low and moderate level. We have analyzed the interesting possibility of using the quantitative approach not only for positive data but for combined positive and negative data as well. We have stressed that short-term tests of genotoxicity should be asked to predict only initiation and irreversible alterations in the genome and not to predict a combination of these events, including promotion and modulation of differentiation. Even with regard to only initiation, genotoxicity data should be related to comparative metabolism, as well as to considerations of the significance of different end points and structure-activity relationship data. In conclusion, the information coming from short-term tests of genotoxicity is probably useful but should be used in conjunction with other types of information and only for predicting one particular class of events in the entire process of carcinogenesis.

Utilization of the quantitative component of the information obtained from short term tests

We are referring in this paper to traditional tests of genotoxicity that are essentially detecting properties correlated with the initiating activity of chemical and physical agents. In classical initiation-promotion experiments, promotion is changing dramatically tumor frequency, but a better correlation between initiation and tumor frequency may exist when carcinogenesis experiments in rodents utilize only an initiator agent. End points, metabolism and target organs of short term test may be not optimal in respect to the real initiation process. In conclusion, we have to expect a very high level of statistical noise in the correlation between short term tests and carcinogenicity in rodents. Correlations of this type are not unique in science. For instance, the input data for weather forecasting and the real weather are often related with a high level of statistical noise. But this is not considered a good reason for throwing away the quantitative component of the input information. Similarly, in this context the utilization of the quantitative component of the information improves in a moderate, but not negligible way the predictive value of the information offered from short term tests, especially when they are used in a battery. In this review we discuss the possibility that, when studying correlations between genotoxicity tests and carcinogenicity in rodents, a quantitative approach could replace with important advantages the qualitative approach generally adopted up to the present time. The qualitative approach appeared as a more modest but realistic approach to the complexities of these correlation studies. What we suggest is that a quantitative approach mathematically not less correct than the qualitative approach is feasible. More precise and useful information for risk assessment evaluations can be obtained.

The calculation and use of carcinogenic potency: a review

Six methods of estimating carcinogenic potency now in use to some extent by regulatory agencies are examined. It is concluded that none of these methods is adequate for regulatory decision making when used alone, as is usually the case, but that all are useful as a contribution to the whole risk assessment process. The needs for further development and improvement of these methods, where appropriate to human risk, are identified and discussed in view of the growing use of potency estimates in regulatory decision making.

Comparison of rat and hamster hepatocyte primary culture/DNA repair assays

Previous studies have demonstrated marked differences in the capacity of hepatocytes from rats or hamsters to mediate the metabolic activation of chemical carcinogens to genotoxic (ie, mutagenic) products. Thus far, very few investigations of species differences in DNA repair have been performed. Therefore, a comparison of the relative extent of DNA repair elicited by various genotoxic chemicals in rat and hamster hepatocytes was conducted, using the hepatocyte primary culture/DNA repair (HPC/DR) assay. Of the 11 chemicals tested, eight were more potent in inducing DNA repair in hamster hepatocytes than in rat hepatocytes. Dimethylnitrosamine, diethylnitrosamine, 2-acetylaminofluorene, 9-aminoacridine, pararosaniline hydrochloride, 1-naphthylamine, benzidine and 1,2:3,4-diepoxybutane were all active in hamster hepatocytes at a concentration at least ten times less than the lowest effective concentration in rat hepatocytes. The direct-acting alkylating agent, methylmethane sulfonate, was equipotent in inducing DNA repair in both rat and hamster hepatocytes, indicating that the differences in DNA repair observed for the other chemicals were probably not a result of species differences in DNA repair capacities. In contrast, 1-nitropyrene produced a greater DNA repair response in rat hepatocytes than hamster hepatocytes, while the bacterial mutagen 3-(chloromethyl)pyridine hydrochloride was inactive in both hepatocyte systems. These studies demonstrate the feasibility of using hamster hepatocytes in the HPC/DR assay and illustrate the utility of performing the assay with hepatocytes from more than one species.

Quantitative predictivity of the transformation in vitro assay compared with the Ames test

For 59 chemical compounds, we have found homogeneous data on transformation in vitro, mutagenicity in the Ames test, and carcinogenicity. We have compared the potency in inducing transformation in vitro in hamster fibroblast cells with the carcinogenic potency and found a modest correlation coefficient between the two parameters (r = 0.37). For these same 59 compounds it was also possible to compare mutagenic potency in the Ames test with carcinogenic potency. The correlation level was very similar (r = 0.34). The predictivity of transformation in vitro increased significantly when only compounds for which some kind of dose-response relationship was available were utilized (r = 0.65). This result stresses the importance of the quantitative aspect of the response in predictivity studies. The present study is compared with previous studies on the quantitative predictivity of different short-term tests. Our work is not definitive, but gives an idea of the possible type of approach to the problem of comparing quantitative predictivities.