A minimalist biosensor: Quantitation of cyclic di-GMP using the conformational change of a riboswitch aptamer

Biosensor-guided discovery and engineering of metabolic enzymes

A variety of chemicals have been produced through metabolic engineering approaches, and enhancing biosynthesis performance can be achieved by using enzymes with high catalytic efficiency. Accordingly, a number of efforts have been made to discover enzymes in nature for various applications. In addition, enzyme engineering approaches have been attempted to suit specific industrial purposes. However, a significant challenge in enzyme discovery and engineering is the efficient screening of enzymes with the desired phenotype from extensive enzyme libraries. To overcome this bottleneck, genetically encoded biosensors have been developed to specifically detect target molecules produced by enzyme activity at the intracellular level. Especially, the biosensors facilitate high-throughput screening (HTS) of targeted enzymes, expanding enzyme discovery and engineering strategies with advances in systems and synthetic biology. This review examines biosensor-guided HTS systems and highlights studies that have utilized these tools to discover enzymes in diverse areas and engineer enzymes to enhance their properties, such as catalytic efficiency, specificity, and stability.

c-di-GMP signaling in Pseudomonas syringae complex

The Pseudomonas syringae Complex is one of the model phytopathogenic bacteria for exploring plant-microbe interactions, causing devastating plant diseases and economic losses worldwide. The ubiquitous second messenger bis-(3'-5')-cyclic dimeric guanosine monophosphate (c-di-GMP) plays an important role in the 'lifestyle switch' from single motile cells to biofilm formation and modulates bacterial behavior, thus influencing virulence in Pseudomonas and other bacterial species. However, less is known about the role of c-di-GMP in the P. syringae complex, in which c-di-GMP levels are controlled by diguanylate cyclases (DGCs) and phosphodiesterases (PDEs), such as Chp8, BifA and WspR. Deletion the chemotaxis receptor PscA also influences c-di-GMP levels, suggesting a cross-talk between chemotaxis and c-di-GMP pathways. Another transcription factor, FleQ, plays a dual role (positive or negative) in regulating cellulose synthesis as a c-di-GMP effector, whereas the transcription factor AmrZ regulates local c-di-GMP levels by inhibiting the DGC enzyme AdcA and the PDE enzyme MorA. Our recent research demonstrated that an increase in the c-di-GMP concentration increased biofilm development, siderophore biosynthesis and oxidative stress tolerance, while it decreased the siderophore content, bacterial motility and type III secretion system activity in P. syringae complex. These findings show that c-di-GMP intricately controls virulence in P. syringae complex, indicating that adjusting c-di-GMP levels may be a valuable tactic for defending plants against pathogens. This review highlights recent research on metabolic enzymes, regulatory mechanisms and the phenotypic consequences of c-di-GMP signaling in the P. syringae.

The First FRET-Based RNA Aptamer NanoKit for Sensitively and Specifically Detecting c-di-GMP

An effective method to identify c-di-GMP may significantly facilitate the exploration of its signaling pathways and bacterial pathogenesis. Herein, we have developed the first conjugated polymer-amplified RNA aptamer NanoKit with a unique core-shell-shell architecture, which combines the advantages of high selectivity of RNA aptamers and high sensitivity of strong fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) effect, for precisely detecting c-di-GMP. We identified that NanoKit could selectively detect c-di-GMP with a low detection limit of 50 pM. Importantly, NanoKit could identify bacterial species and physiological states, such as planktonic, biofilm, and even antibiotic-resistance, on the basis of their different c-di-GMP expression patterns. Particularly, NanoKit could distinguish bacterial infection and inflammation and identify Pseudomonas aeruginosa associated pneumonia and sepsis, thereby guiding treatment choice and monitoring antibiotic effects. Therefore, NanoKit provides a promising strategy to rapidly identify c-di-GMP and its associated diseases and may benefit for pathophoresis management.

A STING-based fluorescent polarization assay for monitoring activities of cyclic dinucleotide metabolizing enzymes

Cyclic dinucleoties, such as cGAMP, c-di-GMP and c-di-AMP, are fascinating second messengers with diverse roles in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes. Consequently there is a need for simple and inexpensive methods for profiling these compounds in biological media, monitoring their synthesis or degradation by enzymes and for identifying inhibitors of proteins that metabolize or bind to these dinucleotides. Since 2011, when we reported the first simple method to detect c-di-GMP (S. Nakayama, I. Kelsey, J. Wang, K. Roelofs, B. Stefane, Y. Luo, V. T. Lee and H. O. Sintim, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2011, 133, 4856) or in 2014 when we revealed another surprisingly simple assay to detect c-di-AMP (J. Zhou, D. A. Sayre, Y. Zheng, H. Szmacinski and H. O. Sintim, Anal. Chem., 2014, 86, 2412), there have been efforts to develop assays to detect cyclic dinucleotides by others. However a unified and simple assay, which can be used for all cyclic dinucleotides is lacking. Here, we investigate STING binding by various fluorescein-labeled c-di-GMP, c-di-AMP and cGAMP, using fluorescent polarization (FP). Fluorescein-labeled c-di-GMP (F-c-di-GMP) was found to be the best binder of STING. This probe could be displaced by unlabeled cGAMP, c-di-AMP or c-di-GMP and hence it is a universal probe, which can be used to monitor all three dinucleotides. HPLC analysis was used to validate the new F-c-di-GMP-based FP assay.

Cyclic dinucleoties, such as cGAMP, c-di-GMP and c-di-AMP, are fascinating second messengers with diverse roles in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes.

Fluorescent Detection of the Ubiquitous Bacterial Messenger 3',5' Cyclic Diguanylic Acid by Using a Small Aromatic Molecule

3′,5′ Cyclic diguanylic acid (c-di-GMP) has been shown to play a central role in the regulation of bacterial physiological processes such as biofilm formation and virulence production, and is regarded as a potential target for the development of anti-infective drugs. A method for the facile detection of the bacterial level of cellular c-di-GMP is required to explore the details of c-di-GMP signaling and design drugs on the basis of this pathway. Current methods of c-di-GMP detection have limited sensitivity or difficultly in probe preparation. Herein a new fluorescent probe is reported for the detection of c-di-GMP at concentrations as low as 500 nM. The probe was developed on the basis of the G-quadruplex formation of c-di-GMP induced by aromatic molecules. When used on crude bacterial cell lysates, it can effectively distinguish between the low c-di-GMP levels of bacteria in plankton and the high c-di-GMP levels in biofilm. The method described here is simple, inexpensive, sensitive, and suitable for practical applications involving the rapid detection of cellular c-di-GMP levels in vitro after simple bacterial lysis and filtration.

Tools and systems for evolutionary engineering of biomolecules and microorganisms

Evolutionary approaches have been providing solutions to various bioengineering challenges in an efficient manner. In addition to traditional adaptive laboratory evolution and directed evolution, recent advances in synthetic biology and fluidic systems have opened a new era of evolutionary engineering. Synthetic genetic circuits have been created to control mutagenesis and enable screening of various phenotypes, particularly metabolite production. Fluidic systems can be used for high-throughput screening and multiplexed continuous cultivation of microorganisms. Moreover, continuous directed evolution has been achieved by combining all the steps of evolutionary engineering. Overall, modern tools and systems for evolutionary engineering can be used to establish the artificial equivalent to natural evolution for various research applications.

Single-Cell Microscopy Reveals That Levels of Cyclic di-GMP Vary among Bacillus subtilis Subpopulations

The synthesis of signaling molecules is one strategy bacteria employ to sense alterations in their environment and rapidly adjust to those changes. In Gram-negative bacteria, bis-(3'-5')-cyclic dimeric GMP (c-di-GMP) regulates the transition from a unicellular motile state to a multicellular sessile state. However, c-di-GMP signaling has been less intensively studied in Gram-positive organisms. To that end, we constructed a fluorescent yfp reporter based on a c-di-GMP-responsive riboswitch to visualize the relative abundance of c-di-GMP for single cells of the Gram-positive model organism Bacillus subtilis Coupled with cell-type-specific fluorescent reporters, this riboswitch reporter revealed that c-di-GMP levels are markedly different among B. subtilis cellular subpopulations. For example, cells that have made the decision to become matrix producers maintain higher intracellular c-di-GMP concentrations than motile cells. Similarly, we find that c-di-GMP levels differ between sporulating and competent cell types. These results suggest that biochemical measurements of c-di-GMP abundance are likely to be inaccurate for a bulk ensemble of B. subtilis cells, as such measurements will average c-di-GMP levels across the population. Moreover, the significant variation in c-di-GMP levels between cell types hints that c-di-GMP might play an important role during B. subtilis biofilm formation. This study therefore emphasizes the importance of using single-cell approaches for analyzing metabolic trends within ensemble bacterial populations.IMPORTANCE Many bacteria have been shown to differentiate into genetically identical yet morphologically distinct cell types. Such population heterogeneity is especially prevalent among biofilms, where multicellular communities are primed for unexpected environmental conditions and can efficiently distribute metabolic responsibilities. Bacillus subtilis is a model system for studying population heterogeneity; however, a role for c-di-GMP in these processes has not been thoroughly investigated. Herein, we introduce a fluorescent reporter, based on a c-di-GMP-responsive riboswitch, to visualize the relative abundance of c-di-GMP for single B. subtilis cells. Our analysis shows that c-di-GMP levels are conspicuously different among B. subtilis cellular subtypes, suggesting a role for c-di-GMP during biofilm formation. These data highlight the utility of riboswitches as tools for imaging metabolic changes within individual bacterial cells. Analyses such as these offer new insight into c-di-GMP-regulated phenotypes, especially given that other biofilms also consist of multicellular communities.

Evaluating riboswitch optimality

Riboswitches are RNA elements that recognize diverse chemical and biomolecular inputs, and transduce this recognition process to genetic, fluorescent, and other engineered outputs using RNA conformational changes. These systems are pervasive in cellular biology and are a promising biotechnology with applications in genetic regulation and biosensing. Here, we derive a simple expression bounding the activation ratio-the proportion of RNA in the active vs. inactive states-for both ON and OFF riboswitches that operate near thermodynamic equilibrium: 1+[I]/K_d^I, where [I] is the input ligand concentration and K_d^I is the intrinsic dissociation constant of the aptamer module toward the input ligand. A survey of published studies of natural and synthetic riboswitches confirms that the vast majority of empirically measured activation ratios have remained well below this thermodynamic limit. A few natural and synthetic riboswitches achieve activation ratios close to the limit, and these molecules highlight important principles for achieving high riboswitch performance. For several applications, including "light-up" fluorescent sensors and chemically-controlled CRISPR/Cas complexes, the thermodynamic limit has not yet been achieved, suggesting that current tools are operating at suboptimal efficiencies. Future riboswitch studies will benefit from comparing observed activation ratios to this simple expression for the optimal activation ratio. We present experimental and computational suggestions for how to make these quantitative comparisons and suggest new molecular mechanisms that may allow non-equilibrium riboswitches to surpass the derived limit.

From fluorescent proteins to fluorogenic RNAs: Tools for imaging cellular macromolecules

The explosion in genome-wide sequencing has revealed that noncoding RNAs are ubiquitous and highly conserved in biology. New molecular tools are needed for their study in live cells. Fluorescent RNA-small molecule complexes have emerged as powerful counterparts to fluorescent proteins, which are well established, universal tools in the study of proteins in cell biology. No naturally fluorescent RNAs are known; all current fluorescent RNA tags are in vitro evolved or engineered molecules that bind a conditionally fluorescent small molecule and turn on its fluorescence by up to 5000-fold. Structural analyses of several such fluorescence turn-on aptamers show that these compact (30-100 nucleotides) RNAs have diverse molecular architectures that can restrain their photoexcited fluorophores in their maximally fluorescent states, typically by stacking between planar nucleotide arrangements, such as G-quadruplexes, base triples, or base pairs. The diversity of fluorogenic RNAs as well as fluorophores that are cell permeable and bind weakly to endogenous cellular macromolecules has already produced RNA-fluorophore complexes that span the visual spectrum and are useful for tagging and visualizing RNAs in cells. Because the ligand binding sites of fluorogenic RNAs are not constrained by the need to autocatalytically generate fluorophores as are fluorescent proteins, they may offer more flexibility in molecular engineering to generate photophysical properties that are tailored to experimental needs.

Identification of Small-Molecule Modulators of Diguanylate Cyclase by FRET-Based High-Throughput Screening

The bacterial second messenger cyclic diguanosine monophosphate (c-di-GMP) is a key regulator of cellular motility, the cell cycle, and biofilm formation with its resultant antibiotic tolerance, which can make chronic infections difficult to treat. Therefore, diguanylate cyclases, which regulate the spatiotemporal production of c-di-GMP, might be attractive drug targets for control of biofilm formation that is part of chronic infections. We present a FRET-based biochemical high-throughput screening approach coupled with detailed structure-activity studies to identify synthetic small-molecule modulators of the diguanylate cyclase DgcA from Caulobacter crescentus. We identified a set of seven small molecules that regulate DgcA enzymatic activity in the low-micromolar range. Subsequent structure-activity studies on selected scaffolds revealed a remarkable diversity of modulatory behavior, including slight chemical substitutions that reverse the effects from allosteric enzyme inhibition to activation. The compounds identified represent new chemotypes and are potentially developable into chemical genetic tools for the dissection of c-di-GMP signaling networks and alteration of c-di-GMP-associated phenotypes. In sum, our studies underline the importance of detailed mechanism-of-action studies for inhibitors of c-di-GMP signaling and demonstrate the complex interplay between synthetic small molecules and the regulatory mechanisms that control the activity of diguanylate cyclases.

Discovering Selective Diguanylate Cyclase Inhibitors: From PleD to Discrimination of the Active Site of Cyclic-di-GMP Phosphodiesterases

One of the most important signals involved in controlling biofilm formation is represented by the intracellular second messenger 3',5'-cyclic diguanylic acid (c-di-GMP). Since the pathways involved in c-di-GMP biosynthesis and breakdown are found only in bacteria, targeting c-di-GMP metabolism represents an attractive strategy for the development of biofilm-disrupting drugs. Here, we present the workflow required to perform a structure-based design of inhibitors of diguanylate cyclases, the enzymes responsible for c-di-GMP biosynthesis. Downstream of the virtual screening process, detailed in the first part of the chapter, we report the step-by-step protocols required to test the positive hits in vitro and to validate their selectivity, thus minimizing possible off-target effects.

Using Light-Activated Enzymes for Modulating Intracellular c-di-GMP Levels in Bacteria

Signaling pathways involving second messenger c-di-GMP regulate various aspects of bacterial physiology and behavior. We describe the use of a red light-activated diguanylate cyclase (c-di-GMP synthase) and a blue light-activated c-di-GMP phosphodiesterase (hydrolase) for manipulating intracellular c-di-GMP levels in bacterial cells. We illustrate the application of these enzymes in regulating several c-di-GMP-dependent phenotypes, i.e., motility and biofilm phenotypes in E. coli and chemotactic behavior in the alphaproteobacterium Azospirillum brasilense. We expect these light-activated enzymes to be also useful in regulating c-di-GMP-dependent processes occurring at the fast timescale, for spatial control of bacterial populations, as well as for analyzing c-di-GMP-dependent phenomena at the single-cell level.

Identification and characterization of nucleobase-modified aptamers by click-SELEX

Aptamers are single-stranded oligonucleotides that are in vitro-selected to recognize their target molecule with high affinity and specificity. As they consist of the four canonical nucleobases, their chemical diversity is limited, which in turn limits the addressable target spectrum. Introducing chemical modifications into nucleic acid libraries increases the interaction capabilities of the DNA and thereby the target spectrum. Here, we describe a protocol to select nucleobase-modified aptamers by using click chemistry (CuAAC) to introduce the preferred chemical modification. The use of click chemistry to modify the DNA library enables the introduction of a wide range of possible functionalities, which can be customized to the requirements of the target molecule and the desired application. This protocol yields modified DNA aptamers with extended interaction properties that are not accessible with the canonical set of nucleotides. After synthesis of the starting library containing a commercially available, alkyne-modified uridine (5-ethynyl-deoxyuridine (EdU)) instead of thymidine, the library is functionalized with the modification of choice by CuAAC. The thus-modified DNA is incubated with the target molecule and the best binding sequences are recovered. The chemical modification is removed during the amplification process. Therefore, this protocol is compatible with conventional amplification procedures and avoids enzymatic incompatibility problems associated with more extensive nucleobase modifications. After single-strand generation, the modification is reintroduced into the enriched library, which can then be subjected to the subsequent selection cycle. The duration of each selection cycle as outlined in the protocol is ∼1 d.

Covalent attachment and Pro-Pro endopeptidase (PPEP-1)-mediated release of Clostridium difficile cell surface proteins involved in adhesion

In the past decade, Clostridium difficile has emerged as an important gut pathogen. This anaerobic, Gram-positive bacterium is the main cause of infectious nosocomial diarrhea. Whereas much is known about the mechanism through which the C. difficile toxins cause diarrhea, relatively little is known about the dynamics of adhesion and motility, which is mediated by cell surface proteins. This review will discuss the recent advances in our understanding of the sortase-mediated covalent attachment of cell surface (adhesion) proteins to the peptidoglycan layer of C. difficile and their release through the action of a highly specific secreted metalloprotease (Pro-Pro endopeptidase 1, PPEP-1). Specific emphasis will be on a model in which PPEP-1 and its substrates control the switch from a sessile to motile phenotype in C. difficile, and how this is regulated by the cyclic dinucleotide c-di-GMP (3'-5' cyclic dimeric guanosine monophosphate).

Naringenin-responsive riboswitch-based fluorescent biosensor module for Escherichia coli co-cultures

The ability to design and construct combinatorial synthetic metabolic pathways has far exceeded our capacity for efficient screening and selection of the resulting microbial strains. The need for high-throughput rapid screening techniques is of upmost importance for the future of synthetic biology and metabolic engineering. Here we describe the development of an RNA riboswitch-based biosensor module with dual fluorescent reporters, and demonstrate a high-throughput flow cytometry-based screening method for identification of naringenin over producing Escherichia coli strains in co-culture. Our efforts helped identify a number of key operating parameters that affect biosensor performance, including the selection of promoter and linker elements within the sensor-actuator domain, and the effect of host strain, fermentation time, and growth medium on sensor dynamic range. The resulting biosensor demonstrates a high correlation between specific fluorescence of the biosensor strain and naringenin titer produced by the second member of the synthetic co-culture system. This technique represents a novel application for synthetic microbial co-cultures and can be expanded from naringenin to any metabolite if a suitable riboswitch is identified. The co-culture technique presented here can be applied to a variety of target metabolites in combination with the SELEX approach for aptamer design. Due to the compartmentalization of the two genetic constructs responsible for production and detection into separate cells and application as independent modules of a synthetic microbial co-culture we have subsequently reduced the need for re-optimization of the producer module when the biosensor is replaced or removed. Biotechnol. Bioeng. 2017;114: 2235-2244. © 2017 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

Live Flow Cytometry Analysis of c-di-GMP Levels in Single Cell Populations

Second-generation RNA-based fluorescent biosensors have been developed that enable flow cytometry experiments to monitor the population dynamics of c-di-GMP signaling in live bacteria. These experiments are high-throughput, provide information at the single-cell level, and can be performed on cells grown in complex media and/or under anaerobic conditions. Here, we describe flow cytometry methods for three applications: (1) high-throughput screening for diguanylate cyclase activity, (2) analyzing c-di-GMP levels under anaerobic conditions, and (3) monitoring cell population dynamics of c-di-GMP levels upon environmental changes. These methods showcase RNA-based fluorescent biosensors as versatile tools for studying c-di-GMP signaling in bacteria.

Riboswitches: From living biosensors to novel targets of antibiotics

Riboswitches are generally located in 5'-UTR region of mRNAs and specifically bind small ligands. Following ligand binding, gene expression is controlled mostly by transcription termination, translation inhibition or mRNA degradation processes. More than 30 classes of known riboswitches have been identified by now. Most riboswitches consist of an aptamer domain and an expression platform. The aptamer domain of each class of riboswitch is a conserved structure and stabilizes specific structures of the expression platforms through binding to specific compounds. In this review, we are highlighting most aspects of riboswitch research including the novel riboswitch discoveries, routine methods for discovering and investigating riboswitches along with newly discovered classes and mechanistic principles of riboswitch-mediated gene expression control. Moreover, we will give an overview about the potential of riboswitches as therapeutic targets for antibiotic design and also their utilization as biosensors for molecular detection.

Mutational analysis of structural elements in a class-I cyclic di-GMP riboswitch to elucidate its regulatory mechanism

The Vc2 riboswitch possesses an aptamer domain belonging to the class-I c-di-GMP riboswitch family. This domain has been analysed and the molecular mechanism by which it recognizes the c-di-GMP ligand has been elucidated. On the other hand, the regulatory mechanism of the full-length Vc2 riboswitch to control its downstream open reading frame (ORF) remains largely unknown. In this study, we performed in vivo reporter assays and in vitro biochemical analyses of the full-length riboswitch and its aptamer domain. We evaluated the results of in vivo and in vitro analyses to elucidate the regulatory mechanism of the Vc2 riboswitch. The present results suggest that recognition of c-di-GMP ligand by the Vc2 riboswitch aptamer domain downregulates expression of its downstream ORF primarily at the translational level.

Opportunities in the design and application of RNA for gene expression control

The past decade of synthetic biology research has witnessed numerous advances in the development of tools and frameworks for the design and characterization of biological systems. Researchers have focused on the use of RNA for gene expression control due to its versatility in sensing molecular ligands and the relative ease by which RNA can be modeled and designed compared to proteins. We review the recent progress in the field with respect to RNA-based genetic devices that are controlled through small molecule and protein interactions. We discuss new approaches for generating and characterizing these devices and their underlying components. We also highlight immediate challenges, future directions and recent applications of synthetic RNA devices in engineered biological systems.

Characterization of a natural triple-tandem c-di-GMP riboswitch and application of the riboswitch-based dual-fluorescence reporter

c-di-GMP riboswitches are structured RNAs located in the 5'-untranslated regions (5'-UTRs) of mRNAs that regulate expression of downstream genes in response to changing concentrations of the second messenger c-di-GMP. We discovered three complete c-di-GMP riboswitches (Bc3, Bc4 and Bc5 RNA) with similar structures, which are arranged in tandem to constitute a triple-tandem (Bc3-5 RNA) riboswitch in the 5'-UTR of the cspABCDE mRNA in Bacillus thuringiensis subsp. chinensis CT-43. Our results showed that this natural triple-tandem riboswitch controlled the expression of the reporter gene more stringently and digitally than the double-tandem or single riboswitch. A sandwich-like dual-fluorescence reporter was further constructed by fusing the Bc3-5 RNA gene between the two fluorescence protein genes amcyan and turborfp. This reporter strain was found to exhibit detectable fluorescence color changes under bright field in response to intracellular c-di-GMP level altered by induced expression of diguanylate cyclase (DGC) PleD. Using this system, two putative membrane-bound DGCs from B. thuringiensis and Xanthomonas oryzae were verified to be functional by replacing pleD with the corresponding DGC genes. This report represented the first native triple-tandem riboswitch that was applied to serve as a riboswitch-based dual-fluorescence reporter for the efficient and convenient verification of putative DGC activity in vivo.