Functions of the cellular prion protein, the end of Moore's law, and Ockham's razor theory

Analysis of co-isogenic prion protein deficient mice reveals behavioral deficits, learning impairment, and enhanced hippocampal excitability

Background

Cellular prion protein (PrP^C) is a cell surface GPI-anchored protein, usually known for its role in the pathogenesis of human and animal prionopathies. However, increasing knowledge about the participation of PrP^C in prion pathogenesis contrasts with puzzling data regarding its natural physiological role. PrP^C is expressed in a number of tissues, including at high levels in the nervous system, especially in neurons and glial cells, and while previous studies have established a neuroprotective role, conflicting evidence for a synaptic function has revealed both reduced and enhanced long-term potentiation, and variable observations on memory, learning, and behavior. Such evidence has been confounded by the absence of an appropriate knock-out mouse model to dissect the biological relevance of PrP^C, with some functions recently shown to be misattributed to PrP^C due to the presence of genetic artifacts in mouse models. Here we elucidate the role of PrP^C in the hippocampal circuitry and its related functions, such as learning and memory, using a recently available strictly co-isogenic Prnp^0/0 mouse model (Prnp^ZH3/ZH3).

Results

We performed behavioral and operant conditioning tests to evaluate memory and learning capabilities, with results showing decreased motility, impaired operant conditioning learning, and anxiety-related behavior in Prnp^ZH3/ZH3 animals. We also carried in vivo electrophysiological recordings on CA3-CA1 synapses in living behaving mice and monitored spontaneous neuronal firing and network formation in primary neuronal cultures of Prnp^ZH3/ZH3 vs wildtype mice. PrP^C absence enhanced susceptibility to high-intensity stimulations and kainate-induced seizures. However, long-term potentiation (LTP) was not enhanced in the Prnp^ZH3/ZH3 hippocampus. In addition, we observed a delay in neuronal maturation and network formation in Prnp^ZH3/ZH3 cultures.

Conclusion

Our results demonstrate that PrP^C promotes neuronal network formation and connectivity. PrP^C mediates synaptic function and protects the synapse from excitotoxic insults. Its deletion may underlie an epileptogenic-susceptible brain that fails to perform highly cognitive-demanding tasks such as associative learning and anxiety-like behaviors.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12915-021-01203-0.

On the role of the cellular prion protein in the uptake and signaling of pathological aggregates in neurodegenerative diseases

Neurodegenerative disorders are associated with intra- or extra-cellular deposition of aggregates of misfolded insoluble proteins. These deposits composed of tau, amyloid-β or α-synuclein spread from cell to cell, in a prion-like manner. Novel evidence suggests that the circulating soluble oligomeric species of these misfolded proteins could play a major role in pathology, while insoluble aggregates would represent their protective less toxic counterparts. Recent convincing data support the proposition that the cellular prion protein, PrP^C, act as a toxicity-inducing receptor for amyloid-β oligomers. As a consequence, several studies focused their investigations to the role played by PrP^C in binding other protein aggregates, such as tau and α-synuclein, for its possible common role in mediating toxic signalling. The biological relevance of PrP^C as key ligand and potential mediator of toxicity for multiple proteinaceous aggregated species, prions or PrP^Sc included, could lead to relevant therapeutic implications. Here we describe the structure of PrP^C and the proposed interplay with its pathological counterpart PrP^Sc and then we recapitulate the most recent findings regarding the role of PrP^C in the interaction with aggregated forms of other neurodegeneration-associated proteins.

The IDIP framework for assessing protein function and its application to the prion protein

The quest to determine the function of a protein can represent a profound challenge. Although this task is the mandate of countless research groups, a general framework for how it can be approached is conspicuously lacking. Moreover, even expectations for when the function of a protein can be considered to be 'known' are not well defined. In this review, we begin by introducing concepts pertinent to the challenge of protein function assignments. We then propose a framework for inferring a protein's function from four data categories: 'inheritance', 'distribution', 'interactions' and 'phenotypes' (IDIP). We document that the functions of proteins emerge at the intersection of inferences drawn from these data categories and emphasise the benefit of considering them in an evolutionary context. We then apply this approach to the cellular prion protein (PrP^C ), well known for its central role in prion diseases, whose function continues to be considered elusive by many investigators. We document that available data converge on the conclusion that the function of the prion protein is to control a critical post-translational modification of the neural cell adhesion molecule in the context of epithelial-to-mesenchymal transition and related plasticity programmes. Finally, we argue that this proposed function of PrP^C has already passed the test of time and is concordant with the IDIP framework in a way that other functions considered for this protein fail to achieve. We anticipate that the IDIP framework and the concepts analysed herein will aid the investigation of other proteins whose primary functional assignments have thus far been intractable.

The role of the cellular prion protein in the uptake and toxic signaling of pathological neurodegenerative aggregates

Neurodegenerative disorders are invariably associated with intra- or extra-cellular deposition of aggregates composed of misfolded insoluble proteins. These deposits composed of tau, amyloid-β or α-synuclein spread from cell to cell, in a prion-like manner. Emerging evidence suggests that the circulating soluble species of these misfolded proteins (usually referred as oligomers) could play a major role in pathology, while insoluble aggregates would represent their protective less toxic counterparts. Convincing data support the hypothesis that the cellular prion protein, PrP^C, act as a toxicity-transducing receptor for amyloid-β oligomers. As a consequence, several studies extended investigations to the role played by PrP^C in binding aggregates of proteins other than Aβ, such as tau and α-synuclein, for its possible common role in mediating toxic signaling. A better characterization of the biological relevance of PrP^C as key ligand and potential mediator of toxicity for multiple proteinaceous aggregated species, prions or PrP^Sc included, would bring relevant therapeutic implications. Here we will first describe the structure of the prion protein and the hypothesized interplay with its pathological counterpart PrP^Sc and then we will recapitulate the most relevant discoveries regarding the role of PrP^C in the interaction with aggregated forms of other neurodegeneration-associated proteins.

The Quest for Cellular Prion Protein Functions in the Aged and Neurodegenerating Brain

Cellular (also termed ‘natural’) prion protein has been extensively studied for many years for its pathogenic role in prionopathies after misfolding. However, neuroprotective properties of the protein have been demonstrated under various scenarios. In this line, the involvement of the cellular prion protein in neurodegenerative diseases other than prionopathies continues to be widely debated by the scientific community. In fact, studies on knock-out mice show a vast range of physiological functions for the protein that can be supported by its ability as a cell surface scaffold protein. In this review, we first summarize the most commonly described roles of cellular prion protein in neuroprotection, including antioxidant and antiapoptotic activities and modulation of glutamate receptors. Second, in light of recently described interaction between cellular prion protein and some amyloid misfolded proteins, we will also discuss the molecular mechanisms potentially involved in protection against neurodegeneration in pathologies such as Alzheimer’s, Parkinson’s, and Huntington’s diseases.

Plasma exosomal prion protein levels are correlated with cognitive decline in PD patients

OBJECTIVE

Cognitive decline is a common non-motor symptom of Parkinson disease (PD), and cellular prion protein (PrP^C) has been suggested to play a role in this process. This study aimed to investigate the correlation between plasma exosomal prion protein and cognitive decline in PD patients.

METHOD

A total of 60 participants, which included 23 PD patients without cognitive impairment (the PD-NCI group), 17 PD patients with cognitive impairment (the PD-CI group) and 20 health controls were included in this study. All participants received a complete evaluation of motor symptoms as well as non-motor symptoms, which include devaluations of cognitive function(assessed with the Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA)) and their psychiatric state(assessed with the Hamilton Anxiety Scale(HAM-A) and Hamilton Depression Scale(HAMD-17)). We used an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) to measure the plasma exosomal prion protein level. The exosomal marker Heat shock protein 70 (HSP 70) was used to normalize the protein level to the exosome content.

RESULT

In PD patients, the plasma exosomal prion protein concentration was negatively correlated with the cognitive level. The plasma exosomal prion protein concentration was significantly higher in the PD-CI group than in the control group (p < 0.05) and the PD-NCI group (p < 0.05).Multivariate regression analysis indicated that plasma exosomal prion protein levels were significantly associated with the cognitive level (t=-3.185, P = 0.001) after adjusting for age, education, disease duration, H&Y stage and MDS-UPDRS-III scores.

CONCLUSION

The plasma exosomal prion protein level is correlated with cognitive decline in PD patients and might be a potential biomarker for PD patients at risk for cognitive impairment.

Prion and Prion-Like Protein Strains: Deciphering the Molecular Basis of Heterogeneity in Neurodegeneration

Increasing evidence suggests that neurodegenerative disorders share a common pathogenic feature: the presence of deposits of misfolded proteins with altered physicochemical properties in the Central Nervous System. Despite a lack of infectivity, experimental data show that the replication and propagation of neurodegenerative disease-related proteins including amyloid-β (Aβ), tau, α-synuclein and the transactive response DNA-binding protein of 43 kDa (TDP-43) share a similar pathological mechanism with prions. These observations have led to the terminology of “prion-like” to distinguish between conditions with noninfectious characteristics but similarities with the prion replication and propagation process. Prions are considered to adapt their conformation to changes in the context of the environment of replication. This process is known as either prion selection or adaptation, where a distinct conformer present in the initial prion population with higher propensity to propagate in the new environment is able to prevail over the others during the replication process. In the last years, many studies have shown that prion-like proteins share not only the prion replication paradigm but also the specific ability to aggregate in different conformations, i.e., strains, with relevant clinical, diagnostic and therapeutic implications. This review focuses on the molecular basis of the strain phenomenon in prion and prion-like proteins.

iPS Cell Cultures from a Gerstmann-Sträussler-Scheinker Patient with the Y218N PRNP Mutation Recapitulate tau Pathology

Gerstmann-Sträussler-Scheinker (GSS) syndrome is a fatal autosomal dominant neurodegenerative prionopathy clinically characterized by ataxia, spastic paraparesis, extrapyramidal signs and dementia. In some GSS familiar cases carrying point mutations in the PRNP gene, patients also showed comorbid tauopathy leading to mixed pathologies. In this study we developed an induced pluripotent stem (iPS) cell model derived from fibroblasts of a GSS patient harboring the Y218N PRNP mutation, as well as an age-matched healthy control. This particular PRNP mutation is unique with very few described cases. One of the cases presented neurofibrillary degeneration with relevant Tau hyperphosphorylation. Y218N iPS-derived cultures showed relevant astrogliosis, increased phospho-Tau, altered microtubule-associated transport and cell death. However, they failed to generate proteinase K-resistant prion. In this study we set out to test, for the first time, whether iPS cell-derived neurons could be used to investigate the appearance of disease-related phenotypes (i.e, tauopathy) identified in the GSS patient.

Role of cellular prion protein in interneuronal amyloid transmission

Several studies have indicated that certain misfolded amyloids composed of tau, β-amyloid or α-synuclein can be transferred from cell to cell, suggesting the contribution of mechanisms reminiscent of those by which infective prions spread through the brain. This process of a 'prion-like' spreading between cells is also relevant as a novel putative therapeutic target that could block the spreading of proteinaceous aggregates throughout the brain which may underlie the progressive nature of neurodegenerative diseases. The relevance of β-amyloid oligomers and cellular prion protein (PrP^C) binding has been a focus of interest in Alzheimer's disease (AD). At the molecular level, β-amyloid/PrP^C interaction takes place in two differently charged clusters of PrP^C. In addition to β-amyloid, participation of PrP^C in α-synuclein binding and brain spreading also appears to be relevant in α-synucleopathies. This review summarizes current knowledge about PrP^C as a putative receptor for amyloid proteins and the physiological consequences of these interactions.

The role of the prion protein in the internalization of α-synuclein amyloids

Synucleinopathies are a group of neurodegenerative diseases characterized by the accumulation of α-synuclein amyloids in several regions of the brain. α-Synuclein fibrils are able to spread via cell-to-cell transfer, and once inside the cells, they can template the misfolding and aggregation of the endogenous α-synuclein. Multiple mechanisms have been shown to participate in the process of propagation: endocytosis, tunneling nanotubes and macropinocytosis. Recently, we published a research showing that the cellular form of the prion protein (PrP^C) acts as a receptor for α-synuclein amyloid fibrils, facilitating their internalization through and endocytic pathway. This interaction occurs by a direct interaction between the fibrils and the N-terminal domain of PrP^C. In cell lines expressing the pathological form of PrP (PrP^Sc), the binding between PrP^C and α-synuclein fibrils prevents the formation and accumulation of PrP^Sc, since PrP^C is no longer available as a substrate for the pathological conversion templated by PrP^Sc. On the contrary, PrP^Sc deposits are cleared over passages, probably due to the increased processing of PrP^C into the neuroprotective fragments N1 and C1. Starting from these data, in this work we present new insights into the role of PrP^C in the internalization of protein amyloids and the possible therapeutic applications of these findings.

The cellular prion protein (PrPC) as neuronal receptor for α-synuclein

The term 'prion-like' is used to define some misfolded protein species that propagate intercellularly, triggering protein aggregation in recipient cells. For cell binding, both direct plasma membrane interaction and membrane receptors have been described for particular amyloids. In this respect, emerging evidence demonstrates that several β-sheet enriched proteins can bind to the cellular prion protein (PrPC). Among other interactions, the physiological relevance of the binding between β-amyloid and PrPC has been a relevant focus of numerous studies. At the molecular level, published data point to the second charged cluster domain of the PrPC molecule as the relevant binding domain of the β-amyloid/PrPC interaction. In addition to β-amyloid, participation of PrPC in binding α-synuclein, responsible for neurodegenerative synucleopathies, has been reported. Although results indicate relevant participation of PrPC in the spreading of α-synuclein in living mice, the physiological relevance of the interaction remains elusive. In this comment, we focus our attention on summarizing current knowledge of PrPC as a receptor for amyloid proteins and its physiological significance, with particular focus on α-synuclein.

Physiological Functions of the Cellular Prion Protein

The prion protein, PrP^C, is a small, cell-surface glycoprotein notable primarily for its critical role in pathogenesis of the neurodegenerative disorders known as prion diseases. A hallmark of prion diseases is the conversion of PrP^C into an abnormally folded isoform, which provides a template for further pathogenic conversion of PrP^C, allowing disease to spread from cell to cell and, in some circumstances, to transfer to a new host. In addition to the putative neurotoxicity caused by the misfolded form(s), loss of normal PrP^C function could be an integral part of the neurodegenerative processes and, consequently, significant research efforts have been directed toward determining the physiological functions of PrP^C. In this review, we first summarise important aspects of the biochemistry of PrP^C before moving on to address the current understanding of the various proposed functions of the protein, including details of the underlying molecular mechanisms potentially involved in these functions. Over years of study, PrP^C has been associated with a wide array of different cellular processes and many interacting partners have been suggested. However, recent studies have cast doubt on the previously well-established links between PrP^C and processes such as stress-protection, copper homeostasis and neuronal excitability. Instead, the functions best-supported by the current literature include regulation of myelin maintenance and of processes linked to cellular differentiation, including proliferation, adhesion, and control of cell morphology. Intriguing connections have also been made between PrP^C and the modulation of circadian rhythm, glucose homeostasis, immune function and cellular iron uptake, all of which warrant further investigation.

Involvement of Cellular Prion Protein in α-Synuclein Transport in Neurons

The cellular prion protein, encoded by the gene Prnp, has been reported to be a receptor of β-amyloid. Their interaction is mandatory for neurotoxic effects of β-amyloid oligomers. In this study, we aimed to explore whether the cellular prion protein participates in the spreading of α-synuclein. Results demonstrate that Prnp expression is not mandatory for α-synuclein spreading. However, although the pathological spreading of α-synuclein can take place in the absence of Prnp, α-synuclein expanded faster in PrP^C-overexpressing mice. In addition, α-synuclein binds strongly on PrP^C-expressing cells, suggesting a role in modulating the effect of α-synuclein fibrils.

Prion Diseases

Prion diseases are a group of invariably fatal and transmissible neurodegenerative disorders that are associated with the misfolding of the normal cellular prion protein, with the misfolded conformers constituting an infectious unit referred to as a "prion". Prions can spread within an affected organism by directly propagating this misfolding within and between cells and can transmit disease between animals of the same and different species. Prion diseases have a range of clinical phenotypes in humans and animals, with a principle determinant of this attributed to different conformations of the misfolded protein, referred to as prion strains. This chapter will describe the different clinical manifestations of prion diseases, the evidence that these diseases can be transmitted by an infectious protein and how the misfolding of this protein causes disease.