Advances in meat spoilage detection: A short focus on rapid methods and technologies

Towards Reducing Food Wastage: Analysis of Degradation Products Formed during Meat Spoilage under Different Conditions

Foodstuffs, particularly perishable ones such as meat, are frequently discarded once the best-before date has been reached, despite the possibility of their continued suitability for human consumption. The implementation of intelligent packaging has the potential to contribute to a reduction in food wastage by enabling the monitoring of meat freshness during storage time independently of the best-before date. The process of meat spoilage is associated with the formation of specific degradation products, some of which can be potentially utilized as spoilage indicators in intelligent packaging. The aim of the review is to identify degradation products whose concentration correlates with meat shelf life and to evaluate their potential use as spoilage indicators in intelligent packaging. To this end, a comprehensive literature research was conducted to identify the factors influencing meat spoilage and the eight key degradation products (carboxylic acids, biogenic amines, total volatile basic nitrogen, aldehydes, alcohols, ketones, sulfur compounds, and esters) associated with this process. These degradation products were analyzed for their correlation with meat shelf life at different temperatures, atmospheres, and meat types and for their applicability in intelligent packaging. The review provides an overview of these degradation products, comparing their potential to indicate spoilage across different meat types and storage conditions. The findings suggest that while no single degradation product universally indicates spoilage across all meat types and conditions, compounds like carboxylic acids, biogenic amines, and volatile basic nitrogen warrant further investigation. The review elucidates the intricacies inherent in identifying a singular spoilage indicator but underscores the potential of combining specific degradation products to expand the scope of applications in intelligent packaging. Further research (e.g., storage tests in which the concentrations of these substances are specifically examined or research on which indicator substance responds to these degradation products) is recommended to explore these combinations with a view to broadening their applicability.

System Design Based on Biological Olfaction for Meat Analysis Using E-Nose Sensors

The deterioration of food, especially in meat products, can lead to serious health problems. Even with modern preservation technologies, a significant amount of food is lost due to microbial deterioration. As the very first step of the preservation process, the microflora that grows during the storage time and in spoiling foods should be well-known to identify critical levels. Electronic nose and gas chromatography analysis systems can provide sensitive and promising results. Similarly, bacterial analysis is an important process for determining bacterial groups that result in the emergence of such gases in gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) analysis during the degradation time. This study aims to determine the degradation levels for some meat types under different environmental conditions, such as temperature and duration, to compare with other measurement techniques for evaluating the verification of data. E-nose device, developed in this study, can detect carbon monoxide (CO), methane (CH4), ethanol (C2H5OH), and ammonia (NH3) using metal oxide semiconductor (MOS) sensors. In order to test sensory measurements during this period, GC-MS and microbial measurements were used. E-nose measurements show that the results are in accord with each other. This system can easily be made portable, occupying very little space.

Quality Assessment of Minced Poultry Products Including Black Fermented Garlic

The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of the addition of fermented black garlic on the quality of minced poultry products. Treatments were organized in four groups (1%, 2%, 3%, and 4%) containing either black fermented garlic (bg) or fresh garlic (fg), and a control (produced without garlic). The quality assessment of minced poultry products included physicochemical properties (weight losses, pH, colour and shear force), microbiological quality (Enterobacteriaceae, total count of bacteria, lactic acid bacteria, and Pseudomonas spp.) and evaluation of sensory attributes. The results showed that the pH values in the black garlic groups, pH 6.06, 6.03, and 6.01, were lower than in the control group, pH 6.16, and tended to decrease during the period of cold storage. As the percentage of black garlic increased, there was a decrease in pH, the value of L* (brightness) from 76.16 in the control group to 48.03 in the group with 4% bg, while the value of b* (yellowing) increased analogously from 12.59 to 16.08. The use of black fermented garlic at 2% as a substitute for fresh garlic is a viable alternative to obtaining product with an acceptable taste and aroma. The addition of 4% black garlic was not acceptable to the assessors.

IoT-Enabled Electronic Nose System for Beef Quality Monitoring and Spoilage Detection

Food spoilage is a major concern in the food industry, especially for highly perishable foods such as beef. In this paper, we present a versatile Internet of Things (IoT)-enabled electronic nose system to monitor food quality by evaluating the concentrations of volatile organic compounds (VOCs). The IoT system consists mainly of an electronic nose, temperature/humidity sensors, and an ESP32-S3 microcontroller to send the sensors' data to the server. The electronic nose consists of a carbon dioxide gas sensor, an ammonia gas sensor, and an ethylene gas sensor. This paper's primary focus is to use the system for identifying beef spoilage. Hence, the system performance was examined on four beef samples stored at different temperatures: two at 4 °C and two at 21 °C. Microbial population quantifications of aerobic bacteria, Lactic Acid Bacteria (LAB), and Pseudomonas spp., in addition to pH measurements, were conducted to evaluate the beef quality during a period of 7 days to identify the VOCs concentrations that are associated with raw beef spoilage. The spoilage concentrations that were identified using the carbon dioxide, ammonia, and ethylene sensors were 552 ppm-4751 ppm, 6 ppm-8 ppm, and 18.4 ppm-21.1 ppm, respectively, as determined using a 500 mL gas sensing chamber. Statistical analysis was conducted to correlate the bacterial growth with the VOCs production, where it was found that aerobic bacteria and Pseudomonas spp. are responsible for most of the VOCs production in raw beef.

Microbial diversity of meat products under spoilage and its controlling approaches

Meat spoilage (MS) is a complex microbial ecological process involving multiple specific microbial interactions. MS is detrimental to people's health and leads to the waste of meat products which caused huge losses during production, storage, transportation, and marketing. A thorough understanding of microorganisms related to MS and their controlling approaches is a necessary prerequisite for delaying the occurrence of MS and developing new methods and strategies for meat product preservation. This mini-review summarizes the diversity of spoilage microorganisms in livestock, poultry, and fish meat, and the approaches to inhibit MS. This would facilitate the targeted development of technologies against MS, to extend meat's shelf life, and effectively diminish food waste and economic losses.

Cellular Aquaculture: Prospects and Challenges

Aquaculture plays an important role as one of the fastest-growing food-producing sectors in global food and nutritional security. Demand for animal protein in the form of fish has been increasing tremendously. Aquaculture faces many challenges to produce quality fish for the burgeoning world population. Cellular aquaculture can provide an alternative, climate-resilient food production system to produce quality fish. Potential applications of fish muscle cell lines in cellular aquaculture have raised the importance of developing and characterizing these cell lines. In vitro models, such as the mouse C2C12 cell line, have been extremely useful for expanding knowledge about molecular mechanisms of muscle growth and differentiation in mammals. Such studies are in an infancy stage in teleost due to the unavailability of equivalent permanent muscle cell lines, except a few fish muscle cell lines that have not yet been used for cellular aquaculture. The Prospect of cell-based aquaculture relies on the development of appropriate muscle cells, optimization of cell conditions, and mass production of cells in bioreactors. Hence, it is required to develop and characterize fish muscle cell lines along with their cryopreservation in cell line repositories and production of ideal mass cells in suitably designed bioreactors to overcome current cellular aquaculture challenges.

Anthocyanins From Clitoria ternatea Flower: Biosynthesis, Extraction, Stability, Antioxidant Activity, and Applications

Clitoria ternatea plant is commonly grown as an ornamental plant and possesses great medicinal value. Its flower is edible and also known as blue pea or butterfly pea flower. The unique feature of anthocyanins present in blue pea flowers is the high abundance of polyacylated anthocyanins known as ternatins. Ternatins are polyacylated derivatives of delphinidin 3,3',5'-triglucoside. This review covers the biosynthesis, extraction, stability, antioxidant activity, and applications of anthocyanins from Clitoria ternatea flower. Hot water extraction of dried or fresh petals of blue pea flower could be employed successfully to extract anthocyanins from blue pea flower for food application. Blue pea flower anthocyanins showed good thermal and storage stability, but less photostability. Blue pea flower anthocyanins also showed an intense blue colour in acidic pH between pH 3.2 to pH 5.2. Blue pea flower anthocyanin extracts demonstrate significant in vitro and cellular antioxidant activities. Blue pea flower anthocyanins could be used as a blue food colourant in acidic and neutral foods. The incorporation of blue pea flower anthocyanins in food increased the functional properties of food such as antioxidant and antimicrobial properties. Blue pea flower anthocyanins have also been used in intelligent packaging. A comparison of blue pea flower anthocyanins with two other natural blue colouring agents used in the food industry, spirulina or phycocyanin and genipin-derived pigments is also covered. Anthocyanins from blue pea flowers are promising natural blue food colouring agent.

Biomapping of Microbial Indicators on Beef Subprimals Subjected to Spray or Dry Chilling over Prolonged Refrigerated Storage

As the global meat market moves to never frozen alternatives, meat processors seek opportunities for increasing the shelf life of fresh meats by combinations of proper cold chain management, barrier technologies, and antimicrobial interventions. The objective of this study was to determine the impact of spray and dry chilling combined with hot water carcass treatments on the levels of microbial indicator organisms during the long-term refrigerated storage of beef cuts. Samples were taken using EZ-Reach™ sponge samplers with 25 mL buffered peptone water over a 100 cm² area of the striploin. Sample collection was conducted before the hot carcass wash, after wash, and after the 24 h carcass chilling. Chilled striploins were cut into four sections, individually vacuum packaged, and stored to be sampled at 0, 45, 70, and 135 days (n = 200) of refrigerated storage and distribution. Aerobic plate counts, enterobacteria, Escherichia coli, coliforms, and psychrotroph counts were evaluated for each sample. Not enough evidence (p > 0.05) was found indicating the hot water wash intervention reduced bacterial concentration on the carcass surface. E. coli was below detection limits (<0.25 CFU/cm²) in most of the samples taken. No significant difference (p > 0.05) was found between coliform counts throughout the sampling dates. Feed type did not seem to influence the (p > 0.25) microbial load of the treatments. Even though no immediate effect was seen when comparing spray or dry chilling of the samples at day 0, as the product aged, a significantly lower (p < 0.05) concentration of aerobic and psychrotrophic organisms in dry-chilled samples could be observed when compared to their spray-chilled counterparts. Data collected can be used to select alternative chilling systems to maximize shelf life in vacuum packaged beef kept over prolonged storage periods.

Nanoscale Metal-Organic Frameworks as Fluorescence Sensors for Food Safety

Food safety has attracted attention worldwide, and how to detect various kinds of hazardous substances in an efficient way has always been a focus. Metal-Organic Frameworks (MOFs) are a class of hybrid porous materials formed by organic ligand and metal ions. Nanoscale MOFs (NMOFs) exhibit great potential in serving as fluorescence sensors for food safety due to their superior properties including high accuracy, great stability, fast response, etc. In this review, we focus on the recent development of NMOFs sensing for food safety. Several typical methods of NMOFs synthesis are presented. NMOFs-based fluorescence sensors for contaminants and adulterants, such as antibiotics, food additives, ions and mycotoxin etc. are summarized, and the sensing mechanisms are also presented. We explore these challenges in detail and provide suggestions about how they may be surmounted. This review could help the exploration of NMOFs sensors in food related work.

Development of a Dye-Based Device to Assess Poultry Meat Spoilage. Part I: Building and Testing the Sensitive Array

The rationale behind the material and dye selection and the investigation of the properties of a solid-phase sensor array designed for following chicken meat spoilage is presented, having in mind that the final target must be the naked eye identification of the degradation steps. The device is obtained by fixing five acid-base indicators, m-cresol purple (1), o-cresol red (2), bromothymol blue (3), thymol blue (4), and chlorophenol red (5), and a sensing molecule specific for thiols, 5,5'-dithiobis(2-nitrodibenzoic acid), called Ellman's reagent, (6) on a commercial cellulose-based support. The dimensions of the sensor and the amount of dye sorbed on the solid are carefully studied. The preparation protocol to get reproducible sensing materials is established, based on the kinetic study and the color change investigation. The material stability and the capacity of changing color, according to the acid-base properties of the dyes, are tested. The sources of uncertainty, coming from the technique employed for signal data acquisition and treatment and from the intrinsic variability of the spots based on the commercial support, are established. The highest variability does not come from photo acquisition by a mobile phone, the effect of the illumination equipment, the partial least-squares (PLS) model employed to assess the amount of dye sorbed into the solid but from the variability of different spots and was found equal to 10%. The uncertainty is adequate for final employment since it is referred to as replicates under different conditions that are definitively judged almost always identical by naked eye evaluation, which is our last target for assessing a change of the colors associated with spoilage.

A survey of a blown pack spoilage produced by Clostridium perfringens in vacuum-packaged wurstel

Three hundred Clostridium strains were isolated from spoiled wurstels and were identified by traditional and molecular methods as Clostridium perfringens. The phenotypic characteristics of the strains were studied. All the strains produced acetic and butyric acids and enterotoxin. C. perfringens grew in the spoiled wurstels because it was present in raw meat (Lot 150) at a level of 3.2 log CFU/g due to an unchecked cooling phase that took 28 h to decrease the temperature of the wurstels from 60 to 9-10 °C, which is the lower limit for C. perfringens growth. During the 28 h of cooling, the concentration of C. perfringens increased to 6.5 CFU/g. It was concluded that its presence and the long cooling time were the main factors responsible for the spoilage. Wurstels intentionally made with contaminated meat (3 log CFU/g) but cooled after cooking for 17 h to 9 °C did not support C. perfringens growth; consequently, these wurstels remained unspoiled. The packages of the spoiled wurstels were blown, and the products were soft (soggy), textureless and had the odour of acetic acid, ethanol and sulfur.

AIEgens: An emerging fluorescent sensing tool to aid food safety and quality control

As a global public health problem, food safety has attracted increasing concern. To minimize the risk exposure of food to harmful ingredients, food quality and safety inspection that covers the whole process of "from farm to fork" is much desired. Fluorescent sensing is a promising and powerful screening tool for sensing hazardous substances in food and thus plays a crucial role in promoting food safety assurance. However, traditional fluorphores generally suffer the problem of aggregation-caused quenching (ACQ) effect, which limit their application in food quality and safety inspection. In this regard, luminogens with aggregation-induced emission property (AIEgens) showed large potential in food analysis since AIEgens effectively surmount the ACQ effect with much better detection sensitivity, accuracy, and robustness. In this contribution, we review the latest developments of food safety monitoring by AIEgens, which will focus on the molecular design of AIEgens and their sensing principles. Several examples of AIE-based sensing applications for screening food contaminations are highlighted, and future perspectives and challenges in this emerging field are tentatively elaborated. We hope this review can motivate new research ideas and interest to aid food safety and quality control, and facilitate more collaborative endeavors to advance the state-of-the-art sensing developments and reduce actual translational gap between laboratory research and industrial production.

Plant Phenolics and Phenolic-Enriched Extracts as Antimicrobial Agents against Food-Contaminating Microorganisms

Phenolic compounds and extracts with bioactive properties can be obtained from many kinds of plant materials. These natural substances have gained attention in the food research as possible growth inhibitors of foodborne pathogenic and spoilage bacteria. Many phenolic-enriched plant extracts and individual phenolics have promising anti-quorum sensing potential as well and can suppress the biofilm formation and toxin production of food-related pathogens. Various studies have shown that plant phenolics can substitute or support the activity of synthetic food preservatives and disinfectants, which, by the way, can provoke serious concerns in consumers. In this review, we will provide a brief insight into the bioactive properties, i.e., the antimicrobial, anti-quorum sensing, anti-biofilm and anti-enterotoxin activities, of plant phenolic extracts and compounds, with special attention to pathogen microorganisms that have food relation. Carbohydrase aided applications to improve the antimicrobial properties of phenolic extracts are also discussed.

Response of Optically Transparent pH Sensing Films to Temperature and Temperature Variations

There are numerous applications for thin films based chemical pH sensors, in such areas as biomedical, military, environmental, food, and consumer products. pH sensitive films fabricated through the ionic self-assembled monolayers technique were made of polyelectrolyte polyallylamine hydrochloride and the water-soluble organic dye molecule Direct Yellow 4. The films were monitored in various environmental conditions and for selected periods, at temperatures varying between −13.7 and 46.2 °C. Absorbance measurements and atomic force microscopy performed before and after thermal treatment indicate that for optimized thickness and composition the films maintain their functionality and are not affected by long-term exposure at these temperatures.

Relevant Aspects of Clostridium estertheticum as a Specific Spoilage Organism of Vacuum-Packed Meat

Clostridium estertheticum is a psychrotolerant, gram-positive, motile, anaerobic, spore-forming, rod-shaped bacteria that causes blown pack spoilage (BPS). Spoilage occurs in vacuum-packed meat without temperature abuse. Having been reported in the last 30 years in several countries, BPS by Cl. estertheticum is a major issue around the world and presents a huge economic impact on the meat industry. Despite being an important spoilage microorganism, studies on Cl. estertheticum are challenged by numerous aspects. These include, lack or poor growth in laboratory media, long culturing periods, and unpredictable isolation on the media. These factors hamper the detection of Cl. estertheticum before occurrence of BPS, which further undermines efforts to prevent the occurrence of BPS. Nevertheless, considerable developments have taken place with regard to culture-independent methods. Although information on Cl. estertheticum is available, it is limited and remains highly fragmented. Therefore, this review collates the available information and discusses relevant aspects of Cl. estertheticum as a specific spoilage organism of BPS in vacuum-packed meat.