Evidence for a tubulin-containing lipid-protein structural complex in ciliary membranes

Plasma membrane tubulin

The association of tubulin with the plasma membrane comprises multiple levels of penetration into the bilayer: from integral membrane protein, to attachment via palmitoylation, to surface binding, and to microtubules attached by linker proteins to proteins in the membrane. Here we discuss the soundness and weaknesses of the chemical and biochemical evidence marshaled to support these associations, as well as the mechanisms by which tubulin or microtubules may regulate functions at the plasma membrane.

Insights into the association of FcgammaRII and TCR with detergent-resistant membrane domains: isolation of the domains in detergent-free density gradients facilitates membrane fragment reconstitution

Plasma membrane rafts are routinely isolated as detergent-resistant membranes (DRMs) floating in detergent-free density gradients. Here we show that both the presence and exclusion of TX-100 during the density gradient fractionation have profound effects on the location of FcgammaRII and TCR in DRM fractions. The presence of TX-100 during fractionation promoted solubilization of non-cross-linked FcgammaRII when the receptor was insufficiently dissolved upon cell lysis. In the detergent-supplemented gradients, TX-100 micelles floated, further enhancing dissociation of FcgammaRII and TCR from DRMs and promoting a shift of the receptors toward higher-density fractions. Hence, fractionation of cell lysates over the detergent-containing gradients enables isolation of DRMs devoid of weakly associated proteins, like nonactivated FcgammaRII and TCR. On the other hand, in a detergent-free gradient, non-cross-linked FcgammaRII, fully soluble in 0.2% TX-100, was recovered in DRM fractions. Moreover, employment of the TX-100-free gradient for refractionation of intermediate-density fractions, derived from detergent-supplemented gradients and containing FcgammaRII and TCR, resulted in flotation of the receptors to buoyant fractions. An analysis of the TX-100 concentration revealed that after fractionation of 0.2% TX-100 cell lysates in the absence of detergent, the level of TX-100 in DRM fractions was reduced to 0.01%, below the critical micelle concentration. Therefore, fractionation of detergent cell lysates over detergent-free gradients can mimic conditions for a membrane reconstitution, evoking association of a distinct subset of membrane proteins, including FcgammaRII and TCR, with DRMs.

Interaction of cytoskeletal proteins with membrane lipids

Rapid and significant progress has been made in understanding lipid/protein interactions involving cytoskeletal components and the plasma membrane. Covalent and noncovalent lipid modifications of cytoskeletal proteins mediate their interaction with lipid bilayers. The application of biophysical techniques such as differential scanning colorimetry, neutron reflection, electron spin resonance, CD spectroscopy, nuclear magnetic resonance, and hydrophobic photolabeling, allow various folding stages of proteins during electrostatic adsorption and hydrophobic insertion into lipid bilayers to be analyzed. Reconstitution of proteins into planar lipid films and liposomes help to understand the architecture of biological interfaces. During signaling events at plasma membrane interfaces, lipids are important for the regulation of catalytic protein functions. Protein/lipid interactions occur selectively and with a high degree of specificity and thus have to be considered as physiologically relevant processes with gaining impact on cell functions.

Microtubule organization and the distribution of gamma-tubulin in spermatogenesis of a beetle, Tenebrio molitor (Tenebrionidae, Coleoptera, Insecta)

The present study focuses on the restructuring of the microtubule (MT) cytoskeleton and microtubule-organizing centres (MTOCs) throughout spermatogenesis of a darkling beetle, Tenebrio molitor (Tenebrionidae, Coleoptera, Insecta). To this end, serial ultrathin sections through male germ cells were studied using transmission electron microscopy. Additionally, spindles and young spermatids were isolated from testes under MT-stabilizing conditions and doubly labeled with antibodies against beta- and gamma-tubulin. The latter is a tubulin isoform detected in MTOCs of a wide variety of species. The observations suggest that microtubules may be nucleated from sites with and without high gamma-tubulin content and that these sites do not necessarily possess canonical centrosomes. In a prominent cytoplasmic MT system of primary spermatocytes in prophase, microtubule nucleation apparently occurs in the absence of immunologically detectable gamma-tubulin. At the poles of meiotic spindles, MTs are directly inserted into gamma-tubulin-containing material and this connection is considered responsible for their nucleation. The interzone spindle MTs of telophase cells contain gamma-tubulin and this may confer stability to them. Finally, manchette MTs of spermatids originate in the vicinity of the acrosome precursor but are not inserted into this body. The acrosome precursor is surrounded by a membrane and is clearly detected by the antibody against gamma-tubulin.

Physiological oxygen tension modulates the chemically induced mitogenic response of cultured rat hepatocytes

Freshly isolated rat hepatocytes were cultured at periportal- (13% O2) or perivenous-like (4% O2) oxygen tension and exposed to subtoxic exposure levels of cyproterone acetate (CPA: 10-330 microM), phenobarbital (PB: 0.75-6 mM), and dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO: 0.1-3.3%) from 24-72 h after seeding. Induced alterations in ploidy, in the number of S-phase cells, the degree of binuclearity, and cellular protein content were determined by twin parameter protein/DNA flow cytometry analysis of intact cells and isolated nuclei. CPA and PB increased whereas DMSO decreased dose dependently the total number of S-phase cells. The changes differed within individual ploidy classes and were modulated by the oxygen tension. CPA increased and DMSO decreased the number of S-phase cells preferentially among the diploid hepatocytes at periportal-like oxygen tension. In contrast, PB increased binuclearity and S-phase cells mainly among the tetraploid hepatocytes at perivenous-like oxygen tension. Cellular protein content increased dose dependently after exposure to the hepatomitogens (CPA, PB) and decreased after exposure to DMSO at both oxygen tensions. Comparison with in vitro data proves that chemicals which interact with cells from the progenitor liver compartment (CPA, DMSO) exert their mitogenic activity best in cultures at periportal-like oxygen tension preferentially in diploid hepatocytes, whereas chemicals which affect cells from the functional compartment show a higher activity at perivenous-like oxygen tension. Physiological oxygen tension seems to be an effective modulator of the proliferative response of cultured rat hepatocytes similar to that expected for periportally or perivenously derived hepatocytes.

Mechanical properties of ciliary axonemes and membranes as shown by paddle cilia

Cilia with a distal membrane expansion enclosing a coiled end of the axoneme (paddle cilia or discocilia) have been commonly reported in marine invertebrates. We recently showed that paddle cilia in molluscan veligers are artifacts of non-physiological conditions. Here we investigated the possible mechanisms of formation of paddle cilia under hypotonic conditions; particularly, whether a helical conformational change of doublet microtubules induced by Ca or proton flux is responsible. Typical paddle cilia are induced by hypotonic Ca-free solutions at normal or low pH, showing that axonemal coiling does not require Ca influx or proton efflux. In addition, Triton-demembranated straight axonemes do not coil in high Ca solutions. Most decisively, complete removal of paddle ciliary membranes with detergents, but not mere permeabilization, causes immediate uncoiling and straightening of the axonemes to approximately their original length before hypotonic treatment. These findings and other data show that axonemal coiling in paddles is due to membrane tensile stress acting on an elastic axoneme. Light and electron microscopy of paddles show that axonemes coil uniformly toward the direction of the effective stroke (doublets nos 5–6), even when beating is inhibited by sodium azide or glutaraldehyde before hypotonic treatment. This indicates that axonemes possess an intrinsic asymmetry of stiffness within the beat plane, independent of active microtubule sliding. Paddle cilia thus reveal important mechanical properties of ciliary axonemes and membranes that should be useful for understanding ciliary function.

Tyrosinated, detyrosinated and acetylated tubulin isotypes in rat brain membranes. Their proportions in comparison with those in cytosol

The heterogeneity of alpha-tubulin and the relative proportions of the tubulin isotypes were investigated in brain membranes of rats of 1, 25 and 180 days of age by using four anti-alpha-tubulin antibodies: a) the monoclonal DM1A antibody, specific for alpha-tubulin; b) the monoclonal 6-11B-1 antibody, specific for acetylated tubulin; c) a polyclonal antibody (Glu antibody), specific for detyrosinated tubulin; and d) a polyclonal antibody (Tyr antibody), specific for tyrosinated tubulin. We found that rat brain membranes contain the three tubulin isotypes mentioned above. The proportions of tyrosinated and detyrosinated tubulin relative to total alpha-tubulin were somewhat lower in membrane than in cytosol in animals of 25 and 180 days of age. At day one of development, the proportions in membrane were similar to those found in cytosol. With respect to the acetylated form, it was about 20 times higher in membrane than in cytosol at the three ages studied. The proportion of acetylated tubulin was determined in different subcellular fractions: myelin, synaptic vesicles, mitochondria, microsomes, and plasma membrane. While the amount of total tubulin differed between the different subcellular fractions, the proportion of acetylated tubulin relative to total alpha-tubulin was constant and similar to that found in total membranes. The proportion of acetylated tubulin was also investigated in non-neural tissues (kidney, liver and lung). Although values for cytosol were about 10-fold higher than that found in brain cytosol, no detectable values for membranes could be obtained in these organs.

Identification of Tetrahymena ciliary surface proteins labeled with sulfosuccinimidyl 6-(biotinamido) hexanoate and Concanavalin A and fractionated with Triton X-114

Tetrahymena thermophila cells were labeled with sulfosuccinimidyl 6-(biotinamido) hexanoate, a sensitive nonradioactive probe for cell surface proteins, and Western blots of axonemes and ciliary membrane vesicles were compared to cilia fractionated with Triton X-114 (TX-114) in order to study the orientation of ciliary membrane proteins. Greater than 40 ciliary surface polypeptides, from greater than 350 kDa to less than 20 kDa, were resolved. The major surface 50-60 kDa proteins are hydrophobic and partition into the TX-114 detergent phase. Two high molecular weight proteins, one of which is biotinylated, comigrate with the heavy chains of ciliary dynein, sediment at 14S in a sucrose gradient, and partition into the TX-114 aqueous phase. Fractions containing these high molecular weight proteins as well as fractions enriched in 88-kDa and 66-kDa polypeptides contain Mg(2+)-ATPase activities. Detergent-solubilized tubulins partition into the TX-114 aqueous phase, are not biotinylated, and must not be exposed to the ciliary surface. The detergent-insoluble axoneme and membrane fraction contains a 36-kDa polypeptide and a portion of the 50-kDa polypeptides that otherwise partition into the detergent phase. These polypeptides could not be solubilized by ATP or by NaCl extraction and appear to be associated with pieces of ciliary membrane tightly linked to the axoneme. The ciliary membrane polypeptides were also tested for Concanavalin A binding and at least sixteen Con A-binding polypeptides were resolved. Of the major Con A-binding polypeptides, three are hydrophobic and partition into the TX-114 detergent phase, three partition into the TX-114 aqueous phase, and four partition exclusively in the detergent-insoluble fraction, which contains axonemes and detergent-resistant membrane vesicles.

Identification of surface components of mammalian respiratory tract cilia

Cilia isolation methods were modified to retain respiratory tract ciliary membranes and to identify accessible surface components. Prior to isolation of cilia, halves of cow tracheae were treated with the extended spacer arm analog of N-hydroxysuccinimido-biotin (NHS-LC-biotin) to label accessible membrane constituents. Mechanical disruption of the epithelium and substitution of CHAPS for Triton X-100 provided a good yield of cilia with membranes and with minimal contamination. Subsequent extraction of these cilia with Triton X-100 solubilized the membranes and released soluble matrix proteins. Proteins of membrane + matrix and axoneme fractions were analyzed after electrophoresis in sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gels. The major biotin-labeled components in the membrane + matrix fraction were 105, 98, and 92 kd, were glycosylated, and remained with reconstituted, pelleted membrane vesicles along with the major non-biotinylated protein at 51 kd. Other membrane + matrix proteins at 126 and 76 kd bound streptavidin even from nonlabeled trachea, but remained soluble. Several biotin-labeled proteins distinct from those in the membrane fraction remained with Triton X-100-extracted axonemes. Streptavidin-colloidal-gold (SAG) particles appeared to bind randomly along the length of cilia. The peripheral join between A and B microtubules was a predominant nonspecific location of SAG on axonemes. Axonemes with biotin label also bound significant numbers of SAG to outer dynein arms, confirming the streptavidin reaction with separated proteins on transfers. These results suggest close association of the membrane with the axoneme in respiratory tract cilia and a membrane composition somewhat different from protozoan cilia.

Fractionation of Tetrahymena ciliary membranes with triton X-114 and the identification of a ciliary membrane ATPase

Cilia were isolated from Tetrahymena thermophila, extracted with Triton X-114, and the detergent-soluble membrane + matrix proteins separated into Triton X-114 aqueous and detergent phases. The aqueous phase polypeptides include a high molecular mass polypeptide previously identified as a membrane dynein, detergent-soluble alpha and beta tubulins, and numerous polypeptides distinct from those found in axonemes. Integral membrane proteins partition into the detergent phase and include two major polypeptides of 58 and 50 kD, a 49-kD polypeptide, and 5 polypeptides in relatively minor amounts. The major detergent phase polypeptides are PAS-positive and are phosphorylated in vivo. A membrane-associated ATPase, distinct from the dynein-like protein, partitions into the Triton X-114 detergent phase and contains nearly 20% of the total ciliary ATPase activity. The ATPase requires Mg++ or Ca++ and is not inhibited by ouabain or vanadate. This procedure provides a gentle and rapid technique to separate integral membrane proteins from those that may be peripherally associated with the matrix or membrane.

The characterization of phospholipids associated with microtubules, purified tubulin and microtubule associated proteins in vitro

1. Significant levels of total phospholipid phosphate were detected in highly purified microtubule protein preparations. 2. While the phospholipid profiles of total microtubule proteins and microtubule-associated proteins showed both similarities and differences to that of a whole brain homogenate, purified tubulin was associated only with phospholipids that were not detectable in the latter. 3. Phosphatidyl ethanolamine, found exclusively in a fraction of microtubule associated proteins, stimulated microtubule assembly in vitro.

Axonal tubulin and microtubules: morphologic evidence for stable regions on axonal microtubules

Biochemical studies indicate that axonal tubulin is composed of at least two distinct pools that differ in cold solubility and biochemical composition [Brady et al: J. Cell Biol. 99:1716-1724]. To determine the morphologic correlate of cold-insoluble tubulin, segments of rat optic nerves were exposed to a series of in vitro experimental conditions that affect microtubules (MTs), including cold, podophyllotoxin (PT), triflupromazine (TFP), and taxol, and then examined by electron microscopy. Longitudinal sections of control axons showed MTs oriented parallel to the long axis of the axons. Axons exposed to cold, PT, and TFP showed short segments of MTs in association with cytoskeletal disarray. Morphometric studies were used to distinguish between a simple malorientation of MTs (undulation or zigzags in their course) and the loss of labile segments of MTs, leaving the stable portions behind. The lengths of MT segments were measured in longitudinal sections, and the numbers of MTs were determined in the cross sections. All MT segment-length histograms showed a unimodal distribution. Cold and PT produced a simple shift of the control histogram to the shorter length MTs. In cross sections the numbers of MTs in cold- and PT-exposed axons were significantly decreased, indicating that the presence of short segments of MTs in the longitudinal plane of sections was due to a loss of portions of MTs. Taxol, an agent that promotes MT assembly, reversed the cold effect partially and resulted in increases in both MT segment length and number. These studies indicate that stable MT segments are portions of longer MTs containing both stable and labile regions. Furthermore, these findings are consistent with the hypothesis that cold-insoluble tubulin functions as a transportable MT-organizing complex in the axon.

Phenotypic switching to long cilia effected by various proteases: results with Dendraster excentricus and Stronglyocentrotus purpuratus blastulae

Incubation in trypsin effects a phenotypic switch from short to long cilia (greater than 30 micron) in hatched blastulae of the sea urchin, Arbacia punctulata. To determine how trypsin causes such a switch we tested whether the phenomenon was unique to the species, Arbacia, and to the protease, trypsin. With two other echinoderm species, the sand dollar, Dendraster excentricus, and the sea urchin, Strongylocentrotus purpuratus, trypsin incubation increased the percentage of long cilia. During incubation of D. excentricus in trypsin, the percentage of long cilia increased progressively from the normal 10% long cilia of the apical tuft to 45-50% long cilia covering 1/2-3/4 of the embryo. With S. purpuratus blastulae, however, the percentage of long cilia was lower (32-40%) and the results were more variable. Of the additional proteases tested with D. excentricus, elastase was more effective than trypsin in terms of the percentage of long cilia (58%), the mean length, and the broad distribution of lengths formed. Thermolysin was about as effective as trypsin but chymotrypsin was much less so. Thus, increases in ciliary length were not unique to a particular echinoderm species or to incubation in trypsin. The magnitude of the change in length distribution, however, was species- and enzyme-dependent. An extracellular or membrane component with differential susceptibility to various proteases may, therefore, be involved in altering ciliary length.

Microtubules and the endoplasmic reticulum are highly interdependent structures

The interrelationships of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), microtubules, and intermediate filaments were studied in the peripheral regions of thin, spread fibroblasts, epithelial, and vascular endothelial cells in culture. We combined a fluorescent dye staining technique to localize the ER with immunofluorescence to localize microtubules or intermediate filaments in the same cell. Microtubules and the ER are sparse in the lamellipodia, but intermediate filaments are usually completely absent. These relationships indicate that microtubules and the ER advance into the lamellipodia before intermediate filaments. We observed that microtubules and tubules of the ER have nearly identical distributions in lamellipodia, where new extensions of both are taking place. We perturbed microtubules by nocodazole, cold temperature, or hypotonic shock, and observed the effects on the ER distribution. On the basis of our observations in untreated cells and our experiments with microtubule perturbation, we conclude that microtubules and the ER are highly interdependent in two ways: (a) polymerization of individual microtubules and extension of individual ER tubules occur together at the level of resolution of the fluorescence microscope, and (b) depolymerization of microtubules does not disrupt the ER network in the short term (15 min), but prolonged absence of microtubules (2 h) leads to a slow retraction of the ER network towards the cell center, indicating that over longer periods of time, the extended state of the entire ER network requires the microtubule system.

Interaction of tubulin with octyl glucoside and deoxycholate. 1. Binding and hydrodynamic studies

Tubulin purified from calf brain cytoplasm, normally a compact water-soluble dimer, is able to interact with the mild detergents octyl glucoside (a minimum of 60 detergent molecules) and deoxycholate (95 +/- 8 molecules). Binding is cooperative and approaches saturation below the critical micelle concentration of the amphiphiles. Binding is accompanied by a quenching of the intrinsic protein fluorescence, but no spectral shape changes indicating denaturation such as in the case of sodium dodecyl sulfate are observed. Glycerol, which is known to be preferentially excluded from the tubulin domain and to favor the folded and associated forms of this protein, inhibits the binding of the mild detergents. Octyl glucoside induces a rapidly equilibrating tubulin self-association reaction characterized by a bimodal sedimentation velocity profile with boundaries at approximately 5 and 12 S. Full dissociation of this detergent restores the normal sedimentation behavior to 90% of the protein. Binding of deoxycholate slows the sedimentation velocity of tubulin from s(0)20,w = 5.6 +/- 0.2 S to s(0)20,w = 4.8 +/- 0.3 S. Measurements of the molecular weight of the tubulin-deoxycholate complex indicate an increase from 100,000 to 143,000 +/- 5,000. The diffusion rate consistently decreases from (5.3 +/- 0.5) X 10(-7) to (3.8 +/- 0.2) X 10(-7) cm2 S-1. This is most simply interpreted as an expansion of the undissociated tubulin dimer upon detergent binding (a change in the frictional ratio, f/f min, from 1.35 to 1.86). It is concluded that tubulin shows a reversible transition between the water-soluble state and amphipathic detergent-bound forms which constitute a model system of tubulin-membrane interactions.

Ciliary membrane tubulin and associated proteins: a complex stable to Triton X-114 dissociation

When either membranes from scallop gill cilia or reconstituted membranes from the same source are solubilized with Triton X-114 and the detergent is condensed by warming, no significant fraction of any major membrane protein partitions into the micellar detergent. Rather, most of the membrane lipids condense with the detergent phase, forming mixed micelles from which nearly pure lipid vesicles may be produced by adsorption of detergent with polystyrene beads. One minor membrane protein, with a molecular weight of about 20 000, is associated consistently with these vesicles. The aqueous phase contains a fairly homogeneous protein-Triton X-114 micelle sedimenting at 2.6 S in the analytical ultracentrifuge. Sucrose gradient velocity analysis in a detergent-free gradient indicates moderate size polydispersity but constant polypeptide composition throughout the sedimenting protein zone. Sucrose gradient equilibrium analysis (also in a detergent-free gradient) results in a protein-detergent complex banding at a density of 1.245 g/cm3. Sedimentation of the protein-detergent complex in the ultracentrifuge, followed by fixation and normal processing for electron microscopy, reveals a fine, reticular material consisting of 5-10-nm granules. These data are consistent with previous evidence that membrane tubulin and most other membrane proteins exist together as a discrete lipid-protein complex in molluscan gill ciliary membranes.