Effect of idiotype-specific suppressor T cells on primary and secondary responses

On the origin of C3 nephritic factor (antibody to the alternative pathway C3 convertase): evidence for the Adam and Eve concept of autoantibody production

The antibody to the alternative pathway C3 convertase, designated C3 nephritic factor or C3NeF, is an autoantibody that is produced in everyone from the time of birth. The elaboration of C3NeF utilizes germline V-region genes which undergo antigen-driven affinity maturation, resulting in an autoantibody that is produced in large amounts with high affinity and narrow specificity. Our data also suggest that under normal conditions, the idiotypic network may play an important part in the control of this autoantibody. Further, a defect in the network with loss of control or inappropriate stimulation may be an underlying mechanism in the unrestricted production of C3NeF in patients with membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis.

Intrinsic and extrinsic factors in protein antigenic structure

Recent advances in the preparation of synthetic peptide vaccines and the use of synthetic peptides as probes of antigenic structure and function have led to renewed interest in the prediction of antigenic sites recognized by antibodies and T cells. This review focuses on antibodies. Features intrinsic to the antigen, such as hydrophilicity and mobility, may be useful in the selection of amino acid sequences of the native protein that will elicit antibodies cross-reacting with peptides, or sequences which, as peptides, will be more likely to elicit antibodies cross-reactive with the native protein. Structural mobility may also contribute to protein-protein interactions in general. However, the entire accessible surface of a protein is likely to be detectable by a large enough panel of antibodies. Which of these antibodies are made in any individual depends on factors extrinsic to the antigen molecule, host factors such as self-tolerance, immune response genes, idiotype networks, and the immunoglobulin structural gene repertoire.

Cellular basis for neonatally induced T-suppressor activity. Primary B cell maturation is blocked by suppressor-helper interactions restricted by loci on chromosome 12

The cellular mechanism and genetic restriction of neonatally induced HA-specific suppressor T (Ts) cells have been examined. The in vivo effect of these Ts cells on antibody production, primary B cell proliferation, B cell surface marker changes, and helper T (Th) cell priming during primary responses to HA have been determined. The results indicate that, although antigen-induced B cell proliferative responses and surface marker changes occur in the presence of Ts cells, differentiation to Ig secretion, and long-lived memory B cell production are prevented. Further, antigen-specific Th cell priming is completely ablated by Ts cells, suggesting that Ts act by preventing the delivery of Th signals required for both the later stages of primary B cell maturation, and the formation of memory B cell populations. Finally, in vivo cell mixing experiments using congenic mice indicate that this Ts-Th interaction is restricted by loci on mouse chromosome 12.

A highly sensitive enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for idiotype-bearing antibodies

A sensitive and specific immunoenzyme assay (ELISA) for quantitation of total and cross-reactive idiotype-bearing (CRI) anti-ABA antibodies is described. Total anti-ABA antibodies are directly assessed in ABA-BGG coated polyvinyl wells with enzyme-labelled rabbit anti-mouse immunoglobulins. By interpolation on a standard curve absorbance values give the concentration of anti-ABA antibodies with a sensitivity of 30 ng/ml. CRI+ antibodies are quantitated by inhibition of enzyme-labelled monoclonal CRI+ antibody binding to solid-phase coated rabbit anti-CRI immunoglobulins. The concentration of CRI+ antibodies, evaluated by interpolation on a standard inhibition curve, can be measured at the level of 10 ng/ml. This highly sensitive, rapid, specific and reproducible assay is easily used, with minor modifications, to detect specific antibodies in any idiotype system.

The introduction of one or two 3 beta-cholestanyl residues into benzylpenicilloyl-eicosa-L-lysines greatly potentiates their tolerogenicity for anti-benzylpenicillol IgE antibody formation

BALB/c mice were repeatedly immunized with microgram doses of benzylpenicilloylated Ascaris protein(s) (BPO9Asc) in alum. At different stages of the immune response, BPO21 eicosa-L-lysine or two analogs containing one or two hydrophobic p-oxymethylbenzyl-3 beta-cholestanyl succinate (OSuco) groups were injected. When injected early in the immune response, the anti-BPO IgE antibody formation was much more strongly and permanently suppressed by the lipophilic conjugates than by the hydrophilic BPO21 eicosa-L-lysine. A similar, but less marked, suppressive effect was observed on the anti-BPO IgG1 response. By adoptive cell transfer experiments, it was found that the OSuco-containing derivatives induce and act via suppressor T lymphocytes, since this cell-mediated suppression was sensitive to cyclophosphamide or to treatment with anti-Lyt-2.2 antibody plus complement. When these compounds were injected into repeatedly immunized mice producing late ongoing antibody responses no differences in suppression between hydrophilic and hydrophobic derivatives were observed. In this case, the IgE response was suppressed by about 50%, while the IgG1 response was not affected. These results are compatible with the suggestion that early IgE responses are most sensitive to T cell-mediated suppression and that T suppressor cells are better induced by lipophilic than by hydrophilic antigens. The late ongoing IgE response, on the other hand, is less amenable to T cell-induced suppression and tolerogenic effects brought about by plurivalent BPO antigens operate directly on hapten-specific IgE-bearing B cells, regardless of their lipophilic character.

Restricted adult clonal profiles induced by neonatal immunization. Influence of suppressor T cells

The effects of neonatal antigen exposure on the adult B cell repertoire have been examined by characterizing the influenza hemagglutinin (HA)-specific response of adult BALB/c mice given antigen soon after birth. Ligand exposure during early life exerts a profound and lasting effect upon the B cell repertoire, characterized by the expansion and preservation of particular antigen-reactive clones and the apparent loss of others. The precise subset of clonotypes selectively preserved depends upon the age at which antigen is first encountered; and is predictable given a knowledge of the emerging primary pool's dynamics and composition. The preserved (secondary) B cells differ from their unprimed precursors with respect to (a) expression of the surface marker detected by the monoclonal antibody J11d, and (b) susceptibility to T cell-mediated suppression. These studies thus demonstrate a strong relationship between the heritable dynamics of the emerging primary B cell repertoire and the effect of ligand-driven events upon repertoire phenotype. In addition, they provide a mechanistic model for certain forms of antigen-induced oligoclonal dominance, especially the phenomenon of original antigenic sin.

ABA-specific helper T cells in A/J mice bear the major cross-reactive idiotype

Attempts were made to induce azobenzenearsonate (ABA)-specific helper cell responses in A/J mice. These were measured by an increase in TNP plaque-forming cells following administration of the double hapten conjugate ABA-bovine serum albumin-TNP. Immunization with ABA coupled homologous immunoglobulin or spleen cells produced ABA-specific help only when the same carrier was used to boost. Hapten-specific help was achieved by two injections of ABA-N-acetyltyrosine in complete Freund's adjuvant 5 weeks apart. This help was passively transferable by T cells as shown by its elimination with anti-Thy 1.2 serum and complement treatment. The presence of the major ABA cross-reactive idiotype (CRI) on these T helper cells could be similarly shown by the elimination of help when the cells were treated with rabbit anti-CRI antibody and complement prior to passive transfer. The same treatment did not effect ABA-specific helper activity of CBA/J mice.

Demonstration of active tolerance in maintenance of established islet of Langerhans allografts

Streptozotocin-induced diabetes in mice can be reversed by transplantation of islets of Langerhans from histoincompatible mice if the islets are treated with anti-Ia-serum and complement before transplantation. Here we show that anti-Ia-treated islets most likely induce tolerance in the recipient animals. Daily injections of recipient-specific anti-I-J-serum (beginning 80 or more days after transplantation) and small numbers of donor splenocytes caused the prompt rejection of the islets in half of the animals; neither anti-I-J-serum nor donor splenocytes alone were effective. It is likely that rejection of established allografts after this treatment is the result of abolition of the activity of allograft-specific suppressor cells.

The assessment of anti-idiopathic antibodies as effective immunoregulatory probes in vivo

In order to increase our understanding of the potential to use anti-idiotypic antibodies as immune modulators in vivo, we extensively analysed influences induced by one such antibody (anti-Id-l) following its administration to animals of different ages, genetic backgrounds, and immunological histories. Id-l is an inter-strain idiotype associated with rat anti-Group A streptococcal carbohydrate antibodies. The intraperitoneal (i.p.) injection of anti-Id-l antibodies, prepared against Id-l+ antibodies from an HPR rat could effectively induce long-term idiotype suppression in all tested strains of rats, regardless of the age at the time of treatment, the RTl haplotype or IgG2c or k-chain allotype. Total anti-streptococcal antibodies were not suppressed by this treatment. Although long-term suppression could be induced at any age, the percentage of animals suppressed following neonatal injections was consistently less than that following adult injections of anti-idiotypic antibodies. In addition, neonatal injections of anti-Id-l or Id-l with anti-Id-l appeared to enhance Id-l production in a minority of the animals. Similar treatment of adult animals never increased Id-l synthesis, suggesting that cells associated with enhanced Id-l production in older animals are either refractory to activation-differentiation signals and/or are sequestered and no longer accessible by i.v. or i.p. routes of administration of the probe. Auto-anti-Id-l immunity induced by immunizing adult rats with heavy, light, F(ab')2 fragments or whole IgG molecules could also induce an Id-l suppressed state. We were not able to induce significant Id-l suppression if animals were immunized with antigen prior to the injection of anti-Id-l. There was evidence, however, that such treatment might lead in time to the development of some idiotype specific suppression.

Regulation by complementary idiotypes. Ig protects the clone producing it

A/He mice actively producing complementary or anti-idiotypic antibody directed against a combining site structure for phosphorylcholine (PC) have profound and long-lasting suppression of their response to PC. B cells from unresponsive mice are unresponsive in vitro, and attempts to demonstrate suppressor cells in unresponsive mice were unsuccessful. Although the process ultimately responsible for suppression has not been defined, suppression can be initiated by anti-idiotypic antibody alone and prevented by complementary Ig; i.e., by anti-PC antibody. Furthermore, a suppressed anti-PC response can be rescued by sublethal irradiation and anti-PC antibody given passively. The recovery of the suppressed response is slow and presumably results from maturation from "stem" cells, which are protected from tolerization by the passively given antibody. Thus, by extrapolation, one of the functions of secreted Ig may be to protect the clone that produces it.

Autoregulation of immune responses via idiotype network interactions

Images

Studies on the control of antibody synthesis. XVII. Effect of specific suppressor cells on the affinity of the antibody response by naive or primed lymphocytes

A comparison was made of the effects of carrier-specific helper T-cell tolerance and carrier-specific suppressor cells on the affinity of the anti-hapten PFC produced in both a primary and secondary anti-hapten response. Carrier-specific suppressor T cells caused a striking preferential loss of high affinity PFC in the primary response, but had only a slight effect on the affinity of the anti-hapten PFC formed in the secondary response. A carrier-specific state of tolerance, induced at a dosage which was shown not to generate significant suppressor cell activity, was associated with minimal alterations in the affinity of the primary anti-hapten PFC response. Carrier specific tolerance, induced in animals which had been previously primed to the hapten on a different carrier, had little or no effect on the affinity of the PFC response.

Selective suppression of the major idiotypic component of an antihapten response by soluble T cell-derived factors with idiotypic or anti-idiotypic receptors

Evidence is presented for the selective suppression of the major idiotypic component of the humoral response to the phenylarsonate hapten by soluble factors derived from T cells (TsF). The existence of TsF with anti-idiotypic receptors was also demonstrated. It was found that TsF with idiotypic and anti-idiotypic receptors coexist in cultures of spleen cells prepared from idiotypically suppressed, hyperimmunized mice. By gel filtration the molecular weight of each factor was found to be 50,000-100,000. Each is sensitive to trypsin and is bound to a column containing anti-H-2a antibodies. Evidence is discussed which suggests the possibility of mutual stimulation of suppressor T cells with idiotypic and anti-idiotypic receptors.

A mature T lymphocyte subpopulation marker closely linked to the Ig-1 allotype Ch locus

An antiserum raised in BALB/c AnN mice against selected CAL.20 T cells reacts with a cell surface antigen in virgin animals that is found on 25% of mature thymocytes and Lyt-2-bearing T cells, but not on prothymocytes, Lyt-1 T cells or B cells. The antigen is restricted to strains carrying the Ig-1d or Ig-1e heavy chain allotype haplotypes. It is expressed in F1 mice. The antiserum blocks the binding of suppressor T cells to the cross-reacting idiotype for arsonate while reagents specific for Fab, Fc or Ig were ineffective. We suggest that the antigen described represents a determinant on the product of a new locus coding for a heavy chain-linked polypeptide found on a subpopulation of T cells.

Suppression of hapten-specific delayed-type hypersensitivity responses in mice by idiotype-specific suppressor T cells after administration of anti-idiotypic antibodies

Delayed-type hypersensitivity (DTH) responses specific for the phosphorylcholine (PC) hapten were induced in BALB/c mice by immunization with syngeneic peritoneal exudate cells (PEC) coupled with diazotized phenyl-phosphoryl-choline. PC-specific DTH responses were elicited in such immunized mice after footpad challenge with PC-derivatized syngeneic spleen cells. Moreover, PC-immune lymph node cells could passively transfer PC-specific DTH responses to naive BALB/c mice and it was possible to demonstrate that the cells responsible for such passively transferred responses were T lymphocytes. Because the T-15 idiotypic determinant displayed on the TEPC-15 PC-binding myeloma protein is known to be a dominant idiotype associated with anti-PC antibody responses in BALB/c mice, an analysis was made of the effects of anti-T-15 idiotypic antibodies on the induction and expression of murine PC-specific DTH responses. Repeated injections of anti-T-15 idiotypic antiserum, raised in A/J mice by immunization with TEPC-15 myeloma protein, into recipient BALB/c mice both immediately before and after sensitization with PC-PEC virtually abolished the development of PC-specific DTH responses. Although administration of anti-T-15 antiserum effectively inhibited the induction phase of PC-specific DTH responses, these anti-idiotypic antibodies had no suppressive activity at the effector phase of these responses. The inhibition observed with anti-T-15 antibodies was highly specific for the PC hapten, and for PC-specific DTH responses of BALB/c but not A/J mice. Studies were conducted to address the possibility that anti-Id treatment induced suppressor T lymphocytes capable of specifically inhibiting the activity of PC-specific T cells participating in DTH responses. The results demonstrate that idiotype-specific suppressor T cells are, indeed, induced by treatment with anti-Id; moreover, such suppressor T cells, once induced, are highly effective in abrogating both the induction and the effector phases of PC-specific T cell-mediated DTH responses in BALB/c mice.

Suppression of idiotype and generation of suppressor T cells with idiotype-conjugated thymocytes

Inoculation of A/J mice with syngeneic thymocytes conjugated with specifically purified A/J anti-phenylarsonate (anti-Ar) antibodies, selectively suppressed the subsequent synthesis of those anti-Ar antibodies which carry the major cross-reactive idiotype. High titers of anti-Ar antibodies were produced upon subsequent immunization but in most mice the idiotype was undetectable. Suppression similarly occurred in F1(A/J X BALB/c) and in C.AL-20 mice. Although some mice were suppressed when unconjugated antibody was injected, the suppressive effect was much more pronounced, particularly in the F1 and C.AL-20 recipients, when the antibody was coupled to thymocytes. The state of suppression could be adoptively transferred with T cells to mildly irradiated syngeneic recipients. A population enriched for B cells had little if any suppressive effect. There was no requirement for antigen in the generation of suppressors. Thymocytes conjugated with antibody did not induce idiotype-specific suppression in mice that had been recently challenged with antigen. Thymocytes from BALB/c and C57BL/10 mice were effective carriers for the anti-Ar antibodies, i.e., there was no evidence for H-2 restriction. The experiments demonstrate the feasibility of suppressing idiotype production and generating idiotype-specific suppressor T cells without the use of anti-idiotypic antibody or antigen.