Suppression of T cells specific for the nonthymic parental H-2 haplotype in thymus-grafted chimeras

Cellular and molecular signals in T cell differentiation

The thymic epithelium exerts its differentiative effects through several mechanisms, involving direct contact with stem cells as well as secretion of various thymic hormones. Indirect and direct evidence suggests that the thymus produces chemotactic factors for the stem cells that colonize the thymus anlage. The epithelium also produces several maturational factors which act upon stem cells that have undergone primary differentiation by contact with thymic epithelium. The chemical characteristics of these hormones and their mode of action at the cellular level (high affinity receptors, metabolic effects, target cells) are partly known. Their relationship with T cell factors such as Interleukin-2--produced in the periphery and endowed with strong differentiative capacity--is intriguing, the more so because thymic hormones not only act within the thymus but also affect peripheral T cells after they have emigrated from the thymus.

Positive selection determines T cell receptor V beta 14 gene usage by CD8+ T cells

We report here a mAb, 14-2, reactive with TCRs that include V beta 14. The frequency of V beta 14+ T cells varies with CD4 and CD8 subset and is controlled by the H-2 genes. Thus CD8+ T cells from H-2b mice include approximately 2.3% V beta 14+ T cells while CD8+ T cells from mice expressing K kappa include greater than 8% V beta 14+ T cells. In all strains examined, 7-8% of CD4+ T cells express V beta 14. The frequent usage of V beta 14 in CD8+ T cells of K kappa-expressing mice is a result of preferential positive selection of V beta 14+ CD8+ T cells as demonstrated by analysis of radiation chimeras. These studies demonstrate that H-2-dependent positive selection occurs in unmanipulated mice. Furthermore, the results imply that positive selection, and possibly H-2 restriction, can be strongly influenced by a V beta domain, with some independence from the beta-junctional sequence and alpha chain.

Bone marrow-derived thymic antigen-presenting cells determine self-recognition of Ia-restricted T lymphocytes

We previously have demonstrated that in radiation-induced bone marrow chimeras, T-cell self-Ia restriction specificity appeared to correlate with the phenotype of the bone marrow-derived antigen-presenting (or dendritic) cell in the thymus during T-cell development. However, these correlations were necessarily indirect because of the difficulty in assaying thymic function directly by adult thymus transplant, which has in the past been uniformly unsuccessful. We now report success in obtaining functional T cells from nude mice grafted with adult thymuses reduced in size by treatment of the thymus donor with anti-thymocyte globulin and cortisone. When (B10 Scn X B10.D2)F1 nude mice (I-Ab,d) are given parental B10.D2 (I-Ad) thymus grafts subcutaneously, their T cells are restricted to antigen recognition in association with I-Ad gene products but not I-Ab gene products. Furthermore, thymuses from (B10 X B10.D2)F1 (I-Ab,d)----B10 (I-Ab) chimeras transplanted 6 months or longer after radiation (a time at which antigen-presenting cell function is of donor bone marrow phenotype) into (B10 X B10.D2)F1 nude mice generate T cells restricted to antigen recognition in association with both I-Ad and I-Ab gene products. Thymuses from totally allogeneic bone marrow chimeras appear to generate T cells of bone marrow donor and thymic host restriction specificity. Thus, when thymus donors are radiation-induced bone marrow chimeras, the T-cell I-region restriction of the nude mice recipients is determined at least in part by the phenotype of the bone marrow-derived thymic antigen presenting cells or dendritic cells in the chimeric thymus.

RISH III. Haplotype-sharing in immune responses

A number of hypotheses have been proposed for the reactivity of lymphocytes with allogeneic tissue. However, these hypotheses have not been generally accepted for they cannot accommodate the observation that lymphocytes from chimeras cooperate with each other. Also, only a few percent of lymphocytes react with allogeneic tissue in rejection reactions.

Graft-versus-host reactions in F1 hybrid mice: MHC-restriction-independent generalized depression of virus-specific cytotoxic T cell response

A graft-versus-host reaction (GVHR) was induced in F1 hybrid mice by intravenous injection of parental spleen cells. A possible effect generated by recipient F1 mice of a GVHR on the restriction specificities of anti-viral cytotoxic T cells was investigated. (A/J X C57BL/6) F1 recipients were injected with 1 X 10(8) or 2 X 10(7) spleen cells from either parent. Zero to two weeks later during an acute GVHR or 12 to 26 weeks later during a chronic GVHR, spleen cells from these F1 recipients were assayed for their capacity to generate vaccinia (or lymphocytic choriomeningitis) virus-specific cytotoxic T cells. No effect was seen when parental cells were injected with virus on the same day. During the acute phase of the GVHR, recipients of spleen cells of both doses or from either parent injected 7 or 14 days previously generated markedly fewer cytotoxic T cells with respect to both parental restriction specificities. In the more chronic situation only, recipients of 1 X 10(8) parental spleen cells showed depressed virus-specific cytotoxic responses, again both restriction specificities were affected comparably. Therefore, a GVHR depresses generation of virus-specific cytotoxic T cells in a dose- and time-dependent way, but does not measurably disturb the balance of parental 1 versus parental 2 restriction specificity in an F1 recipient.

H-2 restriction specificity of T cells from H-2 incompatible radiation bone marrow chimeras: further evidence for the absence of crucial influence of the host/thymus environment on the generation of H-2 restricted TNP-specific T lymphocyte precursors

Experiments were conducted to answer the questions related to (a) the role played by the antigen-presenting cells (APCs) present within the thymus and (b) the effect of radiation dose to the recipients on the H-2 restriction profile of TNP-specific cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors (CTLP) recovered from spleens and/or thymuses of H-2 incompatible radiation bone marrow chimeras (BMC). The H-2 restriction profile of intrathymically differentiating TNP-specific CTLPs was also analyzed in order to test an argument that donor-H-2 restricted CTLP detected in spleens of H-2 incompatible BMC were due to the extrathymically differentiated T cells under the influence of donor-derived lymphoreticular cells. The results indicated the following: (i) splenic T cells from B10(H-2b) leads to (B10(H-2b) leads to B10.BR(H-2k)) chimeras, which were constructed by irradiating primary B10 leads to B10.BR chimeras with 1100 R and reconstituting them with donor-type (B10) bone marrow cells as long as 8 months after their construction, manifested restriction specificities for both donor- and host-type H-2, (ii) splenic T cells from two types of (B10 X B10.BR)F1 leads to B10 chimeras which were reconstituted after exposure of the recipients with either 900 or 1100 R with donor-type bone marrow cells generated both donor- and host-H-2 restricted TNP-specific cytotoxic T cells, and (iii) the TNP-specific CTLPs present in the regenerating thymuses of B10.BR leads to B10 and (B10 X B10.BR)F1 leads to B10 chimeras 4 weeks after their construction were also shown to manifest both donor- and host-H-2 restriction specificities. The significance of these findings on the H-2 restriction profile of CTLP generated in BMCs is discussed.

Anti-viral immune response of allogeneic irradiation bone marrow chimeras: cytotoxic T cell responsiveness depends upon H-2 combination and infectious agent

Allogeneic irradiation bone marrow chimeras C57BL/10 (H-2b) leads to B10.BR (H-2k) and B10.BR (H-2k) leads to C57BL/10 (H-2b) were raised under specific pathogen-free (SPF) conditions; they survived very well and were healthy under SPF for 3-4 months and subsequently, under conventional housing conditions, for 1 to 8 months. Their immune response against third-party alloantigens was comparable with that of controls. Anti-vaccinia virus responses were very low when compared with syngeneic control chimeras or unmanipulated control animals; if anti-vaccinia virus cytotoxic T cell reactivity was measurable, it was specific for the bone marrow donor, rather than the recipient thymic H-2 type. In contrast, the anti-LCMV (lymphocytic-choriomeningitis virus) response was excellent and comparable to that in controls for B10.BR (H-2k) leads to C57BL/10 (H-2b) chimeras, but was completely absent for C57BL/10 (H-2b) leads to 10.BR (H-2k) chimeras. LCMV-specific cytotoxic effector T cells from B10.BR leads to C57BL/10 chimeras were restricted entirely to recipient H-2b. In contrast to the asymmetric cytotoxic T cell response, both types of chimeras developed good primary footpad swelling reactions after local infection, which arose somewhat slower with LCMV than in control of chimeras. The capacity to control infection by Listeria monocytogenes was excellent for all controls and B10.BR leads to C57BL/10 chimeras but apparently absent in C57BL/10 leads to B10.BR chimeras. Differentiation of T cell restriction specificity for thymic H-2 is apparently most efficient, but it remains unclear whether the observed asymmetry reflects exaggerated immune response regulation in H-2-incompatible stem cell-thymus chimeras or differential cross-reactivities between restricting transplantation antigens.

Allogeneic H-2d leads to H-2b irradiation bone marrow chimeras: a) failure to transfer chimerism adoptively and b) immune reactivity of immunocompetent lymphocytes adoptively transferred to chimeras

Long-lived, GVHD-free, H-2 incompatible haemopoietic chimeras (P1 leads to P2) were constructed transfusing unmanipulated bone marrow cells together with recently identified marrow-regulating factors (MRF) in lethally irradiated recipients. The chimeric tolerance of P1 leads to P2 chimeras proved to be adoptively untransferable. Another peculiar property of established P1 leads to P2 allochimeras was their ability to "suppress" or reject passively transfused immunocompetent P1 or P2 lymphocytes. Even this "suppression" appeared to be untransferable and to operate in the chimera only in a fashion dependent upon the age of the established chimeras. This chimeric "unidentified suppressive principle" seems not to follow familiar immunologic lines. A relationship with the mechanism of chimeric tolerance is suggested.

Transplantation tolerance: evidence for Lyt 1+,2-,Qa 1.2+ Suppressor-inducer T cells in allogeneic thymus-grafted nude mice

Nude mice, of BALB/c genotype, grafted with thymus stroma become immunocompetent (R. Hong, H. Schultz-Wisserman, E. Jarreth-Toth, S. D. Horowitz, and D.D. Manning, J. Exp. Med. 149, 398, 1979; B. P. Chen and G. A. Splitter, Cell. Immunol. 51, 127, 1980), but are tolerant to the thymus-donor genotype. Using such mice to investigate the mechanism(s) of transplantation tolerance, it was found that maintenance of tolerance required active interactions of three subsets of T cells specific for alloantigens of the thymus-donor genotype: (i) Lyt 1+,2- helper T cells, (ii) Lyt 1-,2+ suppressor T cells, and (iii) Lyt 1+,2-,Qa 1.2+ suppressor-inducer T cells. In mixed-lymphocyte culture, helper T cells could be activated by alloantigens of the thymus-donor genotype, but clonal expansion of these helper T cells was inhibited by suppressor T cells with the same specificity. Furthermore, exogenous interleukin-2 (IL-2) could modulate this suppressor activity, which suggested that one consequence of suppression was to limit IL-2 available to effector T cells. The response of cultures to exogenous IL-2 also indicated that thymus alloantigen-specific helper T cells had functional IL-2 receptors. Last, the presence of Lyt 1+,2-,Qa 1.2+ suppressor-inducer T cells were essential for active suppression, as suppressor T cells could not prevent helper T cells from proliferating to thymus-donor alloantigens when Lyt 1+,2-,Qa 1.2+ cells were removed. Altogether, the data presented in this study indicate a feedback-suppression pathway that led to clonal silencing of effector cells in transplantation tolerance.

Immunoreactivity of long lived H-2 incompatible irradiation chimeras (H-2d leads to H-2b)

Allogenic irradiations bone marrow chimeras made according to a new protocol with unmanipulated bone marrow are long lived, healthy and stable full chimeras (H-2d leads to H-2b). Their immunocompetence is split. Alloreactivity measured by skin graft rejection and mixed lymphocyte culture is within normal range. In contrast, major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted T-cell-dependent primary responses against sheep red blood cells (SRBC) or viruses are clearly deficient. The quantitative difference in immunocompetence is at least of the order of ten-to thirty-fold. The implications of the findings for lymphohaemopoietic reconstitution of immunodeficient patients are briefly discussed.

A one-receptor view of T-cell behaviour

The discovery of T cells and their behaviour has forced a re-evaluation of the immunological relationship between self and not-self. T cells seem to respond against foreign antigens only when the latter are in some form of association with self molecules encoded by the major histocompatibility complex. This has raised the question of whether T-cell recognition may depend on two separate receptors. I present here the case for a model of T-cell behaviour based on a single receptor.

Frequency analysis of cytotoxic T lymphocyte precursors in chimeric mice. Evidence for intrathymic maturation of clonally distinct self-major histocompatibility complex- and allo-major histocompatiblilty complex-restricted virus-specific T cells

To study whether the thymic major histocompatibility complex (MHC) imposes a constraint on the receptor repertoire of maturating cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) precursors, the restriction phenotypes of virus-specific CTL of MHC-compatible and of MHC-incompatible thymus- and bone marrow-grafted (A X B)F1 chimeric mice were compared. Dependent on the mode of in vitro sensitization, thymocytes or splenocytes of both types of chimeric mice generated Sendai virus-specific, self-MHC-or allo-MHC-restricted CTL. By applying the limiting-dilution technique, the CTL-precursor (CTL-P) frequencies of self-MHC-restricted and allo-MHC-restricted virus-specific T cells as well as of alloreactive T cells were determined. The data obtained revealed that independent of MHC differences between thymus and bone marrow, the frequencies of self-MHC-restricted and allo-MHC-restricted CTL-P were comparable, and in the same older of magnitude as those previously determined in conventionally reared mice. Self-MHC-restricted, virus-specific CTL-P were in a three- to fivefold excess over allo-MHC-restricted CTL-P. A segregation analysis revealed that clonally distinct CTL-P give rise to either self-restricted or allo-MHC-restricted, virus-specific CTL. Both sets were found not only in the spleen, but also in the thymus of chimeric mice, formally demonstrating the intrathymic differentiation pathway of self-MHC as well of allo-MHC-restricted CTL-P. These data reveal no major constraint of the thymic MHC on the capacity of T cells to recognize viral antigens either in the context of self-MHC or of allogeneic MHC products.

Restricted antibody formation to sheep erythrocytes of allogeneic bone marrow chimeras histoincompatible at the K end of the H-2 complex

Employing a new method for allogeneic bone marrow transplantation, irradiation chimeras constructed from various combinations of marrow cells from B10 H-2 recombinant mice and AKR recipients were prepared. Though these chimeras had well-developed populations of T and B cells, they showed strikingly different patterns of responses in the primary antibody formation to sheep erythrocytes (SRBC), a T dependent antigen. These are (a) AKR mice treated with C57BL/10 cells, [B10 leads to AKR] fully H-2 incompatible, and AKR mice treated with B10.A (5R) cells, [5R leads to AKR] I-J,E compatible chimeras that were almost completely unresponsive to SRBC; (b) AKR mice treated with B10.BR cells [BR leads to AKR] fully H-2 compatible, and AKR mice treated with B10 AKM cells, [AKM leads to AKR] chimeras where donor and recipient differed only at H-2D, showed the same number of plaque-forming cells (PFC) as B10 control mice; (c) AKR mice treated with B10.A cells, [B10 leads to AKR] chimeras, where donor and recipient were matched at H-2K-I-E region, showed about one-half the number of PFC as the control mice. From these results we conclude that in allogeneic bone marrow chimeras primary antibody response to T-dependent antigen, such as SRBC, is generated when at least the K end of the H-2 complex is compatible between donor and recipient.

Sendai virus-specific, H-2-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocyte responses of nude mice grafted with allogeneic or semi-allogeneic thymus glands

The in vitro secondary cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) response to Sendai virus-treated stimulator cells by primed spleen cells from thymus gland-grafted nude mice was examined. BALB/c (H-2d) nude mice grafted with allogeneic C57BL/10 (H-2b) thymus glands developed CTL responses directed exclusively to Sendai virus-infected H-2d target cells. (C57BL/6 X BALB/c)F1 nude mice grafted with thymus glands of either parent developed CTL responses preferentially against infected target cells expressing the MHC antigens present in the parental thymus graft, but also had detectable activity for infected target cells of the parental haplotype not expressed in the thymus. These results provide evidence against the concept that self recognition by MHC-restricted CTL is directed exclusively by the MCH type of the thymus.

T-cell specificity for H-2 and Ir gene phenotype correlates with the phenotype of thymic antigen-presenting cells

Experiments with chimaeric animals have demonstrated that the H-2 restriction specificity and immune response (Ir) gene phenotype of the T cell is acquired during development in the thymus. The mechanism by which this process occurs is unclear. One level of obligate expression of H-2 and Ir gene products is on the surface of antigen-presenting cells (APCs) which come from bone marrow precursors. We have now examined the turnover of APCs in the thymuses of F1 leads to parent (P) radiation-induced bone marrow chimaeras and found that APCs of donor phenotype appear at about 2 months after reconstitution. If the peripheral T-cell population is depleted after this time, new T cells emerging from the parental thymus (containing F1 APCs) behaving like F1 T cells, suggesting that cells from the bone marrow can influence thymic-directed T-cell differentiation. The thymic APC is an attractive condidate to play such a part in the development of the T-cell repertoire.

Role of the major histocompatibility gene products in regulating the antibody response to dinitrophenylated poly(L-Glu55,L-Ala35,L-Phe9)n

These studies were carried out to investigate the potential helper T cell repertoire specific for the random copolymer poly(L-Glu55,L-Ala35, L-Phe9)n(GL phi 9) of responder, nonresponder, and (responder x nonresponder)F1 murine strains. We tested the ability of these T cells to collaborate with dinitrophenyl (DNP)-specific primary and secondary B lymphocytes of each strain in response to the antigen CNP-GL phi 9 in the splenic-fragment culture system. The results of these experiments show that there are GL phi 9-specific T lymphocytes in the responder, nonresponder, and F1 strains; but that these three GL phi 9-specific T cell populations differ in their collaborative potential. Responder T cells are able to collaborate with their own syngeneic responder B cells as well as the allogeneic nonresponder B cells in a syngeneic fashion. The F1 T cell population resembles that of the nonresponder in its ability to collaborate with only responder B cells in a syngeneic fashion. Analysis carried out using appropriately selected mouse strains indicate that these results are unlikely to be a result of positive or negative allogeneic effects. The results obtained suggest that individuals within a given murine strain do possess the capacity to collaborate in a syngeneic fashion with B cells of any other MHC-allogeneic strain as well as their own MHC-identical B cells. The nonresponder status in the response to GL phi 9 appears to be the result of a deletion of T cells capable of recognizing antigen in the context of B cells of the nonresponder haplotype. Thus, the MHC gene products appear to play a determinative role in shaping the expressed helper T cell specificity repertoire within an individual mouse strain.