Clonal analysis of the Mls system. A reappraisal of polymorphism and allelism among Mlsa, Mlsc, and Mlsd

Potential alteration of tumor microenvironments by β-mercaptoethanol

The therapeutic effectiveness of immune checkpoint inhibitors in cancer patients is quite profound. However, it is generally accepted that further progress is curtailed by accompanying adverse events and by low cure rates linked to the tumor microenvironment. The multitudes of immune processes altered by low-molecular-weight thiols published over the past decades suggest they have potential to alter tumor microenvironment processes which could result in an increase in immune checkpoint inhibitor survival rates. Based on one of the most studied and most potent low-molecular-weight thiols, β-mercaptoethanol (BME), it is proposed that clinical assessment be undertaken to identify any BME benefits with relevance for proliferation/differentiation of immune cells, lymphocyte exhaustion, immunogenicity of tumor antigens and inactivation of suppressor cells/factors. The BME alterations projected to be most effective are: maintenance/replacement of glutathione in lymphocytes via facilitation of cysteine uptake, inhibition of suppressor cells/soluble factors and inactivation of free-radical, reactive oxygen species.

Bacterial and viral superantigens: roles in autoimmunity?

Superantigens are bacterial, viral, or retroviral proteins which can activate specifically a large proportion of T cells. In contrast with classical peptide antigen recognition, superantigens do not require processing to small peptides but act as complete or partially processed proteins. They can bind to major histocompatibility complex class II molecules and stimulate T cells expressing particular T cell receptor V beta chains. The other polymorphic parts of the T cell receptor, which are crucial for classical antigen recognition, are not important for this interaction. When this strategy is used a large proportion of the host immune system can be activated shortly after infection. The activated cells have a wide variety of antigen specificities. The ability to stimulate polyclonal B (IgG) as well as T cell responses raises possibilities of a role for superantigens in the induction of autoimmune diseases. Superantigens have been a great tool in the hands of immunologists in unravelling some of the basic mechanisms of tolerance and immunity.

Influence of viral superantigens on V beta- and V alpha-specific positive and negative selection

In mice, V beta-specific negative selection is mediated by a number of superantigens encoded by various mouse mammary tumor viruses. We have identified Mtv-3, Mtv-27, Mtv-44, Mtv-8, Mtv-9, Mtv-11, and MMTV(D2.GD), and have confirmed Mtv-1. Although specificities of superantigens correlate well with sequences of their carboxy terminal regions, Mtv-44 appears to be an exception: the product is specific for V beta 3, V beta 6, V beta 8.1, and V beta 9. It remains to be determined whether Mtv-44 produces one or two different superantigens to exhibit this specificity. V beta 5+ T-cell deletion is induced by two groups of superantigens: V beta 3-specific superantigens encoded by Mtv-1, Mtv-3, Mtv-6, Mtv-13, Mtv-27, and Mtv-44, and V beta 11-specific superantigens encoded by Mtv-8, Mtv-9, and Mtv-11. Furthermore, these V beta 3-specific superantigens are also specific for V beta 17a(cz). In contrast, V beta-specific positive selection and V alpha-specific positive and negative selection do not seem to involve non-H-2 (super)antigens, although their involvement can not be excluded. In the near future, superantigens, powerful modulators of T-cell functions, will be exploited for clinical applications.

Mls genes and self-superantigens

The Mls gene products, which have long been known for their potent T-cell stimulatory function, have recently come of age through two pivotal discoveries, revealing that they act as superantigens and originate from retroviruses. In addition, recent experiments suggest that two retroviruses, the murine B-type mammary tumor virus and the human lentivirus HIV, make use of the T-cell stimulatory capacity of a virally encoded superantigen for facilitating viral replication.

Molecular characterization of Mls-1

Recently a series of endogenous and exogenous superantigens have been described which have one common feature, namely, they lead to in vivo deletion and in vitro stimulation of T cells expressing particular T cell receptor V beta genes. The Mls antigens represent the prototypes of these molecules. We have mapped Mls-1 to the endogenous mammary tumor virus (MMTV) Mtv-7, while other SAG have also been associated with various MMTV. The open reading frame gene of the MMTV encodes the SAG. Thus, the new terminology MMTV sag has been proposed for this gene. Transfection experiments suggest that the expression of MMTV sag is tightly controlled, probably by a negative acting factor encoded within the open reading frame. Furthermore, a pronounced IL-4 effect is seen in the functional detection of the transfected Mtv-7 sag. Since this lymphokine does not influence the mRNA level of the endogenous or transfected MMTV genes, it is likely that it exerts its effect by increasing transcription of MHC class II genes, whose products are required for functional detection of Mls. We have identified one mouse strain, MA/MyJ, which has an Mls-1 phenotype but does not contain Mtv-7. The SAG activity of this strain was mapped to a new mammary tumor provirus, Mtv-43, not seen in other inbred strains. Sequence analyses revealed that the predicted amino acid sequences of the Mtv-7 and the Mtv-43 sag genes are very similar. This is particularly striking in the C-terminus, where all other MMTV sag sequences differ 100%. Thus, this region of the molecule seems to control the V beta specificity of SAG molecules. It is likely that the SAG expression provides an advantage for the infectious MMTV, probably by facilitating its transmission by T cells from the site of primary residence in the gut to its final destination, the mammary glands.

Allostimulatory analysis of a newly-defined and widely-distributed Mls superantigen

We previously noted that Mlsa,c C58/J responder cells proliferated unexpectedly to H-2k-compatible Mlsa or Mlsc prototypic stimulator cells in a primary mixed lymphocyte reaction. The present investigation was performed to evaluate whether the response of C58/J T cells to these H-2- and Mls-compatible stimulator cells could functionally identify a newly-defined member of the Mls superantigen family through its allostimulatory ability. We observed that C58/J responder cells also proliferated when cultured with H-2-compatible prototypic Mls(null), Mlsb (nonstimulatory), or Mlsa,c splenic stimulator cells. The widely distributed nature of the non-MHC ligand recognized by C58/J T cells is indicated by the finding that 11 of 12 H-2k inbred mouse strains clearly expressed this specificity. A gradient of stimulatory capacity from low to high across this newly-defined non-MHC difference was detected with splenocytes from these different inbred mouse strains. The Mls(a,c) genetic composition of C58/J was confirmed by the observation that crossing C58/J with parental B10.BR (responsive to both Mlsa and Mlsc determinants) generated F1 progeny that were unresponsive to H-2k-compatible Mlsa, Mlsc, or Mls(a,c) stimulator cells. Like prototypic Mlsa and Mlsc, the non-MHC specificity recognized by C58/J responder cells, termed Mlsf, was particularly sensitive to radiation (versus mitomycin C) treatment of the stimulator cells, was greatly augmented after anti-IgD activation of splenic stimulator cells, was blocked with anti-MHC class II antibody, and was effectively presented by phenotypically normal female but not B cell-defective xid+ male CBA/N F1 stimulator cells.

Linkage of Mls genes to endogenous mammary tumour viruses of inbred mice

T cells that recognize self antigen are clonally deleted in the thymus--a maturation process that occurs in the context of histocompatibility molecules and the T-cell receptor. The minor lymphocyte stimulation antigens (Mls) effect these deletions through interactions with the V beta portion of the T-cell receptor, thus mimicking bacterial 'superantigens'. Intrigued by the fact that each known Mls gene maps to the same chromosomal region as an endogenous mouse mammary tumour virus (Mtv), we reevaluated the linkage relationships between the two gene families. Here we report perfect concordance in inbred and recombinant inbred mice between the presence of four Mtv proviruses with the expression of Mls gene products. These data suggest a general model in which mammary tumour virus gene products themselves are the ligands that shape a considerable portion of the immunological repertoire of common laboratory mice.

Genetic analysis of the Mls system. Formal Mls typing of the commonly used inbred strains

In order to elucidate the biological role of minor lymphocyte stimulating (Mls) gene products, we have been investigating the fundamental immunogenetic characteristics of the Mls system. In this report, we describe the distribution of stimulatory Mls products, Mlsa and Mlsc, in a panel of laboratory inbred strains based on the response pattern of H-2-compatible naive T-cell populations as well as monospecific Mlsa- or Mlsc-reactive T-cell clones. In addition, the expression of four different T-cell receptor (Tcr) b-V segment Tcrb-V3, -V6, -V8.1, and -V9, which were recently reported to be associated with T-cell recognition of Mls gene products in these strains, was examined. The results indicate that the majority of commonly used laboratory strains including those originally typed as Mlsa are also expressing Mlsc determinants and that very few independent inbred strains are non-Mlsc. Moreover, the pattern of Tcrb-V expression in spleen as well as in thymus suggests that the association between Mls expression and clonal deletion of self Mls-reactive T cells appears to be the general rule in inbred strains. Based on these results, implications for the nondetectable Mls-like gene products in other species besides the mouse are discussed.

The staphylococcal enterotoxins and their relatives

Staphylococcal enterotoxins and a group of related proteins made by Streptococci cause food poisoning and shock in man and animals. These proteins share an ability to bind to human and mouse major histocompatibility complex proteins. The complex ligand so formed has specificity for a particular part of T cell receptors, V beta, and by engaging V beta can stimulate many T cells. It is likely that some or all of the pathological effects of these toxins are caused by their ability to activate quickly so many T cells. It is also possible that encounters with such toxins have caused mice, at least, to evolve mechanisms for varying their T cell V beta repertoires, such that they are less susceptible to attack by the toxins.

Analysis of Mlsc genetics. A novel instance of genetic redundancy

The identity of the self determinants involved in the selection of the T cell repertoire has been a matter of considerable interest. In addition to the apparent critical role of MHC gene products, accumulated experimental results indicate the importance of non-MHC gene products in T cell repertoire selection. In particular, murine Mlsa and Mlsc determinants have been shown to be highly stimulatory to allogeneic T cells and to be involved in the negative selection (elimination) of self-reactive T cells expressing selected TCR V beta segments. In this work, a unique phenomenon of genetic redundancy is described in the control of Mlsc expression: Mlsc appears to be controlled by at least two unlinked loci, and the product of either one of these loci is sufficient to evoke Mlsc-specific T cell response and to act as a ligand in the deletion of self Mlsc-reactive V beta 3+ T cells. Based on these findings, we propose a possible explanation for the fact that Mls-like genes or gene products have not been identified in other species such as man.

Multi-gene/allele control of Mlsb of CBA/H

Festenstein originally described the Mls locus as a single dominant autosomal gene with four alleles which mapped in the 13th linkage group of chromosome 1. We subsequently presented evidence indicating that the mixed leukocyte reaction (MLR) stimulatory products of DBA/2 and CBA/J were controlled by two independently segregating Mls loci and that Mls of C3H was in fact a composite of three independently segregating loci. Recently, Mlsd of CBA/J was shown to be composed of Mlsa of AKR and a product on C3H, which was presumed to be Mlsc. Based on strain distributions, this product cannot be encoded by the Mlsc originally defined by Festenstein. In the present report, three Mls specificities of CBA/H (Mlsb) are defined. Based on the strain distribution, we postulate that these specificities are controlled by three loci, three alleles/locus, or by some combination of the preceding two possibilities.

The V beta-specific superantigen staphylococcal enterotoxin B: stimulation of mature T cells and clonal deletion in neonatal mice

Staphylococcal enterotoxin B is known to be a powerful T cell stimulant in mouse and man. In this paper we show that, for mice, this is because the protein in association with major histocompatibility complex class II molecules stimulates virtually all T cells bearing V beta 3 and V beta 8.1, 8.2, and 8.3, and few others. Neonatal mice given the enterotoxin eliminate all mature, and some immature, T cells bearing these V beta s, demonstrating that tolerance to exogenously administered antigen can be caused by clonal deletion of reactive T cells. The enterotoxin shares these "superantigenic" properties with known self-antigens in mice, Mls-1a and Mls-2a, and a B cell-derived product, a shared property that is unlikely to be coincidental or inconsequential.

Analysis of specificity for antigen, Mls, and allogenic MHC by transfer of T-cell receptor alpha- and beta-chain genes

The majority of peripheral T lymphocytes bear cell-surface antigen receptors comprised of a disulphide-linked alpha beta dimer. In an immune response, this receptor endows T cells with specificities for foreign antigenic protein fragments bound to cell surface glycoproteins encoded in the major histocompatibility complex (MHC). At a high frequency (greater than 1%), the same population of T lymphocytes responds to allogeneic MHC glycoproteins, or to differences at other genetic loci termed Mls, in conjunction with MHC. The alpha beta-antigen receptor has been implicated in alloreactivity and Mls reactivity. In fact, many monoclonal T-cell lines recognize a foreign protein fragment bound to self-MHC molecules and, in addition, recognize allogeneic MHC glycoproteins, an Mls-encoded determinant, or both. For at least one T-cell clone, a monoclonal antibody directed against the alpha beta antigen receptor has been shown to block activation induced by either antigen-bound self-MHC or by allogeneic MHC. However, it remains to be demonstrated directly that a single alpha beta receptor can mediate antigen specificity, alloreactivity and Mls reactivity, a prerequisite to understanding the structural basis of these high-frequency cross-reactivities. To address this issue we have performed transfers of receptor chain genes from a multiple-reactive T-cell clone into an unrelated host T lymphocyte. We now demonstrate definitively that the genes encoding a single alpha beta-receptor chain pair can transfer the recognition of self-MHC molecules complexed with fragments of antigen, allogeneic MHC molecules, and an Mls-encoded determinant (presumably in conjunction with MHC). In this case the transfer of antigen specificity and alloreactivity requires a specific alpha beta-receptor chain combination, whereas Mls reactivity can be transferred with the beta-chain gene alone into a recipient expressing a randomly selected alpha-chain.

Multigene control of Mlsc

Festenstein originally described the Mls locus as a single dominant autosomal gene with four alleles which mapped in the 13th linkage group of chromosome 1. We subsequently presented evidence which indicated that the mixed leukocyte reaction stimulatory products of DBA/2 and CBA/J were controlled by two independently segregating Mls loci. Recently, Mlsd of CBA/J was shown to be composed of Mlsa of AKR and Mlsc of C3H. In the present report, classic segregation data is presented which indicates that Mlsc of C3H is controlled by three independently segregating loci. As defined by stimulatory patterns of numerous cell lines, we postulate the following: either one of the loci is shared with BALB.K, CE, C58, and partially with MA/MyJ, one is shared with CBA/H and CBA/J, and one is shared with BALB.K, CBA/J, and partially with CE; or the groups of shared determinants are controlled by different alleles of unique loci (or locus). In any event, Mlsc appears to be composed of at least three independently segregating loci; the number of alleles/locus is being investigated. In addition, C3H was stimulated by BALB.K (both were recently postulated to be Mlsc); this epitope was shared with CBA/J, CBA/H, AKR/Cum, Ma/MyJ, and C58/J.

Neonatal tolerance induction to Mlsa. I. Tolerance to Mlsa is restricted by shared MHC determinants

In this paper we have examined the influence of MHC (major histocompatibility complex) on neonatal tolerance to Mlsa (minor lymphocyte stimulating). By employing a novel approach we have shown that tolerance to Mlsa is restricted by shared MHC determinants. Thus, neonatal Mlsb mice, injected at birth with spleen cells from Mlsa mice, were tested as adults for Mlsa specific responses by interleukin-2 limiting dilution analysis, a technique which allows us to discriminate between responses to MHC + Mlsa and to MHC alone. Tolerance to Mlsa was in the context of any MHC type examined--donor, host, and third-party MHC products. These results show that tolerance to Mlsa is restricted by shared MHC determinants and extend previous studies indicating that activation of Mlsa responses is similarly restricted.

Neonatal tolerance induction to Mlsa. II. T cells induce tolerance to Mlsa

We have investigated the ability of murine T cell lines to induce neonatal tolerance to Mlsa (minor lymphocyte stimulating). Mlsb mice were injected within 24 hr of birth with MHC (major histocompatibility complex) identical T cell lines generated by culturing responders from Mlsa strains with stimulators from Mlsb strains. Injected mice were tested at 6 to 8 weeks of age for responses in either primary mixed leukocyte reaction or IL-2 limiting dilution analysis. Mlsa specific responses by injected tolerant mice relative to noninjected controls were reduced by 92-98% in MLR and by 2- to 10-fold in IL-2 LDA. In contrast, responses against third-party MHC antigens by either the injected or the noninjected mice were identical. Fifty percent of all mice injected with the T cell lines were tolerant to Mlsa. These results strongly suggest that murine T cells express the Mlsa gene product.

Preferential expression of the T-cell receptor V beta 3 gene by Mlsc reactive T cells

The precursor frequency of T cells specific for any given foreign antigen is, in general, extremely low. Prominent exceptions to this rule are the T cells that are specific for foreign major histocompatibility complex (MHC) products or for products of the minor lymphocyte stimulatory (Mls) genes in the mouse which are present at high frequencies. Here, we report a striking overlap or cross-reactivity between the T cells specific for the protein antigen pigeon cytochrome c in association with Ek alpha Ek beta and the set of T cells specific for Mlsc products. In addition, we demonstrate that the basis for this overlap is the predominant expression of one T-cell receptor (TCR) V beta gene, V beta 3, by T cells that recognize Mlsc products. These results indicate the importance of specific TCR alpha beta dimers in the recognition of Mlsc products and that positive or negative selection of T cells specific for Mls self-determinants may selectively alter the repertoire of T cells available for MHC-restricted recognition of foreign antigens.

Self-tolerance alters T-cell receptor expression in an antigen-specific MHC restricted immune response

The influence of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) gene products on the T-lymphocyte alpha beta receptor (TCR) repertoire is well documented, but how specificity is also generated for a diverse array of foreign peptide antigens is unknown. One proposed mechanism is that the TCR repertoire is selected by the recognition of processed self-antigens bound to MHC molecules. Here, we examine the influence of non-MHC-encoded self-antigens on the TCR repertoire expressed in an antigen-specific immune response. Most pigeon cytochrome c-specific, Ek alpha Ek beta (Ek) Ia-restricted T cells from B10.A mice express a product of the V alpha 11 gene family in association with a V beta 3 gene-encoded protein. We therefore examined V alpha 11 and V beta 3 gene expression in cytochrome c-specific T-cell lines derived from various mouse strains with different non-MHC genetic backgrounds. T cells from several strains failed to express any V beta 3 due to tolerance induced by Mlsc-encoded self-antigens. Variable levels of V alpha 11 messenger RNA (mRNA) were expressed by antigen-specific T cells from all the strains. In one strain V beta 3 was expressed in the relative absence of V alpha 11. These results directly demonstrate that self-tolerance alters TCR gene usage in the immune response to a foreign antigen, and indicate that TCR V alpha and V beta proteins may, in part, be independently selected.

The T-cell repertoire is heavily influenced by tolerance to polymorphic self-antigens

T cells with V beta 3+ alpha beta receptors are deleted by self-tolerance in mice with particular major histocompatibility complex/self-antigen combinations. This also occurs for other V beta elements. Polymorphism in the major histocompatibility complex and/or the self-antigens that cause massive deletion of T cells using particular V beta elements may be maintained by the need to balance the advantage of a diverse T-cell repertoire against the potential involvement of those elements in autoimmune disease.

The expression of Mlsc determinants on Mlsa, Mlsb, and Mlsx prototypic strains

In the mouse system, specific determinants other than major histocompatibility complex (MHC) gene products are capable of inducing strong primary proliferative responses in naive T cells. These determinants are encoded by at least two gene loci designated as minor lymphocyte stimulatory (Mls) loci. In order to elucidate the biological role of the Mls system, an effort has been initiated to clarify the fundamental immunogenetic characteristics of the Mls system. In this report, we describe the unexpected finding that Mlsc determinants are expressed on splenocytes of strains including those which have been used as prototypic examples of three other Mls types: Mlsa (DBA/2, DBA/1), Mlsb (BALB/c), and Mlsx (PL/J). The expression of Mlsc by these strains was demonstrated both by the response patterns of unprimed T cells from MHC-identical inbred or F1 hybrid strains and by the responses of a panel of Mls-specific T-cell clones. The experimental results reported here also suggest that the expression of Mls determinants may be influenced by multiple other genes, including MHC-linked genes.

Down-regulation of cytotoxic T lymphocyte generation by two distinct suppressor-cell systems

Two distinct suppressor systems have been described that are capable of down-regulating in vivo generation of cytotoxic T cells directed toward haptenaltered self-antigens. One system, induced by hapten, involves three T cells that others have shown to function sequentially to suppress DTH. The initiator of this cascade is a T cell that is readily induced in spleens of mice injected intravenously with syngenic membrane-coupled hapten. This Ts, when triggered by the same syngeneic membrane-coupled hapten that induced it, elaborates a factor. The other two Ts arise in lymph nodes and spleens of mice painted epidermally with hapten. One of the two Ts in this set is readily armed by the factor of the first Ts. The factor confers its specificity and genetic restriction upon the accepting Ts. The latter, when properly triggered, makes a factor that is taken up by its companion Ts, which actually suppresses by way of a nonspecific factor. Whereas this Ts cascade is operative at the efferent limb of DTH, it mediates suppression only at the afferent phase of the CTL response. A distinctly different suppressor system is induced by minor locus (Mls) antigen. When Mlsd lymphoid cells are injected intravenously into Mlsc-possessing mice, an Lyt-1+ T-suppressor cell is generated that can be found in the spleen as well as among peritoneal exudate cells. This Ts interacts with macrophages to accomplish nonspecific suppression of the CTL response that is detectable both in vivo as well as in vitro. A Ts soluble product has been found to be effective to suppress CTL generation in vitro only when macrophages are present in culture. The macrophage that accomplishes suppression is I-A-. Although the afferent limb of the CTL response is down-regulated by this suppressor system, our in vitro culturing system is so structured as to make the helper T cell inactive. Thus, the mechanism of suppression must be oriented to the other early participants in the response, namely, precursor CTL, helper and differentiation factors, and/or the antigen-presenting cell.

T-cell receptor V beta use predicts reactivity and tolerance to Mlsa-encoded antigens

T lymphocytes reactive with the product of the Mlsa-allele of the minor lymphocyte stimulating (Mls) locus use a predominant T-cell receptor beta-chain variable gene segment (V beta 6). Such V beta 6-bearing T cells are selectively eliminated in the thymus of Mlsa-bearing mice, consistent with a model in which tolerance to self antigens is achieved by clonal deletion.

Self-tolerance eliminates T cells specific for Mls-modified products of the major histocompatibility complex

In mice the product of the Mlsa locus is an unusual antigen capable of interaction with certain products of the major histocompatibility locus (MHC) to form a ligand for a large portion of the T-cell alpha/beta receptor repertoire, including nearly all receptors that use V beta 8.1. The presence of Mlsa/MHC during T-cell development results in the deletion of T cells that express V beta 8.1, documenting the importance of clonal deletion in establishing tolerance to self antigens.

Mls allo-determinants are recognized in an MHC class II antigen-dependent but unrestricted fashion by a discrete set of T cells

Blocking studies carried out with anti-H-2 class II antigen antibodies show that H-2 class II molecules are intimately involved in the recognition of Mlsa determinants by unprimed, specifically responsive T cells. The blocking of the anti-Mlsa response by these antibodies were not due to inhibition of IL-1 production by H-2 class II antigen positive macrophages. A strain analysis indicates that the response to Mlsa is regulated by H-2-linked genes and that this effect is exerted at the level of the stimulator cells; however, the response to Mls epitopes does not appear to be H-2 restricted. Finally, the ability of spleen cells from Mls-incompatible mice to induce a state of Mls-specific, clonal deletion type tolerance by neonatal injection, shows that Mls determinants exist in qualitatively allelic forms and suggests that these determinants are recognized by specific clones of T cells.

Mlsa determinants: relationship to Fc gamma receptor and tissue distribution

We have analysed the genetic relationship between Mlsa and Fc gamma R in mice. Using the Fc gamma R-specific DNA probes, we were unable to detect a restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) which is consistent in DNA derived from Mlsa strains and which differed from that of Mlsb strains, while we could see a polymorphism that distinguishes Ly17.1 from Ly17.2, alleles of the Fc gamma R. These results strongly suggest that Mlsa is neither a product of the alpha Fc gamma R nor of the beta Fc gamma R gene. Furthermore, we have re-examined the tissue distribution of Mlsa determinants using a major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II antigen-positive T-cell tumour as well as a pure population of bone marrow derived macrophages of Mlsa genotype. Both these cell types were recognized to varying degrees by alloreactive cells; however, none of them expressed functionally detectable Mlsa determinants. We conclude from our studies that Mlsa is a highly stimulatory self peptide that is exclusively expressed in B cells.

A comment on H-2-restricted T cell recognition of Mls determinants: a question of perspective

Data presented here addressed the question of whether T lymphocyte recognition of Mls determinants is MHC restricted. Using isolated T cell blasts from primary MLCs involving H-2-identical, Mls-disparate strain combinations as responding cell populations in secondary MLCs, and measuring their responses against fresh stimulating cells from different strains, has permitted the study of reactions towards Mls determinants in the presence of MHC antigenic differences. Results strongly suggest that recognition of Mlsc (Mls-2 locus) determinants is H-2 restricted. In contrast, there is still little evidence that the recognition of Mlsa (Mls-1 locus) determinants is H-2 restricted. Furthermore, data are also presented which refute the notion that different H-2 haplotypes possess different abilities to present Mlsa determinants to responding T cells.

Augmented in vitro presentation of Mls determinants after anti-immunoglobulin-induced B cell activation: ontogeny and role of purified B cells

Murine splenocytes which contained B cells activated by in vivo exposure to affinity-purified goat anti-mouse IgD (GaMD) antibody were utilized to present major histocompatibility complex (MHC) and non-MHC minor lymphocyte-stimulating (Mlsa) determinants in a primary mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR). As the time in hours after in vivo exposure to GaMD increased, splenocytes from adult mice showed a co-ordinate increase in cell size, expression of public and private MHC class II antigenic determinants and MHC and Mlsa antigen-presenting capacity. This augmented alloantigen-presenting capacity was demonstrable with either irradiated or mitomycin C-treated adult splenocytes. In contrast, GaMD-treated neonatal splenocytes from 10-day-old mice demonstrated no significantly increased class II expression or enhanced MHC stimulatory capacity, but nevertheless triggered augmented responder cell proliferation across an Mlsa barrier. Thus, increased class II expression or presenting capacity may not be required for an augmentation in splenocyte Mls-stimulating ability to occur. In vitro exposure of T cell-depleted splenocytes or highly purified small resting B cells to GaMD or lipopolysaccharide (LPS) induced a substantially increased ability in those populations to present MHC and Mlsa antigens in a primary MLR. Hence in vivo or in vitro activation of B lymphocytes in a stimulator cell population may yield more effective presentation of MHC and non-MHC determinants.

Mls determinants and anti-Mls receptors

We review evidence from this laboratory that T cell recognition of Mlsa determinants is not controlled solely by the alpha-beta T cell receptor (TcR) molecule. We propose a model in which Mlsa recognition reflects a receptor-ligand interaction between two sets of complementary accessory molecules, one molecule (Mlsa) being expressed on B cells and the other (the anti-Mlsa receptor) on T cells; this interaction augments recognition of self class II molecules by the TcR. The biological role of Mls molecules might be to facilitate physiological T-B interaction.

Evidence for a histocompatibility locus probably linked to but distinct from Mls and H-25

BALB/c (Mlsb) and BALB.D2-Mlsa strains of mice, both H-2d, are congenic and differ for the Mls locus (and linked genes) located on chromosome 1. The BALB.D2-Mlsa strain was obtained by introducing the Mlsa allele of DBA/2 mice into BALB/c mice. In previous studies we showed that BALB.D2-Mlsa recipients reject, relatively rapidly, all skin grafts from BALB/c donors. We and other groups have questioned whether the rejections observed were indeed due to the incompatibility for Mlsb products or for products of a histocompatibility (non-H-2) locus linked to, but distinct from, Mlsb. To answer this question, several hybrids carrying either Mlsa or Mlsb in various genetic contexts were grafted with skin from Mls-compatible BALB/c or BALB.D2-Mlsa donors; in the genetic combinations selected, any rejection which might occur would reflect the effects of a non-Mls incompatibility between BALB/c and BALB.D2-Mlsa strains. In certain of the donor-recipient combinations studied, the skin grafts were tolerated for greater than 200 days, but a relatively rapid rejection of BALB/c skin grafts was observed in (B10.D2 x BALB.D2-Mlsa)F1 and (B10.BR x BALB. D2-Mlsa)F1 hybrid recipients. These results indicated that in addition to Mls, the BALB/c and BALB.D2-Mlsa strains differ for at least one other non-H-2 histocompatibility locus. The possible involvement of H-25 was then investigated. Indeed, disparity for H-25, which maps on chromosome 1 close to Mls, can induce relatively rapid skin graft rejection. The H-25 allele of the DBA/2 strain has not been defined: we considered, therefore, that BALB/c and DBA/2 could be disparate at the H-25 locus, and that H-25 (transmitted by DBA/2 to the BALB.D2-Mlsa strain, together with the Mlsa allele) could be responsible for the skin graft rejection we observed. Our results showed, however, that DBA/2, BALB/c and BALB.D2-Mlsa strains of mice all share the H-25c allele; they therefore ruled out a role for H-25 incompatibility in the skin graft rejections we observed, and indicated that these rejections are due to the effects of a yet undefined histocompatibility locus (locus 'x'), probably linked to, but distinct from, the Mls locus. Further experiments showed that the histocompatibility effect of locus 'x' cumulates with that exhibited by Mlsb (or by a putative histocompatibility locus linked to Mlsb).

Genetic complexity of Mls

For almost 20 years, little new has been described for Mls or the products it encodes. In the present report, data is presented which indicate that either the number of loci or the number of alleles per locus that control Mls-like products is much larger than the two-locus model or five allele-model presently envisaged.

Genetic relationships of Mlsa among polymorphic loci on distal mouse chromosome 1

The segregation of Mlsa with respect to genes localized distally on mouse chromosome 1 was examined in two sets of recombinant inbred (RI) strains. In order to localize Mlsa, a linkage map based on analysis of both interspecific backcross mice and multiple sets of RI strains was utilized: (centromere) - Ren-1,2 - 10 centimorgans (cM) - At-3 - 8cM-Apo-A2/Ly-17 - 2cM - Spna-1 - 4cM - Akp-1 - (telomere). The Mlsa allele was mapped to a region that extended just centromeric of Ly-17 (one crossover in 40 RI strains) to just telomeric of Spna-1 (no crossover in 40 RI strains). The identification of multiple polymorphic loci in the region of Mlsa should allow precise gene localization and assist in efforts to clone this gene.

A reappraisal of Mls genetics

Although the minor lymphocyte stimulatory locus (Mls) system was originally described as a single-locus, multiple-allelic system, allelism among the genes which encode Mlsa, Mlsc and Mlsd has not been demonstrated formally. In this report, genetic linkage between genes encoding Mlsa and Mlsc was studied by testing responses of unprimed T cells, as well as Mlsa- and Mlsc-specific T cell clones, to the progeny of (AKR/J x C3H/HeJ) F1 x B10.BR [(Mlsa x Mlsc)F1 x Mlsb] crosses. In addition, the configuration of Mls genes expressed by CBA/J (Mlsd) was evaluated by examining the response pattern of a panel of Mlsd-specific clones to (CBA/J x B10.BR)F1 x B10.BR stimulators. Results of these segregation analyses indicated that the Mls system is composed of at least two independent and unlinked genes which encode, respectively, the determinants identified as Mlsa and Mlsc.

Mls determinants recognized by T cells

The relationship among different minor lymphocyte stimulatory locus (Mls) determinants, Mlsa, Mlsb, Mlsc and Mlsd, remains unclear. Because of the high degree of cross-reactivity between Mlsa and Mlsd determinants, the weak stimulatory capacity of Mlsc, and the generally non-stimulatory nature of Mlsb, some investigators have recently suggested that Mls is composed of only a single expressed allele originally defined as the a and d alleles. In order to clarify the nature of Mls determinants, T cell clones positively selected for reactivity to the three stimulatory Mls determinants, Mlsa, Mlsc and Mlsd, were generated and their specificities defined by extensive genetic studies. The response pattern of these Mls-specific clones as well as the results of primary mixed lymphocyte responses indicated that: (i) Mlsa and Mlsc determinants recognized by T cells are distinct, demonstrating that polymorphism does exist within the Mls system; and (ii) Mlsd is not an independent Mls type since Mlsd determinants are composed of Mlsa and Mlsc determinants and anti-Mlsd T cell responses are, in fact, the sum of anti-Mlsa and anti-Mlsc responses.

The relationship of Mlsx to Mlsc

Among T cell clones with specificity for cow insulin and autologous class II MHC products, a significant number displayed interesting patterns of alloreactivity to non-MHC antigens. Four clones are described in this report. One is a typical Mlsa-reactive clone, while the other three proliferate to a variety of allogeneic spleen cells with reportedly different Mls phenotypes. These include PL/J stimulator cells, designated Mlsx, all strains reported to be Mlsc, and several strains previously typed as Mlsa. Little is known about Mlsx except that it does not appear to be cross-reactive with Mlsa. In this report, therefore, we attempt to investigate the reasons why these clones seem to be stimulated by a variety of different Mls phenotypes. Our conclusions are, first, that some of the strains previously typed as Mlsa may actually express a second Mls product, either c or x, in a manner analogous to the CBA/J strain (which expresses both Mlsa and Mlsc), and second, that Mlsc and Mlsx are cross-reactive. In preliminary experiments, we investigate the genetic relationship between Mlsc and Mlsx by analysis of backcrosses, and the extent of cross-reactive recognition of Mlsc and Mlsx by raising T cell clones which recognize one but not the other. Our preliminary conclusion is that Mlsc and Mlsx are cross-reactive, but represent distinct gene products.

Establishment of a molecular genetic map of distal mouse chromosome 1: further definition of a conserved linkage group syntenic with human chromosome 1q

A linkage map of distal mouse chromosome 1 was constructed by restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis of DNAs from seven sets of recombinant inbred (RI) strains. The data obtained with seven probes on Southern hybridization combined with data from previous studies suggest the gene order Cfh, Pep-3/Ren-1,2, Ly-5, Lamb-2, At-3, Apoa-2/Ly-17,Spna-1. These results confirm and extend analyses of a large linkage group which includes genes present on a 20-30 cM span of mouse chromosome 1 and those localized to human chromosome 1q21-32. Moreover, the data indicate similar relative positions of human and mouse complement receptor-related genes REN, CD45, LAMB2, AT3, APOA2, and SPTA. These results suggest that mouse gene analyses may help in detailed mapping of human genes within such a syntenic group.

Isolation of antigen-specific T cell clones from nonresponder mice

The mechanisms responsible for major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-linked unresponsiveness are still poorly understood. Here we examine the cellular events that follow when B10. A mice are immunized with cow insulin, an antigen to which they make no apparent immunologic response. Despite the fact that there is no detectable antibody or T cell proliferative response to cow insulin, we have been able to clone out responding T cells after priming and restimulating in vitro with this "nonimmunogenic" antigen. These cells are L3T4+, and co-recognize specific antigen and class II MHC gene products. The data demonstrate that "nonresponder" mice to cow insulin have both the capacity to present antigen and T cells capable of recognizing that antigen. The diversity within this population was investigated by analyzing various parameters of cellular activation. These include fine specificity of both antigen and MHC recognition, as well as recognition of allogeneic MHC and M1s determinants. In addition, the antigen-presenting cell requirements were studied. The results demonstrate that this population comprise a surprisingly heterogeneous group in terms of its repertoire of receptors.

Mls is not a single gene, allelic system. Different stimulatory Mls determinants are the products of at least two nonallelic, unlinked genes

Mls determinants share with MHC products the unique property of stimulating T cells at extraordinarily high precursor frequencies. The Mls system was originally described as a single locus on chromosome 1, with four alleles, Mlsa, Mlsb, Mlsc, and Mlsd, that encode polymorphic cell surface structures. However, the fundamental issues of polymorphism and allelism in the Mls system remain controversial. To clarify these questions, a formal segregation analysis of the genes encoding Mlsa and Mlsc determinants was carried out by testing the capacity of spleen cells from progeny of (Mlsa X Mlsc)F1 X Mlsb breedings to stimulate responses by unprimed T cells and by Mlsa- and Mlsc-specific cloned T cells. The results of this analysis indicated that the gene encoding Mlsa determinants is neither allelic to nor linked to the gene encoding Mlsc determinants. Together with previous findings, these results also suggest that another strongly stimulatory type, Mlsd, in fact results from the independent expression of unlinked Mlsa and Mlsc gene products. Based on these observations, it is concluded that, contrary to conventional concepts, the stimulatory phenotypes designated as Mlsa, Mlsc, and Mlsd can be accounted for by the independent expression of the products of at least two unlinked gene loci.