Induction of long-term H-Y-specific tolerance in female mice given male lymphoid cells while transiently depleted of CD4+ or CD8+ T cells

Memory programming in CD8(+) T-cell differentiation is intrinsic and is not determined by CD4 help

CD8⁺ T cells activated without CD4⁺ T-cell help are impaired in memory expansion. To understand the underlying cellular mechanism, here we track the dynamics of helper-deficient CD8⁺ T-cell response to a minor histocompatibility antigen by phenotypic and in vivo imaging analyses. Helper-deficient CD8⁺ T cells show reduced burst expansion, rapid peripheral egress, delayed antigen clearance and continuous activation, and are eventually exhausted. Contrary to the general consensus that CD4 help encodes memory programmes in CD8⁺ T cells and helper-deficient CD8⁺ T cells are abortive, these cells can differentiate into effectors and memory precursors. Importantly, accelerating antigen clearance or simply increasing the burst effector size enables generation of memory cells by CD8⁺ T cells, regardless of CD4 help. These results suggest that the memory programme is CD8⁺ T-cell-intrinsic, and provide insight into the role of CD4 help in CD8⁺ T-cell responses.

Persistent antigen stimulation can cause exhaustion and unresponsiveness of CD8 cells, impairing the immune response. Here the authors show that increasing the number of CD8 cells, decreasing the antigen load or providing CD4 help can overcome the exhaustion and establish a memory response.

Ig gene-like molecule CD31 plays a nonredundant role in the regulation of T-cell immunity and tolerance

CD31 is an Ig-like molecule expressed by leukocytes and endothelial cells with an established role in the regulation of leukocyte trafficking. Despite genetic deletion of CD31 being associated with exacerbation of T cell-mediated autoimmunity, the contribution of this molecule to T-cell responses is largely unknown. Here we report that tumor and allograft rejection are significantly enhanced in CD31-deficient mice, which are also resistant to tolerance induction. We propose that these effects are dependent on an as yet unrecognized role for CD31-mediated homophilic interactions between T cells and antigen-presenting cells (APCs) during priming. We show that loss of CD31 interactions leads to enhanced primary clonal expansion, increased killing capacity, and diminished regulatory functions by T cells. Immunomodulation by CD31 signals correlates with a partial inhibition of proximal T-cell receptor (TCR) signaling, specifically Zap-70 phosphorylation. However, CD31-deficient mice do not develop autoimmunity due to increased T-cell death following activation, and we show that CD31 triggering induces Erk-mediated prosurvival activity in T cells either in conjunction with TCR signaling or autonomously. We conclude that CD31 functions as a nonredundant comodulator of T-cell responses, which specializes in sizing the ensuing immune response by setting the threshold for T-cell activation and tolerance, while preventing memory T-cell death.

Ethylenecarbodiimide-treated splenocytes carrying male CD4 epitopes confer histocompatibility Y chromosome antigen transplant protection by inhibiting CD154 upregulation

In humans and certain strains of laboratory mice, male tissue is recognized as nonself and destroyed by the female immune system via recognition of histocompatibility Y chromosome Ag (Hya). Male tissue destruction is thought to be accomplished by CTLs in a helper-dependent manner. We show that graft protection induced with the immunodominant Hya-encoded CD4 epitope (Dby) attached to female splenic leukocytes (Dby-SPs) with the chemical cross-linker ethylenecarbodiimide significantly, and often indefinitely, prolongs the survival of male skin graft transplants in an Ag-specific manner. In contrast, treatments with the Hya CD8 epitopes (Uty-/Smcy-SPs) failed to prolong graft survival. Dby-SP-tolerized CD4(+) T cells fail to proliferate, secrete IFN-gamma, or effectively prime a CD8 response in recipients of male grafts. Ag-coupled splenocyte treatment is associated with defective CD40-CD40L interactions as demonstrated by the observation that CD4 cells from treated animals exhibit a defect in CD40L upregulation following in vitro Ag challenge. Furthermore, treatment with an agonistic anti-CD40 Ab at the time of transplantation abrogates protection from graft rejection. Interestingly, anti-CD40 treatment completely restores the function of Dby-specific CD4 cells but not Uty- or Smcy-specific CD8 cells.

Therapy with nonglycosaminoglycan-binding mutant CCL7: a novel strategy to limit allograft inflammation

Chemokines are immobilized by binding to glycosaminoglycans (GAGs). A non-GAG-binding mutant CCL7 (mtCCL7) was developed that retained its affinity for chemokine receptors. This mtCCL7 induced leukocyte chemotaxis in diffusion gradients but did not stimulate trans-endothelial migration (p<0.01). Unlike wild-type CCL7, mtCCL7 persisted in the circulation of BALB/c mice for more than 6 h and prevented leukocyte infiltration of skin isografts (p<0.05). Treatment with mtCCL7 marginally increased the survival of C57BL/6 to BALB/c skin allografts and reduced graft infiltration by CD3+ cells (p<0.05). Importantly, mtCCL7 promoted long-term (>40 day) graft survival following minor histocompatibility (HY) antigen mismatched C57BL/6 skin transplantation; control grafts were rejected by day 24. Treatment with mtCCL7 produced a significant decrease in the frequency of IFN-gamma producing donor-reactive splenic T cells, reduced CCR2 expression by circulating leukocytes for 6 h (p<0.01) and blocked the normal increase in affinity of alpha4beta1 integrins for VCAM-1 following transient chemokine stimulation. These data suggest that mtCCL7 persists in the circulation and reduces both specific T-cell priming and the capacity of circulating immune cells to respond to GAG-bound chemokine at sites of developing inflammation.

Cognate CD4 help is essential for the reactivation and expansion of CD8 memory T cells directed against the hematopoietic cell–specific dominant minor histocompatibility antigen, H60

In contrast to previous notions of the help-independency of memory CD8 T cells during secondary expansion, here we show that CD4 help is indispensable for the re-expansion of once-helped memory CD8 T cells, using a hematopoietic cell–specific dominant minor histocompatibility (H) antigen, H60, as a model antigen. H60-specific memory CD8 T cells generated during a helped primary response vigorously expanded only when rechallenged under helped conditions. The help requirement for an optimal secondary response was confirmed by a reduction in peak size by CD4 depletion, and was reproduced after skin transplantation. Helpless conditions or noncognate separate help during the secondary response resulted in a significant reduction in the peak size and different response kinetics. Providing CD4 help again during a tertiary challenge restored robust memory expansion; however, the repeated deprivation of help further reduced clonal expansion. Adoptively transferred memory CD8 T cells did not proliferate in CD40L−/− hosts. In the CD40−/− hosts, marginal memory expansion was detected after priming with male H60 cells but was completely abolished by priming with peptide-loaded CD40−/− cells, suggesting the essential role of CD40 and CD40L in memory responses. These results provide insight into the control of minor H antigen-specific CD8 T-cell responses, to maximize the graft-versus-leukemia response.

Antisense targeting of cFLIP sensitizes activated T cells to undergo apoptosis and desensitizes responses to contact dermatitis

Contact dermatitis is the result of inflammatory responses mediated by hapten-specific activated CD8+ and CD4+ T cells. Activation-induced cell death (AICD) is a naturally occurring process regulating the resolution of T-cell responses through decreased expression of the antiapoptotic molecule cellular FLICE inhibitory protein (cFLIP). We show that targeting cFLIP expression in vitro and in vivo, with morpholino antisense applied systemically or topically in conjunction with antigen, sensitizes T cells to undergo "early" AICD resulting in tolerance. Analysis of antisense-treated CD8+ OT-1 splenocytes after co-culture with SIINFEKL-pulsed DCs showed apoptosis occurring in a dose-dependent manner with respect to cFLIP peptide-conjugated phosphorodiamidate morpholino oligomer (PPMO) concentration. A transplant acceptance model using male DO.11 donor cells and female BALB/c recipient mice showed that cFLIP antisense treatment could promote antigen tolerance. Hypersensitivity responses induced in mice by the epicutaneous application of the haptens FITC and oxazolone confirmed that topically applied cFLIP antisense could reduce inflammation. Treatment of the skin produced significant reduction in dermatitis and localized infiltration of lymphocytes. Moreover, the treatment was target- and antigen-specific, dose-dependent, and capable of inducing long-lived tolerance. These data suggest that the targeted expression of immune-regulating molecules is possible through the application of antisense to the skin.

Natural Regulation of Immunity to Minor Histocompatibility Antigens

MHC-matched hemopoietic stem cell transplantation is commonly used for the treatment of some forms of leukemia. Conditioning regimens before transplant act to reduce the burden of leukemic cells and the graft-vs-leukemia (GvL) effect can eliminate residual disease. The GvL effect results largely from the recognition of minor histocompatibility Ags by donor T cells on recipient tissues. These Ags are generally widely expressed and also provoke graft-vs-host (GvH) disease. Manipulation of immunity to promote GvL while curtailing GvH would greatly improve clinical outcome. To develop strategies that may achieve this, the parameters which control immunity to minor histocompatibility Ags need to be defined. In this study, we have analyzed responses to the mouse HY minor histocompatibility Ag using hemopoietic cell and skin grafts as surrogate GvL and GvH targets, respectively. We show that natural regulation of CD8 T cell responses to HY operates at multiple levels. First, CD4 T cell help is required for primary CD8 responses directed at hemopoietic cells. However, although CD4 T cells of H2(k) mouse strains recognize HY, they provide ineffective help associated with a proportion of recipients developing tolerance. This was further investigated using TCR-transgenic mice which revealed H2(k)-restricted HY-specific CD4 T cells are highly susceptible to regulation by CD25(+) regulatory T cells which expand in tolerant recipients. A second level of regulation, operating in the context of skin grafts, involves direct inhibition of CD8 T cell responses by CD94/NKG2 engagement of the nonclassical MHC class I molecule Qa1.

Examination of HY response: T cell expansion, immunodominance, and cross-priming revealed by HY tetramer analysis

We have applied MHC class I tetramers representing the two H2(b) MHC class I-restricted epitopes of the mouse male-specific minor transplantation Ag, HY, to directly determine the extent of expansion and immunodominance within the CD8+ T cell compartment following exposure to male tissue. Immunization with male bone marrow (BM), spleen, dendritic cells (DCs) and by skin graft led to rapid expansion of both specificities occupying up to >20% of the CD8+ T cell pool. At a high dose, whole BM or spleen were found to be more effective at stimulating the response than BM-derived DCs. In vivo, immunodominance within the responding cell population was only observed following chronic Ag stimulation, whereas epitope immunodominance was established rapidly following in vitro restimulation. Peptide affinity for the restricting MHC molecule was greater for the immunodominant epitope, suggesting that this might be a factor in the emergence of immunodominance. Using tetramers, we were able to directly visualize the cross-primed CD8+ HY response, but we did not find it to be the principal route for MHC class I presentation. Immunization with female spleen or DCs coated with the full complement of defined HY peptides, including the A(b)-restricted CD4+ Th cell determinant, failed to induce tetramer-reactive cells.

Persistence of physiological self antigen is required for the regulation of self tolerance

Endogenous Ag requirement for induction and maintenance of T cell tolerance has been extensively investigated in mice that express a transgenic Ag and/or its cognate transgenic TCR. In contrast, studies on tolerance for physiologically expressed self Ag and normal T cells are limited. Herein, we showed that the murine ovarian-specific ZP3 Ag is detectable from birth. Tolerance to ZP3 is detected in female relative to male mice. In comparison to males, 100-fold more ovarian peptide (pZP3) is required to elicit a comparable pathogenic response in females. Female tolerance to pZP3 was dependent on the presence of endogenous ovarian Ag, because neonatal ovariectomy converted the female response to that of males. Moreover, in female mice that were ovariectomized from the ages of 1-6 wk, the pZP3 responses were enhanced to the male level if ovaries were removed up to 7 days, but not 3 days, before adult challenge with pZP3. Thus, the physiologically expressed ZP3 Ag induces tolerance to pZP3, and the maintenance of tolerance is critically dependent on the continuous presence of the endogenous ovarian Ag. In contrast, exposure to endogenous ovarian Ag confined to the neonatal period is insufficient for the induction and maintenance of tolerance to ZP3.

Differentiation and functions of T cell subsets

The Tc1 and Tc2 subsets of CD8+ T effector cells secrete different patterns of cytokines, but have similar functions, including perforin- and Fas-dependent cytotoxicity, and induction of delayed type hypersensitivity (DTH) reactions involving oedema and granulocytic infiltration. The characteristic cytokines of Tc1 (gamma-interferon) and Tc2 (interleukins 4 and 5) are expressed in vivo during the DTH reaction. Tc1 cells that are deficient in cytokine synthesis also induce similar levels of DTH, supporting the lack of correlation between CD8+ T cell cytokine patterns and DTH. CD8+ T cells often produce lower cytokine levels than CD4 cells because the CD8 cells kill their antigen-presenting cells before full stimulation can occur. This effect can be counteracted by increasing the frequency of stimulation, or using perforin-deficient T cells. A multiparameter analysis of cytokine effects on CD8+ T cell differentiation has been initiated, on the basis of the principle that normal immune responses involve complex cytokine mixtures. All combinations of seven cytokines were tested. In some combinations, the combined effect could not have been predicted from individual cytokine functions. Conditions were identified in which each of interleukins 4, 10 and 12 could have opposite effects on CD8+ T cell differentiation.

Long-lasting CD8 T cell memory in the absence of CD4 T cells or B cells

The cellular basis of immunological memory has been a debated issue. It is not clear whether CD8 T cell memory is maintained by long-lived cells or by specific or nonspecific restimulation. Here, we have approached the question from a different angle, asking whether the cellular interactions that are required to maintain memory are the same as those necessary to activate cytotoxic T lymphocytes. We studied the CD8 memory response to the male antigen H-Y in mice deficient in CD4 cells, or B cells and found that memory in these mice was virtually unimpaired. These results suggest that CD8 memory is CD4 independent and that there is no requirement for long term retention of immune complexes on follicular dendritic cells, nor for B cells as antigen-presenting cells.

T cell tolerance and activation to a transgene-encoded tumor antigen

Much has been learned in recent years concerning the nature of tumor antigens recognized by T cells. To apply this knowledge clinically, the nature of the host response to individual and multiple tumor antigens has to be characterized. This will help to define the efficacy of immune surveillance and the immune status of the host following exposure to tumor antigens expressed on pre-neoplastic tissue. To approach these questions, we have developed a transgenic mouse which expresses the tumor-specific antigen P91A. The single amino acid substitution in P91A results in the expression of a new MHC class I (H-2Ld)-binding peptide. In transgenic tissue, the H-2Ld/P91A complex is expressed in isolation from other tumor-associated antigens, allowing definition of the immune response to a single defined tumor antigen, a situation closely analogous to events during tumorigenesis. We show that CD8+ T cell immune surveillance of P91A is ineffective without the introduction of a helper determinant operating through stimulation of CD4+ T cells. Recognition of the isolated P91A tumor antigen on normal tissue by CD8+ T cells is a tolerogenic process. Induction of T cell tolerance suggests tumor antigen-T cell interactions occurring during tumorigenesis may elicit T cell tolerance and hence confound some immunotherapeutic approaches.

Bone marrow-derived chimerism in non-irradiated, cyclosporin-treated rats receiving microvascularized limb transplants: evidence for donor-derived dendritic cells in recipient lymphoid tissues

Tolerance to donor transplantation antigens develops when recipients are made chimeric with donor bone marrow. To establish chimerism, the haemopoietic system of recipients typically is severely compromised. We report on a system in which chimerism develops without ablative therapies. Immunosuppression with cyclosporin A allowed the lower limb of a rat to be replaced by a microvascularized transplant from a fully allogeneic donor. Many donor-derived cells populated recipient lymph nodes and spleen, and most had the large size, irregular shape and strong major histocompatibility complex (MHC) class II expression that typify dendritic cells. Donor cells were not found in the macrophage-rich regions of lymphoid tissues, but instead occupied splenic white pulp and lymph node cortex. The donor cells were derived from radiosensitive marrow precursors, as chimerism was abolished if the grafted limb was irradiated, or if muscle and skin flaps devoid of bone were grafted. Donor cells were rare or not detectable in blood, thymus and liver. Whereas lymphoid chimerism was prominent following limb transfer, donor cells were not detected 1-2 weeks after an injection of two femur equivalents of a marrow suspension. We suggest that dendritic cells that undergo rapid turnover in lymphoid organs are replaced from allogeneic precursors in bone grafts. The combination of cyclosporin and vascularized bone provides a means for inducing chimerism in lymphoid tissues of non-irradiated recipients.

The pharmacology of immunosuppressant drugs in skin transplant rejection in mice and other rodents

1. Skin transplantation in rodents is a convenient, widely used method, particularly in mice. It is used as much as an indicator of immune responsiveness as for pharmacological studies. 2. Many differences exist in experimental protocols, both for transplantation and drug administration and in this review, the increase in graft survival time with respect to control times is used to indicate drug effects, in an attempt to account for these differences. 3. The mechanisms underlying skin graft rejection in rodents are described, emphasising the crucial role of both helper and effector T cells. 4. The pharmacology of clinically-used immunosuppressants, including CsA, FK506, rapamycin and purine or pyrimidine synthesis inhibitors, in rodent models of skin transplantation is reviewed. 5. The effects of other potential immunosuppressants and compounds modulating immune responses are described, including the effects of UV light and involvement of platelet-derived factors, prostaglandins and thromboxanes.