A parent-of-origin effect in two families with retinoblastoma is associated with a distinct splice mutation in the RB1 gene

Retinoblastoma caused by an RB1 variant with unusually low penetrance in a Danish family

Retinoblastoma is the most common eye cancer in children. It is caused by pathogenic alterations of both alleles of the tumor suppressor gene RB1. In heritable retinoblastoma, a constitutional RB1 variant predisposes the cells to tumor formation, and loss of the other allele is a prerequisite for the development of retinoblastoma. Heritable retinoblastoma is inherited in an autosomal dominant manner; however, the majority of cases are the result of a de novo pathogenic RB1 variant. Penetrance is usually high (>90%), but with marked inter-familial variability. In some families, penetrance is incomplete and family members who develop tumors tend to remain unilaterally affected. Moreover, some families with low penetrance also show a parent-of-origin effect. We describe a patient with unilateral retinoblastoma caused by a previously unreported likely pathogenic RB1 variant (c.1199T>C) that disrupts a highly conserved amino acid residue within the A-box functional domain. Segregation analysis showed that the variant had unusually low penetrance as nine non-affected family members carried the same variant. We emphasize the use of genetic analysis on tumor DNA for classifying the RB1 variant, and underline the challenges in clinical management and counseling of families carrying the specific RB1 variant.

An overview of RB1 transcript alterations detected during retinoblastoma genetic screening

Identification of pathogenic RB1 variants aids in the clinical management of families with retinoblastoma. We routinely screen DNA for RB1 variants, but transcript analysis can also be used for variant screening, and to help decide variant pathogenicity. DNA was screened by conformation analysis followed by Sanger sequencing. Large deletion/insertions were detected by polymorphism analysis, MLPA and quantitative-PCR. Methylation-specific PCR was used to detect hypermethylation. RNA screening was performed when a DNA pathogenic variant was missing, or to determine effects on splicing.Two hundred and thirteen small coding variants were predicted to affect splicing in 207 patients. Splice donor (sd) variants were nearly twice as frequent as splice acceptor (sa) with the most affected positions being sd + 1 and sa-1. Some missense and nonsense codons altered splicing, while some splice consensus variants did not. Large deletion/insertions can disrupt splicing, but RNA analysis showed that some of these are more complex than indicated by DNA testing. RNA screening found pathogenic variants in 53.8% of samples where DNA analysis did not. RB1 splicing is altered by changes at consensus splice sites, some missense and nonsense codons, deep intronic changes and large deletion/insertions. Common alternatively spliced transcripts may complicate analysis. An effective molecular screening strategy would include RNA analysis to help determine pathogenicity.

Familial retinoblastoma: variations in clinical presentation and management based on paternal versus maternal inheritance

BACKGROUND

Several studies have demonstrated the effect of parent-of-origin on retinoblastoma penetrance. The purpose of the current study was to assess differences in clinical presentation of paternally versus maternally inherited retinoblastoma.

METHODS

The clinical records of all children with familial retinoblastoma treated on a tertiary Ocular Oncology Service between December 1975 and May 2020 were reviewed retrospectively.

RESULTS

A total of 179 patients with familial retinoblastoma were included. Paternal inheritance (PI) was identified in 109 (61%) patients and maternal inheritance (MI) in 70 patients (39%). A comparison (PI vs MI) revealed PI patients were older at presentation (57.2 vs 24.4 months [P = 0.002]) with no difference in patient sex (53% females vs 57% males [P = 0.606]) or number of family members affected (3.2 vs 3.0 family members [P = 0.255]). PI patients had more advanced classification according to the International Classification of Retinoblastoma (ICRB) (group E: 31% vs 8% [P = 0.012)] and greater largest tumor in basal diameter (9.0 vs 6.2 mm [P = 0.040]) and thickness (5.6 vs 4.0 mm [P = 0.038]); they were also less likely to be located in the macula (40% vs 60% [P = 0.004]). There was no difference in tumor laterality (69% vs 64% bilaterality [P = 0.530]). PI patients required enucleation more frequently (34% vs 14% [P = 0.007]). There was no difference in need for plaque radiotherapy (P = 0.86) or chemotherapy (P = 0.85). One PI patient developed metastatic retinoblastoma, and there were no retinoblastoma-related deaths.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with paternally inherited retinoblastoma presented at an older age, with larger, more peripheral tumors and more advanced ICRB group, and were more likely to require enucleation compared to those with maternally inherited retinoblastoma.

RB1 gene mutations and genetic spectrum in retinoblastoma cases

The aim of the study was to investigate the frequency and types of mutations on the retinoblastoma gene (RB1 gene) in Turkish population. RB1 gene mutation analysis was performed in a total of 219 individuals (122 probands with retinoblastoma, 14 family members with retinoblastoma and 83 clinically healthy family members). All 27 exons and close intronic regions of the RB1 gene were sequenced for small deletions and insertions using both the Sanger sequencing or NGS methods, and the large deletions and duplications were investigated using the MLPA analysis and CNV algorithm. The bilateral/trilateral retinoblastoma rate was 66% in the study population. The general frequency of RB1 gene mutation in the germline of the patients with retinoblastoma was 41.9%. Approximately 51.5% of the patients were diagnosed earlier than 12 months old, and de novo mutation was found in 32.4% of the patients. Germline small genetic rearrangement mutations were detected in 78.9% of patients and LGRs were detected in 21.1% of patients. An association was detected between the eye color of the RB patients and RB1 mutations. 8 of the mutations detected in the RB1 gene were novel in the study.

Alternative RNA Splicing Defects in Pediatric Cancers: New Insights in Tumorigenesis and Potential Therapeutic Vulnerabilities

BACKGROUND

Compared to adult cancers, pediatric cancers are uniquely characterized by a genomically stable landscape and lower tumor mutational burden. However, alternative splicing, a global cellular process that produces different mRNA/protein isoforms from a single mRNA transcript, has been increasingly implicated in the development of pediatric cancers.

DESIGN

We review the current literature on the role of alternative splicing in adult cancer, cancer predisposition syndromes, and pediatric cancers. We also describe multiple splice variants identified in adult cancers and confirmed through comprehensive genomic profiling in our institutional cohort of rare, refractory and relapsed pediatric and adolescent young adult cancer patients. Finally, we summarize the contributions of alternative splicing events to neoantigens and chemoresistance and prospects for splicing-based therapies.

RESULTS

Published dysregulated splicing events can be categorized as exon inclusion, exon exclusion, splicing factor upregulation, or splice site alterations. We observe these phenomena in cancer predisposition syndromes (Lynch syndrome, Li-Fraumeni syndrome, CHEK2) and pediatric leukemia (B-ALL), sarcomas (Ewing sarcoma, rhabdomyosarcoma, osteosarcoma), retinoblastoma, Wilms tumor, and neuroblastoma. Within our institutional cohort, we demonstrate splice variants in key regulatory genes (CHEK2, TP53, PIK3R1, MDM2, KDM6A, NF1) that resulted in exon exclusion or splice site alterations, which were predicted to impact functional protein expression and promote tumorigenesis. Differentially spliced isoforms and splicing proteins also impact neoantigen creation and treatment resistance, such as imatinib or glucocorticoid regimens. Additionally, splice-altering strategies with the potential to change the therapeutic landscape of pediatric cancers include antisense oligonucleotides, adeno-associated virus gene transfers, and small molecule inhibitors.

CONCLUSIONS

Alternative splicing plays a critical role in the formation and growth of pediatric cancers, and our institutional cohort confirms and highlights the broad spectrum of affected genes in a variety of cancers. Further studies that elucidate the mechanisms of disease-inducing splicing events will contribute toward the development of novel therapeutics.

Parental Origin of the RB1 Gene Mutations in Families with Low Penetrance Hereditary Retinoblastoma

Simple Summary

Some families with hereditary retinoblastoma exhibit mild phenotype with low penetrance and variable expressivity, including complete absence of clinical signs of the disease in some carriers of the germline RB1 mutation. The identification of low-penetrance mutations in the RB1 gene and the study of their inheritance in pedigrees is contributing to understanding the mechanisms underlying the development of retinoblastoma with low penetrance. It is important both for further expansion of knowledge in the field of molecular genetics of retinoblastoma, and for competent genetic counseling and subsequent clinical management of families with this form of the disease. Our results support an assumption that parental origin of an RB1 mutation influences the likelihood of developing retinoblastoma. We also revealed a relatively high frequency of asymptomatic carriage of the RB1 mutations among the parents of retinoblastoma patients, highlighting the utmost necessity for molecular analysis among the probands’ relatives irrespective of their clinical status and family history of retinoblastoma.

Abstract

Our aim was to identify RB1 alterations causing hereditary low penetrance retinoblastoma and to evaluate how the parental origin of an RB1 mutation affects its phenotypic expression. By NGS and MLPA, RB1 mutations were found in 191 from 332 unrelated retinoblastoma patients. Among patients with identified RB1 mutations but without clinical family history of retinoblastoma, 7% (12/175) were found to have hereditary disease with one of the parents being an asymptomatic carrier of an RB1 mutation. Additionally, in two families with retinoblastoma history, mutations were inherited by probands from unaffected parents. Overall, nine probands inherited RB1 mutations from clinically unaffected fathers and five, from mothers. Yet, we gained explanations of maternal “unaffectedness” in most cases, either as somatic mosaicism or as clinical presentation of retinomas in involution, rendering the proportion of paternal to maternal truly asymptomatic mutation carriers as 9:1 (p = 0.005). This observation supports an assumption that parental origin of an RB1 mutation influences the likelihood of developing retinoblastoma. Additionally, our study revealed a relatively high frequency of asymptomatic carriage of the RB1 mutations among the parents of retinoblastoma patients, highlighting the utmost necessity of molecular analysis among the probands’ relatives irrespective of their clinical status and family history of retinoblastoma.

Introduction of a Variant Classification System for Analysis of Genotype-Phenotype Relationships in Heritable Retinoblastoma

Simple Summary

Heritable retinoblastoma is a genetic disease that predisposes to develop multiple retinoblastomas in childhood and other extraocular tumors later in life. It is caused by genetic variants in the RB1 gene. Here we present a new classification for genetic variants in the RB1 gene (REC) that focuses on the variant’s effect. The different classes, REC-I to -V, correlate with different risks of tumor predisposition. REC correlated with different clinical courses when applied in our study cohort. REC aims to facilitate risk estimation for physicians, patients and their families, and researchers and to improve the definition of the necessity of screening examination.

Abstract

Constitutional haploinsufficiency of the RB1 gene causes heritable retinoblastoma, a tumor predisposition syndrome. Patients with heritable retinoblastoma develop multiple retinoblastomas early in childhood and other extraocular tumors later in life. Constitutional pathogenic variants in RB1 are heterogeneous, and a few genotype-phenotype correlations have been described. To identify further genotype-phenotype relationships, we developed the retinoblastoma variant effect classification (REC), which considers each variant’s predicted effects on the common causal mediator, RB1 protein pRB. For validation, the RB1 variants of 287 patients were grouped according to REC. Multiple aspects of phenotypic expression were analyzed, known genotype-phenotype associations were revised, and new relationships were explored. Phenotypic expression of patients with REC-I, -II, and -III was distinct. Remarkably, the phenotype of patients with variants causing residual amounts of truncated pRB (REC-I) was more severe than patients with complete loss of RB1 (REC-II). The age of diagnosis of REC-I variants appeared to be distinct depending on truncation’s localization relative to pRB structure domains. REC classes identify genotype-phenotype relationships and, therefore, this classification framework may serve as a tool to develop tailored tumor screening programs depending on the type of RB1 variant.

Whole-Genome Sequencing of Retinoblastoma Reveals the Diversity of Rearrangements Disrupting RB1 and Uncovers a Treatment-Related Mutational Signature

The development of retinoblastoma is thought to require pathological genetic changes in both alleles of the RB1 gene. However, cases exist where RB1 mutations are undetectable, suggesting alternative pathways to malignancy. We used whole-genome sequencing (WGS) and transcriptomics to investigate the landscape of sporadic retinoblastomas derived from twenty patients, sought RB1 and other driver mutations and investigated mutational signatures. At least one RB1 mutation was identified in all retinoblastomas, including new mutations in addition to those previously identified by clinical screening. Ten tumours carried structural rearrangements involving RB1 ranging from relatively simple to extremely complex rearrangement patterns, including a chromothripsis-like pattern in one tumour. Bilateral tumours obtained from one patient harboured conserved germline but divergent somatic RB1 mutations, indicating independent evolution. Mutational signature analysis showed predominance of signatures associated with cell division, an absence of ultraviolet-related DNA damage and a profound platinum-related mutational signature in a chemotherapy-exposed tumour. Most RB1 mutations are identifiable by clinical screening. However, the increased resolution and ability to detect otherwise elusive rearrangements by WGS have important repercussions on clinical management and advice on recurrence risks.

Conservative management of retinoblastoma: Challenging orthodoxy without compromising the state of metastatic grace. "Alive, with good vision and no comorbidity"

Retinoblastoma is lethal by metastasis if left untreated, so the primary goal of therapy is to preserve life, with ocular survival, visual preservation and quality of life as secondary aims. Historically, enucleation was the first successful therapeutic approach to decrease mortality, followed over 100 years ago by the first eye salvage attempts with radiotherapy. This led to the empiric delineation of a window for conservative management subject to a "state of metastatic grace" never to be violated. Over the last two decades, conservative management of retinoblastoma witnessed an impressive acceleration of improvements, culminating in two major paradigm shifts in therapeutic strategy. Firstly, the introduction of systemic chemotherapy and focal treatments in the late 1990s enabled radiotherapy to be progressively abandoned. Around 10 years later, the advent of chemotherapy in situ, with the capitalization of new routes of targeted drug delivery, namely intra-arterial, intravitreal and now intracameral injections, allowed significant increase in eye preservation rate, definitive eradication of radiotherapy and reduction of systemic chemotherapy. Here we intend to review the relevant knowledge susceptible to improve the conservative management of retinoblastoma in compliance with the "state of metastatic grace", with particular attention to (i) reviewing how new imaging modalities impact the frontiers of conservative management, (ii) dissecting retinoblastoma genesis, growth patterns, and intraocular routes of tumor propagation, (iii) assessing major therapeutic changes and trends, (iv) proposing a classification of relapsing retinoblastoma, (v) examining treatable/preventable disease-related or treatment-induced complications, and (vi) appraising new therapeutic targets and concepts, as well as liquid biopsy potentiality.

Spectrum of germline RB1 mutations and clinical manifestations in retinoblastoma patients from Thailand

Purpose

Retinoblastoma (RB) is a retinal tumor that most commonly occurs in children. Approximately 40% of RB patients carry germline mutations in the RB1 gene. RB survivors with germline mutations are at increased risk of passing on the disease to future offspring and of secondary cancer in adulthood. This highlights the importance of genetic testing in disease management and counseling. This study aimed to identify germline RB1 mutations and to correlate the mutations with clinical phenotypes of RB patients.

Methods

Genomic DNA was extracted from peripheral blood mononuclear cells isolated from 52 RB patients (27 unilaterally and 25 bilaterally affected probands). Mutations in the RB1 gene, including the promoter and exons 1-27 with flanking intronic sequences, were identified by direct sequencing. The samples with negative test results were subjected to multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification (MLPA) to detect any gross mutations. A correlation of germline RB1 mutations with tumor laterality or age at diagnosis was determined for RB patients. Age at diagnosis was examined in regard to genetic test results and the presence of extraocular tumor extension.

Results

Germline RB1 mutations were detected in 60% (31/52) of patients. RB1 mutations were identified in 92% (22/25) of bilateral RB patients, and a high rate of germline RB1 mutations was found in unilateral RB cases (33% or 9/27). Whole gene and exon deletions were reported in five patients. Twenty-three distinct mutations as a result of base substitutions and small deletions were identified in 26 patients; seven mutations were novel. Nonsense and splicing mutations were commonly identified in RB patients. Furthermore, a synonymous mutation was detected in a patient with familial RB; affected mutation carriers in this family exhibited differences in disease severity. The types of germline RB1 mutations were not associated with age at diagnosis or laterality. In addition, patients with positive and negative test results for germline RB1 mutations were similar in age at diagnosis. The incidence of extraocular tumors was high in patients with heritable RB (83% or 5/6), particularly in unilateral cases (33% or 3/9); the mean age at diagnosis of these patients was not different from that of patients with intraocular tumors.

Conclusions

This study provides a data set of an RB1 genotypic spectrum of germline mutations and clinical phenotypes and reports the distribution of disease-associated germline mutations in Thai RB patients who attended our center. Our data and the detection methods could assist in identifying a patient with heritable RB, establishing management plans, and informing proper counseling for patients and their families.

Parent-of-origin effect of hypomorphic pathogenic variants and somatic mosaicism impact on phenotypic expression of retinoblastoma

Retinoblastoma is the most common eye cancer in children. Numerous families have been described displaying reduced penetrance and expressivity. An extensive molecular characterization of seven families led us to characterize the two main mechanisms impacting on phenotypic expression, as follows: (i) mosaicism of amorphic pathogenic variants; and (ii) parent-of-origin-effect of hypomorphic pathogenic variants. Somatic mosaicism for RB1 splicing variants (c.1960+5G>C and c.2106+2T>C), leading to a complete loss of function was demonstrated by high-depth NGS in two families. In both cases, the healthy carrier parent (one with retinoma) showed a variant frequency lower than that expected for a heterozygous individual, indicating a 56-60% mosaicism level. Previous evidences of a ~3-fold excess of RB1 maternal canonical transcript led us to hypothesize that this differential allelic expression could influence phenotypic outcome in families at risk for RB onset. Accordingly, in five families, we identified a higher tumor risk associated with paternally inherited hypomorphic pathogenic variants, namely a deletion resulting in the loss of 37 amino acids at the N-terminus (c.608-16_608del), an exonic substitution with a "leaky" splicing effect (c.1331A>G), a partially deleterious substitution (c.1981C>T) and a truncating C-terminal variant (c.2663+2T>C). The identification of these mechanisms changes the genetic/prenatal counseling and the clinical management of families, indicating a higher recurrence risk when the hypomorphic pathogenic variant is inherited from the father, and suggesting the need for second tumor surveillance in unaffected carriers at risk of developing adult-onset cancer such as osteosarcoma or leiomyosarcoma.

Heterogeneity in retinoblastoma: a tale of molecules and models

Retinoblastoma, an intraocular pediatric cancer, develops in the embryonic retina following biallelic loss of RB1. However, there is a wide range of genetic and epigenetic changes that can affect RB1 resulting in different clinical outcomes. In addition, other transformations, such as MYCN amplification, generate particularly aggressive tumors, which may or may not be RB1 independent. Recognizing the cellular characteristics required for tumor development, by identifying the elusive cell-of-origin for retinoblastoma, would help us understand the development of these tumors. In this review we summarize the heterogeneity reported in retinoblastoma on a molecular, cellular and tissue level. We also discuss the challenging heterogeneity in current retinoblastoma models and suggest future platforms that could contribute to improved understanding of tumor initiation, progression and metastasis in retinoblastoma, which may ultimately lead to more patient-specific treatments.

Defective splicing of the RB1 transcript is the dominant cause of retinoblastomas

Defective splicing is a common cause of genetic diseases. On average, 13.4% of all hereditary disease alleles are classified as splicing mutations with most mapping to the critical GT or AG nucleotides within the 5' and 3' splice sites. However, splicing mutations are underreported and the fraction of splicing mutations that compose all disease alleles varies greatly across disease gene. For example, there is a great excess (46%; ~threefold) of hereditary disease alleles that map to splice sites in RB1 that cause retinoblastoma. Furthermore, mutations in the exons and deeper intronic position may also affect splicing. We recently developed a high-throughput method that assays reported disease mutations for their ability to disrupt pre-mRNA splicing. Surprisingly, 27% of RB1-coding mutations tested also disrupt splicing. High-throughput in vitro spliceosomal assembly assay reveals heterogeneity in which stage of spliceosomal assembly is affected by splicing mutations. 58% of exonic splicing mutations were primarily blocked at the A complex in transition to the B complex and 33% were blocked at the B complex. Several mutants appear to reduce more than one step in the assembly. As RB1 splicing mutants are enriched in retinoblastoma disease alleles, additional priority should be allocated to this class of allele while interpreting clinical sequencing experiments. Analysis of the spectrum of RB1 variants observed in 60,706 exomes identifies 197 variants that have enough potential to disrupt splicing to warrant further consideration.

Mutation spectrum of RB1 mutations in retinoblastoma cases from Singapore with implications for genetic management and counselling

Retinoblastoma (RB) is a rare childhood malignant disorder caused by the biallelic inactivation of RB1 gene. Early diagnosis and identification of carriers of heritable RB1 mutations can improve disease outcome and management. In this study, mutational analysis was conducted on fifty-nine matched tumor and peripheral blood samples from 18 bilateral and 41 unilateral unrelated RB cases by a combinatorial approach of Multiplex Ligation-dependent Probe Amplification (MLPA) assay, deletion screening, direct sequencing, copy number gene dosage analysis and methylation assays. Screening of both blood and tumor samples yielded a mutation detection rate of 94.9% (56/59) while only 42.4% (25/59) of mutations were detected if blood samples alone were analyzed. Biallelic mutations were observed in 43/59 (72.9%) of tumors screened. There were 3 cases (5.1%) in which no mutations could be detected and germline mutations were detected in 19.5% (8/41) of unilateral cases. A total of 61 point mutations were identified, of which 10 were novel. There was a high incidence of previously reported recurrent mutations, occurring at 38.98% (23/59) of all cases. Of interest were three cases of mosaic RB1 mutations detected in the blood from patients with unilateral retinoblastoma. Additionally, two germline mutations previously reported to be associated with low-penetrance phenotypes: missense-c.1981C>T and splice variant-c.607+1G>T, were observed in a bilateral and a unilateral proband, respectively. These findings have implications for genetic counselling and risk prediction for the affected families. This is the first published report on the spectrum of mutations in RB patients from Singapore and shows that further improved mutation screening strategies are required in order to provide a definitive molecular diagnosis for every case of RB. Our findings also underscore the importance of genetic testing in supporting individualized disease management plans for patients and asymptomatic family members carrying low-penetrance, germline mosaicism or heritable unilateral mutational phenotypes.

Genetics and Molecular Diagnostics in Retinoblastoma--An Update

Retinoblastoma is the prototype genetic cancer: in one or both eyes of young children, most retinoblastomas are initiated by biallelic mutation of the retinoblastoma tumor suppressor gene, RB1, in a developing retinal cell. All those with bilateral retinoblastoma have heritable cancer, although 95% have not inherited the RB1 mutation. Non-heritable retinoblastoma is always unilateral, with 98% caused by loss of both RB1 alleles from the tumor, whereas 2% have normal RB1 in tumors initiated by amplification of the MYCN oncogene. Good understanding of retinoblastoma genetics supports optimal care for retinoblastoma children and their families. Retinoblastoma is the first cancer to officially acknowledge the seminal role of genetics in cancer, by incorporating "H" into the eighth edition of cancer staging (2017): those who carry the RB1 cancer-predisposing gene are H1; those proven to not carry the familial RB1 mutation are H0; and those at unknown risk are HX. We suggest H0* be used for those with residual <1% risk to carry a RB1 mutation due to undetectable mosaicism. Loss of RB1 from a susceptible developing retinal cell initiates the benign precursor, retinoma. Progressive genomic changes result in retinoblastoma, and cancer progression ensues with increasing genomic disarray. Looking forward, novel therapies are anticipated from studies of retinoblastoma and metastatic tumor cells and the second primary cancers that the carriers of RB1 mutations are at high risk to develop. Here, we summarize the concepts of retinoblastoma genetics for ophthalmologists in a question/answer format to assist in the care of patients and their families.

A Parent-of-Origin Effect Impacts the Phenotype in Low Penetrance Retinoblastoma Families Segregating the c.1981C>T/p.Arg661Trp Mutation of RB1

Retinoblastoma (Rb), the most common pediatric intraocular neoplasm, results from inactivation of both alleles of the RB1 tumor suppressor gene. The second allele is most commonly lost, as demonstrated by loss of heterozygosity studies. RB1 germline carriers usually develop bilateral tumors, but some Rb families display low penetrance and variable expressivity. In order to decipher the underlying mechanisms, 23 unrelated low penetrance pedigrees segregating the common c.1981C>T/p.Arg661Trp mutation and other low penetrance mutations were studied. In families segregating the c.1981C>T mutation, we demonstrated, for the first time, a correlation between the gender of the transmitting carrier and penetrance, as evidenced by Fisher's exact test: the probability of being unaffected is 90.3% and 32.5% when the mutation is inherited from the mother and the father, respectively (p-value = 7.10(-7). Interestingly, a similar correlation was observed in families segregating other low penetrance alleles. Consequently, we investigated the putative involvement of an imprinted, modifier gene in low penetrance Rb. We first ruled out a MED4-driven mechanism by MED4 methylation and expression analyses. We then focused on the differentially methylated CpG85 island located in intron 2 of RB1 and showing parent-of-origin-specific DNA methylation. This differential methylation promotes expression of the maternal c.1981C>T allele. We propose that the maternally inherited c.1981C>T/p.Arg661Trp allele retains sufficient tumor suppressor activity to prevent retinoblastoma development. In contrast, when the mutation is paternally transmitted, the low residual activity would mimic a null mutation and subsequently lead to retinoblastoma. This implies that the c.1981C>T mutation is not deleterious per se but needs to be destabilized in order to reach pRb haploinsufficiency and initiate tumorigenesis. We suggest that this phenomenon might be a general mechanism to explain phenotypic differences in low penetrance Rb families.

"Monoallelic germline methylation and sequence variant in the promoter of the RB1 gene: a possible constitutive epimutation in hereditary retinoblastoma"

Background

Retinoblastoma is a malignant tumor of the retina in children <5 years of age and occurs after two mutations in the RB1 gene. The first mutation (M1) is germinal and confers predisposition to the hereditary type, which is transmitted as an autosomal dominant highly penetrant trait, so 90 % of carriers develop retinoblastoma; however, 10 % of carriers either do not develop the tumor or develop it unilaterally. Most mutations are point mutations. Inactivation of the RB1 gene is usually caused by mutations affecting the coding region. Silencing by methylation of the RB1 promoter has been observed in retinoblastoma tumors as a second mutation (M2) and is classified as somatic epimutation. Germline methylation of the RB1 gene promoter was studied in a particular pedigree of six generations from the paternal side, with incomplete penetrance and bias towards healthy male carriers and those affected with unilateral retinoblastoma.

Results

The methylation status of the 27 CpGs dinucleotides that constitute the core of the RB1 gene promoter, analyzed by cloning and genomic sequencing after DNA sodium bisulfite conversion, demonstrated a monoallelic methylation pattern which coincides with a c. [−187T > G; −188T > G] sequence variant that is found in peripheral blood lymphocytes and tumor DNA. Unexpectedly, it was the mother who transmitted this variant to two more generations. Microsatellite markers of D chromosome showed a biparental contribution of both D13 chromosomes to the retinoblastoma phenotype, conferring double heterozygosity in the affected cases.

Conclusions

The monoallelic genetic-epigenetic finding, the sequence variant, and methylation suggest a constitutive epimutation and probably a genetic-epigenetic hereditary predisposition for retinoblastoma in this family.

Deregulation of RB1 expression by loss of imprinting in human hepatocellular carcinoma

The tumour suppressor gene RB1 is frequently silenced in many different types of human cancer, including hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). However, mutations of the RB1 gene are relatively rare in HCC. A systematic screen for the identification of imprinted genes deregulated in human HCC revealed that RB1 shows imprint abnormalities in a high proportion of primary patient samples. Altogether, 40% of the HCC specimens (16/40) showed hyper- or hypomethylation at the CpG island in intron 2 of the RB1 gene. Re-analysis of publicly available genome-wide DNA methylation data confirmed these findings in two independent HCC cohorts. Loss of correct DNA methylation patterns at the RB1 locus leads to the aberrant expression of an alternative RB1-E2B transcript, as measured by quantitative real-time PCR. Demethylation at the intron 2 CpG island by DNMT1 knock-down or aza-deoxycytidine (DAC) treatment stimulated expression of the RB1-E2B transcript, accompanied by diminished RB1 main transcript expression. No aberrant DNA methylation was found at the RB1 locus in hepatocellular adenoma (HCA, n = 10), focal nodular hyperplasia (FNH, n = 5) and their corresponding adjacent liver tissue specimens. Deregulated RB1 expression due to hyper- or hypomethylation in intron 2 of the RB1 gene is found in tumours without loss of heterozygosity and is associated with a decrease in overall survival (p = 0.032) if caused by hypermethylation of CpG85. This unequivocally demonstrates that loss of imprinting represents an important additional mechanism for RB1 pathway inactivation in human HCC, complementing well-described molecular defects.

Where genotype is not predictive of phenotype: towards an understanding of the molecular basis of reduced penetrance in human inherited disease

Some individuals with a particular disease-causing mutation or genotype fail to express most if not all features of the disease in question, a phenomenon that is known as 'reduced (or incomplete) penetrance'. Reduced penetrance is not uncommon; indeed, there are many known examples of 'disease-causing mutations' that fail to cause disease in at least a proportion of the individuals who carry them. Reduced penetrance may therefore explain not only why genetic diseases are occasionally transmitted through unaffected parents, but also why healthy individuals can harbour quite large numbers of potentially disadvantageous variants in their genomes without suffering any obvious ill effects. Reduced penetrance can be a function of the specific mutation(s) involved or of allele dosage. It may also result from differential allelic expression, copy number variation or the modulating influence of additional genetic variants in cis or in trans. The penetrance of some pathogenic genotypes is known to be age- and/or sex-dependent. Variable penetrance may also reflect the action of unlinked modifier genes, epigenetic changes or environmental factors. At least in some cases, complete penetrance appears to require the presence of one or more genetic variants at other loci. In this review, we summarize the evidence for reduced penetrance being a widespread phenomenon in human genetics and explore some of the molecular mechanisms that may help to explain this enigmatic characteristic of human inherited disease.

Human PPP1R26P1 functions as cis-repressive element in mouse Rb1

The human retinoblastoma gene (RB1) is imprinted; the mouse Rb1 gene is not. Imprinted expression of RB1 is due to differential methylation of a CpG island (CpG85), which is located in the pseudogene PPP1R26P1 in intron 2 of RB1. CpG85 serves as promoter for an alternative RB1 transcript, which is expressed from the unmethylated paternal allele only and is thought to suppress expression of the full-length RB1 transcript in cis. PPP1R26P1 contains another CpG island (CpG42), which is biallelically methylated. To determine the influence of PPP1R26P1 on RB1 expression, we generated an in vitro murine embryonic stem cell model by introducing human PPP1R26P1 into mouse Rb1. Next generation bisulfite sequencing of CpG85 and CpG42 revealed differences in their susceptibility to DNA methylation, gaining methylation at a median level of 4% and 18%, respectively. We showed binding of RNA polymerase II at and transcription from the unmethylated CpG85 in PPP1R26P1 and observed reduced expression of full-length Rb1 from the targeted allele. Our results identify human PPP1R26P1 as a cis-repressive element and support a connection between retrotransposition of PPP1R26P1 into human RB1 and the reduced expression of RB1 on the paternal allele.

More epigenetic hits than meets the eye: microRNAs and genes associated with the tumorigenesis of retinoblastoma

Retinoblastoma (RB), a childhood neoplasia of the retinoblasts, can occur unilaterally or bilaterally, with one or multiple foci per eye. RB is associated with somatic loss of function of both alleles of the tumor suppressor gene RB1. Hereditary forms emerge due to germline loss of function mutations in RB1 alleles. RB has long been the prototypic “model” cancer ever since Knudson's “two-hit” hypothesis. However, a simple two-hit model for RB is challenged by an increasing number of studies documenting additional hits that contribute to RB development. Here we review the genetics and epigenetics of RB with a focus on the role of small non-coding RNAs (microRNAs) and on novel findings indicating the relevance of DNA methylation in the development and prognosis of this neoplasia. Studies point to an elaborated landscape of genetic and epigenetic complexity, in which a number of events and pahtways play crucial roles in the origin and prognosis of RB. These include roles for microRNAs, inprinted loci, and parent-of-origin contributions to RB1 regulation and RB progression. This complexity is also manifested in the structure of the RB1 locus itself: it includes numerous repetitive DNA segments and retrotransposon insertion elements, some of which are actively transcribed from the RB1 locus. Altogether, we conclude that RB1 loss of function represents the tip of an iceberg of events that determine RB development, progression, severity, and disease risk. Comprehensive assessment of personalized RB risk will require genetic and epigenetic evaluations beyond RB1 protein coding sequences.

Splicing aberrations caused by constitutional RB1 gene mutations in retinoblastoma

Analysis of RB1 mRNA from blood leukocytes of patients with retinoblastoma identified the effects of mutations involving consensus splice site, exonic substitution and whole-exon deletions identified in genomic DNA of these patients. In addition, this study identified mutations in cases in which no mutations were detectable in the genomic DNA. One proband had mutation at the canonical splice site at +5 position of IVS22, and analysis of the transcripts in this family revealed skipping of exon 22 in three members of this family. In one proband, a missense substitution of c.652T greater than G (g.56897T greater than G; Leu218Val) in exon 7 led to splicing aberrations involving deletions of exons 7 and 8, suggesting the formation of a cryptic splice site. In two probands with no detectable changes in the genomic DNA upon screening of RB1 exons and flanking intronic sequences, transcripts were found to have deletions of exon 6 in one, and exons 21 and 22 in another family. In two probands, RNA analysis confirmed genomic deletions involving one or more exons. This study reveals novel effects of RB1 mutations on splicing and suggests the utility of RNA analysis as an adjunct to mutational screening of genomic DNA in retinoblastoma.

Spectrum of SMARCB1/INI1 mutations in familial and sporadic rhabdoid tumors

BACKGROUND

Germline mutations and deletions of SMARCB1/INI1 in chromosome band 22q11.2 predispose patients to rhabdoid tumor and schwannomatosis. Previous estimates suggested that 15-20% of rhabdoid tumors were caused by an underlying germline abnormality of SMARCB1. However, these studies were limited by case selection and an inability to detect intragenic deletions and duplications.

PROCEDURE

One hundred matched tumor and blood samples from patients with rhabdoid tumors of the brain, kidney, or soft tissues were analyzed for mutations and deletions of SMARCB1 by FISH, multiplex ligation-dependent probe amplification (MLPA), sequence analysis and high resolution Illumina 610K SNP-based oligonucleotide array studies.

RESULTS

Thirty-five of 100 patients were found to have a germline SMARCB1 abnormality. These abnormalities included point and frameshift mutations, intragenic deletions and duplications, and larger deletions including regions both proximal and distal to SMARCB1. There were nine cases that demonstrated parent to child transmission of a mutated copy of SMARCB1. In eight of the nine cases, one or more family members were also diagnosed with rhabdoid tumor or schwannoma, and two of the eight families presented with multiple affected children in a manner consistent with gonadal mosaicism.

CONCLUSIONS

Approximately one-third of newly diagnosed patients with rhabdoid tumor have an underlying genetic predisposition to tumors due to a germline SMARCB1 alteration. Families may demonstrate incomplete penetrance and gonadal mosaicism, which must be considered when counseling families of patients with rhabdoid tumor.

Imprinting des RB1-Gens und „Parent-of-Origin-Effekte“ beim Retinoblastom

Mutationen beider Allele des Retinoblastomgens (RB1) sind Voraussetzung für die Entstehung des Retinoblastoms. Dieser Augentumor kann auf der Grundlage einer autosomal-dominanten Disposition entstehen, die durch Keimbahnmutationen im RB1-Gen verursacht wird. Die Entstehung eines Tumorherds wird durch eine somatische Mutation des anderen RB1-Allels ausgelöst. Bei Patienten mit der nichterblichen Form sind beide RB1-Mutationen somatisch. Beim erblichen und beim nichterblichen Retinoblastom können Elterneffekte beobachtet werden. Diesen ist gemeinsam, dass die onkogene Wirkung der ersten Mutation höher ist, wenn sie das RB1-Allel paternaler Herkunft betrifft. Das RB1-Gen des Menschen unterliegt dem Imprinting: Als indirekte Folge differenzieller Methylierung einer CpG-Insel im Intron 2 überwiegt die Expression der mit Exon 1 beginnenden Transkripte vom maternalen, methylierten Allel. Ob und wie das Imprinting dieser CpG-Insel zu den beobachteten Elterneffekten führt, ist noch ungeklärt.

Estimating penetrance from multiple case families with predisposing mutations: extension of the 'genotype-restricted likelihood' (GRL) method

Some diseases are due to germline mutations in predisposing genes, such as cancer family syndromes. Precise estimation of the age-specific cumulative risk (penetrance) for mutation carriers is essential for defining prevention strategies. The genotype-restricted likelihood (GRL) method is aimed at estimating penetrance from multiple case families with such a mutation. In this paper, we proposed an extension of the GRL to account for multiple trait disease and to allow for a parent-of-origin effect. Using simulations of pedigrees, we studied the properties of this method and the effect of departures from underlying hypotheses, misspecification of disease incidence in the general population or misspecification of the index case, and penetrance heterogeneity. In contrast with the previous version of the GRL, accounting for multiple trait disease allowed unbiased estimation of penetrance. We also showed that accounting for a parent-of-origin effect allowed a powerful test for detecting this effect. We found that the GRL method was robust to misspecification of disease incidence in the population, but that misspecification of the index case induced a bias in some situations for which we proposed efficient corrections. When ignoring heterogeneity, the penetrance estimate was biased toward that of the highest risk individuals. A homogeneity test performed by stratifying the families according to the number of affected members was shown to have low power and seems useless for detecting such heterogeneity. These extensions are essential to better estimate the risk of diseases and to provide valid recommendations for the management of patients.

Imprinting of RB1 (the new kid on the block)

Recent data have revealed that the paradigmatic tumour suppressor gene RB1 on chromosome 13 is preferentially expressed from the maternal allele. Imprinted expression of RB1 is linked to a differentially methylated CpG island in intron 2 of this gene (CpG 85). On the paternal chromosome, CpG 85 is unmethylated and acts as a weak promoter of an alternative RB1 transcript. Paternal mRNA levels are probably reduced as the result of transcriptional interference of the regular promoter and the alternative promoter on this chromosome. CpG 85 is part of a truncated processed pseudogene (KIAA0649P) that integrated into the RB1 gene prior to the speciation of extant primates. It is plausible that differential penetrance and variation of age at diagnosis, which have been observed in patients with hereditary and non-hereditary retinoblastoma, respectively, are a consequence of imprinted expression of the RB1 gene. Interestingly, RB1 is imprinted in the same direction as CDKN1C, which operates upstream of RB1. The imprinting of two components of the same pathway indicates that there has been strong evolutionary selection for maternal inhibition of cell proliferation.

Epigenetics and transgenerational transfer: a physiological perspective

Epigenetics, the transgenerational transfer of phenotypic characters without modification of gene sequence, is a burgeoning area of study in many disciplines of biology. However, the potential impact of this phenomenon on the physiology of animals is not yet broadly appreciated, in part because the phenomenon of epigenetics is not typically part of the design of physiological investigations. Still enigmatic and somewhat ill defined is the relationship between the overarching concept of epigenetics and interesting transgenerational phenomena (e.g. 'maternal/parental effects') that alter the physiological phenotype of subsequent generations. The lingering effect on subsequent generations of an initial environmental disturbance in parent animals can be profound, with genes continuing to be variously silenced or expressed without an associated change in gene sequence for many generations. Known epigenetic mechanisms involved in this phenomenon include chromatin remodeling (DNA methylation and histone modification), RNA-mediated modifications (non-coding RNA and microRNA), as well as other less well studied mechanisms such as self-sustaining loops and structural inheritance. In this review we: (1) discuss how the concepts of epigenetics and maternal effects both overlap with, and are distinct from, each other; (2) analyze examples of existing animal physiological studies based on these concepts; and (3) offer a construct by which to integrate these concepts into the design of future investigations in animal physiology.

The human retinoblastoma gene is imprinted

Genomic imprinting is an epigenetic process leading to parent-of-origin–specific DNA methylation and gene expression. To date, ∼60 imprinted human genes are known. Based on genome-wide methylation analysis of a patient with multiple imprinting defects, we have identified a differentially methylated CpG island in intron 2 of the retinoblastoma (RB1) gene on chromosome 13. The CpG island is part of a 5′-truncated, processed pseudogene derived from the KIAA0649 gene on chromosome 9 and corresponds to two small CpG islands in the open reading frame of the ancestral gene. It is methylated on the maternal chromosome 13 and acts as a weak promoter for an alternative RB1 transcript on the paternal chromosome 13. In four other KIAA0649 pseudogene copies, which are located on chromosome 22, the two CpG islands have deteriorated and the CpG dinucleotides are fully methylated. By analysing allelic RB1 transcript levels in blood cells, as well as in hypermethylated and 5-aza-2′-deoxycytidine–treated lymphoblastoid cells, we have found that differential methylation of the CpG island skews RB1 gene expression in favor of the maternal allele. Thus, RB1 is imprinted in the same direction as CDKN1C, which operates upstream of RB1. The imprinting of two components of the same pathway indicates that there has been strong evolutionary selection for maternal inhibition of cell proliferation.

Genomic imprinting is an epigenetic process leading to parent-of-origin–specific DNA methylation and gene expression. Defects in this process lead to abnormal development, growth, or behavior. It is still unclear why and how imprinting evolved and how many human genes are imprinted. Based on genome-wide DNA methylation analysis in a patient with a generalized imprinting defect, we have found that the paradigmatic retinoblastoma 1 (RB1) gene on chromosome 13 is imprinted. Imprinting of RB1 is linked to the insertion of a DNA sequence derived by retrotransposition from a gene on chromosome 9. Part of the inserted DNA sequence has evolved into a differentially methylated alternative RB1 promoter. Differential methylation of this sequence skews expression of the RB1 gene in favour of the maternal allele. The direction of the imprint imposed on the RB1 gene is the same as of the maternally expressed CDKN1C gene, which operates upstream of RB1. The imprinting of two components of the same pathway indicates that there has been strong evolutionary selection for maternal inhibition of cell proliferation.

Frontiers in the management of retinoblastoma

PURPOSE

To provide an overview of the current clinical management of retinoblastoma by discussing the trends in the categorization, treatment, and recent advances in molecular diagnostics as well as therapy for retinoblastoma.

DESIGN

Literature review and commentary.

METHODS

Selected articles from the medical literature and the authors' clinical and research experience were reviewed critically.

RESULTS

Retinoblastoma has evolved from a deadly childhood cancer to a largely curable cancer within the past 40 years. Current treatment strategies aim to salvage the eye and provide the best visual outcome possible. Using the international classification system to stratify intraocular retinoblastoma into treatment groups, the multicenter Children's Oncology Group treatment protocols use 2- to 3-drug chemoreduction with focal consolidative therapy for most categories of disease. Furthermore, collaborative efforts are being directed toward a better understanding of genotype-phenotype relationships in retinoblastoma that will be useful in the multidisciplinary management of this disease. Molecular targeting therapy is emerging as a potential strategy to individualize therapy. Finally, improvements in local drug delivery methods and vehicles are providing solutions for the problem of systemic toxicity from existing chemotherapy regimens.

CONCLUSIONS

The management of retinoblastoma has become a prototype for other ophthalmic diseases and systemic cancers in which genetic information and molecular targets are being used to design more elegant treatment strategies.

Constitutional retinoblastoma gene deletion in Egyptian patients

BACKGROUND

Retinoblastoma is a neuroblastic tumor of childhood with an incidence of 1: 20 000. Retinoblastoma gene (Rb1) is a tumor suppressor gene that is located on the long arm of chromosome 13 at region 14. This study was to evaluate the constitutional monoallelic Rb1 deletion among retinoblastoma families.

METHODS

Nine families with an affected Rb proband were evaluated. Clinical examination, pedigree analysis, and complete eye examination were given to patients, their sibs and parents. Standard cytogenetic and fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analyses were carried out for all of them. Also, two sib fetuses were tested for Rb1 deletion.

RESULTS

No dysmorphic features were detected in any patient. Developmental milestones were within normal limit except in one proband who had a mild delay. The age of onset ranged from one month to 4 years. Positive family history was found in two families. In one, the father and 3 sibs had retinoblastoma, and in the other, 2 sibs were affected, but the parents were free. Chromosomal study revealed no abnormalities in all parents and sibs. Two patients had mosaic chromosome 13 abnormalities, 46,XY/46,XY,del(13)(pter-->q14:) and 46,XX/46,inv(13)(q14q22). FISH analysis detected mosaic Rb1 deletion in two patients and excluded Rb1 deletion in two fetuses.

CONCLUSIONS

The detection of genetic alterations affecting the Rb1 locus is important for the establishment of carriers, and prenatal and presymptomatic diagnosis. The search for deleted Rb1 mosaic cell lines is important for genetic counseling. Germline mutation may be considered as genetic transmission method of the Rb1 gene.

Detection of mosaic RB1 mutations in families with retinoblastoma

The RB1 gene mutation detection rate in 1,020 retinoblastoma families was increased by the use of highly sensitive allele specific-PCR (AS-PCR) to detect low-level mosaicism for 11 recurrent RB1 CGA>TGA nonsense mutations. For bilaterally affected probands, AS-PCR increased the RB1 mutation detection sensitivity from 92.6% to 94.8%. Both RB1 oncogenic changes were detected in 92.7% of sporadic unilateral tumors (357/385); 14.6% (52/357) of unilateral probands with both tumor mutations identified carried one of the tumor mutations in blood. Mosaicism was evident in 5.5% of bilateral probands (23 of 421), in 3.8% of unilateral probands (22 of 572), and in one unaffected mother of a unilateral proband. Half of the mosaic mutations were only detectable by AS-PCR for the 11 recurrent CGA>TGA mutations, and not by standard sequencing. This suggests that significant numbers of low-level mosaics with other classes of RB1 mutations remain unidentified by current technology. We show that the use of linkage analysis in a two-generation retinoblastoma family resulted in the erroneous conclusion that a child carried the parental mutation, because the founder parent was mosaic for the RB1 mutation. Of 142 unaffected parental pairs tested, only one unaffected parent of a proband (0.7%) showed somatic mosaicism for the proband's mutation, in contrast to an overall 4.5% somatic mosaicism rate for retinoblastoma probands, suggesting that mosaicism for an RB1 mutation is highly likely to manifest as retinoblastoma.

Molecular biology of retinoblastoma

Retinoblastoma (Rb), the most common intraocular tumor in childhood, is caused by the loss of function of both retinoblastoma susceptibility gene (RB1 or Rb1) alleles. In 1971, Alfred Knudson proposed his "two-hit" theory based upon empiric observations of the clinical genetics of Rb, revealing the role of tumor-suppressor genes in human cancer. Knudson proposed that: "In the dominant inherited form of Rb, one mutation is inherited via germ line and the second occurs in somatic cells. In the nonhereditary form, both mutations occur in somatic cells." The Knudson hypothesis was validated later with the cloning of RB1, the first tumor-suppressor gene to be identified. A few years later, Harbour extended these findings to small-cell lung cancer, showing that the RB1 locus was disrupted in tumors other than Rb and osteosarcoma. Since then, it has been found that most, if not all, tumors have defects in their RB1 pathway through genetic lesions in the RB1 gene itself or other genes in the pathway. The history of Rb research highlights how basic research on a rare childhood cancer can have a much broader effect on a disease that affects millions of people each year worldwide.

Genotype-phenotype correlations in hereditary familial retinoblastoma

We studied 50 unrelated pedigrees with a family history of retinoblastoma (Rb) (165 carriers of a RB1 mutation) to delineate the spectrum of RB1 germline mutations in familial Rb and to identify genotype-phenotype correlations as well as putative modifiers. Patients were followed at Institut Curie and they were examined by an ophthalmologist, a pediatrician, and a geneticist. All cases of familial Rb were determined via genetic counseling. Clinical features included disease status, laterality, age at diagnosis, mutation type, follow-up, and disease-eye ratio (DER). To eliminate mosaic cases, first-generation carriers displaying low-penetrance (LP) Rb were excluded from the analysis. Complete penetrance was the rule for nonsense and frameshift mutations (25 families) and high penetrance was observed for large rearrangements (eight families). Promoter (two families) and missense (two families) mutations displayed heterogeneous phenotypes and LP. Variable penetrance was observed for splice abnormalities (13 families) and was explained by in/out of frame mutations or respect of functional domains. Surprisingly, two families with the LP g.45867G>T/IVS6+1G>T mutation presented data that conflicted with the data reported in previous publications, as unaffected carriers had paternally inherited mutant alleles. Moreover, RNA analyses suggested that the lack of penetrance in unaffected carriers could be explained by an increase in expression levels of the wild-type allele. This observation prompted us to define a new class "3" of LP alleles. We believe this is the first large-scale study of familial Rb with a high level of homogeneity in the clinical and genetic analysis of patients and their relatives, thereby allowing for reliable intrafamilial genotype-phenotype correlations. Our analysis suggests in some cases the influence of modifier factors probably involved in mRNA level regulation and/or pRB pathway regulation.

Attenuation of disease phenotype through alternative translation initiation in low-penetrance retinoblastoma

Hereditary predisposition to retinoblastoma (RB) is caused by germline mutations in the retinoblastoma 1 (RB1) gene and transmits as an autosomal dominant trait. In the majority of cases disease develops in greater than 90% of carriers. However, reduced penetrance with a large portion of disease-free carrier is seen in some families. Unambiguous identification of the predisposing mutation in these families is important for accurate risk prediction in relatives and their genetic counseling but also provides conceptual information regarding the relationship between the RB1 genotype and the disease phenotype. In this study we report a novel mutation detected in 10 individuals of an extended family, only three of whom are affected by RB disease. The mutation comprises a 23-basepair (bp) duplication in the first exon of RB1 (c.43_65dup) producing a frameshift in exon 1 and premature chain termination in exon 2. Mutations resulting in premature chain termination classically are associated with high penetrance disease, as message translation may not generate functional product and nonsense mediated RNA decay (NMD) frequently eliminates the mutant transcript. However, appreciable NMD does not follow from the mutation described here and transcript expression in tissue culture cells and translation in vitro reveals that alternative in-frame translation start sites involving Met113 and possibly Met233 are used to generate truncated RB1 products (pRB94 and pRB80), known and suspected to exhibit tumor suppressor activity. These results strongly suggest that modulation of disease penetrance in this family is achieved by internal translation initiation. Our observations provide the first example for rescue of a chain-terminating mutation in RB1 through alternative translation initiation.

Diagnóstico molecular del retinoblastoma: epidemiología molecular y consejo genético

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Retinoblastoma, a prototype of hereditary cancer, is the most common intraocular tumor in children and a potential cause of blindness from therapeutic eye ablation, second tumors in germ line mutation carriers, and even death when untreated. The molecular scanning of RB1 in search of germ line mutations in 213 retinoblastoma patients from Spain, Cuba, Colombia and Serbia, has led to the detection of 106 mutations whose knowledge is important for genetic counselling and characterization of phenotypic-genotypic relations.

PATIENTS AND METHOD

Mutational study (PCR-sequentiation and microsatellites analysis) in patients with retinoblastoma, from Spain, Cuba, Colombia and Serbia.

RESULTS

45% of mutations, including most of the frame shift (FS), missense (MS) and splicing (SP), were new, while all nonsense mutations (NS) corresponded to hypermutable sites in RB1. Germ line mutations were found in 22% of unilateral sporadic patients. The incidence of SP plus MS mutations in this group of patients was greater (p = 0.018) than in bilateral patients. The frequency of SP mutations was higher (p = 0.0003) in Spain and France than in Germany and United Kingdom, while the incidence of NS mutations was lower (p = 0.0006). SP mutations were associated with the low penetrance phenotype and were also overrepresented (p = 0.018) in patients with delayed retinoblastoma onset.

CONCLUSIONS

Mutational scanning of unilateral patients is important for genetic counselling and may help decipher the molecular mechanisms leading to low penetrance or expressivity. The functional characterization of mutations associated with low-penetrance or expressivity phenotypes and the molecular classification of tumors using multiple expression profiling is important for a better understanding of the retinoblastoma pathogenesis.

RB1 gene mutation up-date, a meta-analysis based on 932 reported mutations available in a searchable database

Background

Retinoblastoma, a prototype of hereditary cancer, is the most common intraocular tumour in children and potential cause of blindness from therapeutic eye ablation, second tumours in germ line carrier's survivors, and even death when left untreated. The molecular scanning of RB1 in search of germ line mutations lead to the publication of more than 900 mutations whose knowledge is important for genetic counselling and the characterization of phenotypic-genotypic relationships.

Results

A searchable database (RBGMdb) has been constructed with 932 published RB1 mutations. The spectrum of these mutations has been analyzed with the following results: 1) the retinoblastoma protein is frequently inactivated by deletions and nonsense mutations while missense mutations are the main inactivating event in most genetic diseases. 2) Near 40% of RB1 gene mutations are recurrent and gather in sixteen hot points, including twelve nonsense, two missense and three splicing mutations. The remainder mutations are scattered along RB1, being most frequent in exons 9, 10, 14, 17, 18, 20, and 23. 3) The analysis of RB1 mutations by country of origin of the patients identifies two groups in which the incidence of nonsense and splicing mutations show differences extremely significant, and suggest the involvement of predisposing ethnic backgrounds. 4) A significant association between late age at diagnosis and splicing mutations in bilateral retinoblastoma patients suggests the occurrence of a delayed-onset genotype. 5) Most of the reported mutations in low-penetrance families fall in three groups: a) Mutations in regulatory sequences at the promoter resulting in low expression of a normal Rb; b) Missense and in-frame deletions affecting non-essential sequence motifs which result in a partial inactivation of Rb functions; c) Splicing mutations leading to the reduction of normal mRNA splicing or to alternative splicing involving either true oncogenic or defective (weak) alleles.

Conclusion

The analysis of RB1 gene mutations logged in the RBGMdb has shown relevant phenotype-genotype relationships and provided working hypothesis to ascertain mechanisms linking certain mutations to ethnicity, delayed onset of the disease and low-penetrance. Gene profiling of tumors will help to clarify the genetic background linked to ethnicity and variable expressivity or delayed onset phenotypes.

Age at diagnosis of isolated unilateral retinoblastoma does not distinguish patients with and without a constitutional RB1 gene mutation but is influenced by a parent-of-origin effect

Patients with hereditary cancer are usually diagnosed earlier than patients with non-hereditary tumours. In children with isolated unilateral retinoblastoma, some of whom have a hereditary predisposition, this rule has been subject to debate. We have analysed the clinical manifestation of disease in 188 children with completely resolved mutational status. In 24 (13%) of these patients, testing of blood DNA showed a constitutional RB1 mutation. The distribution of age at diagnosis was not different between patients with and without a constitutional mutation. However, patients with loss of the maternally inherited RB1 allele had an earlier age at diagnosis than patients with loss of the paternally inherited RB1 allele. Our data show that early age at diagnosis does not identify patients with isolated unilateral retinoblastoma that have a higher risk of being carriers of a RB1 gene mutation. Our findings suggest that, at least in some patients, age at diagnosis is modified by a parent-of-origin effect.

Retinoblastoma: revisiting the model prototype of inherited cancer

Hereditary retinoblastoma is an autosomal dominant disorder caused by mutations in the RB1 gene. Analysis of this rare condition has helped to elucidate the mechanisms underlying hereditary cancer predisposition in general. As identification of RB1 gene mutations has become a part of clinical management of patients with retinoblastoma, there is now a wealth of data. In this article, we summarize the current knowledge on the relations between the genotype and phenotypic expression. Moreover, detailed analysis of genotype-phenotype relations shows that hereditary retinoblastoma has features of a complex trait.

Comprehensive screening for constitutional RB1 mutations by DHPLC and QMPSF

Constitutional mutations of the RB1 gene are associated with a predisposition to retinoblastoma. It is essential to identify these mutations to provide appropriate genetic counseling in retinoblastoma patients, but this represents an extremely challenging task, as the vast majority of mutations are unique and spread over the entire coding sequence. Since 2001, we have implemented RB1 testing on a routine basis as part of the clinical management of retinoblastoma. As most screening techniques do not meet the requirements for efficient RB1 testing, we have devised a semi-automated denaturing high-performance liquid chromatography (DHPLC) method for point mutation detection combined with a quantitative multiplex PCR of short fluorescent fragments (QMPSF) approach to screen for gene rearrangements. We report the results of this comprehensive screening of all exons and promoter of RB1 in 192 unrelated patients, mostly of French origin. Among 102 bilateral and/or familial cases and 90 unilateral sporadic probands, mutations were identified in 83 (81.5%) and 5 (5.5%) cases, respectively. A total of 43 mutations have not been previously reported. The mutational spectrum was found to be significantly different from previous published series, displaying a surprising amount of splice mutations and large deletions. This study demonstrates the reliability of DHPLC for RB1 analysis, but also illustrates the need for a deletion scanning approach. Finally, considering the benefits to retinoblastoma patients, RB1 testing should be widely implemented in routine healthcare because our study clearly illustrates its feasibility.

Sensitive flow cytometric analysis reveals a novel type of parent-of-origin effect in the mouse genome

The discovery of classic parental imprinting came, at least in part, from the analysis of transgene expression in mice. It was noticed that some transgenes were only expressed following paternal transmission and that others sometimes showed differential patterns of methylation depending on the parent of origin. Here, we present evidence of a novel and more subtle form of parental imprinting by taking advantage of the highly sensitive detection of murine transgene expression afforded by flow cytometry. We have produced nine lines of transgenic mice carrying a GFP reporter linked to the human alpha-globin promoter and enhancer elements, which direct expression to erythroid cells. A high proportion of transgenic lines, four of the nine, display significantly lower levels of expression following maternal transmission. Both the percentage of expressing cells and the mean fluorescence in expressing cells are between 10% and 30% lower following maternal transmission. These effects are reversible upon passage through the opposite germline. This finding raises the possibility that differences in the epigenetic state of the maternal and paternal chromosomes in adult somatic cells are more widespread than was previously thought.

Sensitive and efficient detection of RB1 gene mutations enhances care for families with retinoblastoma

Timely molecular diagnosis of RB1 mutations enables earlier treatment, lower risk, and better health outcomes for patients with retinoblastoma; empowers families to make informed family-planning decisions; and costs less than conventional surveillance. However, complexity has hindered clinical implementation of molecular diagnosis. The majority of RB1 mutations are unique and distributed throughout the RB1 gene, with no real hot spots. We devised a sensitive and efficient strategy to identify RB1 mutations that combines quantitative multiplex polymerase chain reaction (QM-PCR), double-exon sequencing, and promoter-targeted methylation-sensitive PCR. Optimization of test order by stochastic dynamic programming and the development of allele-specific PCR for four recurrent point mutations decreased the estimated turnaround time to <3 wk and decreased direct costs by one-third. The multistep method reported here detected 89% (199/224) of mutations in bilaterally affected probands and both mutant alleles in 84% (112/134) of tumors from unilaterally affected probands. For 23 of 27 exons and the promoter region, QM-PCR was a highly accurate measure of deletions and insertions (accuracy 95%). By revealing those family members who did not carry the mutation found in the related proband, molecular analysis enabled 97 at-risk children from 20 representative families to avoid 313 surveillance examinations under anesthetic and 852 clinic visits. The average savings in direct costs from clinical examinations avoided by children in these families substantially exceeded the cost of molecular testing. Moreover, health care savings continue to accrue, as children in succeeding generations avoid unnecessary repeated anaesthetics and examinations.