Electrical impedance tomography to measure pulmonary perfusion: is the reproducibility high enough for clinical practice?

The Role of Electrical Impedance Tomography for Management of High-Risk Pulmonary Embolism in a Postoperative Patient

Electrical impedance tomography (EIT) is a non-invasive, radiation-free and bedside imaging tool that is widely used for real-time monitoring of lung ventilation. Recently, it has been proposed for use in quantitative assessment of regional lung perfusion with hypertonic saline bolus injection and consequently for pulmonary embolism (PE) detection. Here, we present a case of high-risk PE in a postoperative patient, in which EIT monitoring provided us with useful information for diagnosis and decision-making, especially with the challenge of anticoagulation and risk of bleeding.

A narrative review of electrical impedance tomography in lung diseases with flow limitation and hyperinflation: methodologies and applications

Electrical impedance tomography (EIT) is a functional radiation-free imaging technique that measures regional lung ventilation distribution by calculating the impedance changes in the corresponding regions. The aim of the present review was to summarize the current literature concerning the methodologies and applications of EIT in lung diseases with flow limitation and hyperinflation. PubMed was searched up to May 2020 to identify studies investigating the use of EIT in patients with asthma, bronchiectasis, bronchitis, bronchiolitis, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, and cystic fibrosis. The extracted data included study design, EIT methodologies, interventions, validation and comparators, population characteristics, and key findings. Of the 44 included studies, seven were related to simulation, animal experimentation, or reconstruction algorithm development with evaluation on patients; 27 studies had the primary objective of validating EIT technique and measures including regional ventilation distribution, regional EIT-spirometry parameters, end-expiratory lung impedance, and regional time constants; and 10 studies had the primary objective of applying EIT to monitor the response to therapeutic interventions, including various ventilation supports, patient repositioning, and airway suctioning. In pediatric and adult patients, EIT has been successfully validated for assessing spatial and temporal ventilation distribution, measuring changes in lung volume and flow, and studying regional respiratory mechanics. EIT has also demonstrated potential as an alternative or supplement to well-established measurement modalities (e.g., conventional pulmonary function testing) to monitor the progression of obstructive lung diseases, although the existing literature lacks prediction values as references and lacks clinical outcome evidence.

Monitoring lung impedance changes during long-term ventilator-induced lung injury ventilation using electrical impedance tomography

OBJECTIVE

The target of this methodological evaluation was the feasibility of long-term monitoring of changes in lung conditions by time-difference electrical impedance tomography (tdEIT). In contrast to ventilation monitoring by tdEIT, the monitoring of end-expiratory (EELIC) or end-inspiratory (EILIC) lung impedance change always requires a reference measurement.

APPROACH

To determine the stability of the used Pulmovista 500^® EIT system, as a prerequisite it was initially secured on a resistive phantom for 50 h. By comparing the slopes of EELIC for the whole lung area up to 48 h from 36 pigs ventilated at six positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) levels from 0 to 18 cmH₂O we found a good agreement (range of r ² = 0.93-1.0) between absolute EIT (aEIT) and tdEIT values. This justified the usage of tdEIT with its superior local resolution compared to aEIT for long-term determination of EELIC.

MAIN RESULTS

The EELIC was between -0.07 Ωm day^-1 at PEEP 4 and -1.04 Ωm day^-1 at PEEP 18 cmH₂O. The complex local time pattern for EELIC was roughly quantified by the new parameter, centre of end-expiratory change (CoEEC), in equivalence to the established centre of ventilation (CoV). The ventrally located mean of the CoV was fairly constant in the range of 42%-46% of thorax diameter; however, on the contrary, the CoEEC shifted from about 40% to about 75% in the dorsal direction for PEEP levels of 14 and 18 cmH₂O.

SIGNIFICANCE

The observed shifts started earlier for higher PEEP levels. Changes of EELI could be precisely monitored over a period of 48 h by tdEIT on pigs.

Electrical Impedance Tomography for monitoring cardiac radiofrequency ablation: a scoping review of an emerging technology

Arrhythmias are common cardiac diseases which can be treated effectively by the cardiac radiofrequency ablation (CRFA). However, information regarding the lesion growth within the myocardium is critical to the procedure's safety and efficacy but still unavailable in the current catheterisation lab (CathLab). Over the last 20 years, many efforts have been made in order to track the lesion size during the procedure. Unfortunately, all the approaches have their own limitations preventing them from the clinical translation and hence making the lesion size monitoring during a CRFA still an open issue. Electrical Impedance Tomography (EIT) is an impedance imaging modality that might be able to image the thermal-related impedance changes from which the lesion size can be measured. With the availability of the patient's CT scans, for a detailed model, and the catheter-based electrodes for the internal electrodes, EIT accuracy and sensitivity to the ablated sites can be significantly improved and is worth being explored for this application. Though EIT is still new to CRFA with no in-vivo experiments being done according to our up-to-date searching, many related EIT studies and its extensive research in Hyperthermia and other ablations can reveal many hints for a possibility of the CRFA-EIT application. In this paper, we present a review on multiple aspects of EIT in CRFA. First, the expected CRFA-EIT signal range and frequency are discussed based on various measured impedance results obtained from lesions in the past. Second, the possible noise sources that can happen in a clinical CRFA procedure, along with their signal range and frequency compared to the CRFA-EIT signal, and, third, the available current solutions to separate such noises from the CRFA-EIT signal. Finally, we review the progress of EIT in thermal applications over the last two decades in order to identify the developments that EIT can take advantage of and the current drawbacks that need to be solved for a potential CRFA-EIT application.

EIT based pulsatile impedance monitoring during spontaneous breathing in cystic fibrosis

OBJECTIVE

Evaluating the lung function in patients with obstructive lung disease by electrical impedance tomography (EIT) usually requires breathing maneuvers containing deep inspirations and forced expirations. Since these maneuvers strongly depend on the patient's co-operation and health status, normal tidal breathing was investigated in an attempt to develop continuous maneuver-free measurements.

APPROACH

Ventilation related and pulsatile impedance changes were systematically analyzed during normal tidal breathing in 12 cystic fibrosis (CF) patients and 12 lung-healthy controls (HL). Tidal breaths were subdivided into three inspiratory (In1, In2, In3) and three expiratory (Ex1, Ex2, Ex3) sections of the same amplitude of global impedance change. Maximal changes of the ventilation and the pulsatile impedance signal occurring during these sections were determined (▵I _V and ▵I _P). Differences in ▵I _V and ▵I _P among sections were ascertained in relation to the first inspiratory section. In addition, ▵I _V/▵I _P was calculated for each section.

MAIN RESULTS

Medians of changes in ▵I _V were  <0.05% in all sections for both subject groups. Both groups showed a similar pattern of ▵I _P changes during tidal breathing. Changes in ▵I _P first decreased during inspiration (In2), then increased towards the end of inspiration (In3) and reached a maximum at the beginning of expiration (Ex1). During the last two sections of expiration (Ex2, Ex3) ▵I _P changes decreased. The CF patients showed higher variations in ▵I _P changes compared to the controls (CF:  -426.5%, HL:  -158.1%, coefficient of variation). Furthermore, ▵I _V/▵I _P significantly differed between expiratory sections for the CF patients (Ex1-Ex2, p  <  0.01; Ex1-Ex3, p  <  0.001; Ex2-Ex3, p  <  0.05), but not for the controls. No significant differences in ▵I _V/▵I _P between inspiratory sections were determined for both groups.

SIGNIFICANCE

Differences in ▵I _P changes and in ▵I _V/▵I _P between both subject groups were speculated to be caused by higher breathing efforts of the CF patients due to airway obstruction leading to higher intrathoracic pressures, and thus to greater changes in lung perfusion.

Monitoring of cardiac output and lung ventilation by Electrical Impedance Tomography in a porcine model of acute lung injury

Adequate medical treatment of the Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome is still challenging since patient-individual aspects have to be taken into account. Lung protective ventilation and hemodynamic stability have always been two of the most crucial aims of intensive care therapy. For both aspects, a continuous - preferably non-invasive - monitoring is desirable that is available at the bedside. Unfortunately, there is no technique clinically established yet, that provides both measurement of cardiac stroke volume and ventilation dynamics in real-time. Electrical Impedance Tomography (EIT) is a promising technique to close this gap. The aim of the study was to investigate if stroke volume can be estimated by a self-developed software using EIT-based image analysis. In addition, two EIT-derived parameters, namely Global Inhomogeneity Index (GII) and Impedance Ratio (IR), were calculated to evaluate homogeneity of air distribution. Experimental acute lung injury (ALI) was provoked in seven female pigs (German Landrace) by lipopolysaccharide (LPS). All animals suffered from experimental ALI 3 to 4 hours after LPS infusion. At defined time points, respiratory and hemodynamic parameters, blood gas analyses and EIT-recordings were performed. Eight hours after ALI, animals were euthanized. Stroke volume, derived from pulmonary artery catheter (PAC), decreased continuously up to four hours after ALI. Then, stroke volume increased slightly. Stroke volume, derived from the self-developed tool, showed the same characteristics (p=0.047, r = 0.365). In addition to the GII and IR individually, both classified scores showed a high correlation with the Horowitz Index, defined as p_aO₂/FiO₂. To conclude, EIT-derived measures enabled a reliable estimation of cardiac stroke volume and regional distribution of ventilation.

Comparison of impedance measurements near the skin of newborns and adults

Electrical impedance tomography (EIT) is a non-invasive imaging technology that has been extensively studied for monitoring lung function of neonatal and adult subjects, especially in neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) and intensive care unit (ICU) environments. The sources of the total impedance in these applications include internal organs, near-boundary tissues, electrode-skin impedance, electrodes and conducting wires. This total impedance must be considered for system design and setting voltage gain since it will contribute to the measured voltage. To adapt a single instrument for use on infants and adults, we studied the difference between the impedance near the skin in both classes of patients. We used a simultaneous multi-source EIT (SMS-EIT) system to make impedance measurements. Characteristic resistance was calculated for two different current patterns: one that is more sensitive to boundary region impedance and another that is more sensitive to interior changes. We present ratios of these resistances to assess the relative contribution of near-skin effects to the overall impedance. Twenty adult ICU subjects (10 male, 10 female, age: 49.05  ±  16.32 years (mean  ±  standard deviation)) and 45 neonates (23 male, 22 female, gestational age: 37.67  ±  2.11 weeks, postnatal age, 2.56  ±  2.67 d) were studied at Columbia University Medical Center. Impedance measurements at 10 kHz were collected for approximately one hour from each subject. The characteristic resistance ratio for each subject was computed and analyzed. The result shows the impedance at or near the skin of newborns is significantly higher than in adult subjects.

Parametric electrical impedance tomography for measuring bone mineral density in the pelvis using a computational model

Osteoporosis is defined as bone microstructure deterioration resulting a decrease of bone's strength. Measured bone mineral density (BMD) constitutes the main tool for Osteoporosis diagnosis, management, and defines patient's fracture risk. In the present study, parametric electrical impedance tomography (pEIT) method was examined for monitoring BMD, using a computerized simulation model and preliminary real measurements. A numerical solver was developed to simulate surface potentials measured over a 3D computerized pelvis model. Varying cortical and cancellous BMD were simulated by changing bone conductivity and permittivity. Up to 35% and 16% change was found in the real and imaginary modules of the calculated potential, respectively, while BMD changes from 100% (normal) to 60% (Osteoporosis). Negligible BMD relative error was obtained with SNR>60 [dB]. Position changes errors indicate that for long term monitoring, measurement should be taken at the same geometrical configuration with great accuracy. The numerical simulations were compared to actual measurements that were acquired from a healthy male subject using a five electrodes belt bioimpedance device. The results suggest that pEIT may provide an inexpensive easy to use tool for frequent monitoring BMD in small clinics during pharmacological treatment, as a complementary method to DEXA test.

Real-time 3D electrical impedance imaging for ventilation and perfusion of the lung in lateral decubitus position

We report a prototype Electrical Impedance Imaging System. It is able to detect the gravity-induced changes in the distributions of perfusion and ventilation in the lung between supine and lateral decubitus positions. Impedance data were collected on healthy volunteer subjects and 3D reconstructed images were produced in real-time, 20 frames per second on site, without using averaging or a contrast agent. Imaging data also can be reconstructed offline for further analysis.

Challenging a paradigm: positional changes in ventilation distribution are highly variable in healthy infants and children

RATIONALE

Current understanding is that infants and children preferentially ventilate non-dependent lungs, a reversal of that of adults, based on studies using krypton-81m ventilation scanning. Participants in these studies had lung disease and were either sedated or ventilated. There is little understanding of the distribution of ventilation in spontaneous breathing healthy infants and children.

OBJECTIVES

This study aimed to determine the effects of side lying on the distribution of ventilation in healthy, spontaneously breathing infants and children between the ages of 6 months and 9 years.

METHODS AND MEASUREMENTS

Measurements were taken using electrical impedance tomography (EIT) in supine, left and right side lying. Distribution of ventilation was described using end-expiratory to end-inspiratory relative impedance change.

RESULTS

Fifty-six (31, 55% male) participants were studied. Nineteen (35%) participants consistently showed greater ventilation in the non-dependent lung, eight (15%) consistently showed greater ventilation in the dependent lung and 28 (51%) showed a varied pattern between left and right side lying. Overall, left side lying resulted in significantly better mean ventilation of the right (non-dependent) lung (P < 0.01). Distribution of ventilation in right side lying was relatively equal between left and right lungs.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates that the distribution of ventilation in spontaneously breathing infants and children is not as straightforward as previously described. The distribution of ventilation was variably affected by body position with no clear reversal of the adult pattern evident.

Nanoparticle-enhanced electrical impedance detection and its potential significance in image tomography

The conductivity and permittivity of tumors are known to differ significantly from those of normal tissues. Electrical impedance tomography (EIT) is a relatively new imaging method for exploiting these differences. However, the accuracy of data capture is one of the difficult problems urgently to be solved in the clinical application of EIT technology. A new concept of EIT sensitizers is put forward in this paper with the goal of expanding the contrast ratio of tumor and healthy tissue to enhance EIT imaging quality. The use of nanoparticles for changing tumor characteristics and determining the infiltration vector for easier detection has been widely accepted in the biomedical field. Ultra-pure water, normal saline, and gold nanoparticles, three kinds of material with large differences in electrical characteristics, are considered as sensitizers and undergo mathematical model analysis and animal experimentation. Our preliminary results suggest that nanoparticles are promising for sensitization work. Furthermore, in experimental and simulation results, we found that we should select different sensitizers for the detection of different types and stages of tumor.

Electrical Impedance Tomography for hemodynamic monitoring

Electrical Impedance Tomography (EIT) is a known technique to monitor impedance changes in a cross-section of a body segment, which recently gained increasing interest for regional ventilation monitoring. In this paper, we focus on hemodynamic monitoring using EIT. Past and ongoing research activities to obtain cardiac related signals and regional perfusion information from EIT image streams are summarized. Finally, we present some preliminary results on stroke volume estimation using EIT.

[Electrical impedance tomography in acute lung injury]

Electrical impedance tomography has been described as a new method of monitoring critically ill patients on mechanical ventilation. It has recently gained special interest because of its applicability for monitoring ventilation and pulmonary perfusion. Its bedside and continuous implementation, and the fact that it is a non-ionizing and non-invasive technique, makes it an extremely attractive measurement tool. Likewise, given its ability to assess the regional characteristics of lung structure, it could be considered an ideal monitoring tool in the heterogeneous lung with acute lung injury. This review explains the physical concept of bioimpedance and its clinical application, and summarizes the scientific evidence published to date with regard to the implementation of electrical impedance tomography as a method for monitoring ventilation and perfusion, mainly in the patient with acute lung injury, and other possible applications of the technique in the critically ill patient. The review also summarizes the limitations of the technique and its potential areas of future development.

Electrical impedance tomography applied to assess matching of pulmonary ventilation and perfusion in a porcine experimental model

INTRODUCTION

Electrical impedance tomography (EIT) can be used to measure impedance changes related to the thoracic content of air and blood. Few studies, however, have utilised EIT to make concurrent measurements of ventilation and perfusion. This experimental study was performed to investigate the feasibility of EIT to describe ventilation/perfusion (V/Q) matching after acute changes of pulmonary perfusion and aeration.

METHODS

Six mechanically ventilated, anaesthetised pigs in the supine position were studied at baseline, after inflation of a balloon in the inferior caval vein (Binfl) to reduce cardiac output and after an increased positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) of 20 cmH2O (PEEP20) to increase pulmonary aeration. EIT measurements were performed at the mid-thoracic level to measure the amplitude of impedance changes related to ventilation (ZV) and perfusion (ZQ), both globally and in four defined regions of interest (ROI) extending from the ventral to dorsal distance.

RESULTS

A largely parallel distribution of ZV and ZQ in all four ROIs during baseline conditions corresponded to a bell-shaped frequency distribution of ZV/ZQ ratios with only moderate scatter. Binfl and PEEP20 with unchanged tidal volumes significantly increased the mismatch of regional ZV and ZQ, the scatter of ZV/ZQ ratios and the heterogeneity of the ZV/ZQ frequency distribution. Significant positive and negative correlations were demonstrated between fractional alveolar dead space (r2 = 0.63 [regression coefficient]) and venous admixture (r2 = 0.48), respectively, and the global ZV/ZQ ratio.

CONCLUSIONS

EIT may be used to monitor the distribution of pulmonary ventilation and perfusion making detailed studies of V/Q matching possible.

Reproducibility of regional lung ventilation distribution determined by electrical impedance tomography during mechanical ventilation

Electrical impedance tomography (EIT) has the potential to become a new tool for bedside monitoring of regional lung ventilation. The aim of our study was to assess the reproducibility of regional lung ventilation distribution determined by EIT during mechanical ventilation under identical ventilator settings. The experiments were performed on 10 anaesthetized supine pigs ventilated in a volume-controlled mode. EIT measurements were performed with the Goe-MF II device (Viasys Healthcare, Höchberg, Germany) during repeated changes in positive end-expiratory pressure (PEEP) from 0 to 10 cm H2O. Regional lung ventilation was determined in the right and left hemithorax as well as in 64 regions of interest evenly distributed over each chest side in the ventrodorsal direction. Ventilation distributions in both lungs were visualized as ventrodorsal ventilation profiles and shifts in ventilation distribution quantified in terms of centres of ventilation in relation to the chest diameter. The proportion of the right lung on total ventilation in the chest cross-section was 0.54+/-0.04 and remained unaffected by repetitive PEEP changes. Initial PEEP increase resulted in a redistribution of ventilation towards dorsal lung regions with a shift of the centre of ventilation from 45+/-3% to 49+/-3% of the chest diameter in the right and from 47+/-2% to 50+/-2% in the left hemithorax. Excellent reproducibility of the results in the individual regions of interest with almost identical patterns of ventilation distribution was found during repeated PEEP changes.

Assessment of the Pulmonary Volume Pulse in Idiopathic Pulmonary Arterial Hypertension by Means of Electrical Impedance Tomography

BACKGROUND

Electrical impedance tomography (EIT) is a non-invasive imaging technique which can be used to measure the blood volume changes in the pulmonary vascular bed during the cardiac cycle.

STUDY OBJECTIVES

This study was performed to evaluate the differences in the EIT signal of the pulmonary vascular bed between healthy subjects and patients with idiopathic pulmonary arterial hypertension (IPAH), who are known to have a remodelled pulmonary vascular bed.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Twenty-one patients (17 females, 4 males) with IPAH and 30 healthy controls (5 females, 25 males) were measured. EIT measurements were performed in duplicate, on the same day as right heart catheterization to obtain haemodynamic data. The maximal impedance change during systole (Delta Z(sys)) was used as a measure of the pulmonary volume pulse and expressed in arbitrary units (AU). Total lung capacity, spirometric values and diffusion capacity for carbon monoxide were measured as well.

RESULTS

Mean Delta Z(sys) was 215 +/- 58 x 10(-2) AU (95% CI 193 x 10(-2) to 236 x 10(-2)) in the healthy subjects and 78 +/- 27 x 10(-2) AU (95% CI 66 x 10(-2) to 91 x 10(-2)) in the IPAH patient group (p < 0.0001). No significant correlation was found between Delta Z(sys) and any of the haemodynamic or lung function data.

CONCLUSION

The impedance pulsation of the pulmonary vascular bed is reduced in IPAH in comparison with controls, indicating a reduced volume pulse. This might represent the reduced cross section area, as well as the reduced compliance and number of the pulmonary vessels in these patients.

Imaging cardiac activity by the D-bar method for electrical impedance tomography

A practical D-bar algorithm for reconstructing conductivity changes from EIT data taken on electrodes in a 2D geometry is described. The algorithm is based on the global uniqueness proof of Nachman (1996 Ann. Math. 143 71-96) for the 2D inverse conductivity problem. Results are shown for reconstructions from data collected on electrodes placed around the circumference of a human chest to reconstruct a 2D cross-section of the torso. The images show changes in conductivity during a cardiac cycle.

Resistivity probing of multi-layered tissue phantoms using microelectrodes

We present the use of an array of rectangular microelectrodes to discriminate between different resistivities in a thin, layered sample. Each electrode was 8 mm long and 200 nm thick. The electrode widths ranged from 20 to 500 microm. The electrodes were designed such that all pairs of consecutive electrodes had the same relative geometry, and therefore identical cell constants. A hydrogel-based tissue phantom, made by photopolymerization of 2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate (HEMA), was developed. By changing the hydrogel composition and the ionic strength of the storage medium, the resistivity of the hydrogels could be tuned between 100 omegam and 100 komegam. Using bipolar measurements, the tissue phantoms were characterized in the frequency range from 100 Hz to 30 MHz. The relative resistivity distribution of a three-layered structure composed of 120 microm sheets could be calculated and was shown to agree to within 7% of the bulk measurements. Potential clinical applications for this technique include probing of epithelial tissue and skin cancer screening.

Determinants of pulmonary perfusion measured by electrical impedance tomography

Electrical impedance tomography (EIT) is a non-invasive imaging technique for detecting blood volume changes that can visualize pulmonary perfusion. The two studies reported here tested the hypothesis that the size of the pulmonary microvascular bed, rather than stroke volume (SV), determines the EIT signal. In the first study, the impedance changes relating to the maximal pulmonary pulsatile blood volume during systole (Delta Z(sys)) were measured in ten healthy subjects, ten patients diagnosed with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, who were considered to have a reduced pulmonary vascular bed, and ten heart failure patients with an assumed low cardiac output but with a normal lung parenchyma. Mean Delta Z(sys) (SD) in these groups was 261 (34)x10(-5), 196 (39)x10(-5) ( P<0.001) and 233 (61)x10(-5) arbitrary units (AU) (P=NS), respectively. In the second study, including seven healthy volunteers, Delta Z(sys) was measured at rest and during exercise on a recumbent bicycle while SV was measured by means of magnetic resonance imaging. The Delta Z(sys) at rest was 352 (53)x10(-5 ) and 345 (112)x10(-5 )AU during exercise (P=NS), whereas SV increased from 83 (21) to 105 (34) ml (P<0.05). The EIT signal likely reflects the size of the pulmonary microvascular bed, since neither a low cardiac output nor a change in SV of the heart appear to influence EIT.