Effectiveness and biocompatibility of a novel biological adhesive application for repair of meniscal tear on the avascular zone

Current Concepts on Tissue Adhesive Use for Meniscal Repair-We Are Not There Yet: A Systematic Review of the Literature

BACKGROUND

Tissue adhesives (TAs) represent a promising alternative or augmentation method to conventional tissue repair techniques. In sports medicine, TA use has been suggested and implemented in the treatment of meniscal tears. The aim of this review was to present and discuss the current evidence and base of knowledge regarding the clinical usage of TAs for meniscal repair.

STUDY DESIGN

Systematic review; Level of evidence, 4.

METHODS

A systematic literature search was performed using the PubMed, Embase, and Cochrane Library databases for studies reporting on clinical outcomes of TA usage for meniscal repair in humans in the English language published before January 2020.

RESULTS

Ten studies were eligible for review and included 352 meniscal repairs: 94 (27%) were TA-based repairs and 258 (73%) were combined suture and TA repairs. Concomitant anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction was performed in 224 repairs (64%). All included studies utilized fibrin-based TA. Of the 10 studies, 9 were evidence level 4 (case series), and 8 reported on a cohort of ≤40 meniscal repairs. Rates of meniscal healing were evaluated in 9 of 10 studies, with repair failure seen in 39 repairs (11%).

CONCLUSION

The use of TAs, specifically fibrin-based TAs, for meniscal repair shows good results as either an augmentation or primary repair of various configurations of meniscal tears. However, this review reveals an absence of comparative high-quality evidence supporting the routine use of TAs for meniscal repair and emphasizes the lack of an ideal TA designed for that purpose. Further high-quality research, basic science and clinical, will facilitate the development of new materials and enable testing their suitability for use in meniscal repair.

Rapid in situ cross-linking of hydrogel adhesives based on thiol-grafted bio-inspired catechol-conjugated chitosan

In this paper, a novel chitosan derivative, thiol-grafting bio-inspired catechol-conjugated chitosan was synthesized. The chemical structure of the synthesized catechol-conjugated chitosan was verified by ¹H NMR, and its contents of thiol group and catechol group were determined by UV-vis spectrum. Four percent of catechol-conjugated chitosan aqueous solution could form hydrogels rapidly in situ in 1 min or less with the addition of sodium periodate. Rheological studies showed that the mechanical properties depend on the concentrations of catechol-conjugated chitosan and the molar ratio of sodium periodate to catechol groups. Additionally, the adhesive properties of the resulting adhesives were evaluated, and the adhesion strength of obtained adhesives was as high as 50 kPa because of the complex and multiple interactions, especially the anti-oxidation mechanism of thiol group. The in vitro cytotoxicity assays demonstrated an excellent biocompatibility of the catechol-conjugated chitosan hydrogels. Benefiting from the in situ fast cured, desired mechanical strength, biocompatibility and relatively high adhesion performance, these properties suggested that catechol-conjugated chitosan hydrogel adhesives have potential applications as tissue adhesive for soft tissues.

Relevance of meniscal cell regional phenotype to tissue engineering

PURPOSE

Meniscus contains heterogeneous populations of cells that have not been fully characterized. Cell phenotype is often lost during culture; however, culture expansion is typically required for tissue engineering. We examined and compared cell-surface molecule expression levels on human meniscus cells from the vascular and avascular regions and articular chondrocytes while documenting changes during culture-induced dedifferentiation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Expressions of 16 different surface molecules were examined by flow cytometry after monolayer culture for 24 h, 1 week, and 2 weeks. Menisci were also immunostained to document the spatial distributions of selected surface molecules.

RESULTS

Meniscus cells and chondrocytes exhibited several similarities in surface molecule profiles with dynamic changes during culture. A greater percentage of meniscal cells were positive for CD14, CD26, CD49c, and CD49f compared to articular chondrocytes. Initially, more meniscal cells from the vascular region were positive for CD90 compared to cells from the avascular region or chondrocytes. Cells from the vascular region also expressed higher levels of CD166 and CD271 compared to cells from the avascular region. CD90, CD166, and CD271-positive cells were predominately perivascular in location. However, CD166-positive cells were also located in the superficial layer and in the adjacent synovial and adipose tissue.

CONCLUSIONS

These surface marker profiles provide a target phenotype for differentiation of progenitors in tissue engineering. The spatial location of progenitor cells in meniscus is consistent with higher regenerative capacity of the vascular region, while the surface progenitor subpopulations have potential to be utilized in tears created in the avascular region.

Tissue adhesives for meniscus tear repair: an overview of current advances and prospects for future clinical solutions

Menisci are crucial structures in the knee joint as they play important functions in load transfer, maintaining joint stability and in homeostasis of articular cartilage. Unfortunately, ones of the most frequently occurring knee injuries are meniscal tears. Particularly tears in the avascular zone of the meniscus usually do not heal spontaneously and lead to pain, swelling and locking of the knee joint. Eventually, after a (partial) meniscectomy, they will lead to osteoarthritis. Current treatment modalities to repair tears and by that restore the integrity of the native meniscus still carry their drawbacks and a new robust solution is desired. A strong tissue adhesive could provide such a solution and could potentially improve on sutures, which are the current gold standard. Moreover, a glue could serve as a carrier for biological compounds known to enhance tissue healing. Only few tissue adhesives, e.g., Dermabond(®) and fibrin glue, are already successfully used in clinical practice for other applications, but are not considered suitable for gluing meniscus tissue due to their sub-optimal mechanical properties or toxicity. There is a growing interest and research field focusing on the development of novel polymer-based tissue adhesives, but up to now, there is no material specially designed for the repair of meniscal tears. In this review, we discuss the current clinical gold standard treatment of meniscal tears and present an overview of new developments in this field. Moreover, we discuss the properties of different tissue adhesives for their potential use in meniscal tear repair. Finally, we formulate recommendations regarding the design criteria of material properties and adhesive strength for clinically applicable glues for meniscal tears.

Shear lag sutures: Improved suture repair through the use of adhesives

Suture materials and surgical knot tying techniques have improved dramatically since their first use over five millennia ago. However, the approach remains limited by the ability of the suture to transfer load to tissue at suture anchor points. Here, we predict that adhesive-coated sutures can improve mechanical load transfer beyond the range of performance of existing suture methods, thereby strengthening repairs and decreasing the risk of failure. The mechanical properties of suitable adhesives were identified using a shear lag model. Examination of the design space for an optimal adhesive demonstrated requirements for strong adhesion and low stiffness to maximize the strength of the adhesive-coated suture repair construct. To experimentally assess the model, we evaluated single strands of sutures coated with highly flexible cyanoacrylates (Loctite 4903 and 4902), cyanoacrylate (Loctite QuickTite Instant Adhesive Gel), rubber cement, rubber/gasket adhesive (1300 Scotch-Weld Neoprene High Performance Rubber & Gasket Adhesive), an albumin-glutaraldehyde adhesive (BioGlue), or poly(dopamine). As a clinically relevant proof-of-concept, cyanoacrylate-coated sutures were then used to perform a clinically relevant flexor digitorum tendon repair in cadaver tissue. The repair performed with adhesive-coated suture had significantly higher strength compared to the standard repair without adhesive. Notably, cyanoacrylate provides strong adhesion with high stiffness and brittle behavior, and is therefore not an ideal adhesive for enhancing suture repair. Nevertheless, the improvement in repair properties in a clinically relevant setting, even using a non-ideal adhesive, demonstrates the potential for the proposed approach to improve outcomes for treatments requiring suture fixation. Further study is necessary to develop a strongly adherent, compliant adhesive within the optimal design space described by the model.