Optimal voltage stimulation parameters for network-mediated responses in wild type and rd10 mouse retinal ganglion cells

Improvements for recording retinal function with Microelectrode Arrays

A microelectrode array (MEA) is a configuration of multiple electrodes that enables the concurrent targeting of multiple sites for extracellular recording and stimulation. By utilizing light pulses or electrical stimulations, MEA recordings unveil the complex patterns of electrical activities that arise from the signaling processes within the retinal network. Here, we present a stepwise approach for using microelectrode arrays (MEAs) for recording action potentials from the mouse retina in response to electrical and light stimuli. We provide detailed techniques accompanied by description of a custom optical system, example recordings, troubleshooting guidelines, and data processing methods including spike sorting and code resources for analyzing light and electrical responses. The comprehensive nature of this paper aims to guide researchers in utilizing MEAs effectively for investigating retinal functionality. In particular, it can be easy to have a MEA experiment fail, but hard to identify the source of the failure. This paper is meant to demystify that process. It includes:•A description of MEA setup, recording, and spike data validation.•A troubleshooting guide for common failure modes in MEA recordings from mouse retina.•Spike detection and sorting to precisely extract distinctive action potential.

Neural extracellular matrix regulates visual sensory motor integration

Visual processing depends on sensitive and balanced synaptic neurotransmission. Extracellular matrix proteins in the environment of cells are key modulators in synaptogenesis and synaptic plasticity. In the present study, we provide evidence that the combined loss of the four extracellular matrix components, brevican, neurocan, tenascin-C, and tenascin-R, in quadruple knockout mice leads to severe retinal dysfunction and diminished visual motion processing in vivo. Remarkably, impaired visual motion processing was accompanied by a developmental loss of cholinergic direction-selective starburst amacrine cells. Additionally, we noted imbalance of inhibitory and excitatory synaptic signaling in the quadruple knockout retina. Collectively, the study offers insights into the functional importance of four key extracellular matrix proteins for retinal function, visual motion processing, and synaptic signaling.

Bi-directional electrical recording and stimulation of the intact retina with a screen-printed soft probe: a feasibility study

Introduction

Electrophysiological investigations of intact neural circuits are challenged by the gentle and complex nature of neural tissues. Bi-directional electrophysiological interfacing with the retina, in its intact form, is particularly demanding and currently there is no feasible approach to achieve such investigations. Here we present a feasibility study of a novel soft multi-electrode array suitable for bi-directional electrophysiological study of the intact retina.

Methods

Screen-printed soft electrode arrays were developed and tested. The soft probes were designed to accommodate the curvature of the retina in the eye and offer an opportunity to study the retina in its intact form.

Results

For the first time, we show both electrical recording and stimulation capabilities from the intact retina. In particular, we demonstrate the ability to characterize retina responses to electrical stimulation and reveal stable, direct, and indirect responses compared with ex-vivo conditions.

Discussion

These results demonstrate the unique performances of the new probe while also suggesting that intact retinas retain better stability and robustness than ex-vivo retinas making them more suitable for characterizing retina responses to electrical stimulation.

Simulating the impact of photoreceptor loss and inner retinal network changes on electrical activity of the retina

Objective.A major reason for poor visual outcomes provided by existing retinal prostheses is the limited knowledge of the impact of photoreceptor loss on retinal remodelling and its subsequent impact on neural responses to electrical stimulation. Computational network models of the neural retina assist in the understanding of normal retinal function but can be also useful for investigating diseased retinal responses to electrical stimulation.Approach.We developed and validated a biophysically detailed discrete neuronal network model of the retina in the software package NEURON. The model includes rod and cone photoreceptors, ON and OFF bipolar cell pathways, amacrine and horizontal cells and finally, ON and OFF retinal ganglion cells with detailed network connectivity and neural intrinsic properties. By accurately controlling the network parameters, we simulated the impact of varying levels of degeneration on retinal electrical function.Main results.Our model was able to reproduce characteristic monophasic and biphasic oscillatory patterns seen in ON and OFF neurons during retinal degeneration (RD). Oscillatory activity occurred at 3 Hz with partial photoreceptor loss and at 6 Hz when all photoreceptor input to the retina was removed. Oscillations were found to gradually weaken, then disappear when synapses and gap junctions were destroyed in the inner retina. Without requiring any changes to intrinsic cellular properties of individual inner retinal neurons, our results suggest that changes in connectivity alone were sufficient to give rise to neural oscillations during photoreceptor degeneration, and significant network connectivity destruction in the inner retina terminated the oscillations.Significance.Our results provide a platform for further understanding physiological retinal changes with progressive photoreceptor and inner RD. Furthermore, our model can be used to guide future stimulation strategies for retinal prostheses to benefit patients at different stages of disease progression, particularly in the early and mid-stages of RD.

Differences in the spatial fidelity of evoked and spontaneous signals in the degenerating retina

Vision restoration strategies aim to reestablish vision by replacing the function of lost photoreceptors with optoelectronic hardware or through gene therapy. One complication to these approaches is that retinal circuitry undergoes remodeling after photoreceptor loss. Circuit remodeling following perturbation is ubiquitous in the nervous system and understanding these changes is crucial for treating neurodegeneration. Spontaneous oscillations that arise during retinal degeneration have been well-studied, however, other changes in the spatiotemporal processing of evoked and spontaneous activity have received less attention. Here we use subretinal electrical stimulation to measure the spatial and temporal spread of both spontaneous and evoked activity during retinal degeneration. We found that electrical stimulation synchronizes spontaneous oscillatory activity, over space and through time, thus leading to increased correlations in ganglion cell activity. Intriguingly, we found that spatial selectivity was maintained in rd10 retina for evoked responses, with spatial receptive fields comparable to wt retina. These findings indicate that different biophysical mechanisms are involved in mediating feed forward excitation, and the lateral spread of spontaneous activity in the rd10 retina, lending support toward the possibility of high-resolution vision restoration.

An in-silico analysis of electrically-evoked responses of midget and parasol retinal ganglion cells in different retinal regions

BACKGROUND

Visual outcomes provided by present retinal prostheses that primarily target retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) through epiretinal stimulation remain rudimentary, partly due to the limited knowledge of retinal responses under electrical stimulation. Better understanding of how different retinal regions can be quantitatively controlled with high spatial accuracy, will be beneficial to the design of micro-electrode arrays (MEAs) and stimulation strategies for next-generation wide-view, high-resolution epiretinal implants.

METHODS

A computational model was developed to assess neural activity at different eccentricities (2 mm and 5 mm) within the human retina. This model included midget and parasol RGCs with anatomically accurate cell distribution and cell-specific morphological information. We then performed in silico investigations of region-specific RGC responses to epiretinal electrical stimulation using varied electrode sizes (5 µm - 210 µm diameter), emulating both commercialized retinal implants and recently-developed prototype devices.

RESULTS

Our model of epiretinal stimulation predicted RGC population excitation analogous to the complex percepts reported in human subjects. Following this, our simulations suggest that midget and parasol RGCs have characteristic regional differences in excitation under preferred electrode sizes. Relatively central (2 mm) regions demonstrated higher number of excited RGCs but lower overall activated receptive field (RF) areas under the same stimulus amplitudes (two-way ANOVA, p < 0.05). Furthermore, the activated RGC numbers per unit active RF area (number-RF ratio) were significantly higher in central than in peripheral regions, and higher in the midget than in the parasol population under all tested electrode sizes (two-way ANOVA, p < 0.05). Our simulations also suggested that smaller electrodes exhibit a higher range of controllable stimulation parameters to achieve pre-defined performance of RGC excitation. ..

Classification of pseudocalcium visual responses from mouse retinal ganglion cells

Recently, a detailed catalog of 32 retinal ganglion cell (RGC) visual response patterns in mouse has emerged. However, the 10,000 samples required for this catalog-based on fluorescent signals from a calcium indicator dye-are much harder to acquire from the extracellular spike train recordings underlying our bionic vision research. Therefore, we sought to convert spike trains into pseudocalcium signals so that our data could be directly matched to the 32 predefined, calcium signal-based groups. A microelectrode array (MEA) was used to record spike trains from mouse RGCs of 29 retinas. Visual stimuli were adapted from the Baden et al. study; including moving bars, full-field contrast and temporal frequency chirps, and black-white and UV-green color flashes. Spike train histograms were converted into pseudocalcium traces with an OGB-1 convolution kernel. Response features were extracted using sparse principal components analysis to match each RGC to one of the 32 RGC groups. These responses mapped onto of the 32 previously described groups; however, some of the groups remained unmatched. Thus, adaptation of the Baden et al. methodology for MEA recordings of spike trains instead of calcium recordings was partially successful. Different classification methods, however, will be needed to define clear RGC groups from MEA data for our bionic vision research. Nevertheless, others may pursue a pseudocalcium approach to reconcile spike trains with calcium signals. This work will help to guide them on the limitations and potential pitfalls of such an approach.

The Effect of Electrical Stimulation on the Response of Mouse Retinal Ganglion Cells

Retinal prostheses can restore the basic visual function of patients with retinal degeneration, which relies on effective electrical stimulation to evoke the physiological activities of retinal ganglion cells (RGCs). Current electrical stimulation strategies suffer from unstable effects and insufficient stimulation positions. Therefore, it is crucial to determine the optimal parameters for precise and safe electrical stimulation. Biphasic voltages (cathode-first) with a pulse width of 25 ms and different amplitudes were used to ex vivo stimulate RGCs of three wild-type (WT) mice using a commercial microelectrode array (MEA) recording system. Based on a facile and efficient spike sorting method, comprehensive statistics of RGCs response types were performed, and the influence of electrical stimulation on RGCs response status was analyzed. There were three types of RGCs response measured from the retinas of three WT mice, and the proportions were calculated to be 91.5%, 3.11% and 5.39%, respectively. This work can provide an in-depth understanding of the internal effects of electrical stimulation and RGCs response, with the potential as a useful guidance for optimizing parameters of electrical stimulation strategies in retinal prostheses.

A facile and comprehensive algorithm for electrical response identification in mouse retinal ganglion cells

Retinal prostheses can restore the basic visual function of patients with retinal degeneration, which relies on effective electrical stimulation to evoke the physiological activities of retinal ganglion cells (RGCs). Current electrical stimulation strategies have defects such as unstable effects and insufficient stimulation positions, therefore, it is crucial to determine the optimal pulse parameters for precise and safe electrical stimulation. Biphasic voltages (cathode-first) with a pulse width of 25 ms and different amplitudes were used to ex vivo stimulate RGCs of three wild-type (WT) mice using a commercial microelectrode array (MEA) recording system. An algorithm is developed to automatically realize both spike-sorting and electrical response identification for the spike signals recorded. Measured from three WT mouse retinas, the total numbers of RGC units and responsive RGC units were 1193 and 151, respectively. In addition, the optimal pulse amplitude range for electrical stimulation was determined to be 0.43 V-1.3 V. The processing results of the automatic algorithm we proposed shows high consistency with those using traditional manual processing. We anticipate the new algorithm can not only speed up the elaborate electrophysiological data processing, but also optimize pulse parameters for the electrical stimulation strategy of neural prostheses.

Targeted Stimulation of Retinal Ganglion Cells in Epiretinal Prostheses: A Multiscale Computational Study

Retinal prostheses aim at restoring partial sight to patients that are blind due to retinal degenerative diseases by electrically stimulating the surviving healthy retinal neurons. Ideally, the electrical stimulation of the retina is intended to induce localized, focused, percepts only; however, some epiretinal implant subjects have reported seeing elongated phosphenes in a single electrode stimulation due to the axonal activation of retinal ganglion cells (RGCs). This issue can be addressed by properly devising stimulation waveforms so that the possibility of inducing axonal activation of RGCs is minimized. While strategies to devise electrical stimulation waveforms to achieve a focal RGCs response have been reported in literature, the underlying mechanisms are not well understood. This article intends to address this gap; we developed morphologically and biophysically realistic computational models of two classified RGCs: D1-bistratified and A2-monostratified. Computational results suggest that the sodium channel band (SOCB) is less sensitive to modulations in stimulation parameters than the distal axon (DA), and DA stimulus threshold is less sensitive to physiological differences among RGCs. Therefore, over a range of RGCs distal axon diameters, short-pulse symmetric biphasic waveforms can enhance the stimulation threshold difference between the SOCB and the DA. Appropriately designed waveforms can avoid axonal activation of RGCs, implying a consequential reduction of undesired strikes in the visual field.

Towards Controlling Functionally-Distinct Retinal Ganglion Cells In Degenerate Retina

Present retinal neuroprostheses have limited performance capabilities due to indiscriminate activation of different neural pathways. Based on our success in differentially activating ON and OFF cells using high frequency stimuli in a healthy retina, in this study we explored whether we could achieve similar differential activation between these two cell types but in degenerate retina. We found that after blocking the synaptic network, ON retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) could be differentially activated at higher frequencies (4 - 6 kHz) and amplitudes (200 - 240 µA), and OFF RGCs at relatively lower amplitudes (80 - 160 µA) across all tested frequencies. We further found that both cell types could be controlled by quickly modulating the frequency using short stimulation bursts. This work takes us one step closer to reducing the likelihood of indiscriminate activation of RGCs by accurately controlling the activation of functionally-distinct neural pathways.

Retinal Degeneration Reduces Consistency of Network-Mediated Responses Arising in Ganglion Cells to Electric Stimulation

Retinal prostheses use periodic repetition of electrical stimuli to form artificial vision. To enhance the reliability of evoked visual percepts, repeating stimuli need to evoke consistent spiking activity in individual retinal ganglion cells (RGCs). However, it is not well known whether outer retinal degeneration alters the consistency of RGC responses. Hence, here we systematically investigated the trial-to-trial variability in network-mediated responses as a function of the degeneration level. We patch-clamp recorded spikes in ON and OFF types of alpha RGCs from r d10 mice at four different postnatal days (P15, P19, P31, and P60), representing distinct stages of degeneration. To assess the consistency of responses, we analyzed variances in spike count and timing across repeats of the same stimulus delivered multiple times. We found the trial-to-trial variability of network-mediated responses increased considerably as the disease progressed. Compared to responses taken before degeneration onset, those of degenerate retinas showed up to ~70% higher variability (Fano Factor) in spike counts (p < 0.001) and ~95% lower correlation level in spike timing (p < 0.001). These results indicate consistency weakens significantly in electrically-evoked network-mediated responses and therefore raise concerns about the ability of microelectronic retinal implants to elicit consistent visual percepts at advanced stages of retinal degeneration.

Stimulation Strategies for Improving the Resolution of Retinal Prostheses

Electrical stimulation using implantable devices with arrays of stimulating electrodes is an emerging therapy for neurological diseases. The performance of these devices depends greatly on their ability to activate populations of neurons with high spatiotemporal resolution. To study electrical stimulation of populations of neurons, retina serves as a useful model because the neural network is arranged in a planar array that is easy to access. Moreover, retinal prostheses are under development to restore vision by replacing the function of damaged light sensitive photoreceptors, which makes retinal research directly relevant for curing blindness. Here we provide a progress review on stimulation strategies developed in recent years to improve the resolution of electrical stimulation in retinal prostheses. We focus on studies performed with explanted retinas, in which electrophysiological techniques are the most advanced. We summarize achievements in improving the spatial and temporal resolution of electrical stimulation of the retina and methods to selectively stimulate neurons with different visual functions. Future directions for retinal prostheses development are also discussed, which could provide insights for other types of neuromodulatory devices in which high-resolution electrical stimulation is required.

Probing and predicting ganglion cell responses to smooth electrical stimulation in healthy and blind mouse retina

Retinal implants are used to replace lost photoreceptors in blind patients suffering from retinopathies such as retinitis pigmentosa. Patients wearing implants regain some rudimentary visual function. However, it is severely limited compared to normal vision because non-physiological stimulation strategies fail to selectively activate different retinal pathways at sufficient spatial and temporal resolution. The development of improved stimulation strategies is rendered difficult by the large space of potential stimuli. Here we systematically explore a subspace of potential stimuli by electrically stimulating healthy and blind mouse retina in epiretinal configuration using smooth Gaussian white noise delivered by a high-density CMOS-based microelectrode array. We identify linear filters of retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) by fitting a linear-nonlinear-Poisson (LNP) model. Our stimulus evokes spatially and temporally confined spiking responses in RGC which are accurately predicted by the LNP model. Furthermore, we find diverse shapes of linear filters in the linear stage of the model, suggesting diverse preferred electrical stimuli of RGCs. The linear filter base identified by our approach could provide a starting point of a model-guided search for improved stimuli for retinal prosthetics.

New Features of Receptive Fields in Mouse Retina through Spike-triggered Covariance

Retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) encode various spatiotemporal features of visual information into spiking patterns. The receptive field (RF) of each RGC is usually calculated by spike-triggered average (STA), which is fast and easy to understand, but limited to simple and unimodal RFs. As an alternative, spike-triggered covariance (STC) has been proposed to characterize more complex patterns in RFs. This study compares STA and STC for the characterization of RFs and demonstrates that STC has an advantage over STA for identifying novel spatiotemporal features of RFs in mouse RGCs. We first classified mouse RGCs into ON, OFF, and ON/OFF cells according to their response to full-field light stimulus, and then investigated the spatiotemporal patterns of RFs with random checkerboard stimulation, using both STA and STC analysis. We propose five sub-types (T1–T5) in the STC of mouse RGCs together with their physiological implications. In particular, the relatively slow biphasic pattern (T1) could be related to excitatory inputs from bipolar cells. The transient biphasic pattern (T2) allows one to characterize complex patterns in RFs of ON/OFF cells. The other patterns (T3–T5), which are contrasting, alternating, and monophasic patterns, could be related to inhibitory inputs from amacrine cells. Thus, combining STA and STC and considering the proposed sub-types unveil novel characteristics of RFs in the mouse retina and offer a more holistic understanding of the neural coding mechanisms of mouse RGCs.

Optimal Electric Stimulus Amplitude Improves the Selectivity Between Responses of ON Versus OFF Types of Retinal Ganglion Cells

Outer retinal degenerative diseases destroy photoreceptors primarily in the retina, resulting in a profound vision loss. Fortunately, surviving retinal neurons can be electrically stimulated using retinal prostheses to re-transmit visual information. Although retinal prostheses are promising for sight restoration, the best performance is still sub-optimal. For the enhanced performance, it is critical to optimize stimulation parameters. This study explored how stimulus charge and current amplitude alters responses of retinal ganglion cells (RGCs). From the isolated mouse retina, spiking activities of alpha ON, OFF sustained, and OFF transient RGCs were recorded in response to epiretinally-delivered cathodal current pulses ranging from -10 to [Formula: see text]. We have found that intermediate current amplitudes (-30 and [Formula: see text]) maximize the response ratio of ON over OFF types. Also, the ON/OFF response ratio was always bigger for 10-ms-long than 5-ms-long stimuli. It was because, by the longer pulses, ON RGC responses were always significantly enhanced ( ) while OFF RGC responses were minimally changed ( ). Given the earlier work reporting electrically-elicited responses are more natural in ON than OFF RGCs, the present study suggests effect strategies of more selective activation of ON RGCs for improved efficacy of retinal implant.

Toward a Bidirectional Communication Between Retinal Cells and a Prosthetic Device - A Proof of Concept

Background: Significant progress toward the recovery of useful vision in blind patients with severe degenerative retinal diseases caused by photoreceptor death has been achieved with the development of visual prostheses that stimulate the retina electrically. However, currently used prostheses do not provide feedback about the retinal activity before and upon stimulation and do not adjust to changes during the remodeling processes in the retina. Both features are desirable to improve the efficiency of the electrical stimulation (ES) therapy offered by these devices. Accordingly, devices that not only enable ES but at the same time provide information about the retinal activity are beneficial. Given the above, a bidirectional communication strategy, in which inner retinal cells are stimulated and the output neurons of the retina, the ganglion cells, are recorded using penetrating microelectrode arrays (MEAs) is proposed.

Methods: Custom-made penetrating MEAs with four silicon-based shanks, each one with three or four iridium oxide electrodes specifically designed to match retinal dimensions were used to record the activity of light-adapted wildtype mice retinas and degenerated retinas from rd10 mice in vitro. In addition, responses to high potassium concentration and to light stimulation in wildtype retinas were examined. Furthermore, voltage-controlled ES was performed.

Results: The spiking activity of retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) was recorded at different depths of penetration inside the retina. Physiological responses during an increase of the extracellular potassium concentration and phasic and tonic responses during light stimulation were captured. Moreover, pathologic rhythmic activity was recorded from degenerated retinas. Finally, ES of the inner retina and simultaneous recording of the activity of RGCs was accomplished.

Conclusion: The access to different layers of the retina with penetrating electrodes while recording at the same time the spiking activity of RGCs broadens the use and the field of action of multi-shank and multi-site penetrating MEAs for retinal applications. It enables a bidirectional strategy to stimulate inner retinal cells electrically and to record from the spiking RGCs simultaneously (BiMEA). This opens the possibility of a feedback loop system to acknowledge the success of ES carried out by retinal prostheses.

Differential electrical responses in retinal ganglion cell subtypes: effects of synaptic blockade and stimulating electrode location

OBJECTIVE

Visual prostheses have shown promising results in restoring visual perception to blind patients. The ability to differentially activate retinal ganglion cell (RGC) subtypes could further improve the efficacy of these medical devices.

APPROACH

Using whole-cell patch clamp, we investigated membrane potential differences between ON and OFF RGCs in the mouse retina when their synaptic inputs were blocked by synaptic blockers, and examined the differences in stimulation thresholds under such conditions. By injecting intracellular current, we further confirmed the relationship between RGC stimulation thresholds and resting membrane potentials (RMPs). In addition, we investigated the effects of stimulating electrode location on the differences in stimulation thresholds between ON and OFF RGCs.

MAIN RESULTS

With synaptic blockade, ON RGCs became significantly more hyperpolarized (from  -61.8  ±  1.4 mV to  -70.8  ±  1.6 mV), while OFF RGCs depolarized slightly (from  -60.5  ±  0.7 mV to  -58.6  ±  0.9 mV). RGC stimulation thresholds were negatively correlated with their RMPs (Pearson r value:  -0.5154; p-value: 0.0042). Thus, depriving ON RGCs of synaptic inputs significantly increased their thresholds (from 14.7  ±  1.3 µA to 22.3  ±  2.1 µA) over those of OFF RGCs (from 13.2  ±  0.7 µA to 13.1  ±  1.1 µA). However, with control solution, ON and OFF RGC stimulation thresholds were not significantly different. Finally, placement of the stimulating electrode away from the axon enhanced differences in stimulation thresholds between ON and OFF RGCs, facilitating preferential activation of OFF RGCs.

SIGNIFICANCE

Since ON and OFF RGCs have antagonistic responses to natural light, achieving differential RGC activation could convey more natural visual information, leading to better visual prosthesis outcomes.

Electric stimulus duration alters network-mediated responses depending on retinal ganglion cell type

OBJECTIVE

To improve the quality of artificial vision that arises from retinal prostheses, it is important to bring electrically-elicited neural activity more in line with the physiological signaling patterns that arise normally in the healthy retina. Our previous study reported that indirect activation produces a closer match to physiological responses in ON retinal ganglion cells (RGCs) than in OFF cells (Im and Fried 2015 J. Physiol. 593 3677-96). This suggests that a preferential activation of ON RGCs would shape the overall retinal response closer to natural signaling. Recently, we found that changes to the rate at which stimulation was delivered could bias responses towards a stronger ON component (Im and Fried 2016a J. Neural Eng. 13 025002), raising the possibility that changes to other stimulus parameters can similarly bias towards stronger ON responses. Here, we explore the effects of changing stimulus duration on the responses in ON and OFF types of brisk transient (BT) and brisk sustained (BS) RGCs.

APPROACH

We used cell-attached patch clamp to record RGC spiking in the isolated rabbit retina. Targeted RGCs were first classified as ON or OFF type by their light responses, and further sub-classified as BT or BS types by their responses to both light and electric stimuli. Spiking in targeted RGCs was recorded in response to electric pulses with durations varying from 5 to100 ms. Stimulus amplitude was adjusted at each duration to hold total charge constant for all experiments.

MAIN RESULTS

We found that varying stimulus durations modulated responses differentially for ON versus OFF cells: in ON cells, spike counts decreased significantly with increasing stimulus duration while in OFF cells the changes were more modest. The maximum ratio of ON versus OFF responses occurred at a duration of ~10 ms. The difference in response strength for BT versus BS cells was much larger in ON cells than in OFF cells.

SIGNIFICANCE

The stimulation rates preferred by subjects during clinical trials are similar to the rates that maximize the ON/OFF response ratio in in vitro testing (Im and Fried 2016a J. Neural Eng. 13 025002). Here, we determine the stimulus duration that produces the strongest bias towards ON responses and speculate that it will further enhance clinical effectiveness.