Analysis of testes and semen from rabbits treated by intravenous injection with a retroviral vector encoding the human factor VIII gene: no evidence of germ line transduction

Regulatory Consideration for the Nonclinical Safety Assessment of Gene Therapies

The nonclinical safety assessments for gene therapies are evolving, leveraging over 20 years of experimental and clinical experience. Despite the growing experience with these therapeutics, there are no approved harmonized global regulatory documents for developing gene therapies with only the ICH (International Council for Harmonization of Technical Requirements for Pharmaceuticals for Human Use) S12 guidance on nonclinical biodistribution currently under discussion. Several health authorities have issued guidance over the last 15 years on the nonclinical safety aspects for gene therapy products, but many of the recommendations are limited to high-level concepts on nonclinical safety aspects or altogether silent on key topics. Historically, this approach was appropriately vague given our relatively small dataset of nonclinical experience, where a comprehensive and detailed regulatory guidance approach was unlikely to be appropriate to address all scenarios. However, harmonization of key considerations and assumptions can provide a consistent basis for developing the appropriate nonclinical safety development plans for individual programs, reducing uncertainty across regulatory regions and unnecessary animal use. Several key areas of nonclinical safety testing are nearing maturation for a harmonized approach, including species selection, certain aspects of study design, study duration, and unintended genomic integration risks. Furthermore, several emerging topics are unaddressed in current regulatory guidance for gene therapy products, which will become key areas of differentiation for the next generation of therapeutics. These topics include redosing, juvenile/pediatric safety, and reproductive/developmental safety testing, where relevant experience from other modalities can be applied. The rationale and potential study design considerations for these topics will be proposed, acknowledging that certain aspects of gene therapy development are not considered appropriate for harmonization. This article provides an overview of the current nonclinical safety regulatory landscape, summarizes typical nonclinical safety study designs, highlights areas of uncertainty, and discusses emerging topics that warrant consideration. Specific recommendations and perspectives are provided to inform future regulatory discussions and harmonization efforts.

Intravenous administration of retroviral replicating vector, Toca 511, demonstrates therapeutic efficacy in orthotopic immune-competent mouse glioma model

Toca 511 (vocimagene amiretrorepvec), a nonlytic, amphotropic retroviral replicating vector (RRV), encodes and delivers a functionally optimized yeast cytosine deaminase (CD) gene to tumors. In orthotopic glioma models treated with Toca 511 and 5-fluorocytosine (5-FC) the CD enzyme within infected cells converts 5-FC to 5-fluorouracil (5-FU), resulting in tumor killing. Toca 511, delivered locally either by intratumoral injection or by injection into the resection bed, in combination with subsequent oral extended-release 5-FC (Toca FC), is under clinical investigation in patients with recurrent high-grade glioma (HGG). If feasible, intravenous administration of vectors is less invasive, can easily be repeated if desired, and may be applicable to other tumor types. Here, we present preclinical data that support the development of an intravenous administration protocol. First we show that intravenous administration of Toca 511 in a preclinical model did not lead to widespread or uncontrolled replication of the RVV. No, or low, viral DNA was found in the blood and most of the tissues examined 180 days after Toca 511 administration. We also show that RRV administered intravenously leads to efficient infection and spread of the vector carrying the green fluorescent protein (GFP)-encoding gene (Toca GFP) through tumors in both immune-competent and immune-compromised animal models. However, initial vector localization within the tumor appeared to depend on the mode of administration. Long-term survival was observed in immune-competent mice when Toca 511 was administered intravenously or intracranially in combination with 5-FC treatment, and this combination was well tolerated in the preclinical models. Enhanced survival could also be achieved in animals with preexisting immune response to vector, supporting the potential for repeated administration. On the basis of these and other supporting data, a clinical trial investigating intravenous administration of Toca 511 in patients with recurrent HGG is currently open and enrolling.

Gene therapy for hemophilia

Hemophilia is an X-linked inherited bleeding disorder consisting of two classifications, hemophilia A and hemophilia B, depending on the underlying mutation. Although the disease is currently treatable with intravenous delivery of replacement recombinant clotting factor, this approach represents a significant cost both monetarily and in terms of quality of life. Gene therapy is an attractive alternative approach to the treatment of hemophilia that would ideally provide life-long correction of clotting activity with a single injection. In this review, we will discuss the multitude of approaches that have been explored for the treatment of both hemophilia A and B, including both in vivo and ex vivo approaches with viral and nonviral delivery vectors.

Host and vector-dependent effects on the risk of germline transmission of AAV vectors

The assessment of the risk of germline transmission of vector-coded sequences is critical for clinical translation of gene transfer strategies. We used rabbit models to analyze the risk of germline transmission of adeno-associated viral (AAV) vectors. Intravenous injection of AAV-2 or AAV-8 resulted in liver-mediated, long-term expression of therapeutic levels of human factor IX (hFIX) in a dose-dependent manner. In high-dose cohorts, AAV-8 resulted in twofold higher levels of circulating hFIX and of vector DNA in liver compared to AAV-2. Vector sequences were found in the semen of all rabbits. The kinetics of vector clearance from semen was dose- and time-dependent but serotype-independent. No late recurrence of AAV-8 sequences was found in the semen over several consecutive cycles of spermatogenesis. In a novel rabbit model, AAV-2 or AAV-8 sequences were detected in the semen of vasectomized animals that lack germ cells. Therefore, structures of the genitourinary (GU) tract, as well as the testis, contribute significantly to vector shedding in the semen. Collectively, data from these two models suggest that the risk of inadvertent germline transmission in males by AAV-8 vectors is low, similar to that of AAV-2, and that AAV dissemination to the semen is in part modulated by host-dependent factors.

Gene therapy for haemophilia

The ultimate goal of gene therapy is the replacement of a defective gene sequence with a corrected version to eliminate disease for the lifetime of the patient. This challenging task is not yet accomplished, however significant progress is evident. An initial spate of clinical trials attempting the treatment of haemophilia with gene transfer primarily resulted in the demonstration of good safety profiles, but without efficacy. Subsequent reengineering of vector plasmids and delivery systems resulted in markedly improved outcomes in animal models of the disease. The most recent clinical trial for the treatment of haemophilia B with gene transfer showed transient achievement of efficacy in the highest dose cohort tested, but also exposed a previously hidden barrier to the future success of these treatments. The progress and problems of gene therapies for haemorrhagic disorders will be discussed. This review will concentrate on approaches in or near clinical application.

Induction of megakaryocytes to synthesize and store a releasable pool of human factor VIII

von Willebrand factor (VWF) is a complex plasma glycoprotein that modulates platelet adhesion at the site of a vascular injury, and it also serves as a carrier protein for factor (F)VIII. As megakaryocytes are the only hematopoietic lineage to naturally synthesize and store VWF within alpha-granules, this study was performed to determine if expression of a FVIII transgene in megakaryocytes could lead to trafficking and storage of FVIII with VWF in platelet alpha-granules. Isolex selected CD34+ cells from human G-CSF mobilized peripheral blood cells (PBC) and murine bone marrow were transduced with a retrovirus encoding the B-domain deleted form of human FVIII (BDD-FVIII). Cells were then induced with cytokines to form a population of multiple lineages including megakaryocytes. Chromogenic analysis of culture supernatant from FVIII-transduced human cells demonstrated synthesis of functional FVIII. Treatment of cells with agonists of platelet activation (ADP, epinephrine, and thrombin receptor-activating peptide) resulted in the release of VWF antigen and active FVIII into the supernatant from transduced cells. Immunofluorescence analysis of cultured human and murine megakaryocytes revealed a punctate pattern of staining for FVIII that was consistent with staining for VWF. Electron microscopy of transduced megakaryocytes using immunogold-conjugated antibodies colocalized FVIII and VWF within the alpha-granules. FVIII retained its association with VWF in human platelets isolated from the peripheral blood of NOD/SCID mice at 2-6 weeks post-transplant of transduced human PBC. These results suggest feasibility for the development of a locally inducible secretory pool of FVIII in platelets of patients with hemophilia A.

Phase 1 trial of FVIII gene transfer for severe hemophilia A using a retroviral construct administered by peripheral intravenous infusion

In a phase 1 dose escalation study, 13 subjects with hemophilia A received by peripheral intravenous infusion a retroviral vector carrying a B-domain-deleted human factor VIII (hFVIII) gene. Infusions were well tolerated. Tests for replication competent retrovirus have been negative. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analyses demonstrate the persistence of vector gene sequences in peripheral blood mononuclear cells in 3 of 3 subjects tested. Factor VIII was measured in serial samples using both a one-stage clotting assay and a chromogenic assay. While no subject had sustained FVIII increases, 9 subjects had FVIII higher than 1% on at least 2 occasions 5 or more days after infusion of exogenous FVIII, with isolated levels that ranged from 2.3% to 19%. Pharmacokinetic parameters of exogenous FVIII infused into subjects 13 weeks after vector infusion showed an increased half-life (T1/2; P <.02) and area under the curve (AUC, P <.04) compared with prestudy values. Bleeding frequency decreased in 5 subjects compared with historical rates. These results demonstrate that this retroviral vector (hFVIII(V)) is safe and, in some subjects, persists more than a year in peripheral blood mononuclear cells, with measurable factor VIII levels and with increased available FVIII activity (increased T1/2 and AUC) after infusion of exogenous FVIII concentrate.

Seminiferous tubule cannulation (STC): a new, sensitive technique for detecting gene transfer in developing sperm

As gene therapy vectors, strategies, and disease targets continue to expand and diversify, the likelihood that developing germ cells will be exposed to gene transfer vectors increases. Insertion of exogenous genetic material into the germ line might have devastating effects on normal development which could be heritable. Accordingly, it is important that vectors be tested for their potential to insert genes into developing gametes. Such tests are most difficult in males, where differentiating sperm are sequestered behind the blood-testis barrier. In this communication we report the development of a new technique, which we call seminiferous tubule cannulation (STC). We demonstrate that STC allows delivery of high quantities of gene therapy vector directly to spermatogenic cells without significantly disturbing the cytoarchitecture of the seminiferous tubule. To demonstrate the effectiveness of this technique, three promoters driving lacZ gene expression in adenovirus vectors were tested for their ability to transduce cells within the seminiferous tubule. Results indicate that the cytomegalovirus promoter, but not the Rous sarcoma virus or elongation factor 1alpha promoters, is active within the seminiferous tubule. Further development of this technique promises to lead to a standardized test for male germ cell transduction by gene therapy vectors.

Hemophilia gene therapy: update

Gene transfer is an exciting and potentially important treatment approach for hemophilia A and B. Four phase I clinical trials of the safety of gene transfer in hemophilia A or B have been completed and two more trials are currently underway. The results of these trials indicate that gene transfer in hemophilia with the vectors and doses used is safe and well tolerated. Efforts continue to understand the basic biology and improve the efficiency of gene transfer.

Restoration of spermatogenesis by lentiviral gene transfer: offspring from infertile mice

Disruption of spermatogenesis found in azoospermia and oligozoospermia is thought to be of primarily genetic origin. Sl/Sl(d) mutant mice offer a model system in which lack of transmembrane type c-kit ligand (KL2) expression on the somatic Sertoli cell surface results in disruption of spermatogenesis. We investigated the ability of adeno-, adeno-associated-, retro-, and lentiviral vectors to transduce Sertoli cells and found that transduction with either adeno- or lentiviral vectors led to reporter gene expression for more than 2 mo after testicular tubule injection. Because adenoviral vectors showed toxicity, lentiviral vectors were used to express the c-kit ligand in Sl/Sl(d) Sertoli cells. Restoration of spermatogenesis was observed in all recipient testes. Furthermore, the sperm collected from recipient testes were able to generate normal pups after intracytoplasmic sperm injection. None of the offspring carried the transgene, suggesting the inability of lentiviral vectors to infect spermatogenic cells in vivo. We propose that lentiviral vectors can be used for gene therapy of male infertility without the risk of germ-line transmission.