Validation of the Nordic flow cytometry standard for CD34+ cell enumeration in blood and autografts: report from the third workshop. Nordic Stem Cell Laboratory Group

The Blood Circulating Rare Cell Population. What is it and What is it Good For?

Blood contains a diverse cell population of low concentration hematopoietic as well as non-hematopoietic cells. The majority of such rare cells may be bone marrow-derived progenitor and stem cells. This paucity of circulating rare cells, in particular in the peripheral circulation, has led many to believe that bone marrow as well as other organ-related cell egress into the circulation is a response to pathological conditions. Little is known about this, though an increasing body of literature can be found suggesting commonness of certain rare cell types in the peripheral blood under physiological conditions. Thus, the isolation and detection of circulating rare cells appears to be merely a technological problem. Knowledge about rare cell types that may circulate the blood stream will help to advance the field of cell-based liquid biopsy by supporting inter-platform comparability, making use of biological correct cutoffs and “mining” new biomarkers and combinations thereof in clinical diagnosis and therapy. Therefore, this review intends to lay ground for a comprehensive analysis of the peripheral blood rare cell population given the necessity to target a broader range of cell types for improved biomarker performance in cell-based liquid biopsy.

Priming with r-metHuSCF and filgrastim or chemotherapy and filgrastim in patients with malignant lymphomas: a randomized phase II pilot study of mobilization and engraftment

SCF has been shown to synergize with G-CSF to mobilize CD34(+) PBPCs. In this study we report results from this combination after a phase II trial of 32 patients with malignant lymphoma randomized to receive recombinant methionyl human SCF (ancestim, r-metHuSCF) in combination with recombinant methionyl human G-CSF (filgrastim, r-metHuG-CSF) (experimental arm A) or routine chemotherapy plus filgrastim (conventional arm B). The primary objective was to evaluate the side effects and toxicity during priming and mobilization. The secondary objectives were efficacy by the level of blood-circulating PBPCs, the number of harvest days and the time to three-lineage engraftment after autografting. First, during priming 5 patients had 8 serious events, 4 in each arm. A summary of all adverse events revealed 30 (94%) patients suffering from 132 events of all grading. Second, neutropenia and thrombocytopenia was documented in arm B. Third, 9/14 (64%) patients in arm A reached the target of 5 million CD34(+) cells/kg body weight (bw) compared with 13/15 (87%) in arm B. The results represent the first randomized trial of growth factor plus chemotherapy priming and indicate that a formal phase III trial very unlikely may challenge chemotherapy plus r-metHuG-CSF priming in candidates for high-dose therapy.

Peripheral blood stem cell yield in 400 normal donors mobilised with granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (G-CSF): impact of age, sex, donor weight and type of G-CSF used

Mobilised peripheral blood is now the main source of stem cells collected from normal donors. We report our experience of mobilising and collecting 400 normal healthy donors using standardised procedures and techniques. Target recipient doses were reached with one aphaeresis in 63% of donors and with two aphereses in 81% of donors. Approximately 2% of donors yielded such low progenitor values that they were termed 'poor mobilisers'. There were minor effects of donor age, weight and sex and where possible, larger male donors under the age of 55 years should be selected. Two forms of granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (G-CSF) were used at the same dose and no significant difference was seen in the yield of CD34+ cells collected/l of blood processed. However, a greater number of granulocyte-macrophage colony-forming cells were harvested using lenograstim (glycosylated G-CSF) compared with filgrastim (non-glycosylated G-CSF; P = 0.002). CD34+ cell yields were also measured halfway through the aphaeresis procedure. This was found to be highly predictive of final yield and facilitated distribution of the stem cell product to other centres. The observation that CD34+ yields did not decline in the second half compared with the first half of aphaeresis suggests that the circulating cell numbers are not static.

Fludarabine, cyclophosphamide and horse antithymocyte globulin conditioning regimen for allogeneic peripheral blood stem cell transplantation performed in non-HEPA filter rooms for multiply transfused patients with severe aplastic anemia

Multiply transfused patients of severe aplastic anemia are at increased risk of graft rejection. Five such patients underwent peripheral blood stem cell transplantation from HLA-identical siblings with a fludarabine-based protocol. The conditioning consisted of fludarabine 30 mg/m(2)/day x 6 days, cyclophosphamide 60 mg/kg/day x 2 days and horse antithymocyte globulin (ATG) x 4 days. Two different ATG preparations were used: ATGAM (dose 30 mg/kg/day x 4 days) or Thymogam (dose 40 mg/kg/day x 4 days). Engraftment: median time to absolute neutrophil count (ANC) >0.5 x 10(9)/l was 11 days (range: 8-17) and median time to platelet count >20 x 10(9)/l was 11 days (range: 9-17). At a median follow-up of 171 days (range: 47-389), there has been no graft rejection and all patients are in complete remission. Acute GVHD (grade 1) occurred in one patient only. Chronic GVHD developed in two patients (extensive in one and limited in another). The transplants were performed in non-HEPA filter rooms. In only one patient, systemic antifungal therapy (voriconazole) was used. The use of Thymogam brand of ATG for conditioning is being reported for the first time. Our experience suggests that this fludarabine-based protocol allows rapid sustained engraftment in high-risk patients without significant immediate toxicity.

Magnetic resonance investigation of bone marrow following priming and stem cell mobilization

PURPOSE

To evaluate application of MRI and magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) to monitor bone marrow cellularity during pretransplant priming with chemotherapy and hematopoietic growth factor (HGF) administration.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 10 lymphoma and myeloma patients, in remission following induction therapy and considered eligible for high-dose therapy and autologous stem cell transplantation, were included in the study. MR investigation was scheduled four times: at study entry, and one, two, and four weeks following priming. Priming with cyclophosphamide and recombinant human granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (rhG-CSF) started the day after study entry. MR parameters studied in a region of interest were as follows: bone marrow intensity on short-time inversion-recovery (STIR) turbo spin-echo (TSE; thus STIRTSE) and on T1-weighted TSE (T1TSE) images, T2 value for fat component, T2 value for water component, water/fat ratio (W/F), T1 value for fat component, and T1 value for water component.

RESULTS

The results did not support the hypothesis that hematopoietic expansion quantitated and monitored by MR correlates to the level of mobilized progenitor cells.

CONCLUSION

The results indicate that release of stem cells is a more complex phenomenon than hematopoietic expansion and reduction of fat tissue in bone marrow.

Quality assessment of autografting by probability evaluation: model estimation by clinical end-points in newly diagnosed multiple myeloma patients

BACKGROUND

Pre-transplant clinical evaluation of autografting is an important step in predicting post-transplant support, complications and safety. Today, unfavorable outcomes such as early death or graft failure are rare, making them unsuitable for quality assessment of supportive autografting. However, end-points constructed from frequently occurring clinical events may estimate clinically relevant prognostic models.

METHODS

The present retrospective analysis was based on two consecutive clinical trials in the Nordic area including up to 640 newly diagnosed multiple myeloma patients.

RESULTS

In the model, the efficacy (time on antibiotics and use of transfusions) was influenced by pre-transplant variables, including sex, nationality, serum creatinine, hemoglobin, disease stage at diagnosis, response following induction therapy, length of priming and average graft CD34+ cell number per day of harvest. The toxicity end-point (time to blood cell recovery) was influenced by nationality, marrow plasma cell percentage, serum creatinine, M-component isotype, response to induction therapy, length of priming and graft CD34+ cell number. The safety (early disease recurrence or death) was influenced by serum creatinine, hemoglobin, treatment response and CD34+ cell number.

DISCUSSION

In conclusion, the model illustrates that intervention strategies in quality assessment of autografting may benefit from probability estimates of graded clinical end-points.

Nordic Myeloma Study Group, the first 15 years: scientific collaboration and improvement of patient care

The accomplishments of the Nordic Myeloma Study Group (NMSG) during its first 15 yr are briefly surveyed, together with a discussion of principles guiding the group's clinical trials and of problems that need to be addressed in coming years. The group has so far carried out 12 clinical trials, comprising more than 2500 patients, spanning from minor phase II to large randomised phase III trials. At the time of writing, two randomised trials are running (comparing two doses of i.v. pamidronate, and melphalan-prednisone (MP) vs. MP-thalidomide to elderly patients). The group has strived for a simple organisation with much responsibility delegated to regional coordinators (Denmark 3, Norway 5, Sweden 5). With regard to trial design, the group has considered it important that studies are based on sound scientific questions, are simple to handle for the participants, population based, investigator initiated, include quality of life and health resources assessment as end-points, and can be used as basis for diverse scientific spin-off projects. Like other clinical trial groups, NMSG faces a number of challenges in coming years. The financial situation for independent investigator-initiated trials is far from satisfactory, especially with regard to the resource-consuming implementation of more stringent good clinical practice rules and ethical committee demands. NMSG has also encountered increasing difficulties in recruiting patients to recent trials, partly because of problems related to participating physicians (lack of support, laborious paper work, insufficient credit for participation). Solutions to these problems have to be found if industry-independent clinical trial groups are to survive.

Mobilized peripheral blood SSCloALDHbr cells have the phenotypic and functional properties of primitive haematopoietic cells and their number correlates with engraftment following autologous transplantation

We have developed an approach for identifying primitive mobilized peripheral blood cells (PBSC) that express high levels of aldehyde dehydrogenase (ALDH). PBSC were stained with a fluorescent ALDH substrate, termed BODIPY trade mark -aminoacetaldehyde (BAAA), and then analysed using flow cytometry. A population of cells with a low side scatter (SSC) and a high level of BAAA staining, termed the SSCloALDHbr population, was readily discriminated and comprised a mean of 3 +/- 5% of leukapheresis samples. A mean of 73 +/- 11% of the SSCloALDHbr population expressed CD34 and 56 +/- 25% of all the mobilized CD34+ cells resided within the SSCloALDHbr population. The SSCloALDHbr population was largely depleted of cells with mature phenotypes and enriched for cells with immature phenotypes. Sorted SSCloALDHbr and SSCloALDHbr CD34+ PBSC were enriched for progenitors with the ability to (1) generate colony-forming units (CFU) and long-term culture (LTC)-derived CFU, (2) expand in primary and secondary LTC, and (3) generate multiple cell lineages. In 21 cancer patients who had undergone autologous PBSC transplantation, the number of infused SSCloALDHbr cells/kg highly correlated with the time to neutrophil and platelet engraftment (P < 0.015 and P < 0.003 respectively). In summary, peripheral blood SSCloALDHbr cells have the phenotypic and functional properties of primitive haematopoietic cells and their number correlates with engraftment following autologous transplantation.

Individual quality assessment of autografting by probability evaluation: a model estimated by analysis of graft-related end points in 204 patients with malignancies

Haematological toxicity is considered a secondary end point important for graft evaluation - in today's practice graft evaluation focuses on the primary impact of health economic end points. This report illustrates the benefit of combining CD34 enumeration and demographic as well as disease-related variables in models for individual quality assessment of autografting following high-dose therapy. A total of 24 centres in Scandinavia enrolled 204 patients younger than 67 years who received high-dose therapy with autologous peripheral blood stem cell transplantation. Using the binary Logistic Regression Analysis, the prognostic value of diagnostic demographic variables, therapy and graft-related factors was entered into a multivariate analysis and the final significant models were used to estimate probabilities for acceptable or unacceptable outcome among different patient scenarios. The model that estimated post-transplant efficacy by selected primary end points (time on antibiotics and use of transfusions) includes six independent variables related to sex, age, disease, conditioning, growth factor administration, and graft CD34+ cell number. The model that estimated transplantation-related toxicity by selected secondary end points (time to blood cell recovery) included four independent variables related to age, disease, growth factor administration and graft CD34+ cell number.

Circulating highly fluorescent reticulocytes to predict the adequate harvesting of peripheral blood progenitor cells in platinum-based chemotherapy

We prospectively evaluated whether peripheral blood progenitor cells (PBPC) yield from a single leukapheresis could be predicted by measurement of circulating highly fluorescent reticulocytes (HFR). PBPC were collected from 46 leukaphereses in 15 patients with gynecological cancer following platinum-based chemotherapy. Once a level of at least 5.0% HFR was achieved, sufficient PBPC were collected in a single harvest in 71% of the procedures. Whereas, failure to mobilize sufficient PBPC occurred in 24 of 28 leukaphereses when the percentage of circulating HFR was less than 5.0%. In conclusion, circulating HFR may aid in the efficiency of PBPC collections in platinum-based chemotherapy.

Simultaneous administration of G-CSF and GM-CSF for re-mobilization in patients with inadequate initial progenitor cell collections for autologous transplantation

BACKGROUND

A proportion of candidates for high-dose chemotherapy with autologous PBPC support (HDC-PBPCS) will not provide an adequate PBPC yield from their first mobilization. The value of re-mobilization and the best regimen for re-mobilization in these patients is unclear.

METHODS

In 23 patients who failed to provide > or = 3 x 10(6) CD34+ cells/kg after their first mobilization, PBPC were re-mobilized using a regimen of simultaneous administration of G-CSF and GM-CSF (10 microg/kg/day each) with leukaphereses (LP) starting Day 4 or 5 of CSF administration. Yields of WBC/kg, MNC/kg and CD34+ cells/kg/L of processed blood were compared between the first and second mobilization in each patient. The ability of the combined yield from the two mobilizations to achieve the desired threshold PBPC yield and the tolerability of the re-mobilization were determined.

RESULTS

The re-mobilization regimen was well-tolerated and no patient discontinued the regimen because of toxicity. Median collected WBC/kg/L (1.37 x 10(7) versus 2.62 x 10(7), p = 0.0065), MNC/kg/L (0.77 x 10(7) versus 1.97 x 10(7), p = 0.0003), CD34+ cells/kg/L (1.64 x 10(7) versus 4.18 x 10(7), p = 0.001) were significantly higher after the second mobilization (G-CSF/GM-CSF combination). Percentage of CD34+ cells in the leukapheresis was also significantly higher after the second mobilization (median 0.104% versus 0.195%, p = 0.036). Twelve of 22 patients achieved the target PBPC dose (> 3 x 10(6)/CD34+ cells/kg) after two mobilizations (six patients achieved the target from the second mobilization alone). A further eight underwent HDC-PBPCS without achieving the target PBPC dose. These patients experienced a significant delay in neutrophil and platelet engraftment when compared with those patients achieving the target dose.

DISCUSSION

This study demonstrates that the combination of G-CSF and GM-CSF is an effective and tolerable method for re-mobilization of PBPC in patients who fail to provide an adequate yield from their first mobilization.

Assessing agreement between CD34 enumeration by flow cytometry and volumetric analysis

Prior to replacement of an established method for CD34 enumeration by an alternative approach, evaluation of the agreement between the methods is essential. In this study, the comparison of two assays was evaluated according to the recommendation of Bland and Altman describing the agreement between two methods where the true value is not known. CD34 enumeration was performed on blood or leukapheresis product from 105 patients by flow cytometry (dual platform assay) and volumetric analysis (single platform assay). Both the flow cytometric and the volumetric analysis showed poor reproducibility for measures lower than approximately 9 CD34+ cells/mm3. For values higher than 29 CD34+ cells/mm3, evaluation of the agreement demonstrated a difference between the single and dual platform assay, where CD34 enumeration by the volumetric analysis demonstrated values 73-80% of the flow cytometric value. The difference between the two assays could be due to several technical pitfalls which are discussed.

Efficacy and safety of CD34-selected and CD19-depleted autografting in multiple myeloma patients: a pilot study

OBJECTIVE

If multiple myeloma patients are to be cured after high-dose treatment supported by autologous stem cell transplantation, grafts must be purged of circulating myeloma cells. Myeloma cells are present in all grafts and have been identified as CD38(++)CD45(-) plasma cells, plasma blasts, and CD19(+) B cells.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In an attempt to improve the purging strategy, we studied a two-step procedure consisting of CD34(+) enrichment followed by CD19 depletion. This article describes the evaluation of this sequential magnetic microbead selection after 18 procedures in 14 patients.

RESULTS

The processed autografts contained a median CD34 purity of 81% (range 21-99%) and a recovery of 47% (range 15-82%). Flow cytometric analysis documented the expected reduction of CD34(-) B cells and plasma cells, in most cases to a level below the sensitivity of flow cytometry. Real-time reverse transcriptase polymerase chain reaction documented a CD19 mRNA relative reduction to 0.042 (range 0.01-0.21). Allele-specific oligonucleotide IgH primers were designed for five patients. All products were positive for clonal myeloma cells before processing, but only 1 of 5 was negative after the procedure. The clinical outcome after reinfusion of the processed autografts was evaluated by blood cell recovery and found to be within the range expected from engraftment of unmanipulated autografts. One patient who had delayed platelet recovery associated with cytomegalovirus infection recovered after anti-cytomegalovirus treatment.

CONCLUSIONS

This pilot study documented engraftment after reinfusion of CD34-selected and CD19-depleted autografts. However, one patient suffered from unexpected prolonged thrombocytopenia. The efficacy of the procedure was evaluated and reduction of myeloma cells was indicated, with only one autograft free of clonal cells.

A European reference protocol for quality assessment and clinical validation of autologous haematopoietic blood progenitor and stem cell grafts

Recently, the regulatory authorities have begun to show interest in haematopoietic stem cell products. On a professional rather than a regulatory basis, the International Society for Hematotherapy and Graft Engineering (ISHAGE) has established the Foundation for the Accreditation of Haematopoietic Cell Therapy (FACHT), which has drawn up guidelines for standards and accreditation of such activity. In Europe, the regulatory environment with regard to haematopoietic stem cell grafts, processing and storage are currently less stringent. However, in 1998 the European Joint Accreditation Committee Euro-ISHAGE/EBMT (JACIE) prepared a regulatory document 'Standards for Blood and Marrow Progenitor Cell Collection, Processing and Transplantation' which was approved by the EBMT General Assembly. The major objectives were to promote quality of medical and laboratory practice in haematopoietic progenitor cell transplantation. The standards extend and detail the pre-existing activity of EBMT centres including all phases of collection, processing and administration of these cells. This is the platform for the proposed reference protocol for CD34(+) cell enumeration and clinical validation of quality assessment to ensure that appropriate standards of work and product quality are established and will be maintained.

Cytofluorometric methods for assessing absolute numbers of cell subsets in blood. European Working Group on Clinical Cell Analysis

The enumeration of absolute levels of cells and their subsets in clinical samples is of primary importance in human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)+ individuals (CD4+ T- lymphocyte enumeration), in patients who are candidates for autotransplantation (CD34+ hematopoietic progenitor cells), and in evaluating leukoreduced blood products (residual white blood cells). These measurements share a number of technical options, namely, single- or multiple-color cell staining and logical gating strategies. These can be accomplished using single- or dual-platform counting technologies employing cytometric methods. Dual-platform counting technologies couple the percentage of positive cell subsets obtained by cytometry and the absolute cell count obtained by automated hematology analyzers to derive the absolute value of such subsets. Despite having many conceptual and technical limitations, this approach is traditionally considered as the reference method for absolute cell count enumeration. As a result, the development of single-platform technologies has recently attracted attention with several different technical approaches now being readily available. These single-platform approaches have less sources of variability. A number of reports clearly demonstrate that they provide better coefficients of variation (CVs) in multicenter studies and a lower chance to generate aberrant results. These methods are therefore candidates for the new gold standard for absolute cell assessments. The currently available technical options are discussed in this review together with the results of some cross-comparative studies. Each analytical system has its own specific requirements as far as the dispensing precision steps are concerned. The importance of precision reverse pipetting is emphasized. Issues still under development include the establishment of the critical error ranges, which are different in each test setting, and the applicability of simplified low-cost techniques to be used in countries with limited resources.

Technical aspects and clinical impact of hematopoietic progenitor subset quantification

As high-dose therapy for malignancies is now being applied to newly diagnosed patients as adjuvant therapy, it has become a requirement that quality and safety assessment of hematopoietic stem cell grafts be evidence-based. This process has developed a new institution in medicine, the stem cell laboratory. In most cases this speciality has evolved from or within hematological research laboratories. However, the increased routine technologies applied in quality evaluation, ex vivo manipulation and safety assessment in stem cell handling naturally places this activity in transfusion medicine. Multiparametric flow cytometry can identify progenitor subsets in normal human bone marrow and peripheral blood, and such subset quantification has been used retrospectively to predict three-lineage engraftment following high-dose therapy for malignancies. Published single center data have suggested an impact on clinical outcome, and a standardized technique for subset enumeration needs to be established before prospective multicenter trials can be initiated to document the prognostic value of such quality assessment in autografting. Based on experiences of CD34 enumeration, which we consider to be the first step in quality assessment of hematopoietic stem cell grafts, this review discusses flow cytometry subset identification by lineage-specific differentiation markers, stromal-dependent adherence molecules, and regulatory growth factor receptors from a technical point of view. The aim of this review is:To recommend a simple method based on the experiences of the Nordic workshop III on subset identification; To present new molecular genetic-based methods for future use in quality assessment; and To propose new endpoints necessary for validation of the likely clinical impact of subsets in prospective trials. As sample differences between blood and marrow result in technical difficulties, this review only focuses on the methodology of identifying subsets in blood and leukapheresis products. Methods for subset analysis in diagnostic bone marrow samples will be covered in a forthcoming review.

Reduction of intra- and interlaboratory variation in CD34+ stem cell enumeration using stable test material, standard protocols and targeted training. DK34 Task Force of the European Working Group of Clinical Cell Analysis (EWGCCA)

The European Working Group on Clinical Cell Analysis (EWGCCA) has, in preparation for a multicentre peripheral blood stem cell clinical trial, developed a single-platform flow cytometric protocol for the enumeration of CD34+ stem cells. Using this protocol, stabilized blood and targeted training, the EWGCCA have attempted to standardize CD34+ stem cell enumeration across 24 clinical sites. Results were directly compared with participants in the UK National External Quality Assessment Scheme (NEQAS) for CD34+ Stem Cell Quantification that analysed the same specimens using non-standardized methods. Two bead-counting systems, Flow-Count and TruCount, were also evaluated by the EWGCCA participants during trials 2 and 3. Using Flow-Count, the intralaboratory coefficient of variation (CV) was </= 5% in 39% of the laboratories (trial 1), increasing to 65% by trial 3. Interlaboratory variation was reduced from 23.3% (trial 1) to 10.8% in trial 3. In trial 2, 70% of laboratories achieved an intralaboratory CV </= 5% using TruCount, increasing to 74% for trial 3; the interlaboratory CV was reduced from 23.4% to 9.5%. Comparative analysis of the EWGCCA and the UK NEQAS cohorts revealed that EWGCCA laboratories, using the standardized approach, had lower interlaboratory variation. Thus, the use of a common standardized protocol and targeted training significantly reduced intra- and interlaboratory CD34+ cell count variation.

Highly purified CD34+ cells isolated using magnetically activated cell selection provide rapid engraftment following high-dose chemotherapy in breast cancer patients

The primary objective of this study was to evaluate the safety of infusion of CD34+ cells, selected using a clinical scale magnetically activated cell sorting device, assessed by time to hematological engraftment and incidence of adverse events. Secondary objectives included evaluation of device performance in terms of purity and recovery of the CD34+ cell product. Breast cancer patients suitable for transplantation received cyclophosphamide and filgrastim for mobilisation, followed by three leukaphereses. The products of the first two leukaphereses underwent CD34+ cell selection. The product of the third leukapheresis was cryopreserved unmanipulated. Following high-dose cyclophosphamide, thiotepa and carboplatin, selected CD34+ cells were infused. In 54 patients who received selected cells only, the median time to platelet recovery and neutrophil recovery was 11 days (range 5-51) and 9 days (range 5-51), respectively. There were no adverse events associated with infusion of selected cells. A total of 126 leukapheresis samples was available before and after selection for central CD34+ analysis. The median purity was 96.1% (27.4-99.4) and the median recovery was 52. 3% (15.2-146.3). These data show that cells selected using magnetically activated cell selection provide safe and rapid engraftment after high-dose therapy. Bone Marrow Transplantation (2000) 25, 243-249.