Immunogenicity of recombinant vaccinia viruses that display the HIV type 1 envelope glycoprotein on the surface of infectious virions

Comparison on virulence and immunogenicity of two recombinant vaccinia vaccines, Tian Tan and Guang9 strains, expressing the HIV-1 envelope gene

BACKGROUND

The vaccinia virus Guang9 strain (VG9), derived from the vaccinia virus Tian Tan strain (VTT) has been found to be less virulent than VTT.

METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS

To investigate whether VG9 could be a potential replicating virus vector, the TK genes in VG9 and VTT were replaced with the HIV-1 envelope gene via homologous recombination, resulting in the recombinant viruses, VG9-E and VTT-E. The biology, virulence, humoral and cellular immunological responses of VG9-E and VTT-E were evaluated. Our results indicated no obvious difference in range of host cells and diffusion between two recombinant viruses. Neurovirulence for VG9-E in weanling and suckling mice, and skin virulence in rabbits, were lower than that of VTT-E. The humoral immune responses, including binding antibody and neutralizing antibody responses, induced by VG9-E were not significantly different from those for VTT-E whilst IFN-γ response which represented cellular immune response induced by VG9-E was significantly higher than that did by VTT-E.

CONCLUSIONS/SIGNIFICANCE

Our results indicated that VG9-E was less virulent, yet induced higher cellular immune response than VTT-E. Therefore, it could be an ideal replicating vaccinia vector for HIV vaccine research and development.

Enhancement of immune response to an antigen delivered by vaccinia virus by displaying the antigen on the surface of intracellular mature virion

Vaccinia virus (VACV) is the vaccine for smallpox and a widely used vaccine vector for infectious diseases and cancers. The majority of the antibodies elicited by live VACV vaccination respond to virion structural proteins, including many integral membrane proteins on the intracellular mature virion (MV). Here, we showed that antibody response to an exogenous antigen delivered by VACV was greatly enhanced by incorporating the antigen as an integral membrane protein of MV. We constructed recombinant VACV expressing a Yersinia pestis protective antigen, LcrV, unmodified or fused with either a signal peptide or with the transmembrane domain of VACV D8 protein (LcrV-TM). Electron microscopy showed that LcrV-TM was displayed on the surface of MV. Importantly, VACV expressing LcrV-TM elicited a significantly higher titer of anti-LcrV antibody in mice than viruses expressing other forms of LcrV. Only mice immunized with LcrV-TM-expressing VACV were protected from lethal Y. pestis and VACV WR challenges. Antigen engineering through fusion with D8 transmembrane domain may be broadly applicable for enhancing the immune response to antigens delivered by a VACV vector. The recombinant virus described here could also serve as the basis for developing a vaccine against both smallpox and plague.

In vitro host range, multiplication and virion forms of recombinant viruses obtained from co-infection in vitro with a vaccinia-vectored influenza vaccine and a naturally occurring cowpox virus isolate

Background

Poxvirus-vectored vaccines against infectious diseases and cancer are currently under development. We hypothesized that the extensive use of poxvirus-vectored vaccine in future might result in co-infection and recombination between the vaccine virus and naturally occurring poxviruses, resulting in hybrid viruses with unpredictable characteristics. Previously, we confirmed that co-infecting in vitro a Modified vaccinia virus Ankara (MVA) strain engineered to express influenza virus haemagglutinin (HA) and nucleoprotein (NP) genes with a naturally occurring cowpox virus (CPXV-NOH1) resulted in recombinant progeny viruses (H Hansen, MI Okeke, Ø Nilssen, T Traavik, Vaccine 23: 499–506, 2004). In this study we analyzed the biological properties of parental and progeny hybrid viruses.

Results

Five CPXV/MVA progeny viruses were isolated based on plaque phenotype and the expression of influenza virus HA protein. Progeny hybrid viruses displayed in vitro cell line tropism of CPXV-NOH1, but not that of MVA. The HA transgene or its expression was lost on serial passage of transgenic viruses and the speed at which HA expression was lost varied with cell lines. The HA transgene in the progeny viruses or its expression was stable in African Green Monkey derived Vero cells but became unstable in rat derived IEC-6 cells. Hybrid viruses lacking the HA transgene have higher levels of virus multiplication in mammalian cell lines and produced more enveloped virions than the transgene positive progenitor virus strain. Analysis of the subcellular localization of the transgenic HA protein showed that neither virus strain nor cell line have effect on the subcellular targets of the HA protein. The influenza virus HA protein was targeted to enveloped virions, plasma membrane, Golgi apparatus and cytoplasmic vesicles.

Conclusion

Our results suggest that homologous recombination between poxvirus-vectored vaccine and naturally circulating poxviruses, genetic instability of the transgene, accumulation of non-transgene expressing vectors or hybrid virus progenies, as well as cell line/type specific selection against the transgene are potential complications that may result if poxvirus vectored vaccines are extensively used in animals and man.

Investigation of orf virus structure and morphogenesis using recombinants expressing FLAG-tagged envelope structural proteins: evidence for wrapped virus particles and egress from infected cells

Orf virus (ORFV) is the type species of the genus Parapoxvirus, but little is known about the structure or morphogenesis of the virus. In contrast, the structure and morphogenesis of vaccinia virus (VACV) has been extensively studied. VACV has two main infectious forms, mature virion (MV) and extracellular virion (EV). The MV is wrapped by two additional membranes derived from the trans-Golgi to produce a wrapped virion (WV), the outermost of which is lost by cellular membrane fusion during viral egress to form the EV. Genome sequencing of ORFV has revealed that it has homologues of almost all of the VACV structural genes. Notable exceptions are A36R, K2L, A56R and B5R, which are associated with WV and EV envelopes. This study investigated the morphogenesis and structure of ORFV by fusing FLAG peptide to the structural proteins 10 kDa, F1L and ORF-110 to form recombinant viruses. 10 kDa and F1L are homologues of VACV A27L and H3L MV membrane proteins, whilst ORF-110 is homologous to VACV A34R, an EV membrane protein. Immunogold labelling of FLAG proteins on virus particles isolated from lysed cells showed that FLAG-F1L and FLAG-10 kDa were displayed on the surface of infectious particles, whereas ORF-110-FLAG could not be detected. Western blot analysis of solubilized recombinant ORF-110-FLAG particles revealed that ORF-110-FLAG was abundant and undergoes post-translational modification indicative of endoplasmic reticulum trafficking. Fluorescent microscopy confirmed the prediction that ORF-110-FLAG localized to the Golgi in virus-infected cells. Finally, immunogold labelling of EVs showed that ORF-110-FLAG became exposed on the surface of EV-like particles as a result of egress from the cell.

A comparative immunogenicity study of HIV-1 virus-like particles bearing various forms of envelope proteins, particles bearing no envelope and soluble monomeric gp120

To assess the potential of native Envelope glycoprotein (Env) trimers as neutralizing antibody vaccines, we immunized guinea pigs with three types of VLPs and soluble gp120. Particles included "SOS-VLPs" (bearing disulfide-shackled functional trimers), "UNC-VLPs" (bearing uncleaved nonfunctional Env) and "naked VLPs" (bearing no Env). The SOS-VLPs were found to have a density of about 27 native trimers per particle, approximately twice that of live inactivated HIV-1 preparations. As immunogens, UNC- and SOS-VLP rapidly elicited anti-gp120 antibodies focused on the V3 loop and the gp120 coreceptor binding site. Reactivity to the gp41 immunodominant domain was absent in SOS-VLP sera, presumably because gp120-gp41 association is stabilized, effectively covering this epitope. Gp120-immune sera reacted with the receptor binding sites of gp120 and were less focused on the V3 loop. Some Env-VLP sera neutralized primary isolates at modest titers. The measurement of neutralization was found to be affected by the cell lines used. Depending on the assay particulars, non-Env specific antibodies in VLP sera could enhance infection, or nonspecifically neutralize. However, a neutralization assay using TZM-BL cells was essentially clear of these effects. We also describe a native trimer binding assay to confirm neutralization activity in a manner that completely eliminates nonspecific effects. Overall, our data suggests that Env-VLP sera were primarily focused on nonfunctional forms of Env on VLP surfaces, possibly gp120/gp41 monomers and not the trimers. Therefore, to make progress toward a more effective VLP-based vaccine, we will need to find ways to refocus the attention of B cells on native trimers.

Host range, growth property, and virulence of the smallpox vaccine: Vaccinia virus Tian Tan strain

Vaccinia Tian Tan (VTT) was used as a vaccine against smallpox in China for millions of people before 1980, yet the biological characteristics of the virus remain unclear. We have characterized VTT with respect to its host cell range, growth properties in vitro, and virulence in vivo. We found that 11 of the 12 mammalian cell lines studied are permissive to VTT infection whereas one, CHO-K1, is non-permissive. Using electron microscopy and sequence analysis, we found that the restriction of VTT replication in CHO-K1 is at a step before viral maturation probably due to the loss of the V025 gene. Moreover, VTT is significantly less virulent than vaccinia WR but remains neurovirulent in mice and causes significant body weight loss after intranasal inoculation. Our data demonstrate the need for further attenuation of VTT to serve either as a safer smallpox vaccine or as a live vaccine vector for other pathogens.

Improved protection conferred by vaccination with a recombinant vaccinia virus that incorporates a foreign antigen into the extracellular enveloped virion

Recombinant poxviruses have shown promise as vaccine vectors. We hypothesized that improved cellular immune responses could be developed to a foreign antigen by incorporating it as part of the extracellular enveloped virion (EEV). We therefore constructed a recombinant vaccinia virus that replaced the cytoplasmic domain of the B5R protein with a test antigen, HIV-1 Gag. Mice immunized with the virus expressing Gag fused to B5R had significantly better primary CD4 T-cell responses than recombinant virus expressing HIV-Gag from the TK-locus. The CD8 T-cell responses were less different between the two groups. Importantly, although we saw differences in the immune response to the test antigen, the vaccinia virus-specific immune responses were similar with both constructs. When groups of vaccinated mice were challenged 30 days later with a recombinant Listeria monocytogenes that expresses HIV-Gag, mice inoculated with the virus that expresses the B5R-Gag fusion protein had lower colony counts of Listeria in the liver and spleen than mice vaccinated with the standard recombinant. Thus, vaccinia virus expressing foreign antigen incorporated into EEV may be a better vaccine strategy than standard recombinant vaccinia virus.

Ultraviolet-irradiated vaccinia virus recombinants, exposing HIV-envelope on their outer membrane, induce antibodies against this antigen in rabbits

The construction and isolation of recombinants of vaccinia virus (IHD-J strain), bearing on their outer membrane a chimeric protein consisting of the cytoplasmic and transmembrane domains of vaccinia B5R protein and the external domain of HIV envelope, has been previously described by us. The present study aimed to investigate the potential use of such recombinants as a vaccine, following inactivation of their infectivity by ultraviolet (UV) irradiation. The minimal dose of UV irradiation, required for the complete inactivation of the infectivity of these recombinants, was determined. Injections of rabbits with the irradiated noninfectious recombinant viruses successfully induced specific antibodies against the HIV envelope antigen, in addition to those against the poxvirus.

Immunization of rabbits with a modified vaccinia Ankara recombinant virus bearing the HIV envelope antigen on its outer membrane

Modified vaccinia virus Ankara (MVA) is a highly attenuated strain of vaccinia virus, which propagates efficiently in chicken embryo fibroblasts but fails to complete its growth cycle in many types of mammalian cells. We constructed a recombinant virus MVA/EK5, which has a chimeric gene encoding for the extracellular domain of the HIV envelope protein fused to the cytoplasmic and transmembrane domain of the B5R protein of vaccinia virus. The fused HIV envelope antigen was expressed in the African green monkey kidney BS-C-1 cells infected with the recombinant virus. This virus, which had been grown in chicken embryo fibroblasts, induced in rabbits antibodies against the HIV envelope antigen, in addition to those against poxvirus.

Rational development of prophylactic HIV vaccines based on structural and regulatory proteins

The severity of the AIDS epidemic clearly emphasises the urgent need to expedite HIV vaccine candidates into clinical trials. Prophylactic HIV vaccine candidates have been evaluated in non-human primates. Based on specific proof of principle studies the first phase III clinical studies have recently begun in humans. However, a truly effective HIV vaccine is not yet at hand and many problems related to specific properties of the virus remain to be overcome. Previously proven empirical approaches have largely failed and now rational thinking based on an understanding of immunity to lentiviral infections is needed. This review addresses the scientific problems and complications facing the development of an HIV vaccine as well as the possible strategies currently available to overcome these problems. Recent attention has focussed on identifying the immune correlates and mechanisms of protection from either HIV infection or protection from disease progression. Based on these observations, the logic and rational behind the development of multiple component vaccine strategies are highlighted.

Selective induction of apoptosis in antigen-presenting cells in mice by Parapoxvirus ovis

Viruses have evolved numerous mechanisms to avoid host immune reactions. Here we report a mechanism by which Parapoxvirus ovis (PPVO) interferes with antigen presentation. PPVO (orf virus) causes orf, an acute skin disease of sheep and goats worldwide. Importantly, PPVO can repeatedly infect its host in spite of a vigorous inflammatory and host immune response to the infection. We demonstrate in a mouse system that PPVO induces apoptosis in a significant number of antigen-presenting cells after intraperitoneal injection using the CD95 pathway, thus preventing a primary T-cell response. We also show that PPVO induces a compensatory activation of the immune system. Our results may help to explain the phenomenon that natural PPVO infections in sheep occur repeatedly even after short intervals. They also suggest that the combination of immunosuppressive and immunostimulatory mechanisms is an effective survival strategy that might be used in other viruses as well.

Enveloped virus is the major virus form produced during productive infection with the modified vaccinia virus Ankara strain

Modified vaccinia virus Ankara (MVA) is a highly attenuated virus strain that may be useful as a vaccine vector. Ultrastructural examination of purified MVA showed that most of the viral particles are enveloped in contrast to the Copenhagen strain (COP). In CsCl gradients, the majority of the MVA particles displayed a light buoyant density characteristic of the enveloped form. Consistent with these results, MVA particles were poorly labeled with antibodies against the surface of intracellular mature virus but strongly labeled with antibodies against an envelope antigen. Furthermore, MVA was more resistant than the COP strain to neutralization by mouse anti-COP antibodies. These results suggest that the MVA strain may be particularly suitable for the engineering of envelope proteins and that MVA may be able to resist the humoral immunity displayed by previously vaccinated individuals.

Chimeras between the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV-1) Env and vaccinia virus immunogenic proteins p14 and p39 generate in mice broadly reactive antibodies and specific activation of CD8+ T cell responses to Env

A vaccine based on the envelope protein (Env) of the human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) that triggers widely reactive antibodies might be a desirable approach to control virus infection. To expose epitopes which could induce broadly reactive antibodies against HIV-1 Env, we have generated vaccinia virus (VV) recombinants that express Env fused at its N- or C-terminus with two major antigenic proteins of VV, p14 (A27L gene) and p39 (A4L gene). Biochemical analysis of the chimeric proteins in cell cultures revealed that, in all cases, recombinant viruses expressed the correct fusion proteins. When p14 or p39 are fused at the N-terminus of Env the chimeric proteins are poorly glycosylated but when p14 or p39 are fused at the C-terminus of Env, the chimeric proteins are fully glycosylated. In Balb/c mice, immunisation with the referred VV recombinants induced similar levels of CD8+ T cell specific responses to Env as immunisation with the entire Env protein. The humoral immune response triggered by the fusion proteins was broader than in animals immunised with VV expressing the entire Env (VVEnv1), and was directed to epitopes outside of the V3 loop (V1/V2, C1, C2, C4). One of the chimeric constructs induced a better neutralising antibody response than VVEnv1. We conclude that fusing VV proteins p14 or p39 to Env provides an effective means to induce broadly reactive antibodies and CD8+ T cell responses to Env. This approach might have utility against HIV and other pathogens.

Production of recombinant subunit vaccines: protein immunogens, live delivery systems and nucleic acid vaccines

The first scientific attempts to control an infectious disease can be attributed to Edward Jenner, who, in 1796 inoculated an 8-year-old boy with cowpox (vaccinia), giving the boy protection against subsequent challenge with virulent smallpox. Thanks to the successful development of vaccines, many major diseases, such as diphtheria, poliomyelitis and measles, are nowadays kept under control, and in the case of smallpox, the dream of eradication has been fulfilled. Yet, there is a growing need for improvements of existing vaccines in terms of increased efficacy and improved safety, besides the development of completely new vaccines. Better technological possibilities, combined with increased knowledge in related fields, such as immunology and molecular biology, allow for new vaccination strategies. Besides the classical whole-cell vaccines, consisting of killed or attenuated pathogens, new vaccines based on the subunit principle, have been developed, e.g. the Hepatitis B surface protein vaccine and the Haemophilus influenzae type b vaccine. Recombinant techniques are now dominating in the strive for an ideal vaccine, being safe and cheap, heat-stable and easy to administer, preferably single-dose, and capable of inducing broad immune response with life-long memory both in adults and in infants. This review will describe different recombinant approaches used in the development of novel subunit vaccines, including design and production of protein immunogens, the development of live delivery systems and the state-of-the-art for nucleic acids vaccines.

Functional analysis of vaccinia virus B5R protein: role of the cytoplasmic tail

Vaccinia extracellular enveloped virus (EEV) is important for cell-to-cell and long-range virus spread both in vitro and in vivo. Six genes have been identified that encode protein constituents of the EEV outer membrane, and some of these proteins are critical for EEV formation. The B5R gene encodes an EEV-specific type I membrane protein, and deletion of this gene markedly decreases EEV formation and results in a small plaque phenotype. Data suggest that the transmembrane domain, cytoplasmic tail, or both contain the EEV localization signals that are required for targeting of the B5R protein to EEV and for EEV formation. Here, we report the construction of mutant vaccinia viruses in which the wild-type B5R gene was replaced with a mutated one that encodes a protein with the putative cytoplasmic tail deleted. The mutated protein showed normal intracellular distribution and was properly incorporated into EEV. Vaccinia viruses expressing the B5R protein lacking the cytoplasmic tail formed plaques that were similar in type and size to those formed by wild-type viruses and produced equivalent amounts of infectious EEV. These results indicate that the B5R cytoplasmic tail is not necessary for EEV formation and points to the transmembrane domain as the major determinant for targeting the B5R protein to the outer membrane of EEV and for supporting EEV formation.

Studies of the neutralizing activity and avidity of anti-human immunodeficiency virus type 1 Env antibody elicited by DNA priming and protein boosting

DNA vaccination is an effective means of eliciting strong antibody responses to a number of viral antigens. However, DNA immunization alone has not generated persistent, high-titer antibody and neutralizing antibody responses to human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1) envelope glycoprotein (Env). We have previously reported that DNA-primed anti-Env antibody responses can be augmented by boosting with Env-expressing recombinant vaccinia viruses. We report here that recombinant Env protein provides a more effective boost of DNA-initiated antibody responses. In rabbits primed with Env-expressing plasmids, protein boosting increased titer, persistence, neutralizing activity, and avidity of anti-Env responses. While titers increased rapidly after boosting, avidity and neutralizing activity matured more slowly over a 6-month period following protein boosting. DNA priming and protein immunization with HIV-1 HXB-2 Env elicited neutralizing antibody for T cell line-adapted, but not primary isolate, viruses. The most effective neutralizing antibody responses were observed after priming with plasmids which expressed noninfectious virus-like particles. In contrast to immunizations with HIV-1 Env, DNA immunizations with the influenza virus hemagglutinin glycoprotein did not require a protein boost to achieve high-titer antibody with good avidity and persistence.