Nonanimal Approaches to Assessing the Toxicity of Inhaled Substances: Current Progress and Future Promise

Ex vivo pulmonary assay applied for screening of toxicity potential of chemicals

Acute inhalation toxicity testing for chemical classification and labeling has been performed using animal models, however, these models have limited predictibility of the toxicity on the respiratory system. Thus, non-animal models have been emerging as alternatives for preclinical assessment of respiratory toxicity of chemicals, comprising in chemico, in vitro, ex vivo, and in silico approaches. In this study, we characterized and evaluated the applicability of a new ex vivo bovine bronchial model for addressing key aspects of pulmonary toxicity. Standardized bronchial fragments were cultured at an air-liquid interface for seven days showing cell viability, morphology, and function during the ex vivo time of cultivation. Different exposure ways, liquid or aerosol exposure, were also studied using paraformaldehyde (PFA) as a positive control. In a concentration-dependent manner, a decrease in tissue viability was observed for aerosols instead of direct liquid exposure upon tissue surface. Moreover, PFA exposure allowed the addressment of several damage biomarkers, including epithelium thickness, mitochondrial activity, ROS production, and caspase-3 activation. Besides, the bronquial tissue was exposed to chemicals from different UN GHS inhalation toxicity categories and presented a concentration-dependent response for most of the evaluated materials. The proposed airway ex vivo model represents a low-cost and reproducible tool applicable for pulmonary toxicity assessment of chemicals.

In vitro model for predicting acute inhalation toxicity by using a Calu-3 epithelium cytotoxicity assay

INTRODUCTION

As the current methods to predict the inhalation toxicity of chemicals using animal models are limited, alternative methods are required. We present a new in vitro prediction method for acute inhalation toxicity using the Calu-3 epithelial cytotoxicity assay applicable for water-soluble inhalable chemicals.

METHOD

To confirm the characteristics of the optimal Calu-3 epithelium, tight-junction formation, morphology, and mucus secretion were verified using scanning electron microscopy, transepithelial electrical resistance analysis, and immunofluorescence after growth in an air-liquid interface (ALI). Sixty chemicals, including 38 positive and 22 negative for acute inhalation toxicity, were selected from the European Chemical Agency chemical database. The cell viability of the exposed cells was assessed using an MTT assay to predict the acute inhalation toxicity by calculating the area under the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve and accuracy.

RESULTS

When cultivated in an ALI, the epithelium was thicker and secreted more mucin than that under submerged cultivation, characteristic of the in vivo respiratory epithelium. The areas under the ROC curve were 0.75 and 0.78 when exposed to chemicals at concentrations of 2.5 and 5%, respectively. The highest accuracy of the methods was 68 and 78% at cut-off values of 85 and 40% cell viability, respectively.

DISCUSSION

The in vitro model was moderately accurate with good prediction. It is replicable because of its advantages, i.e., the use of cultured cells and the simplicity of the method. Overall, the Calu-3 epithelial cytotoxicity assay may be a useful and simple approach to identify substances that cause acute inhalation toxicity.

Validation of the CULTEX® Radial Flow System for the assessment of the acute inhalation toxicity of airborne particles

The CULTEX® Radial Flow System (RFS) is a modular in vitro system for the homogenous exposure of cells to airborne particles at the air-liquid interface (ALI). A former pre-validation study successfully demonstrated the general applicability of the CULTEX® RFS and its transferability, stability and reproducibility. Based on these results, the methodology was optimized, validated and prediction models for acute inhalation hazards were established. Cell viability of A549 cells after ALI exposure to 20 pre-selected test substances was assessed in three independent laboratories. Cytotoxicity of test substances was compared to the respective incubator controls and used as an indicator of toxicity. Substances were considered to exert an acute inhalation hazard when viability decreased below 50% (prediction model (PM) 50%) or 75% (PM 75%) at any of three exposure doses (25, 50 or 100 μg/cm²). Results were then compared to existing in vivo data and revealed an overall concordance of 85%, with a specificity of 83% and a sensitivity of 88%. Depending on the applied PM, the within-laboratory and between-laboratory reproducibility ranged from 90 to 100%. In summary, the CULTEX® RFS was proven as a transferable, reproducible and well predictive screening method for the qualitative assessment of the acute pulmonary cytotoxicity of airborne particles.