A Review of International Biobanks and Networks: Success Factors and Key Benchmarks—A 10-Year Retrospective Review

Toward standardized brain tumor tissue processing protocols in neuro-oncology: a perspective for gliomas and beyond

Implementation of standardized protocols in neurooncology during the surgical resection of brain tumors is needed to advance the clinical treatment paradigms that use tissue for diagnosis, prognosis, bio-banking, and treatment. Currently recommendations on intraoperative tissue procurement only exist for diffuse gliomas but management of other brain tumor subtypes can also benefit from these protocols. Fresh tissue from surgical resection can now be used for intraoperative diagnostics and functional precision medicine assays. A multidisciplinary neuro-oncology perspective is critical to develop the best avenues for practical standardization. This perspective from the multidisciplinary Oncology Tissue Advisory Board (OTAB) discusses current advances, future directions, and the imperative of adopting standardized protocols for diverse brain tumor entities. There is a growing need for consistent operating room practices to enhance patient care, streamline research efforts, and optimize outcomes.

Biobanking Legislation in Spain: Advancing or Undermining Its Ethical Values?

Biobanks are important resources for improving public health and individual care. Some legal frameworks can be more or less conducive to advancing the potential benefits of biobanks. The purpose of this article is to assess biobanking legislation and practices in Spain to determine how well they fare in such a regard. We focus here on some of the primary ethical values that ground relevant legislation and that we believe are consistent with promoting biobanking benefits: the value of scientific research; efficient use of scarce resources; and respect for the dignity of donors. We argue that although Spanish regulations advance these values in important ways, they also have provisions that undermine them and thus risk limiting the potential benefits of biobanks. We offer some suggestions for improvement.

Economics of Biobanking: Business or Public Good? Literature Review, Structural and Thematic Analysis

This paper reviewed the relevant scientific literature on the business and economics of biobanking to explore key themes and paradigms. The structural properties of the literature were investigated, such as key authors, journals, studies, as well as co-citation and co-authorship networks; the study revealed that the research on business and economics is a niche area within the vast biobanking literature. The research is concentrated in a relatively small number of journals, institutions, and countries, which is rather surprising given the substantial public investment in and concerns about biobank sustainability. The structural analysis also suggested major themes in research on biobanking business and economics and noted shifts in focus on specific themes. The commercialisation of samples is more acknowledged than before but under the condition of equitable sharing of benefits across various stakeholders. Most biobanks are heavily subsidised by the public sector and are considered public goods rather than business enterprises. This is OK, but underutilisation of specimens and low rates of cost recovery suggest that the current mainstream operating model is hardly sustainable. With many biobanks maturing, long-term sustainability became a key topic of the discussion on biobanking trends.

Prospective Real-World Gynaecological Cancer Clinical Registry with Associated Biospecimens: A Collaborative Model to Promote Translational Research between GEICO and the Spanish Biobank Network

Patient registries linked to biorepositories constitute a valuable asset for clinical and translational research in oncology. The Spanish Group of Ovarian Cancer Research (GEICO), in collaboration with the Spanish Biobank Network (RNBB), has developed a multicentre, multistakeholder, prospective virtual clinical registry (VCR) associated with biobanks for the collection of real-world data and biological samples of gynaecological cancer patients. This collaborative project aims to promote research by providing broad access to high-quality clinical data and biospecimens for future research according to the needs of investigators and to increase diagnostic and therapeutic opportunities for gynaecological cancer patients in Spain. The VCR will include the participation of more than 60 Spanish hospitals entering relevant clinical information in harmonised electronic case report forms (eCRFs) in four different cohorts: ovarian, endometrial, cervical, and rare gynaecological cancers (gestational trophoblastic disease). Initial data for the cases included till December 2021 are presented. The model described herein establishes a real-world win-win collaboration between multicentre structures, promoted and supported by GEICO, that will contribute to the success of translational research in gynaecological cancer.

Finding the Value in Biobanks: Enhancing the CTRNet Locator

Biobanks are a critical piece of Research Infrastructure (RI). However, biobanks need to accept the reality of a life cycle for RIs. Until recently, strategies to sustain biobanks have been commonly focused on ways to maintain current operational models. However, sustaining biobanks as they exist today may be increasingly challenging in the face of the disruption in health and research priorities caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. In this opinion article, we review the current and emerging future drivers of biobank value for their researchers, institutions, and funders, highlighting utilization and impact of research performed using the biobank as key measures of future value. While biobanks can only indirectly influence the specific impact of the research performed, they can transform themselves to more actively redefine utilization to their advantage. Utilization means more than the balance of samples and data in versus out. Utilization means redirecting expertise to best support end users, and importantly, closing the operating gap between biobanks and their end users who seek to find the right biospecimens and data to pursue their research. We discuss the specific role of locators (those created by public investment) in closing this gap and the need for additional tools for researchers, before and subsequent to connecting with locators. For the former, we specifically propose that more support is needed to assist researchers in the decision as to how to best obtain biospecimens and navigate the options as to whether finding existing biospecimens and data held by a biobank is the optimal solution for a given project, or whether the optimal solution is either contracting with a biobank to collect samples or creating a new biobank. We believe this type of biospecimen navigator platform will help to maximize utilization of current biobank resources, and also promote the services and expertise in biobanks to better serve researchers' needs.

Moving with the Times: The Health Science Alliance (HSA) Biobank, Pathway to Sustainability

Human biobanks are recognised as vital components of translational research infrastructure. With the growth in personalised and precision medicine, and the associated expansion of biomarkers and novel therapeutics under development, it is critical that researchers can access a strong collection of patient biospecimens, annotated with clinical data. Biobanks globally are undertaking transformation of their operating models in response to changing research needs; transition from a ‘classic’ model representing a largely retrospective collection of pre-defined specimens to a more targeted, prospective collection model, although there remains a research need for both models to co-exist. Here we introduce the Health Science Alliance (HSA) Biobank, established in 2012 as a classic biobank, now transitioning to a hybrid operational model. Some of the past and current challenges encountered are discussed including clinical annotation, specimen utilisation and biobank sustainability, along with the measures the HSA Biobank is taking to address these challenges. We describe new directions being explored, going beyond traditional specimen collection into areas involving bioimages, microbiota and live cell culture. The HSA Biobank is working in collaboration with clinicians, pathologists and researchers, piloting a sustainable, robust platform with the potential to integrate future needs.

Druggable genome and precision medicine in cancer: current challenges

The past decades have seen tremendous developments with respect to "specific" therapeutics that target key signaling molecules to conquer cancer. The key advancements with multiomics technologies, especially genomics, have allowed physicians and molecular oncologists to design "tailor-made" solutions to the specific oncogenes that are deregulated in individual patients, a strategy which has turned out to be successful though the patients quickly develop resistance. The swift integration of multidisciplinary approaches has led to the development of "next generation" therapeutics and, with synergistic therapeutic regimes combined with immune checkpoint inhibitors to reactivate the dampened immune response, has provided the much-needed promise for cancer patients. Despite these advances, a large portion of the druggable genome remains understudied, and the role of druggable genome in the immune system needs further attention. Establishment of patient-derived organoid models has fastened the preclinical validation of novel therapeutics for swift clinical translation. We summarized the current advances and challenges and also stress the importance of biobanking and collection of longitudinal data sets with structured clinical information, as well as the critical role these "high content data sets" will play in designing new therapeutic regimes in a tailor-made fashion.