Thyroid Hormone in Biodegradable Nerve Guides Stimulates Sciatic Nerve Regeneration: A Potential Therapeutic Approach for Human Peripheral Nerve Injuries

Factors Related to Neuropathic Pain following Lower Extremity Amputation

BACKGROUND

Lower extremity amputations are common, and postoperative neuropathic pain (phantom limb pain or symptomatic neuroma) is frequently reported. The use of active treatment of the nerve end has been shown to reduce pain but requires additional resources and should therefore be performed primarily in high-risk patients. The aim of this study was to identify the factors associated with the development of neuropathic pain following above-the-knee amputation, knee disarticulation, or below-the-knee amputation.

METHODS

Retrospectively, 1565 patients with an average follow-up of 4.3 years who underwent a primary above-the-knee amputation, knee disarticulation, or below-the-knee amputation were identified. Amputation levels for above-the-knee amputations and knee disarticulations were combined as proximal amputation level, with below-the-knee amputations being performed in 61 percent of patients. The primary outcome was neuropathic pain (i.e., phantom limb pain or symptomatic neuroma) based on medical chart review. Multivariable logistic regression was performed to identify independent factors associated with neuropathic pain.

RESULTS

Postoperative neuropathic pain was present in 584 patients (37 percent), with phantom limb pain occurring in 34 percent of patients and symptomatic neuromas occurring in 3.8 percent of patients. Proximal amputation level, normal creatinine levels, and a history of psychiatric disease were associated with neuropathic pain. Diabetes, hypothyroidism, and older age were associated with lower odds of developing neuropathic pain.

CONCLUSIONS

Neuropathic pain following lower extremity amputation is common. Factors influencing nerve regeneration, either increasing (proximal amputations and younger age) or decreasing (diabetes, hypothyroidism, and chronic kidney disease) it, play a role in the development of postamputation neuropathic pain.

CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Risk, III.

Silicone tubes with thyroid hormone (Τ3) and BDNF as an alternative to autografts for bridging neural defects

The way thyroid hormone works in peripheral nerve regeneration has not been fully elucidated, although studies have shown that it has a strong positive effect on nerve regeneration. It is argued that its action is probably stronger than the neurotrophic factors that have been used for some time. It is hypothesized that the use of thyroid hormone in the nerve tubes has a beneficial effect on nerve regeneration to the extent that the results of its use are comparable to those of the autograft technique in bridging small nerve deficits. In this experimental study, we examined the effect of thyroid hormone and BDNF (Brain Derived Neurotrophic Factor) on the repair of 10 mm nerve defects when administered within silicone nerve tubes and compared the results with the autograft method. Thyroid hormone promotes nerve regeneration mainly by increasing its speed and its effect on the maturation of nerve fibers compared to the other groups where the nerve deficit was bridged by entubulation. Also, better organization and the absence of intraneural fibrosis, compared to the other groups, may argue for the action of thyroid hormone in regulating the inflammatory response. Functionally, the AG group showed better results compared to the other groups by the end of the study (16 weeks).

Stimulating effect of thyroid hormones in peripheral nerve regeneration: research history and future direction toward clinical therapy

Injury to peripheral nerves is often observed in the clinic and severe injuries may cause loss of motor and sensory functions. Despite extensive investigation, testing various surgical repair techniques and neurotrophic molecules, at present, a satisfactory method to ensuring successful recovery does not exist. For successful molecular therapy in nerve regeneration, it is essential to improve the intrinsic ability of neurons to survive and to increase the speed of axonal outgrowth. Also to induce Schwann cell phenotypical changes to prepare the local environment favorable for axonal regeneration and myelination. Therefore, any molecule that regulates gene expression of both neurons and Schwann cells could play a crucial role in peripheral nerve regeneration. Clinical and experimental studies have reported that thyroid hormones are essential for the normal development and function of the nervous system, so they could be candidates for nervous system regeneration. This review provides an overview of studies devoted to testing the effect of thyroid hormones on peripheral nerve regeneration. Also it emphasizes the importance of combining biodegradable tubes with local administration of triiodothyronine for future clinical therapy of human severe injured nerves. We highlight that the local and single administration of triiodothyronine within biodegradable nerve guide improves significantly the regeneration of severed peripheral nerves, and accelerates functional recovering. This technique provides a serious step towards future clinical application of triiodothyronine in human severe injured nerves. The possible regulatory mechanism by which triiodothyronine stimulates peripheral nerve regeneration is a rapid action on both axotomized neurons and Schwann cells.

Progesterone neuroprotection: The background of clinical trial failure

Since the first pioneering studies in the 1990s, a large number of experimental animal studies have demonstrated the neuroprotective efficacy of progesterone for brain disorders, including traumatic brain injury (TBI). In addition, this steroid has major assets: it easily crosses the blood-brain-barrier, rapidly diffuses throughout the brain and exerts multiple beneficial effects by acting on many molecular and cellular targets. Moreover, progesterone therapies are well tolerated. Notably, increased brain levels of progesterone are part of endogenous neuroprotective responses to injury. The hormone thus emerged as a particularly promising protective candidate for TBI and stroke patients. The positive outcomes of small Phase 2 trials aimed at testing the safety and potential protective efficacy of progesterone in TBI patients then provided support and guidance for two large, multicenter, randomized and placebo-controlled Phase 3 trials, with more than 2000 TBI patients enrolled. The negative outcomes of both trials, named ProTECT III and SyNAPSE, came as a big disappointment. If these trials were successful, progesterone would have become the first efficient neuroprotective drug for brain-injured patients. Thus, progesterone has joined the numerous neuroprotective candidates that have failed in clinical trials. The aim of this review is a reappraisal of the preclinical animal studies, which provided the proof of concept for the clinical trials, and we critically examine the design of the clinical studies. We made efforts to present a balanced view of the strengths and limitations of the translational studies and of some serious issues with the clinical trials. We place particular emphasis on the translational value of animal studies and the relevance of TBI biomarkers. The probability of failure of ProTECT III and SyNAPSE was very high, and we present them within the broader context of other unsuccessful trials.

Role of thyroid hormones in different aspects of nervous system regeneration in vertebrates

Spontaneous functional recovery from injury in the adult human nervous system is rare and trying to improve recovery remains a clinical challenge. Nervous system regeneration is a complicated sequence of events involving cell death or survival, cell proliferation, axon extension and remyelination, and finally reinnervation and functional recovery. Successful recovery depends on the cell-specific and time-dependent activation and repression of a wide variety of growth factors and guidance molecules. Thyroid hormones (THs), well known for their regulatory role in neurodevelopment, have recently emerged as important modulators of neuroregeneration. This review focuses on the endogenous changes in the proteins regulating TH availability and action in different cell types of the adult mammalian nervous system during regeneration as well as the impact of TH supplementation on the consecutive steps in this process. It also addresses possible differences in TH involvement between different vertebrate classes, early or late developmental stages and peripheral or central nervous system. The available data show that THs are able to stimulate many signaling pathways necessary for successful neurogeneration. They however also suggest that supplementation with T4 and/or T3 may have beneficial or detrimental influences depending on the dose and more importantly on the specific phase of the regeneration process.

Effect of local administration of insulin-like growth factor I combined with inside-out artery graft on peripheral nerve regeneration

The objective was to assess the effect of topically administered insulin-like growth factor (IGF I) on peripheral nerve regeneration and functional recovery. Eighty male healthy white Wistar rats were divided into four experimental groups (n=20), randomly: in transected group (TC), the left sciatic nerve was transected and stumps were fixed in the adjacent muscle. In treatment group, defect was bridged using an inside-out artery graft (IOAG/IGF) filled with 10 μL IGF I (100 ng/kg). In artery graft group (IOAG), the graft was filled with phosphate-buffered saline alone. In sham-operated group (SHAM), sciatic nerve was exposed and manipulated. Each group was subdivided into five subgroups of five animals each and regenerated nerve fibres were studied 4, 8, 12 and 16 weeks after surgery. Behavioural testing, sciatic nerve functional study, gastrocnemius muscle mass and morphometric indices confirmed faster recovery of regenerated axons in IOAG/IGF than IOAG group (P<0.05). In immunohistochemistry, location of reactions to S-100 in IOAG/IGF was clearly more positive than that in IOAG group. When loaded in an artery graft, IGF I accelerated and improved functional recovery and morphometric indices of sciatic nerve.

Ketoprofen combined with artery graft entubulization improves functional recovery of transected peripheral nerves

The objective was to assess the local effect of ketoprofen on sciatic nerve regeneration and functional recovery. Eighty healthy male white Wistar rats were randomized into four experimental groups of 20 animals each: In the transected group (TC), the left sciatic nerve was transected and nerve cut ends were fixed in the adjacent muscle. In the treatment group the defect was bridged using an artery graft (AG/Keto) filled with 10 microliter ketoprofen (0.1 mg/kg). In the artery graft group (AG), the graft was filled with phosphated-buffer saline alone. In the sham-operated group (SHAM), the sciatic nerve was exposed and manipulated. Each group was subdivided into four subgroups of five animals each and regenerated nerve fibres were studied at 4, 8, 12 and 16 weeks post operation. Behavioural testing, sciatic nerve functional study, gastrocnemius muscle mass and morphometric indices showed earlier regeneration of axons in AG/Keto than in AG group (p < 0.05). Immunohistochemical study clearly showed more positive location of reactions to S-100 in AG/Keto than in AG group. When loaded in an artery graft, ketoprofen improved functional recovery and morphometric indices of the sciatic nerve. Local usage of this easily accessible therapeutic medicine is cost saving and avoids the problems associated with systemic administration.

Thyroid hormones and peripheral nerve regeneration

Peripheral nerve regeneration is a unique process in which cellular rather than tissue response is involved. Depending on the extent and proximity of the lesion and the age and type of the neuronal soma, the cell body may either initiate a reparative response or may die. Microsurgical intervention may alter the prognosis after a peripheral nerve injury but to a certain extent. By altering the biochemical microenvironment of the neuron, we can increase the proportion of neurons that survive the injury and initiate the reparative response. Thyroid hormone critically regulates tissue growth and differentiation and plays a crucial role during organ development. Furthermore, recent research has provided new insight into thyroid hormone cellular action. Thyroid hormone regulates stress response intracellular signaling and targets molecules important for cytoskeletal stability and cell integrity. Changes in thyroid hormone signaling occur in nerve and other tissues, with important physiological consequences. The interest in thyroid hormone in the context of nerve regeneration has recently been revived.

Construction of tissue engineered nerve grafts and their application in peripheral nerve regeneration

Surgical repair of severe peripheral nerve injuries represents not only a pressing medical need, but also a great clinical challenge. Autologous nerve grafting remains a golden standard for bridging an extended gap in transected nerves. The formidable limitations related to this approach, however, have evoked the development of tissue engineered nerve grafts as a promising alternative to autologous nerve grafts. A tissue engineered nerve graft is typically constructed through a combination of a neural scaffold and a variety of cellular and molecular components. The initial and basic structure of the neural scaffold that serves to provide mechanical guidance and optimal environment for nerve regeneration was a single hollow nerve guidance conduit. Later there have been several improvements to the basic structure, especially introduction of physical fillers into the lumen of a hollow nerve guidance conduit. Up to now, a diverse array of biomaterials, either of natural or of synthetic origin, together with well-defined fabrication techniques, has been employed to prepare neural scaffolds with different structures and properties. Meanwhile different types of support cells and/or growth factors have been incorporated into the neural scaffold, producing unique biochemical effects on nerve regeneration and function restoration. This review attempts to summarize different nerve grafts used for peripheral nerve repair, to highlight various basic components of tissue engineered nerve grafts in terms of their structures, features, and nerve regeneration-promoting actions, and finally to discuss current clinical applications and future perspectives of tissue engineered nerve grafts.

Thyroid hormone enhances transected axonal regeneration and muscle reinnervation following rat sciatic nerve injury

Improvement of nerve regeneration and functional recovery following nerve injury is a challenging problem in clinical research. We have already shown that following rat sciatic nerve transection, the local administration of triiodothyronine (T3) significantly increased the number and the myelination of regenerated axons. Functional recovery is a sum of the number of regenerated axons and reinnervation of denervated peripheral targets. In the present study, we investigated whether the increased number of regenerated axons by T3-treatment is linked to improved reinnervation of hind limb muscles. After transection of rat sciatic nerves, silicone or biodegradable nerve guides were implanted and filled with either T3 or phosphate buffer solution (PBS). Neuromuscular junctions (NMJs) were analyzed on gastrocnemius and plantar muscle sections stained with rhodamine alpha-bungarotoxin and neurofilament antibody. Four weeks after surgery, most end-plates (EPs) of operated limbs were still denervated and no effect of T3 on muscle reinnervation was detected at this stage of nerve repair. In contrast, after 14 weeks of nerve regeneration, T3 clearly enhanced the reinnervation of gastrocnemius and plantar EPs, demonstrated by significantly higher recovery of size and shape complexity of reinnervated EPs and also by increased acetylcholine receptor (AChRs) density on post synaptic membranes compared to PBS-treated EPs. The stimulating effect of T3 on EP reinnervation is confirmed by a higher index of compound muscle action potentials recorded in gastrocnemius muscles. In conclusion, our results provide for the first time strong evidence that T3 enhances the restoration of NMJ structure and improves synaptic transmission.

Thyroxin regulates BDNF expression to promote survival of injured neurons

A growing amount of evidence indicates that neuronal trauma can induce a recapitulation of developmental-like mechanisms for neuronal survival and regeneration. Concurrently, ontogenic dependency of central neurons for brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) is lost during maturation but is re-acquired after injury. Here we show in organotypic hippocampal slices that thyroxin, the thyroid hormone essential for normal CNS development, induces up-regulation of BDNF upon injury. This change in the effect of thyroxin is crucial to promote survival and regeneration of damaged central neurons. In addition, the effect of thyroxin on the expression of the K-Cl cotransporter (KCC2), a marker of neuronal maturation, is changed from down to up-regulation. Notably, previous results in humans have shown that during the first few days after traumatic brain injury or spinal cord injury, thyroid hormone levels are often diminished. Our data suggest that maintaining normal levels of thyroxin during the early post-traumatic phase of CNS injury could have a therapeutically positive effect.