Development and characterization of monoclonal antibodies specific for the murine thyrotropin receptor

Novel Antimurine Thyroid-Stimulating Hormone Receptor Monoclonal Antibodies

Autoantibodies against thyroid proteins are present in several thyroid diseases. Thyroid-stimulating hormone receptor (TSHR) is a G-protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) that binds to thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) and stimulates production of thyroxine (T4) and triiodothyronine (T3). When agonized by anti-TSHR autoantibodies, aberrant production of thyroid hormone can lead to Graves' Disease (GD). In Hashimoto's thyroiditis (HT), anti-TSHR autoantibodies target the thyroid for immune attack. To better understand the role of anti-TSHR antibodies in thyroid disease, we generated a set of rat antimouse (m)TSHR monoclonal antibodies with a range of affinities, blocking of TSH, and agonist activity. These antibodies could be used to investigate the etiology and therapy of thyroid disease in mouse models and as building blocks in protein therapeutics that target the thyroid for treatment in either HT or GD.

Characterization of apparently paradoxical thyrotropin binding inhibitory immunoglobulins with neutral bioactivity

Context

The thyrotropin (TSH) receptor (TSH-R) autoantibody activity is clinically measured by inhibition of labeled ligand (TSH or M22) binding to the TSH-R (TSH-binding inhibitory immunoglobulin [TBII]) or by stimulation (TSH-R stimulating antibody [TSAb]) or inhibition (TSH-R blocking antibody [TSBAb]) of 3′,5′-cyclic adenosine 5′-monophosphate (cAMP) production in isolated cells.

Objective

We experienced a patient with hypothyroid Graves disease (GD) having strong positive TBII but with almost neutral bioactivities on the TSH-R. The aim of this study is the characterization of this apparently paradoxical TBII (serum sample S).

Methods

We first compared the TBII, TSAb, and TSBAb activities of serum sample S with mixtures of stimulating (S-mAb) and blocking monoclonal Ab (B-mAb). Next, we serially measured cAMPs stimulated by various serum samples in the presence or absence of TSH.

Results

Mixtures of S-mAb and B-mAb did not reproduce the characteristics of serum sample S. Instead, serum sample S had a unique feature that blocked the TSH-stimulated cAMP initially but disappeared the blocking activity thereafter to reach the control level.

Conclusion

We present here the TBIIs with neutral bioactivities found in the patient with autoimmune thyroid disease, which strongly inhibit TSH binding to the TSH-R but exerts neither TSAb nor TSBAb activity. Differences in the methods of detecting TRAb between TBII in vitro and bioassay may cause the discrepancy. Although serum sample S may be an extreme example, a variety of TRAb that not only stimulates or blocks but also interferes with TSH-R binding for only a short time may exist in the serum samples of GD patients.

Blocking type TSH receptor antibodies

TSH receptor (TSHR) autoantibodies (TRAbs) play a key role in the pathogenesis of Graves' disease. In the majority of patients, TRAbs stimulate thyroid hormone synthesis via activation of the TSHR (stimulating TRAbs, TSHR agonists). In some patients, TRAbs bind to the receptor but do not cause activation (blocking TRAbs, TSHR antagonists). Isolation of human TSHR monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) with either stimulating (M22 and K1-18) or blocking activities (5C9 and K1-70) has been a major advance in studies on the TSHR. The binding characteristics of the blocking MAbs, their interaction with the TSHR and their effect on TSHR constitutive activity are summarised in this review. In addition, the binding arrangement in the crystal structures of the TSHR in complex with the blocking MAb K1-70 and with the stimulating MAb M22 (2.55 Å and 1.9 Å resolution, respectively) are compared. The stimulating effect of M22 and the inhibiting effect of K1-70 on thyroid hormone secretion in vivo is discussed. Furthermore the ability of K1-70 to inhibit the thyroid stimulating activity of M22 in vivo is shown. Human MAbs which act as TSHR antagonists are potentially important new therapeutics. For example, in Graves' disease, K1-70 may well be effective in controlling hyperthyroidism and the eye signs caused by stimulating TRAb. In addition, hyperthyroidism caused by autonomous TSH secretion should be treatable by K1-70, and 5C9 has the potential to control hyperthyroidism associated with TSHR activating mutations. Furthermore, K1-70 has potential applications in thyroid imaging as well as targeted drug delivery to TSHR expressing tissues.

Delineating the autoimmune mechanisms in Graves' disease

The immunologic processes involved in autoimmune thyroid disease (AITD), particularly Graves' disease (GD), are similar to other autoimmune diseases with the emphasis on the antibodies as the most unique aspect. These characteristics include a lymphocytic infiltrate at the target organs, the presence of antigen-reactive T and B cells and antibodies, and the establishment of animal models of GD by antibody transfer or immunization with antigen. Similar to other autoimmune diseases, risk factors for GD include the presence of multiple susceptibility genes, including certain HLA alleles, and the TSHR gene itself. In addition, a variety of known risk factors and precipitators have been characterized including the influence of sex and sex hormones, pregnancy, stress, infection, iodine and other potential environmental factors. The pathogenesis of GD is likely the result of a breakdown in the tolerance mechanisms, both at central and peripheral levels. Different subsets of T and B cells together with their regulatory populations play important roles in the propagation and maintenance of the disease process. Understanding different mechanistic in the complex system biology interplay will help to identify unique factors contributing to the AITD pathogenesis.

TSH receptor monoclonal antibodies with agonist, antagonist, and inverse agonist activities

Autoantibodies in autoimmune thyroid disease (AITD) bind to the TSH receptor (TSHR) and can act as either agonists, mimicking the biological activity of TSH, or as antagonists inhibiting the action of TSH. Furthermore, some antibodies with antagonist activity can also inhibit the constitutive activity of the TSHR, that is, act as inverse agonists. The production of animal TSHR monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) with the characteristics of patient autoantibodies and the isolation of human autoantibodies from patients with AITD has allowed us to analyze the interactions of these antibodies with the TSHR at the molecular level. In the case of animal MAbs, advances such as DNA immunization allowed the production of the first MAbs which showed the characteristics of human TSHR autoantibodies (TRAbs). Mouse MAbs (TSMAbs 1-3) and a hamster MAb (MS-1) were obtained that acted as TSHR agonists with the ability to stimulate cyclic AMP production in CHO cells expressing the TSHR. In addition, a mouse TSHR MAb (MAb-B2) that had the ability to act as an antagonist of TRAbs and TSH was isolated and characterized. Also, a mouse TSHR MAb that showed TSH antagonist and TSHR inverse agonist activity (CS-17) was described. Furthermore, a panel of human TRAbs has been obtained from the peripheral blood lymphocytes of patients with AITD and extensively characterized. These MAbs have all the characteristics of TRAbs and are active at ng/mL levels. To date, two human MAbs with TSHR agonist activity (M22 and K1-18), one human MAb with TSHR antagonist activity (K1-70) and one human MAb (5C9) with both TSHR antagonist and TSHR inverse agonist activity have been isolated. Early experiments showed that the binding sites for TSH and for TRAbs with thyroid stimulating or blocking activities were located on the extracellular domain of the TSHR. Extensive studies using TSHRs with single amino acid mutations identified TSHR residues that were important for binding and biological activity of TSHR MAbs (human and animal) and TSH. The structures of several TSHR MAb Fab fragments were solved by X-ray crystallography and provided details of the topography of the antigen binding sites of antibodies with either agonist or antagonist activity. Furthermore stable complexes of the leucine-rich repeat domain (LRD) of the TSHR with a human MAb (M22) with agonist activity and with a human MAb (K1-70) with antagonist activity have been produced and their structures solved by X-ray crystallography at 2.55 and 1.9Å resolution, respectively. Together these experiments have given detailed insights into the interactions of antibodies with different biological activities (agonist, antagonist, and inverse agonist) with the TSHR. Although the nature of ligand binding to the TSHR is now understood in some detail, it is far from clear how these initial interactions lead to functional effects on activation or inactivation of the receptor.

TSH receptor antibodies

The discovery of thyroid-stimulating autoantibodies by Adams and Purves 50 years ago was one of the most important observations in the history of thyroidology. Since that time, the thyroid-stimulating hormone receptor (TSHR) has been shown to be the antigen recognized by these autoantibodies (1974) and the receptor cloned (1989). More recently, different mouse monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) to the TSHR have been produced, culminating in 2002 in the preparation of mouse and hamster MAbs with strong thyroid-stimulating activity. Further, in 2003 a human MAb to the TSHR (M22) with the characteristics of patient thyroid-stimulating autoantibodies was described. M22 has been particularly useful in advancing our knowledge of the TSHR and TSHR autoimmunity, including the development of new assays for TSHR autoantibodies (2004) and determination of a high-resolution (2.55 A) crystal structure of the TSHR leucine-rich domain in combination with M22 (2007). The structure shows that M22 positions itself on the TSHR in an almost identical way to the native hormone TSH but the evolutionary forces that have resulted in production of a common autoantibody that mimics the actions of TSH so well are far from clear at this time. Very recently, a human MAb (5C9) with the characteristics of blocking-type patient serum TSHR autoantibodies has been isolated (2007). Studies on how 5C9 interacts with the TSHR at the molecular level are planned and should provide key insights as to the differences between TSHR autoantibodies with blocking and with stimulating activities. Also, 5C9 and similar MAbs have considerable potential as drugs to inhibit TSHR stimulation by autoantibodies. Further, now the M22-TSHR structure is known at the atomic level, rational design of specific low-molecular-weight inhibitors of the TSHR-TSHR autoantibody interaction is feasible.

Monoclonal antibodies to the thyrotropin receptor

The thyrotropin receptor (TSHR) is a seven transmembrane G-protein linked glycoprotein expressed on the thyroid cell surface and which, under the regulation of TSH, controls the production and secretion of thyroid hormone from the thyroid gland. This membrane protein is also a major target antigen in the autoimmune thyroid diseases. In Graves' disease, autoantibodies to the TSHR (TSHR-Abs) stimulate the TSHR to produce thyroid hormone excessively. In autoimmune thyroid failure, some patients exhibit TSHR-Abs which block TSH action on the receptor. There have been many attempts to generate human stimulating TSHR-mAbs, but to date, only one pathologically relevant human stimulating TSHR-mAb has been isolated. Most mAbs to the TSHR have been derived from rodents immunized with TSHR antigen from bacteria or insect cells. These antigens lacked the native conformation of the TSHR and the resulting mAbs were exclusively blocking or neutral TSHR-mAbs. However, mAbs raised against intact native TSHR antigen have included stimulating mAbs. One such stimulating mAb has demonstrated a number of differences in its regulation of TSHR post-translational processing. These differences are likely to be reflective of TSHR-Abs seen in Graves' disease.

Dissecting linear and conformational epitopes on the native thyrotropin receptor

The TSH receptor (TSHR) is the primary antigen in Graves' disease. In this condition, autoantibodies to the TSHR that have intrinsic thyroid-stimulating activity develop. We studied the epitopes on the native TSHR using polyclonal antisera and monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) derived from an Armenian hamster model of Graves' disease. Of 14 hamster mAbs analyzed, five were shown to bind to conformational epitopes including one mAb with potent thyroid-stimulating activity. Overlapping conformational epitopes were determined by cell-binding competition assays using fluorescently labeled mAbs. We identified two distinct conformational epitopes: epitope A for both stimulating and blocking mAbs and epitope B for only blocking mAbs. Examination of an additional three mouse-derived stimulating TSHR-mAbs also showed exclusive binding to epitope A. The remaining nine hamster-derived mAbs were neutral or low-affinity blocking antibodies that recognized linear epitopes within the TSHR cleaved region (residues 316-366) (epitope C). Serum from the immunized hamsters also recognized conformational epitopes A and B but, in addition, also contained high levels of TSHR-Abs interacting within the linear epitope C region. In summary, these studies indicated that the natively conformed TSHR had a restricted set of epitopes recognized by TSHR-mAbs and that the binding site for stimulating TSHR-Abs was highly conserved. However, high-affinity TSHR-blocking antibodies recognized two conformational epitopes, one of which was indistinguishable from the thyroid-stimulating epitope. Hence, TSHR-stimulating and blocking antibodies cannot be distinguished purely on the basis of their conformational epitope recognition.

Thyroid-stimulating hormone receptor and its role in Graves' disease

The thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH, or thyrotropin) receptor (TSHR) mediates the activating action of TSH to the thyroid gland, resulting in the growth and proliferation of thyrocytes and thyroid hormone production. In Graves' disease, thyroid-stimulating autoantibodies can mimic TSH action and stimulate thyroid cells. This leads to hyperthyroidism and abnormal overproduction of thyroid hormone. TSHR-antibodies-binding epitopes on the receptor molecule are well studied. Mechanism of TSHR-autoantibodies production is more or less clear but a susceptibility gene, which is linked to their production, is still unknown. Genetic studies show no linkage between the TSHR gene and Graves' disease. Among three common polymorphisms in the TSHR gene, only the D727E germline polymorphism in the cytoplasmic tail of the receptor showed an association with the disease, and this association is weak. The absence of a strong genetic effect of the TSHR polymorphisms in such a common and complex disorder as Graves' disease may be explained by a high degree of evolutionary conservation in TSHR. This can be shown by naturally existing germline and somatic mutations in the TSHR gene that cause various types of nonautoimmune and hereditary thyroid disease.

Thyroid-stimulating monoclonal antibodies

Thyrotropin (TSH) receptor monoclonal antibodies (TSHR mAbs) were obtained from cDNA-immunized NMRI mice. Three mAb immunoglobulin Gs (IgGs) (TSmAbs 1-3) that had distinct V(H )and V(L) region sequences stimulated cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) production in isolated porcine thyroid cells greater than 10x basal and as little as 20 ng/mL (0.13 nmol/L) of TSmAb 1 IgG caused a 2x basal stimulation. TSmAb 1 and 2 Fab fragments were also effective stimulators and thyroid-stimulating activities of the IgGs and Fabs were confirmed using TSHR transfected Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. The TSmAbs also inhibited (125)I-labeled TSH binding to TSHR-coated tubes by 50% or more at concentrations of 1 microg/mL or less and gave 15%-20% inhibition at 20-50 ng/mL. (125)I-labeled TSmAbs bound to TSHR-coated tubes with high affinity (approximately 10(10) L/mol) and this binding was inhibited by TSHR autoantibodies with both TSH agonist and antagonist activities. Inhibition of labeled TSmAb binding by Graves' sera correlated well with inhibition of TSH binding (r = 0.96; n = 18; p < 0.001 for TSmAb 2). The TSmAbs have considerable potential as (1) new probes for TSHR structure-function studies, (2) reagents for new assays for TSHR autoantibodies, and (3) alternatives to recombinant TSH in various in vivo applications.

Characterization of the thyrotropin binding pocket

A panel of monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) to the thyrotropin receptor (TSHR) was prepared using three different immunization strategies. The mAbs obtained (n = 138) reacted with linear epitopes covering most of the TSHR extracellular domain and with conformational epitopes. mAbs that bound to five different regions of the TSHR (amino acids [aa] 32-41, aa 36-42, aa 246-260, aa 277-296, and aa 381-385) were able to inhibit (125)I-labeled thyrotropin (TSH) binding to solubilized TSHR preparations. Fab and immunoglobulin G (IgG) preparations were similarly effective inhibitors for mAbs reactive with aa 246-260, aa 277-291 and aa 381-385 suggesting that these three regions of the TSHR are involved in TSH binding. In contrast mAbs reactive with aa 32-41 and aa 36-42 were not effective at inhibiting TSH binding when Fab preparations were used, suggesting that these N terminal regions of the TSHR were less critical for TSH binding. Our studies suggest that three distinct and discontinuous regions of the TSHR (aa 246-260 and 277-296 on the TSHR A subunit) and aa 381-385 (on the TSHR B subunit) fold together to form a complex TSH binding pocket. Alignment of the aa sequences of these three regions in TSHRs from different species indicates that they are highly conserved.

A monoclonal thyroid-stimulating antibody

The thyrotropin receptor, also known as the thyroid-stimulating hormone receptor (TSHR), is the primary antigen of Graves disease. Stimulating TSHR antibodies are the cause of thyroid overstimulation and were originally called long-acting thyroid stimulators due to their prolonged action. Here we report the successful cloning and characterization of a monoclonal antibody (MS-1) with TSHR-stimulating activity. The thyroid-stimulating activity of MS-1 was evident at IgG concentrations as low as 20 ng/ml. MS-1 also competed for radiolabeled TSH binding to the native TSHR and was able to compete for TSH-induced stimulation. MS-1 recognized a conformational epitope within the TSHR alpha (or A) subunit but excluding the receptor cleavage region. Using an assay measuring loss of antibody recognition after cleavage we demonstrated that MS-1, in contrast to TSH, was unable to enhance TSHR posttranslational cleavage. Since receptor cleavage is followed by alpha subunit shedding and receptor degradation, the functional half-life of the receptor may be extended. The isolation and characterization of MS-1 provides a novel explanation for the prolonged thyroid stimulation in this disease which may be secondary to the lack of receptor cleavage in addition to the prolonged half-life of IgG itself.

New insights into the thyroid-stimulating hormone receptor. The major antigen of Graves' disease

The receptor for thyroid-stimulating hormone is one of the most interesting hormone-binding sites because of its close association with common human diseases, including thyroid nodules and Graves' hyperthyroidism. This article discusses the structure and biosynthetic processing of this elusive glycoprotein, whose paucity and instability have impeded its isolation from natural sources. Topics include cleavage and subunit structure, variant species, and structural modeling, the thyroid-stimulating hormone receptor as the major autoantigen in Graves' disease, and a summary of recent efforts to replicate the symptoms of this uniquely human disease in animal models.