Health and social care providers' perspectives of older people's drinking: A systematic review and thematic synthesis of qualitative studies

Domiciliary Carers' Perspectives on Alcohol Use by Older Adults in Their Care: A Systematic Review and Thematic Synthesis of Qualitative Studies

As global populations continue to age, alcohol consumption rises, and we strive to age in place, it is important to have an up-to-date understanding of domiciliary carers' perspectives on older adults' alcohol use in their care. Therefore, a systematic review and thematic synthesis of qualitative studies of the unique challenges faced by domiciliary care workers in front line roles regarding older adults' alcohol use was conducted (PROSPERO registration number: CRD42024516660). Eight databases were searched on 22 February 2024 for qualitative studies focusing on older adults' (defined as aged 50 or over) alcohol consumption and domiciliary care. The Critical Appraisal Skills Programme checklist was utilised for quality appraisal. Twenty articles reporting 14 unique studies of mainly medium to low quality were included. Three overarching themes (and associated subthemes) were identified as follows: identification (alcohol problems are common, no assessment for alcohol problems, and additional overt signs of excessive alcohol use), management (to buy or not to buy that is the question, balancing rights and risks, monitor and report but do not intervene, maintaining the vicious circle, home as a barrier to accessing support and services, and more support needed from healthcare professionals), and training (lack of alcohol education). Domiciliary carers are well placed to make every contact count to target alcohol consumption but would benefit from support and resources for alcohol consumption identification and management. Clear guidance on how to manage alcohol consumption to harmoniously balance rights and risks is crucial, particularly when caring for older adults with cognitive difficulties.

Supporting older adults who misuse alcohol

Older adulthood is a unique time of transition often referred to as the 'golden years'. It is characterised by positive life experiences such as retirement but also by a loss of routine, identity and meaning. The literature identifies alcohol misuse as a growing issue in this population. However, the stigma, perceptions and patterns of drinking associated with alcohol misuse among older people can be a barrier to individuals seeking health advice. This article identifies that older adulthood is a period when nurses can offer health education and support using their unique relationships with patients to encourage healthy drinking behaviours.

Addressing Patients' Alcohol Consumption-A Population-Based Survey of Patient Experiences

Objectives: To identify the proportion of the population that had experienced that alcohol was addressed in health care the previous year, to explore experiences and perceived effects of addressing alcohol, and to investigate the proportion of risky drinkers in the population. Methods: Cross-sectional national web-based survey with 1,208 participants. Socio-demographic data, alcohol consumption (AUDIT-C), and experiences with alcohol conversations were investigated. Results: Approximately four in five respondents had visited health care the past 12 months, and one in six reported having experienced addressing alcohol. Women and older respondents were less likely to report having experienced alcohol conversations compared to other groups. Risky drinkers were not more likely to have experienced an alcohol conversation, but reported longer duration of alcohol conversations and more frequently perceived addressing alcohol as awkward or judgmental. Almost a third of respondents were classified as risky drinkers. Conclusion: The proportion experiencing addressing alcohol in routine health care is low, also among risky drinkers, and risky drinkers more frequently experienced the conversations as judgmental. More sensitive and relevant ways of addressing alcohol in health care is needed.

Factors affecting primary care practitioners' alcohol-related discussions with older adults: a qualitative study

BACKGROUND

Risk of harm from drinking is heightened in later life, owing to age-related sensitivities to alcohol. Primary care services have a key role in supporting older people (aged ≥50 years) to make healthier decisions about alcohol.

AIM

To examine primary care practitioners' perceptions of factors that promote and challenge their work to support older people in alcohol risk-reduction.

DESIGN AND SETTING

Qualitative study consisting of semi-structured interviews and focus groups with primary care practitioners in Northern England.

METHOD

Thirty-five practitioners (GPs, practice/district nurses, pharmacists, dentists, social care practitioners, and domiciliary carers) participated in eight interviews and five focus groups. Data were analysed thematically, applying principles of constant comparison.

RESULTS

Practitioners highlighted particular sensitivities to discussing alcohol among older people, and reservations about older people's resistance to making changes in old age; given that drinking practices could be established, and promote socialisation and emotional wellbeing in later life. Age-related health issues increased older people's contact with practitioners, but management of older people's long-term conditions was prioritised over discussion of alcohol. Dedicated time to address alcohol in routine consultations with older people and training in alcohol intervention facilitated practitioners, particularly pharmacists and practice nurses.

CONCLUSION

There are clear opportunities to support older people in primary care to make healthier decisions about alcohol. Dedicated time to address alcohol, training in identification of alcohol-related risks (particularly those associated with old age), and tailored interventions for older people, feasible to implement in practice settings, would help primary care practitioners to address older people's alcohol use.

Health Professionals' Experiences Regarding Alcohol Consumption and Its Relation to Older Care Recipient's Health and Well-Being

BACKGROUND

Alcohol consumption among older people is expected to increase in the years ahead. Health professionals' experiences of, and reflections on, alcohol consumption and its relation to well-being are thus important to the provision of adequate and high-quality treatment and care.

AIM

To investigate health professionals' experiences and reflections about alcohol consumption among older people and how it is related to their health and well-being.

METHODS

A case study design approach was adopted, incorporating three qualitative studies involving Norwegian health professionals. The health professionals interviewed included workers in nursing homes, home care professionals and general practitioners.

RESULTS

The study revealed a diversity of views and reflections on alcohol consumption, its facilitation, and the impact on the health and well-being of older patients and care recipients. Six themes were revealed by the three studies: (i) the facilitation of alcohol consumption to promote and normalize life in nursing homes, (ii) the restriction of unhealthy alcohol consumption, (iii) attempts to discuss alcohol consumption with care recipients, (iv) the initiation of collaboration with informal caregivers in restricting alcohol consumption, (v) minimalizing the dialogue regarding alcohol consumption to guard patient privacy and (vi) a desire for joint action and a national political strategy.

CONCLUSION

Health professionals working in NHs, in-home and GPs find it difficult to discuss the use and elevated use of alcohol with older people for whom they have care and treatment responsibilities. In general, they are concerned that such conversations infringe on the principles governing an individual's autonomy. However, because they are aware that elevated alcohol intake may have a negative impact on health and well-being, they also express a need for guidelines how they in a better and open minded way can discuss the use and elevated use of alcohol with the patients they care for.

A Substance Misuse Intervention Program in Postacute Care: Who Declines Participation?

OBJECTIVES

Alcohol and substance misuse has been under-acknowledged and underidentified in older adults. However, promising treatment approaches exist (e.g., brief interventions) that can support older adults with at-risk alcohol and substance use. Postacute rehabilitation settings of Skilled Nursing Facilities (SNFs) can offer such programs, but little is known about patient characteristics that are associated with the likelihood of participating in interventions offered in postacute rehabilitation care. Thus, the objective of this study was to identify individual patient characteristics (predisposing, enabling, and need-related factors) associated with participation in a brief alcohol and substance misuse intervention at a SNF.

METHODS

This cross-sectional study analyzed medical record data of postacute care patients within a SNF referred to a substance misuse intervention. Participants were 271 patients with a history of substance misuse, 177 of whom enrolled in the intervention and 94 refused. Data collected upon patient admission were used to examine predisposing, enabling, and need-related factors related to likelihood of program participation.

RESULTS

Older age and ethnic minority status were associated with a reduction in likelihood to participate, while widowhood increased the likelihood of participation.

CONCLUSION

Upon referral to a substance misuse intervention, clinicians in SNFs should be cognizant that some patients may be more likely to refuse intervention, and additional efforts should be made to engage patients at-risk for refusal.

Managing older people's perceptions of alcohol-related risk: a qualitative exploration in Northern English primary care

BACKGROUND

Risk of harm from drinking increases with age as alcohol affects health conditions and medications that are common in later life. Different types of information and experiences affect older people's perceptions of alcohol's effects, which must be navigated when supporting healthier decisions on alcohol consumption.

AIM

To explore how older people understand the effects of alcohol on their health; and how these perspectives are navigated in supportive discussions in primary care to promote healthier alcohol use.

DESIGN AND SETTING

A qualitative study consisting of semi-structured interviews and focus groups with older, non-dependent drinkers and primary care practitioners in Northern England.

METHOD

A total of 24 older adults aged ≥65 years and 35 primary care practitioners participated in interviews and focus groups. Data were analysed thematically, applying principles of constant comparison.

RESULTS

Older adults were motivated to make changes to their alcohol use when they experienced symptoms, and if they felt that limiting consumption would enable them to maintain their quality of life. The results of alcohol-related screening were useful in providing insights into potential effects for individuals. Primary care practitioners motivated older people to make healthier decisions by highlighting individual risks of drinking, and potential gains of limiting intake.

CONCLUSION

Later life is a time when older people may be open to making changes to their alcohol use, particularly when suggested by practitioners. Older people can struggle to recognise potential risks or perceive little gain in acting on perceived risks. Such perceptions may be challenging to navigate in supportive discussions.