Testing microbiome association using integrated quantile regression models

Analysis of Microbiome Data

The microbiome represents a hidden world of tiny organisms populating not only our surroundings but also our own bodies. By enabling comprehensive profiling of these invisible creatures, modern genomic sequencing tools have given us an unprecedented ability to characterize these populations and uncover their outsize impact on our environment and health. Statistical analysis of microbiome data is critical to infer patterns from the observed abundances. The application and development of analytical methods in this area require careful consideration of the unique aspects of microbiome profiles. We begin this review with a brief overview of microbiome data collection and processing and describe the resulting data structure. We then provide an overview of statistical methods for key tasks in microbiome data analysis, including data visualization, comparison of microbial abundance across groups, regression modeling, and network inference. We conclude with a discussion and highlight interesting future directions.

MK-BMC: a Multi-Kernel framework with Boosted distance metrics for Microbiome data for Classification

MOTIVATION

Research on human microbiome has suggested associations with human health, opening opportunities to predict health outcomes using microbiome. Studies have also suggested that diverse forms of taxa such as rare taxa that are evolutionally related and abundant taxa that are evolutionally unrelated could be associated with or predictive of a health outcome. Although prediction models were developed for microbiome data, no prediction models currently exist that use multiple forms of microbiome-outcome associations.

RESULTS

We developed MK-BMC, a Multi-Kernel framework with Boosted distance Metrics for Classification using microbiome data. We propose to first boost widely used distance metrics for microbiome data using taxon-level association signal strengths to up-weight taxa that are potentially associated with an outcome of interest. We then propose a multi-kernel prediction model with one kernel capturing one form of association between taxa and the outcome, where a kernel measures similarities of microbiome compositions between pairs of samples being transformed from a proposed boosted distance metric. We demonstrated superior prediction performance of (i) boosted distance metrics for microbiome data over original ones and (ii) MK-BMC over competing methods through extensive simulations. We applied MK-BMC to predict thyroid, obesity, and inflammatory bowel disease status using gut microbiome data from the American Gut Project and observed much-improved prediction performance over that of competing methods. The learned kernel weights help us understand contributions of individual microbiome signal forms nicely.

AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION

Source code together with a sample input dataset is available at https://github.com/HXu06/MK-BMC.

multiMiAT: an optimal microbiome-based association test for multicategory phenotypes

Microbes can affect the metabolism and immunity of human body incessantly, and the dysbiosis of human microbiome drives not only the occurrence but also the progression of disease (i.e. multiple statuses of disease). Recently, microbiome-based association tests have been widely developed to detect the association between the microbiome and host phenotype. However, the existing methods have not achieved satisfactory performance in testing the association between the microbiome and ordinal/nominal multicategory phenotypes (e.g. disease severity and tumor subtype). In this paper, we propose an optimal microbiome-based association test for multicategory phenotypes, namely, multiMiAT. Specifically, under the multinomial logit model framework, we first introduce a microbiome regression-based kernel association test for multicategory phenotypes (multiMiRKAT). As a data-driven optimal test, multiMiAT then integrates multiMiRKAT, score test and MiRKAT-MC to maintain excellent performance in diverse association patterns. Massive simulation experiments prove the success of our method. Furthermore, multiMiAT is also applied to real microbiome data experiments to detect the association between the gut microbiome and clinical statuses of colorectal cancer as well as for diverse statuses of Clostridium difficile infections.