RFC1 nonsense and frameshift variants cause CANVAS: clues for an unsolved pathophysiology

Neurological disorders caused by novel non-coding repeat expansions: clinical features and differential diagnosis

Nucleotide repeat expansions in the human genome are a well-known cause of neurological disease. In the past decade, advances in DNA sequencing technologies have led to a better understanding of the role of non-coding DNA, that is, the DNA that is not transcribed into proteins. These techniques have also enabled the identification of pathogenic non-coding repeat expansions that cause neurological disorders. Mounting evidence shows that adult patients with familial or sporadic presentations of epilepsy, cognitive dysfunction, myopathy, neuropathy, ataxia, or movement disorders can be carriers of non-coding repeat expansions. The description of the clinical, epidemiological, and molecular features of these recently identified non-coding repeat expansion disorders should guide clinicians in the diagnosis and management of these patients, and help in the genetic counselling for patients and their families.

An Updated Canvas of the RFC1-mediated CANVAS (Cerebellar Ataxia, Neuropathy and Vestibular Areflexia Syndrome)

Proliferation of specific nucleotide sequences within the coding and non-coding regions of numerous genes has been implicated in approximately 40 neurodegenerative disorders. Cerebellar ataxia, neuropathy and vestibular areflexia syndrome (CANVAS), a neurodegenerative disorder, is distinguished by a pathological triad of sensory neuropathy, bilateral vestibular areflexia and cerebellar impairments. It manifests in adults gradually and is autosomal recessive and multi-system ataxia. Predominantly, CANVAS is associated with biallelic AAGGG repeat expansions in intron 2 of the RFC1 gene. Although various motifs have been identified, only a subset induces pathological consequences, by forming stable secondary structures that disrupt gene functions both in vitro and in vivo. The pathogenesis of CANVAS remains a subject of intensive research, yet its precise mechanisms remain elusive. Herein, we aim to comprehensively review the epidemiology, clinical ramifications, molecular mechanisms, genetics, and potential therapeutics in light of the current findings, extending an overview of the most significant research on CANVAS.

RFC1 Repeat Distribution in the Cypriot Population: Study of a Large Cohort of Patients With Undiagnosed Ataxia and Non-Disease Controls

Background and Objectives

The intronic biallelic AAGGG expansion in the replication factor C subunit 1 (RFC1) gene was recently associated with a phenotype combining cerebellar ataxia, neuropathy, and vestibular areflexia syndrome, as well as with late-onset ataxia. Following this discovery, studies in multiple populations extended the phenotypic and genotypic spectrum of this locus. Multiple benign and additional pathogenic configurations are currently known. Our main objectives were to study the prevalence of the pathogenic AAGGG expansion in the Cypriot population, to further characterize the RFC1 repeat locus allele distribution, and to search for possible novel repeat configurations.

Methods

Cypriot undiagnosed patients, in the majority presenting at least with cerebellar ataxia and non-neurologic disease controls, were included in this study. A combination of conventional methods was used, including standard PCR flanking the repeat region, repeat-primed PCR, long-range PCR, and Sanger sequencing. Bioinformatics analysis of already available in-house short-read whole-genome sequencing data was also performed.

Results

A large group of undiagnosed patients (n = 194), mainly presenting with pure ataxia or with ataxia accompanied by neuropathy or additional symptoms, as well as a group of non-disease controls (n = 100), were investigated in the current study. Our findings include the diagnosis of 10 patients homozygous for the pathogenic AAGGG expansion and a high percentage of heterozygous AAGGG carriers in both groups. The benign AAAAGn, AAAGGn, and AAGAGn configurations were also identified in our cohorts. We also report and discuss the identification of 2 recently reported novel and possibly benign repeat configurations, AAAGGGn and AAGACn, thus confirming their existence in another distinct population, and we highlight an increased frequency of the AAAGGGn in the patient group, including a single case of homozygosity.

Discussion

Our findings indicate the existence of genetic heterogeneity regarding the RFC1 repeat configurations and that the AAGGG pathogenic expansion is a frequent cause of ataxia in the Cypriot population.

An Update on the Adult-Onset Hereditary Cerebellar Ataxias: Novel Genetic Causes and New Diagnostic Approaches

The hereditary cerebellar ataxias (HCAs) are rare, progressive neurologic disorders caused by variants in many different genes. Inheritance may follow autosomal dominant, autosomal recessive, X-linked or mitochondrial patterns. The list of genes associated with adult-onset cerebellar ataxia is continuously growing, with several new genes discovered in the last few years. This includes short-tandem repeat (STR) expansions in RFC1, causing cerebellar ataxia, neuropathy, vestibular areflexia syndrome (CANVAS), FGF14-GAA causing spinocerebellar ataxia type 27B (SCA27B), and THAP11. In addition, the genetic basis for SCA4, has recently been identified as a STR expansion in ZFHX3. Given the large and growing number of genes, and different gene variant types, the approach to diagnostic testing for adult-onset HCA can be complex. Testing methods include targeted evaluation of STR expansions (e.g. SCAs, Friedreich ataxia, fragile X-associated tremor/ataxia syndrome, dentatorubral-pallidoluysian atrophy), next generation sequencing for conventional variants, which may include targeted gene panels, whole exome, or whole genome sequencing, followed by various potential additional tests. This review proposes a diagnostic approach for clinical testing, highlights the challenges with current testing technologies, and discusses future advances which may overcome these limitations. Implementing long-read sequencing has the potential to transform the diagnostic approach in HCA, with the overall aim to improve the diagnostic yield.

Pathogenic CANVAS (AAGGG)n repeats stall DNA replication due to the formation of alternative DNA structures

CANVAS is a recently characterized repeat expansion disease, most commonly caused by homozygous expansions of an intronic (A2G3)n repeat in the RFC1 gene. There are a multitude of repeat motifs found in the human population at this locus, some of which are pathogenic and others benign. In this study, we conducted structure-functional analyses of the pathogenic (A2G3)n and nonpathogenic (A4G)n repeats. We found that the pathogenic, but not the nonpathogenic, repeat presents a potent, orientation-dependent impediment to DNA polymerization in vitro. The pattern of the polymerization blockage is consistent with triplex or quadruplex formation in the presence of magnesium or potassium ions, respectively. Chemical probing of both repeats in vitro reveals triplex H-DNA formation by only the pathogenic repeat. Consistently, bioinformatic analysis of S1-END-seq data from human cell lines shows preferential H-DNA formation genome-wide by (A2G3)n motifs over (A4G)n motifs. Finally, the pathogenic, but not the nonpathogenic, repeat stalls replication fork progression in yeast and human cells. We hypothesize that the CANVAS-causing (A2G3)n repeat represents a challenge to genome stability by folding into alternative DNA structures that stall DNA replication.

Chronic Cough and Cerebellar Ataxia With Neuropathy and Bilateral Vestibular Areflexia Syndrome (CANVAS): Screening for Mutations in Replication Factor C Subunit 1 (RFC1)

INTRODUCTION

A common complaint in patients is chronic cough (CC), which may be refractory (RCC) or unexplained (UCC). Recent studies point, as a possible cause of CC, to the hereditary cerebellar ataxia with neuropathy and bilateral vestibular areflexia syndrome (CANVAS), with an estimated carrier prevalence of 1 in 20000.

AIM

In patients with CC, determine the prevalence of the biallelic (AAGGG)exp mutation in replication factor C subunit 1 (RFC1) responsible for CANVAS, test the usefulness of the Rydel-Seiffer fork test, and evaluate patient quality of life (QoL).

METHODS

Clinical and functional data were collected for the 33 included patients undergoing CC studies in our specialized unit. Performed were an etiological study of CC following European Respiratory Society recommendations, a genetic study of RFC1 mutations, and Rydel-Seiffer fork testing to detect possible peripheral vibratory sensitivity impairment. Administered to evaluate QoL were 4 questionnaires.

RESULTS

Prevalence of biallelic (AAGGG)exp in RFC1 was 6.1% (n=2) overall, increasing to 7.1% in the RCC subgroup, and to 33.3% in the Rydel-Seiffer fork altered results subgroup. Prevalence of monoallelic (AAGGG)exp in RFC1 was 18.2% (n=6) overall, rising to 50.0% (n=2) in the UCC subgroup.

CONCLUSION

Genetic screening for (AAGGG)exp in RFC1, and also use of the Rydel-Seiffer fork test, should be considered in specialized CC consultations for patients with RCC and UCC. Detecting possible CANVAS symptoms in CC studies would identify candidates for early genetic screening, of interest in reducing the disease burden for patients and health systems alike.

Role of the repeat expansion size in predicting age of onset and severity in RFC1 disease

RFC1 disease, caused by biallelic repeat expansion in RFC1, is clinically heterogeneous in terms of age of onset, disease progression and phenotype. We investigated the role of the repeat size in influencing clinical variables in RFC1 disease. We also assessed the presence and role of meiotic and somatic instability of the repeat. In this study, we identified 553 patients carrying biallelic RFC1 expansions and measured the repeat expansion size in 392 cases. Pearson's coefficient was calculated to assess the correlation between the repeat size and age at disease onset. A Cox model with robust cluster standard errors was adopted to describe the effect of repeat size on age at disease onset, on age at onset of each individual symptoms, and on disease progression. A quasi-Poisson regression model was used to analyse the relationship between phenotype and repeat size. We performed multivariate linear regression to assess the association of the repeat size with the degree of cerebellar atrophy. Meiotic stability was assessed by Southern blotting on first-degree relatives of 27 probands. Finally, somatic instability was investigated by optical genome mapping on cerebellar and frontal cortex and unaffected peripheral tissue from four post-mortem cases. A larger repeat size of both smaller and larger allele was associated with an earlier age at neurological onset [smaller allele hazard ratio (HR) = 2.06, P < 0.001; larger allele HR = 1.53, P < 0.001] and with a higher hazard of developing disabling symptoms, such as dysarthria or dysphagia (smaller allele HR = 3.40, P < 0.001; larger allele HR = 1.71, P = 0.002) or loss of independent walking (smaller allele HR = 2.78, P < 0.001; larger allele HR = 1.60; P < 0.001) earlier in disease course. Patients with more complex phenotypes carried larger expansions [smaller allele: complex neuropathy rate ratio (RR) = 1.30, P = 0.003; cerebellar ataxia, neuropathy and vestibular areflexia syndrome (CANVAS) RR = 1.34, P < 0.001; larger allele: complex neuropathy RR = 1.33, P = 0.008; CANVAS RR = 1.31, P = 0.009]. Furthermore, larger repeat expansions in the smaller allele were associated with more pronounced cerebellar vermis atrophy (lobules I-V β = -1.06, P < 0.001; lobules VI-VII β = -0.34, P = 0.005). The repeat did not show significant instability during vertical transmission and across different tissues and brain regions. RFC1 repeat size, particularly of the smaller allele, is one of the determinants of variability in RFC1 disease and represents a key prognostic factor to predict disease onset, phenotype and severity. Assessing the repeat size is warranted as part of the diagnostic test for RFC1 expansion.

RFC1: Motifs and phenotypes

Biallelic intronic expansions (AAGGG)exp in intron 2 of the RFC1 gene have been shown to be a common cause of late-onset ataxia. Since their first description, the phenotypes, neurological damage, and pathogenic variants associated with the RFC1 gene have been frequently updated. Here, we review the various motifs, genetic variants, and phenotypes associated with the RFC1 gene. We searched PubMed for scientific articles published between March 1st, 2019, and January 15th, 2024. The motifs and phenotypes associated with the RFC1 gene are highly heterogeneous, making molecular diagnosis and clinical screening and investigation challenging. In this review we will provide clues to give a better understanding of RFC1 disease. We briefly discuss new methods for molecular diagnosis, the origin of cough in RFC1 disease, and research perspectives.

Structural investigation of pathogenic RFC1 AAGGG pentanucleotide repeats reveals a role of G-quadruplex in dysregulated gene expression in CANVAS

An expansion of AAGGG pentanucleotide repeats in the replication factor C subunit 1 (RFC1) gene is the genetic cause of cerebellar ataxia, neuropathy, and vestibular areflexia syndrome (CANVAS), and it also links to several other neurodegenerative diseases including the Parkinson's disease. However, the pathogenic mechanism of RFC1 AAGGG repeat expansion remains enigmatic. Here, we report that the pathogenic RFC1 AAGGG repeats form DNA and RNA parallel G-quadruplex (G4) structures that play a role in impairing biological processes. We determine the first high-resolution nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) structure of a bimolecular parallel G4 formed by d(AAGGG)2AA and reveal how AAGGG repeats fold into a higher-order structure composed of three G-tetrad layers, and further demonstrate the formation of intramolecular G4s in longer DNA and RNA repeats. The pathogenic AAGGG repeats, but not the nonpathogenic AAAAG repeats, form G4 structures to stall DNA replication and reduce gene expression via impairing the translation process in a repeat-length-dependent manner. Our results provide an unprecedented structural basis for understanding the pathogenic mechanism of AAGGG repeat expansion associated with CANVAS. In addition, the high-resolution structures resolved in this study will facilitate rational design of small-molecule ligands and helicases targeting G4s formed by AAGGG repeats for therapeutic interventions.

RNA Foci in Two bi-Allelic RFC1 Expansion Carriers

Cerebellar ataxia, neuropathy, vestibular areflexia syndrome (CANVAS) is a late-onset, autosomal recessive neurodegenerative disorder caused by biallelic AAGGG/ACAGG repeat expansion (AAGGG-exp/ACAGG-exp) in RFC1. The recent identification of patients with CANVAS exhibiting compound heterozygosity for AAGGG-exp and truncating variants supports the loss-of-function of RFC1 in CANVAS patients. We investigated the pathological changes in 2 autopsied patients with CANVAS harboring biallelic ACAGG-exp and AAGGG-exp. RNA fluorescence in situ hybridization of the 2 patients revealed CCTGT- and CCCTT-containing RNA foci, respectively, in neuronal nuclei of tissues with neuronal loss. Our findings suggest that RNA toxicity may be involved in the pathogenesis of CANVAS. ANN NEUROL 2024;95:607-613.

Clinical and functional characteristics, possible causes, and impact of chronic cough in patients with cerebellar ataxia, neuropathy, and bilateral vestibular areflexia syndrome (CANVAS)

Cerebellar ataxia with neuropathy and bilateral vestibular areflexia syndrome (CANVAS) is an hereditary autosomal recessive disease. Recent studies propose including chronic cough (CC) as a symptom of CANVAS. For 10 patients with CANVAS as genetically confirmed by biallelic expansion of the AAGG repeat motif (AAGGGexp) in intron 2 of replication factor C subunit 1 (RFC1), our aim was, as a multidisciplinary team, to describe clinical and functional characteristics and possible causes of CC following European Respiratory Society (ERS) recommendations, and to evaluate CC impact on quality of life (QoL) using self-administered questionnaires (Cough Severity Diary, Leicester Cough Questionnaire, Discrete Emotions Questionnaire, and EQ-5D-5L). In all 10 patients, the CC was a dry cough that developed several years prior to the neurological symptoms (mean 14.2 years); 7 patients had symptoms compatible with gastroesophageal reflux (GER), 5 with pathological GER diagnosed by 24-h esophageal pH testing, and 6 patients had impaired esophageal motility diagnosed by high-resolution esophageal manometry, most frequently ineffective peristalsis. Although further studies are required for confirmation, we conclude that CC may be a characteristic prodrome of CANVAS and may be related to GER and esophageal disorders. Furthermore, CC affects patients' QoL, especially in the psychosocial sphere.

Chronic Cough as a Genetic Neurological Disorder? Insights from Cerebellar Ataxia with Neuropathy and Vestibular Areflexia Syndrome (CANVAS)

Chronic cough is common, and in many cases unexplained or refractory to otherwise effective treatment of associated medical conditions. Cough hypersensitivity has developed as a paradigm that helps to explain clinical and research observations that frequently point towards chronic cough as a neuropathic disorder. Cerebellar ataxia with neuropathy and vestibular areflexia syndrome (CANVAS) is a recently described neurological condition whose clinical features include gait ataxia, unsteadiness, peripheral neuropathy, and autonomic dysfunction. Chronic cough is also a common feature of the syndrome, with features of hypersensitivity, often preceding core neurological symptoms by up to 30 years or more. The genetic basis in a majority of cases of CANVAS appears to be biallelic variable repeat intron expansion sequences within RFC1, a gene normally involved in the regulation of DNA replication and repair. The same polymorphism has now been identified at an increased frequency in patients with unexplained or refractory chronic cough in the absence of defining clinical features of CANVAS. This review expands on these points, aiming to increase the awareness of CANVAS amongst clinicians and researchers working with chronic cough. We discuss the implications of a link between RFC1 disease and cough. Improved understanding of CANVAS may lead to an enhanced grasp of the pathophysiology of chronic cough, and new approaches to antitussive treatments.

Normal and pathogenic variation of RFC1 repeat expansions: implications for clinical diagnosis

Cerebellar ataxia, neuropathy and vestibular areflexia syndrome (CANVAS) is an autosomal recessive neurodegenerative disease, usually caused by biallelic AAGGG repeat expansions in RFC1. In this study, we leveraged whole genome sequencing data from nearly 10 000 individuals recruited within the Genomics England sequencing project to investigate the normal and pathogenic variation of the RFC1 repeat. We identified three novel repeat motifs, AGGGC (n = 6 from five families), AAGGC (n = 2 from one family) and AGAGG (n = 1), associated with CANVAS in the homozygous or compound heterozygous state with the common pathogenic AAGGG expansion. While AAAAG, AAAGGG and AAGAG expansions appear to be benign, we revealed a pathogenic role for large AAAGG repeat configuration expansions (n = 5). Long-read sequencing was used to characterize the entire repeat sequence, and six patients exhibited a pure AGGGC expansion, while the other patients presented complex motifs with AAGGG or AAAGG interruptions. All pathogenic motifs appeared to have arisen from a common haplotype and were predicted to form highly stable G quadruplexes, which have previously been demonstrated to affect gene transcription in other conditions. The assessment of these novel configurations is warranted in CANVAS patients with negative or inconclusive genetic testing. Particular attention should be paid to carriers of compound AAGGG/AAAGG expansions when the AAAGG motif is very large (>500 repeats) or the AAGGG motif is interrupted. Accurate sizing and full sequencing of the satellite repeat with long-read sequencing is recommended in clinically selected cases to enable accurate molecular diagnosis and counsel patients and their families.

Optical Genome Mapping Enables Detection and Accurate Sizing of RFC1 Repeat Expansions

A recessive Short Tandem Repeat expansion in RFC1 has been found to be associated with cerebellar ataxia, neuropathy and vestibular areflexia syndrome (CANVAS), and to be a frequent cause of late onset ataxia and sensory neuropathy. The usual procedure for sizing these expansions is based on Southern Blotting (SB), a time-consuming and a relatively imprecise technique. In this paper, we compare SB with Optical Genome Mapping (OGM), a method for detecting Structural Variants (SVs) based on the measurement of distances between fluorescently labelled probes, for the diagnosis of RFC1 CANVAS and disease spectrum. The two methods are applied to 17 CANVAS patients' blood samples and resulting sizes compared, showing a good agreement. Further, long-read sequencing is used for two patients to investigate the agreement of sizes with either SB or OGM. Our study concludes that OGM represents a viable alternative to SB, allowing for a simpler technique, a more precise sizing of the expansion and ability to expand analysis of SV in the entire genome as opposed to SB which is a locus specific method.

Frequency and Phenotype of RFC1 Repeat Expansions in Bilateral Vestibulopathy

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Bilateral vestibulopathy (BVP) is a chronic debilitating neurologic disorder with no monogenic cause established so far despite familiar presentations. We hypothesized that replication factor complex subunit 1 (RFC1) repeat expansions might present a recurrent monogenic cause of BVP.

METHODS

The study involved RFC1 screening and in-depth neurologic, vestibulo-oculomotor, and disease evolution phenotyping of 168 consecutive patients with idiopathic at least "probable BVP" from a tertiary referral center for balance disorders, with127 of them meeting current diagnostic criteria of BVP (Bárány Society Classification).

RESULTS

Biallelic AAGGG repeat expansions in RFC1 were identified in 10/127 patients (8%) with BVP and 1/41 with probable BVP. Heterozygous expansions in 10/127 patients were enriched compared with those in reference populations. RFC1-related BVP manifested at a median age of 60 years (range 34-72 years) and co-occurred predominantly with mild polyneuropathy (10/11). Additional cerebellar involvement (7/11) was subtle and limited to oculomotor signs in early stages, below recognition of classic cerebellar ataxia, neuropathy, and vestibular areflexia syndrome. Clear dysarthria, appendicular ataxia, or cerebellar atrophy developed 6-8 years after onset. Dysarthria, absent patellar reflexes, and downbeat nystagmus best discriminated RFC1-positive BVP from RFC1-negative BVP, but neither sensory symptoms nor fine motor problems. Video head impulse gains of patients with RFC1-positive BVP were lower relative to those of patients with RFC1-negative BVP and decreased until 10 years disease duration, indicating a potential progression and outcome marker for RFC1-disease.

DISCUSSION

This study identifies RFC1 as the first-and frequent-monogenic cause of BVP. It characterizes RFC1-related BVP as part of the multisystemic evolution of RFC1 spectrum disease, with implications for designing natural history studies and future treatment trials.

CLASSIFICATION OF EVIDENCE

This study provides Class II evidence that RFC1 repeat expansions cause BVP.

Pathogenic CANVAS (AAGGG)n repeats stall DNA replication due to the formation of alternative DNA structures

CANVAS is a recently characterized repeat expansion disease, most commonly caused by homozygous expansions of an intronic (A2G3)n repeat in the RFC1 gene. There are a multitude of repeat motifs found in the human population at this locus, some of which are pathogenic and others benign. In this study, we conducted structure-functional analyses of the main pathogenic (A2G3)n and the main nonpathogenic (A4G)n repeats. We found that the pathogenic, but not the nonpathogenic, repeat presents a potent, orientation-dependent impediment to DNA polymerization in vitro. The pattern of the polymerization blockage is consistent with triplex or quadruplex formation in the presence of magnesium or potassium ions, respectively. Chemical probing of both repeats in supercoiled DNA reveals triplex H-DNA formation by the pathogenic repeat. Consistently, bioinformatic analysis of the S1-END-seq data from human cell lines shows preferential H-DNA formation genome-wide by (A2G3)n motifs over (A4G)n motifs in vivo. Finally, the pathogenic, but not the non-pathogenic, repeat stalls replication fork progression in yeast and human cells. We hypothesize that CANVAS-causing (A2G3)n repeat represents a challenge to genome stability by folding into alternative DNA structures that stall DNA replication.

RFC1 in an Australasian neurological disease cohort: extending the genetic heterogeneity and implications for diagnostics

Cerebellar ataxia, neuropathy and vestibular areflexia syndrome is a progressive, generally late-onset, neurological disorder associated with biallelic pentanucleotide expansions in Intron 2 of the RFC1 gene. The locus exhibits substantial genetic variability, with multiple pathogenic and benign pentanucleotide repeat alleles previously identified. To determine the contribution of pathogenic RFC1 expansions to neurological disease within an Australasian cohort and further investigate the heterogeneity exhibited at the locus, a combination of flanking and repeat-primed PCR was used to screen a cohort of 242 Australasian patients with neurological disease. Patients whose data indicated large gaps within expanded alleles following repeat-primed PCR, underwent targeted long-read sequencing to identify novel repeat motifs at the locus. To increase diagnostic yield, additional probes at the RFC1 repeat region were incorporated into the PathWest diagnostic laboratory targeted neurological disease gene panel to enable first-pass screening of the locus for all samples tested on the panel. Within the Australasian cohort, we detected known pathogenic biallelic expansions in 15.3% (n = 37) of patients. Thirty indicated biallelic AAGGG expansions, two had biallelic 'Māori alleles' [(AAAGG)exp(AAGGG)exp], two samples were compound heterozygous for the Māori allele and an AAGGG expansion, two samples had biallelic ACAGG expansions and one sample was compound heterozygous for the ACAGG and AAGGG expansions. Forty-five samples tested indicated the presence of biallelic expansions not known to be pathogenic. A large proportion (84%) showed complex interrupted patterns following repeat-primed PCR, suggesting that these expansions are likely to be comprised of more than one repeat motif, including previously unknown repeats. Using targeted long-read sequencing, we identified three novel repeat motifs in expanded alleles. Here, we also show that short-read sequencing can be used to reliably screen for the presence or absence of biallelic RFC1 expansions in all samples tested using the PathWest targeted neurological disease gene panel. Our results show that RFC1 pathogenic expansions make a substantial contribution to neurological disease in the Australasian population and further extend the heterogeneity of the locus. To accommodate the increased complexity, we outline a multi-step workflow utilizing both targeted short- and long-read sequencing to achieve a definitive genotype and provide accurate diagnoses for patients.