The within-host evolution of antimicrobial resistance in Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Contribution of the infection ecosystem and biogeography to antibiotic failure in vivo

The acquisition of antibiotic resistance in bacteria, though a deeply concerning international issue, is reasonably well-understood at a mechanistic level. Less well-understood is why bacteria that are sensitive in vitro to well-established and widely-used antibiotics sometimes fail to respond to these agents in vivo. This is a particularly common problem in chronic, polymicrobial infection scenarios. Here, we discuss this in vitro-in vivo disconnect from the perspective of the bacterium, focusing in particular on how infection micro/macro-environment, biogeography, and the presence of co-habiting species affect the response to antibiotics. Using selected exemplars, we also consider interventions that might improve treatment outcomes, as well as ecologically 'eubiotic' approaches that have less of an impact on the patient's commensal microflora. In our view, the accrued data strongly suggest that we need a more comprehensive understanding of the in situ microbiology at infection sites.

Ecological and evolutionary mechanisms driving within-patient emergence of antimicrobial resistance

The ecological and evolutionary mechanisms of antimicrobial resistance (AMR) emergence within patients and how these vary across bacterial infections are poorly understood. Increasingly widespread use of pathogen genome sequencing in the clinic enables a deeper understanding of these processes. In this Review, we explore the clinical evidence to support four major mechanisms of within-patient AMR emergence in bacteria: spontaneous resistance mutations; in situ horizontal gene transfer of resistance genes; selection of pre-existing resistance; and immigration of resistant lineages. Within-patient AMR emergence occurs across a wide range of host niches and bacterial species, but the importance of each mechanism varies between bacterial species and infection sites within the body. We identify potential drivers of such differences and discuss how ecological and evolutionary analysis could be embedded within clinical trials of antimicrobials, which are powerful but underused tools for understanding why these mechanisms vary between pathogens, infections and individuals. Ultimately, improving understanding of how host niche, bacterial species and antibiotic mode of action combine to govern the ecological and evolutionary mechanism of AMR emergence in patients will enable more predictive and personalized diagnosis and antimicrobial therapies.

Clinical performance of nucleotide MALDI-TOF-MS in the rapid diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis and drug resistance

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the application value of nucleotide matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF-MS) technology in the rapid diagnosis of pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) and its drug resistance.

METHODS

From February 2021 to January 2022, respiratory specimens from 214 suspected PTB patients at the First Hospital of Quanzhou were collected. Nucleotide MALDI-TOF-MS and BACTEC MGIT 960 culture methods were used for the detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB) and drug resistance to anti-tuberculosis drugs.

RESULTS

Compared with culture method, nucleotide MALDI-TOF-MS technology had a sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy of 92.2%, 74.1%, and 82.7%, respectively, for the detection of MTB in respiratory specimens. With clinical diagnosis as the reference standard, the sensitivity and accuracy of nucleotide MALDI-TOF-MS were 82.5% and 86.0%, respectively, which were higher than those of the culture method (69.2% and 78.0%, respectively). The specificity of nucleotide MALDI-TOF-MS was 93.0%, which was slightly lower than that of culture method (95.8%). As for drug resistance, the results of nucleotide MALDI-TOF-MS exhibited good consistence with culture methods for rifampin, isoniazid, ethambutol, and streptomycin.

CONCLUSION

Nucleotide MALDI-TOF-MS detection has a good clinical performance for rapid detection of MTB and drug sensitivity to rifampin, isoniazid, ethambutol, and streptomycin directly on respiratory specimens.

Drug-Tolerant Mycobacterium tuberculosis Adopt Different Survival Strategies in Alveolar Macrophages of Patients with Pulmonary Tuberculosis

The rapid spread of drug-resistant M. tuberculosis (Mtb) strains and the phenomenon of phenotypic tolerance to drugs present challenges toward achieving the goal of tuberculosis (TB) elimination worldwide. By using the ex vivo cultures of alveolar macrophages obtained from lung tissues of TB patients after intensive antimicrobial chemotherapy before surgery, different subpopulations of multidrug-tolerant Mtb with a spectrum of phenotypic and growth features were identified in the same TB lesions. Our results are indicative of not only passive mechanisms generating nonheritable resistance of Mtb to antibiotics, which are associated mainly with a lack of Mtb growth, but also some active mechanisms of Mtb persistence, such as cell wall and metabolic pathway remodeling. In one of the subpopulations, non-acid-fast Mtb have undergone significant reprogramming with the restoration of acid-fastness, lipoarabinomannan expression and replication in host cells of some patients after withdrawal of anti-TB drugs. Our data indicate the universal stress protein Rv2623 as a clinically relevant biomarker of Mtb that has lost acid-fastness in human lungs. The studies of Mtb survival, persistence, dormancy, and resumption and the identification of biomarkers characterizing these phenomena are very important concerning the development of vaccines and drug regimens with individualized management of patients for overcoming the resistance/tolerance crisis in anti-TB therapy.

A soft-computation hybrid method for search of the antibiotic-resistant gene in Mycobacterium tuberculosis for promising drug target identification and antimycobacterial lead discovery

Tuberculosis (TB) control programs were already piloted before the COVID-19 pandemic commenced and the global TB response was amplified by the pandemic. To combat the global TB epidemic, drug repurposing, novel drug discovery, identification and targeting of the antimicrobial resistance (AMR) genes, and addressing social determinants of TB are required. The study aimed to identify AMR genes in Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB) and a new anti-mycobacterial drug candidate. In this research, we used a few software to explore some AMR genes as a target protein in MTB and identified some potent antimycobacterial agents. We used Maestro v12.8 software, along with STRING v11.0, KEGG and Pass Server databases to gain a deeper understanding of MTB AMR genes as drug targets. Computer-aided analysis was used to identify mtrA and katG AMR genes as potential drug targets to depict some antimycobacterial drug candidates. Based on docking scores of -4.218 and -6.161, carvacrol was identified as a potent inhibitor against both drug targets. This research offers drug target identification and discovery of antimycobacterial leads, a unique and promising approach to combating the challenge of antibiotic resistance in Mycobacterium, and contributes to the development of a potential futuristic solution.

Quantification of Isoniazid-Heteroresistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis Using Droplet Digital PCR

The quantitative detection of drug-resistance mutations in Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB) is critical for determining the drug resistance status of a sample. We developed a drop-off droplet digital PCR (ddPCR) assay targeting all major isoniazid (INH)-resistant mutations. The ddPCR assay consisted of three reactions: reaction A detects mutations at katG S315; reaction B detects inhA promoter mutations; and reaction C detects ahpC promoter mutations. All reactions could quantify 1%-50% of mutants in the presence of the wild-type, ranging from 100 to 50,000 copies/reaction. Clinical evaluation with 338 clinical isolates yielded clinical sensitivity of 94.5% (95% confidence interval [CI] = 89.1%-97.3%) and clinical specificity of 97.6% (95% CI = 94.6%-99.0%) compared with the traditional drug susceptibility testing (DST). Further clinical evaluation using 194 nucleic acid-positive MTB sputum samples revealed clinical sensitivity of 87.8% (95% CI = 75.8%-94.3%) and clinical specificity of 96.5% (95% CI = 92.2%-98.5%) in comparison with DST. All the mutant and heteroresistant samples detected by the ddPCR assay but susceptible by DST were confirmed by combined molecular assays, including Sanger sequencing, mutant-enriched Sanger sequencing and a commercial melting curve analysis-based assay. Finally, the ddPCR assay was used to monitor longitudinally the INH-resistance status and the bacterial load in nine patients undergoing treatment. Overall, the developed ddPCR assay could be an indispensable tool for quantification of INH-resistant mutations in MTB and bacterial loads in patients.

Clinical implications of molecular drug resistance testing for Mycobacterium tuberculosis: a 2023 TBnet/RESIST-TB consensus statement

Drug-resistant tuberculosis is a substantial health-care concern worldwide. Despite culture-based methods being considered the gold standard for drug susceptibility testing, molecular methods provide rapid information about the Mycobacterium tuberculosis mutations associated with resistance to anti-tuberculosis drugs. This consensus document was developed on the basis of a comprehensive literature search, by the TBnet and RESIST-TB networks, about reporting standards for the clinical use of molecular drug susceptibility testing. Review and the search for evidence included hand-searching journals and searching electronic databases. The panel identified studies that linked mutations in genomic regions of M tuberculosis with treatment outcome data. Implementation of molecular testing for the prediction of drug resistance in M tuberculosis is key. Detection of mutations in clinical isolates has implications for the clinical management of patients with multidrug-resistant or rifampicin-resistant tuberculosis, especially in situations when phenotypic drug susceptibility testing is not available. A multidisciplinary team including clinicians, microbiologists, and laboratory scientists reached a consensus on key questions relevant to molecular prediction of drug susceptibility or resistance to M tuberculosis, and their implications for clinical practice. This consensus document should help clinicians in the management of patients with tuberculosis, providing guidance for the design of treatment regimens and optimising outcomes.

Intermittent antibiotic treatment of bacterial biofilms favors the rapid evolution of resistance

Bacterial antibiotic resistance is a global health concern of increasing importance and intensive study. Although biofilms are a common source of infections in clinical settings, little is known about the development of antibiotic resistance within biofilms. Here, we use experimental evolution to compare selection of resistance mutations in planktonic and biofilm Escherichia coli populations exposed to clinically relevant cycles of lethal treatment with the aminoglycoside amikacin. Consistently, mutations in sbmA, encoding an inner membrane peptide transporter, and fusA, encoding the essential elongation factor G, are rapidly selected in biofilms, but not in planktonic cells. This is due to a combination of enhanced mutation rate, increased adhesion capacity and protective biofilm-associated tolerance. These results show that the biofilm environment favors rapid evolution of resistance and provide new insights into the dynamic evolution of antibiotic resistance in biofilms.

Within-host evolution of bacterial pathogens during persistent infection of humans

Many bacterial pathogens can form persistent infections, providing an infectious reservoir, which allows for infection of new hosts. Currently, the molecular mechanisms and evolutionary dynamics driving persistence are still not well-understood. High-throughput sequencing methods have enabled the study of within-host evolution of persistent bacterial pathogens, revealing common trends among bacterial species in how they adapt to persist. We will focus on trends emerging from longitudinal human-cohort studies, including i) genome-size reduction, ii) metabolic adaptation to the host, iii) antimicrobial resistance, iv) changes in virulence and the bacterial cell surface, and v) hypermutation, and comment on where the field should focus going forward.

Assessing the relative importance of bacterial resistance, persistence and hyper-mutation for antibiotic treatment failure

To curb the rising threat of antimicrobial resistance, we need to understand the routes to antimicrobial treatment failure. Bacteria can survive treatment by using both genetic and phenotypic mechanisms to diminish the effect of antimicrobials. We assemble empirical data showing that, for example, Pseudomonas aeruginosa infections frequently contain persisters, transiently non-growing cells unaffected by antibiotics (AB) and hyper-mutators, mutants with elevated mutation rates, and thus higher probability of genetic resistance emergence. Resistance, persistence and hyper-mutation dynamics are difficult to disentangle experimentally. Hence, we use stochastic population modelling and deterministic fitness calculations to investigate the relative importance of genetic and phenotypic mechanisms for immediate treatment failure and establishment of prolonged, chronic infections. We find that persistence causes 'hidden' treatment failure with very low cell numbers if antimicrobial concentrations prevent growth of genetically resistant cells. Persister cells can regrow after treatment is discontinued and allow for resistance evolution in the absence of AB. This leads to different mutational routes during treatment and relapse of an infection. By contrast, hyper-mutation facilitates resistance evolution during treatment, but rarely contributes to treatment failure. Our findings highlight the time and concentration dependence of different bacterial mechanisms to escape AB killing, which should be considered when designing 'failure-proof' treatments.

The Contribution of Chest Radiography to the Clinical Management of Children Exposed to Tuberculosis

Rationale: Although World Health Organization guidelines emphasize contact investigation for tuberculosis (TB)-exposed children, data that support chest radiography as a useful tool are lacking. Objectives: We evaluated the diagnostic and prognostic information of chest radiography in children exposed to TB and measured the efficacy of isoniazid preventive therapy (IPT) in those with relevant radiographic abnormalities. Methods: Between September 2009 and August 2012, we enrolled 4,468 TB-exposed children who were screened by tuberculin skin testing, symptom assessment, and chest radiography. Those negative for TB disease were followed for 1 year for the occurrence of new TB diagnoses. We assessed the protective efficacy of IPT in children with and without abnormal chest radiographs. Measurements and Main Results: Compared with asymptomatic children with normal chest films, asymptomatic children with abnormal radiographs were 25.1-fold more likely to have coprevalent TB (95% confidence interval [CI], 1.02-613.76) and 26.7-fold more likely to be diagnosed with incident TB disease during follow-up (95% CI, 10.44-68.30). Among the 29 symptom-negative and CXR-abnormal child contacts, 20% (3/15) of the isoniazid recipients developed incident TB, compared with 57% (8/14) of those who did not receive IPT (82% IPT efficacy). Conclusions: Our results strongly support the use of chest radiography as a routine screening tool for the evaluation of child TB contacts, which is readily available. Radiographic abnormalities not usually considered suggestive of TB may indicate incipient or subclinical disease, although TB preventive treatment is adequate in most cases.

Central carbon metabolism remodeling as a mechanism to develop drug tolerance and drug resistance in Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Suboptimal efficacy of the current antibiotic regimens and frequent emergence of antibiotic-resistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb), an etiological agent of tuberculosis (TB), render TB the world’s deadliest infectious disease before the COVID-19 outbreak. Our outdated TB treatment method is designed to eradicate actively replicating populations of Mtb. Unfortunately, accumulating evidence suggests that a small population of Mtb can survive antimycobacterial pressure of antibiotics by entering a “persister” state (slowly replicating or non-replicating and lacking a stably heritable antibiotic resistance, termed drug tolerance). The formation of drug-tolerant Mtb persisters is associated with TB treatment failure and is thought to be an adaptive strategy for eventual development of permanent genetic mutation-mediated drug resistance. Thus, the molecular mechanisms behind persister formation and drug tolerance acquisition are a source of new antibiotic targets to eradicate both Mtb persisters and drug-resistant Mtb. As Mtb persisters are genetically identical to antibiotic susceptible populations, metabolomics has emerged as a vital biochemical tool to differentiate these populations by determining phenotypic shifts and metabolic reprogramming. Metabolomics, which provides detailed insights into the molecular basis of drug tolerance and resistance in Mtb, has unique advantages over other techniques by its ability to identify specific metabolic differences between the two genetically identical populations. This review summarizes the recent advances in our understanding of the metabolic adaptations used by Mtb persisters to achieve intrinsic drug tolerance and facilitate the emergence of drug resistance. These findings present metabolomics as a powerful tool to identify previously unexplored antibiotic targets and improved combinations of drug regimens against drug-resistant TB infection.

Are all antibiotic persisters created equal?

Antibiotic persisters are a sub-population of bacteria able to survive in the presence of bactericidal antibiotic despite the lack of heritable drug resistance mechanisms. This phenomenon exists across many bacterial species and is observed for many different antibiotics. Though these bacteria are often described as “multidrug persisters” very few experiments have been carried out to determine the homogeneity of a persister population to different drugs. Further, there is much debate in the field as to the origins of a persister cell. Is it formed spontaneously? Does it form in response to stress? These questions are particularly pressing in the field of Mycobacterium tuberculosis, where persisters may play a crucial role in the required length of treatment and the development of multidrug resistant organisms. Here we aim to interpret the known mechanisms of antibiotic persistence and how they may relate to improving treatments for M. tuberculosis, exposing the gaps in knowledge that prevent us from answering the question: Are all antibiotic persisters created equal?

Application of Next Generation Sequencing for Diagnosis and Clinical Management of Drug-Resistant Tuberculosis: Updates on Recent Developments in the Field

The World Health Organization’s End TB Strategy prioritizes universal access to an early diagnosis and comprehensive drug susceptibility testing (DST) for all individuals with tuberculosis (TB) as a key component of integrated, patient-centered TB care. Next generation whole genome sequencing (WGS) and its associated technology has demonstrated exceptional potential for reliable and comprehensive resistance prediction for Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolates, allowing for accurate clinical decisions. This review presents a descriptive analysis of research describing the potential of WGS to accelerate delivery of individualized care, recent advances in sputum-based WGS technology and the role of targeted sequencing for resistance detection. We provide an update on recent research describing the mechanisms of resistance to new and repurposed drugs and the dynamics of mixed infections and its potential implication on TB diagnosis and treatment. Whilst the studies reviewed here have greatly improved our understanding of recent advances in this arena, it highlights significant challenges that remain. The wide-spread introduction of new drugs in the absence of standardized DST has led to rapid emergence of drug resistance. This review highlights apparent gaps in our knowledge of the mechanisms contributing to resistance for these new drugs and challenges that limit the clinical utility of next generation sequencing techniques. It is recommended that a combination of genotypic and phenotypic techniques is warranted to monitor treatment response, curb emerging resistance and further dissemination of drug resistance.

The Neglected Contribution of Streptomycin to the Tuberculosis Drug Resistance Problem

The airborne pathogen Mycobacterium tuberculosis is responsible for a present major public health problem worsened by the emergence of drug resistance. M. tuberculosis has acquired and developed streptomycin (STR) resistance mechanisms that have been maintained and transmitted in the population over the last decades. Indeed, STR resistant mutations are frequently identified across the main M. tuberculosis lineages that cause tuberculosis outbreaks worldwide. The spread of STR resistance is likely related to the low impact of the most frequent underlying mutations on the fitness of the bacteria. The withdrawal of STR from the first-line treatment of tuberculosis potentially lowered the importance of studying STR resistance. However, the prevalence of STR resistance remains very high, could be underestimated by current genotypic methods, and was found in outbreaks of multi-drug (MDR) and extensively drug (XDR) strains in different geographic regions. Therefore, the contribution of STR resistance to the problem of tuberculosis drug resistance should not be neglected. Here, we review the impact of STR resistance and detail well-known and novel candidate STR resistance mechanisms, genes, and mutations. In addition, we aim to provide insights into the possible role of STR resistance in the development of multi-drug resistant tuberculosis.

Division of labor between SOS and PafBC in mycobacterial DNA repair and mutagenesis

DNA repair systems allow microbes to survive in diverse environments that compromise chromosomal integrity. Pathogens such as Mycobacterium tuberculosis must contend with the genotoxic host environment, which generates the mutations that underlie antibiotic resistance. Mycobacteria encode the widely distributed SOS pathway, governed by the LexA repressor, but also encode PafBC, a positive regulator of the transcriptional DNA damage response (DDR). Although the transcriptional outputs of these systems have been characterized, their full functional division of labor in survival and mutagenesis is unknown. Here, we specifically ablate the PafBC or SOS pathways, alone and in combination, and test their relative contributions to repair. We find that SOS and PafBC have both distinct and overlapping roles that depend on the type of DNA damage. Most notably, we find that quinolone antibiotics and replication fork perturbation are inducers of the PafBC pathway, and that chromosomal mutagenesis is codependent on PafBC and SOS, through shared regulation of the DnaE2/ImuA/B mutasome. These studies define the complex transcriptional regulatory network of the DDR in mycobacteria and provide new insight into the regulatory mechanisms controlling the genesis of antibiotic resistance in M. tuberculosis.

Screening of Compounds for Anti-tuberculosis Activity, and in vitro and in vivo Evaluation of Potential Candidates

Tuberculosis (TB) is a debilitating infectious disease responsible for more than one million deaths per year. The emergence of drug-resistant TB poses an urgent need for the development of new anti-TB drugs. In this study, we screened a library of over 4,000 small molecules and found that orbifloxacin and the peptide AK15 possess significant bactericidal activity against Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) in vitro. Orbifloxacin also showed an effective ability on the clearance of intracellular Mtb and protect mice from a strong inflammatory response but not AK15. Moreover, we identified 17 nucleotide mutations responsible for orbifloxacin resistance by whole-genome sequencing. A critical point mutation (D94G) of the DNA gyrase (gyrA) gene was found to be the key role of resistance to orbifloxacin. The computational docking revealed that GyrA D94G point mutation can disrupt the orbifloxacin–protein gyrase interactions mediated by magnesium ion bridge. Overall, this study indicated the potential ability of orbifloxacin as an anti-tuberculosis drug, which can be used either alone or in combination with first-line antibiotics to achieve more effective therapy on TB.

Multi-step vs. single-step resistance evolution under different drugs, pharmacokinetics, and treatment regimens

The success of antimicrobial treatment is threatened by the evolution of drug resistance. Population genetic models are an important tool in mitigating that threat. However, most such models consider resistance emergence via a single mutational step. Here, we assembled experimental evidence that drug resistance evolution follows two patterns: (i) a single mutation, which provides a large resistance benefit, or (ii) multiple mutations, each conferring a small benefit, which combine to yield high-level resistance. Using stochastic modeling, we then investigated the consequences of these two patterns for treatment failure and population diversity under various treatments. We find that resistance evolution is substantially limited if more than two mutations are required and that the extent of this limitation depends on the combination of drug type and pharmacokinetic profile. Further, if multiple mutations are necessary, adaptive treatment, which only suppresses the bacterial population, delays treatment failure due to resistance for a longer time than aggressive treatment, which aims at eradication.