Reactogenicity and immunogenicity of whole and ether-Tween-split influenza A virus vaccines in volunteers

Inactivated influenza virions are a flexible vaccine platform for eliciting protective antibody responses against neuraminidase

Most seasonal influenza vaccines are produced using hemagglutinin (HA) surface antigens from inactivated virions. However, virions are thought to be a suboptimal source for the less abundant neuraminidase (NA) surface antigen, which is also protective against severe disease. Here, we demonstrate that inactivated influenza virions are compatible with two modern approaches for improving protective antibody responses against NA. Using a DBA/2J mouse model, we show that the strong infection-induced NA inhibitory (NAI) antibody responses are only achieved by high dose immunizations of inactivated virions, likely due to the low viral NA content. Based on this observation, we first produced virions with higher NA content by using reverse genetics to exchange the viral internal gene segments. Single immunizations with these inactivated virions showed enhanced NAI antibody responses and improved NA-based protection from a lethal viral challenge while also allowing for the development of natural immunity to the heterotypic challenge virus HA. Second, we combined inactivated virions with recombinant NA protein antigens. These combination vaccines increased NA-based protection following viral challenge and elicited stronger antibody responses against NA than either component alone, especially when the NAs possessed similar antigenicity. Together, these results indicate that inactivated virions are a flexible platform that can be easily combined with protein-based vaccines to improve protective antibody responses against influenza antigens.

A prime-boost vaccination of mice with heterologous H5N1 strains

We evaluated the priming effect of an H5N1 pandemic vaccine in a mouse model to investigate strategies for influenza pandemic vaccination. For priming, an alum-adjuvanted inactivated whole H5N1 vaccine (NIBRG-14, clade 1) was used. As booster vaccines, several formulations of Indo05/05/2005(H5N1)PR8-IBCDC-RG2 vaccines (clades 2-1)were evaluated, including split, whole, alum-adjuvanted split, and alum-adjuvanted whole vaccines. Any type of booster vaccination elicited a significant HI antibody response despite the difference in antigenicity between the priming and booster vaccines. The split vaccine elicited a much stronger booster response than the alum-adjuvanted whole vaccine. When the mice were primed with the H1N1 or H3N2 vaccines, this did not affect the booster response to the H5N1 vaccine. These results indicated that an alum-adjuvanted whole vaccine is able to confer immunological memory to haemagglutinin even if the primed and boosted vaccine strains are in different clades and, once vaccinated, a split vaccine is preferred to evoke recall responses.

Immune response of human volunteers and animals to vaccination with egg-grown influenza A (H1N1) virus is influenced by three amino acid substitutions in the haemagglutinin molecule

Inactivated subunit vaccines were prepared from high-growth reassortants derived from two separate egg isolates from a single clinical specimen of influenza A (H1N1) virus. One of these reassortants, NIB-14, was antigenically indistinguishable from isolates made in tissue culture, while the other, NIB-17, was antigenically different and typical of egg isolates. The viruses differed by three amino acid residues in the haemagglutinin (HA) molecule and the anti-HA serological response induced was studied in animal models and human volunteers. In the volunteer groups both vaccines induced very high levels of circulating haemagglutination inhibition antibodies but with different serological specificities. Both NIB-14 and NIB-17 vaccines induced high levels of cross-reactive antibodies capable of reacting with both strains, but only NIB-14 vaccine induced significant levels of strain-specific antibodies capable of reacting exclusively with the homologous strain. Antisera containing only cross-reactive antibodies proved as capable of virus neutralization as antisera containing high levels of strain-specific antibodies. We extended the argument that epidemic strains are antigenically more closely related to tissue culture isolates and established that viruses which differ by only single amino acids at critical points in the HA structure can induce a significantly different immune response when used as inactivated vaccines.

Specificity and in vitro transfer of the immunosuppressive effect of detergent-disrupted influenza virus vaccine

Primed murine splenocytes give an in vitro antibody response to influenza whole virus vaccine (WVV), as measured by enzyme immunoassay (EIA). When subunit vaccine (SV) of either influenza A or influenza B virus was added to in vitro splenocyte cultures stimulated with WVV, the EIA antibody response to homologous WVV was reduced. This reduction in antibody response was observed when SV was prepared using zwitterionic detergent (empigen BB), non-ionic detergent (triton-X-100) or cationic detergent cetyl-trimethyl ammonium bromide (CTAB); it was found to be effected only by SV of strains of the same virus subtype--when SVs prepared from a heterotypic (H3N2) strain, an H1N1 strain and an influenza B strain were added to splenocyte cultures in the presence of WVV. When splenocytes from immunologically naive mice, exposed in vitro to SV, were transferred to secondary cultures of primed splenocytes, the antibody response to WVV in the secondary cultures was also reduced. Mechanisms that may suppress the in vitro antibody response are discussed.

Improved colorimetric assay for detecting influenza B virus neutralizing antibody responses to vaccination and infection

An automated neutralization test for influenza B virus is described in which antibody titers are determined according to the release of neutral red from infected or uninfected cells of the Madin-Darby canine kidney line. Endpoints are determined in a standard enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay reader. The test requires no expensive immunologic reagents and was used to evaluate responses to both vaccination and natural infection against influenza B virus. Overall responses to vaccination were comparable with those obtained by hemagglutination inhibition, using Tween-ether-split influenza B/Ann Arbor/1/86 virus as the antigen (the HI-TE test). The sensitivities of neutralization responses compared with those obtained by the HI-TE test for two vaccines were 88 and 89%; the specificities were lower at 61 and 60%, respectively. Responses to vaccination, measured by hemagglutination inhibition, were significantly higher with split virus compared with whole virus. However, seroconversion by both the HI-TE and neutralization tests was observed in 5 of 10 individuals from whom virus was detected by either culture of nasal or throat washings or the presence of antigen from immunofluorescence in cells from nasal washings.

Antibody response and persistence in volunteers following immunization with varying dosages of a trivalent surface antigen influenza virus vaccine

The serum antibody responses and 50% protective levels (PL50) of antibody were determined, using the SRH test, at one and twelve months post-vaccination in a group of student volunteers immunized with one of three dosages of a trivalent surface-antigen influenza virus vaccine, or with placebo. It was found that, for the H3, H1 and B haemagglutinin components present in the vaccine, a dose of 6 micrograms HA elicited high serum antibody responses at one month post-immunization. High mean antibody levels and a high incidence of volunteers with PL50 values of antibody against each of the HA components of the vaccine remained in the volunteer group twelve months later. The results are discussed in relation to the vaccine dosage used and the nature of the population immunized.

Responses to one or two doses of a deoxycholate subunit influenza vaccine in a primed population

A trial with a trivalent influenza subunit vaccine prepared with sodium deoxycholate was carried out in 88 volunteers between May and November 1981. Each haemagglutinin antigen was present at 7 micrograms per dose. Fourfold or greater haemagglutination inhibition antibody (HI) responses to the H1N1 virus A/Brazil/11/78 occurred in 70% of volunteers following a single dose. For the H3N2 virus A/Bangkok/1/79 and B/Singapore/222/79 these figures were 52 and 11%, respectively. No increase in the antibody titre was noted to any of the antigens following a second vaccination dose. Antibody levels remained relatively constant six months after vaccination. A response to B/Singapore/222/79, comparable with the HI response for the influenza A antigens, was noted when serum titres were estimated by a plaque reduction procedure. No neuraminidase inhibition antibody could be detected in response to either A/Brazil/11/78 or A/Bangkok/1/79. No reactions specifically attributable to the vaccine occurred after either injection. A lower HI response to A/Brazil/11/78 was noted in volunteers 52 years of age and older, who also showed less evidence of earlier priming to this virus. Levels of nasal wash neutralizing antibodies to A/Brazil/11/78 were proportional to those detected in sera by HI tests, but were present in smaller amounts.

Inactivated influenza virus vaccines in man: a comparative study of subunit and split vaccines using two methods for assessment of antibody responses

The serum antibody responses and reactions of volunteers to a trivalent subunit influenza virus vaccine prepared using cetyl trimethyl ammonium bromide (CTAB) or trivalent split vaccine prepared by ether-extraction, were essentially similar, although the antibody levels to the A/Brazil/78 (H1N1) components of the vaccine were greater in volunteers receiving the subunit preparation. Antibody responses to the vaccines were assessed using both the haemagglutination-inhibition (HI) and single radial haemolysis (SRH) tests. Although good correlation was found between the tests with respect to both antibody titres in individual sera and antibody responses in serum pairs to both A(H3N2 and H1N1) and B influenza viruses, the greater reliability of SRH, indicates this test should supplant the HI test for the routine measurement of antibody responses to influenza viruses.

A comparison of live and inactivated influenza A (H1N1) virus vaccines. 1. Short-term immunity

Groups of volunteers were immunized subcutaneously with one of three inactivated influenza virus A/USSR/77 (H1N1) vaccine preparations; a whole virus vaccine, a surface-antigen subunit adsorbed vaccine, or an aqueous surface-antigen subunit vaccine. The reactions to immunization were recorded, and the antibody response was measured 1 month later. A fourth group of volunteers were inoculated intranasally with live attentuated A/USSR/77 (H1N1) influenza virus; the reactions and antibody response of these volunteers were also measured. One month after immunization, the incidence of infection by challenge with homologous live attentuated virus was determined for all groups of volunteers. The results showed that all four vaccines used were relatively non-reactogenic, and that inactivated vaccines induced higher titres of serum antibody than the live attenuated vaccine. All the vaccines induced significant protection against challenge virus infection which was directly related to the level of serum HI antibody response.

A graded-dose study of inactivated, surface antigen influenza B vaccine in volunteers: reactogenicity, antibody response and protection to challenge virus infection

One hundred and nineteen volunteers were divided into five groups, and each volunteer inoculated subcutaneously with an aqueous subunit B/Hong Kong/73 vaccine containing 40, 20, 10, or 5 micrograms of HA or saline alone in a 0.5 ml volume. The incidence of reactions was recorded 24 h after inoculation. One month following immunization the serum HI antibody to B/Hong Kong/73 virus was measured; each volunteer was inoculated intranasally with live, attenuated influenza B (RB77) virus; and the incidence of infection by the challenge virus was determined by HI antibody response. The results showed that the incidence of reactions to all doses of vaccine were relatively low, the severity mild, and the duration short. However, the incidence of reactions was highest for those given 40 micrograms HA and least for those given 5 micrograms HA. The serum HI antibody responses to vaccine showed a dose-response relationship. For volunteers given 40 micrograms HA, 22 (96%) showed a fourfold rise in antibody titre and all volunteers had antibody titres of greater than 40 following immunization: for volunteers given 5 micrograms HA the g.m.t. increased from 16.6 to 86.1; and for those given 10 and 20 micrograms HA the response was intermediate. Following challenge, the lowest incidence of infection was seen in volunteers given the highest dose of vaccine. However, all doses of vaccine induced some protection against challenge virus infection, and the incidence of infection was directly related to the serum antibody titre at the time of challenge. The 50% protection titre of serum HI antibody was estimated as 15 to 20.

Transmissibility of influenza viruses in hamsters

The growth characteristics of a series of influenza A viruses in the turbinates and lungs of hamsters was measured: in addition, the susceptibility of hamsters to infection by these viruses was also determined. These two criteria were used to give estimates of the growth potential of influenza viruses in hamsters, and the results were related to the incidence of transmission of virus from inoculated hamsters to cage-contacts. The results showed that strains of influenza virus reported as virulent for man tended to grow to higher titres in hamster nasal washings and lungs; were more infective for hamsters when inoculated by the intranasal route; and showed a high incidence of spread to cage-contacts. The methods could provide valuable measurements of virus attenuation and transmissibility for man, and the further exploitation of these techniques could facilitate the production and licensing of live, attenuated influenza virus vaccines.

Use of the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for the estimation of serum antibodies in an influenza virus vaccine study

The value of the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for determining the serum antibody responses of volunteers following immunisation with various inactivated influenza virus vaccines was assessed, and the incidence of seroconversions, as measured by both haemagglutination-inhibition (HI) and ELISA response of the volunteers determined. ELISA was found to be more sensitive than the HI test in detecting serum antibodies, but was also less specific under the conditions used. With regard to efficacy, the whole virus vaccine proved to be more effective in inducing serum antibody in an unprimed population than either tween-ether split or subunit adsorbed vaccines, but the reverse situation held when the population was primed with respect to the antigen concerned.

Clinical trial of a subunit influenza vaccine

A double-blind field trial was performed comparing a subunit influenza vaccine (A/Victoria/75 and B/Hongkong/73) with placebo. A good protection against influenza was induced by the vaccine. On the basis of serological determinations (enzyme immunoassay, EIA) the incidences of influenza A and B infections were reduced within a period from 3 weeks up to 5 months after the vaccination by 88 and 68%, respectively. Three weeks after the vaccination 79% of the vaccines had acquired protective serum antibody levels (greater than or equal to 32 x 10(2) by EIA) against influenza A and 62% against influenza B, while in the control subjects protective antibody levels were measured in frequencies from 4 to 13% in subsequent serum samples. With a few exceptions antibody levels were still present in 5-month samples. Side effects were recorded within the first 3 days following the vaccination. Some minor symptoms like redness and tenderness at the vaccination site and muscle ache were reported more frequently by the vaccines than by the controls, but no more harmful systemic reactions.

Responses of volunteers to inactivated influenza virus vaccines

Three different types of bivalent influenza virus vaccine, a whole virus, an aqueous-surface-antigen vaccine and an adsorbed-surface-antigen vaccine were tested at three dosage levels in volunteers primed with respect to only one of the haemagglutinin antigens present in the vaccines. The local and systemic reactions to all three vaccine types were mild in nature and, following first immunization, the aqueous-surface-antigen vaccine was the least reactogenic. The serum haemagglutination-inhibiting antibody response to the A/Victoria/75 component of the vaccines to which the volunteer population was primed, was greatest following immunization with the aqueous-surface-antigen vaccine; the greatest antibody response to the A/New Jersey/76 component of the vaccines was observed following immunization with whole virus vaccine.

The spread and persistence of influenza viruses in normal and cyclophosphamide-treated mice

The persistence and extrapulmonary spread of three strains of influenza virus, the mouse neuro-adapted A/NWS virus, the wild-type strain A/Victoria/75, and a recombinant virus RIT4050, bearing surface antigens derived from A/Victoria/75, were studied in both normal and cyclophosphamide-treated CBA mice following either intranasal or intracerebral inoculation. All three viruses showed increased lethality in mice in the presence of cyclophosphamide but exhibited distinctive patterns of replication and spread. The recombinant virus RIT4050 showed a reduced ability to replicate, persist, and spread in CBA mice compared to either A/NWS or A/Victoria/75 viruses, and in general, the A/NWS virus persisted to a greater extent than the A/Victoria/75 virus in both normal and treated mice. However, in the presence of cyclophosphamide, no extrapulmonary spread of A/NWS virus was observed. The reasons for the differences are discussed.

The specificity of the anti-haemagglutinin antibody response induced in man by inactivated influenza vaccines and by natural infection

The anti-haemagglutinin antibody response in adult human volunteers to inactivated whole virus or tween ether split influenza A/Victoria/75 (H3N2) and A/Scotland/74 (H3N2) virus vaccines was investigated using antibody absorption and single-radial-haemolysis (SRH) techniques. The concentrations of haemagglutinin (HA), nucleoprotein (NP) and matrix (M) antigens measured by single radial diffusion (SRD) and rocket immunoelectrophoresis were similar for both the whole virus and split vaccines. Whole virus and split vaccines induced crossreactive (CR) antibody in 87% of vaccinees. Strain specific (SS) antibody to A/Hong Kong/1/68 of the homologous virus was induced less frequently than CR antibody. Higher anti-haemagglutinin antibody titres were detected in persons receiving the split virus vaccines than in those receiving the whole virus vaccines. No antibody to the type-specific matrix protein was detectable, but 33% of volunteers developed an antibody rise to type-specific nucleoprotein antigen. The specificity of the anti-haemagglutinin antibody response in human adults to natural infection with A/Port Chalmers/73 (H3N2) virus was similar to that induced by inactivated vaccines in that a high proportion of subjects developed CR anti-haemagglutinin antibody, which reacted with A/Hong Kong/68 virus and the homologous A/Port Chalmers/73 virus, and SS antibody for A/Hong Kong/68 virus but SS antibody for A/Port Chalmers/73 virus was infrequently stimulated by natural infection.