Transient virus expression during murine leukemia induction by X-irradiation

Ionising radiations from nuclear establishments and childhood leukaemias--an enigma

The Gardner report, recently published in the UK, showing a correlation between incidence of childhood leukaemia and paternal exposure to ionising radiations (amongst fathers working in nuclear power plants) has added a new element to debates about both the risk factors in nuclear power plants and the relationships between ionising radiations and leukaemogenesis. The epidemiologic and genetic evidence concerning leukaemias is reviewed here and it is concluded that the leukaemogenic agent, whose existence is indicated in the Gardner report, is unlikely to be paternal radiation dose per se but rather exposure to another factor that is correlated with parternal radiation dose received.

Endogenous murine leukemia viruses: frequency of radiation-activation and novel pathogenic effects of viral isolates

Female C57BL/6 and BALB/c mice were injected i.p. with 0.06 microCi/kg or 0.5 microCi/kg of the short-lived alpha-emitting radionuclide 224radium at 3-day intervals. Infectious N-ecotropic XC+, and xenotropic C-type retroviruses were activated in several tissues in both strains. In C57BL/6 mice the activation of ecotropic and xenotropic virus was dose-dependent as observed 4 weeks after the start of irradiation. In BALB/c mice a few animals showed activation of ecotropic virus after four weeks of irradiation. The expression of xenotropic virus was similar in irradiated mice and controls. Viral antigen, indicative for viraemia, was not detected in irradiated or control animals. Antiviral antibodies were found in both control and irradiated mice but higher titers were found in the irradiated mice. Bone tissue-derived N-tropic XC+ virus isolates were found to be non-oncogenic in newborn mice of the parental strain. In contrast, the same virus isolates induced a novel pattern of disease, such as osteopetrosis and osteomas together with malignant lymphomas in NMRI mice. The data indicate that the pattern of endogenous murine leukemia virus activation by internal alpha-irradiation is dependent on the dose rate, and on the genetics of the mouse strain.

Studies on emerging radiation leukemia virus variants in C57BL/Ka mice

To analyze the emergence of radiation leukemia virus (RadLV) variants in primary X-ray-induced C57BL/Ka thymoma and to identify the virus responsible for the very high leukemogenic potential of passaged Kaplan strain BL/VL3 preparation, we cloned several primary and passaged ecotropic RadLV infectious genomes. By restriction analysis, we found that BL/VL3 cells harbor three related but different ecotropic RadLVs. Their restriction map differs significantly from those of primary RadLVs. Hybridization analysis also indicated that BL/VL3 and primary RadLVs differ in their p15E and long terminal repeat (LTR) regions. As compared with the LTR sequence of the putative parental endogenous ecotropic provirus, the LTR sequence of primary weakly leukemogenic RadLV has only one change, a C-rich sequence, generating a 6-base-pair direct repeat just in front of the promotor. The LTR of the primary nonleukemogenic RadLV only showed few base changes, mainly clustered in R and U5. The LTR from a moderately leukemogenic passaged BL/VL3 RadLV had conserved the C-rich sequence and acquired a 43-base-pair direct repeat in U3 and several other point mutations, small insertions, and deletions scattered in U3, R, and U5. All cloned primary RadLVs were fibrotropic, and some were weakly leukemogenic. All cloned BL/VL3 RadLVs were thymotropic and nonfibrotropic. The block of their replication was found to be after the synthesis of unintegrated linear and supercoiled viral DNA. Most of the BL/VL3 RadLVs were moderately leukemogenic, and one (V-13) was highly leukemogenic, being as virulent as the Moloney strain. We propose a model for the emergence of the RadLV variants and show that the virus responsible for the high leukemogenic potential of BL/VL3 preparation is a nondefective, ecotropic, lymphotropic, nonfibrotropic, unique retrovirus which most likely arose from a parental primary RadLV similar to those studied here.

Molecular analysis of emerging radiation leukemia virus variants of C57BL/Ka mice

Molecular cloning of several primary or passaged RadLV variants and their biological characterization has allowed us to propose a model of their emergence following X-ray irradiation of C57BL/6 mouse.

RNA virus expression during and after methylnitrosourea-induced T-cell leukemogenesis in mice

The expression of RNA tumor virus was studied in BDF 1 mice after leukemogenic treatment with a single dose of methylnitrosourea (MNU) and in leukemic thymuses by a cell ELISA using antibodies against the viral glycoprotein gp 70 and by co-culture for the detection of eco- and xenotropic virus. The majority of the thymomas were positive for gp 70; ecotropic, but not xenotropic infectious virus could be detected in some of them. Early after MNU application the thymus and the bone marrow were positive for gp 70 in some animals. Later, after a phase with positive results with spleen cells, the bone marrow and the spleen were negative again. Only the thymus of some mice were positive during the last weeks before the first leukemias appeared.

A comparative analysis of radiation- and virus-induced leukemias in BALB/c mice

Endogenous murine leukemia virus (MuLV) proviral copies were analyzed in thymomas induced in normal BALB/c (Fv-1b) and in Fv-1n congenic mice by X-irradiation. Both strains of mice developed leukemia with similar kinetics, indicating that N-tropism of endogenous MuLV was not a rate-limiting factor in development of disease. Southern blot analysis, using a probe specific for ecotropic virus and for ecotropic-specific sequences retained in pathogenic, env-recombinant viruses, showed that the majority of radiation leukemias lacked newly acquired, clonally integrated, proviruses. This was in contrast to virus-induced leukemias, which routinely exhibited several new proviral integration sites. When an internal proviral DNA restriction fragment was monitored, some radiation leukemias showed evidence of nonclonal infection, accounting for more frequent isolation of infectious virus from such leukemias. Differences in expression of T-cell surface antigens were found in X-ray-induced and virus-induced leukemias. All radiation leukemias were TL positive, whereas virus-induced leukemias were primarily negative for TL. Some differences were also found in Lyt-1 and Lyt-2 expression. The data as a whole suggest that, in the majority of cases, radiation leukemogenesis is not initiated by a viral route--that is, the sort of viral mechanism for which exogenous infection by known pathogenic MuLV is the paradigm.

Strong selection for cells containing new ecotropic recombinant murine leukemia virus provirus after propagation of C57BL/6 radiation-induced thymoma cells in vitro or in vivo

Using the Southern procedure, we have studied the presence of ecotropic-specific murine leukemia viral sequences in genomic DNA isolated from primary X-ray-induced thymomas, from lymphoid cell lines established from them, or from secondary tumors passaged in vivo. We found that primary radiation-induced thymomas and infiltrated spleens do not harbor newly acquired ecotropic provirus. However, additional ecotropic proviruses (which appear recombinant in the gagpol region) could be detected in most of the tumorigenic cell lines established in vitro from them and in tumors arising from subcutaneous transplantation of the primary thymomas. These results suggest that primary radiation-induced thymomas may not be clonal. They also indicate a strong correlation between the presence of ecotropic recombinant proviruses in the genome and the growth ability, both in vitro and in vivo, of specific cells within these thymomas, suggesting a possible mitogenic function for murine leukemia virus.

Strong selection for cells containing new ecotropic recombinant murine leukemia virus provirus after propagation of C57BL/6 radiation-induced thymoma cells in vitro or in vivo

Using the Southern procedure, we have studied the presence of ecotropic-specific murine leukemia viral sequences in genomic DNA isolated from primary X-ray-induced thymomas, from lymphoid cell lines established from them, or from secondary tumors passaged in vivo. We found that primary radiation-induced thymomas and infiltrated spleens do not harbor newly acquired ecotropic provirus. However, additional ecotropic proviruses (which appear recombinant in the gagpol region) could be detected in most of the tumorigenic cell lines established in vitro from them and in tumors arising from subcutaneous transplantation of the primary thymomas. These results suggest that primary radiation-induced thymomas may not be clonal. They also indicate a strong correlation between the presence of ecotropic recombinant proviruses in the genome and the growth ability, both in vitro and in vivo, of specific cells within these thymomas, suggesting a possible mitogenic function for murine leukemia virus.

New class of leukemogenic ecotropic recombinant murine leukemia virus isolated from radiation-induced thymomas of C57BL/6 mice

We previously reported the establishment of several lymphoid cell lines from X-ray-induced thymomas of C57BL/Ka mice, and all, except one, produce retroviruses (P. Sankar-Mistry and P. Jolicoeur, J. Virol.35:270-275, 1980). Biological characterization of five of these new primary radiation leukemia viruses (RadLVs) indicated that they had a B-tropic, fibrotropic, and ecotropic host range and were leukemogenic when reinjected into C57BL/Ka newborn mice. The leukemogenic potential of one isolate (G(6)T(2)) was further assessed and shown to be retained after prolonged passaging on fibroblasts in vitro. Restriction endonuclease analysis of the DNA of four of our new RadLV isolates (G(6)T(2), Ti-7, Ti-8, and Ti-9) revealed that G(6)T(2) and Ti-7 murine leukemia virus (MuLV) genomes had identical restriction maps, whereas Ti-8 and Ti-9 genomes were different from each other and from the G(6)T(2) and Ti-7 genomes. The physical maps of these genomes were similar to that of known ecotropic MuLV genomes (including the C57BL/Ka endogenous ecotropic MuLV) within their long terminal repeats, env, the right portion of pol, and the left portion of gag. However, a region covering the end of gag and the beginning of pol was different and showed several similarities with xenotropic MuLV genomes of BALB/c, AKR, and C58 mice previously mapped. Our results suggest that these primary RadLV genomes are recombinants between the parental ecotropic MuLV genome and a nonecotropic (xenotropic) sequence. This nonecotropic gag-pol region might be important in conferring the leukemogenic potential to these isolates. Therefore, these RadLVs appear to form a new class of leukemogenic recombinant MuLVs recovered from leukemic tissues of mice. They appear to be distinct from the recombinant AKR mink cell focus-inducing MuLVs which have a dual-tropic host range and harbor xenotropic env sequences. To further study the leukemogenic potential of these RadLVs, the genome of one of them (G(6)T(2)) was cloned in Charon 21A as an infectious molecule.

Involvement of peritoneal macrophages and spleen stromal cells in X-irradiation-induced reticulum cell neoplasms in C57BL/6 mice

Some correlation was observed between the occurrence of FA-positive PE-MO and spleen stromal cells (removed from X-irradiated RCN-bearing old-adult B6 mice) and the generation of RCN. No significant correlation was found between the viral content of lymphoid organs from the same mice and the occurrence of RCN. The main viral particle detected in lymphoid organs from radiation-induced RCN-bearing mice was the xenotropic virus. Ecotropic viruses were detected in a few spleens and Payer patches from such mice. These ecotropic viruses showed very poor lymphomagenic activity and required 400R X-ray as a cofactor. No dualtropic viruses were detected. However, inoculation of ecotropic (SFA2) helper virus to X-irradiated old-adult B6 mice, resulted in an efficient rescue of lymphomagenic viruses, enriched with phenotypically mixed, dualtropic viruses. Some of these DT viral preparations were cloned and seemed to consist mainly of xenotropic sequences. Thus, inoculation of helper viruses influenced the generation and selection of DT viruses. Such viral preparations, enriched with DT viruses, had a better lymphomagenic activity compared to endogenous ecotropic viruses, isolated from radiation-induced RCN-bearing mice. Indirect evidence suggested the involvement of a defective (xenotropic and possibly adjacent cellular genes) particle in lymphoma induction. To conclude, a possible mechanism for the development of radiation-induced RCN is suggested, emphasizing the role of MO in such a process.

The effect of daily low dose gamma irradiation on growth and differentiation of human myeloid leukaemic bone marrow in diffusion chambers

Bone marrow from each of 8 untreated patients with myeloproliferative disorders was grown in diffusion chambers in 760 rad total body irradiated rats. Rats were then exposed to 11.5, 57.5, or 108.5 rad daily for 14-2l d and cell growth compared to that detected in unirradiated chambers. Cells from acute myelogenous leukaemia patients exposed to 11.5 rad per d grew for 11-21 d and there was no consistent stimulation of differentiation of immature granulocytic cells to mature granulocytes that was attributable to irradiation. Cells from a chronic myeloid leukaemia patient in chronic phase or blast crisis, and a polycythaemia vera patient with myeloid metaplasia showed significant morphologic differentiation from immature to mature granulocytes in control chambers with no additional effect of daily irradiation. Marrow specimens from 2 AML patients exposed to each of 3 daily dose fractions over 14 d revealed a dose-dependent decrease in immature granulocytes with no persistent increase in mature granulocytes. In both irradiated and control chambers, macrophages increased over 21 d. Thus, cells from patients with myeloproliferative disorders may not necessarily differentiate to mature granulocytes following in vivo exposure to ionizing irradiation.

Expression of murine leukemia viruses in the highly lymphomatous BXH-2 recombinant inbred mouse strain

Among 12 recombinant inbred strains of mice derived from crossing two strains, C57BL/6J and C3H/HeJ, which have a low incidence of neoplastic disease, one strain (BXH-2) has been found to have a high incidence of lymphoma, of non-T-cell origin, at an early age. The BXH-2 strain carries the Fv-1b allele and spontaneously expresses a B-tropic murine leukemia virus beginning at as early as 10 days of gestation and continuing throughout their life. No significant differences in ecotropic virus titers were observed at any age tested (16 to 17 days of gestation through 7 months), whereas xenotropic virus was first detected in lymphoid tissues of 2-month-old mice and virus titers increased with age. Dual tropic virus(es), which induced cytopathic changes on mink lung cells, was isolated from BXH-2 lymphomatous tissues. Unlike AKR mink lung focus-forming virus (N-tropic recombinant), BXH-2 dual tropic virus is B tropic and induces cytopathic changes in mouse fibroblast cultures as well. The BXH-2 mouse provides a model system for studying the role of replication-competent viruses in spontaneously occurring leukemias of non-T-cell lineage and neurological disease.

Abrogation of radiation leukemia virus-induced lymphomagenesis by antisera to thymotropic but not to ecotropic or dual-tropic viruses

Leukemia induction by culture-grown thymotropic radiation leukemia virus or by tumor-derived virus present in cell-free tumor extracts was abrogated by incubation of either virus with anti-thymotropoc virus serum, but not by antiserum raised against ecotropic or dual-tropic (mink cell focus-inducing type) viruses that were isolated from radiation leukemia virus-induced thymic leukemias. Thus, virus similar or identical to the cultured thymotropic leukemogenic species may also be the major biologically active principle in tumor-derived extracts, even though the latter also contain viruses of the dual-tropic, mink cell focus-inducing type class.

Time course of C-type retrovirus expression in mice submitted to osteosarcomagenic doses of 224radium

Virus particles with the biochemical properties of C-type retroviruses appeared transiently in bone tissues of (C3H x 101) f1 hybrid mice early after treatment with 224 Radium; such particles were then again detected in the bones of the irradiated animals at the onset of osteosarcoma formation and in the osteosarcomas. Antibodies against a murine retrovirus isolated from a 224 Ra-induced osteosarcoma were produced and detected in the serum of the 224 Ra-treated animals within a month after treatment began. The antibody levels plateaued to a maximum after about 2 months and remained elevated until the tumors started to develop. The antibody concentration in the serum of these irradiated animals decreased then progressively to reach levels similar to those observed in untreated controls. It thus appears that the imminence of osteosarcoma development can be predicted by monitoring the anti-C-type virus antibody levels in the serum of the irradiated mice. These experiments also strongly suggest that treatment with 224Radium induces expression of endogenous viruses in the animals.

Frequent isolation of ecotropic murine leukemia virus after x-ray irradiation of C57BL/6 mice and establishment of producer lymphoid cell lines from radiation-induced lymphomas

Fractionated whole-body X irradiation of C57BL/Ka mice leads to the development of thymic leukemia in 90% of the treated animals at an average age of 6 months. Using a sensitive high-density cocultivation procedure, we were able to demonstrate the presence of ecotropic murine leukemia virus (MuLV) from 1 month post-irradiation up to leukemia development. These viruses are not specific to any one particular organ, but can be found in at least two of the three lymphoreticular tissues studied, namely, spleen, thymus, and bone marrow. Host range studies on the isolated viruses showed that both N- and B-tropic MuLV could be isolated early after irradiation. However, as mice reached an age where leukemias develop, only the B-tropic MuLV could be recovered. We have established cell lines from primary radiation-induced tumors that are being maintained in continuous culture: except one cell line, all are virus producers. The results clearly indicate that X irradiation induces ecotropic MuLV in C57BL/Ka mice and suggest that B-tropic MuLV might be involved in the disease process.

Cell-surface antigens associated with dualtropic and thymotropic murine leukemia viruses inducing thymic and nonthymic lymphomas

Unique type-specific antigens were detected on cells infected with dualtropic and thymotropic viruses isolated and x-ray-induced T cell- and B cell-malignant lymphomas of C57BL/6 mice. These antigens were defined by membrane fluorescence with antisera made in rabbits against rabbit cells chronically infected with cloned virus. The antisera were qualitatively absorbed with a group of cells chronically infected with related dualtropic, ecotropic, and xenotropic viruses. The absorbed antisera detected type-specific, virus-related cell-surface antigens that were unique for different dualtropic virus isolates. The unabsorbed sera also reacted with antigens found specifically on ecotropic and xenotropic virus-infected cells. These findings support the contention that T cell lymphoma (TCL)-inducing and B cell lymphoma (BCL)-inducing viruses isolated from x-irradiated C57BL/6 mice are env gene recombinants in which ecotropic gene sequences have been substituted by xenotropic sequences. We found that unique antigenicities are associated with each TCL-inducing and BCL-inducing dualtropic virus, and that the thymotropic TCL-inducing virus isolates (e.g., 136.5 adn 136.7 viruses) represent a separate serologic group, different from the dualtropic TCL-inducing viruses. By using a series of absorbed antisera in microimmunofluorescence tests we could perform serologic virus mapping of dualtropic clones isolated by us or by others and relate them serologically to previously isolated clones. These virus mapping experiments indicated that many serologically different recombinant viruses can be isolated from C57BL/6 mice. It is suggested that many distinct recombinant viruses may exist in lymphomagenic C57BL/6 mice, some of which are associated with specific lymphoma induction.

Association of endogenous retroviruses with radiation-induced leukemias of BALB/c mice

X-irradiation of BALB/c mice in the second month of life induced a high incidence of generalized lymphatic leukemia of T-cell origin, beginning at 7 months of age. Infectious ecotropic murine leukemia virus (B-tropic predominant over N-tropic) was isolable from all tumor extracts but exhibited a wide titer range among individual leukemias. Detection of infectious xenotropic virus usually required extensive amplification on indicator cells. Dual-tropic (mink cell focus-forming) virus has not been found in the leukemias. Expression of ecotropic virus in tail extracts prepared at 6.5 months of age, although greatly enhanced compared with unirradiated controls, was not found to be prognostic of tumor development in individual mice. We conclude that leukemogenesis does not show a simple dependence on infectious murine leukemia virus expression in these mice.

Absence of ecotropic or recombinant murine leukaemia virus in preleukaemic and leukaemic X-irradiated NZB mice

NZB mice X-irradiated with a single dose of 630 R when they were 1-month old developed a high incidence of histologically defined lymphocytic leukaemia 8--25 weeks later. We have screened for murine leukaemia viruses (MuLV) in the lymphoid tissues of 8 of these leukaemic mice, and in 8 "preleukaemic", apparently healthy NZBs killed 1 month post irradiation. Xenotropic, but not ecotropic or recombinant MuLV, was detected by in vitro co-cultivation of bone marrow, spleen and thymus with selectively permissive cell lines, followed by the immunofluorescence test for MuLV gs antigen, and the XC test. Our results are not consistent, therefore, with the concept that the factor causing the leukaemias was an oncogenic virus activated by X-irradiation.

Azathioprine-induced lymphocytic neoplasms of NZB mice lack ecotropic murine leukaemia virus

NZB mice injected intramuscularly throughout a 6-month period with the immunosuppressant azathioprine (Imuran) developed lymphocytic lymphomas 6--7 months after treatment was initiated. These malignancies were quite distinct from the reticulum-cell neoplasia which occurs spontaneously in the strain, and were readily transplantable to NZB or histocompatible BALB/c recipients. Xenotropic, but not ecotropic murine leukaemia virus (MuLV) was detected in leukaemic tissues of some donor and recipient NZBs when tested in vitro by co-cultivation with permissive cell lines, genome rescue, XC and viral polymerase assays. Virus filtrates prepared from donor leukaemic tissues were non-pathogenic when injected into newborn C3H mice. These results are evidence against a mandatory ecotropic MuLV genome in lymphocytic neoplasia.

Active immunization against murine radiation-induced leukemia using a sarcoma virus pseudotype

Immunization of C57BL/Ka mice against the radiation leukemia virus (Rad LV) markedly reduced their susceptibility to development of leukemia after X-radiation. The active immunogen used consisted of a sarcoma virus pseudotype of Rad LV which induces regressing sarcomas in young adult mice. These immunized animals were challenged with four weekly 160-rad X-ray exposures. The appearance of lymphomas and leukemias resulting from such irradiation was delayed and their incidence significantly decreased. These results indicate that oncornavirus immunization may be used to reduce the incidence of murine leukemias which are triggered by a physical agent.