A variety of synergistic and antagonistic interactions mediated by cis-acting DNA motifs regulate gene expression in plant cells and modulate stability of the transcription complex formed on a basal promoter

Detection and validation of cis-regulatory motifs in osmotic stress-inducible synthetic gene switches via computational and experimental approaches

Synthetic cis -regulatory modules can improve our understanding of gene regulatory networks. We applied an ensemble approach for de novo cis motif discovery among the promoters of 181 drought inducible differentially expressed soybean (Glycine max L.) genes. A total of 43 cis motifs were identified in promoter regions of all gene sets using the binding site estimation suite of tools (BEST). Comparative analysis of these motifs revealed similarities with known cis -elements found in PLACE database and led to the discovery of cis -regulatory motifs that were not yet implicated in drought response. Compiled with the proposed synthetic promoter design rationale, three synthetic assemblies were constructed by concatenating multiple copies of drought-inducible cis motifs in a specific order with inter-motif spacing using random bases and placed upstream of 35s minimal core promoter. Each synthetic module substituted 35S promoter in pBI121 and pCAMBIA3301 to drive glucuronidase expression in soybean hairy roots and Arabidopsis thaliana L. Chimeric soybean seedlings and 3-week-old transgenic Arabidopsis plants were treated with simulated with different levels of osmotic stress. Histochemical staining of transgenic soybean hairy roots and Arabidopsis displayed drought-inducible GUS activity of synthetic promoters. Fluorometric assay and expression analysis revealed that SP2 is the better manual combination of cis -elements for stress-inducible expression. qRT-PCR results further demonstrated that designed synthetic promoters are not tissue-specific and thus active in different parts upon treatment with osmotic stress in Arabidopsis plants. This study provides tools for transcriptional upgradation of valuable crops against drought stress and adds to the current knowledge of synthetic biology.

Construction of a Porcine Skeletal Muscle-Specific Promoter by Inducing the Seed Region of miR-208a

Transgenic promoter systems are of great interest for their potential use in gene therapy or production due to their high activity, long term, and cell specificity. Here, in order to obtain promoters with high activity and expressed specifically in skeletal muscle, the MYOD1, MYF5, and MCK were selected as the candidate genes. The truncated promoters were amplified and their activity was verified through dual-luciferase reporter gene test. We used genetic engineering techniques to improve promoter activity by tandemly linking enhancers and promoters or two promoters. Furthermore, synthetic promoter was the most active when two eMCK enhancers and pMCK promoter were cascaded. To improve the tissue specificity of the promoter, the seed region of translational repressor miR-208a was inserted into the downstream of the promoter (pGL3-2eMCK-pMCK-T208-mCherry-EGFP). The results showed that the expression level of target genes decreased significantly (P < 0.05) in myocardium rather than in skeletal muscle. The results of in vivo transfection indicated that tandem transcriptional regulatory elements can increase promoter activity in mice. This work laid the foundation for future research on genetically modified pigs.

Rational design and testing of abiotic stress-inducible synthetic promoters from poplar cis-regulatory elements

Abiotic stress resistance traits may be especially crucial for sustainable production of bioenergy tree crops. Here, we show the performance of a set of rationally designed osmotic-related and salt stress-inducible synthetic promoters for use in hybrid poplar. De novo motif-detecting algorithms yielded 30 water-deficit (SD) and 34 salt stress (SS) candidate DNA motifs from relevant poplar transcriptomes. We selected three conserved water-deficit stress motifs (SD18, SD13 and SD9) found in 16 co-expressed gene promoters, and we discovered a well-conserved motif for salt response (SS16). We characterized several native poplar stress-inducible promoters to enable comparisons with our synthetic promoters. Fifteen synthetic promoters were designed using various SD and SS subdomains, in which heptameric repeats of five-to-eight subdomain bases were fused to a common core promoter downstream, which, in turn, drove a green fluorescent protein (GFP) gene for reporter assays. These 15 synthetic promoters were screened by transient expression assays in poplar leaf mesophyll protoplasts and agroinfiltrated Nicotiana benthamiana leaves under osmotic stress conditions. Twelve synthetic promoters were induced in transient expression assays with a GFP readout. Of these, five promoters (SD18-1, SD9-2, SS16-1, SS16-2 and SS16-3) endowed higher inducibility under osmotic stress conditions than native promoters. These five synthetic promoters were stably transformed into Arabidopsis thaliana to study inducibility in whole plants. Herein, SD18-1 and SD9-2 were induced by water-deficit stress, whereas SS16-1, SS16-2 and SS16-3 were induced by salt stress. The synthetic biology design pipeline resulted in five synthetic promoters that outperformed endogenous promoters in transgenic plants.

Synthetic Promoters: Designing the cis Regulatory Modules for Controlled Gene Expression

Designing the expression cassettes with desired properties remains the most important consideration of gene engineering technology. One of the challenges for predictive gene expression is the modeling of synthetic gene switches to regulate one or more target genes which would directly respond to specific chemical, environmental, and physiological stimuli. Assessment of natural promoter, high-throughput sequencing, and modern biotech inventory aided in deciphering the structure of cis elements and molding the native cis elements into desired synthetic promoter. Synthetic promoters which are molded by rearrangement of cis motifs can greatly benefit plant biotechnology applications. This review gives a glimpse of the manual in vivo gene regulation through synthetic promoters. It summarizes the integrative design strategy of synthetic promoters and enumerates five approaches for constructing synthetic promoters. Insights into the pattern of cis regulatory elements in the pursuit of desirable "gene switches" to date has also been reevaluated. Joint strategies of bioinformatics modeling and randomized biochemical synthesis are addressed in an effort to construct synthetic promoters for intricate gene regulation.

Expression of a novel bi-directional Brassica napus promoter in soybean

The expression profile of a natural bi-directional promoter, derived from the Brassica napus EPSPS-A gene, was studied in transgenic soybean (Glycine max C.V. Maverick) lines. Two constructs, pDAB100331 and pDAB100333, were assembled to test the bi-directionality of the promoter. Two reporter genes, gfp and gusA, were employed and they were interchangeably placed in both constructs, one on each end of the promoter such that both proteins expressed divergently in each construct. In the T0 generation, GUS expression was more uniform throughout the leaf of pDAB100333 transgenic plants, where the gusA gene was expressed from the downstream or EPSPS-A end of the bi-directional promoter. Comparatively, GUS expression was more localized in the midrib and veins of the leaf of pDAB100331 transgenic plants, where the gusA gene was expressed from the upstream end of the bi-directional promoter. These observations indicated a unique expression pattern from each end of the promoter and consistently higher expression in genes expressed from the downstream end (e.g., EPSPS-A end) of the promoter in the tissues examined. The GFP expression pattern followed that of GUS when placed in the same position relative to the promoter. In the T1 generation, transcript analysis also showed higher expression of both gusA and gfp when those genes were located at the downstream end of the promoter. Accordingly, the pDAB100331 events exhibited a higher gfp/gusA transcript ratio, while pDAB100333 events produced a higher gusA/gfp transcript ratio consistent with the observations in T0 plants. These results demonstrated that the EPSPS-A gene bidirectional promoter can be effectively utilized to drive expression of two transgenes for the desired traits.

Construction of a novel synthetic root-specific promoter and its characterization in transgenic tobacco plants

Synthetic promoter technology offers a framework for designing expression cassettes that could provide precise control of transgene expression. Such artificially designed promoters enable defined transgene regulation, reduce unwanted background expression, and can overcome homology-dependent gene silencing in transgenic plants. In the present study, a synthetic root-specific module was designed using characterized cis-acting elements, fused with minimal promoter (86 bp) from PortUbi882 promoter, and cloned in pCAMBIA1305.1 by replacing CaMV 35S promoter so as to drive GUS expression. Two constructs were made; one had the synthetic module at the 5' end of the minimal promoter (SynR1), whereas in the other construct, the module was present in both 5' and 3' ends (SynR2). Furthermore, the synthetic promoter constructs were transformed in tobacco wherein SynR1 promoter drove constitutive expression, whereas SynR2 conferred root-specific expression though slight leaky expression was present in stem. GUS assay in the roots of transgenic tobacco plants (T₁) indicated that SynR2 promoter expressed significantly higher GUS activity than the CaMV 35S promoter. The real-time quantitative PCR (RT-qPCR) analysis of GUS gene further confirmed that SynR2 promoter conferred 2.1-fold higher root-specific expression when compared to CaMV 35S promoter.

Synthetic introns help identify sequences in the 5' UTR intron of the Glycine max polyubiquitin (Gmubi) promoter that give increased promoter activity

MAIN CONCLUSION

Specific sequences within the leader intron of a soybean polyubiquitin gene stimulated gene expression when placed either within a synthetic intron or upstream of a core promoter. The intron in the 5' untranslated region of the soybean polyubiquitin promoter, Gmubi, seems to contribute to the high activity of this promoter. To identify the stimulatory sequences within the intron, ten different sequential intronic sequences of 40 nt were isolated, cloned as tetrameric repeats and placed upstream of a minimal cauliflower mosaic virus 35S (35S) core promoter, which was used to control expression of the green fluorescent protein. Intron fragment tetramers were also cloned within a modified, native intron, creating a Synthetic INtron Cassette (SINC), which was then placed downstream of Gmubi and 35S core promoters. Intron fragment tetramers and SINC constructs were evaluated using transient expression in lima bean cotyledons and stable expression in soybean hairy roots. Intron fragments, used as tetramers upstream of the 35S core promoter, yielded up to 80 times higher expression than the core promoter in transient expression analyses and ten times higher expression in stably transformed hairy roots. Tetrameric intronic fragments, cloned downstream of the Gmubi and 35S core promoters and within the synthetic intron, also yielded increased transient and stable GFP expression that was up to 4 times higher than Gmubi alone and up to 40 times higher than the 35S core promoter alone. These intron fragments contain sequences that seem to act as promoter regulatory elements and may contribute to the increased expression observed with this native strong promoter. Intron regulatory elements and synthetic introns may provide additional tools for increasing transgene expression in plants.

A combinatorial bidirectional and bicistronic approach for coordinated multi-gene expression in corn

Transgene stacking in trait development process through genetic engineering is becoming complex with increased number of desired traits and multiple modes of action for each trait. We demonstrate here a novel gene stacking strategy by combining bidirectional promoter (BDP) and bicistronic approaches to drive coordinated expression of multi-genes in corn. A unidirectional promoter, Ubiquitin-1 (ZMUbi1), from Zea mays was first converted into a synthetic BDP, such that a single promoter can direct the expression of two genes from each end of the promoter. The BDP system was then combined with a bicistronic organization of genes at both ends of the promoter by using a Thosea asigna virus 2A auto-cleaving domain. With this gene stacking configuration, we have successfully obtained expression in transgenic corn of four transgenes; three transgenes conferring insect (cry34Ab1 and cry35Ab1) and herbicide (aad1) resistance, and a phiyfp reporter gene using a single ZMUbi1 bidirectional promoter. Gene expression analyses of transgenic corn plants confirmed better coordinated expression of the four genes compared to constructs driving each gene by independent unidirectional ZmUbi1 promoter. To our knowledge, this is the first report that demonstrates application of a single promoter for co-regulation of multiple genes in a crop plant. This stacking technology would be useful for engineering metabolic pathways both for basic and applied research.

Genome wide analysis of Arabidopsis thaliana reveals high frequency of AAAGN7CTTT motif

Sequence specific elements in DNA regulate transcription by recruiting transcription factors. The Dof proteins are a large family of transcription factors that share a single highly conserved zinc finger. The core to which Dof proteins bind has a consensus AAAG or ACTTTA sequence. These motifs have been over represented in many promoters. We performed a genome wide analysis of AAAG repeat elements increasing the spacer length from 0 to 25. Similar analyses was done with AAAG-CTTT motifs. We report unusual high frequency of AAAGN7CTTT in Arabidopsis thaliana genome. We also conclude that there is a preference for A/G nucleotides in spacer sequence between two AAAG repeats.

Combinatorial control of gene expression

The complexity and diversity of eukaryotic organisms are a feat of nature's engineering. Pulling the strings of such an intricate machinery requires an even more masterful and crafty approach. Only the number and type of responses that they generate exceed the staggering proportions of environmental signals perceived and processed by eukaryotes. Hence, at first glance, the cell's sparse stockpile of controlling factors does not seem remotely adequate to carry out this response. The question as to how eukaryotes sense and respond to environmental cues has no single answer. It is an amalgamation, an interplay between several processes, pathways, and factors—a combinatorial control. A short description of some of the most important elements that operate this entire conglomerate is given in this paper.

Patterns and evolution of ACGT repeat cis-element landscape across four plant genomes

BACKGROUND

Transcription factor binding is regulated by several interactions, primarily involving cis-element binding. These binding sites maintain specificity by means of their sequence, and other additional factors such as inter-motif distance and spacer specificity. The ACGT core sequence has been established as a functionally important cis-element which frequently regulates gene expression in synergy with other cis-elements. In this study, we used two monocotyledonous - Oryza sativa and Sorghum bicolor, and two dicotyledonous species - Arabidopsis thaliana and Glycine max to analyze the conservation of co-occurring ACGT core elements in plant promoters with respect to spacer distance between them. Using data generated from Arabidopsis thaliana and Oryza sativa, we also identified conserved regions across all spacers and possible conditions regulating gene promoters with multiple ACGT cis-elements.

RESULTS

Our data indicated specific predominant spacer lengths between co-occurring ACGT elements, but these lengths were not universally conserved across all species under analysis. However, the frequency distribution indicated local regions of high correlation among monocots and dicots. Sequence specificity data clearly revealed a preference for G at the first and C at the terminal position of a spacer sequence, suggesting that the G-box motif is the most prevalent for the ACGT class of promoters. Using gene expression databases, we also observed trends suggesting that co-occurring ACGT elements are responsible for gene regulation in response to exogenous stress. Conservation in patterns of ACGT (N) ACGT among orthologous genes also indicated the possibility that emergence of functional significance across species was a result of parallel evolution of these cis-elements.

CONCLUSIONS

Although the importance of ACGT elements has been acknowledged for several plant species, ours is the first study that attempts to compare their occurrence across four species and analyze conservation among them. The apparent preference for particular spacer distances suggest that these motifs might be implicated in important physiological functions which are yet to be identified. Variations in correlation patterns among monocots and dicots might arise out of differences in transcriptional regulation in the two classes. In accordance with literature, we established the involvement of co-occurring ACGT elements in stress responses and showed how this regulation differs with variation in the ACGT (N) ACGT motif. We believe that our study will be an essential resource in determining optimum spacer length and spacer sequence between ACGT elements for promoter design in future.

Cis-acting motifs in artificially synthesized expression cassette leads to enhanced transgene expression in tomato (Solanum lycopersicum L.)

Efficacy of artificial synthetic expression modules was compared with native CaMV35S and DECaMV35S promoter in transgenic tomato developed by Agrobacterium-mediated transformation. The promoters under trial were CaMV35S-mec (PcamI), CaMV35S (PcamII), DECaMV35S (PcamIII), synthetic minimal expression cassette (Pmec), complete expression cassette (Pcec), double enhancer expression cassette (Pdec) and triple enhancer expression cassette (Ptec) for driving the uidA gene for β-glucuronidase (GUS) activity. The promoter efficiency based on average of GUS expression in T(0) and T(1) transgenic tomato was in the order Pcec > Pdec > PcamIII > PcamII > PcamI > Ptec > Pmec. The two promoters Pcec and PcamIII were deployed for development of insect-resistant transgenic tomato with optimal expression of modified cry1Ac insecticidal toxin gene from Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt). The transgenic status and copy number of the cry1Ac in T(0) transgenic tomato was confirmed through PCR, Southern hybridization, RT-PCR and Western immunoassay, while toxin expression was monitored by DAS-ELISA. The expression level of Cry1Ac toxin driven by Pcec in T(0) population ranged from 0.08 to 0.8% of total soluble protein (TSP) that was significantly higher to PcamIII which ranged from 0.02 to 0.13% of TSP. The outcome of insect mortality bioassay with Helicoverpa armigera correlated well with the results of DAS-ELISA. The higher expression of cry1Ac gene driven by Pcec promoter in transgenic tomato did not show any yield penalty and reflected complete protection, while low recovery of promising transgenics expressing Cry1Ac toxin driven by PcamIII was a major limitation for complete protection against the fruit borer insect.

Evidence for directed evolution of larger size motif in Arabidopsis thaliana genome

Transcription control of gene expression depends on a variety of interactions mediated by the core promoter region, sequence specific DNA-binding proteins, and their cognate promoter elements. The prominent group of cis acting elements in plants contains an ACGT core. The cis element with this core has been shown to be involved in abscisic acid, salicylic acid, and light response. In this study, genome-wide comparison of the frequency of occurrence of two ACGT elements without any spacers as well as those separated by spacers of different length was carried out. In the first step, the frequency of occurrence of the cis element sequences across the whole genome was determined by using BLAST tool. In another approach the spacer sequence was randomized before making the query. As expected, the sequence ACGTACGT had maximum occurrence in Arabidopsis thaliana genome. As we increased the spacer length, one nucleotide at a time, the probability of its occurrence in genome decreased. This trend continued until an unexpectedly sharp rise in frequency of (ACGT)N25(ACGT). The observation of higher probability of bigger size motif suggests its directed evolution in Arabidopsis thaliana genome.

Designer promoter: an artwork of cis engineering

Advances in systematic computational biology and rapid elucidation of synergistic interplay between cis and trans factors governing transcriptional control have facilitated functional annotation of gene networks. The generation of data through deconstructive, reconstructive and database assisted promoter studies, and its integration to principles of synthetic engineering has started an era of designer promoters. Exploration of natural promoter architecture and the concept of cis engineering have not only enabled fine tuning of single or multiple transgene expression in response to perturbations in the chemical, physiological and environmental stimuli but also provided researchers with a unique answer to various problems in crop improvement in the form of bidirectional promoters.

Promoter activation by ACGT in response to salicylic and abscisic acids is differentially regulated by the spacing between two copies of the motif

A variety of small sequence motifs, located upstream of minimal promoters influence gene expression. The function of the core sequence ACGT, present in a family of commonly occurring cis acting transcription regulatory motifs was investigated in the background of an artificially designed synthetic promoter sequence. The ACGT was placed in one or two copies and separated by different spacer lengths between the two copies, to study their affect on the expression of basal promoter in plant cells. The activation of transcription by the ACGT element was examined by transient and stable transformation in tobacco, using gusA as the reporter gene. The analysis shows that the expression of the reporter gene was influenced differently by spacing between two adjacent copies of the motif. Two copies of the ACGT element separated by 5 nucleotides gave highest activation. This configuration imparted salicylic acid inducibility to the basal promoter. However, two copies of ACGT separated by 25 nucleotides allowed the promoter to be induced by abscisic acid but not salicylic acid. Computational analysis of the Arabidopsis thaliana genome database showed the presence of these motifs in several genes associated with a variety of stress responses. The results on motif-related inducibility by salicylic acid and abscisic acid, as seen in a synthetic sequence background were validated by experiments on the expression of the native promoter of a protein phosphatase 2C-like gene of Arabidopsis in tobacco leaves. The study supports the importance of spacing between the ACGT sequence motifs on the elicitor specific modulation of gene expression and demonstrates the role of different ACGT motifs in the regulation of PP2C gene expression.

In vivo characterization of plant promoter element interaction using synthetic promoters

Short directly-repeated (DR) DNA enhancer elements of plant viral origin were analyzed for their ability, both individually and in combination, to influence in vivo transcription when inserted upstream from a minimal CaMV35S promoter. Synthetic promoters containing multiple copies and/or combinations of DR cassettes were tested for their effect upon reporter gene (luciferase) expression using an Agrobacteria-based leaf-infiltration transient assay and within stably transformed plants (Nicotiana tabacum). Transgenic plants harboring constructs containing different numbers or combinations of DR cassettes were further tested to look for tissue-specific expression patterns and potential promoter response to the infiltration process employed during transient expression. Multimerization of DR elements produced enhancer activity that was in general additive, increasing reporter activity in direct proportion to the number of DR cassettes within the test promoter. In contrast, combinations of different DR cassettes often functioned synergistically, producing reporter enhancement markedly greater then the sum of the combined DR activities. Several of the DR constructs responded to Agrobacteria (lacking T-DNA) infiltration of transgenic leaves by an induction (2 elements) or reduction (1 element) in reporter activity. Combinations of DR cassettes producing the strongest enhancement of reporter activity were used to create two synthetic promoters (SynPro3 and SynPro5) that drive leaf reporter activities at levels comparable to the CaMV35S promoter. Characterization of these synthetic promoters in transformed tobacco showed strong reporter expression at all stages of development and in most tissues. The arrangement of DR elements within SynPro3 and SynPro5 appears to play a role in defining tissue-specificity of expression and/or Agrobacteria-infusion responsiveness.

Synthetic promoters: genetic control through cis engineering

Technological advances in plant genetics integrated with systems biology and bioinformatics has yielded a myriad of novel biological data and insights into plant metabolism. This unprecedented advance has provided a platform for targeted manipulation of transcriptional activity through synthetic promoter engineering, and holds great promise as a way to further our understanding of regulatory complexity. The challenge and strategy for predictive experimental gene expression is the accurate design and use of molecular 'switches' and modules that will regulate single or multiple plant transgenes in direct response to specific environmental, physiological and chemical cues. In particular, focusing on cis-motif rearrangement, future plant biotechnology applications and the elucidation of cis- and trans-regulatory mechanisms could greatly benefit from using plant synthetic promoters.

Analysis of polarity in the expression from a multifactorial bidirectional promoter designed for high-level expression of transgenes in plants

A synthetic bidirectional expression module was constructed by placing a computationally designed minimal promoter sequence on the 5' and 3' sides of a transcription activation module. The activation of transcription from the unidirectional and bidirectional promoters constructed from the same sequence elements was evaluated by using the reporter genes gusA and gfp. The analysis based on transient and stable transformation of tobacco showed that the artificially designed multifactorial activation module activated transcription simultaneously to comparable levels in both the directions. The transcription activation module responded to elicitors like salicylic acid, NaCl and IAA in the forward as well as reverse directions. The concentration of the elicitor required for highest gene activation was similar for the two directions in case of the three activators. The kinetics of time of induction was similar in the two directions for salicylic acid and NaCl. In the case of IAA, the transcription activation was faster in the reverse direction. The results show that constitutive and chemically inducible bidirectional promoters can be deployed for predictable simultaneous regulation of two genes for genetic engineering in plants.