Combat-related peripheral nerve injuries

Active-duty service members (ADSM) and military Veterans represent a population with increased occupational risk for nerve injuries sustained both during training operations and wartime. Mechanisms of war-related nerve injuries have evolved over time, from the musket ball-related traumas described by S.W. Mitchell to complex blast injuries and toxic exposures sustained during Middle East conflicts in the 21st century. Commonly encountered nerve injury etiologies in this population currently include compression, direct trauma, nutritional deficits, traumatic limb amputation, toxic chemical exposures, or blast-related injuries. Expeditious identification and comprehensive, interdisciplinary treatment of combat-associated neuropathies, as well as prevention of these injuries whenever possible is critical to reduce chronic morbidity and disability for service members and to maintain a well-prepared military. However, diagnosis of a combat-associated nerve injury may be particularly challenging due to comorbid battlefield injuries or delayed presentation of neuropathy from military toxic exposures. Advances in imaging for nerve injury, including MRI and ultrasound, provide useful tools to compliment EMG in establishing a diagnosis of combat-associated nerve injury, particularly in the setting of anatomic disruption or edema. Surgical techniques can improve pain control or restoration of function. In all cases, comprehensive interdisciplinary rehabilitation provides the best framework for optimization of recovery. Further work is needed to prevent combat-associated nerve injuries and promote nerve recovery following injury.

Longitudinal traumatic peripheral nerve injury recovery: quantitative description, classification and prediction

Aim: Repair of peripheral nerves is recommended following transection. Systematic evaluation of longitudinal recovery in injury models is needed to improve patient management. Gompertz function provided straightforward interpretation and prediction of recovery outcomes. Materials & methods: Behavioural sciatic function index, measured 3 days post injury, and weekly for 12 weeks following full nerve transection and repair (n = 6) as well as crush injuries (n = 6). Results: Gompertz parametrization provided early classification between types of traumatic peripheral nerve injuries following surgical repair. Results distinguished injury nerves (A: p < 0.01; T_i: p < 0.05; Ic: p < 0.05 and outcome: p < 0.01). Early prognostication of outcomes (crush: 5.5 ± 0.3 and cut/repair: 8 ± 1 weeks) preceded current methods. Conclusion: Our findings identify injury type, state of recovery and early prognostication of outcome.

Novel Approach of Femur Shortening With Insertion of Expandable Rod to Achieve End-to-End Repair of Sciatic Nerve Laceration

BACKGROUND

Sciatic nerve injuries are challenging for diagnosis and treatment. Particularly in proximally located high-grade injuries, neurorrhaphy often has poor outcomes. Most advocate autologous grafting and some more recently have suggested the value of knee flexion braces to facilitate end-to-end repair.

OBJECTIVE

To describe a case of femur shortening to facilitate tension-free, end-to-end sciatic nerve neurorrhaphy.

METHODS

The patient was a 17-year-old man who was injured by the propeller of a motor boat and suffered a series of lacerations to both lower extremities including transection of his right sciatic nerve in the proximal thigh. After extensive mobilization of the nerve, a greater than 7-cm gap was still present. The patient was treated with femur shortening to facilitate end-to-end coaptation. He subsequently had an expandable rod placed which was lengthened 1 mm per day until his leg length was symmetric.

RESULTS

Within 7 months postoperatively, the patient had an advancing Tinel sign and paresthesias to the dorsum of his foot. Nine months postoperatively, he had early mobility in his plantarflexion.

CONCLUSION

We present a novel method of femur shortening with insertion of an expandable rod to facilitate direct end-to-end and tension-free sciatic nerve neurorrhaphy in a proximally located injury. Furthermore, larger scale and comparative studies are warranted to further explore this and other techniques.

Pathophysiological Aspects of Muscle Atrophy and Osteopenia Induced by Chronic Constriction Injury (CCI) of the Sciatic Nerve in Rats

Skeletal muscle atrophy is a condition characterized by a loss of muscle mass and muscle strength caused by an imbalance between protein synthesis and protein degradation. Muscle atrophy is often associated with a loss of bone mass manifesting as osteoporosis. The aim of this study was to evaluate if chronic constriction injury (CCI) of the sciatic nerve in rats can be a valid model to study muscle atrophy and consequent osteoporosis. Body weight and body composition were assessed weekly. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was performed on day zero before ligation and day 28 before sacrifice. Catabolic markers were assessed via Western blot and Quantitative Real-time PCR. After the sacrifice, a morphological analysis of the gastrocnemius muscle and Micro-Computed Tomography (Micro-CT) on the tibia bone were performed. Rats that underwent CCI had a lower body weight increase on day 28 compared to the naive group of rats (p < 0.001). Increases in lean body mass and fat mass were also significantly lower in the CCI group (p < 0.001). The weight of skeletal muscles was found to be significantly lower in the ipsilateral hindlimb compared to that of contralateral muscles; furthermore, the cross-sectional area of muscle fibers decreased significantly in the ipsilateral gastrocnemius. The CCI of the sciatic nerve induced a statistically significant increase in autophagic and UPS (Ubiquitin Proteasome System) markers and a statistically significant increase in Pax-7 (Paired Box-7) expression. Micro-CT showed a statistically significant decrease in the bone parameters of the ipsilateral tibial bone. Chronic nerve constriction appeared to be a valid model for inducing the condition of muscle atrophy, also causing changes in bone microstructure and leading to osteoporosis. Therefore, sciatic nerve constriction could be a valid approach to study muscle-bone crosstalk and to identify new strategies to prevent osteosarcopenia.

Rapid and effective fusion repair of severed digital nerves using neurorrhaphy and bioengineered solutions including polyethylene glycol: A case report

Peripheral nerve injuries (PNIs) that consist of simple nerve severance often result in severe motor impairment and permanent loss of function. Such patients face significant costs and pose major burdens to healthcare systems. Currently, the most promising surgical technique to achieve the best clinical outcome after such PNIs is immediate primary coaptation of severed nerve ends by microsutures (neurorrhaphy). However, recovery is often poor and delayed for many months due to Wallerian degeneration (WD) and slow (1-2 mm/day) axonal outgrowths from severed proximal axons that may not properly reinnervate denervated afferent/efferent targets that have atrophied. In contrast, recent pre-clinical studies using polyethylene glycol (PEG) to facilitate primary nerve repair have greatly improved the rate and extent of sensory and motor recovery and prevented much WD and muscle atrophy. That is, PEG-fused axons rapidly establish proximal-distal axoplasmic/axolemmal continuity, which do not undergo WD and maintain the structure and function of neuromuscular junction (NMJ). PEG-fused axons rapidly reinnervate denervated NMJs, thereby preventing muscle atrophy associated with monthslong denervation due to slowly regenerating axonal outgrowths. We now describe PEG-mediated fusion repair of a digital nerve in each of two patients presenting with a digital laceration resulting in total loss of sensation. The first patient's tactile perception improved markedly at 3 days postoperatively (PO). Two-point discrimination improved from greater than 10 mm at initial presentation to 4 mm at 11-week PO, and the Semmes-Weinstein monofilament score improved from greater than 6.65 to 2.83 mm, a near-normal level. The second patient had severe PO edema and scar development requiring a hand compression glove and scar massage, which began improving at 11-week PO. The sensory function then improved for 4 months PO, with both two-point discrimination and Semmes-Weinstein scores approaching near-normal levels at the final follow-up. These case study data are consistent with data from animal models. All these data suggest that PEG-fusion technologies could produce a paradigm shift from the current clinical practice of waiting days to months to repair ablation PNIs with autografts, anucleated nerve allografts, or conduits in which the patient outcome is solely dependent upon axon regeneration over months or years.

A Penetrating Lumbar Spine Injury With Misleading Neurological Symptoms

Penetrating spinal injuries require specific neurosurgical attention. To date, there are no guidelines regarding emergency neurosurgical management of such injuries and the decision whether to operate is made individually, based on the neurological examination and the analysis of any imaging available. We report the case of a 22-year-old patient who sustained two gunshots in the thighs and one in the lumbar spine. Clinical examination revealed neurological deficit in both legs prevailing on the right side. Discussion between the radiologist and the neurosurgeon concluded to an injury to the left S1 nerve root within the spinal canal, and to the right sciatic nerve. Thus, there was no need for a decompressive laminectomy. In the light of the current literature, penetrating spinal injuries rarely require an extensive surgical exploration; indications for such a procedure include incomplete neurological deficit with persistent neurological compression, cerebrospinal fluid leakage, and obvious instability. Furthermore, penetrating spinal injuries are rarely encountered, even for military neurosurgeons. Their surgical management and especially the need for laminectomy, stabilization, and dural sac watertight closure are still a matter of debate. An expert consensus statement would give food to surgeons facing penetrating spinal injuries.

Traumatic injury to peripheral nerves

This article reviews the epidemiology, classification, localization, prognosis, and mechanisms of recovery of traumatic peripheral nerve injuries (PNIs). Electrodiagnostic (EDx) assessments are critical components of treating patients with PNIs. In particular, motor and sensory nerve conduction studies, needle electromyography, and other electrophysiological methods are useful for localizing peripheral nerve injuries, detecting and quantifying the degree of axon loss, and contributing toward treatment decisions as well as prognostication. It is critical that EDx medical consultants are aware of the timing of these changes as well as limitations in interpretations. Mechanisms of recovery may include recovery from conduction block, muscle fiber hypertrophy, distal axonal sprouting, and axon regrowth from the site of injury. Motor recovery generally reaches a plateau at 18 to 24 months postinjury. When patients have complete or severe nerve injuries they should be referred to surgical colleagues early after injury, as outcomes are best when nerve transfers are performed within the first 3 to 6 months after onset.

Proteomics reveals the key molecules involved in curcumin-induced protection against sciatic nerve injury in rats

We generated a rat model of sciatic nerve crush injury and characterized the effects of curcumin on sciatic nerve recovery by using behavioral experiments, hematoxylin-eosin staining, toluidine blue staining, and immunohistochemical. Proteomic analysis using tandem mass tagging was performed to determine differentially expressed proteins (DEPs), and GO and KEGG pathway analyses of overlapping DEPs was conducted, following which, qPCR, western blotting, and immunofluorescence were further performed to validate the proteins of interest. Finally, a Schwann cell injury model was used to verify the effect of curcumin on potential targets. The rat model was successful established and curcumin improved the sciatic nerve function index of rats with sciatic nerve injury (SNI) and increased the number and diameter of myelinated axons in the sciatic nerve. In the Sham group versus the Injured group and in the Injured group versus the Curcumin group, we identified a total of 4,175 proteins, of which 953 were DEPs, and 218 were known overlapping DEPs. Ten associated pathways, such as calcium signaling pathway, biosynthesis of antibiotics, and long-term potentiation, were identified. The 218 overlapping DEPs were primarily involved in negative regulation of apoptotic process, biological processes, cytoplasm cellular component, and protein binding molecular function based on GO annotation. Curcumin promoted increased expression of ApoD and inhibited the expression of Cyba in vivo and in vitro. These results indicated that curcumin promoted sciatic nerve repair through regulation of various proteins, targets, and pathways. Cyba and ApoD may be potential targets of curcumin in the treatment of SNI.

Defects of the sciatic nerve and its divisions treated by direct suturing in 90 degrees knee flexion: report on the first clinical series

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate functional results after treatment of large defects of the sciatic nerve and its divisions by direct nerve suturing in high knee flexion.

METHODS

A retrospective review was conducted in patients treated for lower extremity nerve defects between 2011 and 2019. Inclusion criteria were a defect > 2 cm with a minimal follow-up period of 2 years for the sciatic nerve and 1 year for its divisions. Nerve defects were bridged by an end-to-end suture with the knee flexed at 90° for 6 weeks. Functional results were assessed based on the Medical Research Council's grading system.

RESULTS

Seventeen patients with a mean age of 27.6 years were included. They presented with seven sciatic nerve defects and ten division defects, including eight missile injuries. The mean time to surgery was 12.3 weeks and the mean nerve defect length was 5 cm. Overall, 21 nerve sutures were performed, with eight in the tibial distribution and 13 in the fibular distribution. Post-operatively, there was no significant knee stiffness related to the immobilization. The mean follow-up time was 24.5 months. Meaningful motor and sensory recovery were observed after 7 of 8 sutures in the tibial distribution and 11 of 13 sutures in the fibular distribution. A functional sural triceps muscle with protective sensibility of the sole was restored in all patients. There were no differences according to the injury mechanisms.

CONCLUSION

Temporary knee flexion at 90° allows for direct coaptation of sciatic nerve defects up to 8 cm, with promising results no matter the level or mechanism of injury.

Pineal Gland from the Cell Culture to Animal Models: A Review

This review demonstrates current literature on pineal gland physiology, pathology, and animal model experiments to concisely explore future needs in research development with respect to pineal gland function and neuro-regenerative properties. The pineal gland plays an integral role in sleep and recovery by promoting physiologic circadian rhythms via production and release of melatonin. Yet, the current literature shows that the pineal gland has neuroprotective effects that modulate both peripheral and central nerve injuries through several direct and indirect mechanisms, such as angiogenesis and induction of growth factors and anti-inflammatory mediators. Animal models have also shown correlations between pineal gland function and metabolic homeostasis. Studies have shown that a functional pineal gland is essential in preventing and slowing the progression of certain diseases such as diabetes, osteoporosis, vertebral osteoarthritis, and neurodegenerative processes. Lastly, the array of cell culturing methods and animal models that can be used to further develop the study of pineal gland function and nervous system injury were reviewed.

Ballistic peripheral nerve injuries: basic concepts, controversies, and proposal for a management strategy

Ballistic injuries to peripheral nerves are devastating injuries frequently encountered in modern conflicts and civilian trauma centers. Such injuries often produce lifelong morbidity, mainly in the form of function loss and chronic pain. However, their surgical management still poses significant challenges concerning indication, timing, and type of repair, particularly when they are part of high-energy multi-tissue injuries. To help trauma surgeons, this article first presents basic ballistic concepts explaining different types of missile nerve lesions, described using the Sunderland classification, as well as their usual associated injuries. Current controversies regarding their surgical management are then described, including nerve exploration timing and neurolysis's relevance as a treatment option. Finally, based on anecdotal evidence and a literature review, a standardized management strategy for ballistic nerve injuries is proposed. This article emphasizes the importance of early nerve exploration and provides a detailed method for making a diagnosis in both acute and sub-acute periods. Direct suturing with joint flexion is strongly recommended for sciatic nerve defects and any nerve defect of limited size. Conversely, large defects require conventional nerve grafting, and proximal injuries may require nerve transfers, especially at the brachial plexus level. Additionally, combined or early secondary tendon transfers are helpful in certain injuries. Finally, ideal timing for nerve repair is proposed, based on the defect length, associated injuries, and risk of infection, which correlate intimately to the projectile velocity.

Application of Human Epineural Conduit Supported with Human Mesenchymal Stem Cells as a Novel Therapy for Enhancement of Nerve Gap Regeneration

Various therapeutic methods have been suggested to enhance nerve regeneration. In this study, we propose a novel approach for enhancement of nerve gap regeneration by applying human epineural conduit (hEC) supported with human mesenchymal stem cells (hMSC), as an alternative to autograft repair. Restoration of 20 mm sciatic nerve defect with hEC created from human sciatic nerve supported with hMSC was tested in 4 experimental groups (n = 6 each) in the athymic nude rat model (Crl:NIH-Foxn1^rnu): 1 - No repair control, 2 - Autograft control, 3 - Matched diameter hEC filled with 1 mL saline, 4 - Matched diameter hEC supported with 3 × 10⁶ hMSC. Assessments included: functional tests: toe-spread and pinprick, regeneration assessment by immunofluorescence staining: HLA-1, HLA-DR, NGF, GFAP, Laminin B, S-100, VEGF, vWF and PKH26 labeling; histomorphometric analysis of myelin thickness, axonal density, fiber diameter and myelinated nerve fibers percentage; Gastrocnemius Muscle Index (GMI) and muscle fiber area ratio. Best sensory and motor function recovery, as well as GMI and muscle fiber area ratio, were observed in the autograft group, and were comparable to the hEC with hMSC group (p = 0.038). Significant improvements of myelin thickness (p = 0.003), fiber diameter (p = 0.0296), and percentage of myelinated fibers (p < 0.0001) were detected in hEC group supported with hMSC compared to hEC with saline controls. At 12-weeks after nerve gap repair, hEC combined with hMSC revealed increased expression of neurotrophic and proangiogenic factors, which corresponded with improvement of function comparable with the autograft control. Application of our novel hEC supported with hMSC provides a potential alternative to the autograft nerve repair.

Outcomes of Tibial Nerve Repair and Transfer: A Structured Evidence-Based Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Although nerve transfer and repair are well-established for treatment of nerve injury in the upper extremity, there are no established parameters for when or which treatment modalities to utilize for tibial nerve injuries. The objective of our study is to conduct a systematic review of the effectiveness of end-to-end repair, neurolysis, nerve grafting, and nerve transfer in improving motor function after tibial nerve injury. PubMed, Cochrane, Medline, and Embase libraries were queried according to the PRISMA guidelines for articles that present functional outcomes after tibial nerve injury in humans treated with nerve transfer or repair. The final selection included Nineteen studies with 677 patients treated with neurolysis (373), grafting (178), end-to-end repair (90), and nerve transfer (30), from 1985 to 2018. The mean age of all patients was 27.0 ± 10.8 years, with a mean preoperative interval of 7.4 ± 10.5 months, and follow-up period of 82.9 ± 25.4 months. The mean graft repair length for nerve transfer and grafting patients was 10.0 ± 5.8 cm, and the most common donor nerve was the sural nerve. The most common mechanism of injury was gunshot wound, and the mean MRC of all patients was 3.7 ± 0.6. Good outcomes were defined as MRC ≥ 3. End-to-end repair treatment had the greatest number of good outcomes, followed by neurolysis. Patients with preoperative intervals less than 7 months were more likely to have good outcomes than those greater than 7 months. Patients with sport injuries had the highest percentage of good outcomes in contrast to patients with transections and who were in MVAs. We found no statistically significant difference in good outcomes between the use of sural and peroneal donor nerve grafts, nor between age, graft length, and MRC score.

Clinical Outcomes of Symptomatic Neuroma Resection and Reconstruction with Processed Nerve Allograft

Background:

Neuromas causing sensory disturbance can substantially affect nerve function and quality of life. Historically, passive termination of the nerve end and proximal relocation to muscle or bone has been performed after neuroma resection, but this method does not allow for neurologic recovery or prevent recurrent neuromas. The use of processed nerve allografts (PNAs) for intercalary reconstruction of nerve defects following neuroma resection is reasonable for neuroma management, although reported outcomes are limited. The purpose of this study was to assess the outcomes of pain reduction and functional recovery following neuroma resection and intercalary nerve reconstruction using PNA.

Methods:

Data on outcomes of PNA use for peripheral nerve reconstruction were collected from a multicenter registry study. The registry database was queried for upper extremity nerve reconstruction with PNA after resection of symptomatic neuroma. Patients completing both pain and quantitative sensory assessments were included in the analysis. Improvement in pain-related symptoms was determined via patient self-reported outcomes and/or the visual analog scale. Meaningful sensory recovery was defined as a score of at least S3 on the Medical Research Council Classification scale.

Results:

Twenty-five repairs involving 21 patients were included in this study. The median interval from injury to reconstruction was 386 days, and the average nerve defect length was 31 mm. Pain improved in 80% of repairs. Meaningful sensory recovery was achieved in 88% of repairs.

Conclusion:

Neuroma resection and nerve reconstruction using PNA can reduce or eliminate chronic peripheral nerve pain and provide meaningful sensory recovery.

Surgical Treatment of Upper Extremity Gunshot Injures: An Updated Review

INTRODUCTION

Firearm morbidity and mortality have been increasing in recent years, and with this, the demand for medical personnel firearm injury treatment knowledge. Extremities contribute to a majority of firearm injuries, with these injuries being particularly complex because of neurovascular proximity within a confined space. Knowledge of firearm mechanism of injury and treatment management options is important for any trauma hand surgeon. Many factors play vital roles in the treatment of complex upper extremity (UE) gunshot wounds (GSWs). The aim of our review and case illustrations is to provide hand surgeons with an up-to-date guide for initial emergent management, soft tissue, bony, and nerve repair and reconstruction.

PATIENT AND METHODS

A literature review was conducted in the current management of UE GSW injuries, and 2 specific patient case examples were included. High-energy versus low-energy GSWs were documented and compared, as well as containment injures. Management including soft tissue, bony, and nerve injuries was explored along with patient outcome. Based on these findings, guidelines for GSW management were purposed.

CONCLUSION

Gunshot wounds of the UE encompass a group of highly heterogeneous injuries. High-energy wounds are more extensive, and concomitant injuries to bone, vessel, nerve, muscle, and soft tissue are common. Early treatment with adequate debridement, skeletal fixation, and soft tissue coverage is indicated for complex injuries, and antibiotic treatment in the pre-, peri-, and postoperative period is indicated for operative injuries. Soft tissue coverage options include the entire reconstructive ladder, with pattern of injury and considerations of wound characteristics dictating reconstructive choice. There are arguments to using either external or internal bony fixation techniques for bone fracture management, with choice tailored to the patient. For management of nerve injuries, we advocate earlier nerve repair and a shorter duration of observation before secondary reconstruction in selective cases. If transected nerve endings cannot be brought together, nerve autografts of shorter length are recommended to bridge nerve ending gaps. A significant number of patients with GSW fail to make necessary follow-up appointments, which adds to challenges in treatment.

Management of Sciatic Nerve Defects: Lessons Learned and Proposal for a New Strategy

Management of sciatic nerve injuries can be difficult for surgeons without a special interest in nerve surgery as they would only treat a handful of such cases for many years. Sciatic nerve defects pose the greatest repair challenges, with nerve grafting producing mixed results because of the large size of the nerve in both diameter and length. This article first presents the peculiarities of sciatic nerve defects management, based on the authors experience and a literature review. Various issues are dealt with: When to operate depending on the injury mechanism? What are the results of nerve autografting and allografting? On which component should the repair focus in very large defects? Subsequently, alternatives to conventional nerve grafting are proposed. The authors stress the usefulness of direct nerve suture with knee flexion at 90 degrees, which permits bridging of gaps as much as 8 cm in length. For larger defects, other procedures should be considered: long vascularized nerve grafting in complete lesions, short grafting with knee flexed, or tendon transfers in partial lesions.

Missile Injury of the Sciatic Nerve: Observational Study Supporting Early Exploration and Direct Suture With Flexed Knee

Missile injuries of the sciatic nerve are frequently encountered in modern violent conflicts. Gunshot and fragment wounds may cause large nerve defects, for which management is challenging. The great size of the sciatic nerve, in both diameter and length, explains the poor results of nerve repair using autografts or allografts. To address this issue, we used a simple technique consisting of a direct suture of the sciatic nerve combined with knee flexion for 6 weeks. Despite a published series showing that this procedure gives better results than sciatic nerve grafting, it remains unknown or underutilized. The purpose of this cases study is to highlight the efficiency of direct sciatic nerve coaptation with knee flexed through three cases with missile injuries at various levels. At the follow-up of two years, all patients were pain free with a protective sensory in the sole and M3+ or M4 gastrocnemius muscles, regardless of the injury level. Recovery was also satisfying in the fibular portion, except for the very proximal lesion. No significant knee stiffness was noticed, including in a case suffering from an associated distal femur fracture. Key points to enhance functional recovery are early nerve repair (as soon as definitive bone fixation and stable soft-tissue coverage are achieved) and careful patient selection.

Direct Suturing of Sciatic Nerve Defects in High-degree Knee Flexion: An Experimental Study

OBJECTIVE

We sought to elucidate the conditions of direct suturing of sciatic nerve defects in high-degree knee flexion. We aimed to establish a correlation among the defect length, defect location, degree of knee flexion, and eventual need for hip immobilization in extension.

METHODS

We performed an experimental study by completing bilateral dissection of the sciatic nerve in 6 cadavers. Three groups of lesions were identified: at the buttock (BG), in the thigh (TG), and in the popliteal fossa (PG). For each defect, a direct, tensionless suture was performed with minimal knee flexion. Next, the hip was progressively flexed until rupture. The nerve defect length correlated with the degree of knee flexion and hip extension required to perform and protect the installed sutures.

RESULTS

A 30° knee flexion allowed for direct suturing of defects >2 cm in the 3 groups. The largest suturable nerve defects measured 7 cm in the TG and PG and 6 cm in the BG. When considering the same-size defects, the required knee flexion tended to be significantly greater in the BG. A bowstringing effect was noted at the buttock and popliteal levels. Hip flexion placed tension on the nerve suture at all locations.

CONCLUSIONS

The middle third of the thigh was the most compliant level, because the largest defects will be suturable without a visible bowstringing effect. Hip immobilization should be considered as soon as the defect has exceeded 2 cm, regardless of the location.