Optimizing selection of restriction enzymes in the search for DNA variants

A combinatorial approach to the restriction of a mouse genome

BACKGROUND

A fragmentation of genomic DNA by restriction digestion is a popular step in many applications. Usually attention is paid to the expected average size of the DNA fragments. Another important parameter, randomness of restriction, is regularly implied but rarely verified. This parameter is crucial to the expectation, that either all fragments made by restriction will be suitable for the method of choice, or only a fraction of those will be effectively used by the method. If only a fraction of the fragments are used, we often should know whether the used fragments are representative of the whole genome. With a modern knowledge of mouse, human and many other genomes, frequencies and distributions of restriction sites and sizes of corresponding DNA fragments can be analyzed in silico. In this manuscript, the mouse genome was systematically scanned for frequencies of complementary 4-base long palindromes.

FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS

The study revealed substantial heterogeneity in distribution of those sites genome-wide. Only few palindromes showed close to random pattern of distribution. Overall, the distribution of frequencies for most palindromes is much wider than expected by random occurrence. In practical terms, accessibility of genome upon restriction can be improved by a selective combination of restrictases using a few combinatorial rules. It is recommended to mix at least 3 restrictases, their recognition sequences (palindrome) should be the least similar to each other. Principles of the optimization and optimal combinations of restrictases are provided.

Analysis of mutation/rearrangement frequencies and methylation patterns at a given DNA locus using restriction fragment length polymorphism

Restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) is a difference in DNA sequences of organisms belonging to the same species. RFLPs are typically detected as DNA fragments of different lengths after digestion with various restriction endonucleases. The comparison of RFLPs allows investigators to analyze the frequency of occurrence of mutations, such as point mutations, deletions, insertions, and gross chromosomal rearrangements, in the progeny of stressed plants. The assay involves restriction enzyme digestion of DNA followed by hybridization of digested DNA using a radioactively or enzymatically labeled probe. Since DNA can be digested with methylation sensitive enzymes, the assay can also be used to analyze a methylation pattern of a particular locus. Here, we describe RFLP analysis using methylation-insensitive and methylation-sensitive enzymes.

Analysis of genetic variation in the Belgian Blue cattle breed using DNA sequence polymorphism at the growth hormone, low density lipoprotein receptor, alpha-subunit of glycoprotein hormones and thyroglobulin loci

New DNA sequence polymorphisms were identified at four bovine autosomal loci: growth hormone, low density lipoprotein receptor, alpha-subunit of glycoprotein hormones and thyroglobulin. Assuming independent assortment between these polymorphisms, the probabilities to be heterozygous at these four loci are 0.48, 0.36, 0.10 and 0.77 respectively, within the Belgian Blue Cattle breed (BBCB). Nucleotide diversity was estimated, showing that animals from the BBCB are heterozygous for 1/1450 nucleotides, a value significantly lower than the 1/500 value found in man. Moreover, we have estimated that the mutation rate at the cytosines of CG dinucleotides is about 10 times higher than that for other nucleotides.

Alcohol dehydrogenase genes: restriction fragment length polymorphisms for ADH4 (pi-ADH) and ADH5 (chi-ADH) and construction of haplotypes among different ADH classes

Of the five human alcohol dehydrogenase (ADH) genes located in the region q21-25 of chromosome 4, genetic markers have been reported previously only for class I enzymes, ADH1-3. Here, new restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) are described for the genes of two other classes, ADH4 (pi) and ADH5 (chi or formaldehyde dehydrogenase, FDH). The frequencies and modes of inheritance of these RFLPs were determined with DNA both from unrelated individuals and from families. A polymorphic PstI site is assigned to the fourth intron of the ADH4 gene. Pairwise linkage disequilibrium calculations for these new RFLPs and already known RFLPs at the ADH2 and ADH3 loci establish strong linkage disequilibria between polymorphic MspI and BstXI sites in the ADH5 gene as well as between XbaI and MspI sites in the ADH3 gene. Furthermore, linkage disequilibria were detected between RFLPs of the ADH2 and ADH3 genes as well as between those of the ADH4 and ADH5 genes. The latter disequilibrium implies a hitherto unknown physical proximity of two genes belonging to different ADH classes. The RFLPs were used to construct chromosomal haplotypes that include three ADH classes. Of the 16 possible haplotypes for four RFLP markers used here, 10 were experimentally detected. The potential application of the ADH RFLPs and haplotypes in linkage or association studies of inherited diseases such as familial "alcoholism" is discussed.

Molecular and genetic characterization and physical mapping of 11 new markers detecting multiallele restriction fragment length polymorphisms on the short arm of human chromosome 3

Genetic markers with high degrees of polymorphisms are of vital importance in the construction of high resolution (2-4 cM) linkage maps of human chromosomes as specified in the short-term goals of the Human Genome Initiative. In this paper, we report on molecular and genetic characterization and physical localization of 11 new multiallele restriction fragment length polymorphism markers on human chromosome 3p. Ten of these represent three- and four-allele polymorphisms of the base substitution type probably at two adjacent restriction sites. One has been identified as a novel mini-satellite sequence comprising a variable copy number tandem repeat array of a G/T-rich 79-bp sequence. This collection of multiallele polymorphic (PIC values: 0.40-0.60) markers should prove valuable and increase the resolution power of the available chromosome 3p genetic markers.

Restriction fragment length polymorphisms associated with the gene for the major intrinsic protein of eye-lens fibre cell membranes in mice with hereditary cataracts

Cloned cDNAs coding for eye-lens fibre cell-membrane proteins, MIP and MP70, were used to detect restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) in genomic DNA from inbred mice with autosomally inherited cataracts. Whereas distinct RFLPs associated with the MIP gene were identified in the Cba Cat and Nct mutants, no such genetic variation was associated with the MP70 gene. RFLPs associated with the mouse MIP gene may provide informative DNA markers in gene linkage studies of murine hereditary cataracts.

Immunoglobulin variable-region-like domains of diverse sequence within the major histocompatibility complex of the chicken

The highly polymorphic B-G antigens are considered to be part of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) of the chicken, the B system of histocompatibility, because they are encoded in a family of genes tightly linked with the genes encoding MHC class I and class II antigens. To better understand these unusual MHC antigens, full-length B-G cDNA clones were isolated from B21 embryonic erythroid cell cDNA library, restriction-mapped, and sequenced. Five transcript types were identified. Analysis of the deduced amino acid sequences suggests that the B-G polypeptides are composed of single extracellular domains that resemble immunoglobulin domains of the variable-region (V) type, single membrane-spanning domains typical of integral membrane proteins, and long cytoplasmic tails. Sequence diversity among the five transcript types was found in all domains, notably including the B-G immunoglobulin V-like domains. The cytoplasmic tails of the B-G antigens are made up entirely of units of seven amino acid residues (heptads) that are typical of an alpha-helical coiled-coil conformation. The heptads vary in number and sequence between the different transcripts. The presence within B-G polypeptides of polymorphic immunoglobulin V-like domains warrants further investigations to determine the degree and nature of variability within this domain in these unusual MHC antigens.

Linkage disequilibrium study of RFLPs detected at the human muscle nicotinic acetylcholine receptor subunit genes

We screened DNA from unrelated individuals for RFLPs in the muscle nicotinic acetylcholine receptor (AcChoR) genes. These RFLP markers can be used for genetic linkage and association studies to test the hypothesis that receptor structure or regulation is involved in the development of myasthenia gravis (MG). The cDNAs from four subunits (alpha, beta, gamma, and delta) of the murine muscle AcChoR were used as probes to identify RFLPs in the homologous human genes. Digestion of DNA from 15 unrelated individuals with a set of 10 restriction enzymes revealed 11 RFLPs. At least one RFLP was found for each subunit gene. Eight RFLPs were found at the linked gamma and delta gene loci, six with minor allele frequencies greater than 15%, making that linkage group a very informative marker locus (PIC = .72). PIC values were calculated for the RFLPs from allele and haplotype frequency estimates obtained from a population sample of 53 individuals. The delta gene was assigned by in situ hybridization to region q31----q34 of chromosome 2. All pairs of RFLPs were analyzed for linkage disequilibrium. Of the 16 pairs of RFLPs from the same gene or from the linked gamma and delta genes, 13 pairs showed evidence of disequilibrium that was significant, with P less than .05. The implications of these results are discussed.

Identification of more than 500 RFLPs by screening random genomic clones

As part of our genome-mapping effort, we undertook a large-scale screening study to identify RFLPs useful as genetic markers. Some 1,664 single-copy or repeat-containing phage clones from a Charon 4A genomic library were tested for polymorphism against a panel of DNAs, from five unrelated individuals, digested with eight restriction enzymes. Approximately 30% (515) of the clones revealed polymorphism by Southern hybridization; 67 loci detected had PIC values greater than .5. Restriction enzymes MspI, TaqI, and RsaI were most efficient in detecting polymorphism within the 1-20-kb-fragment size range resolved. With only one exception each of the clones detected polymorphism originating from a single locus.

Molecular analysis of the chicken major histocompatibility complex gene and gene products

New technologies are enabling researchers to conduct analysis of the molecular structure of the genes and gene products of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC). Two of these new technologies are the production of monoclonal antibodies by hybridomas and analysis of deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) by restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLP) on Southern blots. Monoclonal antibodies, because of their exquisite specificity, can be used to isolate purified MHC antigens for further study. The RFLP analysis can be used to examine differences in the MHC at the DNA level. This paper describes the two aforementioned technologies and their application to molecular analysis of the chicken MHC.

Polymorphism and linkage of the alpha A-crystallin gene in t-haplotypes of the mouse

Restriction fragment polymorphisms were used to order the alpha A-crystallin locus (Crya-1) relative to other genes in mouse t-chromatin and to investigate the relatedness of alpha-A-crystallin sequences among different t-haplotypes. Analysis of DNA from t-recombinant mice mapped Crya-1 to the K end of the H-2 complex and within the distal inverted region characteristic of t-haplotypes. Hybridization with Crya-1 cDNA revealed three distinct phenotypic groups among the 17 different t-haplotypes studied. A majority (9 of 17) of the t-haplotypes were classified into a novel group (Crya-1t) characterized by restriction fragments apparently unique to t-chromosomes and therefore thought to contain alpha A-crystallin sequences descended from the original t-chromosome. A second group of t-haplotypes had restriction fragment patterns indistinguishable from those observed among many common inbred strains of mice of the Crya-1a type, and a third restriction fragment pattern, observed only in the tw121 haplotype, was indistinguishable from the fragment pattern for C3H/DiSn (Crya-1b) and several other inbred strains of mice. Thus, with respect to sequences around the Crya-1 locus, different t-haplotypes show restriction fragment polymorphisms, some of which are comparable to those found in wild-type chromosomes and provide further evidence for genetic heterogeneity in DNA from the distal region of t-haplotypes.

The X chromosome shows less genetic variation at restriction sites than the autosomes

Using a standard technique, 122 single-copy probes were screened for their ability to detect restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) in the human genome. The use of a standardized RFLP screening enables the introduction of statistical methods in the analysis of differences in RFLP content between chromosomes and enzymes. RFLPs were detected from panels containing at least 17 unrelated chromosomes, digested with TaqI, MspI, BglII, HindIII, EcoRI, and PstI. Forty autosomal probes, representing a sample of 2,710 base pairs (bp) per haploid genome, were tested, and 24 RFLPs were found. With 82 X-chromosomal probes, 17 RFLPs were found in 6,228 bp per haploid genome. The frequency of X-chromosomal RFLPs is three times less than that of the autosomes; this difference is highly significant (P = less than .001). The frequency of RFLPs revealed by various restriction enzymes and the possibility that the X chromosome is a "low mutation" niche in the human genome are discussed.

Genomic analysis I: inheritance units and genetic selection in the rapid discovery of locus linked DNA markers

We propose, and test using a Monte-Carlo analysis (a computer-based numerical analysis using a random number generator), a novel and efficient method to obtain sets of DNA markers linked to any inherited genetic locus. The method consists of a targeted search that is based on the common inheritance among members of an outbred pedigree, of discrete chromosome lengths, which we call inheritance units, to obtain DNA markers linked to the locus. In cases where two individuals inherit the same trait through two different lines of descent from a common ancestor, the set of inheritance units in each of the two genomes includes an inheritance unit that is identical in both individuals for a substantial distance on both sides of the DNA sequence which confers the trait. The power of the technique derives from the genetic selection that reduces the size and number of the inheritance units as the generational distance between the two individuals being compared increases.

A systematic approach for detecting high-frequency restriction fragment length polymorphisms using large genomic probes

Thirteen phage clones containing low-copy sequences were isolated from a human DNA library and tested for their ability to detect restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs). Reported are the RFLPs revealed with each clone, all found in frequencies useful for linkage studies. Cytological data are available for five of the 13 clones, with regional assignments made for three of the markers by in situ hybridization. It is concluded that phage clones containing large unique DNA inserts detect multiple RFLPs with high efficiency. An analysis of the relative efficiency of 20 restriction enzymes for detecting single nucleotide changes is discussed by comparing the observed data to those expected on the basis of recognition and potential site frequencies, as computed from the dinucleotide distribution. Finally, in an effort to facilitate linkage studies using polymorphic DNA sequences, experiments were made with pools of probes from various sources.