Conserved arrangements of repeated DNA sequences in nontranscribed spacers of ciliate ribosomal RNA genes: evidence for molecular coevolution

Developmentally Programmed Switches in DNA Replication: Gene Amplification and Genome-Wide Endoreplication in Tetrahymena

Locus-specific gene amplification and genome-wide endoreplication generate the elevated copy number of ribosomal DNA (rDNA, 9000 C) and non-rDNA (90 C) chromosomes in the developing macronucleus of Tetrahymena thermophila. Subsequently, all macronuclear chromosomes replicate once per cell cycle during vegetative growth. Here, we describe an unanticipated, programmed switch in the regulation of replication initiation in the rDNA minichromosome. Early in development, the 21 kb rDNA minichromosome is preferentially amplified from 2 C to ~800 C from well-defined origins, concurrent with genome-wide endoreplication (2 C to 8-16 C) in starved mating Tetrahymena (endoreplication (ER) Phase 1). Upon refeeding, rDNA and non-rDNA chromosomes achieve their final copy number through resumption of just the endoreplication program (ER Phase 2). Unconventional rDNA replication intermediates are generated primarily during ER phase 2, consistent with delocalized replication initiation and possible formation of persistent RNA-DNA hybrids. Origin usage and replication fork elongation are affected in non-rDNA chromosomes as well. Despite the developmentally programmed 10-fold reduction in the ubiquitous eukaryotic initiator, the Origin Recognition Complex (ORC), active initiation sites are more closely spaced in ER phases 1 and 2 compared to vegetative growing cells. We propose that initiation site selection is relaxed in endoreplicating macronuclear chromosomes and may be less dependent on ORC.

Intragenomic variation in ribosomal RNA gene of the sea urchin Lytechinus variegatus

The first series of studies on the rDNA satellite of the sea urchin, Lytechinus variegatus, based on saturation hybridization of rRNA-rDNA and renaturation kinetics, showed that repeat length of rRNA gene was of about 8 kb in which there was no provision for NTS. The EM denaturation mapping, however, revealed (1) that the gene was 75% larger (longer) than 8 kb, within which there was a NTS whose length varied in repeating units, (3) and there was a region of high GC almost in the middle of the transcribed part. The suggestion of length and sequential heterogeneity in the gene copies coming from the first denaturation mapping prompted further studies with techniques so that the conclusions of the previous results could be stated with finality. The results that emanated from further studies established that the rDNA repeat length of L. variegatus was of about 12 kb and that the NTS ranged from 3.8 to 6.4 kb. Earlier demonstration of a moderately high-GC segment within the transcribed part was also confirmed by sequence analysis. However, the stipulations on the NTS regarding sequential and length heterogeneity, still awaits elucidation by sequence analysis.

Description of Perkinsus andrewsi n. sp. isolated from the Baltic clam (Macoma balthica) by characterization of the ribosomal RNA locus, and development of a species-specific PCR-based diagnostic assay

A Perkinsus species was isolated from the baltic clam Macoma balthica and an in vitro culture established under conditions described for P. marinus. As reported previously, morphological features remarkable enough to clearly indicate that this isolate is a distinct Perkinsus species were lacking. In this study, regions of the rRNA locus (NTS, 18S, ITS1, 5.8S, and ITS2) of this isolate were cloned, sequenced, and compared by alignment with those available for other Perkinsus species and isolates. Sequence data from the rRNA locus and species-specific PCR assays indicated not only that Perkinsus sp. from M. balthica was not P. marinus, but it was different from P. atlanticus and P. olseni. The degree of difference was comparable to or greater than differences between accepted Perkinsus species. In particular, NTS sequence and length were dramatically different from that of P. marinus and P. atlanticus. Therefore, we formally propose to designate the Perkinsus sp. from M. balthica as a separate species, P. andrewsi n. sp. Primers based on P. andrewsi NTS sequence were used to develop a PCR-based diagnostic assay that was validated for species-specificity and sensitivity. PCR-based assays specific for either P. andrewsi or P. marinus were used to test for their presence in bivalve species sympatric to M. balthica. Although isolated from M. balthica, P. andrewsi was also detected in the oyster Crassostrea virginica and clams Macoma mitchelli and Mercenaria mercenaria, and could coexist with P. marinus in all four bivalve species tested.

Three different proteins recognize a multifunctional determinant that controls replication initiation, fork arrest and transcription in Tetrahymena

Type I elements regulate the initiation of DNA replication, elongation of replication forks and transcription of the Tetrahymena thermophila rDNA minichromosome. Previous studies identified a 24 kDa protein, ssA-TIBF, which binds the A-rich strand of type I elements. Here we describe two additional type I element binding activities (native mol. wt approximately 65 and approximately 250 kDa) that interact with DNA via previously unidentified 32 and 110 kDa polypeptides. The 65 kDa activity was purified to homogeneity and consists of a homodimer of a 32 kDa polypeptide. In contrast to the other type I element binding factors, the 65 kDa activity partitions preferentially to the nuclear fraction during isolation. Levels of the 65 kDa activity increase dramatically in starved cells, raising the possibility that it might negatively regulate replication or transcription. By comparison, the other two binding activities were elevated slightly during macronuclear development, when the rDNA was undergoing DNA replication. Previous studies indicate that the initiation of rDNA replication is regulated by long range interactions between dispersed type I elements. Competitive DNA binding or cooperative protein-protein interactions between the factors described here may play a regulatory role in replication or expression of the rDNA minichromosome.

Allele-specific protein-DNA interactions between the single-stranded DNA-binding protein, ssA-TIBF, and DNA replication determinants in Tetrahymena

Type I elements are multifunctional, cis-acting determinants that regulate the initiation of DNA replication, replication fork movement and transcription of the Tetrahymena thermophila rDNA minichromosome. Previous studies identified a protein, ssA-TIBF, that binds specifically to the A-rich strand of type I elements. Here, we examine interactions of ssA-TIBF with the wild-type C3 allele, and a natural variant, B rDNA, which manifests a defect in replication initiation and fork pausing. Purified ssA-TIBF is a homotetramer that binds one substrate molecule and contacts DNA via a single 24 kDa subunit. Both the A-rich and T-rich strands of type I elements are bound by ssA-TIBF, suggesting that this protein might stabilize replication origins in their unwound state. Nucleotides downstream of type I elements contribute to DNA binding, with the extent of DNA-protein contact being greater for wild-type C3 rDNA compared to B rDNA. Allele-specific protein-DNA contacts also occur within the conserved type I element itself. Despite these differences, the binding affinities of ssA-TIBF for C3 and B rDNA substrates are indistinguishable. Consequently, the mode of DNA binding must account for any role ssA-TIBF might play in the regulation of rDNA replication.

Long range cooperative interactions regulate the initiation of replication in the Tetrahymena thermophila rDNA minichromosome

The Tetrahymena thermophila rDNA exists as a 21 kb palindromic minichromosome with two initiation sites for replication in each half palindrome. These sites localize to the imperfect, repeated 430 bp segments that include the nucleosome-free domains 1 and 2 (D1 and D2). To determine if the D1 and D2 segments act independently or in concert to control initiation, stable DNA transformation assays were performed. Single domain derivatives of the plasmid prD1 failed to support autonomous replication in Tetrahymena. Instead, such constructs propagated exclusively by integration into endogenous rDNA minichromosomes and displayed weak origin activity as detected by 2D gel electrophoresis. D1/D1 and D2/D2 derivatives also transformed Tetrahymena poorly, showing similar replication defects. Hence, the D1 and D2 segments are functionally non-redundant and cooperate rather than compete to control initiation. The observed replication defect was greatly reduced in a plasmid derivative that undergoes palindrome formation in Tetrahymena, suggesting that a compensatory mechanism overcomes this replication block. Finally, using a transient replication assay, we present evidence that phylogenetically-conserved type I elements directly regulate DNA replication. Taken together, our data support a model in which cooperative interactions between dispersed elements coordinately control the initiation of DNA replication.

Characterization of the Euplotes crassus macronuclear rDNA and its potential as a DNA transformation vehicle

We have cloned the macronuclear linear DNA molecule carrying the ribosomal RNA genes from the ciliated protozoan Euplotes crassus. DNA sequence analysis was carried out to locate coding regions and to determine whether sequences that have been mutated to confer antibiotic resistance are conserved in the E. crassus genes. The beginning and end of the primary transcript were mapped. In order to determine whether conserved sequences that might serve as replication origins were present, the 5' and 3' non-coding sequences from E. crassus were compared to the corresponding sequences from the macronuclear linear rDNA molecules from the following euplotid species: Euplotes vannus, Euplotes minuta, Euplotes raikovii and Euplotes rariseta. A DNA transformation construct was made by generating a putative anisomycin resistant mutation along with a mutation generating a restriction site polymorphism. Microinjection of the construct into the developing macronucleus of mated cells resulted in exconjugant cell lines with increased resistance to anisomycin. The injected rDNA with the restriction site polymorphism is detectable in the anisomycin resistant cells and appears to represent a minor fraction of the rDNA.

Conserved cis- and trans-acting determinants for replication initiation and regulation of replication fork movement in tetrahymenid species

The rDNA minichromosomes of Tetrahymena thermophila and Tetrahymena pyriformis share a high degree of sequence similarity and structural organization. The T.thermophila 5' non-transcribed spacer (5' NTS) is sufficient for replication and contains three repeated sequence elements that are conserved in T.pyriformis , including type I elements, the only known determinant for replication control. To assess the role of conserved sequences in replication control, structural and functional studies were performed on T.pyriformis rDNA. Similar to T.thermophila , replication initiates exclusively in the 5' NTS, localizing to a 900 bp segment. Elongating replication forks arrest transiently at one site which bears strong similarity to a tripartite sequence element present at fork arrest sites in T.thermophila rDNA. An in vitro type I element binding activity indistinguishable from the T.thermophila protein, ssA-TIBF, was detected in T.pyriformis extracts. The respective TIBF proteins bind with comparable affinity to type I elements from both species, suggesting that in vivo recognition could cross species boundaries. Despite these similarities, the T.pyriformis 5' NTS failed to support replication in transformed T.thermophila cells, suggesting a more complex genetic organization than previously realized.

A promoter region mutation affecting replication of the Tetrahymena ribosomal DNA minichromosome

In the ciliated protozoan Tetrahymena thermophila the ribosomal DNA (rDNA) minichromosome replicates partially under cell cycle control and is also subject to a copy number control mechanism. The relationship between rDNA replication and rRNA gene transcription was investigated by the analysis of replication, transcription, and DNA-protein interactions in a mutant rDNA, the rmm3 rDNA. The rmm3 (for rDNA maturation or maintenance mutant 3) rDNA contains a single-base deletion in the rRNA promoter region, in a phylogenetically conserved sequence element that is repeated in the replication origin region of the rDNA minichromosome. The multicopy rmm3 rDNA minichromosome has a maintenance defect in the presence of a competing rDNA allele in heterozygous cells. No difference in the level of rRNA transcription was found between wild-type and rmm3 strains. However, rmm3 rDNA replicating intermediates exhibited an enhanced pause in the region of the replication origin, roughly 750 bp upstream from the rmm3 mutation. In footprinting of isolated nuclei, the rmm3 rDNA lacked the wild-type dimethyl sulfate (DMS) footprint in the promoter region adjacent to the base change. In addition, a DMS footprint in the origin region was lost in the rmm3 rDNA minichromosome. This is the first reported correlation in this system between an rDNA minichromosome maintenance defect and an altered footprint in the origin region. Our results suggest that a promoter region mutation can affect replication without detectably affecting transcription. We propose a model in which interactions between promoter and origin region complexes facilitate replication and maintenance of the Tetrahymena rDNA minichromosome.

Regulatory sequences for the amplification and replication of the ribosomal DNA minichromosome in Tetrahymena thermophila

We have analyzed the cis-acting sequences that regulate rRNA gene (rDNA) replication in Tetrahymena thermophila. The macronucleus of this ciliated protozoan contains 9,000 copies of a 21-kbp minichromosome in the form of a palindrome comprising two copies of the rDNA. These are derived from a single chromosomally integrated copy during conjugation through selective amplification and are maintained by replicating once per cell cycle during vegetative growth. We have developed a transformation vector and carried out a deletion analysis to determine the minimal sequences required for replication, amplification, and/or stable maintenance of the rDNA molecule. Using constructs containing progressively longer deletions, we show that only a small portion (approximately 900 bp) of the rDNA is needed for extrachromosomal replication and stable maintenance of this molecule. This core region is very near but does not include the rRNA transcription initiation site or its putative promoter, indicating that replication is not dependent on normal rRNA transcription. It includes two nearly identical nuclease-sensitive domains (D1 and D2), one of which (D1) corresponds to the physical origin of replication determined previously. Deletion of both domains abolishes replication, whereas deletion of either domain allows the molecules to replicate, indicating that only one domain is required. In addition to this core region, we have found several DNA segments, including a tandem array of a 21-nucleotide repeat (type II repeats) and sequences within the rRNA coding region, that play distinctive and important roles in maintaining the rDNA at a high copy number.

Developmental regulation of DNA replication: replication fork barriers and programmed gene amplification in Tetrahymena thermophila

The palindromic Tetrahymena ribosomal DNA (rDNA) minichromosome is amplified 10,000-fold during development. Subsequent vegetative replication is cell cycle regulated. rDNA replication differs fundamentally in cycling vegetative and nondividing amplifying cells. Using two-dimensional gel electrophoresis, we show for the first time that replication origins that direct gene amplification also function in normal dividing cells. Two classes of amplification intermediates were identified. The first class is indistinguishable from vegetative rDNA, initiating in just one of the two 5' nontranscribed spacer (NTS) copies in the rDNA palindrome at either of two closely spaced origins. Thus, these origins are active throughout the life cycle and their regulation changes at different developmental stages. The second, novel class of amplification intermediates is generated by multiple initiation events. Intermediates with mass greater than fully replicated DNA were observed, suggesting that onionskin replication occurs at this stage. Unlike amplified rDNA in Xenopus laevis, the novel Tetrahymena species are not produced by random initiation; replication also initiates in the 5' NTS. Surprisingly, a replication fork barrier which is activated only in these amplifying molecules blocks the progression of forks near the center of the palindrome. Whereas barriers have been previously described, this is the first instance in which programmed regulation of replication fork progression has been demonstrated in a eukaryote.

Association of DNA with nuclear matrix in in vitro assembled nuclei induced by rDNA from Tetrahymena shanghaiensis in Xenopus egg extracts

Nuclei assembled in vitro from Xenopus egg extracts and DNA display many properties known from in vivo nuclei. However, the distribution pattern of DNA in such nuclei remains unknown. We introduced rDNA from Tetrahymena macronuclei into Xenopus egg extracts and examined the association of specific DNA sequences with the nuclear matrix (NM) of the nuclei formed. We found that the 5' non-transcribed spacers (5'-NTS) specifically bound to the NM as previously shown in normal Tetrahymena macronuclei.

Association of DNA with nuclear matrix in in vitro assembled nuclei induced by rDNA from Tetrahymena shanghaiensis in Xenopus egg extracts

The nuclei assembled from exogenous DNA or chromatin in egg extracts resemble their in vivo counterparts in many aspects. However, the distribution pattern of DNA in these nuclei remains unknown. We introduced rDNA from the macronuclei of Tetrahymena into Xenopus cell-free extracts to examine the association of specific DNA sequences with nuclear matrix (NM) in the nuclei assembled in vitro. Our previous works showed the 5'NTS (non-transcription sequences) of the rDNA specifically bind to the NM system in the macronuclei. We show now the rDNA could induce chromatin assembly and nuclear formation in Xenopus cell-free system. When we extracted the NM system and compared the binding affinity of different regions of rDNA with the NM system, we found that the 5'NTS still hold their binding affinity with insoluble structure of the assembled nuclei in the extracts of Xenopus eggs.

Replication of an rRNA gene origin plasmid in the Tetrahymena thermophila macronucleus is prevented by transcription through the origin from an RNA polymerase I promoter

In the somatic macronucleus of the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila, the palindromic rRNA gene (rDNA) minichromosome is replicated from an origin near the center of the molecule in the 5' nontranscribed spacer. The replication of this rDNA minichromosome is under both cell cycle and copy number control. We addressed the effect on origin function of transcription through this origin region. A construct containing a pair of 1.9-kb tandem direct repeats of the rDNA origin region, containing the origin plus a mutated (+G), but not a wild type, rRNA promoter, is initially maintained in macronuclei as an episome. Late, linear and circular replicons with long arrays of tandem repeats accumulate (W.-J. Pan and E. H. Blackburn, Nucleic Acids Res, in press). We present direct evidence that the +G mutation inactivates this rRNA promoter. It lacks the footprint seen on the wild-type promoter and produces no detectable in vivo transcript. Independent evidence that the failure to maintain wild-type 1.9-kb repeats was caused by transcription through the origin came from placing a short DNA segment containing the rRNA gene transcriptional termination region immediately downstream of the wild-type rRNA promoter. Insertion of this terminator sequence in the correct, but not the inverted, orientation restored plasmid maintenance. Hence, origin function was restored by inactivating the rRNA promoter through the +G mutation or causing termination before transcripts from a wild-type promoter reached the origin region. We propose that transcription by RNA polymerase I through the rDNA origin inhibits replication by preventing replication factors from assembling at the origin.

Modular structural elements in the replication origin region of Tetrahymena rDNA

Computer analyses of the DNA replication origin region in the amplified rRNA genes of Tetrahymena thermophila identified a potential initiation zone in the 5'NTS [Dobbs, Shaiu and Benbow (1994), Nucleic Acids Res. 22, 2479-2489]. This region consists of a putative DNA unwinding element (DUE) aligned with predicted bent DNA segments, nuclear matrix or scaffold associated region (MAR/SAR) consensus sequences, and other common modular sequence elements previously shown to be clustered in eukaryotic chromosomal origin regions. In this study, two mung bean nuclease-hypersensitive sites in super-coiled plasmid DNA were localized within the major DUE-like element predicted by thermodynamic analyses. Three restriction fragments of the 5'NTS region predicted to contain bent DNA segments exhibited anomalous migration characteristic of bent DNA during electrophoresis on polyacrylamide gels. Restriction fragments containing the 5'NTS region bound Tetrahymena nuclear matrices in an in vitro binding assay, consistent with an association of the replication origin region with the nuclear matrix in vivo. The direct demonstration in a protozoan origin region of elements previously identified in Drosophila, chick and mammalian origin regions suggests that clusters of modular structural elements may be a conserved feature of eukaryotic chromosomal origins of replication.

Identification of DNA-binding proteins that recognize a conserved type I repeat sequence in the replication origin region of Tetrahymena rDNA

An origin of DNA replication has been mapped within the 5' non-transcribed spacer region of the amplified macronuclear rRNA genes (rDNA) of Tetrahymena thermophila. Mutations in 33 nt conserved AT-rich Type I repeat sequences located in the origin region cause defects in the replication and/or maintenance of amplified rDNA in vivo. Fe(II)EDTA cleavage footprinting of restriction fragments containing the Type I repeat showed that most of the conserved nucleotides were protected by proteins in extracts of Tetrahymena cells. Two classes of proteins that bound the Type I repeat were identified and characterized using synthetic oligonucleotides in electrophoretic mobility shift assays. One of these, ds-TIBF, bound preferentially to duplex DNA and exhibited only moderate specificity for Type I repeat sequences. In contrast, a single-stranded DNA-binding protein, ssA-TIBF, specifically recognized the A-rich strand of the Type I repeat sequence. Deletion of the 5' or 3' borders of the conserved sequence significantly reduced binding of ssA-TIBF. The binding properties of ssA-TIBF, coupled with genetic evidence that Type I sequences function as cis-acting rDNA replication control elements in vivo, suggest a possible role for ssA-TIBF in rDNA replication in Tetrahymena.

Modular sequence elements associated with origin regions in eukaryotic chromosomal DNA

We have postulated that chromosomal replication origin regions in eukaryotes have in common clusters of certain modular sequence elements (Benbow, Zhao, and Larson, BioEssays 14, 661-670, 1992). In this study, computer analyses of DNA sequences from six origin regions showed that each contained one or more potential initiation regions consisting of a putative DUE (DNA unwinding element) aligned with clusters of SAR (scaffold associated region), and ARS (autonomously replicating sequence) consensus sequences, and pyrimidine tracts. The replication origins analyzed were from the following loci: Tetrahymena thermophila macronuclear rDNA gene, Chinese hamster ovary dihydrofolate reductase amplicon, human c-myc proto-oncogene, chicken histone H5 gene, Drosophila melanogaster chorion gene cluster on the third chromosome, and Chinese hamster ovary rhodopsin gene. The locations of putative initiation regions identified by the computer analyses were compared with published data obtained using diverse methods to map initiation sites. For at least four loci, the potential initiation regions identified by sequence analysis aligned with previously mapped initiation events. A consensus DNA sequence, WAWTTDDWWWDHWGWHMAWTT, was found within the potential initiation regions in every case. An additional 35 kb of combined flanking sequences from the six loci were also analyzed, but no additional copies of this consensus sequence were found.

Tetrahymena thermophila mutants defective in the developmentally programmed maturation and maintenance of the rDNA minichromosome

The abundant rDNA minichromosome of Tetrahymena thermophila is generated by a series of developmentally controlled processing steps, termed rDNA maturation, during the formation of the new macronucleus in conjugating cells. rDNA maturation involves excision of a region encoding the single copy rRNA gene (rDNA) from its germline location, rearrangement of the rDNA into a palindromic minichromosome, de novo telomere addition, and amplification to approximately 10(4) copies. The rDNA is maintained at this high level in vegetatively growing cells. Using a previously developed genetic scheme for studying rDNA maturation and maintenance, we report the isolation of a new class of mutants defective for rDNA maturation. Several new rDNA maintenance mutants were also obtained. The maturation mutant, rmm10, is severely defective for the production of both monomeric and palindromic rDNA in the developing macronucleus. The mm10 mutation is recessive-lethal and cis-acting. None of the previously identified DNA sequence elements that control rDNA maturation or maintenance is mutated in rmm10. Therefore, additional cis-acting sequence elements must be required for rDNA maturation. Based on our current understanding of rDNA maturation processes, we suggest that the rmm10 mutation affects rDNA excision rather than subsequent rDNA amplification/replication.

Developmentally regulated processing and replication of the Tetrahymena rDNA minichromosome

The ribosomal DNA locus of Tetrahymena thermophila undergoes a dramatic series of developmentally regulated processing events to generate the amplified rDNA minichromosome during formation of the somatic macronucleus. DNA transformation and classical genetic approaches have identified cis-acting elements that regulate rDNA processing in the developing macronucleus and subsequent vegetative rDNA maintenance.

Common sequence elements are important for transcription and replication of the extrachromosomal rRNA-encoding genes of Tetrahymena

Three types of conserved sequence elements have previously been identified in the generally non-conserved, 5' non-transcribed spacer region of the rRNA-encoding gene (rDNA) of Tetrahymena species. In vivo and in vitro experiments have identified the start point (tsp) for rDNA transcription. Comparative sequence analysis suggested that the type-I sequence element was likely to function as the promoter for rDNA transcription. We have used in vitro transcription assays to demonstrate that sequences in the 3' half of the type-I repeat located proximal to the tsp are essential for the accurate initiation of rRNA synthesis. These sequences define the 5' boundary of the core or minimal promoter element and include the sequences which function in rDNA replication and maintenance in the homologous regions in two upstream type-I sequence elements. These sequences may bind factors important for both the transcription and replication of rDNA.

PCR amplification of Tetrahymena rDNA segments starting with individual cells

To facilitate studies of rDNA molecular genetics in Tetrahymena thermophila, we attempted the detection of polymorphisms in the nontranscribed spacers (NTSs) using polymerase chain reaction (PCR), starting with minute amounts of DNA. The targeted polymorphic regions are 85% adenine-thymine (AT). We found conditions of efficient and specific in vitro amplification of targeted segments in the replication domain of the 5'NTS and in the subtelomeric segment of the 3'NTS. The identity of the amplified segments was confirmed by restriction enzyme digestion and DNA sequence analysis. Digestion of the template DNA at restriction sites upstream and downstream of the targeted region increased the efficiency of amplification, presumably because the targeted segments are in a palindromic molecule. Starting from total cell DNA corresponding to as little as 0.03 picogram (equivalent to the DNA content of 0.003 cells or about 30 rDNA molecules), we observed the amplified band after agarose gel electrophoresis and ethidium bromide staining. The yield indicated more than 10-billion-fold amplification. Amplification of the subtelomeric fragment yielded homogeneous product of minimum possible length even though the telomeric-specific primer can bind, at least initially, at a multiplicity of GGGGTT repeats. Amplified 5'NTS product also was detected in an ethidium-bromide-stained gel when PCR was started with a single cell.

Complete sequence of the extrachromosomal rDNA molecule from the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila strain B1868VII

The recent development of rDNA vectors for transformation of Tetrahymena combined with improved microinjection technology should lead to a renewed interest in this organism. In particular, the rDNA itself constitutes an attractive system for biochemical studies. The rDNA is amplified to a level of 2% of the total DNA and exists as extrachromosomal molecules. Furthermore, the rDNA is homogeneous in sequence because it is derived from a single gene during sexual reorganization. In order to facilitate studies of this molecule, we report here a compilation of previously published sequence information together with new sequence data that completes the entire sequence of the 21 kb rDNA molecule.

Amplification of tandemly repeated origin control sequences confers a replication advantage on rDNA replicons in Tetrahymena thermophila

The macronuclear rRNA genes (rDNA) in the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila are normally palindromic linear replicons, containing two copies of the replication origin region in inverted orientation. A circular plasmid containing a single Tetrahymena rRNA gene (one half palindrome) joined to a tandem repeat of a 1.9-kilobase (kb) rDNA segment encompassing the rDNA replication origin and known replication control elements was used to transform Tetrahymena macronuclei by microinjection. This plasmid was shown previously to have a replication advantage over the rDNA allele of the recipient cell strain (G.-L. Yu and E. H. Blackburn, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 86:8487-8491, 1990). During vegetative cell divisions, the circular and palindromic rDNAs were rapidly replaced by novel, successively longer linear rDNAs that eventually contained up to 30 tandem 1.9-kb repeats, resulting from homologous but unequal crossovers between the 1.9-kb repeats. We present evidence to show that increasing the number of copies of the replication control regions increases the replicative advantage of the rDNA, the first such situation for a cellular nuclear replicon in a eucaryote.

Amplification of tandemly repeated origin control sequences confers a replication advantage on rDNA replicons in Tetrahymena thermophila

The macronuclear rRNA genes (rDNA) in the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila are normally palindromic linear replicons, containing two copies of the replication origin region in inverted orientation. A circular plasmid containing a single Tetrahymena rRNA gene (one half palindrome) joined to a tandem repeat of a 1.9-kilobase (kb) rDNA segment encompassing the rDNA replication origin and known replication control elements was used to transform Tetrahymena macronuclei by microinjection. This plasmid was shown previously to have a replication advantage over the rDNA allele of the recipient cell strain (G.-L. Yu and E. H. Blackburn, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 86:8487-8491, 1990). During vegetative cell divisions, the circular and palindromic rDNAs were rapidly replaced by novel, successively longer linear rDNAs that eventually contained up to 30 tandem 1.9-kb repeats, resulting from homologous but unequal crossovers between the 1.9-kb repeats. We present evidence to show that increasing the number of copies of the replication control regions increases the replicative advantage of the rDNA, the first such situation for a cellular nuclear replicon in a eucaryote.

Transformation of Tetrahymena thermophila with a mutated circular ribosomal DNA plasmid vector

A circular plasmid containing a complete Tetrahymena thermophila rRNA gene (rDNA), with a tandem repeat of a 1.9-kilobase-pair segment encompassing the replication origin and the rRNA promoter, and a polylinker in the 3' nontranscribed spacer, was used to transform T. thermophila by microinjection. Most (20/21) stable transformants contained only recombinant linear palindromic rDNA molecules carrying rDNA sequences from both the donor plasmid and the recipient cell, as shown previously. However, in one transformant, the circular plasmid initially outreplicated the endogenous rDNA and was the major rDNA form for up to 65 generations. Stable circular replicons have not been reported previously in Tetrahymena. A single point mutation (+G) was identified in the repeated promoter of the plasmid maintained in this transformant. After recovery from the Tetrahymena transformant and recloning in Escherichia coli, the mutated circular plasmid again transformed Tetrahymena with stable maintenance of the circular rDNA plasmid. Transformants containing circular replicons were also obtained by using a similar plasmid from which the repeated promoter, but not the repeated replication origin, had been removed by BAL-31 deletion. We therefore propose that repeated rRNA promoters are deleterious in vivo in Tetrahymena, which normally lacks them. Transformants were obtained in 2-5 days compared with the 7-14 days required for transformation with unmutated rDNA plasmids by recombination. Similar results were obtained when a 550-base-pair segment containing the telomerase RNA gene of T. thermophila was inserted in the polylinker of the plasmid. We suggest that this plasmid is a useful vector system for transformation of Tetrahymena.

Analysis of Paramecium macronuclear DNA using pulsed field gel electrophoresis

We have analyzed the macronuclear DNA of Paramecium tetraurelia using orthogonal-field-alternation gel electrophoresis. The mean size of the linear macronuclear DNA molecules is approximately 450 kb. Less than 6% of the macronuclear DNA is larger than 800 kb. Using pulse times of 20, 40, 60 and 90 s we show that the macronuclear fragment containing the A type variable surface antigen gene migrates reproducibly as a 320-kb linear DNA. Over the same pulse times we describe the unusual migration of the ribosomal RNA gene (rDNA) of P. tetraurelia. At pulse times of 20 and 40 s the rDNA migrates at limit mobility (300 and 500 kb, respectively) whereas with 60- and 90-s pulse times, 2 components of rDNA are observed; 1 fraction independent of pulse time migrating at limit mobility, and a 2nd component migrating between 100-kb and 400-kb linear markers. Based upon previous electron micrographic studies of Paramecium rDNA as well as data presented here we conclude that the majority of Paramecium rDNA molecules are a circular DNA form.

The replication advantage of a free linear rRNA gene is restored by somatic recombination in Tetrahymena thermophila

The autonomously replicating rRNA genes (rDNA) in the somatic nucleus of Tetrahymena thermophila are maintained at a copy number of approximately 10(4) per nucleus. A mutant in which the replication properties of this molecule were altered was isolated and characterized. This mutation of inbred strain C3, named rmm4, was shown to have the same effect on rDNA replication and to be associated with the same 1-base-pair (bp) deletion as the previously reported, independently derived rmm1 mutation (D. L. Larson, E. H. Blackburn, P. C. Yaeger, and E. Orias, Cell 47:229-240, 1986). The rDNA of inbred strain B, which is at a replicational disadvantage compared with wild-type C3 rDNA, has a 42-bp deletion. This deletion is separated by 25 bp from the 1-bp deletion of rmm4 or rmm1. Southern blot analysis and DNA sequencing revealed that during prolonged vegetative divisions of C3-rmm4/B-rmm heterozygotes, somatic recombination produced rDNAs lacking both the rmm4-associated deletion and the 42-bp deletion. In somatic nuclei in which this rare recombinational event had occurred, all 10(4) copies of nonrecombinant rDNA were eventually replaced by the recombinant rDNA. The results prove that each of the two deletions is the genetic determinant of the observed replication disadvantage. We propose that the analysis of somatically recombinant rDNAs can be used as a general method in locating other mutations which affect rDNA propagation in T. thermophilia.

The replication advantage of a free linear rRNA gene is restored by somatic recombination in Tetrahymena thermophila

The autonomously replicating rRNA genes (rDNA) in the somatic nucleus of Tetrahymena thermophila are maintained at a copy number of approximately 10(4) per nucleus. A mutant in which the replication properties of this molecule were altered was isolated and characterized. This mutation of inbred strain C3, named rmm4, was shown to have the same effect on rDNA replication and to be associated with the same 1-base-pair (bp) deletion as the previously reported, independently derived rmm1 mutation (D. L. Larson, E. H. Blackburn, P. C. Yaeger, and E. Orias, Cell 47:229-240, 1986). The rDNA of inbred strain B, which is at a replicational disadvantage compared with wild-type C3 rDNA, has a 42-bp deletion. This deletion is separated by 25 bp from the 1-bp deletion of rmm4 or rmm1. Southern blot analysis and DNA sequencing revealed that during prolonged vegetative divisions of C3-rmm4/B-rmm heterozygotes, somatic recombination produced rDNAs lacking both the rmm4-associated deletion and the 42-bp deletion. In somatic nuclei in which this rare recombinational event had occurred, all 10(4) copies of nonrecombinant rDNA were eventually replaced by the recombinant rDNA. The results prove that each of the two deletions is the genetic determinant of the observed replication disadvantage. We propose that the analysis of somatically recombinant rDNAs can be used as a general method in locating other mutations which affect rDNA propagation in T. thermophilia.

Entamoeba histolytica ribosomal RNA genes are carried on palindromic circular DNA molecules

Highly abundant DNA fragments obtained after restriction enzyme digests of nuclear DNA of Entamoeba histolytica strain HM-1:IMSS have been cloned and characterized. Northern blot hybridization to E. histolytica rRNA and sequence analysis identified the abundant DNAs as ribosomal DNA containing species. Several overlapping clones containing these abundant DNAs were isolated from 4 different genomic libraries of E. histolytica. Alignment of the restriction maps was consistent with a circular molecule, about 24.6 kilobase pairs (kb) in size. Nuclease BA131 digestion provided additional evidence for the circular nature of this DNA. The ribosomal DNA molecule contains two large inverted repeat-regions, each at least 5.2 kb in length. Sequence analysis of clone R715 revealed homology to the large rRNA units of various eukaryotic organisms. This clone was located in both inverted repeats, suggesting two rRNA cistrons per molecule. The inverted repeats are flanked by stretches of DNA which contain tandemly reiterated sequences. Southern blot analysis of E. histolytica nuclear DNA revealed the presence of two populations of molecules. These molecules have identical arrangements of restriction sites, but differ in size (0.7 kb) in a fragment containing tandemly reiterated sequences. Analysis of E. histolytica nuclear DNA by electron microscopy also revealed circular molecules. These molecules are about 26.6 kb +/- 0.5 kb in size and contain structural features predicted by the restriction map of the extrachromosomal ribosomal DNA of E. histolytica.

The Xenopus laevis ribosomal gene promoter contains a binding site for nuclear factor-1

Nuclear Factor I (NF1) is a DNA binding protein that is known to function in the replication of Adeno virus and also binds to many promoters recognized by RNA polymerase II. We have found that there is also an NF1 binding site within the ribosomal gene promoter from Xenopus laevis as well as in several other promoters recognized by RNA polymerase I. The function of a binding site for a polymerase II transcription factor within a promoter recognized by polymerase I is not known. However, its presence suggests interesting regulatory possibilities.

Molecular evidence for somatic recombination in the ribosomal DNA of Tetrahymena thermophila

The ribosomal DNA (rDNA) in Tetrahymena thermophila is a 21-kilobase-pair palindromic DNA molecule that replicates autonomously in the macronucleus and is maintained at the level of about 10,000 copies per macronucleus. The rDNA of inbred strain C3 outreplicates the rDNA of inbred strain B in most B/C3 heterozygous macronuclei, generating macronuclei containing exclusively C3 rDNA sequences. In 1% or less of the B/C3 heterozygous macronuclei, however, rDNA sequences derived from both B and C3 strains persist in the macronucleus (co-maintainers). We report here that long-term culture of co-maintainers has yielded recombinant rDNA molecules combining sequences from both parental inbred strains. The genetic structure of such molecules also gives us virtual certainty that the differential replication of C3 rDNA with respect to B rDNA is due to the DNA sequence difference previously reported in domain 2 of the rDNA replication regions of the two strains.

Circular ribosomal DNA plasmids transform Tetrahymena thermophila by homologous recombination with endogenous macronuclear ribosomal DNA

We transformed the ciliate Tetrahymena thermophila by microinjection of circular plasmids containing the ribosomal RNA gene (rDNA). In the somatic macronucleus of Tetrahymena, the rDNA is in the form of linear palindromic molecules. The rDNA molecules from the C3 strain have a replication advantage over rDNA from both B strain and the C3 rDNA mutant rmm1. We constructed two circular plasmids carrying replication origin sequences from C3 rDNA and a point mutation (Pmr) in the 17S rRNA gene that confers resistance to the antibiotic paromomycin. One plasmid contained a single complete copy of the rRNA gene and its flanking sequences, while the other had an additional rDNA origin of replication. In all B or rmm1 Tetrahymena cell lines transformed with the plasmids, rDNA sequences from the plasmid were found in palindromic rDNA molecules. In one transformant line, a small amount of the plasmid was also retained in a form with the original circular restriction map. Our results show that the plasmids underwent homologous recombination with one arm of the endogenous rDNA to give heteropalindromic rDNA, or with both arms of the palindrome to form homopalindromic rDNA. The resulting recombinant molecules were able to replace the recipient's original rDNA completely, providing strong evidence that C3 rDNA sequences in the donor DNAs confer a replication advantage over recipient rDNA. Thus microinjection of circular plasmids provides a method for replacement of an endogenous gene or gene fragment with exogenous sequences.

S1 nuclease sensitivity of a double-stranded telomeric DNA sequence

We examined structural properties of poly d(C4A2).d(T2G4), the telomeric DNA sequence of the ciliated protozoan Tetrahymena. Under conditions of high negative supercoiling, poly d(C4A2).d(T2G4) inserted in a circular plasmid vector was preferentially sensitive to digestion with S1 nuclease. Only the C4A2 strand was sensitive to first-strand S1 cutting, with a markedly skewed pattern of hypersensitive sites in tracts of either 46 or 7 tandem repeats. Linear poly d(C4A2).(T2G4) showed no preferential S1 sensitivity, no circular dichroism spectra indicative of a Z-DNA conformation, no unusual Tm, and no unusual migration in polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. The S1 nuclease sensitivity properties are consistent with a model proposed previously for supercoiled poly d(CT).d(AG) (Pulleyblank et al., Cell 42:271-280, 1985), consisting of a double-stranded, protonated, right-handed underwound helix. We propose that this structure is shared by related telomeric sequences and may play a role in their biological recognition.

Dynamics of telomere length variation in Tetrahymena thermophila

We have analyzed the mechanism and dynamics of telomere length variation in the macronucleus of Tetrahymena thermophila. In a newly differentiated macronucleus, the average length of the telomeric repeated sequence, (C4A2 X T2G4)n, is closely regulated. In contrast, in vegetatively dividing cells in log phase, all macronuclear telomeric sequences lengthen coordinately by 3-10 bp per generation until up to 1000 bp are added. In both elongated and short telomeres, characteristic single-stranded breaks on both strands are distally located. Reduction of elongated telomeres to their original length involves either the appearance of a novel type of variant cell, incapable of net telomere elongation, or, under stationary phase conditions, a reversible removal of telomeric sequences. The demonstration that telomeres are dynamic structures provides evidence for a model of telomere length regulation by activities that add and remove telomeric repeats.

Structure of the Bombyx mori rDNA: initiation site for its transcription

The initiation site of rDNA transcription in Bombyx mori was determined to be located at 909bp upstream from the 5'- end of mature 18s rRNA by S1-nuclease mapping and primer extension experiment. An in vitro transcription system, which was constructed using posterior silk glands of Bombyx larvae, initiated the transcription of cloned rDNA at exactly the same site as determined for the in vivo transcription above. The primary transcript seemed to be processed at about 200b downstream of the initiation site both in vivo and in vitro. Sequence analyses of the flanking region of the initiation site revealed that short repetitive sequences are widely distributed throughout the NTS region, and that a highly AT-rich region resides immediately upstream of the initiation region.

Mapping of sequence-specific chromatin proteins by a novel method: topoisomerase I on Tetrahymena ribosomal chromatin

DNA derived from the 5' spacers of the rRNA genes from Tetrahymena has unusual electrophoretic properties. These properties made it possible to devise a simple electrophoretic procedure for isolating specific rDNA spacer fragments from preparations of total nuclear DNA, enabling us to study DNA modifications at the level of unfractionated nuclei. We have employed the method to study the distribution of topoisomerase I binding sites on the r-chromatin (ribosomal chromatin) of Tetrahymena at the DNA sequence level. The presence of topoisomerase I in situ was detected by its ability to introduce single-strand cleavages into DNA. The positions of the cleavages were determined on DNA sequencing gels after isolation of the fragments. Topoisomerase I binding in r-chromatin is sequence specific and cleavage is confined to a 16 base-pair conserved sequence element previously determined to be a high-affinity binding site for topoisomerase I in vitro. The high degree of sequence specificity may be of important functional significance, as we find a similar sequence specificity with enzymes isolated from five evolutionarily distant species, indicating that preference for the 16 base-pair element is an intrinsic property of eukaryotic type I topoisomerases.

A restriction fragment length polymorphism in the 5' non-transcribed spacer of the rDNA of Tetrahymena thermophila inbred strains B and C3

The ribosomal DNA of Tetrahymena thermophila is a 21-kb palindromic molecule which replicates autonomously in the macronuclei of this species. In addition to the rRNA coding regions, there are 5' and 3' flanking sequences which are not transcribed (non-transcribed spacer; NTS). The 5' NTS contains a bidirectional origin of DNA replication and promoter elements which direct transcription. We have identified a restriction fragment length polymorphism in the rDNA 5' NTS by comparing the B and C3 inbred strains of T. thermophila. There is a 42-bp region present in the C3 but not in the B strain rDNA; we present evidence that this difference most likely represents a deletion in the B strain rather than an insertion in the C3 strain. We also include a revised version of the nucleotide sequence of the 5' NTS DNA of inbred strain B.

Control of rDNA replication in Tetrahymena involves a cis-acting upstream repeat of a promoter element

A novel genetic scheme was used to isolate mutants altered in the formation or maintenance of amplified rDNA in the Tetrahymena macronucleus. One such mutant had a cis-acting rDNA mutation that affected the ability of mutant rDNA molecules to replicate in macronuclei in the presence of a wild-type (B strain) rDNA. The mutant rDNA was lost from these heterozygous macronuclei during vegetative cell divisions, although it was maintained normally in the homozygous or hemizygous state. In contrast, wild-type macronuclear rDNA of the C3 strain used to obtain the mutant outreplicated B strain rDNA in B/C3 heterozygote macronuclei. Sequence differences were found between wild-type B and C3 and mutant C3 rDNAs in the replication origin region, changing an upstream repeat of a highly conserved rRNA promoter element. We propose that the various rDNA alleles differentially compete for limiting amounts of trans-acting factors that bind to these enhancer-like repeats and positively regulate rDNA replication.

Conservation of sequences adjacent to the telomeric C4A2 repeats of ciliate macronuclear ribosomal RNA gene molecules

We sequenced and compared the telomeric regions of linear rDNAs from vegetative macronuclei of several ciliates in the suborder Tetrahymenina. All telomeres consisted of tandemly repeated C4A2 sequences, including the 5' telomere of the 11 kb rDNA from developing macronuclei of Tetrahymena thermophila. Our sequence of the 11 kb 5' telomeric region shows that each one of a previously described pair of inverted repeats flanking the micronuclear rDNA (Yao et al., Mol. Cell. Biol. 5: 1260-1267, 1985) is 29 bp away from the positions to which telomeric C4A2 repeats are joined to the ends of excised 11 kb rDNA. In general we found that the macronuclear rDNA sequences adjacent to C4A2 repeats are not highly conserved. However, in the non-palindromic rDNA of Glaucoma, we identified a single copy of a conserved sequence, repeated in inverted orientation in Tetrahymena spp., which all form palindromic rDNAs. We propose that this sequence is required for a step in rDNA excision common to both Tetrahymena and Glaucoma.

In vitro deletion analysis of ARS elements spanning the replication origin in the 5' non-transcribed spacer of Tetrahymena thermophila ribosomal DNA

Two adjacent but non-overlapping restriction fragments that encompass the replication origin of the macronuclear copy of rDNA from Tetrahymena thermophila allow autonomous replication of plasmids in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae; i.e. they function as autonomously replicating segments (ARS). Deletions generated in vitro into these fragments yield an 82 bp segment from each as the smallest sequence specifying ARS function. These 82 bp segments are at the 5' end of a 220 bp region of homology between the two original ARS restriction fragments. A 39 bp region of almost complete sequence identity between the two 82 bp fragments is suggested to be a core sequence element necessary for ARS function. This 39 bp sequence contains a region identical or nearly identical to the 11 bp yeast ARS consensus sequence (T/ATTTATPuTTTA/T) which is suggested to be essential for ARS function. Detailed comparisons of the 82 bp segments and of the 39 bp core with other ARS sequences reveal no extensive homologies aside from the consensus.

Characterization of two types of rRNA gene repeat units from the crustacean Artemia

We have previously described that Artemia rRNA genes are organized with a basic repeat unit of 16.5 kb [Cruces et al., Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 98 (1981) 404-409]. Here we describe the organization of the DNA coding for rRNA of a different population of this crustacean that has a repeat unit of 12.2 kb. Both types of repeat units have been cloned and the organization of the external spacers studied by restriction analysis. Both external spacers contain repeated sequences, but they are not homologous to each other. Sequences from the external spacer of the 16.5 kb repeat are also found elsewhere in the genome, within sequences not related to rRNA genes.

Autonomously replicating sequences from the non transcribed spacers of Tetrahymena thermophila ribosomal DNA

The non-transcribed spacer (NTS) regions of the linear extrachromosomal palindromic rDNA from the ciliated protozoan Tetrahymena thermophila contain, in addition to sequences regulating transcription, the origin(s) of bidirectional replication as well as telomere associated sequences. These NTS regions function as autonomous replication sequences (ARS) in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae (Kiss, G.B., Amin, A.A. and Pearlman, R.E., Mol. Cell Biol. 1: 535-543, 1981). We have now identified in the 5' NTS two adjacent but non-overlapping restriction fragments which function as ARS in yeast. These fragments contain 200 bp of duplicated sequence and include the in vivo origin of rDNA replication. The ARS in the 3' NTS has been subdivided into a sequence which allows high frequency transformation of yeast but with transformants extremely unstable when grown either under selective or non-selective conditions, and a sequence which appears to be required for plasmid maintenance yet not to be essential for high frequency transformation. Detailed analysis of the DNA sequences in these regions gives rise to interesting information about structural and functional features of the molecule.